circular no. 643/34/2002-CX
Circular - The Central Excise Act, 1944
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Central Excise Act, 1944
Text of this circular
Circular No.643/34/2002-CX.
1 st July, 2002
F.NO. 6/39/2000 - CX 1
Government Of India
Ministry Of Finance
Department Of Revenue
Central Board Of Excise & Customs
Subject : Clarification of doubts under the new Valuation Rules
I am directed to refer to Board's letter F.No.354/81/2000-TRU dated 30 th June 2000 clarifying certain points relating to the
new valuation provisions made effective from 1.7.2000.
2. The Board has received a number of references from the field formations as well as representations from the trade
associations about certain doubts still persisting in the minds of the field officers. These points of doubt are being clarified in
the Table enclosed.
3. Field formations may be suitably informed.
4. Hindi version will follow
5. Receipt of this Circular may kindly be acknowledged.
Sd/-
(A.K.PRASAD)
DIRECTOR (CX I)
3092812
Clarifications on points of doubt under The New Valuation Provisions introduced w.e.f. 1.7.2000
Sl
no. Points of doubt Clarification
1.
What is the scope of the term
"greatest aggregate quantity"
used in Rule 2(b) of the
Central Excise Valuation
(Determination of Price of
Excisable Goods) Rules,
2000. The definition does not
indicate the time period over
which the quantity is to be
computed. Further, it is not
clear whether it refers to the
largest quantity sold to any
particular assessee during the
period or to the goods sold to
the largest number of buyers.
The term "greatest aggregate quantity" has been used to define the term "normal
transaction value" used in Rules 7 and 9 of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of
Price of Excisable Goods) Rules, 2000. Seen in this context the time period should be taken
as the whole day and the transaction value of the "greatest aggregate quantity" would refer
to the price at which the largest quantity of identical goods are sold on a particular day,
irrespective of the number of buyers. In case the "normal transaction value" from the depot or
other place is not ascertainable on the day identical goods are being removed from the
factory/warehouse, the nearest day when clearances of the goods were affected from the
depot or other place should be taken into consideration.
2.
Freight charges:-
1. How is the cost of
transportation to be
deducted in case of
vehicles owned by the
manufacturer ?
2. If
manufacturer/transporter
charges cost of
transportation both for
outward journey up to
the point of delivery and
return therefrom,
whether the cost of
transportation for the
return journey of the
empty truck/vehicle
should also be allowed
as deduction ?
3. Whether transit
insurance can be
allowed as deduction as
being part of
transportation cost?
(a) In such cases the cost of transportation can be calculated through costing method
following the accepted principles of costing. A cost certificate from a certified Cost
Accountant/Chartered Accountant/Company Secretary, may be accepted. The cost of
transportation should, however, be separately shown in the invoice.
(b) As per Rule 5 of the Valuation Rules the actual cost of transportation from the place of
removal up to the place of delivery is only to be excluded. If the assessee is recovering an
amount from the buyer towards the cost of return fare of the empty vehicle from the place of
delivery, this amount will not be available as a deduction. If, however, only the cost of
transportation has been indicated in the invoice without any breakup for the forward and
return journey, normally it should be accepted as the cost of transportation from the place of
removal to the place of delivery.
(c) Yes, the Apex Court in the case of Bombay Tyres International has held that the cost of
transportation will include the cost of insurance also during the transportation of the goods.
But the transit insurance should either be shown separately in the invoice or can be included
in the transportation cost shown separately.
3.
(a)Whether abatement of
sales tax and other taxes can
be allowed based on average
tax actually paid by the
assessee as supported by
costing certificate? [Circular
No 20/90 CX 1 dt 30.8.1990]
(b) As per Board's Circular
No.2/94-CX.1 dt.11.1.94
(F.No.6/20/94-CX.1) the sales
tax set-off available in respect
of inputs is to be ignored while
computing the sales tax
payable. Whether this is still
valid?
1. No. As per definition of "transaction value" taxes are deductible only on actual basis
either paid or payable by the assessee. Attention is invited to paras 10 and 11 of
Board's letter F.No.354/81/2000-TRU dt 30.6.2000.
2. No. The Circular dt.11 th Jan.1994 was based on the definition of 'duty of excise
payable' given in Explanation to the erstwhile Sec.4(4)(d)(ii). The new sec.4 does not
incorporate any such Explanation. The "transaction value" will exclude the sales tax
actually paid or payable on the goods. Thus, for example, if the effective sales tax on
cum-duty price of Rs.100 is 4% and the assessee is eligible for set-off of sales tax of,
say, Rs.10 paid/suffered on the inputs, the actual sales tax paid/payable would be
Rs.40-10 = Rs.30 and this will be the amount permissible as deduction from the
"transaction value" and not Rs 40/-. Attention is also invited to paras 10 and 11 of
Board's letter F.No.354/81/2000- TRU dt 30.6.2000.
4.
Packing:-
1. whether cost of
secondary packing is to
be excluded from the
transaction value ?
2. How is the cost of
reusable containers to
be determined for
inclusion in the
transaction value?
3. Whether rental charges
or cost of maintenance
of reusable metal
containers like gas
cylinders etc. are to be
included in the
transaction value?
4. What about cost of
containers supplied by
the buyer?
(a) No. There is no provision for such a deduction in the concept of transaction value
(b) Normally the cost of reusable containers (glass bottles, crates etc.) is amortized and
included in the cost of the product itself. Therefore the question of adding any further amount
towards this account does not arise, except where Audit of accounts reveals that the cost of
the reusable container has not been amortised and included in the value of the product
(c) Yes, since the amount has been charged by reason of, or in connection with the sale of
goods, this amount will be added to the transaction value
(d) Since in such cases the price will not be the sole consideration for the sale, the valuation
would be governed by Rule 6 and the cost of such packing, whether durable or not, will be
included in the transaction value of the goods. In respect of packing which can be used
repeatedly the cost will have to be amortized over the life span of the packing material as is
done in the case of dies, moulds etc. supplied by the buyer.
5.
How will valuation be done in
cases of captive consumption
(i.e consumed within the same
factory) including transfer to a
sister unit or another factory of
the same company/firm for
further use in the manufacture
of goods?
For captive consumption in one's own factory, valuation would be done as per rule 8 of the
Valuation Rules i.e. the assessable value will be 115% of the "cost of production" of the
goods.
If the same goods are partly sold by the assessee and partly consumed captively, the goods
sold would be assessed on the basis of "transaction value" [provided they meet the
conditions of sec.4(1)(a)] and the goods captively consumed would be valued as per Rule 8
of the Valuation Rules. This is because, as per new section 4, transaction value has to be
determined for each removal.
Where goods are transferred to a sister unit or another unit of the same company valuation
will be done as per the proviso to rule 9.
6.
Whether advertisement and
publicity charges borne by the
dealers/buyers are to be
excluded from the assessable
value
No. Even where the dealings are on principal to principal basis but there is an agreement
either written or oral that the buyer will incur certain expenditure for advertising the goods of
the assessee, the cost of such advertisement and publicity will be added to the price of the
goods to determine the assessable value. In such cases since price would not be sole
consideration for sale, the transaction value would be covered by Rule 6 of the Valuation
Rules
As per definition, "transaction value" has to include the cost which the buyer incurs, or
makes provision for, or on behalf of the assessee, for advertising or publicity charges.
Court judgements delivered on this issue under the earlier Section 4, or the Rules made
thereunder, will not apply w.e.f. 1.7.2000, in view of the definition of "transaction value"
However, where the brand name/copyright owner gets his goods manufactured from outside
(on job-work or otherwise), the expenditure incurred by the brand name/copyright owner on
advertisement and publicity charges, in respect of the said goods, will not be added to the
assessable value, as such expenditure is not incurred on behalf of the manufacturer
(assessee). [Also refer Board's Circular 619/10/2002 CX dt 19.2.2002] ]
7.
What about the cost of after
sales service charges and pre
delivery inspection (PDI)
charges, incurred by the
dealer during the warranty
period ?
Since these services are provided free by the dealer on behalf of the assessee, the cost
towards this is included in the dealer"s margin (or reimbursed to him). This is one of the
considerations for sale of the goods (motor vehicles, consumer items etc.) to the dealer and
will therefore be governed by Rule 6 of the Valuation Rules on the same grounds as
indicated in respect of Advertisement and Publicity charges. That is, in such cases the after
sales service charges and PDI charges will be included in the assessable value.
8.
Will delayed payment charges
be excluded from the
transaction value?
Yes, since " transaction value" relates to the price paid or payable for the goods. In this case
the delayed payment charge is nothing but the interest on the price of the goods which is not
paid during the normal credit period. However, to be admissible as deduction it should be
separately shown or indicated in the invoice and should be charged over and above the sale
price of the goods. Attention in this regard is invited to Board's Circular No. 194/28/96-CX
dated 29.3.1996 which is still relevant so far as this element is concerned. [Also refer to
para 8 of Board's letter F.No.354/81/2000-TRU dt 30.6.2000]
9. Is cash discount an
admissible deduction?
Since valuation is now based on "transaction value" the cash discount, if actually passed on
to the buyers, will be allowed as deduction, the transaction being on principal to principal
basis.
10.
Should erection, installation
and commissioning charges
be included in the assessable
value
If the final product is not excisable, the question of including these charges in the assessable
value of the product does not arise. As for example, since a Steel Plant, as a whole, is an
immovable property and therefore not excisable, no duty would be payable on the cost of
erection, installation and commissioning of the steel plant. Similarly, if a machine is cleared
from a factory on payment of appropriate duty and later on taken to the premises of the
buyer for installation/erection and commissioning into an immovable property, no further duty
would be payable. On the other hand if parts/components of a generator are brought to a
site and the generator erected/installed and commissioned at the site then, the generator
being an excisable commodity, the cost of erection, installation and commissioning charges
would be included in its assessable value. In other words if the expenditure on erection,
installation and commissioning has been incurred to bring into existence any excisable
goods, these charges would be included in the assessable value of the goods. If these costs
are incurred to bring into existence some immovable property, they will not be included in the
assessable value of such resultant property.[Refer Board's 37B Order No 58/1/2002 - CX dt
15.1.2002]
11 How will valuation be done in
cases of job-work?
Please also refer to Board's Circular No.619/10/2002 - CX dt 19.2.2002.
Cost of transporting the raw materials/inputs to the premises of the job-worker will also be
added to determine the cost of the raw material/input.[1997(071)ECR381(TRIB)]
12
How will valuation be done
when goods are sold partly to
related persons and partly to
independent buyers?
There is no specific rule covering such a contingency. Transaction value in respect of sales
to unrelated buyers cannot be adopted for sales to related buyers since as per section 4(1)
transaction value is to be determined for each removal. For sales to unrelated buyers
valuation will be done as per section 4(1)(a) and for sale of the same goods to related
buyers recourse will have to be taken to the residuary rule 11 read with rule 9 (or 10). Rule 9
cannot be applied in such cases directly since it covers only those cases where all the sales
are to be related to buyers only.
13
How will valuation of samples
be done which are distributed
free, as part of marketing
strategy, or as gifts or
donations?
Since the goods are not sold section 4(1)(a) will not apply and recourse will have to be taken
to the Valuation Rules. No specific rule covers such a contingency. Except rule 8 all the other
rules cover contingencies where sale is involved in some form or the other. Therefore, the
residuary rule 11 will have to be adopted along with the spirit of rule 8. In other words, the
assessable value would be 115% of the 'cost of production or manufacture' of the goods.
14
How will valuation be done
when inputs or capital goods,
on which CENVAT credit has
been taken, are removed as
such from the factory, under
the erstwhile sub rule (1C) of
rule 57AB of the Central
Excise Rules, 1944, or under
rule 3(4) of the Cenvat Credit
Rules, 2001 or 2002?
Where inputs or capital goods, on which credit has been taken, are removed as such on
sale, there should be no problem in ascertaining the transaction value by application of
sec.4(1)(a) or the Valuation Rules. [provided tariff values have not been fixed for the inputs
or they are not assessed under Section 4A on the basis of MRP]
There may be cases where the inputs or capital goods are removed as such to a sister unit
of the assessee or to another factory of the same company and where no sale is involved. It
may be noticed that sub rule (1C) of Rule 57AB of the erstwhile Central Excise Rules, 1944
and Rule3(4) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2001( now 2002), talk of determination of value for
"such goods" and not the "said goods". Thus, if the assessee partly sells the inputs to
independent buyers and partly transfers to its sister units, the transaction value of "such
goods" would be available in the form of the transaction value of inputs sold to an unrelated
buyer (if the sale price to the unrelated buyer varies over a period of time, the value nearest
to the time of removal should be adopted).
Problems will, however, arise where the assessee does not sell the inputs/capital goods to
any independent buyer and the only removal of such input/capital goods, outside the factory,
is in the nature of transfer to a sister unit. In such a case proviso to rule 9 will apply and
provisions of rule 8 of the valuation rules would have to be invoked. However, this would
require determination of the 'cost of production or manufacture', which would not be possible
since the said inputs/capital goods have been received by the assessee from outside and
have not been produced or manufactured in his factory. Recourse will, therefore, have to be
taken to the residuary rule 11 of the valuation rules and the value determined using
reasonable means consistent with the principles and general provisions of the valuation
rules and sub-section (1) of sec.4 of the Act. In that case it would be reasonable to adopt the
value shown in the invoice on the basis of which CENVAT credit was taken by the assessee
in the first place. In respect of capital goods adequate depreciation may be given as per the
rates fixed in letter F.No.495/16/93 -Cus VI dated 26.5.93, issued on the Customs side.