HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD THROUGH REGISTRAR GENERAL versus THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 28 March 2018 | [2018] 9 S.C.R. 1090 | 2018 INSC 291
Key facts
- Decided
- 28 March 2018
- Bench
- ADARSH KUMAR GOEL*, R.F. NARIMAN
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3356/2018
- Disposal
- Disposed off
- Citation
- [2018] 9 S.C.R. 1090
- Neutral citation
- 2018 INSC 291
Text of the judgment
1090
A
[2018] REPORTS
9 S.C.R. 1090
SUPREME COURT
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD –
THROUGH REGISTRAR GENERAL
v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
B
(Civil Appeal No.3356 of 2018)
MARCH 28, 2018
[ADARSH KUMAR GOEL AND R. F. NARIMAN, JJ.]
C
D
E
F
G
H
U.P. Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975 – Determination of
seniority of promotees and direct recruits – Earlier, in absence of
determination of vacancies for the period from 2002 till 2007, neither
promotees were appointed in spite of availability of vacancies and
eligibility nor direct recruitments were made – After the amendment
of the Rules in 2007, recruitment process was initiated, and
vacancies were worked out and advertisements were issued – Both
promotees and direct recruits were appointed – After the
appointments, the dispute of seniority cropped up – The direct
recruits claimed that they were entitled to be given seniority as per
Rota system laid down under the Rules and they had been wrongly
placed junior to the promotees – The promotees claimed that their
seniority should commence from the date of accrual of vacancy,
date of their eligibility, without their passing of the suitablity test
which was retrospectively prescribed for the first time after the
amendment of the 2007 Rules – Held: The High Court was correct
in taking the view that suitability test was required in terms of
judgment rendered in All India Judges Association case and under
the amended Rules applicable retrospectively – Promotees could
not be given promotion without suitability test nor could they claim
seniority without the same – They were rightly given seniority from
their appointments – Insofar as Quota-Rota rule is concerned, it is
a mandatory requirement of the Rules – The said requirement has
however to be seen in the peculiar fact situation – On facts, the
issue of determination of vacancies was embroiled in continuous
litigation – The Quota-Rota rule could not be applied in the absence
of determination of vacancies – The rule provided for seniority of
the promotees to be fixed from the date of availability of vacancy
but such seniority could also not be given in the present fact situation
– If Rota rule is applied, it will work serious prejudice to the
1090
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGISTRAR GENERAL v. THE STATE OF U. P.
1091
promotes – Thus, the Rules will have to be given pragmatic
interpretation – If it becomes impractical to act upon rule fixing
quota from two sources, it is no use insisting that the authority must
give effect to such a rule – Every effort has to be made to respect a
rule but if it is not feasible to enforce it, the rule has to be given a
practical interpretation – Thus, interference by the High Court
with the seniority given to the promotees above the direct recruits
without following the rotation principle cannot be sustained.
A
B
Disposing of the matters, the Court
HELD: 1. The first issue raised is whether the promotees
recruited in the year 2008/2009 are entitled to seniority prior to
their selection on the ground that no suitability test was required
prior to 9 th January, 2007 and retrospective effect to such
requirement was illegal. The view taken by the High Court is
correct that suitability test was required in terms of judgment of
this Court in All India Judges’ case and under the amended Rules
applicable retrospectively. Thus, the promotees could not be
given promotion without suitability test nor could they claim
seniority without the same. They have been rightly given seniority
from their appointments. [Para 29] [1111-B-D]
2. With regard to the Quota-Rota rule, there is no doubt
that this is a mandatory requirement of the Rules. The said
requirement has however to be seen in the peculiar fact situation.
The issue of determination of vacancies was embroiled in
continuous litigation. The Quota-Rota rule could not be applied
in the absence of determination of vacancies. The suitability test
though validly laid down could not be held till 2008. No promotion
could be given in absence of suitability test. The rule provided
for seniority of the promotees to be fixed from the date of
availability of vacancy but such seniority could also not be given
in the present fact situation. If rota rule is applied, it will work
serious prejudice to the promotees. Thus, the Rules will have to
be given pragmatic interpretation. If it becomes impractical to
act upon rule fixing quota from two sources, it is no use insisting
that the authority must give effect to such a rule. Every effort
has to be made to respect a rule but if it is not feasible to enforce
it, the rule has to be given a practical interpretation. Thus,
interference by the High Court with the seniority given to the
C
D
E
F
G
H
1092
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
promotees above the direct recruits without following the rotation
principle cannot be sustained. [Para 30] [1111-D-H]
All India Judges Association v. Union of India (2002) 4 SCC
247 : [2002] 2 SCR 712 – followed.
V.K. Srivastava v. Govt. of U.P. (2008) 9 SCC 77 : [2008] 13
SCR 24; R.K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab (1995) 2 SCC
745 : [1995] 2 SCR 35; Direct Recruit Class-II Engineering
Officers’ Association v. State of Maharashtra (1990) 2 SCC
715: [1990] 2 SCR 900 – relied on.
P. K. Dixit v. State of U.P. (1987) 4 SCC 621 : [1988] 1 SCR
398; O.P.Garg v. State of U.P. (1991) Supp. (2) SCC 51 :
[1991] 2 SCR 424; Sri Kant Tripathi v. State of U.P. (2001)
10 SCC 237 : [2001] 2 Suppl. SCR 635; Ashok Pal Singh v.
U.P. Judicial Services Association (2010) 12 SCC 635 : [2010]
12 SCR 25; Het Singh Yadav v. State of U.P. Civil
Appeal No. 5270 of 2012 decided on 15.9.2016 – referred to.
Case Law Reference
[2002] 2 SCR 712
followed
Para 1
[1988] 1 SCR 398
referred to
Para 2
[1991] 2 SCR 424
referred to
Para 2
[2001] 2 Suppl. SCR 635
referred to
Para 2
[2010] 12 SCR 25
referred to
Para 2
[2008] 13 SCR 24
relied on
Para 2
[1995] 2 SCR 35
relied on
Para 10
[1990] 2 SCR 900
relied on
Para 30
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 3356
of 2018
From the Judgment and Order dated 30.06.2017 of the High Court
of Judicature at Allahabad Lucknow Bench, Lucknow in Service Bench
No. 1880 of 2017.
WITH
C. A. No. 3355 of 2018
SLP (C) Nos. 27284 and 27876 of 2017
SLP (C) No. 8334 of 2018
T. P. (C) No. 81 of 2018
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P.
1093
R. Venkataramani, P.S. Patwalia, Siddharth Luthra, Rakesh
Dwivedi, S. R. Singh, R. Basant, Sr. Advs., Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi,
Yashraj Singh Bundela, M. R. Shamshad, Praveen Vignesh, Vyom
Raghuvashi, Sangya Megi, Sakshi Kakkar, Shakti Singh, Karan S.,
Ms. Mainka Verma, Ms. Preetika Dwivedi, Apoorva Garg, Mangal
Prasad, Ankur Yadav, Ms. Shweta Yadav, Yash Pal Dhingra, Rana Ranjit
Singh, Abhay Kumar S., Ravish Singh, Vivek K. Singh, Kaushal Narayan
Mishra, A. K. Behra, Jasbir Singh Malik, Ms. Usha Nandini. V, Praveen
Kumar Aggarwal, Sanjay Rastogi, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Mohit Paul,
Anugrah Niraj Ekka, Vikas Arora, Garvesh Kabra, Aviral Saxena, Sanjay
Kumar Tyagi, Venkita Subramoniam T. R, Rakesh U. Upadhyay, Ms. Aarti
Upadhyay, Amar Deep Sharma, Advs. for the appearing parties.
A
B
C
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J. 1. Leave granted in Special
Leave Petition (Civil) No.26993 of 2017 and SLP (Civil) D. No.39750
of 2017. The question for consideration is the validity of determination
of seniority of promotee and direct recruit Higher Judicial Service (HJS)
officers in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Dispute mainly relates to the
principle to be applied for determining seniority for direct recruits and
promotees of the years 2007 and 2009 in the context of Rules 22 and 26
of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975 (the Rules)
and the judgment of this Court in All India Judges Association versus
Union of India1.
2. Before giving brief facts we may note that the Rules and the
issue of seniority of the HJS officers were subject matter of consideration,
inter alia, in P.K. Dixit versus State of U.P.2, O.P. Garg versus State
of U.P.3, Sri Kant Tripathi versus State of U.P.4, Ashok Pal Singh
versus U.P. Judicial Services Association5, V.K. Srivastava versus
Govt. of U.P.6 and Het Singh Yadav versus State of U.P.7
D
E
F
3. In P. K. Dixit (supra), there was challenge to the seniority list
on the ground that vacancies had not been properly calculated as per the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
(2002) 4 SCC 247
(1987) 4 SCC 621
(1991) Supp. (2) SCC 51
(2001) 10 SCC 237
(2010) 12 SCC 635
(2008) 9 SCC 77
Civil Appeal No.5270 of 2012 decided on 15.9.2016
G
H
1094
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
Rules. This Court directed that matter should be examined afresh with
reference to appointments on posts available before the Rules came into
force.
4. In O.P. Garg (supra), challenge to seniority list of 1988 was
considered. This Court held that benefit of continuous length of service
for a promote officer for a promote officer has to be with reference to
availability of a vacancy and not independent thereof. Second and third
proviso to Rule 8(2) and part of Rules 22 and 26 were declared ultra vires.
5. In Sri Kant Tripathi (supra) question was about correctness
of calculation for working out ratio between direct recruits and promotees.
The issue had arisen with reference to recruitments for the years 1988
to 1994. This Court directed that for 1988 recruitment, the High Court
should determine number of vacancies available in the relevant year of
recruitment and then allocate the vacancies to different sources of
recruitment. It was also directed that vacancies should be filled up in
the year when vacancies become available. If a post is available in the
quota of promotees, selection is made but promotion is not given,
promotion must take effect from the date the promotee could have been
appointed.
6. In Ashok Pal Singh (supra) one of the issues was whether
procedure of carrying forward of vacancies adopted by the High Court
was erroneous. This Court held that no direct recruit at a subsequent
recruitment can claim that his seniority should be reckoned from the
date earlier to the date of his joining. The seniority of the promotee had
to commence from the date he should have been appointed against an
available vacancy for which he had already been selected.
7. In V.K. Srivastava (supra), challenge was to the amendment
of the Rules as notified on 9th January, 2007 on the ground that giving of
retrospective effect prejudiced the vested right of the candidate eligible
for vacancies prior to the amendment. This Court dismissed the writ
petition with the observation that the Rules had been duly complied with
for the year 2008 selection.
8. In Het Singh Yadav (supra) question for consideration was
the validity of seniority list of promotees with regard to vacancies existing
prior to 15th March, 1996. The High Court quashed the seniority list
dated 24th August, 2007. Correctness of the view taken before the High
Court was subject matter of consideration before this Court. This Court
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1095
noted that after the judgment of the High Court dated 16th December,
2010, seniority list had been finalized on 14th April, 2016 consistent with
the directions in Ashok Pal Singh (supra) against which matter was
pending consideration before the High Court. This Court set aside the
judgment of the High Court leaving the merits of the matter to be gone
into by the High Court in the matter pending before it.
A
B
9. In All India Judges case (supra), it was directed that
recruitment to HJS at the relevant time had to be as follows :
“(a) 50 per cent by promotion from amongst Civil Judges (Senior
Division) on the principle of merit-cum-seniority and passing
a suitability test;
(b) 25 per cent by promotion strictly on the basis of merit through
a limited competitive departmental examination on Civil
Judges (Senior Division) having not less than five years
qualifying service, and;
(c) 25 per cent of the posts shall be filled directly from amongst
the eligible advocates on the basis of written and viva voce
test conducted by the respective High Courts.”
10. It was observed that to avoid litigation, seniority rules should
provide for roster system as laid down in R.K. Sabharwal versus State
of Punjab8 . Direction of this Court is as follows :
“29. Experience has shown that there has been a constant
discontentment amongst the members of the Higher Judicial
Service in regard to their seniority in service. For over three
decades a large number of cases have been instituted in
order to decide the relative seniority from the officers
recruited from the two different sources, namely, promotees
and direct recruits. As a result of the decision today, there
will, in a way, be three ways of recruitment to the Higher
Judicial Service. The quota for promotion which we have
prescribed is 50 per cent by following the principle “meritcum seniority”, 25 per cent strictly on merit by limited
departmental competitive examination and 25 per cent by
direct recruitment. Experience has also shown that the least
amount of litigation in the country, where quota system in
recruitment exists, insofar as seniority is concerned, is where
8
(1995) 2 SCC 745
C
D
E
F
G
H
1096
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
a roster system is followed. For example, there is, as per the
rules of the Central Government, a 40-point roster which
has been prescribed which deals with the quotas for
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Hardly, if ever, there
has been a litigation amongst the members of the service
after their recruitment as per the quotas, the seniority is fixed
by the roster points and irrespective of the fact as to when a
person is recruited. When roster system is followed, there is
no question of any dispute arising. The 40-point roster ha
been considered and approved by this Court in R.K.
Sabharwal v. State of Punjab (supra) One of the methods of
avoiding any litigation and bringing about certainty in this
regard is by specifying quotas in relation to posts and not in
relation to the vacancies. This is the basic principle on the
basis of which the 40-point roster works. We direct the High
Courts to suitably amend and promulgate seniority rules on
the basis of the roster principle as approved by this Court in
R.K. Sabharwal case (supra) as early as possible. We hope
that as a result thereof there would be no further dispute in
the fixation of seniority. It is obvious that this system can
only apply prospectively except where under the relevant
rules seniority is to be determined on the basis of quota and
rotational system. The existing relative seniority of the
members of the Higher Judicial Service has to be protected
but the roster has to be evolved for the future.”
(emphasis added)
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
11. The Rules as originally framed envisaged three sources of
recruitment – direct recruitment from the bar, promotion from members
of Uttar Pradesh Nyayik Sewa (UPNS) and officers out of cadre of
judicial magistrates. There was also a provision for quota for the different
sources. Number of appointments to be made is required to be identified.
Seniority is to be determined as per Rule 26.
12. As a result of observations in the above judgments, there was
amendment in the Rules. It may not be necessary to refer all the
amendments but reference to some of the amendments may be
necessary.
13. Accordingly, Rule 6 was amended to give effect to the
judgment of this Court in All India Judges’ case (supra) vide U.P.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1097
Higher Judicial Service (Sixth Amendment) Rules, 2006 notified on
January 09, 2007. By the said amendment, the criteria for recruitment
by promotion was changed. Requirement of passing a suitability test
was incorporated. There was also modification about the percentage of
quota. The suitability test in pursuance of the said amended rules was
held for the first time in the year 2008. The introduction of the roster
was introduced by U.P. Higher Judicial Service (Seventh Amendment)
Rules, 2009 which was notified on 8th August, 2009.
A
B
14. Reference may now be made to the relevant Rules.
Rule 5
C
U.P. Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth Amendment in 2006)
Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service
(Sixth Amendment) Rules, 2006
( come into force w.e.f 21st March, 2002)
Rule 5. Sources of recruitment.-The
recruitment to the Service shall be made-(a) by direct recruitment of pleaders and
advocates of not less than seven years'
standing on the first day of January next
following year in which the notice inviting
applications is published;
(b) by promotion of confirmed members of
the Uttar Pradesh Nyayik Sewa (hereinafter
referred to as the Nyayik Sewa), who have
put in not less than seven years service to be
computed on the first day of Januar y next
following the year in which the notice
inviting application is published:
Provided that so far long as suitable officers
are available from out of the dying cadre of
the Judicial Magistrates confirmed officers
who have put in not less than seven years
service to be computed as aforesaid shall be
eligible for appointment as Additional
Sessions Judges in the Service.
Explanation.--When a person has been both
a pleader and an advocate his total standing
in both the capacities shall be taken into
account in computing the period of seven
years under clause (a)."
Rule 5 was substituted as under:Sources
of
recruitment--The
recruitment to the service shall be made-
D
(a) By promotion from amongst the Civil
Judges (Senior Division) on the basis of
Principle of merit-cum-seniority and
passing a suitability test.
(b) By promotion strictly on the basis of
merit through limited competitive
examination of Civil Judges (Senior
Division) having not less than five years
qualifying service;
(c) By direct recruitment from amongst
the Advocates of not less than seven
years standing on the first day of January
next following the year in which the
notice inviting applications is published.
E
F
G
H
1098
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
Rule 6
U.P. Higher Judicial
Service Rules, 197 5
(Prior to the Sixth
A mendment in 2006)
U ttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service (Sixth
Amendment) Rules,
2006
Uttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service
(Ninth Amendment)
Rules, 2014
st
B
Rule 6. Q uota.- Subject
to the provisions of Rule
8, the qu ota for various
sources of recruitment
shall be-
C
D
Provided that where the
number of vacancies to
be filled in by any of
these
sour ces
in
accordance with the quota
is in fraction, less than
half shall be ignored and
the fraction of h alf or
more sh all ordinarily be
counted as one:
(i) Direct recruits from
the Bar 15%
of the
vacan cies
E
(ii)
Uttar
Pradesh
Nyayik Sewa 70%
(iii) Utt ar Pradesh
Judicial Officers
service (Judicial
M agistrate) 15%
F
G
H
Provided fur ther that
when the stren gth in the
cadre of the Judicial
Mag istrates gradually gets
depleted or is completely
exh austed and suitable
candidates
are
n ot
available in requisite
numbers or no candidate
remains available at all,
the shortfall in the number
of vacan cies required to
be filled from amongst
Judicial Magistrates and
in the long run all the
vacan cies, shall be filled
(come into force w.e.f 21
Mar ch, 2002)
Rule 6 was substituted
as under:6. Quota-Subject to the
provisions of rule 8, the
quota for various sources
of recruitment shall be-
Rule 6 was substituted
as under:Quota-6. Subject to th e
provisions of rule 8, th e
quota
for
various
sources of recruitment
shall be-
(i) Uttar Pradesh Nyayik
Sewa:
(a) from amongst the (i)
Uttar
Pradesh
Civil Judges (Senior Nyayik Sewa:
Division ) on the basis
of
merit-cum- (a) from amongst th e
sen iority an d passing
Civil Judges (Senior
a suitability test. Division) on the
50%
basis of merit-cumseniority and passing
(b) on th e basis of merit
a suitability test. through
limited
65%
competitive
(b)
on the basis of
examination of Civil
merit
through
Judges
(Senior
limited competitive
Division ) having n ot
examination of civil
less than five years
Ju dges
(Senior
qualifying service. Division) having n ot
10%
less than five years
service. -10%
Provided that in case
of there being an y Provided th at in case
shortfall in th e vacancies
of there being an y
to be filled up on the basis
sh ortfall
in
the
of in cadr e competitive
vacancies
to be
examination , the shortfall
filled up on the basis
of 25% reserved for such
of
in
cadre
promotion will be made
competitive
good by corresp on ding
examination,
the
incr ease in the quota
sh ortfall of 10%
reserved for promotion of
reserved for such
Civil
Judge
(Senior
promotion will be
Division ) referred to in
made
good
by
Clause (i)(a).
corr esponding
in crease in the quota
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
Higher
ice
ment)
4
by promotion from
amongst th e members
of the Nyayik Sewa
an d their quota shall,
in
due
course,
become 85 per cent.
tituted
to th e
8, th e
various
uitment
(ii) direct recruitment
from Bar - 25%
Provided
that
where the number of
vacan cies to be filled in
by any of these sources
in accordance with the
quota is in fraction, less
than half shall be ignored
an d th e fraction of half
or more shall ordinarily
be coun ted as one:"
radesh
st th e
Senior
n the
t-cumpassing
test. -
asis of
hrough
petitive
of civil
Senior
ng n ot
years
n case
g an y
the
o be
e basis
cadre
the
10%
such
ill be
by
quota
reserved for promotion
of Civil Judg e (Senior
Division) referred to in
clause (i)(a).
(ii) Direct recruitment
from Bar-25%
Provided that
where th e number of
vacancies to be filled
in by any of the
sources in accordan ce
with the quota is in
fraction, less than half
shall be ignored and
the fraction of half or
more shall ordinarily
be counted as one:
1099
A
B
C
Rule 8
U.P. Higher Judicial Service
Rules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth Amendment in
2006)
Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial
Service (Sixth Amendment) Rules,
2006
Rule 8. Number of appointments to
be made.---(1) Th e Court shall,
from time to time, but not later than
three years
from
the
last
recruitment, fix th e number of
officers to be taken at the
recruitment keeping in view the
vacan cies th en existin g and likely to
occur in the next two years.
In Rule 8 the existing sub rule (2)
was substituted as under:-
Note---The limitation of three years
mentioned in this sub-rule shall not
apply to the first recruitment held
after the enforcement of these rules.
(2) If at any selection the number of
selected direct recruits available for
appointment is less than the number
of recruits decided by th e Court to
be taken from that source, the Court
may in crease correspondingly the
number of recruits to be taken by
promotion from the Nyayik Sewa;
D
(come into force w.e.f 21st March,
20 02)
E
"8.(2) If at any selection the number
of selected direct recruits available
for
"8.(2) If at any selection the number
of selected direct recruits available
for appointment is less than the
number of recruits decided by the
Court to be taken from that source,
the
Court
may
increase
correspondingly the number of
recruits to be taken by promotion
from the Nyayik Sewa;
G
Provided that the number of
vacan cies filled in as aforesaid
under this sub rule sh all be
taken into consideration while
fixing the number of vacancies
to be allotted to the quota of
H
F
1100
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
Provided that the number of vacan cies filled
in as aforesaid under this sub rule shall be
taken into consideration while fixing the
number of vacancies to be allotted to the
quota of direct recruits at th e n ext
recruitment, and the quota for direct recruits
may be raised accordingly; so, h owever, that
the percentage of direct recruits in the
Service does not in any case exceed 1 5 per
cent of stren gth of th e service.
Provided further th at all the perman ent
vacan cies existing on May 10, 1974 plus 31
temporary p osts existing on that date, if an y
when they are converted into perman ent
posts, shall be filled by promotion from
amongst the members of the N yayik Sewa;
and only th e remaining vacancies shall be
shared between th e three sources under these
rules;
Provided also that th e number of vacancies
equal to 15 per cent of the vacan cies referred
to in the last precedin g proviso shall be
worked out for being allocated in future to
the Judicial Magistrates in addition to their
quota of 15 per cent prescribed in Rule 6, an d
thereupon, future recruitment (after the
promotion from amongst th e members of the
Nyayik Sewa against vacancies referred to in
the last preceding proviso) shall be so
arranged that for so lon g as the additional 15
per cent vacancies worked out as above h ave
not been filled up from out of th e Judicial
Magistrates, th e allocation of vacancies sh all
as follows--(i) 15 per cent by direct recruitment.
(ii) 30 per cen t from out of the Ju dicial
Magistrate;
(iii) 55 per cen t from out of the members
of the Nyayik Sewa.
direct recruits at
the
next
recruitment, and
the quota for
direct
recruits
may be raised
accordingly
so,
however, th at the
percentage
of
direct recruits in
the service does
not in any case
exceed 25% of
strength of the
service.
ts at
next
and
for
cruits
aised
so,
t the
of
ts in
does
case
of
the
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1101
Rule 18
A
U.P. Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth Amendment in 2006)
Rule 18. (1) The Selection Committee referred to in Rule 16 shall
scrutinize the applications received and may thereafter hold such
examination, as it may considered necessary for judging the suitability
of the cand idates. The committee may call for interview such of the
applicants wh o in its op inion have qualified for in terview aft er scrutiny
an d examination.
(2) In assessin g the merits of a candidate th e Selection Committee shall
have due regard to his professi on al ability,character, personality and
health.
(3)The Selection Committee shall make a preliminary selection and
submit the record of all candidates to the Chief Justice and recommend
the names of the candidates in order of merit who, in its opinion, are
suitable for appointment to the service.
B
C
D
(4) The Court shall examine the recommendation s of the Selection
Committee and havin g regard to the n umber of direct recruits to be
taken, prepare a list of selected candidates in order of merit and
forward the same to the Governor.
E
Rule 20
U.P. Higher Judicial
Service R ules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth
Amendment in 2006)
Rule 20. Promotion of
M emb ers of Nyayik
Sewa- (1) Recruitment by
promotion
of
the
members of the N yayik
Sewa sh all be made by
selection on the prin ciple
of seniority-cum-merit.
(2)
The
field
of
eligibility for recruitment
by promotion sh all be
Uttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service (Sixth
Amendment) R ules,
2006
(come into force w.e.f.
st
21 March, 2002)
In Rule 20- for the
existing sub -rules (1)
and (2), the following
sub-ru les
were
substituted:(1) Recruitment by
promotion of the
member s of
the
Nyayik Sewa shall
be made by selection
on the prin ciple of
Uttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service (Ninth
Amendment) Rules,
2014
F
The existing sub-rule (3)
of
rule
20
was
substituted as under:20.(3)
The
Selection
Committee sh all, after
examining the record of
the officers included in
the list prepared un der
sub-rule (2) of this rule
make
a
prelimin ary
selection of the officers
G
H
1102
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
confined to four times the
number of vacancies to be
filled by promotion. The
Selection Committee shall
prepare a list in order of
seniority of the officers
eligible under Rule 5(b) of
these rules.
(3)The Selection Committee
shall, after examining the
record of the officers included
in the list prepared under subrule (2) of this Rule make a
preliminary selection of the
officers who in its opinion are
fit to be appointed on the basis
of seniority-cum-merit. In
assessing the merits of a
candidate,
the
Selection
Committee have due regard to
his service record, ability,
character and seniority. The
list shall contain the name of
officers twice the number of
vacancies required to be filled
by promotion of the members
of the Nyayik Sewa.
(4) The Selection Committee
shall forward the list of the
candidates chosen at the
preliminary selection to the
Chief Justice along with the
names of the officers who, if
any, in the opinion of the
Committee have been passed
over for promotion to the
service.
(5) The Court shall examine
the recommendations of the
Selection and make a final
selection for promotion and
prepare a list in order of
seniority of the candidates
who are considered fit for
promotion and forward the
same to the Governor. The list
shall remain operative only till
the next recruitment.
merit-cum-seniority
and on passing such a
suitability test, as
prescribed in Appendix
"G(1)"
(2) The field of
eligibility
for
recruitment
by
promotion
shall be confined to
four times the number
of vacancies to be
filled by promotion.
The
selection
Committee
shall
prepare a list in order
of seniority of the
officers eligible under
Rule 5(a) of these
rules.
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
who in its opinion are fit to
be appointed on the basis
of merit-cum-seniority. In
assessing the merit of a
candidate, the Selection
Committee
have
due
regard to his service
record, ability, character
and seniority. The list shall
contain the names of
officers twice the number
of vacancies required to be
filled by promotion of the
members of the Nyayik
Sewa.
are fit to
he basis
ority. In
it of a
Selection
e
due
service
haracter
list shall
mes of
number
ed to be
n of the
Nyayik
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1103
Rule 21
A
U.P. Higher Judicial Service Rules,
1975
(Prior to the Sixth A mendment in
2006)
Rule 21. Temporary provisions for
the
cadre
of
the
Judicial
Magistrate.- (1) For so long as
suitable officers are available from out
of the dyin g cadre of the Uttar Prad esh
Judicial Officers Service, confirmed
officers who h ave put in not less than
seven years' service shall be eligible
for
appointment as Addition al
Sessions Judges in the service, as
provided in Rules 4, 5, 6 and 8. Such
officers may also b e appointed as
Addition al
Sessions
Judge
in
officiating an d temporary capacity
upto the extent of 15 per cent of the
vacan cies in the cadre occurring
during any on e period of Selection.
(2) The field of eligibility for
appointment from out of the Judicial
Mag istrate shall be con fined to four
times the number of vacancies to be
filled from this source. The Selection
Committee shall prepare a list in order
of seniority of the eligible officers.
(3) Criterion for selection shall be
seniority-cu m-merit. In assessing the
merits of a candidate the Selection
Committee sh all have due regard to
his service record ability, ch aracter
an d seniority. The preliminary
selection shall be made by the
Selection Committee referred to in
Rule 6 and th e list of the selected
candidates shall be forwarded to the
Chief Justice along with the n ames of
the officers wh o, if an y, in the opinion
of the Committee are un fit for
appointment to the Service.
Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial
Service (Sixth Amendment)
R ules, 2006
(come into force w.e.f 21s t
March, 2002)
The existing Rule 21 was
substituted as under:-:
(1) Recruitment by promotion of
the members of Nyayik Sewa as
referred to in Rule 5(b) sh all be
made by selection strictly on the
basis o f merit through a limited
competitive
examination as
prescribed in Appendix 'H'.
B
C
(2)App lication for recruitment to
the service from such sources
sh all be
invited by the Court through
District Judges.
D
(3) th e District Judge shall
forward to the Court all
applications received by him
alongwith his own estimate of
each candidate's character and
fitn ess for appointment to th e
service.
E
(4) Th e Selection Committee
referred to in Rule 16 shall
scrutinize the
applications received and shall
hold a limited competitive
examination, as
prescribed in Appendix 'H'.
(5) Th e Selection Committee
sh all prepare a select list on th e
basis of th e
merit
of
th e
succes sful
can didates.
F
G
.
H
1104
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(4) The Court sh all examine the
recommendations of the Selection
Committee and make a fin al selection
an d prepare a list of candidates
considered fit for appointment in order
of seniority an d forward the n ames of
the o fficers. The list shall remain
operative
only
till the
n ext
recruitment.
(5)..........
(6)..........
(7) The Court sh all examine the
recommendations of the Selection
Committee and make a fin al selection
for appointmen t in HJS cadre and
prepare a list in order of merit and
forward the same to th e Governor.
The list shall remain operative only till
the next recruitment.
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
(6) The committee shall make a
prelimin ary selection an d submit
the record of all candidates to
the
Chief
Justice
and
recommend th e names of the
can didates in order of merit who,
in its opinion are suitable for
appointment to the service.
(7) The Court shall examine the
recommendations
of
the
Selection Committee and make a
final selection for appointment
in HJS cadre and prepare a list in
order of merit and forward th e
same to th e Govern or. The list
sh all remain operative only till
the next recruitment
Rule 22
U.P. Higher Judicial
Service Rules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth
Amendment in 2006)
Uttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service
(Seventh Amendment)
Rules, 2009
Uttar Pradesh Higher
Judicial Service
(Ninth Amendment)
Rules, 2014
Rule 22. Appointment(1) Subject to the provisions
of sub-rules (2) an d (3), the
Governor shall on receipt
from the Court of the lists
mentioned in Rule 18, 20 and
21 make appointments to the
service on the occurrence of
substantive vacancies by
taking candidates from the
lists in the order in which
they stand in the respective
lists.
Rule
22
.
Appointment.-(1)
Subject to the provisions
of sub-rule (2) the
Governor
shall,
on
receipt from the Court of
the list mentioned in
Rules 18, 20 and 21
make appointments to
the service on the
occurrence
of
substantive vacancies by
taking candidates from
the list in the order in
wh ich they stand in the
respective
lists
in
accordance with the
roster.
In Rule 22, the
existing sub-rule (2)
was substituted as
under:22.(2) Appointments to
the service shall be
made on the basis of
roster system, the first
post shall be filled from
the list of promotees,
the second post shall be
filled up by direct
recruit, the third and
fourth posts shall be
filled up from the list of
promotees and fifth
post shall be filled up
by the candidate
ake a
bmit
es to
and
the
who,
e for
e th e
the
ake a
ment
ist in
d the
e list
y till
igher
ce
ment)
the
e (2)
d as
nts to
ll be
sis of
e first
d from
motees,
hall be
direct
d and
be
list of
fifth
ed up
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
(2) Appointments to the
service shall be made on the
rotational system, the first
vacancy shall be filled from
the list of officers of the
Nyayik Sewa. The second
vacancy shall be filled from
the list of direct recruits (and
so on), the remaining
vacancies, shall th erefore be
filled by promotion from the
list of the officers of the
Nyayik Sewa.
Provided that for so long as
suitable
officers
are
available from th e cadre of
the Judicial Magistrates,
appoin tments to the Service
shall be made in such a
way that the second fifth
and eighth (and so on),
vacancy sh all be filled
from the list of judicial
Magistrates.
(3) In the eventuality of delay
in making ap pointment under
sub-rule (1) and further if
exigency of service so
requires, the Governor may,
in consultation with the
Court, make short term
appointment as a stop gap
arrangement from amongst
the members of Nyayik Sewa
in the vacancy in these
services within the quota
fixed by the Court till the
appointment are made under
subrules (1) an d (2):
Provided th at the period of
service spen t by a member of
Nyayik Sewa on short term
appointment to the service as
a stop-gap arrangement shall
not be computed from
seniority under Rule 26.
(2) App ointments to
service shall be made on
the basis of roster
system, th e first and
second post shall be
filled from the list of
promotes, the third post
shall be filled up by
direct recruit an d the
fourth post shall be filled
up by the candidate
selected strictly on merit
through LDCE (and so
on ) according to the
roster as prescribed in
Appendix 'I', which will
cease
to
become
operative on the date the
respective three streams
achieve their full allotted
vacancies. Th ereafter on
account of arising any
vacancy in quota of
respective stream the
same could be filled-up
from th e same stream of
which vacancy arises:
Provided that while
followin g the roster at
no point of time the
percen tage of posts
filled from direct
recruit and LDCE shall
exceed 25% each of
th e vacancies available
at the time of selection.
In case th e percentage
is
exceeding
the
allotted quota, in such
even tuality
the
promotee shall occupy
th e vacan cy which
would have gone to the
direct recruit or LDCE,
had not the same been
an excess of 25% of
either of the two.
selected strictly on
merit through LDCE
(and so on ) according
to the
roster
as
prescribed in Appendix
'1', which will cease to
become operative on
the date the respective
three streams achieve
their
full
allotted
vacan cies. Thereafter
on account of arising
any vacancy in quota of
respective stream the
same could be filled-up
from the same stream
of which
vacan cy arises;
Provided that while
following the roster at
no point of time the
respective percentage
of posts filled from
direct recruit and
LDCE shall exceed
25% an d 10% of the
strength of service. In
case the percentage is
exceeding the allotted
quota,
in
such
eventuality
the
promotee
shall
occupy th e vacancy
which would have
gone to direct recruit
or LDCE, h ad not the
same been in excess
of 25% and 10%
respectivel y of eith er
of the two.
1105
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
1106
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(4) The appoin tments
shall
be
made on
rotational system, the first
vacan cy sh all be filled
from the list of officers of
the Nyayik Sewa, the
second vacancy shall be
filled from the list of
Judicial Magistrates (and
so on).
C
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
(3) In the eventuality of
d elay in making app ointment
under sub-rule (1) and further
if exigency of service so
requires the Governor may,
in constitution with the
Court, make short term
appointment as a stop-gap
arrangement from amongst
the promotees, in the vacancy
in these services fill the
appointment are made under
sub-rules (1) and (2):
Provided th at the period of
service
spen t
by the
promotees on a short term
appointment to the service as
stop-gap arrangement shall
not be computed under Rule
26.
D
Rule 26
E
F
G
H
U.P. Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975
(Prior to the Sixth Amendment in 2006)
Rule 26. Sen iority.--(1 ) Sen iority of the officers appoin ted in the
Service shall be determined in accordance with the order of
ppointment in the Service un der
sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 22 of these rules.
(2)Seniority of members of th e service who have been confirmed in
the service prior to the commencement of these rules shall be as has
been determined by the order of th e Government as amended from
time to time.
15. We may now note the necessary facts. It is clear from resume
of judgments of this Court that there is long history of seniority dispute
of the members of HJS. In the process, there was complex and long
drawn effort in determination and redetermination of vacancies. Though,
in pursuance of judgment of this Court in All India Judges’ case (supra),
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1107
amendment in the Rules was carried out and notified on 9th January,
2007 and principle of suitability test and roaster system were introduced,
in absence of determination of vacancies for the period from 2002 till
2007, neither the promotees could be given appointments in spite of
availability of vacancies and eligibility nor direct recruitments could be
made. Thus, recruitment for the relevant period was initiated belatedly
in the year 2007. In the absence of suitability test, which was conducted
only in the year 2008, the promotees could not be given promotion. In
the circumstances, the direct recruits selected after 2007 could not be
given seniority prior to their joining. Seniority for direct recruits by
following the rota system would have operated unfairly for the promotees.
A
16. In this background, vacancies as on 31st December, 2006 and
expected vacancies upto 31st December, 2008 were determined for the
direct recruits and promotees on 15th February, 2007.
C
17. After the rules were amended in the year 2007, vacancies
were worked out and advertisement was issued on 31st March, 2007.
Suitability test for purposes of promotion was held on 10th February,
2008. Final list of selected direct recruits was approved by the Full
Court on 12th July, 2008.
the
of
d in
has
rom
18. Vide order dated 11th August, 2008, appointments to the UPHJS
by way of promotion were made. Direct recruited officers to the UPHJS
were appointed between 11th September, 2008 and 24th November, 2008.
Though, process for appointment was conducted simultaneously, the
select lists were also forwarded to the Court simultaneously, due to
observance of certain formalities, letters of appointment for direct recruits
were given later to the promotion being affected.
19. For the recruitment year 2009, calculation of vacancies was
finalized on 24th March, 2009. The same was approved by the Full
Court on 10th April, 2009. Suitability test for promotees was held on 29 th
November, 2009. Select list was approved by the Full Court on 9th
January, 2010. Appointments were notified on 7th September, 2010.
Direct recruits for the year 2009 were appointed between 24th December,
2010 to 20th April, 2011. After the appointments, the dispute of seniority
cropped up. The direct recruits claimed that they were entitled to be
given seniority as per rota system laid down under the Rules and that
they had been wrongly placed junior to the promotees. The promotees
claimed that their seniority should commence from the date of accrual
B
D
E
F
G
H
1108
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
of vacancy, date of their eligibility and officiation and not from the date
of actual appointment.
20. The High Court appointed a Committee to go into the matter.
The Committee took up determination of vacancy and fixation of seniority
for the HJS officers appointed upto 1998-2000 which was finalized on
1st August, 2011. Thereafter, determination of vacancies and fixation of
seniority of 2007 and 2009 recruitments was considered by the committee
vide its report dated 23rd September, 2015 and 6th April, 2016. The same
was approved by the Full Court on 14th June, 2016.
21. The report of the Committee dated 23rd September, 2015 was
in continuation of its earlier reports finalizing seniority lists dated 6th May,
1995 and 13th July, 2011, with reference to officers recruited prior to
2007. The Committee determined vacancies vide its report dated 7th
February, 2012 on the basis of which tentative seniority lists dated 25th
July, 2013 and 18th December, 2014 were published. Objections to the
said tentative seniority lists were considered in the said report.
22. The question considered by the Committee was whether long
officiation by officers of UPNS should be given due credit so that they
may not suffer on account of delay in holding suitability test. Suitability
test was not held due to non amendment of the Rules upto 9th January,
2007 inspite of judgment of this Court dated 21st March, 2002. Thus,
from 21st March, 2002 to 2008 since a different regime of Rules was
stipulated under the judgment of this Court in All India Judges case
(supra) and the Rules were amended by the High Court only on 9 th
January, 2007, in spite of availability of vacancies in promotion quota,
the promotee officers who were eligible and were officiating against the
said vacancies, could not be recruited. They were recruited only after
the suitability test was held for the first time in the year 2008. The
Committee thus held that they were entitled to en bloc seniority without
rota system. The direct recruits could not be given seniority for the period
prior to their appointment. Same was the position with regard to 2009
recruitments. The view of the Committee was that rota system will
create imbalance and injustice.
23. The direct recruits as well as the promotees were aggrieved
by the determination of their seniority and challenged the same by filing
Writ Petitions. In Writ Petition (SB) No.1880 of 2017 filed by the direct
recruits, respondents 134 to 173, along with others before the High Court,
H
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
1109
prayer was for quashing the final seniority Report dated 23rd September,
2015 (of Committee of High Court Judges), supplementary report dated
6th April, 2016(also of a Committee of High Court Judges) and for a
direction to redetermine seniority of the writ petitioners who were the
direct recruits on the basis of rotational system proportionate to their
quota, apart from other incidental prayers. It was submitted that since
Rule 22(2) provides for rotational basis for seniority, their date of
appointment was not conclusive for the purpose of seniority. Accordingly,
the writ petitioners sought determination of seniority by applying roster
system. The High Court and the affected officers defended the report
of the Committee as approved by the Full Court.
A
24. In Writ Petition (SB) No.16569 of 2016 filed by the promotees,
challenge was to the validity of the Amendment Rules, 2006 in so far as
the Rules were retrospective. Challenge was also to the reports of the
Committees and decision of the Full Court in so far as objections to
seniority list were rejected. The petitioners in the said writ petition were
promoted against vacancies of the years 2002 onwards but the said
vacancies were actually determined later. According to the said writ
petitioners, they were entitled to seniority from the date of their eligibility,
without their passing of the suitability test which was retrospectively
prescribed for the first time on 9th January, 2007.
C
(i)
B
D
25. The High Court examined two questions : -
E
Whether promotees were entitled to seniority prior to their
appointment on the ground that requirement of suitability test
was introduced for the first time in the year 2007 and they had a
vested right to be promoted against the earlier vacancies without
the suitability test.
F
(ii) Whether direct recruits were entitled to the benefit of rotation in
determination of seniority. The High Court held that the
promotees could not be given seniority prior to their selection.
The retrospectivity of the Rules prescribed suitability test was
valid particularly in view of judgment of this Court in V.K.
Srivastava (supra).
26. It was held that no determination of vacancies had taken place
on account of pendency of litigation which was finalized on 25 th August,
2004. No direct recruitment was made after 1998-2000 upto 2005. Only
after 25th August, 2004 determination of vacancies took place. Promotions
G
H
1110
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
A
and direct recruitments were made in respect of the said selection in the
year 2005. Promotions and direct recruitments which are subject matter
of the present case were made in 2008/2009. Thus, Writ Petition (SB)
No.16569 of 2016 was dismissed and objection of the promotees to their
seniority was rejected.
B
27. As regards claim of the direct recruits based on Quota-Rota
rule and post based roster system, it was observed that the same was
mandatory. It was accordingly, held that seniority was required to be redetermined by applying the Quota-Rota.
28. The conclusions of the High Court are as follows :
C
“In view of the above, we sum up our conclusions as under :
(1) The challenge to the vires of the 6th amendment Rules,
2006 already having been repelled by the Supreme Court in
V.K. Srivastava’s case, is not open to reconsideration by us.
D
E
F
G
(2) There is no factual and legal basis for the petitioners
claim to promotion from date of occurrence of vacancies
and seniority accordingly in Writ Petition No. 16569(SB) of
2016.
(3) The determination of vacancies by the Committee does
not require any interference but determination of seniority
is not sustainable.
(4) Considering the facts of the present case there is no error
in the appointment of direct recruits in December, 2011 and
January, 2012 w.e.f. 04.01.2007 when the last of the selectees
of the same selection had joined following the dictum in Dr.
A.K. Sirkar and in view of Balwant Singh Narwal’s case
(supra).
(5) There has been a complete non-adherence to the QuotaRota Rule and the determination of seniority in accordance
thereof in terms of Rule 22 and 26 of the Rule, 1975. The
judgment rendered in All India Judges’ Cases has not been
followed as was mandatorily required.
(6) The determination of seniority is patently erroneous and
contrary to Rule 26 of the Rules, 1975 which envisages such
determination in accordance with the order of appointment
H
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD – THR.
REGR. GENL. v. STATE OF U. P. [ADARSH KUMAR GOEL, J.]
in the service under Sub-Rules (1) and (2) of the Rule 22
which necessarily means the order of rotational/cyclical
placement of appointees from different sources of recruitment
without disturbing their inter-se placement within the same
stream/quota and not en bloc placement on the basis of date
of appointment as has been done.”
29. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The first issue
raised is whether the promotees recruited in the year 2008/2009 are
entitled to seniority prior to their selection on the ground that no suitability
test was required prior to 9th January, 2007 and retrospective effect to
such requirement was illegal. We are in agreement with the view taken
by the High Court that suitability test was required in terms of judgment
of this Court in All India Judges’ case (supra) and under the amended
Rules applicable retrospectively which was duly upheld by this Court in
V.K. Srivastava (supra). Thus, the promotees could not be given
promotion without suitability test nor could they claim seniority without
the same. They have been rightly given seniority from their appointments.
30. With regard to the Quota-Rota rule, there is no doubt that this
is a mandatory requirement of the Rules. The said requirement has
however to be seen in the peculiar fact situation. The issue of
determination of vacancies was embroiled in continuous litigation. The
Quota-Rota rule could not be applied in the absence of determination of
vacancies. The suitability test though validly laid down could not be held
till 2008 for reasons already noted. No promotion could be given in
absence of suitability test. The rule provided for seniority of the promotees
to be fixed from the date of availability of vacancy but such seniority
could also not be given in the present fact situation. If rota rule is applied,
it will work serious prejudice to the promotees. Thus, the Rules will have
to be given pragmatic interpretation. As laid down by this Court in Direct
Recruit Class-II Engineering Officers’ Association versus State of
Maharashtra9, if it becomes impractical to act upon rule fixing quota
from two sources, it is no use insisting that the authority must give
effect to such a rule. Every effort has to be made to respect a rule but
if it is not feasible to enforce it, the rule has to be given a practical
interpretation. Thus, interference by the High Court with the seniority
given to the promotees above the direct recruits without following the
rotation principle cannot be sustained.
9
(1990) 2 SCC 715, para 23
1111
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
1112
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2018] 9 S.C.R.
31. Accordingly, we allow the appeal arising out of Special Leave
Petition (Civil) No.26993 of 2017 and dismiss the Writ Petition (SB)
No.1880 of 2017 on the file of the High Court filed by the direct recruits.
We uphold the judgment of the High Court with regard to dismissal of
Writ Petition (SB) No.16569 of 2016 filed by the promotees and dismiss
the appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (civil) D.No.39750 of
2017.
In view of the above, all other matters will stand disposed of
accordingly.
Ankit Gyan
C
D
E
F
G
H
Matters disposed of.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org