Regulation 9, Indian Police Service ( Appointment by Promotion) Regulation,1955: Appointments to the Service from the Select List
Indian Police Service ( Appointment by Promotion) Regulation,1955 - Regulation 9
Text of regulation 9
Appointments to the Service from the Select List
9. Appointments to the Service from the Select List.- 9(1)45Appointment of a member
of the State Police Service, who has expressed his willingness to be appointed to the
Service, shall be made by the Central Government in the order in which the names of the
members of the State Police Service appear in the Select List for the time being in force
during the period when the Select List remains in force:
Provided that in a Joint Cadre, the appointment of members of the State Police
Service shall, subject to any agreement regarding filling up of the vacancies in the Joint
Cadre by promotion of a member of the State Police Service serving in connection with
the affairs of any such State, be made in the order in which the names of the members of
the State Police Service occur in the relevant parts of the Select List for the time being in
force:
46Provided further that the appointment of an officer, whose name has been included
or deemed to be included in the Select List provisionally under the proviso to sub-
regulation (5) of regulation 5 or under the proviso to sub-regulation (3) of Regulation 7,
as the case may be, shall be made within sixty days after the name is made unconditional
by the Commission in terms of the first proviso to sub-regulation (4) of regulation 7:
47Provided also that in case a select list officer has expressed his unwillingness for
appointment to the service, he shall have no claim for appointment to the service from
that select list unless he informs the Central Government through the State Government
122
before the expiry of the validity period of the Select List, revoking his earlier expression
of unwillingness for appointment to the service.
489(2) [Omitted].
499(a) Powers of the Central Government not to appoint in certain cases:-
Notwithstanding anything contained in these regulations [deleted]50 the Central
Government may not appoint any person whose name appears in the Select List, if it is
of the opinion that it is necessary or expedient so to do in the public interest:
51Provided that no such decision shall be taken by the Central Government without
consulting the Union Public Service Commission.
1052 Saving.- Omitted.
123
53 “Schedule (see regulation 3)
Sl.
No
Name of the State
Cadre / Joint Cadre
Other members of the Committee
1. Arunachal Pradesh,
Goa, Mizoram and
Union Territories
a) Chief Secretary of the constituent State for which the
meeting is held and in respect of Union Territory
segment, the senior-most Chief Secretary amongst
the Chief Secretaries to the Union Territory
administrations.
b) The senior-most Chief Secretary of the remaining
constituents of the Cadre;
c) DGP of the constituent state for which the meeting is
held, In respect of Union Territory segment, the
Commissioner of Police, Delhi;
d) Head of Home Department of the constituent segment
for which the meeting is held, not below the rank of
Secretary to Government. In case of Union Territory
segment, the senior-most officer looking after Home
Department among all Union Territories;
e) Special / Additional Secretary, Government of India,
dealing with AGMUT cadre in Ministry of Home
Affairs; and
f) Two nominees of Government of India not below the
rank of Joint Secretary.
2. Assam-Meghalaya
and Manipur-
Tripura Joint
Cadres
a) Chief Secretaries to the Governments of the
constituent States;
b) Director Generals of Police of the constituent States;
and
c) Two nominees of Government of India not below the
rank of Joint Secretary
3. Other Cadres a) Chief Secretary of the State Government;
b) Secretary, Home Department or Principal Secretary
(Home) of the State Government as the case may be;
c) The Director General of Police of the State Govt.; and
d) Two nominees of Government of India not below the
rank of Joint Secretary.”
124
GOI's Decision below Rule 5 of IPS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations,
1955
Government of India Decision:
1.1 On the basis of the recommendations of the Committee on the Prevention of
Corruption, it has been decided that the following certificate should be recorded by the
Chief Secretary to the State Government who is the sponsoring authority in respect of al
eligible officers whose cases are placed before the Selection Committee for consideration
:
"The State Government certify the integrity of Shri with reference to the
entries in his annual confidential reports."
1.2. The Selection Committee should also consider the question of suitability of the
officers for selection with reference to their integrity and should specifically record in their
proceedings that they were satisfied from the remarks in the confidential reports of the
officers, selected by them for inclusion in the Select List, that there was nothing against
their integrity.
[G.I.,M.H.A. letter No. 14/23/65-AIS(III), dated 8/6/1965 read with MHA letter No.
14/23/65-AIS(III), dated 28th July,1965.]
2.1 A State Government is competent to declare any duly constituted Police Service
in the State as equivalent to the Principal Police service of the State for the purpose of
regulation 2(i) and rule 2(g) of the I.P.S. (Recruitment ) Rules, 1954. Where equivalence
so declared. It is for the State Government to determine the service in ranks or
categories of the posts which will be equivalent in service to the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police.
2.2 Equivalent posts in non-police departments are intentionally excluded from the
scope of the eligibility clause (regulation 4), the reason being that experience not
involving police duties should not be reckoned for this purpose. In the case of the I.A.S.
however, service in equivalent posts is taken into consideration and the State
Government have been given discretion to declare any post as equivalent to that of
Deputy Collector for the purpose of determining the eligibility of an officer for
consideration for inclusion in the Select List. This is because for holding posts in the
I.A.S. experience in revenue and general administration is required and in some of the
departments (other than police and revenue) the duties involved in the higher posts are
of administrative nature.
2.3 As service in equivalent posts is not taken into account for determining the
eligibility of a State Police Service Officer for inclusion in the Select List, the State
Governments would be well-advised not to send them on deputation to posts which are
in non-police departments and which cannot be declared by them as equivalent to
Principal Police Service of the State.
[G.I.,M.H.A. letter No.28/38/64-AIS(III), dated 5/1/1965.]
3. It is open to the State Government to depute their officers in the State Police
Service to the post of A.D.C. to Governor or a Security Officer in a Public Sector
undertaking which essentially requires the services of a police officer for the discharge of
duties against the deputation reserve provided in the State Police Service cadre or in any
other manner without declaring the non-police department as such in which these posts
exists as equivalent to the Principal Police Service of the State. In these cases, service
125
or deputation as State. In these cases, service or deputation as A.D.C. or Security
Officer in non-police department will count as State Police Service under this regulation.
4. Sub-regulation (4) merely states that the Select List shall be reviewed and revised
every year and does not further say that it can be reviewed only after the expiry of a year.
The validity of a Select List is not, therefore, affected on the ground that it was prepared,
earlier
[G.I.,M/Law U.O.No.7082/64, dated 30.1.65 in MHA File No. 28/41/64-AIS (III).]
5. The Government of India have held that Select Lists are to be maintained only for
the purpose of making substantive appointments of the members of the State Civil /
Police Service to the I.A.S. / I.P.S. against the vacancies in promotion posts. At best, the
Select Lists can be utilized for making temporary appointments of such officers to cadre
posts in accordance with the provisions of Rule 9 of the Cadre Rules. Select Lists are not
maintained for making appointments to non-cadre posts declared equivalent to cadre
posts. In the exigencies of service adjustments of posting is required to be made within a
period of three months.
[ G.I., MHA letter No. 14/51/65-AIS(III) dated 21/2/1966 read with letters No. 19/3/66-
AIS(III) dated 26/4/66 and No. 15/79/66-AIS(III), dated 17/10/1966]
6. Having regard to the provision contained in the proviso to the sub-regulation (4)
of Regulations 7 of the IPS (Appointment by Promotion), Regulation, 1955 the State
Government/the Joint Cadre Authority, while making recommendations for the
appointment of a member of the State Police Service to the Indian Police Service, may
forward a certificate on the following lines:
"The State Government/the Joint Cadre Authority certifies that subsequent to the
inclusion of the name of Shri in the Select List, there has been no deterioration
in his work as to render him unsuitable for appointment to the Indian Police Service nor
has any lapse in his conduct or performance of duties in his part come to the notice of
the State Government/the Joint Cadre Authority."
[DP & AR letter No. 11/4/73-AIS(I), dt. 22/5/73.]
7. It has come to the notice of the Central Government recently where officers not
specified in the relevant Schedule to the Promotion Regulations to participate in the
Selection Committee meetings as members had participated in such meetings and this
had the affect of vitiating the proceedings of the said Selection Committees. In order to
avoid such a situation, the State Governments have been requested to ensure that their
officers, who attend the meetings of the Selection Committees, are invariably those
specified in column 3 of the Schedule to Regulation 3 of the I.A.S. /I.P.S. (Appointment
by Promotion) Regualtions, 1955 and in sub-regulation (1) of Regulation 3 of the I.F.S.
(Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1966.
[DP &AR letter No. 11039/5/80-AIS(I) dated 19.11.80]
8.1 It has been brought to the notice of the Government of India by the Commission
that the State Governments do not bring out specifically to the notice of the Selection
Committee/Commission cases where decisions on representations made against
adverse entries are yet to be taken by the State Government. According to the
Commission, this results in the officers who are not included in the Select List filing writ
petitions against the selections made by the Selection Committees and in some cases
the courts passing orders accepting the writ petitions and directing the respondents to
review the proceedings of the Selection Committee ignoring the adverse entries.
126
8.2 The State Govts. have been requested that while furnishing the
material/information to the Union Public Service Commission for holding the meetings of
the Selection Committees, the State Governments should invariably furnish the following
certificates:-
(a) Adverse remarks in the character rolls of the following eligible officers have not
been communicated by the State Government to the officers concerned.
(b) Adverse entries in respect of the following eligible officers have been
communicated but no representations have been so far received from the officers
concerned but the time limit to represent is not yet over.
(c) Representations against adverse entries in respect of the following officers have
been received within the stipulated time but the decision of the State Government, is yet
to be taken
.
[DP&AR letter No. 14015/14/81-AIS(I), dated 7/7/81.]
9. According to the existing practice, members of the State Civil/Police/Forest Service
whose suitability for promotion to the I.A.S./I.P.S./I.F.S. is considered by the Selection
Committee and against whom disciplinary proceedings are pending are included in the
Select List subject to clearance of enquiries pending against them. The State
Governments have been requested that a list of officers against whom disciplinary
proceedings are pending and a list of those in respect of whom it has been finally decided
to institute disciplinary proceedings, may invariably be given to the Chairman of the
Selection Committee as in the proforma enclosed at the time of the meeting of the
Committee.
[DP&AR letter No. 14015/28/81-AIS(I), dated 6/2/82.]
10 After the amendments dated 31.12.1997, the State Govts. are to forward signed
declaration of marital status and consent for termination of lien in the State Service on
eventual substantive appointment in the IPS from the State Police Service included in the
consideration zone to the Central Government separately, even while sending proposals
for convening the Selection Committee to the Commission. Any adverse development in
respect of the officers included in the consideration zone which is likely to render him
unsuitable for appointment to the Service for the time-being (e.g.) withdrawal of integrity
certificate by the State Govt. / issue of charge sheet / filing of criminal case against the
officer etc. should be immediately brought to the notice of the Central Government and
Commission by the State Govt. concerned by FAX / Speed Post and acknowledgement
secured from the addressee.
11. State Civil Service officers who crossed 54 years of age during 1.4. After the
amendments dated 31.12.1997, the State Govts. are to forward signed declaration of
marital status and consent for termination of lien in the State Service on eventual
substantive appointment is the IAS from the State Civil Service officers included in the
consideration zone to the Central Government separately, even while sending proposals
for convening the Selection Committee to the Commission. Any adverse development in
respect of the officers included in the consideration zone which is likely to render him
unsuitable for appointment to the Service for the time-being (e.g.) withdrawal of integrity
certificate by the State Govt. / issue of charge sheet / filing of criminal case against the
officer etc. should be immediately brought to the notice of the Central Government and
Commission by the State Govt. concerned by FAX /Speed Post and acknowledgement
secured from the addressee.
[DOP&T Lr.No.F.14015/1/98-AIS(I)dt. 6.7.1998]
127
12. State Civil Service Officers who crossed 54 years of age during 1.4.1997 and
31.12.1997 and where no selection Committee met to consider their promotion to IAS
during this period, are eligible to be considered by the selection Committee meeting in
1998, in terms of the second proviso to Regulation 5(3) of the Promotion Regulations.
[DOP&T Lr.No.14015/5/98-AIS(I) dt. 14.9.1998]
13. Every State Civil Service Officer eligible and falling in the consideration zone framed
under Regulation 5(2) shall be considered and graded by the Selection Committee and
the list of suitable Officers drafted in accordance with Regulation 5(4) and 5(5) of the
Promotion Regulations. The choice of option exercised by the State Civil Service Officer
for promotion to IAS shall be reckoned with by the Central Government only in case of
their inclusion in the select list after its approval by the Commission. In terms of third
proviso to Regulation 9(1) of the Promotion Regulations.
[DOP&T Letter No. 14015/16/99-AIS(I) dated 22.11.1999]
Government of India's Decisions under Regulation 9 of IPA (Appointment by
Promotion) Regulations, 1955.
1. The appointment of a State Service Officer to an All India Service against the
promotion quota or otherwise is appointment in a substantive capacity outside his cadre.
His lien on the post in the State Service shall, therefore, be suspended under
Fundamental Rule 14(a)(2) and his written consent obtained for the termination of his lien
on the post in the State Service before he is confirmed in the All India Service. The written
consent should be obtained by the State Government while recommending the names of
State Service Officers for appointment to the All India Service
[G.I., M.H.A. letter No. 4/4/60-AIS(III), dated 15/10/1960.]
2. The appointment of a State Service officer to an All India Service against the
promotion quota or otherwise is appointment in a substantive capacity outside his cadre.
His lien on the post in the State Service shall, therefore, be suspended under
Fundamental Rule 14(a) (2) and his written consent obtained for the termination of his
lien on the post in the State Service before he is confirmed in the All India Service. The
written consent should be obtained by the State Governments while recommending the
names of the State Service officer for appointment to the All India Service.
[G.I. MHA letter No. 4/4/60-AIS(III), dated 15/10/1960]
3.1 X was placed above Y in the earlier Select Lists and he was also officiating in
cadre posts. In the Select List, current at the time of occurrence of the vacancy, however,
he was superseded by Y. The question arose whether Y could be appointed to the service
in preference to X.
3.2 Regulation 9, which is mandatory, requires appointments to the service to be
made in the order in which the names appear in the Select List for the time being in force.
It is independent of regulation 8 which deals with temporary appointment of Select List
officers against cadre post. In the circumstances, X cannot be appointed to the Service
in preference to Y. The fact that he was holding a cadre post in an officiating capacity
from a date earlier than Y or that he was placed above Y in the earlier Select Lists is not
a relevant consideration.
3.3 In this connection Select Lists are subject to revisions as provided in regulations
5(4) and 7(4), and particular Select List will be in force only until its review and revision is
128
approved by the Commission. The fact that X was shown above Y in the earlier Select
List does not confer upon X and right for that position or ranking to be maintained in the
subsequent Select Lis5ts. Also the fact that a person was holding a cadre post in an
officiating capacity does not in any way prevent the Selection Committee from revising
the Select List and, in so doing, the Committee under the proviso to regulation 5(3), will
be within their rights to assign a higher place in the Select List to a junior officer. Thus
under the scheme of the regulations, each Select List is independent of the other and an
officers respective position is not be considered with reference to the previous Select List
which was in force. further, in terms of regulation 5, the seniority of the officers in the
State Police Service is to be taken into consideration in formulating the Select List, but
the Selection Committee is empowered to alter the order of names in the seniority list in
the State Police Service, when the officers are brought on to the Select List.
3.4 The other point to be borne in mind is the distinction between regulations 8 and 9.
Regulation 8 deals with the appointment of State Police Service officers against
vacancies in cadre posts in temporary capacity and such appointments have to be in
accordance with the requirements of rule 9 of the Cadre Rules. As far as these officiating
appointments to cadre posts are concerned the legal status of State Police Service
Officers included in the Select Lists is the same as of those not included in the Select
Lists; in other words to the extent regulation 8 is concerned. Select List officers are also
non-cadre officers and that is the reason why their officiating appointments have to meet
the requirements in rule 9 of the Cadre Rules. thus a Select List officer appointed in an
officiating capacity to a cadre post under regulation 8 will not acquire any right to hold a
cadre post either in preference to a cadre officer who may be placed above him by
subsequent Selection Committee.
3.5 Regulation 9, on the other hand, deals with the appointments of a Select List
officer to a substantive vacancy in the Service and this has to be made from the Select
List for the time being in force and in the order in which the names appear in such a
Select List. The phrase "for the time being force" has relevance to the period at which the
appointment to the service is made by them and not to the time at which the officer started
officiating in a cadre vacancy under regulation 8. That is to say appointment to a vacancy
in the promotion quota is made with reference to the date of the origin of the vacancy or
the date of inclusion of the officer's name in the Select List, whichever is later.
[G.I. MHA letter No. 28/41/64-AIS(III, dated 11.2.65]
4. A State Service Officer, on appointment to an All India Service on probation, would
retain his lien in the State Service and therefore be entitled to all the benefits that may
accrue to him in the Service (such as confirmation in the Selection Grade of the State
Civil Service ) before his confirmation in the All India Service.
[G.I. MHA letter No. 4/12/60-AIS(III, dated 31.10.60]
Government of India's Instructions:
1. In view of the legal position explained in Ministry of Home Affairs letter No.
14/51/65-AIS(II) dated the 21st February, 1966 the proforma I & II prescribed in the
Ministry of Home Affairs letter No. 27/54/64-AISIII, need revision. These proformae have
accordingly been revised and the State Governments are requested that in furture the
requisite information regarding fixation of seniority in respect of Select List officers
proposed to be appointed to the I.A.S. / I.P.S. may be furnished in the revised proformae
I & II (enclosed) along with the State Government's proposals for promotion to I.A.S. /
I.P.S.
129
2. It would appear from proforma I information regarding continuous officiation by
Select List officers or after 21.05.1966 is required to be furnished in respect of their
officiation in cadre posts only, in view of the legal position obtaining under the various
rules explained in the Ministry of Home Affairs letter dated 21.02.1966 referred to above.
The dated 21.05.1966 has been specified in the revised proforma as the position is
required to be regularized within three months from the date of issue of the aforesaid
letter.
130
PROFORMA I
Information in respect of promoted officers
S. Name of Date of The date Details of continuous Details of Item of Ministry of
No. Officer birth from which officiation in the cadre continuous cadre Home
the officer is posts included in Item 1 officiation in strength Affairs
continuously of cadre strength of non- the cadre showing reference
in Select List cadre post declared posts the communi-
(S) equivalent- thereto, prior included in designation cating their
to 21.05.66 Date of of each approval to
declaration of post and the arrange-
equivalence the period ments in
in the case of indicating columns 5 &
each non- dates for 8
cadre post which the
shown in post was
Column 6 held by the
officer on
or after
21.5.66
The date of Details of Details of
approval of cadre post cadre post
the Select showing declared
List(s) the equivalent
designation to cadre
of each posts
post and showing
period the
indicating designation
dates for of each
which the post and
post was the period
held by the indicating
Officer dates for
which the
post was
held by the
officer
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
PROFORMA II
Information in respect of competitive examination recruits borne on the Indian Administrative
Service / Indian Police Service Cadre of
S.No. Name of Officer Year of allotment Date of commencement of
continuous officiation in a post
remunerated on the senior time-
scale of the I.A.S./ I.P.S.
1. 2. 3. 4.
114 [Deleted].
53 “Schedule (see regulation 3)
Government of India Decision:
Government of India's Decisions under Regulation 9 of IPA (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955.
Government of India's Instructions:
PROFORMA I
PROFORMA II
Previous and next
All provisions of Indian Police Service ( Appointment by Promotion) Regulation,1955
Questions people ask
Is regulation 9 of Indian Police Service ( Appointment by Promotion) Regulation,1955 still in force?
No repeal of Indian Police Service ( Appointment by Promotion) Regulation,1955 is recorded.