Circular no. 514/10/2000-CX
Circular - The Central Excise Act, 1944
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Central Excise Act, 1944
Text of this circular
Circular No 514/10/2000
F.NO.206/10/99
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise & Customs
New Delhi, the 16 th February, 2000
Subject: - Excise Audit Scheme (EA-2000)-further guidelines for Implementation
It is a directed to say that certain views have been expressed by various Commissionerates regarding implementation of the
Excise Audit-2000 (EA-2000). The initial guidelines are contained in Board's Circular No. 491/57/99-CX.6 dated 28 th of
October, 1999. The view of the Commissionerate are categories as follows:-
1. Data management for Audit preparations;
2. Audit Report format;
3. Total period of the Audit;
4. Evaluation of the Audit Report through a scoring system;
5. System of institutionalised monitoring;
6. Training;
7. Availability of computer; and
8. Audit of units between Rs. 1 crore and Rs. 5 crore revenue.
Assessee Profile (database)
1. The first view expressed was that data must be collected by all Commissionerates in a standardised format so that only
absolutely essential information relevant for the conduct of audit is collected. This standardised collection would also
facilitate maintenance of a computerised database al l over the country. In this connection, Standardised Format for
Assessee's Profile has been devised to serve as a standard for collection of data relevant for Excise Audit-2000, which
is enclosed as Annexure-I.
1. In addition to this, it would be of advantage to the Department to know certain critical ratios relating to an
assessee's factory/business from the data available in the Balance Sheets (Annual Reports) of the
assessee/Assessee's profile/Other Reports before the audit is contemplated. For example, raw material cost: sale
value, discount; sale, outward freight: sale, power consumption (units): production quantity, change in profit:
assessable value etc.. The officers of the Audit Wing may be trained to derive these ratios. These ratios, wherever
possible, should be studied at the time of "Desk Review".
2. The Assessee's profile and the ratios will serve as a useful database for the conduct of 'Desk Review' which is the
first step in the Audit Programme explained in both the Excise Audit Manual and the Standard Audit Programme.
Needless to mention a comprehensive database would help in proper preparation for conduct of Audit.
Format of Audit Report
2. The Audit Manual speaks about completion of an Audit Report (Chapter 8). No format of the Audit Report has been
provided. It is important that the Audit Report findings are standardised. Keeping in view the need to ensure brevity and
objectiveness, a standardised format has been prepared which is enclosed at Annexure-II. The Audit Report format
particularly focuses on action on old audit points; the summary of the audit objections along with reasons and important
points for future compliance. This must be prepared after finalisation of the Working Papers. The Audit Report should
also substantiate findings, drawing from material in the Working Papers. Both these documents should be put in
computer.
Timeframe of submitting Audit Report
3. Every Audit undertaken must have a reasonably defined timeframe. This would also help to bring in the much-needed
discipline in the conduct of audit. Keeping in view the fact that EA-2000 requires more pointed audit of financial records it
has been decided that the total time limit for the conduct of audit and submission of the audit report should not exceed
20-25 days from the commencement of the Audit in the Assessee's unit.
Scoring System for Monitoring Cell
4. One of the keys to good audit is a system of good monitoring and evaluation of audit reports. EA-2000 makes this task
easier by prescribing that all audit work must be clearly documented in the Working Papers. Senior officers at the level of
Joint Commissioner/Additional Commissioner must evaluate these Working Papers. After due deliberation, a scoring
system has been evolved which may be used to evaluate an audit report which consists of the Working Papers, the
Summary sheet (part of the Working Papers) and the Audit report itself. The Scoring system which is enclosed as
Annexure-III divided the entire process of Audit into five parts: (I) preparation of the audit plan; (ii) conduct of audit; (iii)
revenue points raised (major objections and their quality); (iv) realisation of revenue, and (v) issues relating to future
complaince by the company. The scoring system has been devised so as to give greater emphasis on the conduct of the
audit, which is extremely important in the initial stages of the implemenation of the new Audit system. A greater
responsibility, therefore, rests on the seior officers to duly assess the reports and bring out the strength and weaknesses
of the audit reports. A quantitive system of measurement would help in steering the audit into areas, which are the core of
the new Audit system. It is however, clarified that the scoring system is not meant for reprimanding any officer(s) or fixing
any responsibility. It is meant for providing in-built synergic system so as to correct the weaknesses at the initial stages.
5. In the Board's Circular No. 491/57/99-CX.6 dated 28 th of October, 1999 it was suggested at Para 18 that an Excise
Audit Monitoring Cell be constituted headed by the Commissioner. It must be ensured that the Monitoring Cell meets
once a fortnight and also specially examines in the audit report improtant points raised. Assistant Commissioner/Deputy
Commissioner/Joint Commissioner/Additional Commissioner (Audit) should meet all the Audit Parties at least once in a
month to review their functioning and ensure the exchange of information among the audit parties.
Monitoring by DG (AE)
6. To start with, a copy of the score sheet should be forwarded to DG (AE) as soon as it is ready. A suitable device will be
worked out for seeing the Audit Reports for Rs. 5 crores and above units; selectively in due course.
Audit Protocol
7. Audit Protocol is a limited initiative within the overall EA-2000. Out of the eight corporate with whom discussions had
been held, five, namely, Indian Oil Corporation, Maruti Udyog Ltd; TISCO, Steel Authority of India Ltd. And Hindustan
Lever have already singed Protocol. MRF has given a letter agreeing to sign the Protocol. As stated in Chariman's letter
on Audit Protocol, Assistant Director (Cost) must accompany the audit teams for Protocol audits. In case the
Commissionerate does not have an Assistant Director (Cost), the AD (Cost) from any Commissionerate within the zone
should be a part of the audit team.
Involvement of AD (Cost) in audit
8. Normally, for all Rs. 5 crores and above units, AD (Cost) should, as far as possible, be also involved in audit.
Training
9. The success of Ea-2000 is critically dependent on the requisite training imparted to Auditors. Since in a number of
Commissionerates the Audit teams have not been exposed to any training on Accountancy, it is necessary, keeping in
view the emphasis being placed on scrutiny of business records, that Commissioners ensure that this training
programme on Accountancy is organised for staff not covered so far. The faculty may be drawn either from serving
officers like AD(Cost). Such training should have a practical orientation so that the lectures are linked to practical
application which is necessary to sustain interest.
Computer for Audit Branch
10. It is learnt some of the Commissionerates have not been able to provide a computer to Audit Branch. This should be
done priority basis.
11. Field formations may be suitably informed. Any difficulties noticed in this regard may be brought to the notice of the
Director general (Anti-Evasion) immediately.
ANNEXURE-I
Assessee Profiles for Ea-2000
1. Name of the Assessee :
2. Registration Certificate No. :
3. New ECC No. :
4. General Details :
PART-I
Serial
No.
Description of Goods
manufactured Tariff sub-heading Exemption Notification
availed Rate of Duty
PART-II
Year
Personal Ledger
Account
Modvat
Account Total duty payment
RG23A |
RG23C
5. Commodity-wise details
Commodity/Year Production
Clearance for home
consumption
Qty. Value
Clearances forgoing duty
Exports Imports
Qty. Value Qty
Value
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5A) (5B) (5C)
(5D)
Commodity-I
1996-97
1997-98
1998-99
Commodity-2
1996-97
1997-98
1998-99
Commodity-3
1996-97
1997-98
1998-99
Duty debited in PLA
Duty debited in RG23A/RG23C
(Total)
Payment from Modvat account as
Percentage of Total duty paid
(6) (7) (8)
6. Major Input and Output in the Modvat declaration.
Declaration made under Rule 57G/in respect of 57A inputs.
Sl.No Input Final
Product
1. Major item/sub-heading declared as Capital Goods under Rule 57Q.
2. Major Audit Points:
Serial No. Present
Status CommoditiesDuty
involved Issue
3. Major Preventive Points:
Serial No. Present
Status CommoditiesDuty
involved Issue
10. Marketing pattern, clearance pattern etc.
Sl. No. Nature of Sale/Transfer Etc. Yes No If Yes, Description of Products (s)
!. Sale at the factory gate
2.
Sale through the
depot/distributors/consignment
agents/Marketing intermediaries.
3. Sale in retail
4. Retail Sale Price (Maximum)-Section
4A
5. Inter plant transfer
6. Captive Consumption
7. Clearance to U.N. and other aided
projects
[These details must tally with the declaration given by the assessee in the Declaration specified under sub-rule (3A) of rule
173C of the Central Excise Rules, 1944]
ANNEXURE-II
Audit Report Format For EA-2000
PART-I
1) Name of the unit :
2) Commissionerate/Division/Range in which :
it is located
3) Prodcuts manufactured :
4) Tariff Item
5) Gist of main exemption Notification :
6) Date of last audit :
7) Period for which current audit undertaken :
8) Dated on which audit undertaken :
PART-II
1. Summary of major audit objections from the Working Paper:
Sl. No. Gist of Objection Revenue implicator,if anyAssessee Agreement Yes/No if
no, reasons for disagreement
Department's
conclusions with
reasons
Revenue Law Times
2. Suggestions for better compliance including systemic improvements and notifications in the legal arrangements:
Assistant Commissioner/Deputy Commissioner/Joint
Commissioner/Additional Commissioner(Audit)
ANNEXURE-III
Scoring system for EA-2000
1) Name of the Unit :
2) Commssionerate/Division :
3) Range in which it is located :
4) Constitution of the Audit Party :
(with Names and Designation of the Officers)
5) Reference to the Audit Report taken
for this Scoring :
Areas Points (Maximum) Sl.No.on Working Papers
(a) Quallity of Audit Plans 15 Point No. 7
(b) Systematic conduct of Audit with a
view to taking and integrated ad
comprehensive look at the systems
especially those which have a bearing on
revenue compliance
50
Points 1to 6 and 8 (within this evalaation
of Internal Control could be assigned 20
points)
©Revenue points flowing from finalisation
of Audit 15 Point 9&10
(d) Recovery of Audit Assessments 10 Point 11
(e) Suggestion for better compliance
including systemic improvements and
modifications in the legal arrangements.
10 Point 12
100