DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 30 November 2017 | [2017] 13 S.C.R. 508 | 2017 INSC 1159
Key facts
- Decided
- 30 November 2017
- Bench
- MADAN B. LOKUR*, DEEPAK GUPTA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 295/2012
- Disposal
- Directions issued
- Citation
- [2017] 13 S.C.R. 508
- Neutral citation
- 2017 INSC 1159
Text of the judgment
(2017] 13 S.C.R. 508
A
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II)
V.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
(Writ Petition (Civil) No. 295 of2012)
B
NOVEMBER30, 2017
[MAl)AN B. LOKUR AND DEEPAK GUPTA, JJ.]
c
D
Constitution of India: Art. 32 - Public interest litigation Prayer seeking enforcement of road safety norms and appropriate
treatment of accident victims - Constillltion of Committee on road
safety - Submission of report/recommendations by the Committee Howeve1; non-implementation of the recommendations by the
Government ~ Issuance of directions on road safety and the victims
of road accidents by Supreme Court - Directions as regard road
safety policy, road safety fimd, road safety action plan. road safety
audits, road safety cell, road safety equipment and road safety
education issued - Faithful and sincere compliance of the said
directions would save thousands of lives in road accident and crores
of rupees paid in compensation by the insurance companies.
Issuing directions, the Court
E
F
G
HELD: 1.1 In view of the submissions of the Amicus Curiae
and the response of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways
(MoRTH) to the suggestions and keeping in mind issues of road
safety and the interest of those who may be unfortunate victims
of road accidents, the following directions arc issued:
(i) Road Safety Policy: Most of the State Governments and
Union Territories have already framed a Road Safety
Policy. Those that have not framed such a policy namely
Assam, Nagaland, Tripura, Delhi, Lakshadweep, Dadra and
Nagar Havcli and Andaman and Nicobar Islands, to
formulate the Road Safety Policy by 31" January, 2018.
All States and Union Territories are expected to implement
the Road Safety Policy with all due earnestness and
seriou~sness.
H
(ii) State Road Safety Council: All States have already
constituted a Road Safety Council in terms of Section 215
508
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
509
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The Union Territories of A
Daman and Dlu, Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Andaman
and Nicobar Islands have not constituted the Road Safety
Council as yet. These Union Territories are directed to
constitute the State Road Safety Council on or before 31"
January, 2018. The responsibility and functions of the B
Council would be as recommended by the Committee on
Road Safety. The State Road Safety Councils should
periodically review the laws and take appropriate remedial
steps wherever necessary.
(iii) Lead Agency: Only a few States have established the
Lead Agency as recommended by the Committee on Road C
Safety in its communication of 23'' December, 2014. The
States and Union Territories that have not done so should
establish the Lead Agency on or before 31" January, 2018
in terms of the recommendations made by the Committee
on Road Safety. The Lead Agency would act as the D
Secretariat of the State Road Safety Council and coordinate
all activities such as licensing issues including issues of
driving licences, registration of vehicles, road safety and
features of vehicles, along with other allied matters
including emission norms and other activities as mentioned
E
· in the communication dated 23.12.2014.
(iv) Road Safety Fund: Some of the States have already
established a Road Safety Fund. Those·States and Union
Territories that have not yet established the Road Safety
Fund sl;.cu 1'! do so not later than 31" March, 2018 and
report back to the Committee on Road Safety. The corpus
of the Road Safety Fund woul~ be from the fines collected
for traffic violations and the Fund would be utilized for
meeting expenses relating to road safety.
F
(v) Road Safety Action Plan: The purpose of a Road Safety
Action Plan is to reduce .the number of road accidents, as G
well as the fatality rate. The MoRTH has already requested
all the States and Union Territories to prepare a Road
Safety Action Plan but It appears that the response to this
has been somewhat lukewarm. The State Governments
and Union Territories are therefore directed to urgently H
510
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
prepare a Road Safety Action Plan by 31.03.2018 and pnt
it int11 action after giving it due publicity.
(vi) District Road Safety Committee: A District Road Safety
Committee is required to be set up by the State
Government for every district in terms of Section 215(3)
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. As suggested by the
Amicus and agreed to by the MoRTH, the District Road
Safety Committee should be put in place by 31" January,
2018 and should be headed by the Collector of the District
and should include amongst others the Superintendent of
Police, Health Officers, Engineers of the Public Works
Department, representatives of the National Highways
Authority of India, the Road Transport Officer of the
District and members of civil society from the District.
The District Road Safety Committee must hold regular
and periodic meetings to review road safety issues and
take corrective measures.
(vii) Engineering Improvement: It appears that one of the
main reasons for road accidents is the poor quality of roads,
impr(jper design, etc. The MoRTH is of the opinion that
the protocol for road design and identification of black
spots needs to be reviewed and enforced. Accordingly, it
is directed that the MoRTH should publish a protocol for
identification and rectification of black spots and take
necessary steps for improving the design of roads to make
them safe.
(viii) Traffic Calming Measures: It is suggested by the
Amicus that traffic calming measures must be adopted at
accident prone areas. This is agreed to by the MoRTH.
However, such measures will need to be studied and then
put in place. This is an on-going exercise which must be
carried out by the Road Safety Committee with the
assistance of the MoRTH and other stakeholders.
(ix) Road Safety Audits: It is directed that necessary steps
be taken by the Committee on Road Safety as well as by
the Mi>RTH to work in the direction of Road Safety Audits
since there can be little doubt that an audit of road safety
H
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
is "essential to reduce the possibility of road accidents
through corrective measures.
(x) Engineering Design of New Roads: The Road Safety
Audit should include the design stage audit of new road
projects of 5 kms or more, rather than being based on the
cost of the project.
511
A
B
(XI) Working Group on Engineering: The recommendations
of the Working Group on Engineering (Roads) should be
implemented in the terms prayed for by the Amie us as well
as those accepted by the MoRTH. These would, of course,
be in the nature of interim directions since the National
Road Safety Board is likely to be created as proposed in
the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Bill, 2017.
c
(xii) Drivers' Training: This is the subject matter of the
Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Bill, 2017 and no orders
are required to be passed in this regard.
D
(xiii) Lane Driving: The MoRTH has already issued Motor
Vehicles (Driving) Regulations, 2017 vide GS.R. 634 (E)
dated 23'• June, 2017. The Notification should be
implemented by the State Governments and Union
Territories strictly.
E
(xiv) Road Safety Equipment: The Bureau of Police
Research and Training has already prepared a Report on
the. subject and has submitted it to the Road Safety
Committee in September, 2015. The recommendations in
the Report should be implemented including acquisition
of cameras and surveillance equipments in detecting traffic
and identifying violators. It is also necessary to set up
special patrol forces along the National Highways and State
Highways for which necessary steps must be taken by the
State Governments and Union Territories.
(xv) Alcohol and Road Safety: The MoR.TH has already
written to the States to comply with orders of this Court in
this regard. The MoRTH may issue further advisories in
this regard on a quarterly basis during the calendar year 2018
so as to serve as a reminder to the State Governments
F
G
H
r
512
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
and Union Territories to implement the directions of this
Court.
.,
B
(2017) 13 S.C.R.
(xvi) Road Safety Education: The Amic11s as well as
MoRTH are in agreement that road safety education and
counselling should be incorporated in the curricu)um by
the State Boards by 1" April, 2018. It is directed that the
State Governments may seriously consider this
recommendation and Include Road Safety Education and
Counseling as a part of the school curriculum at the
earliest,
c
(xvii) Sj>eed Governors: Guidelines in this regard have
already been issued by the MoRTH. The MoRTH has
agreed to upload the Unique Identification Number of the
speed governors in the VAHAN database. This should be
followed up by the MoRTH with expedition.
D
(xviii) Emergency Medical Care: There is agreem< nt that
at least one Trauma Care Centre should be set up in every
district with necessary facilities and an ambulance. The
State Governments and Union Territories should take up
this recommendation at the earliest since it is on record
that treatment soon after a road accident is crucial fur
saving tl1e life of the victim. The directions Issued in PL
Pormana,nd Kotara v. Union of India should be followed.
E
F
G
H
(xix) Unlvers11l Accident Helpline Number: The MoRTH
has stated that there is already a call centre number, that
is, 108 provided by the National Health Mission. Due
publicity must be given to this so that an ambulance can
he activated at the earliest whenever necessary.
(xx) Permanent Road Safety Cell: All State Governments
and Union Territories have already been requested by the
MoRTH to set up Road Safety Cells. The State
Governments and Union Territories should establish
Permanent Road Safety Cells by 31" January, 2018.
(xxi) Data Collection: The MoRTH bas already taken
steps for recording accident data and reports through
computerjsed data entry. The State and Union Territories
have been asked to take further action in this regard and
DR. S. RAJASEEK.ARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
make the data public for the information of all stakeholders.
This needs to be followed up and no further orders are
necessary in this regard.
(xxii) GPS : The MoRTH has already notified vide GS.R.
No. 1095 (E) dated 28" November, 2016 mandating the
fitment of vehicle location tracking devices in all public
service vehicles subject to some exceptions. Since this
has cost implications, the MoRTH may assist the State
Governments and Union Territories to ensure that to the
maximum extent possible and within the shortest time
frame, location tracking devices must be fitted in all public
service vehicles as notified.
(xxiii) Bus/Truck-Body Building Code: This has already
been notified by the MoRTH with regard to buses vide
GS.R. No. 287 (E) dated 27 1• April, 2014 and with regard
to trucks vide GS.R. No. 1034(E) dated 2•• November,
2016. No further orders are necessary in this regard.
(xxiv) ABS, Air Bags and Headlights: The MoRTH has
already notified for fitment of ABS in motor cycles vide
GS.R. No. 310(E) dated 16'" March, 2016 and for four
wheelers vide GS.R. No. 120(E) dated tolh February, 2017.
As far as air bags are concerned a standard AIS-145 has
already been notified. As regards automated headlights,
the MoRTH has notified vide GS.R. No. 188(E) dated 22••
February, 2016 for fitment of"Automated Headlights On"
in two wheelers manufactured on or after 1" April, 2017.
No further orders are required in. this regard except the
·faithful implementation of the various notifications issued
by the MoRTH.
(xxv) Crash Test: This too has been notified by the
MoRTH and the test for all light motor vehicles is required
to be conducted by the testing agency notified under Rule
126 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989. No further
orders are required in this regard except the faithful
implementation of the notifications and crash standards
issued by the MoRTH. (Para 17] [535-A-H; 536-A-H;
537-A-H; 538-A-H; 539-A-H; 540-A-C]
513
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
514
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
1.2 The directions given are those that have been agreed
upon by the parties and are in addition to and supplement the
directions already given in S.Rajaseekaran v. Union of India. The
said directions at the instance of the A111ic11s C11riae and the Justice
K.S. Radhakrishnan Committee on Road Safety and with the
support, cooperation and assistance of the MoRTH, would save
thousands of lives in road accidents and crores of rupees in
compensatioll payable by the insurance companies-provided the
directions ar~ faithfully and sincerely complied with. If there is
any doubt or ~larity required in implementing the directions given,
the concerned State Government or Union Territory is at liberty
to move the Committee on Road Safety. [Paras 18, 19) (540-D-FJ
Pt. Parmanand Katara v. Union of India (1989) 4 SCC
286 : (1989) 3 SCR 997; S.Rajaseekaran v. Union of
India (2014) 6 SCC 36: (2014) 5 SCR 444 - referred
to.
D
Case Law Reference
[1989] 3 SCR 997
[2014] 5 SCR 444
E
referred to
referred to
Para 17
Para 18
ORIGINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil)
No. 295 of2012.
Under Article 32 of the Constitution oflndia.
F
G
H
P. S. Narr-asimha, ASG, D.K. Thakur, S.S. Shamshery, AAGs,
Gopal Subramanium (AC), Ajit Kumar Sinha, Sr. Advs., Gaurav Agarwal,
(AC), Talha Abdul Rahman, Jayavardhan Singh, Pavan Bhushan, Manoj
Swamp, Ms. Lalita Kohli, Sajid Imam Naqvi (for Mis Manoj Swarup &
Co.), Krishna Kumar, B. Vinodh Kanna, Ms. Srujana Suman Mund,
S.S. Ray, GS. Makker, Surinder S. Rathi, S. L. Gupta, Rajesh Sharma,
Rajeev Gupta, Ms. Shalu Sharma, Mahabir Singh Mangla, Varinder
Kumar Sharma, M.K. Thakur, Rajesh K. Sharma, Ms. Prerna Mehta,
Dipak K. Nag, Ekansh Bansal, Parmanand Gaur, Bhupesh Narula, K. V.
Jagdishvaran, Ms. G. Indira, Guntur Prabhakar, Ms. Prerna Singh, Gopal
Singh, Shreyas Jain, Ms. Ruchira Gupta, Ms. Mona Sinha, Ms. Surabhi
Mehta, Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Ms. Jesal Wahi, Ms. Puja Singh, Ms.
Shodhika Sharma, Samar Vijay Singh, Ms. Monika Gosain, Shariq Ahmed,
Varindcr Kumar Sharma, M. Shoeb Alam, Ms. Fauzia Shakil, Ujjwal
Singh, Mojahid Karim Khan, Tapesh Kumar Singh, Mohd. Waquas,Aditya
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
515
Pratap Singh, Ms. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Nishant R. Katneshwarkar,
R. Leishangthem Roshmani KH, Ranjan Mukherjee, Naveen Sharma,
Mishra Saurabh, Mrs. K. Enatoli Serna, Edward Belho,Amit Kr. Singh,
K. Luikang Michael. Z.H. Issac Haiding, V. G. Pragasam, S. Prabu
Ramasubramanian, Manuraj, Amit Sharma, Sandeep Singh, Anidt Raj,
Ms. Indira Bhakar, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Ms. Aruna Mathur, Avneesh
Arputham, Ms. Anuradha Arputham, Ms. Simran Jeet (For Mis Arputham
Aruna & Co.), S. Udaya Kumar Sagar, Mrityunjai Singh, Gopal Singh,
Rituraj Biswas, Raja Chatterjee, C.K, Ganguli, Piyush Sachdev,
P. K. Manohar, Ms. Manjeet Chawla, Dr. (Mrs.) Vipin Gupta, Neelesh
Singh Rao, Saurabh Kirpal, Ms. Jaikriti S. Jadeja,Advs. for the appearing
parties.
A
B
C
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
MADAN B. LOKUR, J. 1. In this petition under Article 32 of
the Constitution Dr. S. Rajaseekaran, an orthopaedic surgeon, a public
spirited citizen and President of the Indian Orthopaedic Association has,
inter alia, prayed for enforcement of road safety norms and appropriate
treatment of accident victims.
2. The petitioner states that in his capacity as Chairman and Head
of Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Ganga Hospital, Coimbatore, he
witnesses daily, the acute loss oflife and limbs caused by road accidents.
He suggests that practical measures need to be taken in a time-bound
and expeditious manner to give effect to legislations, reports and
recommendations for ensuring that the loss oflives due to road accidents
is minimized. The petitioner estimates that 90% of the problem of deaths
due to road accidents is the result of a lack of strict enforcement of
safety rules on_roads and strict punishment for those who do not obey
rules. The petitioner has relied upon data published in l)ecember 2011
by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways in its publication
captioned 'Road Accidents in India 201 O' to indicate that the number of
road accidents is increasing every year and that unfortunately more than
half the victims are in the economically active age group of25-65 years.
3. Since the petitioner has no pernonal interest in the matter, the
writ petition filed by him was taken up as a public interest litigation.
4. Initially, the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways opposed
the writ petition but as the litigation progressed, the matter was looked at
in a non-adversarial manner and considered as one in public interest.
D
E
F
G
H
516
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[201'1] 13 S.C.R.
5. In view of the non-adversarial stance of the Government of
India, this Court passed an order on 22'd April, 2014 constituting a
Committee on Road Safety under the Ciiamnanship of Justice K. S.
Radhakrishnan, a former judge of this Court. The Committee was
notified by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) of
the Government ct idiu "" 30th May, 2014 and orders finalizing the
terms anti co!'ditlons of appointment of the Chairperson and Members
of the Committee were issued on 8th August, 2014.
6. In compliance with the orders of this Court and notwithstanding
bureaucratic delays and without having been provided adequate
infrastructure and staff, the Committee commenced its work in earnest
from I5lh/16'h May, 2014. The Committee has since submitted 12 reports
to this Court but it is not necessary at present to deal with all these reports.
7. On JO<h April, 2015 we recognized the exemplary work being
done by the Committee and expressed the view that its recommendations
need to be seriously discussed and debated. This was in the context of
the fact that the number of deaths due to road accidents in the country
was said to be over I 00,000 in a year, which translates to about one
death every three minutes and that the compensation awarded for deaths
and other motor accident claims runs into hundreds of crores of rupees.
8. However, it appeared to us that various State Governments
were not responding positively to the recommendations made by the
Committee and accordingly the Secretary of the MoRTH was directed
to call a meeting of his counterparts from all the States and Union
Territories on or before 31" May, 2015 to deliberate on the reports
prepared by the Committee as well as its recommendations, their
implementation and further measures that could be taken.
9. We also noted that despite the lapse of a considerable period
of time, the Government of India was unable to provide adequate facilities
to the Committee even though a letter was sent by the learned Attorney
General for India on 19th December, 2014 to the Revenue Secretary and
the Urban Development Secretary of the Government oflndia. We are
mentioning this fact only to highlight the casualness with which the
Government of India was takingthe directions of this Court, in spite of
the importance of the work being carried out by the Committee and its
non-adverserial stance. We may mention here that as of now, we have
been informed that the Committee has been provided with all necessary
facilities and support by the Government of India.
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR. J.]
517
I 0. In the hearing on 26"' August, 2016 we noted that in 2014 the
numberof persons who had died in road accidents was 139,671 and that
this figure had jumped up in 2015 to 146,133.
A
11. Since we were informed by Mr. Gaurav Agrawal, Advocate
who was requested to assist us as Amicus Curiae that the State
Governments were still not cooperating with the Committee, we had no
option but to again direct the Transport Secretaries of all States to attend
a meeting to be convened by the Secretary of the MoRTH on 7'h
September, 2016. We had to, perforce, set the agenda for the meeting,
that is, implementation of the recommendations of the Committee, keeping
in mind the very large number of deaths taking place.
12. On J9th September, 2016 we noted that in the meeting chaired
by the Secretary of the MoRTH convened on 2"" September, 2016 (instead
of 7"' September, 2016) only two or three Secretaries of the concerned
Transport Ministries of the State Governments had participated and the
rest of the State Governments were represented by junior officials and
in some cases even the designation of these junior. officials was not
mentioned.
B
c
D
13. During this hearing, we sought to impress upon all concerned
that road safety issues should be taken seriously both by the Central
Government as well as by the State Governments. We also noted that
huge amounts running into hundreds of crores of rupees had been
earmarked for road safety and it was also highlighted that a very large
number of deaths had been taking place due to road accidents. We noted
that the insurance companies had spent an amount of Rs. 11,480 crores
by way of compensation for deaths, injuries, third party property damage
and other damage due to road accidents during the financial year 2015-16.
E
F
14. On 7"' November, 2016 we again noted that there was one
death almost every three minutes as a result of road accidents.
Unfortunately, the legal heirs of half the victims were not compensated
(perhaps being unaware of their entitlement). We expressed our distress
at this unfortunate situation and had to remind all concerned that we
were not dealing with an adversarial issue but a public interest litigation
for the benefit of the common man particularly for the victims of road
accidents and their legal heirs.
15. On 11th April, 2017 we were informed by the learned Amicus
that the Government of India had woken up to the problems faced due
G
H
518
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
to road accidents and had prepared a Bill for the amendment of the
Motor Vehicles A.ct, 1988.
16. Thereiifter, the learned Amicus prepared a chart in three
columns: First, relating to the issues that this Court had been dealing
with in this public interest litigation; second the views expressed by the
MoRTH on these issues, and third, the orders prayed for by the learned
Amicus Curiae. A perusal of the chart indicates that fortunately, the
Government oflndia has now begun considering the issues raised in the
right spirit and in a non-adversarial manner and has accepted almost all
the suggestions. Those that form a part of the Bill seeking to amend the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 will be considered by Parliament. The tabular
statement is given below:
s.
D
No.
i.
E
F
G
H
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
Vi cws by Ministry of
Road Transport &
Highways
Orders prayed by
the AC
Road
Safety Ministry
of
Road
Policy: E~ery State Trausport & Highways
(Jovernmc)1t shall is in agreen1ent with the
i1nple1ncnt
State suggestion.
Road Safety Policy
formulated as a All die States/UTs
result
of
the except Assam, Dellli,
intervention of the Nagaland.
Tripura,
Comtnittee on Road Lakshadweep,
Dadra
Safety. The said Nagar
Haveli
aud
Policy 1nay be I Andaman & Nicobar
notified
in
the 1 h:ivc
already
gazette and brought formulated their Road
into existence w.e.f. Safety Policy.
l"
September, l11e States I UTs which
2017. if not already have not formulated the
done so.
Road Safety Policy.
have been requested to
formulate the policy on
priority basis.
Order Proposed:
The States I UTs
Issue contained in
note of Amicus
Curiae
which have not
formulated
the
Road Safety Policy
may be directed to
formulate
the
policy on priority
basis. latest by 31 si
December
2017.
The
staten1ent
1nade
by
the
Goven1ment
of
India 1nay kindly
be taken on record
and ordered.
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.)
ii
iii.
Slare
Road
Safety
Omncil:
All
State
Glvernment
(except
Nlgaland) have cmstituted
State Road Satay Council
as required under Section
215 of tl1e Mater Vdticles
Ac~ 1988 and. dirocted by
the Comnittee. The said
Cootx:il trust undertake
pericx:lC n1eetings to review
the
actions
and
in"Planentation of road
safety lav.s and submit
suitable reports to the
oot'l'etent Jegishture and
the Committee m Road
Safety.
Lead Agency: Eadt State
Glvernment
nny
be
directed to ~tablish a Lead
Agency as raiuired by tlie
Committee on Road Safety
headed by a senior officer
and with aci:quate slaff to
be solely dedicated to
rratters
rehting
to
ticmsing issuing of driving
licmces, an:l registration of
vehicles, rood safety, and
fuatures
of
vehicles,
l"nution and otl1er allied
ITBtters.
Ministiy
of
Road
Transport & Highway.; is
in agreerrent with the
suggestiott All States I
Ufs except Damm &
Diu, O.dra Nagar Haveli
and Andamm & Ni:chrr
have already cmstituted
State
Road
Safety
Councils.
519
Onler proposed: All
States I urs except
Damm & Diu, Dadra
Nagar Haveli and
Atxlamm & Nicobar
have
already
constituted State Road
Safety Councils. The
at hers may be directed
the
Fe\\'
States
viz.
Chhattis!l'fh, Drumn &
Diu, Haryana, Jharkhatxl,
JanlITll
& Ka<ilunir,
Nagaland,
Raj8'1han,
Tani! Nadu rave ab-mdy
established the Lead
Agoncy.
B
to corlititute tm sarne
as
per
the
rocou1nerxiations of
Ministiy
of
Road
TraIBpOrt & Highways is
1n agreenllnt with the
suggestion
Ministiy hdd review
m:eting with the States to
review
tre
inplen'l!ntation of th!
d~ections
of
the
Comnittee oo Road
Safety from 21' to
3o''June, 2017. The
States I Ufs wa:e
requested to establish
lead Agency and depute
addjuate, dedicated and
professional I technical
:.taff.
A
Comnittee
C
on
Road Safety.
The
Statement nnde by the
Govemm:nt of India
nny kindly be taken
on rocord and ordered.
Onler
proposed:
The States I UTs that
have not established
Lead Agetx:y, as
definal atxl required
by the Committee on
Road Safety and
aci:quate,
depute
d<rlicated
and
profess ion al
I
techniral staff tray be
directed to do so by
31" Dxember 2017 as
per the Slandards set
by tl>e Conrnittee on
Road Safety. The
statanent trade by the
Govemrrent of India
may kindly be taken
on ra:ord and crdered
D
E
F
G
•y
t.
520
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
A
iv
B
c
D
E
F
' Road Safety Fund:
. Pursuart
to
reconnrendatioll'l
of the Ccrnnittee
on Rood Saftty all
the States have
oomneooed
er
00111lleted actim to
set up
a Road
Safuty Fund wth
aSfillred flow of
rrooey as des ired
by fui Committee.
H:iwever, in such
States \\h:re it res
oot ccrne into place
it mll'lt come into
effect w.e.f. 1•
Septcn::ber 201 7.
v
0
G
H
Order Prqiosed:
The States /UTs
that
rove not
cmstituted
tbe
Road Safety Finl
tray be directed to
establish the same
as soon as poSS!ble
an1 not later than
March, 2018 an1
report
to
tbe
Comnittee
on
Road Safuty. The
statemait trade by
the Government of
ln:lia rmy kin:lly
be takai on record
an1 erd:red.
-.. -----+--~-----+ ---·-··--··-----t
Safety
Action Han: State
Cbvennnents tray
be directed to
fi:onulate
and
notify "Road Safety
Action Plan" with
an anrrual targii fer
reducing
rood
acx:1der< ";~ ffect
frcrn a date rnx
later
than
1"
Septerrber 201 7.
Road
Ministty of Road
Trall'lpcrt & Highway.s
is in agreanent with tbe
suggestion
Some of the States viz.
Bihar,
Chhittisg;irh,
Hirnachal
Pradesh,
Jharkhand,
Kerab,
MadhY<t
Praresh,
Pududierry, Rajasthm,
Uttar Pradesh have
establisred dalicated
fund as per directioll'l
of Conrnittee on Road
Safety.
During the review
meeting beld by tbe
Ministty, tbe rermining
States I Ufs rove been
requested to create tbe
Rood Safcty Fund as
per the directims oftbe
Ccmnittee m Road
Safety.
Ministty of Road
Trarnpcrt & Highway.s
is in agreement with tbe
suggestion
During the review
meetings held by tre
Ministty, the States I
UTs
rove
been
requested to prerme the
arnrn.l target based
Action Plan to raluce
accident & fatality rate
in
pursuance
of
directioll'l
of
Comnittee on Road
Safetv.
Onler Prqiosed:
The States I UTs
tray be directed to
prei:are the amual
tar!}'t rused Action
Plan to raluce
accidert & fatality
rate in µirsuanee of
directicns
of
Conrnittee
on
Road Sarety an1
the repcrt to the
Committee.
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
District Road Safety
Committee: All State
Govenunents tnay be
directed to constitute
District Road Safety
Canmittee headed by the
Collector of the District
which will fix target' for
reduction in accidents and
fatality dependent upon
peculiar facts of the
District As suggested in
the \vritten Note, District
Road Safety Committee
could
include
Superintendent of Police,
Health Officers, PWD
Engineers, repr~entati\es
of NHAJ and RTO of tl1e
District
vii
of Road
&
Highwa1s
is
in
agreement with the
suggestion.
Ministry
Tran~-port
Order proposed: State
Govemnients n1ay be
directed to constitute
District Road Safety
Committee 1-,,aded by
tl1e Collector of tl1e
District as soon as
pa;sible
lay down
respcmsibilities of said
corrnnittees. including
regular and periodic
n1eeting and report to the
Committee on Road
Saft1y. The statemm
made
by
the
Govemtnent of indi a
may kindly be taken on
reccrd and ordered.
A
B
c
D
Engineering
The Ministry is in Order
Impro\'ement:
The
Aniicus Curia? submits
that one of the nnin
reasons for accidents is
poor quality of roads,
ilnproper
design,
inadequate
curve,
inadequate depth and
ina:iequate angle which
need to be maintained at
crocial junctions. At the
inS:an<.-e
of
the
Con1n1ittee on Road
Safety. the MoRTH has
set up rrntocol for
identification
and
agreement \vith the
·suggestion. l-Towever.
the protocol has to be
reviewed and updated
fro1n time to tin1e
l:ased
on
the
experience ~ined.
rectification of black
spots. TI1e said protocol
for rectifying black SjX)ts
for better road s:ifety is
annexOO herewith as
521
~-·
proposed:
Prctocol
for
Identification
and
Rectification of Black
Spots
prepared by
MoRTI-1 at the instance
of Cormnittee on Road
Safety lllaY be directed
to be in1Jlemented by all
concerned
including
NHAJ
and •State
GO"\.en1rnents
in
consultation with the
C'..onnnittee on Road
Safety.
lt may be clarified that
E
F
G
the said protocol would
be reviewed and updated
by MoRTH armual ly
based on the experience
giined.
H
522
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I
Annexure 'B' pages (28
to 29). This Hon'ble
Court may be pleased to
direct that the :san-.e be
enforced into i1runediatc
effect by the NHAl, the
Ministry
of
Road
Transron & High""y.; of
Government of India as
I
I
B
I
The statement made by
the Government of India
may kindly be taken on
Ireead and crdered.
well
"' the PWD
Dqiantrents of all State I'
Govennnerts as \vell
their contractors. It is i
important that the saire is
also enforced in all
1
express\vays
being
constructed on PPP 1ncxC.
c
D
I
I
I
Traffic
Calming Ministry of Road Order proposed: This
i\tleasures: This Hon'ble Trrut'ip()rt
& Hon'ble Court may
Court 1my further direct HighW<ly.;
is
in . direct that the State
the State Govem111ents to I agree1nent \.\-ith the Governments
should
adopt Traffic Ca!mmg suggesnoo.
1 a<hpt Traffic Calming
M~ures at accklcrt
Me.asures at accident
prone m;cas. jrn1ctirns of
prore area<>, junctions of
lower hierarchy roads and~
lower hierarchy roads
with higher hierarchy
other wlnemblc spcts
road;
and other
~t~e scl\ools, hospitals.
vulrerable spcts like
schools, lxi;pitals etc.,
1
) aOO subrnit district wise
C001Jliancc repocts to
the Conmittce on Road
I
E
I
I
I
I
F
I
,
I
I
'
1
L-.
H
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
l
[
__
_
_
I
ISafety, as per the
directions
of
the
; Committee on periodic
I~ Theby ;tatm':
IGovem1nent of India
lllaY kindly be takt.'tl on
_j_ ____~rec_oc_d_and_cr_dered_._ _
i'
DR. S. RA.TASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
523
A
ix
Roods Safety Audits: ln-}rinciple,
the Order p~sed: This
This Hon'blc OJurt llllY Ministry
JS
in Hon'ble (hurt imy be
direct State Governirenls agreerrenl with the pleased to direct the
to cany 01.t rood safety suggestioo. Ho'.\ever, Central Government to:
audit< during design, there is a deficiency (i)
Chn:!uct audit of
eonstructioo
and cf qualifioo audilcrs 2 nllSI at'Cident prone
operation of roo:Is and in
road
safely stretcfles
of
also in respect of existing eqiineering in die highw.iys/expressw.iys
roods within a srccificd oomby. Effcrts arc in each State as a pilot
litre fram:. This audit l:cing mide by the programme, and present
m.JSt be carried out by Gi"'mrrent to build stmtegies for redicing
auditors accredited by cajllCity, by w.iy of lhe a::cidenls;
Nliional Road Safety <rJymizirg
(ii)
build capacity
Audit
Board.
This \\OlkshJps on mad arxl train at least 150
Nliional Road Safely safely eqiineering. nne auditors within the
Audit Boord ITT.Et oonsist road safety audit pcriod of next crie iear;
of Senicr Officers of the certification oourses The
State
NHAI, MoRTil, of etc. It \\Ollld take Givemm:nts!Ufs llllY
rCSJ:l!Cli"'
Stale son10 time to build up be directed to train at
Govemm:its as '.\ell as caplcity in the field least 25 such auditors
Rood Safety fapern; ooo of road safety audit. within lhe I"rioo of next
arc tmired Rood Safely Therefurc, Stales nny on: year, and thereafter
Audilcrs. II is resµ:ctfully 1:e µmiitted to set conduct audits.
submitted that if roads their cmn targels fer The statement mire by
wcre propcrly corntructed .CCJYt>leting the mad the Govemm:nt of India
and m1irtained in this safety audits, as pcr 1my kindly be taken on
counby, as is cbne in the guidelines issuoo reccrd and crdered
llllny ovcrsea; ccxmtries, by the Ministry from
rood aecidenls \\Ollld be tiire to time.
much less.
'M th rei;ntl to the
rcconm:ndation of
accrWitalion
by
N!tiooal Road Safety
Audit Board, it is
staled that a pmpa;al
to create a National
Rood Safely Board
Ins bren iocoq=ted
in the Motor Vehicle
(Atrendm:nt) Bill,
'.lll7. The bill has
teen Jn=! by Lok
Sabha The 1>m]DSCd
Boan! will deal with
all a~x:ct' of the road
safely.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
524
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
x
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
Engineering Design of The; road projects costing Rs.
NC\v Roads: It rnay be 10.00 crore er more may be
directed by this Hon'ble of different types like reC'..ourt that no ne\v surfacing of the rood.
row.Vproject
costing reconstru:tion of bridges f
nvre than R~. 10 ('roru; culverts, COfl\truction of
should he undertaken retaining walls fOr protection
unless the desibrt1 is of roack etc_ Such projects
Judited and the audit do not require the rood
recurnn1endation
are safety audit. Therefore,
;n1plemenlied to lhe sp:cifying only cost c1itcria
satisfactiuI!l
of
the for carrying out roa::I safety
aforen"l!ntioned National audits is not appropriate.
Road
Safety
Audit It is proposed that the rwd
Board.
safety audit including the
Order proposed: It
is prayed that this
Hon 'ble Court may
be pleased to dire.1
the r00<l safety audit
including the design
stage audit should be
canied "OUt for all
road
capacity
aug:rrentalion
projects of 5 km or
1nore.
desi g)1 stage audit should be
I carried out for al I rood
D
E
capacity
oogrnentation
f----+~~~~~--~~-+"'=-nrq~·~ec~1~s~o~f~5~k7n~1o~r~17n~or~e~.~-l-~~~~~~~-1
xi
Working Gmup on The report of the Wcrki11g Order
proposed:
Engineering:
it
is Group
on
Engineering This Hon 'ble Court
. prayed that this Hon"ble (Roads) contai11s a detailed niay
issue
the
I Court n1ay pass an urdt.'f background discus.sion. l11e following directions
directing
that reconunendations
and as set out as below:
recun1111endatiuns of the suggested
policies
are l. Highways and
\Vorking Group
on cootained in Para 4 of the urban road design
'1 Enginee1in~ as directed \Vorking Group Report. standards
and
by tl1is Hon 'ble Court Many
of
these i,'llidelines will be
(nra.rkcd as Anncxure reconirnendations are in the niade
consistent
"(."' pag<S (30 to 38)) nature of general wmments. with the safety
in1plen1ented In view of the above, require111ents and in
j thrthwith as dire<.icd by appropriate
tune
\Vith
the
the Hon 'hie· C..ourt.
reconm1endations based on intenlational
best
Working Group
Report practices
on
a
which can be JllSSed by continuous basis at
I I Ion 'hie Supren1e Court as regular intervals.
i directions are brought out as 2.
Conduct Road
safety audits at
belo\v:
..
Higl1\vdys and urlnn different stages of
road design stan.iards <111d construction
and
re
F
guidelines
will
be
111ade
G
\vith the international be;t
practices on a continuous
i OO.Sis at reb'l.llar intervdls.
H
operation.
consistent with the satety 3.
All
reguiren1ents and in u.u1e improvement
I-~-·
1_.
road
project'\
including
resurfacing
works
should
have
provision of sib'llS &
1narkings as 'per 'The
requirenient">.
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (I!) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
Road safety audit<; 4. Adequate traffic
at different stages should cahning 111casurcs
be carried out depending : should be taken,
on the size I type of the : wherever ncoossaiy,
project for all the road · to enhance safety of
developn1ent projects.
. vulnerable
road
All
road , users.
i1nprovement
projt.-"Cts : 5. Rcco1nn1cndations
including
resurfacing of Road Safety
works
should
have Audits should be
provision of signs & in1plcirented, before
nnrkings as per the further work is
requiren1ents.
undertaken on the
A&quatc traffic road concerned.
: cahning measures should 6. Standard Road
be
taken,
wherever accident recording
necessary. to enhance & reporting formats
safety of vulnerable road should be evolved
1
u5ers.
considering
all
Existing stretches
525
A
B
c
aspects of feasibility
of National J-ligln.\'ays & and
nnnpower
State
Highways
not resources and be
. covered in developn1ent published
as
i projects on modes like standard dccun1t.'11t'l
· BOT/EPC
should
be , for adoption by all
subjected to Road Safety authorities at Central
; Audits in phased n1anner and State levels.
· through a tin1c bound 7.
Speciali7Cd
progranl11'le.
accident
Reco1n1nendations · investigation centres
of Road Safety Audits shall be established
should he implen1ented to study a few
preferably within 2 years selected accidents
of sul:nnission of audit using
accident
reports.
reronstruction
Road : techniques etc., and
Standard
acci&nt recording & the details to be
reporting fonnats should preserved- in a data
; be evolved considering all base.
: ac;pects of feasibility and ; 8. lnstitutionali7.Cd
nnnpowcr resources and systern of database
he published as standard storage
and
! documents for adoption by
managerrent should
all authorities at Central , be <level oped for
and State levels.
road accident data.
Specialized
. A suitable web
acci&nt
i1westigation based
electronic
centres shall be e;tablished road accident data
to study a few selected ; collection!
acci&nts using accident ~
D
E
F
G
, recon.'itruction techni ues
H
526
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
and tl1e retails to be callJilation
ireserved in a data ba<ie.
S)'>tem shall be
h1~titutimali2ed
developed
fix
system of databa.<ie staage and ccun1I)'Mde
nnnagenDJt
should
be fill'lC111C111atim
developed for rood accident 9. Centre of
data A suitable ~b ba'led excellence
fix
electronic road accident data road
safety
: oollcction/conlJilatim S)Stem Research
&
shall re de\Clcped fer Accident analyses
ooun1Iyl'1de impleirentatim.
should
be
m
II Centre of excellence developed
for rood safe!y Research & Acadenlic
I Accident analyses shculd be fil~tution~ across
, developed
in
academic tlle OOWltty.
institutions across tl1e ccuntty.
Estabfo;hing synergy nu such !Ure as
NRSB
retwectl various stake holders the
(road authorities, acadenlia, becoires
enforeCJrent authcrities, reuth operatioml, the
a.ithoritics etc) in road safety alx>ve steps llIIY
· at central/ state level~ is being be takCll by the
slrived through National Road Go\Cl1Ul1Cllt
in
Safety Council and State Road cm~ultation with
, Safety Cow:cils. TI1ese should tl>e Collillittee on
Ix: strengthenoo and made Road Safety.
rol:ust to deli= the i1ttended
results.
Centre is extending suppat to
Road Safety Engineering
nllJroVt.~11C11ts m state roads
, tltrough specific sche1res to
oct a~ be1:clum1ks and mxrls
for further etlirts by states.
10% of Central Rood Fund
(CRF) allocatioos lnve beC11
eanmrked for Road Safety
fllginrering works on state
roads tlYough Central Road
' Fund
(State
Roads)
A1rerrl111C11t Rules, 2016.
Detailed guidelmes lnve also ['
L-~-'-~~~~~~h!o::::;cn~1~·ss~u~ed~i~n~tm~·s~i~emnrliz:::=-~-'-~~~~~~
.
I
H
i etc.,
(2017] 13 S.C.R.
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
527
A
xii
Drive111' Training: 1his fu the Mltor Vehicle Order proposed:
Hm'ble Court rrey be (Atncndrrent)
Bill, The Giwnm:nt
pleased to iSSlE a direction 2017,itispropcsedtbat of India and tl:e
that lieernes of all dri\L'l'S tbc transport chi'ing State
would be renewed after license is to be renewed Goveron:ents nny
every
years and ''°ltld at an irtcnal of fi\'C be dim:ted to take
be sul:Jject to thcir qwlifying years.
such steps as
the
stringent
criteria It has been propa;ed in recomn:ended by
incluling
teclmical tbe Mltor Vehicle the Con:nnittee on
efficiency, quality of driving, (Atrendrrent)
Bill, Rood Safety in a
control over a vehicle and 2017 tbat th" central tin:e
bound
oilier relevant factcrs. It fa Gi\cllllrellt may rrnke mumer to ernu:e
necessacy that any person rules fer sirh sclools illlJl'OVenllnt in
"1D drives tbe "'hicle nust or est!blislnrents. Tu the qwlity of
be in complete cmnul of the efforts shall be made to dri\er training and
vehicle to re able to iJ11)!'0\C the q.iality of licensing
minimize the risk of an driving training by (including
accident.
J"'cs:ribing
detailed empha'iis m lane
It is submitted that only curriculum as
as dri\ing) a; ""11 as
accreditoo
dri\ing the infrastructure and in
tho
schools should be autbcrized trainer req.1ireirents by infiasnucture and
to inµut training to tbe tbe D:hing Training the
Uai1:er
learrers and recomren:I the. Schools.
reqiirareots.
grant of perrmrent licen'>eS.
Such institutions nust h:m~
dri\ing teachers (a) witb not
less tban 10 years'
experience: (h) who ha'"
experience in driving all
kinds of vehicles; (c) \\>110
have tbe tbe requisite
learning "'hicle; (d) \\OO
have adcq.Jate facilities and
take suitable n1.miier of tests
before tbe final license by a
public autbmity slnuld only
be qx>ll recommidation of
such an aocredited licensing
institution
Convuterized
dri\ing tests sllOuld be
rescrted for checking d'iving
skills.
fi'"
'"'ll
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
528
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
xiii
B
c
ove1taking.
~iv
D
E
F
G
Lane Driving: 1l1is Court 1nay issue Ministry of Rood
a direction that all the State Transport
&
Gove1nment
would
issue
a Highways
has
tnandatol)' circular that Jane driving already
notified
\.Vil I he strictly insisted upon in all Mater
Vehicles
parts of thi$ counny. Further, (Dliving)
overtaking shaO be ooly according to Regulations 2017
the protocols which are devised for vide G.S.R 634 (El
the said purpose and contravention dated 23"' Jtme
1nay even resnlt in fotfeiture of his or 2017
which
her license.
rmndates the lane
driving and also
provides for the
f!'Olocol
for
Rood Safety Equipment: All the Bureau of Police
State Govem1nenL"i will take steps to Research
&
ncquire and use catncras rn1d other Develq11ncnt
surveillance cquip1nent according to (BPR&D)
had
tl1e nonn~ suggested by the Ministry ~ernred a repo1t in
of Home Affairs to check and detect consultation with
traffic violators.
Further,
this Statcs/UTs on the
Hon'ble Court 1nay direct that nonns
for
the
special patrol forces along the number of Traffic
National Highways. Expressways Police and also for
and the S~1te Highways be the Equipinent for
established. Tiie States 1roy also be identifying
directed to take the following action'i violations of traffic
to the satisfaction of the UJ1runittce la\VS with reference
on Road Safety:
to
vehicle
(A)
Fonnulate and enforce a 1x:.pulation of that
policy for the removal of all City/State
and
hoardings and objects which obstnict submitted the same
d1iving or distract drivers.
to the Committee
(B)
Fonnu1ate and enforce a rn Road Safety in
policy for dztection and rcn1oval of the
rnonth
of
encroaclm1ent on all ped~t1ian path September, 2015.
which v.till cutl'ie any hindrance to Further, Committee
on Rood Safety has
pedcslrians and vehicles.
(C)
Issue a direction that all fo1wardcd
the
to
all
driving licenses will be suspended report
for a period of at least one year under States!UTs on 3ffh
2015
Section 19 of the Motor Vehicles Act November.
and Rule 21 of the CM\' for over (copy attached in
speeding, red-light ju1nping. use of Annexure-Il)
cellular phone while dJ.iving. over
loading, and using goods caniage for
fenving passen~rs.
H
•
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
Order proposed:
The
State
Governrnents/
UTs
n1ay
be
directed to strictly
implement Motor
Vehicles (Diiving)
Regulaticns 2017
notified
vide
G.S.R 634 (E)
dated 23rJ Jmc
20 I7
which
1nandates the lane
driving ard also
provides fer I.he
protocol
for
overtaki112.
Order Proposed:
All
the
State
Goverrnnents/UTs
may be directed to
take
steps
to
acquire and use
cameras and uth1.."T
surveillance
equipment
according to the
nonns suggested
by the Ministry of
Ho1ne Affairs in a
phased tnanncr to
check and detect
traffic violators;
and may further be
directed to set up
special
patrol
forces along the
National
HighWdyS.
Expressways and
die
State
Highways.
This
may be done in
consuJtation wit11
and
to
the
satisfaction of the
Corrunittee
on
Road Safety.
L-~~~·~~-~-~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~--~~~~~~~~---
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR. J.]
529
xv
Minist1y
has Order proposed:
Mitten to the States No further orders
vide letter dated6"' are required at this
April, 2017, for stage.
The
compliance of the statement made by
orders
of
the the Government of
1-lon'ble Supreme lrxlia may kindly
Court. Ministry of be taken on record
Home Affai1> had arxl ordered
issL>::d an adviso1y
on road safety and
accidents to all rl1e
State&IUTs on 17'"
December, 2015,
advising for snict
enfOrcenient
of
provisions of !PC
and MY Act to
prosecute
and
punish
persons
causing injury or .
death in offences
related to road
safety
(detail
attach!d
in
Annexuro-111).
A
The Ministry of
Road Transport &
Highways is in
agreement with tl1e
suggestion.
E
Alcohol and Road Safety: As
per the order dated I sh
December 2016, by a judicial
order passed in (State of
Tamil Nadu v. K. Balu,
(2017) 2 sec 281) rl1is
Hon'ble cmnt prohibited the
grant of licences for the sale of
liquor along national arxl state
highways and o"'r a distance
of 500 metres from the outer
edge
of
the
highway
throughout the territoty of
India. This Hon'ble Court may
ti.nther direct the State
Govem1nents to ensure that the
said prohibition inposed by
this
Hon'ble Cou1t be
effectively
implemented.
Further, three fmmd d1i\1ng
under the influence of alcohol
xvi
should be prosecuted under the
Motor Vehicles Act, I 988 as
well as under the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 within a tinle
period fixed by this Hon'ble
Court.
Rood Safety Education:
Pursuant to recommendations
of the Committee m Road
Safety, Road Safety Education
has already been included by
CBSE in school curriculums.
This Hon'ble Comt 1my
further direct the State
Order
proposed:Tlris
Hon'ble
Court
1my fwther direct
the
State
C'..ovemment&IUTs
to ensure that
Road
Safety
B
c
D
F
Govemn1ents to ensrne that
Education
Road Safety Education and
also
Counselling
is
incotporated
into
t1~
curriculum of the State Boards.
C.ounselling
is
also ircotporated
into
the
curriculum
laid
oown by the State
Boards by I"'
April, 2018.The
statement made by
the Government of
India 1my kindly
and
G
arxl ordered
H
re taken on record
530
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 13 S.C.R.
Speed Goveroors: It i' ( Mini>11y
<f
Rm! Order pll\l(JSed: State
prayed
that
Slate ' Tran;port & Highmiys Gaverrnrents he direct<Il
Governments he diro:tcd ms
already
is:,uxl to take stCJE to emure
to take steps to ensire 91idelines for fit1rent of that "Pl''°'ed spew
that appro\\XI s-peed 3J:Pmved Speed Limited Glvernoo; !l"C fitted in
GovemoIB ai~ frtt<Il in O:vice (speed govemoIB) the existing transport
the existing tran.;JX1!1 m ~rt vehicles. The ve!icles and ghen
vehicles
and
given suggesticn to upload the Unique Tdentificatim
Uni<pe
ldcntification llique
klentificatim Nmrlier. Th:se mniiers
Nurlier. Tht:se nunrns Nunber of the Speed should he uplooded in
should be uploaded in the Givemor in the VAHAN the VAHAN Dital:ese
VAHAN llitahise almg cbtata"' is accqtaHe.
along "ith the de1ails of
\\ith the details of the
the
vehicle.
The
vehicle. TI~ iffitru:::tiorn
instructions i&soo:l ~
is..'\uerl by (',Q111nittee on 1
Coimlittee on Roo:l
Rrnd Safety in this rcgaid I
Safety in this regard llllY
1ruy kindly bc di11.xted to
kindly be dilt!Cted to be
11
strictlv folJcm<Il. _ _
· l(Vu; ·
the Trauma Oller proposed: This
C.n: As fur as I Gire Program"C bciqi Hon'ble Cbut 1my
Cll'CJgency
~
is nrpemented by Ministiy diroct tmt the State
oonccm<rl, this Hon'l>e , <f Health & Farrily Govem1rent
shall
O:urt nny direct tmt the W!lfru,,, a tctal mmier estoolish fur C"'1)'
State Givemm.'llt shall <f 116 Trau1rn Gire Disnict at least one
establish
for
eveiy Facilities (fCFs) -~ Tm11m Oire Centre
District at least one idct•ified 111d awroved \vith all m>dem mxlical
Tmunn Olre Centre \vith duing the 11 • Fhe Year facilities,
an:l
all mJdem 1redical flan (FYP) and 81 TCFs rurbulances equipped
facilities, an:l '1!rbulances \\ere identified dining the "ith fot-<1id fuci!ity
equipped \vitll fi1't-aid 12'h FYP. It 1my further manred ~ trained {'lt"facility
1m1ncd
by ho nutioned that \\ith n"Cdical staffsluuld also
trained I'Xilli-nlXiical ~taff l"C£i:ll'd to trdined par.t- be mid: available.
District
'hould alw be nme nulical
staff
for fu1her,
availal:le
arrbulanccs,
the ~strates <f ""-"IY
ltogrannr Dimiol\ the district 1my he direct<rl
Dircctcr Gencral of to ensure that sufficient
, Hoalth
Sa-vices ha.5 JXJliicity is given in
developed tbc Pre- respect of cxistiqi
luspital
Tra1J1m fucilitie&
1
'I Technician
Cotmsc
CU1icu11J111. and the
training
is
bci Ill
mOCrrnkcn in the three
Qntral
Gi\ennrcnt
Hosptals of O:lhi.
' llllOCly
Safdnjurg
Hosfital, LHMC ruld l::t.
I
B
c
I
D
::.;~~ °''-~redicaihrespeciof
I
E
I
I
F
G
I
H
[_ ---·--· _j~ H<hpital-si_oc_e~------·-
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
xix
xx
xxl
Unhersal
Accident The National Health
Hflpline Number: This Mission ah-eacy ir<Mdcs
Hon'ble C'nurt 1my be for a all! centre nun:ber
pl eased to olilir lhat tha"c (108), \\llich is being
shall be cne Uni""'31 cxternively used in the
Acx:ident
Helpline States
for
nxrlical
Nw1:tier "'1ich should be eirerg,'tlcies indudirg
estal:i ished
by
the acci"""1s. The ani:>ulanx
Dqlart1rent
of services
are
a1so
cperatioml in 1m<t of the
Teleconnunication
throll!hrut the country. states tlmmgh this call
Further, a universal code oettre ruii:><r (108).
fer arrb.ilanxs should be
notified by the M<RlH
Order Pr<posed: Tho
Slate Cb=rcnts/Ufs
1my be directed to
.trerg!hen tbe occid:nt
helpline m.url:ier by
pro,;ding
adeqJate
fucilities. Tho Slate
C"'vennrents that ha"'
not ITTJde ani:>ulanoe
services ~nitiom.I n11y
be directed to mso by
31" March 2018, ard to
linth:::r
dcvdop a
code'n1'th<xl to utilize
servicx:s
of
all
arnbularrcs in the area
Order~: Tho
oells have been set 14'
and no lintber md:rs are
required at ire;ent Tho
statement made by tl1c
Govennrent of India
1my kindly be taken on
reconl and ordtmi.
Penmnett Road Safety The Mini;try of Rood
Cdl: This Hon'ble Crut Transport & High\v.iys is
1my direct lhat Natioml in agreamnt with the
Higmays Aulhaity of &Ugge5.tiffi.
India 1rust lnve a Mini>ily
of
Rood
penmnent Rm! Safcty Trdll5]10rt & Highways as
C'.cll cmsisting of suitable v.<:ll Natiornl Highways
engineers and q.ialified Authority of hla have
pen;onnd and \\hich shall c;1ablished rood safety
be c;1ablished on er engineering cells. All the
before 30"' SeJteni:>er, States!Ufs lnve also
2017.
been
requested
to
establish Rood Safety
Engineering Cell in their
Natiooal
High\wys
Directcrate; by Minc'itJy
of Rood Tr!lll5]10rt &
High"""·
Data Coll«tion: llis MiniS!l)I
of
Rood Order proposed: Ni
Hoo'hle Crurt troy direct Trarnport & High'Mlys linther
onlors
are
that a conwteriw.l Ins already C\olved a required at this stag»
f mmt be rr"fllred by the now fmnat for reccrdirg H::)\.\ever, it 1my be
MoRTH for collecting accid:nt data & report. dirocted lhat the said
rood
accident
dita 1l1e fonmt is embled for fonmt cwl \<XI by 1he
thro~ lhe coun!l)I ca'l'utcri2ed data enny. MinL<try be
strictly
and data so oollected State Gove1111rnt I Ufs followed
should be nmc µiblic so lnve been '6ked to take TI1e ;tatcnmt mule by
that even m.'tli:>ers of tlic fUT1hcr a::ticm to col lcct tlie Govellllrent of India
public oould pur.rue and report the data in new nny kindly be taken on
rcnmial
actions cr fonmt 1re Mnb1ly has reconl and """"'1.
research.
hem 111aki ng the data
µiblic for infrnmtion of
all lhe ;tlkehllcbs.
531
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
532
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
xx ii
GPS: Jt is sub1nitted that
it has been fourx:I that
use of GPS and GIS
niapping:
cncotD"agcs
safety OOth for drivers
and
passengers.
l11crcforc, it is prayed
that a direction be issued
to all car nmufactures
that with effect front J' 1
January 2018 tl1ey would
ensure that all vehicles
are in.tailed with GPS
and GTS.
xxiii
Bus/Truck-Body
Building Code: l11is
Hoo'ble Court nny
direct tliat MoRTH nny
take suitable steps to
notify Bus/Truck-BOOy
Bui !ding Code so that
hencetOrth buses arxl
trucks OOilt on different
cha'isis arc not found
wanting in security airl
safety features.
XXi\'
ABS, Air Bags and
Headlights: It is prayed
that a direction be issued
that in every nlOOcl of
car sold in India there
shall
be Anti-Lock
Braking Systen1 a1xl air
bags. Further a directicn
be issued that all n.vo\Vhccler
n1<1.nufacturer
\Vill take recourse to
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
of
Road
Ministry
Transport & Highways
has already no ti tied vide
G.S.R. No. 1095 (E)
dated 2s• November
2016 niarxlating the
titincnt
of
\t:hiclc
location tracking de\ice
and en1ergency button in
all public service vehicles
exceit two \vh:elers., ericksha\v, three \vheelcrs
and any transpm: vehicles
for \vhich no permit _is
required under the Motcr
Vehicles Act,
1988.
Fitn~nt of GPS devices
on other vehicles would
be considered in due
course since this would
put additional cost burden
on the vd1idc o\\ncrs in
tenns of oost of the GPS
""llinment.
Bus
Body
Code:
Ministry
of
Road
TranSJXlrt & High\\ays
has already notified the
bus body code vide
G.S.R No. 287 (E) dated
22"d Apri I 2014.
Truck Body Code:
!vfinistry
of
Road
Transrort & High\\'llys
has already notified the
truck body code vide
G.S.R. No. 1034 (E)
dated 2"' November 2016
for vehicles regi&ered on
or after 1'1 Octolxr 2018.
ABS: Ministry of Road
Transport & Highways
has notified for the
fitrnent of ABS in rrnccr
cycles vide G.S.R No.
3 to (E) dated 16'' March
2016 and for fotr
wheelers vide G.S.R. No.
120 (E) dated 1o••
February 2017 for ne1.\'
models on or after 1"
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
Order proposed: This
Hon'ble Court may
direct that an public
servic~ vehicles shall be
titted with location
tracking
device
as
matt ioncd by Go! and
the said notification be
strictly
llnplenJented.
The statement 1nadc by
the Government of India
may kindly be taken on
reccrd and ordered.
Order proposed: No
further
orders
are
required at this stage.
The statement made by
the Government of India
may kindly be tikcn on
reccrd and ordered.
Orden proposed:
further
orders
required
No
are
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (11) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
"Automatic Headlights
On' sysrems. It is prayed
that a direction be issued
State
that
the
Govcmincnt inust not
allow vehicles with
April
2018
and
533
A
for
existing nlOdcls on or after
1" April 2019.
Air Bags: Ministry of
Road
TranS'J'Olt
&
Highw.iys finalized a
in1ix:rnlissible headlights stan<lard AIS-145, which
to ply.
is being notified. l11is
stardard would 1mndate
fiu11ent of Air Bags on all
the
LMV
passenger
B
vehicles.
xxv
Crash Test: lt is
respectfully submitted
that in vie\V of the
doubtful crash test of all
the LMVs. crash test in
Proper condirirns rnu11t
be undertcl<.cn in respect
Automated Headlights
On: .. Ministry of Road
Tnutspert & Highways has
notified vide:·o.s.It-. No.:
188 (E) dated 22.02.2016
for iitment of 'Automated
Headlights Oa' (AHO) in
two
vmeelers
n1anufactured on or after
I" April 2017.
The crash tests for all rlle
Light Motor Vehicles
(LMVs)
have
been
notified by the Ministry
for itnple1ncntation. ·n1c
tests are to be conducred
only by tllc testing
c
D
Order proposed:
No further orders
are necessary at
this stage.
The
state1ncnt
made
by
the
Govenu11Cnt
of
of LMVs by laboratories agcn:ies notified under India 1nay kindly
tlurt: are accredited. It is Rule 126 of tlic Central be taken on record
submitted
that
this Motor Vehicle Rules, and ordered.
Hm 'ble Court nuy 1989. 111e agencies are
further direct that all required to have their
vehicle testing agencies testing facilities accredited
in India should be
internationally
accredited I reCOblilized
to ensure that crash tcslli
are
genuinely
and
E
F
by National Accreditatirn
Board for Testing and
Calibration
Lalx>ratocics (NABL).
The Ministry has issUt.>d
sincerely
undertaken S.O. 1139 (E) dated
having ut1rost regard to 28.04.2015 and S.0. 2412
the wlue of human life. (E) dared 03.09.2015
This may be done by 1" ainending the Central
April 2018. ·
Motor Vehicles Rules,
1989 (CMVRs) notifying
the
following
crash
standards: -
G
H
534
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
(2017] 13 S.C.R.
Standards
I
B
Date
of
collvtl"1cement
/validitv
Recpirenrnt
New
fcr bel>1viour Midelsof
steering 1.10.2017
nrchanism of All
a vehicle in a MidelsHead-On
Ol.10.2019
Collision
per
AIS
0%2008
Protecti en of New Modelsoccupants in l.I0.2017
the event of an All
Modelsoffset Frorial 01.10.2019
Collision as
per
AIS
098/2008
-Approval of New Mirelsvehicles with 1.10.2018
regiird to tl1e All
ModelsProtecticn of 01.10.2019
"'
c
D
O::cuparts in
E
the event of a
Lateral
Collision
per
AIS
099!.2008
Approval of
Vehicles with
regwd to the
Protecticn of
Pedefilian and
other
Vulirrable
Rood Usa-s in
the event of a
Collision with
a
Motor
Vehicle a• per
AIS 100'2010
"'
F
i
G
I
I
I
H
New Mxi!ls1.10.2018
All
Models01.10.2020
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (ID v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
(MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
535
17. We have heard learned Amicus Curiae as well as learned
Additional Solicitor General. They have taken us through all the
suggestions made and the response of the MoRTH to these suggestions.
In view of the submissions, and keeping in mind issues of road safety
and the interest of those who may be unfortunate victims ofroad accidents,
we issue the following directions:
A
B
I.Road Safety Policy: Most of the State Governments and
Union Territories have already framed a Road Safety Policy.
Those that have not framed such a policy namely Assam.
Nagaland, Tripura, Delhi, Lakshadweep, Dadra and Nagar Havcli
andAndaman and Nicobar Islands, must now fonnulate the Road
Safety Policy by 31'' January, 2018. All States and Union
Territmies are expected to implement the Road Safety Policy
with all due earnestness and seriousness.
2.State Road Safety Council: All States have already
constituted a Road Safety Council in terms of Section 215 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The Union Territories of Daman
and Diu, Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Andaman and Nicobar
Islands have not constituted the Road Safety Council as yet.
We direct these Union Territories to constitute the State Road
Safety Council on or before 31" January, 2018. The responsibility
and functions of the Council will be as recommended by the
Committee on Road Safety. The State Road Safety Councils
should periodically review the laws and take appropriate remedial
steps wherever necessary.
3.Lead Agency: Only a few States have established the Lead
Agency as recommended by the Committee on Road Safety in
its communication of23"' December, 2014. The States and Union
Territories that have not done so should establish the Lead Agency
on or before 31"January,2018 in terms of the recommendations
made by the Committee on Road Safety. It may be mentioned
that the Lead Agency will act as the Secretariat of the State
Road Safety Council and coordinate all activities such as licensing
issues including issues of driving licences, registration of vehicles,
road safety and features of vehicles, along with other allied
matters including emission norms and other activities as
mentioned in the communication dated 2J•d December, 2014.
c
D
E
F
G
H
536
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2017] 13 S.C.R.
4. Road Safety Fund: Some of the States have already
established a Road Safety Fund. Those States and Union
Territories that have not yet established the Road Safety Fund
should do so not later than 31" March, 2018 and report back to
the Committee on Road Safety. The corpus of the Road Safety
Fund will be from the fines collected for traffic violations and
the Fund will be utilized for meeting expenses relating to road
safety.
5. Road Safety Actfon Plan: The purpose of a Road Safety
Action Plan is to reduce the number of road accidents, as well
as the fatality rate. ''r-he MoRTH has already requested all the
States and Union Territories to prepare a Road Safety Action
Plan but it appears that the response to this has been somewhat
lukewarm. The State Governments and Union Territories are
therefore directed to urgently prepare a Road Safety Action Plan
by 3 l" March, 2018 and put it into action after giving it due
publicity.
6. District Road Safety Committee: A District Road Safety
Collll1!littee is required to be set up by the .State Government for
every district in tenns of Section 215(3) Mthc Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988. As suggest<!\!. by the learned Amicus and agreed to
by the MoRTH, the District Road Safety Committee should be
put in place by 31" January, 2018 and should be headed by the
Collector of the District and should include amongst others the
Superintendent of Police, Health Officers, Engineers of the
Public Works Department, representatives of the National
Highways Authority of India, the Road Transport Officer of the
District and members of civil society from the District. The
District Road Safety Committee must hold regular and periodic
meetings to review road safety issues and take corrective
measures.
7. Engineering Improvement: It appears that one of the main
reasons for road accidents is the poor quality of roads, improper
design. etc. The MoRTH is of the opinion that the protocol for
road desii,'11 and identification ofblack spots needs to be reviewed
and enforced. Accordingly, it is directed that the MoRTH should
publish a protocol for identification and rectification ofblack spots
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
and take necessary steps for improving the design of roads to
make them safe.
8. Traffic Calming Measures: It is suggested by the learned
Amicus that traffic calming measures must be adopted at accident
prone areas. This is agreed to hy the MoRTH. However, such
measures will need to be studied and then put in place. This is
an on-going exercise which must be carried out by the Road
Safety Committee with the assistance of the MoRTH and other
stakeholders.
9. Road Safety Audits: There is agreement, in principle,
between the learned Amicus and the MoRTH to carry out Road
Safety Audits. However, there appears to be a dearth of qualified
auditors in Road Safety Engineering. The MoRTH supports the
idea of capacity building. It is, therefore, directed that necessary
steps be taken by the Committee on Road Safety as well as by
the MoRTH to work in this direction since there can be little
doubt that an audit of road safety is essential to reduce the
possibility of road accidents through corrective measures.
10. Engineering Design of New Roads: The MoRTH is of
the view, and the learned Amicus is also in agreement, that the
Road Safety Audit as mentioned above should include the design
stage audit of new road projects of 5 kms or more, rather than
being based on the cost of the project. It is ordered accordingly.
11. Working Group on Engineering: The Working Group
on Engineering (Roads) has already submitted a Report which is
available with the Road Safety Committee as well as the MoRTH.
This Working Group was constituted pursuant to the decision
taken in the meeting of the 12"' National Road Safety Council
held on 25"' March, 2011. The recommendations of the Working
Group should be implemented in the terms prayed for by the·
learned Amicus as well as those accepted by the MoRTH. These
will, of course, be in the nature of interim directions since the
National Road Safety Board is likely to be created as proposed
in the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Bill, 2017.
12. Drivers' Training: This is the subject matter of the Motor
Vehicles (Amendment) Bill, 2017 and no orders are required to
be passed in this regard.
537
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
538
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 13 S.C.R.
13. Lane Driving: The MoRTH has already issued Motor
Vehicles (Driving) Regulations, 2017 vide GS.R. 634 (E) dated
23n1June,2017.
The Notification should be implemented by the State Governments
and U111ion Territories strictly.
l:J
c
D
E
14. Road Safety Equipment: The Bureau of Police Research
and T~aining has already prepared a Report on the subject and
has submitted it to the Road Safety Committee in September,
2015. The recommendations in the Report should be implemented
including acquisition of cameras and surveillance equipments in
detecting traffic and identifying violators. [t is also necessary to
set up special patrol forces along the National Highways and
State Highways for which necessary steps must be taken by the
State Governments and Union Territories.
15. Alcohol and Road Safety: The MoRTH has already written
to the States to comply with orders of this Court in this regard.
1 he MoRTH may issue further advisories in this regard on a
quarterly basis during the calendar year 2018 so as to serve as a
reminder to the State Governments and Union Territories to
implement the directions of this Court.
F
16. Road Safety Education: The learned Amicus as well as
MoRT}! are in agreement that road safety education and
counselling should be incorporated in the curriculum by the State
Boards by 1" April, 2018. It is directed that the State
Governments may seriously consider this recommendation and
include Road Safety Education and Counseling as ·A part of the
school curriculum at the earliest.
G
17. Speed Governors: Guidelines in this regard have already
been issued by the MoRTH. The MoRTH has agreed to upload
the Unique Identification Number of the speed governors in the
VAHAN database. This should be followed up by the MoRTH
with expedition.
H
18. Emergency Medical Care: There is agreement that at
least one Trauma Care Centre should be set up in every district
with necessary facilities and an ambulance. The State
Governments and Union Territories should take up this
recommendation at the earliest since it is on record that treatment
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR. J.)
soon after a road accident is crucial for saving the life of the
victim. In this context, it may also be mentioned that this Court
has issued certain directions in Pt Parmana11d Katara v. U11io11
ofIndia' which should be followed.
19. Universal Accident Helpline Number: The MoRTH has
stated that there is already a call centre number, that is, I 08
provided by the National Health Mission. Due publicity must be
given to this so that an ambulance can be activated at the earliest
whenever necessary.
20. Permanent Road Safety Cell: All State Governments and
Union Territories have already been requested by the MoRTH
to set up Road Safety Cells. The State Governments and Union
Territories should establish Permanent Road Safety Cells by 3 I"
January, 2018.
21. Data Collection: The MoRTH has already taken steps for
recording accident data and reports through computerised data
entry. The State and Union Territories have been asked to take
further action in this regard and make the data public for the
information of all stakeholders. This needs to be followed up
and no further orders are necessary in this regard.
22. GPS : The MoRTH has already notified vide GS.R. No.
1095 (E) dated 28ili November, 2016 mandating the fitment of
vehicle location tracking devices in all public service vehicles
subject to some exceptions. Since this has cost implications, the
MoRTH may assist the State Governments and Union Territories
to ensure that to the maximum extent possible and within the
shortest time frame, location tracking devices must be fitted in
all public service vehicles as notified.
23. Bus/Truck-Body Building Code: This has already been
notified by the MoRTH with regard to buses vide G.S.R. No.
287 (E) dated 27ili April, 2014 and with regard to trucks vide
GS.R. No. 1034(£) dated 2'"November, 2016. No furtherorders
are necessary in this regard.
539
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
24. ABS, Air Bags and Headlights: The MoRTH has already
notified for fitment ofABS in motor cycles vide GS.R. No. 31 O(E)
' (19891 4 sec 2&6
H
540
A
B
c
D
E
F
r;
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2017] 13 S.C.R.
dated 16" March, 2016 and for four wheelers vide G.S.R. No.
120(E) dated 10"' February, 2017. As far as air bags arc
concerned a standard AIS-145 has already been notified. As
regards automated headlights, the MoRTH has notified vide
G.S.R. No. I 88(E) dated 22'" February, 20 ! 6 for fitment of
"Automated Headlights On" in two wheelers manufactured on
or after I" April, 2017. No further orders are required in this
regard except the faithful implementation of the various
notifications issued by the MoRTH.
25. Crash Test: This too has been notified by the MoRTH and
the test for all light motor vehicles is required to be conducted by
the testing agency notified under Ruic 126 of the Central Motor
Vehicles Rules. 1989. No further orders are required in this regard
except the faithful implementation of the notifications and crash
standards issued by the MoRTH.
18. We make it clear that the directions given above arc those
that have been ~greed upon by the parties before us and are in addition
to and supplement the directions already given in S.Rajaseekaran v.
Union oflndia12 We commend the efforts put in by the learned Amicus
Curiae and the Justice K.S. Radhakrishnan Committee on Road Safety.
We are confident that the directions given above, at their instance and
with the support. cooperation and assistance of the MoRTH, will save
thousands oflives in road accidents and crores ofrupees in compensation
payable by the insurance companies - provided the directions are
faithfully and sincerely complied with.
19. We also make it clear that if there is any doubt or clarity
required in implementing the directions given, the concerned State
Government or Union Territory is at liberty to move the Committee on
Road Safety.
20. We may note that none of the directions given by us or the
directions given earlier by this Court are difficult to comply with. In this
connection, we may draw attention to the excellent document prepared
by the Committee on Road Safety and the MoRTH titled "Consulting
Services to Audit the Imple111entation by the States of the Directions
Issued by the Committee on Road Safety - Group 4- Final Report"
concerning Haryana prepared in September 2017. The Report has
'r2014l 6 sec J6
DR. S. RAJASEEKARAN (II) v. UNiON OF INDIA & ORS.
[MADAN B. LOKUR, J.]
541
received considerable support from the Delhi Integrated Multi-Model
Transit System Limited (DIMTS), Transportation Research and Injury
Prevention Programme (TRIPP), HT-Delhi and The Energy and
Resource Institute (TERI). It would be worthwhile if similar reports are
prepared and published so that roads all over the country are rendered
far safer than what they arc today.
A
21. List for further proceedings on 7'" February, 2018.
Nidhi Jain
Directions issued.
B
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org