Circular no. 529/25/2000-CX
Circular - The Central Excise Act, 1944
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Central Excise Act, 1944
Text of this circular
Circular No. 529/25/2000-CX
F.NO. 390/34/99-JC
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise & Customs
New Delhi, the 19th, May, 2000
Subject: Appeal against CEGAT's orders---filing in proper forum and on proper issues
Your attention is invited to the provisions contained in Sections 35G and 35L(b) of the Central Excise Act, which Sections
clearly stipulate the types of cases where statutory appeal against the Tribunal's order lies before the Supreme Court. A
question of law could be referred to the High Court in respect of issues other than those relating to the rate of duty or to the
valuation of goods as these are covered under Section 35L(b) of the Act. Analogous provisions exist under Chapter XV of the
Customs Act, 1962.
The Board has issued various instructions from time to time on the need for careful scrutiny of CEGAT orders and sending
timely proposals for filing of Civil Appeal in the Supreme Court where warranted. However, it has come to the notice of the
Board that the above provisions of the Act are either lost sight of or at times not properly understood and we are getting in the
Board proposals against CEGAT orders for filing Civil Appeals when even remotely it is not attracting Section 35L of Central
Excise Act, and at best it could be a case of warranting a Reference Application before jurisdictional High Court, Board is also
sometimes coming across cases where because of improper appreciation of the facts and legal provisions, Reference
Applications are being inadvertently filed, where Civil Appeal should have been proposed. Obviously by the time CEGAT/High
Court decide that Reference Application is not entertainable, the civil appeal time limit is over by the huge margins and we lost
the chance of contesting in Supreme Court. Recently one of the Commissionerates had sent one such case where they had
application against CEGAT order on the issue of whether cutting/drilling/punching etc. of Aluminum Sections amounts to
manufacture. The Tribunal rejected the said reference Application on the ground that the matter pertained to bringing into
existence of new goods and hence related to classification and valuation, for which separate provisions existed under Section
35L(b) of the Act. The Commissioner thereafter had forwarded a proposal recommending filing of Civil Appeal in this matter,
but the C.A. proposal involved a delay of 472 days, which could not be explained to the Supreme Court, as pursuing of appeal
before a wrong forum is not considered to be a sufficient reason for condonation of delay, no appeal could, therefore, be filed
before the Supreme Court in the said case.
Board is not happy with such cases of delay and wrong filing of Reference Application or wrong recommendation for Civil
Appeals. All Commissioners are requested to carefully go through the facts of each case and legal issues on which we have
differences of opinion vis-à-vis order taken by CEGAT so that errors of the type mentioned above are avoided in future.