RAJIVE RATURI versus UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 15 December 2017 | [2017] 12 S.C.R. 827 | 2017 INSC 1243
Key facts
- Decided
- 15 December 2017
- Bench
- A.K. SIKRI*, ASHOK BHUSHAN
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 243/2005
- Disposal
- Disposed off
- Citation
- [2017] 12 S.C.R. 827
- Neutral citation
- 2017 INSC 1243
Text of the judgment
[2017] 12 S.C.R. 827
RAJIVE RATURI
A
v.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
(Writ Petition (Civil) No. 243 of2005)
DECEMBER 15, 2017
B
[A. K. SIKRI AND ASHOK BHUSHAN, JJ.]
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 - Visual~v
disabled person - Proper and adequate access to public places Writ petition by a visually disabled perso11, seeking safe accessibility
c
to roads and transport facilities - Enumeration of ten action points
by the petitioner for providing proper access to public facilities to
such perso11s - Held: Right of the disabled persons flows from the
Constitution as also are statutorily recognised - Having regard
thereto, no denial of the fact that visually impaired persons need to
be provided proper and safe access to roads and transport as well D
as to buildi11gs, public places etc. - Without these facilities, moveme11t
of such perso11s gets impaired and can be treated as infringement
of their fundamental rights 11/Art. 19(l)(c), guaranteed to each and
every citizen of this country - Therefore, the prayers niade not
adversarial in nature - Ten action points enumerated by the
E
petitioner, are now statutorily recognised under the Disabilities Act,
2016 - It becomes a statutory obligation on the part of the Central
Government as well as the State Governments to do the needful by
the target dates - Union of India has been filing status reports from
time to time in the form of affidavits by bringing on record the various
measures taken by the Govemment to make the lives of such disabled F
persons as comfortable as possible - Though, Central Government
has taken va/'ious measures, many State Governments have not
respo11ded at all - In view thereof, issuance of important directions
and deadlines set to make public places accessible to visually
disabled- Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection
G
of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 - Constitution of India
- Arts. 32, 19(1)(c).
Rights of visually impaired persons - At international level
and national level - Discussed.
827
H
828
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
Disposing of the petition, the Court
(2017) 12 S.C.R.
HELD: 1.1 The right of the disabled persons not only flows
from various international covenants to which India is a signatory,
it is recognised as Constitutional right as well. There cannot be
any dispute about the rights of the differently-abled persons,
B particularly those who have visual impairment, to provide them
adequate access to all the facilities on the road as well as
convenient access to transport facilities etc. Without these
facilities, movement of such persons gets impaired and this can
even be treated as infringement of their fundamental rights under
19{1){c) of the Constitution, which is guaranteed to each
c Article
and every citizen of this country. In order to ensure that this
right is exercised by visually disabled persons as well, it becomes
the duty of the State and public authorities to lay down proper
norms in respect of the built environment and public facilities
i.e. roads, buildings, public places, transport {air, land and water)
D carriages etc. It is a well known fact that persons with visually
impaired disability represent far more 'vulnerable section of
society' and 'at-risk cases' vis-a-vis their present surroundings
which also becomes evident from the well known fact that
insurance companies charge a higher premium on insurance
policies extended to the visually disabled as compared to the
E other persons. [Para 10) (843-B-E)
1.2 Pursuant to Beijing Declaration, India enacted Persons
with Disabilities {Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and
Full Participation) Act, 1995. This Act, in no uncertain terms,
brings out one of the important features thereof, namely, the
F creation of a barrier free built environment. The very Preamble
to the Disabilities Act discloses that th.is Act was enacted by the
legislature to fulfill its international obligation to enact a disability
specific law nationally. Sections 44, 45 and 46 provided extremely
specific and unambiguous guidelines for making the built
G environment, roads and transport facilities accessible for visually
disabled persons. The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016 has repealed the earlier Disabilities Act, 1995. This
Disabilities Act, 2016 lays down the provision relating to barrier
free environment. Section 40 mandates the Central Government
H
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
829
to frame Rules and laying down the standards of accessibility for
physical environment, transportation system, information &
communication system and other facilities & services to be
provided to the public in urban and rural areas. Rule 15 deals
with accessibility standards for public buildings, passenger bus
transport and information and communication technology. As
regards public buildings, the accessibility standards prescribed
under the Harmonised Guidelines and Space Standards for barrierfree built environment for persons with disabilities and elderly
persons issued by Ministry of Urban Development have been
adopted. This implies that all the public buildings are now required
to conform to these standards. [Para 15, 16] (848-G-H; 849-A-B,
D-E; 850-H; 851-A-B]
A
B
c
1.3 Apart from conferring rights on disabled persons, there
are adequate provisirins which cast an obligation on the State
also to make provisions for safeguarding the interest of the
handicapped persons. 73rd and 74'h Amendment of the D
Constitution of India make it a Constitutional obligation for the
State to make provisions for safeguarding the interest of the
weaker section of the society, including 'handicapped and mentally
retarded'. Article 41 of the Constitution which is in the nature of
a Directive Principle, imposes a duty on the State to make an
effective provision, inter alia, for public assistance to disabled E
persons and it is a well-established principle that the State has an
obligation to apply the Directive Principles of securing a social
order in promotion of the welfare of the people. Further, the
intention of the legislature was clear and unambiguous when it
enacted the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, F
Protection of Rights and Full Participation Act), an important
feature of which was the creation of a barrier-free built
environment. The provisions of Disabilities Act, 1995 and
Disabilities Act, 2016 have already taken note of. These
provisions emphasize the importance of providing nondiscriminatory access by removing all physical barriers. More G
specifically, they seek to provide access to public places in the
following ways:
A) Suitably altering buses, airplanes, train compartments
and vessels to make them accessible to persons with disabilities;
H
830
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
B) Adapting toilets in these aforementioned vehicles and
waiting rooms to make them accessible, especially for wheelchair
users;
C) Installing auditory feedback in traffic signals for the
benefit of the visually impaired;
B
D) Making necessary curb cuts and slopes in pavements
for wheelchair users;
E) Engraving the surface of zebra crossings for the visually
impaired;
F) Engraving the edges of railway platforms for the benefit
c of the visually impaired;
G) Designing appropriate symbols of disability (for
identification of reserved parking spaces, etc);
H) Providing warning signals at necessary places;
I) Building ramps in all public places;
D
J) Providing auditory feedback in lifts; and
K) Providing ramps in all healthcare facilities including,
inter alia, hospitals and rehabilitation centres. [Para 18) [851-GH; 852-A-H; 853-A-BJ
E.
F
1.4 For effective implementation of these provisions, the
following measures need to be undertaken by the State authorities
for removing obstacles that prevent the disabled from accessing
public places:
(i) Making the gates to public places accessible by
incorporating necessary accessible standards. More
specifically, they must be made wide enough to allow
wheelchairs to pass easily and must provide enough space
for the wheelchair to turn around after entering inside.
G
(ii) Stair must be marked with a broad yellow line to allow
the visually impaired to understand the difference in
gradient.
H
(iii) At places like airports, railway stations, etc passengers
must be clearly informed about the details of their flight/
train such as the gate number for boarding, etc via public
announcement systems (this practice is, surprisingly,
gradually declining).
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
831
(iv) A minimum of 3-5 parking spaces near the entrance
must be reserved for persons with disabilities. This must
be clearly indicated by showing the international symbol
for disability i.e. the wheelchair symbol.
A
(v) All unnecessary obstructions must be removed, and all
access ways must be well lit. Moreover, clear signposts,
along with their Braille equivalents should be put up.
B
(vi) Elevators must have clear Braille signs and auditory
feedback. The buttons of elevators must be accessible from
a wheelchair. Pictograms must be put up near elevators
and other important places such as toilets.
c
(vii) Employees working at public places must be provided
necessary training to enable them to understand the unique
set of challenges that persons with disabilities face. They
should be informed about the best practices for dealing with
these challenges.
o
(viii) Wheelchairs and mobility scooters should be available
at every public place. [Para 19) (853-B-G]
1.5 The Disabilities Act, 1995 put a rider by mentioning
that responsibility of the State to provide these facilities is subject
to adequate economic resources to bear the expenditure involved
in making these facilities disabled friendly, Disabilities Act, 2016
thankfully does not mention any such condition. On the contrary,
Section 45 of the Act provides for time limits for making existing
infrastructure and premises accessible and action for that purpose.
Furthermore, Section 44 casts an obligation on all kinds of
establishments i.e. Government as well as private establishments,
to mandatorily observe accessible norms while building any
structure. [Para 20] [853-H; 854-A-BJ
1.6 Having regard to the Constitutional and Statutory
Scheme, there is no denial of the fact that visually impaired persons
need to be provided proper and safe access to roads and transport
as well as to buildings, public places etc. Therefore, it is
emphasised that the prayers made in the instant petition cannot
be viewed as adversarial in nature. It is not regarded so by the
respondents as well, particularly the Union of India. In fact, the
E
F
G
H
832
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
manner in which the instant case has proceeded would reflect
the commitment of the Central Government in taking care about
the aforesaid needs of the visually disabled persons. It is for this
reason the Union of India has been filing status reports from time
to time in the form of affidavits by bringing on record the various
measures which the Government has taken for fulfilling its
B
Constitutional and statutory obligations in this behalf. This petition
was filed in the year 2005 and the various measures t.akcn by the
Government has been monitored in the last 12 years. It is a 'work
in progress' and the Union of India has been taking various
measures to make the lives of such disabled persons as
c comfortable as possible. [Para 21] (854-C-G]
1.7 Ten action points which arc enumerated by the
petitioner, for providing proper access to public facilities to the
persons suffering from visually disability, arc now statutorily
recognised under the Disabilities Act, 2016. The Legislature has
cast
a duty on the executive wing for making provisions in this
D
behalf. This legal position is accepted by the Union of India in its
affidavit dated August 23, 2017. Jn this affidavit, the respondent
had itself mentioned various provisions under the Disabilities
Act, 2016 which mandate the respondents to make provisions
for these facilities. Not only this, such provisions even specified
E the deadlines for undertaking these measures. Thus, it becomes
a statutory obligation on the part of the Central Government as
well as the State Governments to do the needful by the target
dates. Though, Central Government has taken various measures,
. many State Governments have not responded at all. Having
F regard to the said position emerging on record, the following
directions are issued:
(i) Making 20-50 important government buildings in 50
cities fully accessible December 2017 (State Govt.
Buildings)
A
G
H
Since, this deadline is set by the AIC itself, this should be
met. In ilny case, as per the provisions of Section 46 of the
Disabilities Act, 2016, all Government buildings providing
any services to the public arc to be made fully accessible
by June, 2019 which has to be adhere to.
(ii) Making 50% of all the govt. buildings of the national
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
833
capital and all the state capitals fully accessible by December
A
~
Though the deadline for identifying the buildings was fixed
as February 28, 2017, according to status report dated
August 8, 2017, only 7 States have identified the buildings.
Remaining States arc directed to identify the buildings by
February 28, 2018 and it is made clear that no further time
shall be granted. Insofar as deadline for retrofitting is
concerned, the work should be completed by December,
2018.
(iii) Completing accessibility audit of 50% of govt. buildings
and making them fully accessible in 10 most important cities/
towns of states/UTs not covered in targets (i) and (ii) by
December 2019.
Position regarding this action point is the same as noted in
respect of action point 2, namely, only seven States have
submitted their list of 10 most important cities/towns and
not a single building has been identified so far. The States
are directed to identify 10 most important cities/towns and
complete accessibility audit of 50% of Government buildings
in these cities/towns by February 28, 2018. Likewise,
retrofitting of these be completed by December 2019 as
per the revised deadline set out by CCC.
(iv) Central Govt. buildings.
Having regard to the comments given by the petitioner in
its affidavit dated August 23, 2017 on this aspect, time frame
of August, 2018 is given for completing this target.
(v) Accessibilitv in airports. Completing accessibilitv audit
of all the international airports and making them fully
accessible by December 2016.
The demand of the petitioner that Civil Aviation Ministry
should follow the prescribed template i.e. UT Roorkee template
on the Government website appears to be justified which should
be implemented as expeditiously as possible. The Union of India
should thereafter conduct the accessibility and audit and upload
the same on the website by June, 2018.
(vi) Accessibility in Railways. Ministrv of Railways was
required to make all Al, A and B category railway stations
B
C
0
E
F
G
H
834
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
fully accessible by July 2016. 50% of all railway stations to
made fully accessible by March 2018.
As is clear from the affidavit dated June 30, 2017 filed by
the petitioner, as many as 12 directions arc sought under
this action point. Insofar as providing of various facilities
in the railway stations arc concerned, which arc listed by
the petitioner, there cannot be any dispute that the Indian
railways is statutorily obligated to make those provisions.
The petitioner has, however, sought time bound directions
for providing such facilities. Wherever the provisions of
the Disabilities Act, 2016 prescribe the deadlines, the
respondent is to provide those facilities within those time
framework. Insofar as other facilities arc concerned, in
respect of which the petitioner wants those facilities by
specified period, no period is fixed. Instead, the
appropriate/competent authority in the railways is directed
to make an assessment in this behalf so as to ascertain as
to by what date(s) these facilities will be provided. Such a
study can be undertaken and exercise be completed within
a period of three months and report in that behalf shall be
filed in the Court, chalking out the progressive plan.
(vii) 10% of government owned public transport carriers
are to be made fully accessible by March 2018.
Herc again, Section 41 of the Disabilities Act, 2016
provides for comprehensive accessibility in all modes of
transport including but not remitted to the bus transport.
Therefore, it becomes the duty of the Union, States as well
as Union Territories to ensure that all Government buses
arc disabled friendly in accordance with the Harmonized
Guidelines. Likewise, the respondents arc duty bound to
sec that private buses also become disabled friendly. Thus,
we direct the Government to lay down the plan giving the
dates by which the aforesaid task shall be undertaken,
keeping in view the directions which arc sought by the
petitioner in this behalf and the same shall be filed within
three months.
(viii) Comprehensive revision of target deadliness under
accessibility of knowledge and ICT Eeosvstcm. At least 50%
of central and state govt. websites arc to meet accessibility
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
835
standards by March 2017. At least 50% of the oublic A
documents are to meet accessibility standards by March
2018.
On this action point, the petitioner has sought five
directions. Again, there cannot be any dispute that such
provisions have to be made as Disabilities Act, 2016 itself B
mandates that. The only question is about the time schedule.
On certain aspects, AIC had itself mentioned the target
date. In any case, let there be a study undertaken in this
behalf as well by the Union oflndia and report be filed within
three months stating as to by what date(s) compliance shall
be ma~.
C
(ix) Bureau of Indian Standards to embed disability aspect
in all relevant parts of revised National Building Code.
It is expected that the respondents would regularly update
the Harmonized Guidelines keeping in view the provisions
of Disabilities Act, 2016 and technological advancement vis- D
a-vis the needs of persons with disabilities.
(x) The target of training additional 200 sign language
interpreters by March 2018.
Needful be done in this behalf as well within reasonable
time and the Government is directed to file an affidavit within
three months stating the time period within which the same E
can be accomplished.
(xi) As per the provisions of Sections 60 and 66 of the
Disabilities Act, 2016, all States and Union Territories arc
required to constitute the Central and State Advisory
Boards. In order to effectively implement the provisions
F
of the said Act, it becomes the duty of the States and Union
Territories to constitute such Advisory Boards. Therefore,
it is directed that these Advisory Boards be constituted by
all States and Union Territories within a period of three
months from today. The matter be listed for directions after
three months on receiving reports in terms of the said G
order.
[Paras 28 & 29] [908-C-F, G-H; 912-A-E; 911-AH; 910-A-H; 909-A-H]
Francis Coralie Mullin v. Administrator, Union Territory
of Delhi & Ors. (1981) 1 SCC 608 : (1981] 2 SCR
516; State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. Umed Ram
H
836
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
Sharma & Ors. (1986) 2 SCC 68 : (1981) 2 SCR 516;
Jeeja Ghosh & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. (2016) 7
SCC 761 : [2016) 4 SCR 638; Jacob M Puthuparambil
& Ors. v. Kera/a Water Authority & 01:1·. (1991) 1 SCC
28 : (1990) 1 Suppl. SCR 562; Justice Sunanda
Bhandare Foundation v. Union of India & Am: (2014)
B
14 SCC 383 : [2014] 4 SCR 113; Justice Sunanda
Bhandare Foundation v. Union of India & Am: 2017
(5) SCALE 288 - referred to.
Case Law Reference
. [1981) 2 SCR 516
referred to
Para 11
C (1981) 2 SCR 516
referred to
Para 12
(2016) 4 SCR 638
referred to
Para 13
(1990) 1 Suppl. SCR 562
referred to
Para 18
(2014] 4 SCR 113
referred to
Para 26
2017 (5) SCALE 288
referred to
Para 26
D
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil) No.
243 of2005
Under Article 32 of the Constitution oflndia
WITH
W.P. (Civil) No. 228 of2006.
E
Colin, Gonsalves, Sr. Adv., Rajanmani, Ms. Sija N. Pal, Ms. Jyoti
Mendiratta, Anjani Kumar Mishra, Ad vs. for the Petitioner.
Ranjit Kumar SG, Ms.Pinky AnandASG, Ms. Sunita Rani Singh,
D.L. Chidanand, R.R. Rajesh, Gurmeet Singh Makker, A.K. Srivastava,
Ms. Asha Gopalan Nair, Raj Bahadur, Shreekant N. Terdal. Ms. Anil
F Katiyar, D.S. Mahra, Ms. Sushma Suri, Aniruddha P. Mayee, Avnish
M. Oza, Chirag Jain, A. Selvin Raja, Anil Grover, Piyush Hans, Satish
Kapoor, B.S. Gutam, Sapam Biswajit Meitei, Naresh Kr. G.,Ashok Kr.
Singh, Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, Pareena Swarup, Ameet Singh, Ms. Alka ·
Sinha, Anuvrat Sharma, M.R. Shamshad, D.K. Thakur, V.K. Sharma,
Milind Kumar, Jogy Scaria, M. Yogesh Kanna, Ms. Nithya, Ms. Maha
G Lakshmi, Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Ms.Jesal Wahi, Ms. Puja Singh,
Ms. Mamta Singh, Ms. Aruna Mathur, Avneesh Arputham, Anuradha
Arputham,Amit Arora, AlputhamAruna and Co., Ms. Niranjana Singh,
Ms. D. Bharathi Reddy, Rajesh Srivastava, P. V. Yogeswaran, Pragati
Neekhra, EdwardBelho,K. Entaoli Sema,Amit Kumar Singh, K. Luikang
Michael, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Ms. Anu K. Joy, Ms. Kamini Jaiswal,
H
A
RAJNE RATURl v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
837
Ranjan Mukherjee, Anil Shrivastav, Raj Singh Rana, Jatinder Kumar
Bhatia, Ashutosh Kumar Sharma, S. Udaya Kumar Sagar, Mrityunjai
Singh, Kuldip Singh, Rajan Chatterjee, Adee! Ahmed, Piyush Sachdev,
Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, Ms.Diksha Rai, Gopal Singh, Rituraj Biswas,
Aditya Raina, M.T. George, Ms. B. Sunita Rao, V.K. Verma,
V.N. Raghupathy, Parikshit P. Angadi, Prakash Jodhar, Mis Corporate
Law Group, Ms. Ranjeeta Rohtagi, S. Doura, Guntur Prabhaka1,
Ms. Prerna Singh, Sanjay Kuarnr Visen, V.G Pragasam, S. Prabu
Ramasubramanian, T. Mahipal, Mishra Saurabh, Jayesh Gaurav, Gopal
Prasad, Ratan Kumar Choudhuri, Ms. Susmita Lal, Sudarshan Singh
Rawat, C.K. Sasi, Kunal A. Cheema, Yogesh K. Ahirrao, Nishant
Ramakantrao Katncshwarkar, B.S. Banthia, Ms. Charu Mathur,
T.N. Rama Rao, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, T. Veera Reddy, G.N. Reddy,
K.V. Jagdishvaran, Ms. G. Indira, M. Shoeb Alam, Ms. Fauzia Shakil
Ujjwal Singh, Moj ahid Karim Khan, Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, Advs.
for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
A~ K. SIKRI, J. I. The petitioner herein, who is a visually
disabled person, is resident ofGurgaon (now 'Gurugram') and works in
Delhi with a human rights organisation. He has filed this petition in public
interest on behalf of the disabled persons (though better expression to
describe these persons is 'differently-abled persons') for proper and
adequate access to public places. In particular, this petition seeks providing
all accessibility requirements to meet the needs of visually disabled persons
in respect of safe access to roads and transport facilities. It is stated in
the petition that there are sixty to seventy million disabled persons in
India and almost 50% thereof suffer from visual disability. The
fundamental concern of these visually impaired persons is safe
accessibility to movements on footpaths and accessibility to roads and
transport. It is stated in the petition· that internationally acceptable
mandatory components of physical accessibility arc the following: ·
a) Safety: the environment must be such where disabled people
can move around safely.
b) Independence: the environment must be such where disabled
persons can use the facilities independently.
c) Affordability: the barrier free or accessible environment should
not come with a premium.
A
d) Logical layout: the environment must be such where disabled
persons arc able to navigate without too much physical exertion
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
838
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
i.e. not having to move to the length and breadth of the building
to access information or make use of the facilities'.
2. As per the petitioner, physical accessibility when translated visa-vis road and transportation facilities for the benefit of visually disabled
persons would imply the following features:
MEASURES IN RESPECT OF ROADS:
a) Installation of auditory signals at every red light so as to aid
visually disabled persons to cross the roads safely. This signal
emits a series of sounds, which would indicate the oppo11une
time to cross the road.
b) Construct zebra crossings at a slight incline so as to aid in
guidance to visually disabled persons and to enable them to
navigate along this raised safe passage of zebra crossings.
This slightly raised level wo9uld indicate the course of the
zebra crossing to visually disabled persons, who would be
able to sense the slight level difference with the aid of their
walking stick.
c) Insert guiding blocks in zebra crossings so as to aid in guidance
to visually disabled persons and to enable them to navigate
along with safe passage of zebra crossings.
d) Placing warning blocks along the edges of the pavement or
footpath so as to denote a level difference between the road
and the pathway and tO ensure the continuity of the pathway.
Warning blocks refers to a standard cement block, such as is
used on pavements and footpaths, consisting of a series of
small blisters on them so as to warn visually disabled persons
wherever there is a gap in the pavement, a level difference
or to indicate the point where the pavement or footpath ends
and a road or a zebra crossing starts.
e) Providing for unobstructed footpaths with minimum
hindrances in such manner so as to leave obstacle-free walking
areas in a straight line on the footpath at either left or right
edges of the footpath.
f) Placing guiding blocks on pavements and footpaths so as to
1
Based on a paper by Sunita Singh titled 'Accessibility Issues' in book called 'Disability
Management in India - Challenges and Commitment•, edited by C.S. Mohapatra and
H
published by the National Institute for the Mentally Handicapped, Ministry of Social
Justice and Empowerment, in collaboration with the Indian Institute of Public
Administration (IIPA).
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
839
aid visually disabled persons in directional guidance. Guiding A
blocks are constructed on the same lines as warning blocks,
the only difference being that while warning blocks consist
of blisters made on a block, guiding blocks comprise oflincs
engraved on a block. These engraved lines on the cement
block, which the visually disabled persons can sense with the
B
aid of their walking stick, serve as an orientation tool to guide
visually disabled persons along a certain direction.
g) Colouring the nosing of stairs in subways/overhead bridges/
escalators. Colouring· the edges of the stairs would be of
immense guidance to persons with low vision so as to enable
such persons to negotiate each step with ease and orientation. c
h) Providing for specially designated parking areas, which do
not obstruct pathways. This feature would ensure that visually
disabled persons could negotiate pathways without the
apprehension of colliding with parked vehicles.
i.) Construction of a protective fencing around obstacles on D
footpaths an pavements so as to serve as a warning of the
obstacle ahead.
j) Providing for signboards/advertisement boards and hoardings
to be placed above head levels. This feature would ensure
that there is no probability of visually disabled persons suffering
head injuries owing to collision with signboards/advertisement E
boards.
k) Erecting a temporary barricade around places where
construction work is in progress so as to serve as a timely
warning to visually disabled persons.
1) Constructing highlands in the middle of main roads, so as to F
make crossing roads safer for the visually disabled. A highland
would divide the main road in to two separate traffic zones of
traffic moving in opposite directions, wherein a visually
disabled person, through the aid of his ears, can concentrate
on the traffic sounds coming from one particular direction
G
whilst crossing over.
MEASURES FOR TRANSPORT FACILITIES:
m) Providing an efficient audio announcement system in all
modes of mass public transport, using Delhi Metro, which
has incorporated this feature with great success, as a model.
H
840
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 12 S.C.R.
n) Providing for bus stops to have route maps and schedules in
Braille, which is placed at eye-level.
o) Providing for a standardized texture of flooring in front of bus
stops.
p) Providing for easily accessible entry and exit points at bus
stops, railway stations and airports.
q) Providing for an exclusive and designated ticketing area and
assistance/information counter for visually disabled persons
at the point which is nearest possible to the entry point and at
every platform.
r) Providing for a designated place for disabled friendly coaches
by placing guiding blocks for disabled-friendly coaches at
railway stations, till the time the entire transport system
becomes disabled friendly entirely.
s) Constructing warning blocks along with edges of platforms at
all railway stations.
t) Modifying the foot board of public transport vehicles so as to
make it more accessible for the visually disabled with
sufficient and uniform width of steps and between steps.
3. As per the petitioner, though there are few instances where
some of these measures arc being implemented, but the authorities have
moved with a slow pace and in sporadic manner. To illustrate the same,
the petitioner has tabulated these measures in Anneuxre P-4 to the writ
petition to show that in most of the cases no action is taken by various
States and Union Territories.
RIGHT OF VISUALLY DISABLED PERSONS TO GET
THESE FACILITIES
(i) At International Level
4. In international human rights law, equality is founded upon two
complementary principles: non-discrimination and reasonable
differentiation. The principle of non-discrimination seeks to ensure that
all persons can equally enjoy and exercise all their rights and freedoms.
Discrimination occurs due to arbitrary denial of opportunities for equal
participation. For example, when public facilities and services are set on
standards out of the reach ofpersons with disabilities, it leads to exclusion
and denial of rights. Equality not only implies preventing discrimination
(example, the protection of individuals against unfavourable treatment
by introducing anti-discrimination laws), but goes beyond in remedying
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
841
discrimination against groups suffering systematic discrimination in A
. society. In concrete terms, it means embracing the notion of positive
rights, affirmative action and reasonable accommodation. The move from
the patronising and paternalistic approach to persons with disabilities
represented by the medical model to viewing them as members of the
community with equal rights has also been reflected in the evolution of B
international standards relating specifically to disabilities, as well as in
moves to place the rights of persons with disabilities within the category
of universal humanrights. 2 ".
•
5. Earlier the traditional approaches to disability have depicted it
as health and welfare issue, to be addressed through care provided to
persons with disabilities, from a charitable point of view. The disabled
persons are viewed as abnormal, deserving of pity and care, and not as
individuals who are entitled to enjoy the same opportunities to live a full
and satisfying life as other members of society. This had resulted in
marginalizing the disabled persons and their exclusion both from the
mainstream of the society and enjoyment of their fundamental rights D
and freedoms. Disability tends to be couched within a medical and welfare
framework, identifying people with disabilities as ill, different from their
non-disabled peers, and in need of care. Because the emphasis is on the
medical needs of people with disabilities, there is a corresponding neglect
of their wider social needs, which has resulted in severe isolation for
people with disabilities and their families). However, Real awareness of E
the problems of disabled and their human rights perspective came to
fore, in international thinking, in the 1970s when United Nations took
number of initiatives, which embrace the growing international concept
of the human rights of persons with disabilities and equalization of
opportunities to them.
F
6. Two major declarations on the disabled were adopted by the
General Assembly in that decade. First is the declaration on the rights of
mentally retarded persons dated December 20, 1971 which provided that
the mentally retarded person should enjoy the same rights as other human
beings, including the right to proper medical care, economic security, the
right to training and rehabilitation, and the right to live with his own family G
or with foster parents. Furthermore, the Assembly declared that there
should be proper legal safeguards to protect the mentally retarded person
against every form of abuse if it should become necessary to restrict or
c
'See Report of United Nations Consultative Expert Group Meeting on International
Norms and Standard~ Relating to Disability I 0-2-200 I
H
842 ,
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
deny his or her rights. In 197 5, the General Assembly of the UN adopted
the Declaration on the Rights of Disabled Persons, which proclaimed
that "disabled persons have the same civil and political rights as other
human beings." The Declaration states, "Disabled persons should receive
equal treatment and services, which will enable them to develop their
capabilities and skills to the maximum and will hasten the process of
their social integration or reintegration." This Declaration is a
comprehensive instrument with a clear focus on the rights of persons
with disabilities. Thereafter, the year 1981 was observed as International
Year of the Disabled Persons with its central theme as "Full Participation
and Equality".
7. In the very next year the UN General Assembly adopted the
World Programme ofAction which placed "Equaliz.ation of Opportunities"
as a central theme. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural
Rights under International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural
Rights (ICESCR) in 1994 assumed the responsibility for disability rights
by issuing a General Comment No.5, in which the Committee makes an
analysis of disability as a human rights issue. Article 6 of the Covenant
emphasizes "Right to Work"; Article 7 refers to "the Right of everyone
to the enjoyment ofjust and favourable conditions of work which ensures
adequate remuneration"; Article 11 recognizes that everyone has the
"Right to an adequate standard ofliving for himself and his family, including
adequate food, clothing and housing"; Article 15 recognizes the "Right
of everyone to take part in cultural life".
8. Even at Asian level, significant development took place when
the Government ofAsian and Pacific countries (ESCAP Region) in their
meeting held in Beijing on 1" to 5'h December, 1992 called "Meet to
Launch the Asian and Pacific Decades of Disabled Persons" adopted
to the proclamation on "Full Participation and Equality of People with
Disabilities in the Asia and the Pacific regions, with this ending view, it
year marked 1993-2002 as the decade of disabled persons. This paved
the way for enactment of the "The Persons with Disabilities (Equal
Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, which
was enacted in the year 1996.
9. The underlined message in the aforesaid documents is the
acknowledgment that human rights are individual and have a definite
linkage to human development, both sharing common vision and with a
common purpose. Respect for human rights is the root for human
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
843
development and realization offull potential of each individual, which in
tum leads to the augmentation of human resources with progress of the
nation. Empowerment of the people through human development is the
aim of human rights.
A
(ii) Rights under the Indian Constitution
l 0. This right not only flows from various international covenants
referred to above to which India is a signatory, it is recognised as
Constitutional right as well. There cannot be any dispute about the rights
of the differently- abled persons, particularly those who have visual
impairment with which category we are concerned in the present case,
to provide them adequate access to all the facilities on the road as well
as convenient access to transport facilities etc. Without these faciiities,
movement of such persons gets impaired and this can even be treated
as infringement of their fundamental rights under Article 19( l )( c) of the
Constitution, which is guaranteed to each and every citizen of this country.
In order to ensure that this right is exercised by visually disabled persons
as well, it becomes the duty of the State and public authorities to lay
down proper nom1S in respect of the built environment and public facilities
i.e. roads, buildings, public places, transport (air, land and water) carriages
etc. It is a well known fact that persons with visually impaired disability,
with which we are concerned, represent far more 'vulnerable section of
society" and 'at-risk cases' vis-a-vis their present surroundings which
also becomes evident from the well known fact that insurance companies
charge a higher premium on insurance policies extended to the visually
disabled as compared to the other persons.
11. Article 21 of the Constitution gives right to life, mandates that
every citizen has right to live with dignity. It is an umbrella right which
subsumes several other rights that enable life to be led meaningfully. In
Francis Coralie Mullin v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi
& Ors. 3, this Court has held that:
"The fundamental right to life which is the most precious human
right and which fo1ms the ark of all other rights must, therefore,
be interpreted in a broad and expansive spirit so as to invest it
with significance and vitality which may endure for years to come
and enhance the dignity of the individual and the worth of human
person."
'(1981) 1sec608
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
844
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
Right to dignity has been particularly recognized in this judgment
as one of the facets ofright to life:
"every act which offends against or impairs human indignity would
constitute deprivation pro tanto of this right to live."
B
c
D
E
.This expansive understanding of right to life assumes greater
proportions in respect of persons with visual impairments, who need a
higher number of compensative skill enhancing facilities in order to go
about their daily lives without suffering the indignity of being generally
perceived as being dependent and helpless.
12. The vitality of the issue of 'Accessibility' vis-a-vis visually
disabled persons' right to life can be gauged clearly by this Court's
judgment in State ofHimuchul Pradesh & Anr. v. Umed Rum Sharma
& Ors. 4, where the right to life under Article 21 has been held broad
enough to incorporate the right to accessibility. Relevrmt paragraphs of
this judgment have been reproduced below:
"Read in the background ofA1ticle 38(2) every person has right
under Article 19( l )(d) to move freely throughout the territory of
India. He has also the right under Article 21 to his life which
embraces not only physical existence oflife but the quality oflife
and for residents of hilly areas, access to road is access to life
itself. Therefore, to the residents of the hilly areas as far as feasible
and possible society has constitutional obligation to provide roads
for communication in reasonable conditions. Denial of that right
would be denial of the life as understood in its richness and fullness
by the ambit of the Constitution.
F
It appears to us that in the facts of this case, the controversy lies
within a short compass. It is well settled that the persons who
G
have applied to the High Court by the letter are persons affected
by the absence of usable road because they arc poor Harijan
residents of the area .• their access by communication, indeed to
life outside is obstructed and/or prevented by the absence of road.
The entire State of Himachal Pradesh is in hills and without
workable roads, no communication is possible. Every person is
entitled to life as enjoined in Article 21 of the Constitution and in
the facts of this case read in conjunction with Article 19( I)( d) of
the Constitution and in the background of Article 38(2) of the
H
'(1986) 2 sec 68
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.)
Constitution every person has right under Article 19( l )(d) to move
freely throughout the territory of India and he has also the right
under Article 21 to his life and that right under Article 21 embrnces
not only physical existence of life but the quality of life and for
residents of hilly areas, access to road is access to life itself.
These propositions are well settled. We accept the proposition
that there should be road for communication in reasonable
conditions in view of our constitutional imperatives and denial of
that right would be denial of the life as understood in its richness
and fullness by the ambit of the Constitution. To the residents of
the hilly areas as far as feasible and possible society has
constitutional obligation to provide roads for communication."
J3. Right to dignity, which is ensured in our Constitutional set up
for every citizen applies with much more vigour in case of persons
suffering from disability and, therefore, it becomes imperative to provide
such facilities so that these persons also are ensured level playing field
and not only they are able to enjoy life meaningfully, they contribute to
the progress of the nation as well. In a recent judgment in Jeeja Ghosh
& Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. 5 , these aspects were highlighted by
this Court in the following form:
37. The rights that arc guaranteed to differently-abled persons
under the 1995 Act, are founded on the sound principle of human
dignity which is the core value of human right and is treated as a
significant facet ofright to life and liberty. Such a right, now treated
as human right of the persons who are disabled, has it roots in
Article 21 of the Constitution. Jurisprudentially, three types of
models for determining the content of the constitutional value of
human dignity arc recognised. These arc: (i) Theological Models,
(ii) Philosophical Models, and (iii) Constitutional Models. Legal
scholars were called upon to determine the theological basis of
human dignity as a constitutional value and as a constitutional
right. Philosophers also came out with their views justifying human
dignity as core human value. Legal understanding is influenced
by theological and philosophical views, though these two are not
identical. Aquinas and Kant discussed the jurisprudential aspects
ofhuman dignity based on the aforesaid philosophies. Over a period
of time, human dignity has found its way through constitutionalism,
'c2016J 1sec161
845
A
B
C
D
E
F
a
H
846
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
whether written or unwritten. Even right to equality is interpreted
based on the value of human dignity. Insofar as India is concerned,
we arc not even required to take shelter under theological or
philosophical theories. We have a written Constitution which
guarantees human rights that are contained in Part III with the
caption "Fundamental Rights". One such right enshrined in Article
21 is right to life and liberty. Right to life is given a purposeful
meariing by this Court to include right to live with dignity. It is the
purposive interpretation which has been adopted by this Court to
give a content of the right to human dignity as the fulfilment of the
constitutional value enshrined in Article 21. Thus, human dignity
is a constitutional value and a constitutional goal. What are the
dimensions of constitutional value ofhuman dignity'? It is beautifUJly
illustrated by Aharon Barak [Aharon Barak, Human Dignity -
The Constitutional Value and the Constitutional
Right (Cambridge University Press, 2015)] (former ChiefJustice
D
E
F
of the Supreme Court ofisrael) in the following manner:
"The constitutional value of human dignity has a central
· normative role. Human dignity as a constitutional value is the
factor that unites the human rights into one whole. It ensures
the normative unity of human rights. This normative unity is
expressed in the three ways: first, the value of human dignity
serves as a normative basis for constitutional rights set out in
the Constitution; second, it serves as an interpretative pririciple
for determining the scope of constitutional rights, including the
right to human dignity; third, the value ofhuman dignity has an
important role in determining the proportionality of a statute
limiting a constitutional right."
xxx
G
H
xxx
xxx
40. In international human rights law, equality is founded upon
two complementary principles: non-discrimination and reasonable
differentiation. The principle of non-discrimination seeks to ensure
that all persons can equally enjoy and exercise all their rights and
freedoms. Discrimination occurs due to arbitrary denial of
opportunities for equal participation. For example, when public
facilities and services are set on standards out of the reach of
persons with disabilities, it leads to exclusion and denial ofrights.
Equality not only implies preventing discrimination (example, the
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
protection of individuals against unfavourable treatment by
introducing anti-discrimination laws), but goes beyond in remedying
discrimination against groups suffering systematic discrimination
in society. In concrete terms, it means embracjng the notion of
positive rights, aftirmative action and reasonable accommodation.
The move from the patronising and paternalistic approach to
persons with disabilities represented by the medical model to
viewing them as members of the community with equal rights has
also been reflected in the evolution of international standards
relating specifically to disabilities, as well as in moves to place the
rights of persons with disabilities within the category of universal
human rights. (Sec Report of United Nations Consultative
847
A
B
c
Expert Group Meeting on International Norms and Standards
Relating to Disability, 10-2-2001.)
xxx
xxx
xxx
43. All these rights conferred upon such persons send an eloquent
message that there is no question of sympathising with such
persons and extending them medical or other help. What is to be
borne in mind is that they are also human beings and they have to
grow as normal persons and arc to be extended all facilities in this
behalf. The subject of the rights of persons with disabilities should
be approached from human rights perspective. which recognised
that persons with disabilities were entitled to enjoy the full range
of internationally guaranteed rights and freedoms without
discrimination on the ground of disability. This creates an obligation
on the part of the State to take positive measures to ensure that in
reality persons with disabilities get enabled to exercise those rights.
There should be insistence on the full measure of general human
rights guarantees in the case of persons with disabilities, as well
as developing specific instruments that refine and give detailed
contextual content of those general guarantees. There should be
a full recognition of the fact that persons with disability were integral
pa11 of the community, equal in dignity and entitled to enjoy the
same human rights and freedoms as others. It is a sad commentary
that this perception has not sunk in the mind and souls of those
who are not concerned with the enforcement of these rights. The
persons suffering from mental or physical disability experience
and encounter nonpareil form of discrimination. They are not looked
D
E
F
G
H
848
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
down by people. However, they are not accepted in the mainstream
either even when people sympathise with them. Most common,
their lives are handicapped by social, cultural and attitudinal barriers
which hamper their full participation and enjoyment of equal rights
and opportunities. This is the worst form of discrimination which .
the disabled feel as their grievance is that others do not understand
them.
A
B
xxx
xxx
xxx
46. It is the common experience of several persons with disabilities
that they are unable to lead a full life due to societal barriers and
discrimination faced by them in employment, access to public
spaces, transportation, etc. Persons with disability are the most
neglected lot not only in the society but also in the family. More
often they are an object of pity. There are hardly any meaningful
attempts to assimilate them in the mainstream of the nation's life.
The apathy towards their problems is so pervasive that even the
number of disabled persons existing in the country is not well
documented."
c
D
(iii) Rights conferred under the Statute
E
F
14. Right of these persons not only flows from the Constitution
but are statutorily recognised as well. As mentioned above, pursuant to
Beijing Declaration, India enacted Disability Act, 1995 (hereinafter
referred to as the' Act') 6• This Act, in no uncertain terms, brings out one
of the impo11ant features thereof, namely, the creation of a barrier free
built environment. The very Preamble to the Disabilities Act discloses
that this act was enacted by the legislature to fulfill its international
obligation to enact a disability specific law nationally. The first in the
statement of objects and reasons are:
i. To spell out the responsibility of the State towards the prevention
of disabilities: and
ii. To create a barrier free environment for Persons with
Disabilities.
G
15. Under its chapter VIII, titled "Non-Discrimination", the
Disabilities Act, 1995 aimed to provide persons with disabilities with a
non-handicapping environment to ensure them equal opportunities and
full participation in all aspects oflife, including social, economic, political
This Act now stands repealed and is replaced by Act, 2016 which is enforced w.e.f.
April 19, 2017.
6
H
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
(A. K. SIKRI, J.]
849
and cultural, at par with other citizens. Sections 44, 45 and 46 under this
chapter provided extremely specific and unambiguous guidelines for
making the built environment, roads and transport facilities accessible
for visually disabled persons.
A
Under Section 44 establishments in the transport sector are required
to design rail compartments, buses, etc. in such a way as to promote
easy access to disabled persons.
Section 45 provides for installation of signals at traffic lights on
public roads, kerb cuts. and slopes to be made in pavements, engravings
on edges of railways platforms, designing appropriate symbols of disability
and warning signals at appropriate places.
B
C
Section 46 directs the appropriate governments and local .
authorities, within the limits of their economic capacity and development,
to provide for ramps, Braille symbols and auditory signals in elevators in
hospitals, primary health centres and other medical care and rehabilitation
institutes.
D
16. The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter
reforred to as the 'Disabilities Act, 2016') has come into force on April
19, 2017 and this Act has repealed the earlier Disabilities Act, 1995. This
Disabilities Act, 2016 lays down the provision relating to barrier free
environment. Those relevant provisions, are as under:
·
E
Section 2(i) - 'establishment includes a Government establishment and
private establishment"
Section 2(k) - 'Government establishment' means a corporation
established by or under a Central Act or State Act or an authority or a
body owned or controlled or aided by the Government ora local authority
or a Government company as defined in section 2 of the. Companies
Act, 2013 (18 of2013) and includes a Department of the Government.
Section 2(v)- "private establishment" means a company, firm, cooperative
or other society, associations, trust, agency, institution, organisation, union,
factory or such other establishment as the appropriate Government may,
by notification, specify; (w) "public building" means a Government or
private building, used or accessed by the public at large, including a
building used for educational or vocational purposes, workplace,
commercial activities, public utilities, religious, cultural, leisure or
recreational activities, medical or health services, law enforcement
F
G
H
850
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 12 S.C.R.
agencies, reformatories or judicial foras, railway stations or platforms,
roadways bus stands or terminus, airports or waterways;
Section 2(w)- "public building" means a Government or private building,
used or accessed by the public at large, including a building used for
educational or vocational purposes, workplace, commercial activities,
public utilities, religious, cultural, leisure or recreational activities, medical
or health services, law enforcement agencies, reformatories or judicial
foras, railway stations or platforms, roadways bus stands or terminus,
airports or waterways;
Section 2(zd) - "transportation systems" includes road transport, rail
transport, air transport, water transport, para transit systems for the last
mile connectivity, road and street infrastructure, etc;
Section 2(ze) - "universal design" means the design of products,
environments, programmes and services to be usable by all people to the
greatest extent possible, without the need for adaptation or specialised
design and shall apply to assistive devices including advanced technologies
for particular group of persons with disabilities.
Section 2(b)- "appropriate Government" means,(i) in relation to the Central Government or any establishment
wholly or substantially financed by that Government, or a Cantonment
Board constituted under the Cantonments Act, 2006 (41 of 2006), the
Central Government;
(ii) in relation to a State Government or any establishment, wholly
or substantially financed by that Government, or any local authority, other
than a Cantonment Board, the State Government.
Section 16 mandates the appropriate Government and the local authorities
to endeavour that all educational institutions funded or recognised by
them provide inclusive education to the children with disabilities and
towards that end shall make buildings, campus and various facilities
accessible.
Section 25(l)(b) mandates the appropriate Government and local
authority to take necessary measures for the persons with disabilities to
provide barrier-free access in all parts of Government and private
hospitals and other health care institutions and centres.
Section 40 mandates the Central Government to frame Rules and laying
down the standards of accessibility for physical environment,
transportation system, information & communication system and other
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
851
facilities & services to be provided to the public in urban and rural areas.
Rule 15 deals with accessibility standards for public buildings, passenger
bus transport and information and communication technology. As regards
public buildings, the accessibility standards prescribed under the
Harmonised Guidelines and Space Standards for barrier-free built
environment for persons with disabilities and elderly persons issued by
Ministry of Urban Development have been adopted. This implies that all
the public buildings are now required to conform to these standards.
,17. It is pertinent to mention at this point that the Ministry Urban
Development and Poverty Alleviation had in the year 1993, at the outset
of the Asia-Pacific Disability Decade, received monetary grants from
UN-ESCAP as part of project for 'the Promotion of Non-Handicapping
Environments for Disabled and Elderly Persons in the Asia-Pacific
Region". The project had developed a set of guidelines on the promotion
of non-handicapping physical environments for disabled persons and
therefore provided funds to implement these guidelines within a period
of three years, beginning May 1995.
A
As a follow up action to the enactment of the Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full
Participation Act) 1995, the Ministry of Urban Development in
collaboration with UN-ESCAP, undertook demonstrative .exercises in
Delhi to create a barrier-free built environment in a 2 square kilometer
area of Indraprastha Estate.
This was followed by the formulation of guidelines for creation of
a barrier-free environment by the Centre Public Works Department
(CPWD) under the Ministry of Urban Development and Employment,
developed "Guidelines on Space Standards for Barriers Free Built
Environment "which also included model building bye-laws for inter alia,
road construction, to facilitate their adoption by local bodies in the states.
A reference was made to all state governments to make suitable
amendments in their building bye-laws to respond to this Act. Thus, there
is no paucity for provisions in the Jaw to safeguard the rights of the
visuaJly disabled
B
C
D
E
F
G
DUTY OF THE STATE
18. Apart from conferring rights on disabled persons, there are
adequate provisions which cast an obligation on the State also to make
provisions for safeguarding the interest of the handicapped persons. 73'd
and 74'" Amendment of the Constitution of India make it a Constitutional
H
852
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
obligation for the State to make provisions for safeguarding the interest
of the weaker section of the society, including 'handicapped and mentally
retarded'. Article 41 of the Constitution which is in the nature of a
Directive Principle, imposes a duty on the State to make an effective
provision, inter alia. for public assistance to disabled persons and it is a
well-established principle that the State has an obligation to apply the
Directive Principles of securing a social order in promotion of the welfare
of the people. The importance of Atiicle 41 in the Constitutional scheme
can be measured by this Court's judgment in Jacob M. Puthuparambil
& Ors. v. Kera/a Water Authority & Ors. 7 wherein it was held that a
Court should interpret an Act so as to advance Article 41. Further, the
intention of the legislature was clear and unambiguous when it enacted
the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights
and Full ParticipationAct), an important feature of which wa~ the creation
of a barrier-free built environment. Chapter 8 of the Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full
Participation) Act, 1995 deals squarely with the issue ofnon-discrimination
in transport and the built environment: The provisions of Disabilities Act,
1995 and Disabilities Act, 2016 have already taken note of. These
provisions emphasize the importance of providing non-discriminatory
access by removing all physical barriers. More specifically, they seek to
provide access to public places in the following ways:
A) Suitably altering buses, airplanes, train compartments and
vessels to make them accessible to persons with disabilities;
B) Adapting toilets in these aforementioned vehicles and waiting
rooms to make them accessible, especially for wheelchair
users;
F
C) Installing auditory feedback in traffic signals for the benefit
of the visually impaired;
D) Making necessary curb cuts and slopes in pavements for
wheelchair users;
G
E) Engraving the surface of zebra crossings for the visually
impaired;
F) Engraving the edges of railway platforms for the benefit Of
the visually impaired;
G) Designing appropriate symbols of disability (for identification
or reserved parking spaces, etc);
H
'(1991) 1sec28
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
H) Providing warning signals at necessary places;
853
A
I) Building ramps in all public places;
J) Providing auditory feedback in lifts; and
K) Providing ramps in all healthcare facilities including, inter alia,
hospitals and rehabilitation centres.
19. For effective implementation of these provisions, the following
measures need to be undertaken by the State authorities for removing
obstacles that prevent the disabled from accessing public places:
i. Making the gates to public places accessible by incorporating
necessary accessible standards. More specifically, they must be made
wide enough to allow wheelchairs to pass easily and must provide enough
space for the wheelchair to turn around after entering inside.
B
c
ii. Stair must be marked with a broad yellow line to allow the
visually impaired to understand the difference in gradient.
iii. At places like airports, railway stations, etc passengers must
be clearly informed about the details of their flight/train such as the gate
number for boarding, etc via public announcement systems (this practice
is, surprisingly, gradually declining).
iv. A minimum of 3-5 parking spaces near the entrance must be
reserved for persons with disabilities. This must be clearly indicated by
showing the international symbol for disability i.e. the wheelchair symbol.
D
E
v. All unnecessary obstructions must be removed, and all access
ways must be well lit. Moreover, clear signposts, along with their Braille
equivalents should be put up.
vi. Elevators must have clear Braille signs and auditory feedback.
The buttons of elevators must be accessible from a wheelchair.
Pictograms must be put up near elevators and other important places
such as toilets.
vii. Employees working at public places must be provided
necessary training to enable them to understand the unique set of
challenges that persons with disabilities face. They should be informed
about the best practices for dealing with these challenges.
F
G
viii. Wheelchairs and mobility scooters should be available at every
public place.
20. One aspect that needs to be highlighted is that whereas
Disabilities Act, 1995 put a rider by mentioning that responsibility of the
H
854
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
State to provide these facilities is subject to adequate economic resources
to bear the expenditure involved in making these facilities disabled friendly,
Disabilities Act, 2016 thankfully does not mention any such condition.
On the contrary, Section 45 of the Act provides for time limits for making
existing infrastructure and premises accessible and action for that
purpose. Furthermore, Section 44 casts an obligation on all kinds of
establishments i.e. Government as well as private establishments, to
mandatorily observe accessible norms while building any structure.
THE PRESENT CASE
21. Having regard to the aforesaid Constitutional and Statutory
Scheme, there is no denial of the fact that visually impaired persons
c need to be provided proper and safe access to roads and transport as
well as to buildings, public places etc. We may, therefore, emphasise
that the prayers made in the present petition cannot be viewed as
adversarial in nature. We find comfort in the fact that it is not regarded
so by the respondents as well, particularly the Union of India. In fact,
D the manner in which the present case has proceeded would reflect the
commitment of the Central Government in taking care about the aforesaid
needs of the visually disabled persons. It is for this reason the Onion of
India has been filing status reports from time to time in the form of
affidavits by bringing on record the various measures which the
Government has taken for fulfilling its Constitutional and statutory
E
obligations in this behalf. This petition was filed in the year 2005 and the
various measures taken by the Government has been monitored in the
last 12 years. It may not be necessary to refer to various status reports
filed by the Government depicting the steps which arc taken by it, as
that would unnecessarily burden the present judgment. As was rightly
F stated by Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned Solicitor General who appeared on
behalf of Union oflndia, that it is a 'work in progress' and the Union of
India has been taking various measures to make the lives of such disabled
persons as comfortable as possible. Thus, instead ofreproducing those
steps which are taken by the Government from time to time, we would
like to confine the discussion by referring to affidavit dated June 30,
G
2017 filed by the petitioner in response to the status report filed by the
Union oflndia on April 12, 2017. In this at1idavit, the petitioner has
tabulated his remarks and comments to the said status report and the
direction which it seeks from this Court. Therefore, this affidavit depicts
what remains to be done at the end of the respondents. It may be pointed
H out that affidavit which was filed by the Union oflndia on April 12, 2017
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
855
was in response to the ten action points which were submitted by the
petitioner. In the said affidavit, the Union of India gave its updated status
on those points in the following manner:
A
Sr.
No.
Targets
1
Making 20-50
important
government
buildings in 50
cities
fully
accessible
by
December
2017.
(State
Govt.
Buildings)
2
set
under AIC
Petitioner's
Remarks'
,\ction taken
Accessibility
audits of only
1165 buildings as
against
1633
buildings on the
of
website
DEPwD.
Of
1293 buildings, a
proposal for only
366
buildings
received.
Sanction
of
Rs.1402.81 lakh
has been issued
only
67
buildings.
- Access audit of
1653
buildings
has
been
completed
and
1653 reports are
shared with the
States.
Making 50% of Standards
and
all the govt. guidelines
for
buildings of the accessibility need
national capital to be drawn out
and all the state prior to creating
capitals
fully accessibility m
accessible
by buildings.
December
2018.
B
As
on
30.03.2017, the
cost estimates for
of
retrofitting
647
buildings
have
been
received
under
Scheme
for
Implementation
PwD
Act
(SIPDA).
Sanction
of
Rs.71.60
crore
has been issued
for 354 buildings.
Harmonized
Guidelines and
Space Standards
for the barrierfree environment
for PwDs were
issued by CPWD
on 23/3/2016.
c
D
E
F
G
H
856
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
- Model Building Byelaws (MBBLs) were
issued by Ministry of
Urban Development on
18/3/2016 which has a
separate
chapter
on
Accessibility for PwDs.
These are to be appointed
by the States and local
authorities. So far 33
states/UTs have adopted
the
accessibility
standards envisages m
theMBBLs.
- National Building Code
2016 has been notified
and published on March
15, 2017, by Bureau of
Indian Standards. It is for
the States and Urban
Bodies to adopt these
standards. Once adopted,
these standards would
become enforceable.
- In respect of this target,
States have to make their
buildings accessible from
their own budget, as per
the decision of Central
Coordination committee
(CCC). In this respect list
of buildings identified in
State capitals has been
received
from
Meghalaya, Karnataka,
Sikkim, Uttar Pradesh,
Assam, Tamil Nadu and
Bihar only.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
3
4
Completing
accessibility
audit of 50% of
govt.
buildings
and making them
fully accessible
in
10
most
important
cities/towns
of
states/UTs
not
covered in targets
(i) and (ii) by
·December 201"9.
States and UTs
need
to
be
communicated
standards
and
guidelines
for
creating
accessibility.
Central
buildings
No status of the
report submitted
by
MoUD
ts
given on their
website.
Govt.
- In response to the
letters
sent
to
States to provide a
list of 10 important
cities, lists of cities
have been received
from
Bihar,
Meghalaya,
Karnataka, Sikkim,
Uttar
Pradesh,
Assam and Tamil
Nadu
only.
However, list of
Buildings in these
cities
have
not
been identified by
the
respective
States.
- CPWD informed
that out of 50 cities
of phase I, 11 cities
do
not
have
General
Pool
Office
Accommodation·
(GPOA) Buildings
under maintenance
of CPWD. These
cities are Daman;
Imphal,
Aizawl,
Gangtok, Agartala,
Silvasa, Gurugram,
Kavaratii, Itanagar,
Kohima
and
Jhansi.
- For the remaining
39
cities,
75
buildings
were
identified, of which
retrofitting in 9
buildings in 4 cities
857
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
858
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
have been completed.
Work is in progress for
43 Buildings in 25 cities.
Further work is also in
progress in respect of
buildings in other cities.
- Also, CPWD stated that
39 buildings of NCR
region
have
been
provided with accessible
features like a ramp with
railing, disabled friendly
toilets, Auditory and
Signage
and
Visual
Braille Button in a lift in
of
multistoried
case
buildings.
D
-Total Number ofGPOA
buildings
under
maintenance of CPW D in
Delhi NCR & State
capitals is 123
E
F
G
H
- Out of 62 buildings
(50% of 123 buildings),
retrofitting work has been
completed
111
21
buildings in 5 cities
(Delhi,
Bangalore,
Hyderabad,
Lucknow,
Mumbai).
Retrofitting
work is in progress in 24
buildings.
Retrofitting
of
remaining
work
buildings
will
be
completed by December
2017.
- In remaining 50% i.e.
61 buildings (123-62),
retrofitting work will be
completed by July 2018.
I
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
X59
A
5
Accessibility m
airports.
Completing
accessibility
audit of all the
international
airports
and
making
them
fully accessible
by
December
2016.
No information is
available as to
whether this has
been done.
- Out of 32
International
30
Airports,
airports have been
provided
with
accessibility
features
namely
ramps, accessible
toilets, lifts with
Braille
symbols
and
auditory
signals. Out of 65
Domestic Airports,
in 58
airports
accessibility
features have been
provided.
- Ministry of Civil
Aviation
has
informed that most
of the airports have
been made barrierfree for PwDs.
Imphal, Srinagar,
Port Blair airports
are single level
airports therefore
no lift is required
for passengers. In
Thiruvananthapurd
m,
Gaya
and
the
Dagdogra,
upgradation of lifts
is under progress
and the works are
likely
to
be
completed by April
30, 2017.
B
c
D
·E
F
G
H
860
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R
A
6
B
c
D
E
, F
G
H
Accessibility m
Railways.
Ministry
of
Railways
was
required to make
all Al, A and B
category railway
stations
fully
accessible
by
July 2016. 50%
of all railway
stations to made
fully accessible
by March 2018.
No information
provided on their
website for the
same.
- Out of 709 Al,
A, B category
railway stations,
644 have been
made accessible
with short-term
features.
Short
term accessibility
features include
ramp
with
railing, parking
for disabled, the
non-slippery
walkway
from
parking
to
Building,
Signage, suitable
drinking
water
facility,
Accessible toilet
at ground floor
and 'May I Help
You' booth.
- Info1mation has
not been received
from
Railways
about
the
remaining
stations.
Long term
accessibility
feature
include
provision of the
facility for inter
platform transfer
and
tactile
flooring
of
platform.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
7
8
l 0% of government No standards and
owned
public guidelines
at
transport
earners · present
are
are to be made available to make
fully accessible by government
March2018.
owned
public
transport carriers
accessible.
Comprehensive
revision of target
deadliness
under
of
accessibility
knowledge and ICT
Ecosystem. At least
50% of central and
state govt. websites
are
to
meet
accessibility
standards by March
2017. At least 50%
of
the
public
documents are to
meet accessibility
standards by March
2018.
World
Accessibility
Guidelines,
as
prescribed
by
W3C are not
being adhered to.
Instead govt. has
framed their own
guidelines.
- Ministry of Road,
&
Transport
Highways
has
issued instructions
to the States and
Executive Director
of organisations of
State Undertakings
to ensure that I 0%
of
Government
Public
owned
Transport is made
fully accessible to
PwDs
by
the
March 2018.
MeitY
has
informed that the
Guidelines
for
Indian Government
Website
are
compliant
to
WCAG2.0.'"
*((WCAG),
developed through
the World Wide
Web (W3C's)
- MeitY has further
informed
that
under the Content
Management
Framework (CMF),
100 govt. websites
are mandated to be
made
accessible.
59
Ministries/Depts.
have on-boarded to
CMF. Out of these,
33 websites are
made Jive so far.
861
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
862
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
8
B
c
D
Comprehensive
revision of target.
deadliness under
accessibility of
knowledge and
ICT Ecosystem.
At least 50% of
central and state
govt.
websites
are
to
meet
accessibility
standards
by
March 2017. At
least 50% of the
public documents
ari:
to
1111:1!1
accessibility
st:111dards
by
March 2018.
World
Accessibility
Guidelines,
as
prescribed
by
W3C are not
being adhered to.
Instead govt. has
frami:d thdr own
guidelines.
E
9
F
G
H
Bureau of Indian No information
Standards
to about the status
embed disability is provided by
aspect
in all BIS
m
the
relevant parts of absence of which
revised National there are no
Building Code.
standards
and
guidelines.
- MeitY has infonned
that the Guidelines
for
Indian
Government Website
are compliant to
WCAG2.0.*
*((WCAG),
developed
through
the World Wide Web
(W3C's)
- MeitY has further
informed that under
the
Content
Management
Framework (CMF),
100 govt. websites
are mandated to be
made accessible. 59
M inistries/Depts.
have on-boarded to
CMF. Out of these,
33 websites are made
live so far.
- The new version of
National
Building
Code oflndia (NBC),
has
been
comprehensively
updated
in
the
revised NBC and is
released on 15 March
2017. This would be
enforceable once the
urban local bodies
adopt the same.
10
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
863
The target of
training
additional 200
sign language
interpreters by
March 2018.
A
No action to
train 2000 sign
language
interpreters.
- A Task Force has
been set up to develop
a module on Sign
Language.
- ISLR TC plans to train
about
475
sign
language interpreters
(about 75
trainees
through Diploma m
Indian Sign Language
Interpretation) and 400
others officials through
short term training
programme.
CRE
(Continuous
Rehabilitation
Education)
and
Workshops till March,
2018. Besides it 1s
proposed to train 25
interpreters who are
native speakers of sign
language
SODA
(Siblings
of
Deaf
Adult),
CODA
(Children
of Deaf
Adults). 25 educators
for the deaf and 25
Indian sing language
teachers training (deaf)
till March, 2018.
IS LRTC
IS
developing
a
comprehensive Indian
Sign Lanugage (ISL)
Dictionary of about
6000
words
from
various areas like every
day words, academic
words, legal, technical
and medical words.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
864
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
22. In its reply dated June 30, 2017, the petitioner has made his
remarks in respect of the aforesaid ten action points and also submitted
that certain directions arc required from this Court iri respect of six to
ten action points.
B
c
D
Sr.
No.
Targets set
under AIC
Action taken
Petitioner's
remarks
l
Making 20-50
important
government
buildings in 50
cities
fully
accessible by
December,
2017.
(State
Govt.
Buildings
- Access audit
of
1653
buildings has
been
completed.
-
Petitioner's
analysis
of
a
sample
of the
access audits is set
out
m
the
Additional
Affidavit of the
Petitioner
dated
6.1.17 from page 3
onwards showing
the pitiable state of
access for disabled
persons.
.
The
cost
As
on estimates
for
30.03.207, the
retrofitting
647
cost estimates
buildings has not
for
disclosed,
retrofitting of been
thus
suppressing
647 buildings
m 50 cities the fun<ls required
retrofitting
have
been for
these
647
received under
Only
the
buildings.
Scheme
for
sanctioned
amount
implementation
Pwd
Act has been disclosed.
It has not been
(SIPDA).
disclosed as to
Sanction
of
whether
this
Rs.71.60 crore
sanctioned
amount
has
been
has been disbursed
issued for 354
and
used.
buildings.
-
E
F
G
I
H
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
865
A
- It does not appear
as if the central and
state governments are
bothered about the
revised deadline of
2017
December
(from July 2016) for
the retrofitting of the
buildings.
- 22 years after
enactment of PwD
Act, 1995 and now
the RPD Act, 2016
(Which have almost
identical provisions
regarding access) no
progress has been
made. Under both
Acts all buildings in
the states were to be
made accessible; not
just 1653. Out of the
thousands
of
government
buildings in the state
only a tiny fraction of
1653 buildings have
been chosen and
these
too
have
missed the deadlines
for retrofitting.
- The Harmonized
Guidelines made by
the
Central
Government
have
been annexed in Vol.
II of the UOI Status
Report dated 28.4.16.
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
866
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
None of the audit
reports
make
any
reference
to
these
Guidelines. It appears
that the audits (though
severely critical of the
access of the buildings)
have been made on
some ad hoc basis
without reference to the
guidelines.
Directions sought
D
E
F
G
H
I)
The
state
goveffilTients
be
directed to submit
within one month from
today the cost estimates
for the remaining I 006
buildings.
2) Union of India be
directed to disburse to
the res pee ti ve states the
entire funds required
for the retrofitting of
1653 buildings within 2
months from today.
3) For an
order
directing
the
state
governments
to
complete
the
retrofitting of 1653
buildings in accordance
with the Harmonized
by
Guidelines
December, 2017.
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
867
A
4) For an order
directing the state
governments
to
conduct
the
accessibility audit of
all the 1653 buildings
after the retrofitting
is completed within 3
of
months
completion and to
upload the audits on
the website.
5) For an order
directing that the
Chief Secretary of
the states and the
Administratives
of
the Union Territories
will
be
held
responsible for the
of
implementation
the orders passed by
this Court.
2
Harmonized
Making 50% of all government Guidelines and
buildings of the Space Standards
national capital for the barrierand the state free environment
capitals fully foe PwDs were
accessible by issued by CPWD
December
on 23/3/2016.
2018.
- Model Building
Bye-laws
(MBBLs) were
issued
by
Ministry
of
- Same as above.
Under
both
the
statutes all buildings
are to be retrofitted.
The
latest
Harmonized
Guidelines filed by
the UOI in this Court
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
868
A
B
c
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Urban
Development
on
18/3/2016
which
has
a
separate
chapter
, on
Accessibility
for
PwDs. These are to
be adopted by the
States and local
authorities. So far
as 33 States/UTs
have adopted the
accessibility
standards
envisages in the
MBBLs.
- National Building
Code 2016 has
been notified and
published
on
March 15, 2017 by
Bureau of Indian
Standards. It is for
and
the
States
Urban Bodies to
adopte
these
Once
standards.
adopted,
these
standards would be
enforceable.
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
in affidavit dated
28.4.16
read
together with any
revision
done
thereafter must be
used.
- Not a single state
capital has made
any attempt either
to
identify
the
buildings
or to
make
cost
estimates and to
make
financial
provisions
for
retrofitti11g of the
buildings. In the
meeting
of the
Central
Coordination
Committee held on
29.11.16
as
directed by the
Supreme Court it
was decided that
all
state
governments
would submit the
names
of
the
identified buildings
by 28.2.17.
Directions sought
G
H
- In respect of this
target, States have
to
make
their
buildings
accessible
from
their own budget,
as per the decision
of
Central
I. For an order
directing
all
States/UTs
to
finalise and submit
to UOI the list of
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
Coordination
Committee
(CCC). In this
respect list of
buildings
identified
m
State
Capitals
has
been
received
from
Meghalaya,
Karnataka,
Sikkimk, Uttar
Pradesh, Assam,
Tamil Nadu and
Bihar only.
869
50%
of
the
government
buildings of all
the state capitals
that are to be
retrofitted within
one month from
today.
2. For an order
directing
all
States/UTs
to
make
cost
estimates,
disburse
funds
and complete the
retrofitting of all
the
identified
buildings
m
accordance with
the Harmonized
Guidelines read
together with any
subsequent
revision,
A
B
c
D
E
by
December 2018,
in such a manner
that 50% of the
work shall be
completed
by
December 2017
and a report be
made to this
Court in respect
thereof.
F
G
3. For an order
directing that the
Chief Secretaries
of the States
shall be held
H
870
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
responsible for the
implementation of
the orders made by
this Court.
B
4. For an order
directing all the
State/UTs
to
complete
an
accessibility audit
of all the buildings
retrofitted
in
accordance
with
the
Harmonized
Guidelines and to
upload these audit
reports.
c
D
3
E
F
G
H
Completing
accessibility
audit of 50% of
government
buildings and
making them
fully accessible
m
10 most
important
cities/towns of
states/UTs not
covered
in
targets (i) and
(ii)
by
December
2019.
In response to the
1etters sent to
States to provide
a list of 10
important cities,
lists of cities
have
been
received
from
Bihar,
Meghalaya,
Kamat aka,
Sikkim,
Uttar
Pradesh, Assam
and Tamil Nadu
only. However,
list of Buildings
in these cities
have not been
identified by the
respective Stales.
- Under both the
statutes
all
buildings are to be
retrofitted.
No
progress
made. Cities not
identified by many
states.
Buildings
not
identified
by
any
state.
Estimates not made
of funds required
by any state.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
871
A
Direction sought
1)
For
an
order
directing all States/UTs
to identify 50% of the
government buildings
in
the
l0
most
important cities/towns
within l month from
today and to allocate
adequate resources and
complete
the
retrofitting of these
buildings by December
2019 in such a manner
that half the work will
by
be
completed
December 2018 and an
interim
report
submitted to this Court
and a final report
submitted thereafter.
2. For an order
directing
all
the
State/UTs to complete
an accessibility audit of
buildings
all
the
retrofitted
in
accordance with the
Harmonized Guidelines
and to upload these
audit reports.
B
c
D
E
F
3.
For
an
order
directing that the Chief
Secretaries
of
the
States shall be held
responsible for the
implementation of the
orders made by this
Court.
G
H
872
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
4
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
Central
Government
buildings
CPWD
infonned that out
of 50 cities of
phase I, l l cities
do
not
have
General
Pool
Accommodation
(GPOA)
Buildings under
maintenance of
CPWD.
These
cities are Daman,
Imphal, Aizawl,
Gangtok,
Agartala, Silvasa,
Gurugram,
Kavaratti,
Itanagar, Kohima
and Jhansi.
- Under both the
statutes of 1995
and of 2016 all
buildings are to be
retrofitted.
- The minutes of I
the
Central
Coordination
Committee
meeting held on
29.11.16
as
directed by the
Supreme
Court
reveals that audits
and retrofitting is
to be done of 466
buildings
including
90
buildings
GPOA
by December, 2016
For
the
remaining
39
cities,
75 Directions sought
buildings
were
identified,
of l) For an order
which retrofitting directing UOI to
in 9 buildings in complete
the
4 cities have retrofitting of the
been completed. mentioned
466
Work
is . in buildings
in
progress for 4 3 accordance
with
buildings in 25 the
Harmonized
cities.
Further Guidelines
as
work is also in revised
and
progress
111
thereafter
to
respect
of complete
the
buildings in other accessibility audit
cities.
by July, 2018 and
to upload the audits
on the websites.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.)
- Also, CPWD stated
that 39 buildings of
NCR region have
been provided with
accessible
features
like a ramp with
railing,
disabled
friendly
toilets,
Auditory and Visual
Signage and Braille
Button in a lift in
case of multistoried
buildings.
- Total number of
GPOA
buildings
under maintenance of
CPWD in Delhi NCR
& State Capitals is
123.
- Out of 62 buildings
(50%
of
123
buildings),
retrofitting work has
been completed in 21
buildings
in 5
cities
(Delhi,
Bangalore,
Hyderabad,
Lucknow, Mumbai).
Retrofitting work of
remaining buildings
will be completed by
December 2017.
In the remaining 50%
i.e.
61
buildings
( 123-62), retrofitting
work
will
be
completed by July
2018.
2) For an order
directing that a
Secretary, MoUD,
shall be the person
held
responsible
for
the
implementation of
the orders made by
the Supreme Court.
873
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
874
SUPREME COURT. REPORTS
A
.
5.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
Accessibility in
international
and domestic
airports.
- Out of 32
International
30
Airports,
airports
have
been
provided
with accessibility
features namely
ramps, accessible
toilets lifts with
Braille symbols
and
auditory
signals. Out of
65
Domestic
Airports, in 58
airports
accessibility
features
have
been provided.
- In the meeting of
the
Central
Coordination
Committee held on
29. l Ll 6
as
mentioned
above
it
Completing
was pointed out
accessibility
that
the
audit of all the
accessibility work
international ·
done was only
airports
and
'basic' and that
making them
further provisions
fully accessible
would be put in
by December
place 'in a phased
2016
and
manner'. . It is
domestic
mentioned that a
airports
by
for
template
March2018.
accessibility audits
was prepared in
- Ministry of order to conduct
and
Civil
Aviation audits
has informed that retrofitting in all
most of the airports. However,
airports
have no audit has been
been
made done.
barrier-free for
PwDs. Imphal, - In the Committee
Srinagar,
Port meeting it is stated
Blair airports are that
'airport
single
level accessibility is riot
airports therefore confined to ramps,
no lift is required toilets and lifts.
for passengers. In The airports have
Thiruvananthapu to
be_
made
ram, Gaya and accessible for all
Bagdogra,
the kinds of disabilities
upgradation of and
the
lifts 1s under accessibility should
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
(A. K. SIKRI, J.] -
875
A
progress and the
works are likely
to be completed
by April 30,
2017.
include
accessible
signage, accessible
parking
places,
tactile. floorings etc.
A copy of the access
audit conducted by
HT, Roorkie for the
Indira
Gandhi
International· Airport
has been sent to
Ministry of Civil
Aviation, which will
act as a template for
access audit and will
facilitate retrofitting
of the airports and
railway stations'.
B
c
D
- No mention is made
in the UOI status
of
the
report
domestic airports.
. Harmonized
guidelines and NBC
clearly mention use
of non slippery matt
finish tiles which
have not been used.
People using crutches
and callipers find it
difficult to . navigate
open
spaces
in
· airports as tiles are
very
slippery.
Carpets
prevent
wheelchair
users
from navigating their
wheelchairs
in
carpeted walkways
E
F
G
'
H
876
A
8
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
and people using
crutches
and
callipers who have
restricted
leg
movements find it
difficult to drag
their
feet
on
carpets.
No
uniform standards
are used in making
accessible toilets.
For instance, rn
Mumbai, Delhi and
other airports no
latches
are
provided
from
inside.
D
E
F
G
H
- In the Central
Committee
meeting it was
stated
by
the
representative
of
the National Trust
'that a template of
access audit had
been provided to
the Ministry of
Railways
and
Ministry of Civil
Aviation
for
conducting access
audit
and
of
retrofitting
railway
stations
and airports. He
pointed out that
these
Ministries
should follow the
prescribed
template and not
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
877
A
pick out only some
elements therefrom.
The representative of
the two Ministries
submitted
that
retrofitting would be
carried out as per the
template, but had
been phased out in
of
the
view
of
availability
resources.'
B
c
Directions sought
1) For an order
directing UOI to
complete
the
retrofitting of all the
international
and
domestic airports by
December
2017
(extending the earlier
deadline of April
2017) in accordance
with the Harmonized
Guidelines as revised
and the UT Roorkee
access audit template
abovementioned.
2) For an order
directing UOI to
thereafter conduct the
accessibility
audit
and upload these
audits on the website
by March 2018.
D
E
F
G
H
878
. SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R .
A
3) For an order
directing UOI to
produce in this
Court
the
accessibility audit
done of IGIA by
' IIT Roorkee.
B ,
6.
c
D
E
F
G
H
·'
Accessibility m
Railways.
of
Ministry
Railways
was
required to make
all Al, A, B
category railway
stations
fully
accessible
by
July 2016. 50%
of all railway
staticms to made
fully accessible
by March 2018~
- Out of 709 Al,
A, l3 category
railway stations,
644 have been
made accessible
with short-term
features, shortterm accessibility
features include
ramp
with
railing, parking
for disabled, the
non
slippery
walkway from
parking
to
Building,
Signage, suitable
drinking water
facility,
Accessible toilet
at ground floor
and 'May I Help
You' booth.
- Information has
not been received
from Railways
about
the
remaining ·
stations.
The
statute
requires
full
accessibility of all
railway stations not
just 50%.
- In the Central
Committee
meeting it was
stated
by
the
representative of
the National Trust
'that a template of
access audit had
b,een provided to
the Ministry of '
Railways
and
Ministry of Civil
for
Aviation
conducting access
audit
and
of
retrofitting
railway
stations
and airports. He
pointed out that
these
Ministries
should follow the
prescriobed
template and not
pick
out only
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
some
elements
therefrom.
The
representative
of
the two Ministries
submitted
that
retrofitting would
be carried out as
per the template,
but
had
been
phased
out in
view
of
tHe
availability
of
resources."
- Mere symbolic
efforts made to
provide
accessibility
in
railway
stations.
For instance:
- To provide access
to drinking water
sources, instead of
lowering
the
drinking
water
source
ad
hoc
platforms
have
been made with
ramps for access.
These
are
dangerous for users
of crutches and
callipers as the
ramps are mostly
wet and slippery.
879
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
-
Low
ticket
counters
are
provided 111 some
H
880
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
reservation
counters but no
low ticket windows
are provided for
buying
general
tickets which are
mostly used by
disabled.
- Some railway
stations have lifts
and
escalators
(Delhi
has
escalators and lifts
at entrances from
both sides) but
escalators cannot
be used by most
people
with
orthopaedic
disabilities.
Also
no such facilities
provided
for
reaching
other
platforms.
- In the last railway
budget
it
as
announced that the
Central
Government would
be providing for
lifts in 600 stations
for inter-platform
accessibility.
Physically
disabled have to be
carried
up
and
down to reach rn
between platforms
which
1s
undignified.
I
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
881
A
- Battery operated cars
used for transporting
persons with disabilities
in Delhi railway station
have been withdrawn by
the railways as the
company providing this
facility through CSR has
withdrawn the facility.
Compartments
for
persons with disabilities
arc
inaccessible
and
generally used by RPF
and railway staff.
- Toilets at railway
stations
have
been
converted into toilets for
disabled
persons
by
making
cosmetic
adjustments
in
the
existing toilets without
any real attempt being
made to comply with the
guidelines.
- In the UOI status report
no reference ·is made to
the compartments and
reference is made only to
the railway stations even
though clause 11. 7 .2.2
provides
detailed
guidelines on accessible
railway
compartments
including
entrances,
wheel chair spaces, seats,
aisles and information
signs
and
announcements.
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
882
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
Directions Sought
.
B
I
c
D
,
E
F
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
l) For an order
directing UOI to
produce in this Court
the accessibility audit
done by UT Roorkee
for the. New Delhi
Railway Station.
2) For an order
directing UOI to
complete
the
retrofitting of all the
709 Al, A & B
category
railway
stations by December
2017 and to conduct
the
accessibility
of
audits
these
railway stations by
March
2018
in
accordance with the
Harmonized ·
Guidelines as revised
and the UT Roorkee
access
audit
,
template, and to
upload the audit
reports
on
the
website.
3) For an order
G
H
directing the UOI tO
complete
the
retrofitting of 50% of
the
remaining
railway stations in
the
country
by
December 2019 and
I
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
the
remaining
railway stations by
· December 2020 in
accordance with the
Harmonized
Guidelines as revised
and the HT Roorkee
accessibility template
and
thereafter
complete
the
accessibility audits
by December 2020
and upload the audits
on the website.
4) For an order
directing UOI to
immediately restart
the facility of battery·
operated cars at New
Railway
Delhi
Station and introduce
this facility at all
other Al, A & B
category
railway
station by December,
2018 .
&83
A
B
C
D
E
.
5) For an order
directing UOI to
install in all railway
stations
in
the
country ramps and
lifts in 600 stations
for inter platform
accessibility
by
December 2017 and
lifts in the remaining
stations by December
2018.
F
G
H
884
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
6)
Introduce
strict
monitoring of and the
introduction of penal
provisions, for non
disabled persons using
compartments
for
disabled;
7)
For
an
order
directing the UOI to
immediately
arrange
for hydraulic lifts or
collapsible ramps to
board
compartments
reserved for disabled
persons.
8)
For
an
order
directing the UOI to
immediately
ensure
that all compartments
of
all
trains
be
retrofitted with one
toilet
Ill
each
compartment which is
accessible
Ill
accordance with the
Harmonized Guidelines
as revised and the IIT
Roorkee accessibility
template by December
2017.
9)
For
an
order
directing
UOI
to
conduct
a
comprehensive
retrofitting of all the
toilets
for disabled
persons at all the
railway stations to
I
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
885
A
ensure that they comply
with the Harmonized
Guidelines as revised and
the
IIT
Roorkee
accessibility audit by
December 2017.
10) For an order directing
the UOI to replace all
disability compartments
with comp~1rtments that
are
constructed
m
accordance with clause
of
the
l l.7.2.2
Harmonized Guidelines
by December 2018.
B
C
D
11) For an order directing
that
the
Chairman,
Railway Board, shall be
responsible
for
the
implementation of the
orders of this Court.
I 2) For an order directing
UOI to act in accordance
with the audits filed by
the petitioner in respect
of the Mumbai Railway
Stations and to forthwith
retrofit all the Mumbai
railway
stations
in
accordance with the said
audits, the Harmonized
Guidelines as revised and
the
IIT
Roorkee
accessibility template by
December 2018.
E
F
G
H
886
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
7
B
.
c
D
E
F
G
H
10%
of
government
owned public
transpbrt
carriers are to
be made fully
accessible by
March 2018.
Ministry of Road
Transport
&
Highways
has
issued
instructions
to
the State and
Executive
Director
of
organisations of
State ·
Undertakings to
ensure 10% of
Government
owned
public
transport is made
fully accessible
to the PwDs by
March 2018.
-The statutes cover
public
all
transportation as well
as all bus depots and
bus stands. The AIC
therefore deals with
only a small fraction
of the work to be
done.
- The UOI status
report covers only
buses and not bus
depots and bus· stands
(clause 10.3)
- The Harmonized
Guidelines
clause
11. 7.1
onwards
extensively
deals
with public transport.
- Delhi Goyernment
informs that there are
6350
government
buses and not 4352
as stated in the status
report. Only 3775 are
said to be disabled
friendly.
- The law requires
that
all
pubIi c
transportation
be
made
disabled
friendly and not just
government
buses.
The guidelines cover
tramps, taxis, mini
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
887
A
buses and three
wheelers as well. as
taxi
and , auto
rickshaws
stands
and car parking.
No mention · is
made of this in the
status report.
Efforts
are
minimal. All bus
stations
remain
inaccessible
and
are nightmares for
No·
disabled.
accessible
toilets
provided. ·
No
provisions
for.
passengers
using
wheel chairs and
crutches
and
callipers to board
No
buses.
provision of tactile
footpaths, kerbside
cuts for wheel
chair users to enter
footpath&,
no
auditory signals at
red light crossings,
no engraved zebra
crossings and no
islands
between
roads. Pedestrian
infrastructure
not included as
AI
targets
in
campaign.
These
are
covered
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
888
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
D
in the Harmonized
Guidelines
Section
11 on Transport and
Road Planning which
covers sidewalks and
footpaths, kerb ramps
at walkways and
pedestrian crossings,
road
intersections,
median
refuge/islands, traffic
signals, subways and
foot over bridges.
There is no reference
to these in the status
report.
Directions sought
!) For an order
directing UOI, States
and UTs to:
E
F
G
H
a) Ensure that all
government buses arc
disabled friendly in
accordance
with
clause 11. 7 .1.2 of the
Harmonized
Guidelines
by
December 2017 by
induction of new
buses
and
the
phasing out of buses
that arc not disabled
friendly.
b) To ensure that all
private
buses
operating
arc
disabled friendly and
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
889
A
that all other buss
are not permitted to
operate after the
deadline
of
December 2017.
B
c) To retrofit all
bus stations and
bus
stands
compliant
with
section 10.3 of the
Harmonized
Guidelines,
inter
alia, in respect of
accessible boarding
points, directional
signs, toilets, seats,
shelter and ramps
etc.
d) To ensure that
all
public
transportation
operating
from
December 2018 is
compliant with the
Harmonized
Guidelines.
8.
-
Comprehensive
MeitY
has
rev1s10n
of informed that the
target deadlines Guidelines
for
under
the
Indian
accessibility of Government
knowledge and Website (GIGW)
ICT
arc compliant to
Ecosystem. At WCAG2.0.*
least
50%
of
central
*((WCAG),
and
state developed
-
- The 2016 statute
requtres
all
websites to meet
accessibility
standards not just
50%. Instead of all
the websites of
government
running
into
thousands,
the
status report only
c
D
E
F
G
H
890
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
government
websites are to
meet accessibility
standards
by
March 2017. At
least 50% of the
public documents
are
to
meet
accessibility
standards
by
March 2018.
through the World
Wide
Web
Consortium's
(W3C's)
covers the central
government
websites and even
there are total
number of central
state
MeitY has further and
informed
that governments
under the Content websites are not
disclosed.
The
Management
Framework (CMF), Central
100 Govt. websites Coordination
are mandated to be Committee
made accessible. meeting gives a
figure of 2,000
59
central government
Ministries/Depts.
Have on-boarded websites that are to
to CMF. Out of be made accessible
these, 33 websites under the AlC
are made Ii ve so (50% of the total).
Out of the blue a
far.
magical figure of
100
central
govenunent
websites are taken
as an arbitrary
target and it is
stated that 33 are
operational. This
will
not
even
amount to I% of
all state and central
government
websites in the
country.
- Similarly, though
the AIC requires
only 50% of public
H
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
891
A
documents to meet
the
accessibility
standards by March
2018 there is no
reference
m
the
status report to this
compliance.
Moreover, the statute
requires all public
documents to meet
the
accessibility
standards.
Although
the
Harmonized
Guidelines do not
refer to accessibility
of documents there is
no controversy that
documents have to be
made accessible m
Braille,
electronic,
audio formats etc. No
documents have been
made accessible in
India.
- The status report
also docs not touch
on public television
programmes (target
7.2 AIC), telephone
and mobile based
services such as PCR
100
number,
ambulance and fire
services etc. TV
programmes
for
example require sign
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
892
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
language interpreters,
close
captioning,
audio
descriptions
etc. Moreover, the
AIC only covers
government
programmes, which
is wrong because the
2002 statute covers
public
information
services provided by
private parties.
Directions sought
D
E
F
G
H
For
an
order
directing UOI and all
the states/UTs to:
1) Made all the
websites accessible
m accordance with
W3C web content
Accessibility
Guidelines (WCAG)
by March 2018 and
accessibility audits
completed by June
2018 and uploaded
on the website.
2) To make 50% of
all public documents
issued by the central
government and the
state
governments
accessible including
all publications such
as laws, regulations,
reports, forms and
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
informational
brochures
(taken
verbatim from the AIC)
by March 2018 in
accordance with the
Organisation
for
Standardization criteria
that are found in
ISO/IEC 40500:2012.
893
A
B
3) To
make
the
remainder of all public
documents accessible
by December 2018.
c
4) To make 25% of all
government
programmes on TV
accessible by March
2018 as stated in the
AIC.
D
4)
To
make
all
government and private
TV
programmes
accessible in terms of
"daily captioning and
sign
language
interpretation" as set
out in Objective 7 of
the AIC by March
2018.
5) To make telephone
and
mobile
based
services such as PCR
100, Ambulance, Fire
and other emergency
services according to
internationally
accepted TTY facility
by December 2017.
E
F
G
H
894
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
9.
Bureau
of
Indian
to
Standards
embed disability
aspect m all
relevant parts of
revised National
Building Code.
The new version of
National Building
Code of India
(NBC), has been
comprehensively
updated in the
revised NBC and is
released on 15
March 2017. This
would
be
enforceable once
the local bodies
adopt the same.
IO.
The target of
training
additional 200
sign language
interpreters by
March 2018.
- A task force has
been set up to
develop a module
on sign language.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
- The standard to
be used ought to
be
the
Harmonized
Guidelines read
together with the
revised NBC.
- The figure of
200
sign
language
interpreters
is
Sign
farcical.
- ISLRTC plans to language
train about 475 interpreters are
sign
language required at least
major
interpreters (about at all
where
75 trainers through places
Diploma in Indian communication
Sing
Language and dealing with
Interpretation) and the public both in
400 others officials the public and
sector
through
short private
take
place.
This
term
training
cover
programme. CRE will
railway stations,
(Continuous
major
bus
Rehabilitation
depots,
hospitals,
Education)
and
Workshops
till airports, major
March,
2018. government
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
895
A
ISLRTC
1s
developing
a
comprehensive
Sign
Indian
Language
(ISL)
Dictionary of about
6000 words from
various areas like
every day words,
academic words,
legal, technical and
medical words.
offices,
large
private
sector
offices, shopping
large
malls,
educational
institutions and the
like. If a realistic
assessment is made
of New Delhi itself
it is quite possible
that the number of
sign
language
interpreters
required for the
capital city alone
would be in excess
of 200. Moreover,
section 17 which
deals
with
inclusive education
requires
the
training
and
recruitment
of
teachers who are
qualified m sign
language. Section
42 deals with
to
access
information
and
communication
services
require
sign
language
interprct.:rs for all
TV programmes.
Thus
the
requirement
for
sign
language
interpreters must
be
assessed
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
896
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
B
c
D
E
F
.
G
H
realistically by an
expert group and
would probably run
into
tens
of
thousands for the
entire country. It
must
be
remembered
that
deaf
persons
constitutes 30% to
40%
of
the
disabled population
and
the actual
figure IS stimated
at a minimum of 13
million persons. In
the absence of sign
language
interpreters in the
educational
institutions and in
the country they
remam
at
the
lowest rungs of the
disability
sector
and suffer almost
complete
exclusion.
Their
performance
m
education
and
employment show
this
extreme
discrimination.
Hence the sign
language
interpreters issue is
one of the most
important human
rights remaining to
be implemented in
India.
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.)
897
A
- The status report
refers to ad hoc
of
training
personnel. This is
most unsatisfactory
and is completely
distinct from the
generation
of
B
qualified
interpreters. Thus
even the target of
200 has not been
met. The status
report shows that
not
even
one
has
interpreter
qualified.
c
D
Directions sought
1) For an order
directing
the
Rehabilitation
Council of India
(RCI), the National
Association of the
Deaf to submit to
this
Court
a
reasonable estimate
of the number of
sign
language
interpreter required
in India.
2) For an order
directing UOI and
all states and UTs
to jointly establish
an
emergency
E
F
G
H
898
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 12 S.C.R.
arrangement
nationwide
where
475 sign language
interpreters qualify
by March 2018 as
stated in the status
report and 500 sign
language interpreters
qualify every year
thereafter until the
target
of
the
estimated
sign
language interpreters
required
in
the
country is met.
3) For an order
directing UOI and all
states/UTs to create a
special cadre of sign
language interpreters
m the Union and
state cadres for the
immediate
employment of the
sign
language
interpreters
who
qualify.
General
sought
directions
I) For an order
directing all states
and UTs to constitute
the Central and State
Advisory
Boards
required to be set up
under Sections 60
and 66 of the 2016
Act.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.)
899
23. Vide orderdatedAugust9, 2017, this Court sought the response
of the respondents in respect of directions which arc sought by the
petitioner and listed above. In compliance therewith, the Union oflndia
has filed affidavit on August 23, 2017. In this affidavit, the Union of
India has itself accepted the position under the Disabilities Act, 2016 by
mentioning relevant provisions of the Act in detail, which have already
been taken note of.
A
B
24. The Government has also pointed out that the Bus Body Coat
as notified by Ministry of Road Transport and Highways vide GSR No.
895(E) dated September 20, 2016 has been adopted, in the form of
Central Motor Vehicles (12' 11 Amendment) Rules, 2016. It is also
c
mentioned that in case of Information & Communication Technology,
the guidelines for Indian Government websites as adopted by Department
of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances are to be complied
with by all the websites of establishments. The Ministry is working with
other line Ministries/Departments to finalise accessible standards for
other facilities and services. Insofar as directions sought by the petitioner D
in his affidavit dated June 30, 2017 arc concerned, the Union of India
has given its response thereto in the following manner:
"(a) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 1,
it is stated that the State Governments are being regularly reminded
up to submit cost estimates for retrofitting for the release of grant E
in aid. 822 proposals have been received so far, however, funds
amounting Rs.84.32 crore for 385 buildings has been released.
For remaining, 437 buildings funds could not be released due to
technical errors in the proposals, pending Utilization certificates
etc. Cost estimates of 780 buildings are yet to be received.
Directing the States to submit the proposal within a period of one. F
month may not be practical since the States are required to get
their cost estimates done through their Executive Engineers of
Public Works Department. Further, the direction sought by the
petitioner to disburse the entire fund to the States within a period
of two months is also not feasible. During the current financial G
year, an amount of Rs.207 crorc is available under Central
Government's scheme called 'Scheme for Implementation of
Persons with Disabilities Act (SIPDA)'. Thus, release of funds
depends on the amount available with the Government at that
H
900
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
point of time. Therefore, it would be appropriate to direct the
States to submit the proposal within a period of six months and
the Central Government would release the fund, ifthe proposal is
complete in accordance with the scheme within a period of two
months from the receipt of the proposal, subject to the availability
of the funds.
It is further submitted that it may also not be practically feasible
possible to direct the State Governments to complete retrofitting
by December, 2017. It may be noted that after sanctioning of the
proposal, the State Governments are required to float tender and
assign the work to the agency which may take time. Fmiher, the
completion of work will take time. It may not be feasible in all the
cases to complete the work within a period of six months. The
States may be directed to complete the process of initiation of
retrofitting work by December, 2017.
It is submitted that the State Governments may be directed
to conduct accessible audit after retrofitment so as to see whether
all the findings of the access audit report have been adequately
addressed or not.
(b) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 2, it
is stated that it may be appropriate to give three months time for
the States to submit the list of 50% of the Government buildings in
all State Capitals as per target 2 of AIC. It may perhaps be
appropriate to advise the States/UTs to devise work plan to ensure
retrofitmcnt in these buildings by December, 2018 and conduct
accessibility audit as soon as the retrofitment work is over.
( c) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Numbcr3, it
is submitted that it may be appropriate to give three months time
for the States to submit the list of buildings in l 0 most important
cities as per target 3 of AIC.
( d) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 4, it
is submitted that CPWD/Ministry of Urban Development is the
nodal Department for maintenance of General Pool Office
Accommodation (GPOA) buildings. CPWD has intimated that
out of 50 cities of phase I, 11 cities do not have GPOA buildings
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
901
under maintenance of CPWD. For the remaining 39 cities, 75 A
buildings were identified, ofwhich retrofitting in 49 buildings in 27
cities have been completed and work is in progress for 9 buildings
in 8 cities. Retrofitting of all the 466 buildings within a period of
one year may not be feasible as it involves allocation of funds.
(e) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 5, it
is submitted that Ministry of Civil Aviation has been requested to
carry out retrofitting activities as per extant guidelines/instructions.
The access audit report of llT Roorkee with respect to Indira
Gandhi International Airport has been placed on the website of
the Department.
B
c
(f) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 6, it
is submitted that the access audit report of IIT Roorkee with
respect to New Delhi Railway Station has been placed on the
website of the Department.
(g) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 7, it
is submitted that Ministry of Road Transport & Highways being
the concerned M\nistry to take a view on the possibility of phasing
out. However, as per Section 46 of the Disabilities Act, 2016, the
service providers whether Government or private shall provide
services in accordance with the rules on accessibility formulated
by the Central Government under Section 40 within period of 2
years from the date of notification of such rules. Mostly the
passenger bus transportation is in the domain of State Governments.
It is for the States to take. a call in the matter. It may be appropriate
to direct them to comply with the provisions of Section 46 of the
Disabilities Act, 2016.
(h) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 8, it
is submitted that with a view to help the State Government to
make their website accessible as per GIGW andW3C compliance,
DEPwD has issued a work order to ERNET India for 917 State
Government websites to be made accessible as per GIGW and
W3C compliance. Now the accessibility standards has been
prescribed for websites and the document to upload on it under
Rule 15(1)(c) of the 2017 Rules.All the establishments are required
to comply with these standards.
D
E
F
G
H
902
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
[2017) 12 S.C.R.
(i) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 9 no
specific directions has been sought. It may be noted that
Harmonised Guidelines and Space Standards for barrier-free built
environment for persons with disabilities and elderly persons issued
by Ministry of Urban Development has been adopted as reference
for accessibility norms and therefore only these guidelines are to
be mandatorily followed.
B
D
(j) With respect to the directions sought under Serial Number 10,
it is submitted that Rehabilitation Council oflndia (RCD has done
this exercise earlier with reference to order of High Com1 of
Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 6250 of 2010 - The National Association
of Deaf v. Union of India & Ors. Accordingly, the Department
has staited training of its officials to develop a pool of sign language
interpreters in the public offices. So far six batches of sign
fanguage training have been completed and about 100 sign
language interpreters have been trained. Status reports are bring
filed in the High Court from time to time."
E
25. It is, thus, stated that though the respondent has taken
appropriate steps in respect of ten action points spelled out by the
petitioner and is attempting to fulfil the needs of such visually impaired
persons in all possible manners.
c
F
26. This affidavit also refers to the judgment of this Court in the
case of Justice S11nanda Bltandare Foundation v. Union of India &
Anr. 8 wherein certain directions were given by this Court. It is mentioned
that while dealing with the compliance of the directions contained in the
aforesaid judgment, this Court has passed order dated April 25, 2017
(reported as Justic'e Suna11da Bltandare Foundation v. Union ofIndia
& Anr. 9 ), as per which following directions arc given:
"25. We have referred to certain provisions only to highlight that
the 2016 Act has been enacted and it has many salient features.
As we find, more rights have been conferred on the disabled
persons and more categories have been added. That apart, access
to justice, free education, role of local authorities, National fund
and the State fund for persons with disabilities have been created.
G
H
• (2014) 14 sec 383
2017 (5) SCALE 288
9
RAINE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
903
The 2016 Act is noticeably a sea change in the perception and
requires a march forward look with regard to the persons with
disabilities and the role of the States, local authorities, educational
institutions and the companies. The statute operates in a broad
spectrum and the stress is laid to protect the rights and provide
punishment for their violation.
A
26. Regard being had to the change in core aspects, we think it
apposite to direct all the States and the Union Territories to file
compliance report keeping in view the provisions of the 2016 Act
within twelve weeks hence. The States and the Union Territories
must realize that under the 2016 Act their responsibilities have
grown and they are required to actualize the purpose of the Act,
for there is an accent on many a sphere with regard to the rights
of the disabilities. When the law is so concerned for the disabled
persons and makes provision, it is the obligation of the law
exc1,,'Uting authorities to give effect to the same in quite promptitude.
The steps taken in this regard shall be concretely stated in the
compliance report within the time stipulated. When we are directing
the States, a duty is cast also on the States and its authorities to
see that the statutory provisions that are enshrined and applicable
to the cooperative soCieties, companies, firms, associations and
establishments, institutions, are scrupulously followed. The State
Governments shall take immediate steps to comply with the
requirements of the 2016 Act and file the compliance report so
that this Court can appreciate the progress made.
27. The compliance report to be filed by the States shall be supplied
to the learned counsel for the petitioner, learned counsel for the
Union oflndia as well as to the learned counsel for the applicant/
intervenor so that they can assist the Court.
B
C
D
E
F
28. The Registry is directed to send a copy of the order passed
today to the Chief Secretaries of the States and the Administrators
of the Union Territories."
27. In respect of the action taken by the respondents as mentioned
in its affidavit dated August 23, 2017, the petitioner has furnished the
following comments:
G
H
904
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Sr.
No.
Petitioner's Comments to the UOJ response dated 23'd
August, 2017
1
I) tbe petitioner reiterates the time limits in the directions
sought (in Col. 2) for the following response:
•
The original deadline of July 2016 under this target has
been extended by the Central Coordination Committee
(CCC) in its meeting on 29.11.2016 to December 2017.
(Annexure R-2 of tbe Action Taken Report of UOI
dated 14.12.2016)
•
The 2016 Act vide Section 46 requires that all service
providers, botb Government and private, make their
facilities, including buildings, accessible within a period
of two years from the date of notification of the
Accessibility Rules (notified in June 2016). Therefore
all government buildings providing any services to the
public are to be made fully accessible by June 2019.
•
Whereas Section 46 of the 2016 Act contemplates all
buildings and facilities throughout tbe cow1try to made
accessible by June 2019, the AIC targets very limited
number in Phase I, i.e. 1653 buildings. Therefore, the
December 2017, set by the CCC ought to be adhered to
and the timeframes in tbe direction sought by the
Petitioner have been made with regard to the revised
CCC deadline.
D
E
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
G
2) The Submission by UOI that funds disbursal under SIPDA
will be subject to availability is not tenable. The 2016 Act
nowhere contemplates the implementation of accessibility in
public buildings and services to be contingent on availability of
fimd in SIPDA. It is therefore respectfully submitted that the
accessibility provisions of the 2016 Act being mandatory, funds
as the required must be allocated by the Central Government
from the Consolidated Funds oflndia.
H
3) It is further reiterated that after retrofitting the State Govt,
buildings, they should be audited according to tbe Harmonised
Guidelines keeping in view that the audits commissioned by
UOI prior to retrofitting were not according to the Harmonised
Guidelines.
F
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
905
A
3
4
5
It is to be noted that as per the UOL Status Report elated
08.08.2017, only 7 States have submitted their lists of 10
most important cities/towns and not a single building has
been identified so far. Therefore the reason stated under
Target 1 above, Petitioner reiterates that the States be
directed to identify the 10 most important cities/towns and
50% of the Govt, buildings in these cities/towns within 1
month from today and the retrofitting of these be
completed by December 2019 which is the revised
extended deadline set down by the CCC.
With regard to this target, the CCC in its meeting on
29.11.2016 has extended the deadline for retrofitting 466
Central Govt. buildings to December 2016. 8 months have
. already passed since then and only 49 building have been
retrofitted. The submission of the UOI that afl' 466
buildings cannot be retrofitted within l year because of
limitations in funds allocated cannot be accepted, As.noted
above the 2016 Act Vide Section 46 requires. all Govt.
service providers to make their facilities including the
buildings accessible by June 2019, which requirement is
not subject to allocation of funds. Admittedly 466
buildings under this target would constitute only a small
fraction of the total number of Central Govt. buildings to
be made accessible under the 2016 Act. Therefore, the
Petitioner reiterates the timeframe of July 2018 for
completing this target.
The Petitioner has brought to the attention of this Hon'ble
Court by its Affidavit dated 30.06.2017 of several features
in which the airports in the country are not accessible. It
may be noted that in its meeting on 29.11.2016, the CCC
had noted that the accessibility work done on airports was
only basic and that the Civil Aviation Ministry should
follow the prescribed template, i.e. HT Roorkee template
on the Govt, website would not serve 'its purpose reiterates
the directions sought with regard to this Target.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
906
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
6
The Petitioner has brought to the attention of this Hon'ble
Com1 by its Affidavit dated 30.06.2017 of several features
in which the railways in the country are not accessible. In
pm1icular the Petitioner conducted a survey of the New
Delhi Railway Station which has been claimed to have been
accessible by UOI. The Petitioner annexed a number of
photographs showing several critical featw·es lacking in
accessibility. It may be noted that 111 its meeting on
i9.l l.2016, the CCC had noted that the accessibility work
done on railways was only basic and that the Railway
Ministry should follow the prescribed template, i.e. UT
Roorkee template for New Delhi Railway Station and not
pick out any clements therefrom. It is submitted that merely
placing the IIT Roorkee template on the Govt, website
would not serve its purpose and therefore the Petitioner
reiterates the directions sought with regard to this target.
7
It may be noted that Section 41 of the 2016 Act provides for
comprehensive accessibility in all modes of transport
including but not limited to bus transpo11. Read with Section
46 and Rule 15 of the 2017 Rules, the UOI and the States
are to ensure that all Public transport systems including
transport carriers and roads are made fully accessible by
June 2019 in accordance with the Harmonised Guidelines.
Therefore, the Petitioner reiterates the directions sought for
with regard to this target.
8
It may be noted that Section 42 of the 2016 Act provides for
comprehensive
accessibility
in
information
and
communication services including audios, print and
electronic media. Section 46 read with Rule 15 of the 2017
Rules mandates that the same be completed by June 2019
throughout the country i8t 1s m this context that the
Petitioner has sought directions to have 50% of the Govt,
websites, 5% of the public documents and 25% of all TV
programmes to be made accessible by mid-2018. The UOI
response only indicates that work orders have been issued
for 917 State Govt, websites but no timeframe for
completion has been mentioned. The earlier status rep011
filed by the Govt, indicated that only I 00 of a total of 4000
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(2017) 12 S.C.R.
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
907
A
Central Govt. websites were being made accessible. It is
therefore, clear that only a very small percentage of Central
and State Govt, websites are being made accessible and then
too no timeframes have been given. With regard to the
public documents' and TV programmes, mere advisories
have been issued to the private and public broadcasters and
to the Govt, departments for making their programmes and
their documents accessible but no timeframe have been
mandated for the same. More significantly, there is no plan
for either the Central or State Govts, to audit the
accessibility features of websites. Documents and TV
programmes after the accessibility work had been
completed. It is iri this contest that the Petitioner reiterates
the directions sought under this target.
9
The Harmonised Guidelines being the repository for all the
accessibility guidelines m the built environment,
transportation and information and communication, the
same should be regularly updated keeping in view the
provisions of the 2016 Act and technological advancements,
vis-a-vis the needs of persons with disabilities and further
any work on accessibility should be done and fully audited
with respect to the updated Harmonised Guidelines.
.
LO
As per the information available with the Petitioner, in the
NADVs. UOI matter, the estimation made by the RCI of the
number of sign language interpreters required was only for
Delhi but did not cover the rest of India. It is reiterated that
Sign Language Interpreters (SL's) arc required at all major
places where communication and dealing with the public in
both the public and private sector take place. This will cover
railway stations, major bus depots, hospitals, airports, major
govt, offices banks, large private sector offices, shopping
malls, large education institutions and the like. Compliance
with the mandate of Section 40, 41, 42 and 46 of the 2016
Act read with Section2 (f), i.e. definition of
"Communication" to include sign language would require a
large number of SLI's to be trained and available across the
country by June 2019 and the figure of 100 SLI's quoted
by the UOI would be highly inadequate to meet this
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
908
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
A
I0
B
requirement. Therefore, the Petitioner reiterates the
directions sought that RCI be directed to make reasonable
estimation of the number of SLI's required in India and
thereafter for the UOl and all States and lJT's to make
adequate arrangements to train and make available 500
SLl's every year until the target of the estimated SLI's in
the country is met.
28. From the foregoing discussion, following pertinent aspects can
be discerned:
c
D
E
a. Ten action points which are enumerated by the petitioner, for
providing proper access to public facilities to the persons
suffering from visually disability, are now statutorily recognised
under the Disabilities Act, 2016. To put it straight, the
Legislature has east a duty on the executive wing for making
provisions in this behalf. This legal position is accepted by the
Union oflndia in its affidavit dated August 23, 2017. In this
affidavit, the respondent had itself mentioned various
provisions under the Disabilities Act, 2016 which mandate
the respondents to make provisions for these facilities. Not
only this, such provisions even specified the deadlines for
undertaking these measures. Thus. it becomes a statutory
obligation on the part of the Central Government as well as
the State Governments to do the needful by the target dates.
b. Though, Central Government has taken various measures,
many State Governments have not responded at all.
F
G
c. In Justice Sunanda Bhandare Foundation case as well,
this Court has given various directions from time to time. In ·
its order dated April 25, 2017, the States as well as Union
Territories are directed to comply with the provisions of
Disabilities Act, 2016 and to report to the Court about the ·
progress made by them in this behalf. The Court is, thus,
monitoring the progress in this behalf in the said writ petition.
Having regard to the aforesaid position emerging on
record, we dispose of these petitions with the following
directions:
H
RAJIVE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
i.
ii.
Making 20-50 imuortant government buildings in
50 cities fulll'. accessible December 2017 (State
Govt. Buildings)
Since, this deadline is set by the AIC itself, this should
be met. In any case, as per the provisions of Section 46
of the Disabilities Act, 2016, all Government buildings
providing any services to the public are to be made fully
accessible by June, 2019 which has to be adhere to.
Making 50% of all the govt. buildings of the national
cauital and all the state cauitals fullI accessible bl'.
December 2018.
Though the deadline for identifying the buildings was
fixed as February 28, 2017, according to status report
dated August 8, 2017, only seven States have identified
the buildings. Remaining States arc directed to identify
the buildings by February 28, 2018 and it is made clear
that no further time in this behalf shall be granted. Insofar
as deadline for retrofitting is concerned, the work should
be completed by December, 2018.
iii. Co111uletin11; accessibilitI audit of 50% of' ii;ovt.
buildings and making them fullI accessible in 10
most imuortant cities/towns of states/UTs not
covered in targets (i} and {ii} bl'. December 2019.
Position regarding this action point is the same as noted
in respect of action point 2, namely, only seven States
have submitted theirlist of l 0 most important cities/towns
and not a single building has been identified so far. The
States are, therefore, directed to identify 10 most
important cities/towns and complete accessibility audit
of 50% of Government buildings in these cities/towns
by February 28, 2018. Likewise, retrofitting of these be
completed by December 2019 as per the revised deadline
set out by CCC.
iv.
909
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
Central Govt. buildings.
Having regard to the comments given by the petitioner
in its affidavit dated August 23, 2017 on this aspect, time
frame ofAugust, 2018 is given for completing this target.
H
910
SUPREME COURI REPORTS
A
v.
B
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
Accessibility in airports. Completing accessibility
audit of all the international airports and making
them fully accessible ltv December 2016.
The demand of the petitioner that Civil Aviation
Ministry should follow the prescribed template i.e. IIT
Roorkce template on the Government website appears
to be justified' which should be implemented as
expeditiously as possible. The Union of India should
thereafter conduct the accessibility and audit and upload
the same on the website by June, 2018.
c
vi. Accessibility in Railways. Ministry of Railwavs was
required to make all Al, A and B category railway
stations fully accessible by July 2016. 50% of all
railway stations to made fully accessible bv March
2018.
D
As is clear from the affidavit dated June 30, 2017 filed
by the petitioner, as many as 12 directions are sought
under this action point. Insofar as providing of various
facilities in the railway stations arc concerned, which
are listed by the petitioner, there cannot be any dispute
that the Indian railways is statutorily obligated to make
those provisions. The petitioner has, however, sought
time bound directions for providing such facilities.
Wherever the provisions of the Disabilities Act, 2016
prescribe the deadlines, the respondent is to provide those
facilities within those time framework. Insofar as other
facilities arc concerned, in respect ofwhich the petitioner
wants those facilities by specified period, we are not
fixing such a period. Instead, we direct that the
appropriate/competent authority in the railways shall
make an assessment in this behalf so as to ascertain as
to by what date(s) these facilities will be provided. Such
a study can be undertaken and exercise be completed
within a period of three months and report in that behalf
shall be filed in the Court, chalking out the progressive
plan.
E
F
G
H
RAJNE RATURI v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
[A. K. SIKRI, J.]
vii. 10% of government owned public transport carriers
are to be made fully accessible by March 2018.
Here again, Section 41 of the Disabilities Act, 2016
provides for comprehensive accessibility in all modes of
transport including but not remitted to the bus transport.
Therefore, it becomes the duty of the Union, States as
well as Union Territories to ensure that all Government
buses are disabled friendly in accordance with the
Harmonized Guidelines. Likewise, the respondents are
duty bound to see that private buses also become disabled
friendly. Thus, we direct the Government to Jay down
the plan giving the dates by which the aforesaid task
shall be undertaken, keeping in view the directions which
are sought by the petitioner in this behalf and the same
shall be filed within three months.
viii. Comprehensive revision of target deadliness under
accessibility of knowledge and JCT Ecosystem. At
least 50% of central and state govt. websites are
to meet accessibilitv standards by March 2017. At
least 50% of the public documents are to meet
accessibility standards bv March 2018.
On this action point, the petitioner has sought five
directions. Again, there cannot be any dispute that such
provisions have to be made as Disabilities Act, 2016 itself
mandates that. The only question is about the time
schedule. On certain aspects, AIC had itself mentioned
the target date. In any case, let there be a study
undertaken in this behalf as well by the Union oflndia
and report be filed within three months stating as to by
what date(s) compliance shall be made.
ix. Bureau of Indian Standards to embed disability
aspect in all relevant parts of revised National
Building Code.
91 l
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
It is expected that the respondents would regularly
update the Harmonized Guidelines keeping in view the
provisions of Disabilities Act, 2016 and technological
H
912
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
advancement vis-a-vis the needs of persons with
·disabilities.
x.
The target of training additional 200 sign language
interpreters by March 2018.
Needful be done in this behalf as well within reasonable
time and the Government is directed to file an affidavit
within threemonths stating the time period within which
the same can be accomplished.
B
xi. As per the provisions of Sections 60 and 66 of the
Disabilities Act, 2016, all States and Union Territories
are required to constitute the Central and State Advisory
Boards. In order to effectively implement the provisions
of the said Act, it becomes the duty of the States and
Union Territories to constitute such Advisory Boards.
Therefore, we direct these Advisory Boards to be
constituted by all States and Union Territories within a
period of three months from today.
c
D
E
[2017] 12 S.C.R.
29. Matter be listed for directions after three months on receiving
reports in terms of the aforesaid order. In the reports to be filed, the
respondents shall also state the follow-up action taken during _the
intervening period in the meantime.
Nidhi Jain
Petition disposed of.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org