BENSON versus STATE OF KERALA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 October 2016 | [2016] 8 S.C.R. 166 | 2016 INSC 944
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 October 2016
- Bench
- DIPAK MISRA*, UDAY UMESH LALIT
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 958/2016
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [2016] 8 S.C.R. 166
- Neutral citation
- 2016 INSC 944
Text of the judgment
[2016] 8 S.C.R. 166
A
BENSON
v.
STATE OF KERALA
(Criminal Appeal No. 958of2016)
B
OCTOBER 03, 2016
[DIPAK MISRA AND UDAY UMESH LALIT, JJ.]
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - s.42? - Concurrent
running of subsequent sentence with previous sentence - Appellant
of having committed various offences - Tried separately
c charged
and sentenced in each of the offences - Plea of appellant for
concurrent running of sentences - Held: Court has the power and
discretion to issue a direction that the subsequent sentence shall
run concurrently with the previous sentence - Whether or not a
direction ought to be issued in a given case would depend upon the
D nature of the offence or offences committed and the fact situation On facts, sentence imposed on appellant in each of the present cases
to run concurrently with the sentence imposed upon the appellant
in another crime committed by him which is currently operative Howeve1; this benefit limited in respect of substantive sentences and
not on default sentences and sentences of fine.
E
Partly allowing the appeals, the Court
HELD: 1. In terms of sub-section (1) of Section 427 of
Cr.P.C., if a person already undergoing a sentence of imprisonment
is sentenced on a subsequent conviction to imprisonment, such
F subsequent term of imprisonment would normally commence at
the expiration of the imprisonment to which he was previously
sentenced. Going by this normal principle, in the instance case
the sentence chart indicated in communication mentioned is quite
correct. However this normal rule is subject to a qualification
and it is within the powers of the Court to direct that the
G subsequent sentence shall run concurrently with the previous
sentence. [Para 6][174-G-H; 175-A)
2. In the present case, the appellant stands convicted and
sentenced in 12 different matters including the present 4 matters.
The maximum sentence in respect of the present crimes is two
H
166
BENSON v. STATE OF KERALA
167
years' rigorous imprisonment. As per the record, these crimes A
were committed on the same day. Having considered the matters,
the sentences imposed in each of the present 4 cases (which
appear at serial nos.9, 10, 11 and 12 of the chart/communication
received from the Director General of Prisons & Correctional
Services) shall run concurrently with the sentence imposed in
8
crime no.8 which is currently operative. This benefit is granted
in respect of substantive sentences to the appellant but the
sentences of fine and the default sentences arc maintained. If
the fine as imposed is not deposited, the default sentence or
sentences are to run consecutively and not concurrently. [Paras
4, 9)174-A; 176-B-D]
C
V.K. Bansal v. State of Haryana (2013) 7 SCC
211 : :Z013 (7) SCR 617 - referred to.
Case Law Reference
2013 (7) SCR 617
referred to
Para 7
D
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
958of2016.
From the Judgment and Order dated 16.09.2015 of the High Court
ofKerala at Ernakulam in Criminal Appeal No. 808 of2015
WITH
E
Criminal Appeal Nos. 957, 959 & 960 of2016.
Ranjith B. Marar, Ms. Lakshmi N. Kaimal and T. K. Babu, Advs.
for the Appellant.
G. Prakash, Jishnu M. L., Ms. Priyanka Prakash, Ms. Beena
Prakash, Manu Srinath and Ramesh Babu M. R., Advs. for the
Respondent.
F
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
UDAY UMESH LALIT, J. I. Leave granted. These appeals . G
by Special Leave arise out of judgments and orders passed by the High
Court of Kerala in Criminal Revision Petition Nos. (i) 808 of 2015 on
16.09.2015, (ii) 859of2015 on 16.09.2015, (iii) 858of2015 on 14.09.2015
and (iv) 670of2015 on 17.09.2015.
H
168
A
B
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 8 S.C.R.
2. On the allegation that the appellant was involved in committing
thefts he was charged of having committed offences on different
occasions and was separately tried in i) CC No.158 of 2004 before
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Chavakkad for offences punishable under
Section 379, 414 read with 34 !PC, ii) CC No.1039 of2003 by Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Chavakkad for offences punishable under Section
379, 414 read with 34 !PC, iii) CC No.390 of2004 by Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Chavakkad for offences punishable under Section 3 79, 414
read with 34 !PC and (iv) CC No.1168 of2006 by Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Kunnamkulam. By separate judgments, the appellant was
convicted and sentenced in each of the aforesaid crimes. The respective
appeals preferred by the appellant were dismissed by the Sessions Judge,
Thrissur. The appellant filed Criminal Revision Petitions in the High
Court which were also dismissed. The following chart would disclose
the relevant details:-
D
C.C.'.\'o,[
Offence
E
F
G
H
15&2004
in the Court
of Judicial
Magistrate First
Class (in shon
JMFC),
Chmkkad!
U/s 379, 414 ri\''
34 ofIPC
Date
Date
of CrL Appeal CrL
of
Conviction and
'.\'o.
R.P.
occurrence Sentence by
'.\'o. in
Judicial
the
Magistrate
High
First Class
Court
03.06.2003 28.06.06,
5312012
80R
RI for 2 years decided on
2015
and fine of 15.11.2012
Rs.1,000/- for by Sessions
offence u!s 379 Judge,
IPC and RI for 2 Thrissur
years u/s 414 ID
RI for 3months
SLP
'.\'o.
SLP
(Cr!.)
3757,'
2016
169
BENSON v. STATE OF KERALA
[UDAY UMESH LAUT, J.]
A
1039;2003
03.06.2003
in the Court
ofJMFC,
Chavakkad/
U!s 379, 414 r;\v
34 of!PC
3902004
03.06.2003
in the Court
of JMFC,
Chavakkadl
Uis 379, 414 r/w
34ofIPC
1168/2006
in the Court
ofJMFC,
Kunnamkulam!
U.s 379 r/w 34
of!PC
03.06.2003
7592011
28.06.06,
RI for 2 years decided on
and fine of 17.09.2012
Rs.l.OOO:- for by Sessions
offence u!s 379 Judge,
!PC and RI for 2 Turissur
years for offence
u/s 414 !PC, ID
RI for 3months.
7612011
28.06.06,
RI for 2 years decided on
and fine of 04.08.2012
Rs.1,000.'- for by Sessions
offence u:s 379 Judge,
!PC and RI for 2 Turissur
years u.!s 414 ID
RI for 3months
31.12.08,
46L201!
RI for 1 year decided on
and fine of 30.09.2011
Rs.1,000'- !D SI by Sessions
for 6months
Judge,
Tiuissur
859!
2015
SLP
(Cd.)
37591
2016
B
858.
2015
SLP
(CrL)
c
3758/
2016
D
670!
2005
SLP
(Cr!.)
3756/
2016
E
F
3. These matters came up on 22.04.20 I 6 when this Court noted
the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellant regarding
concurrent running of sentences and issued notice to the State. The
learned counsel appearing for the State has produced before us
communication dated 27.05.2016 from the Director General of Prisons
and Correctional Services, which is as under:-
G
H
170
[2016) 8 S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
"PRISONS HEADQUARTERS,
A
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Dated: 27.05.2016
WPl-9606/2016
B
From
The Director General of Prisons &
Correctional Services.
To
The Law Officer,
Office of the Resident Commissioner,
C
Travancore Palace,
Kasturba Gandhi Marg,
New Delhi-110 001.
Sir,
D
Sub: Prisons - Prisons Headquarters, Kerala - Supreme
Coui1 case - SLP (Crl) CRLMP No.6727/2016/Benson
vs. State of Kerala - reg.
Ref: Lr. No.38749/81/2016/Home dtd.19/05/2016
Attention is invited to the subject & reference cited.
E
I may furnish the details called for vide reference is noted
below:
Conviction Details
SL
F
No.
1
Case No., Court
and Warrant Date
cc 613i03
JFCM I, Thrissur
Wdt.20-11-2003
2
G
3
H
cc 533;04
JFMC II, Thrissur
Wdt.8-6-2005
cc 529!04
JFMC II, Thrissur
wdt.18-6-2005
Sentence Details
Sentenced to undergo RI for3 years uis 379
IPC
Set off97 days. Atlarge bail period -153
days.
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years ufs 392
IPC
Set off 521 days.
Sentenced to undergo RI for 3 years ufs 392
IPC,
Set off 493 days
BENSON v. STATE OF KERALA
[UDAY UMESH LAUT, J.]
171
A
4
5
6
7
CC 1270113 JFCM
Changanassery
Wdt.18-6-2005
CC 1115103 JFCM
Irinjalakk11da
Wdt. 4-7-2005
cc 932105
JFMC Irinjalak11da
Wdt.4-7-2005
cc 171105
ADSJ Adhoc II
Kanayam
Wdt.25-11-2005
8
cc 274,06
9
JFCM Kodwigallur
Wdt.30-9-2008
cc 158/04
JF CM Chava.kkad
wdt.28-6-2006
10
CC 1039'03 JFCM
Chavakkad
\Vdt. 28-6-2006
11
cc 39004
JFCM Chavakkad
Wdr.28-6-2006
12
cc 1168,06
JFCM
Kunnamangalam
Wdt.31-12-2008
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years +fine
Rs.50001- id SI for 1month u/s 380 IPC, RI
for 2 years +fine Rs.5 ,000!- L'd SI for I
month uis 457 IPC (Concurrently) Set of 348
days
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years +fine
Rs.2,000/- i!d SI for 2 months u/s 379 IPC
Set off 402 davs
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years +fine
Rs-2,000,- L'd SI for 2 months 11's 379 IPC
Set off 465 days
Sentenced to widergo RI for 5years u.s 392
!PC, RI for 3 years u/s 120(B) IPC
(ConC\llrently) Set off 418 days.
Sentenced to undergo SI for 3 years us 205
!PC
Set off 414 days
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years +fme
Rs.1,000. - iid SI for 3 months u's 379 IPC,
RI for2 years u·s 414 !PC (Concurrently)
Set off347 days
Seutenced to undergo RI for 2 years .,. fine
Rs.1,000- i'd SI for 3 months ws 379 !PC, RI
for 2 years u.'s 414 !PC (Concurrently)
Ser off 240 days
Sentenced to undergo RI for 2 years +fine
Rs.1,000- i'd SI for 3 momhs 11s 379 IPC, RI
for 2 years ws 414 !PC (Concurrently) Set off
14ldays
Sentenced to undergo RI for 1year t fine
Rs.1,000 Ld SI for 2months uis 379 r/w 34
!PC Set off 14 days
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
172
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[20 I 6) 8 S.C.R.
A
S.No.
1
B
)
c
3
4
D
I
5
E
I 6
I
Sentence Calculation
Case No.
Sentence Calculation
1n Sentence Started
20-11-2003
cc 613/03
19-11-2006
Sentence 3 years
JFCM I, Thrissur
Set Off 97days
14-08-2006
At large 153 days
14-01-2007
2ui Sentence Started
14-01-2007
cc 533/04
JFCM II, Thrissur
Semence 2years
14-01-2007
Set off 521 days
12-08-2009
cc 529<04
3m Sentence Started
12-08-2009
JFCM II, Thrissur
Sentence 3 years
12-08-2010
Set off 49 3davs
06-04-2009
CC 1270.'13 JFCM
4± Sentence Started
06-04-2009
Changanasseiy
Sentence 2 years
06-04-2011
Set off 348 days
23-04-2010
CC 115/03 JFCM
5± Sentence Started
23-04-2010
hinjalili:uda
Semence 2vears
23-04-2012
Set off ~02 days
lS-03-2011
cc 932'05
6&. Sentence Staned
18-03-2011
JFCM Irinjalakuda
Sentence 2yms
lS-03-2013
Set off 465 days
09-12-2011
SC 171/05
/t't. Sentence Started
09-12-2011
ADSJ Adhoc II,
Sentence 5 years
09-12-2016
Kottayam
Set off 418 days
18-10-2015
cc 27t06
Stt. Sentellce Staned
18-10-2015
JFCM Kodullgallur
Sentence 3years
18-10-2018
Set off~ 14 days
30-08-2017
cc 1ss.o.i
9:: Sentence Stanrd
30-0S-~017
IF C?>I C!ma:.;kad
Senteuce 2wats
30-0S-~019
17-09-2018
Set off 34 7davs
.
7
F
s
G
'
I
I
I
I
H
9
BENSON v. STATE OF KERALA
[UDAY UMESH LALJT, J.]
173
A
10
CC 1039/03 JFCM
Chavakkad
11
cc 390/04
12
JFCM
Chavakkad
cc 1168106
JFCM
Kunnamangalam
Fine Sentence
Details
1OU: Sentence Started
Sentence 2years
Set off 240 days
11 tl: Sentence Started
Sentence 2 years
Set off l·H days
!2U: Sentence Started
Sentence 1year
Set off 14 days
17-9-201&
17-09-2020
21-01-2020
21-01-2020
21-01-2022
02-09-2021
02-09-2021
02-09-2022
19-08-2022
19-10-2022 (F4)
19-12-2022
(F5)
19-02-2023
(F6)
19-05-2023
(F9)
19-08-'.l023 (FlO)
19-11-2023
(11)
19-05-2024
tF12)
B
c
D
E
As per the records, he· wi II spend 12 years 3 months and 8
days in prison as on 31 /07/2016.
F
His date of expiry of substantive sentence falls on 19-082022 without any remission. He has already earned 3 years
I 0 months 27 days remission as on 26-05-16. He has to
pay fine ofRs.18,000/- in various cases in default he has to
undergo I year 5 months in Jail.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Director General of Prisons &
Correctional Services"
G
H
174
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2016) 8 S.C.R.
4. According to the aforesaid communication, the appellant stands
convicted and sentenced in 12 different matters including the present
matters which appear at Serial Nos.9, I 0, 11 and 12 in the chart. Going
by the sentence calculation, the sentence in the 9'h case would begin on
30.08.2017 and finally, the sentence in the J 2•h case, after getting all
benefits of set off, would be over on 02.09.2022.
5. Section 427 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is as
under:-
c
D
E
F
"427. Sentence on offender already sentenced for
another offence. -(I) When a person already undergoing
a sentence of imprisonment is sentenced on a subsequent
conviction to imprisonment or imprisonment for life, such
imprisonment or imprisonment for life shall commence at
the expiration of the imprisonment to which he has been
previously sentenced, unless the Court directs that the
subsequent sentence shall run concurrently with such .
previous sentence:
Provided that where a person who has been sentenced to
imprisonment by an order under Section 122 in default of
furnishing security is, whilst undergoing such sentence,
sentenced to imprisonment for an offence committed prior
to the making of such order, the latter sentence shall
commence immediately.
(2)When a person already undergoing a sentence of
imprisonment for life is sentenced on a subsequent
conviction to imprisonment for a term or imprisonment for
life, the subsequent sentence shall run concurrently with
such previous sentence."
6. In terms of sub-section (I) of Section 427, ifa person already
undergoing a sentence of imprisonment is sentenced on a subsequent
G conviction to imprisonment, such subsequent tenn of imprisonment would
normally commence at the expiration of the imprisonment to which he
was previously sentenced. Going by this normal principle, the sentence
chart indicated in the communication dated 27.05.2016 is quite correct.
However this normal rule is subject to a qualification and it is within the
1-1
BENSON v. STATE OF KERALA
[UDAY UMESH LAUT, J.]
175
powers of the Court to direct that the subsequent sentence shall run
concurrently with the previous sentence.
A
7. In V.K.Bansal v. State of Haryww amt A11otl1er 1 it was
stated by th is Court:
"It is manifest from Section 427(1) that the Court has the
power and the discretion to issue a direction but in the very
nature of the power so conferred upon the Court the
discretionary power shall have to be exercised along the
judicial lines and not in a mechanical, wooden or pedantic
manner. It is difficult to lay down any straitjacket approach
in the matter of exercise of such discretion by the courts.
There is no cut and dried formula for the Court to follow in
the matter of issue or refusal of a direction within the
contemplation of Section 427( I). Whether or not a direction
ought to be issued in a given case would depend upon the
nature of the offence or offences committed, and the fact
situation in which the question of concurrent running of the
sentences arises."
This Court then went on to club various crimes in respect of which
sentences were imposed upon the appellant therein in three groups; i)
the first having 12 cases, ii) the second having 2 cases and iii) the third
having a single case. This Court directed that substantive sentences
within first two groups would run inter se concun-ently and the substantive
sentences in first two groups and that in respect of the case in the third
group would run consecutively. The benefit was confined only in respect
of substantive sentences and no qua sentences in default.
8. We have gone through the record and considered rival
submissions. We do not find anything incorrect in the assessment made
by the Courts below and in our view the orders of conviction recorded
against the appellant in the present cases are quite correct. We also do
not find anything wrong in the quantum of sentence imposed in respect
of the respective crimes. However going by the sentence calculation,
the sentence imposed in respect of the first crime sta1ied with effect
from 20.11.2003 and the last sentence would be over by 19.08.2022,
which would effectively mean that the total length of sentences in
aggregate would be around 19 years. We are not concerned with first
1
(2013) 7 sec 211
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
176
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 8 S.C.R.
eight matters and sentences imposed in respect of those crimes. The
sentence in respect of 8'h crime is presently running against the appellant
and would be over on 30.08.2017.
9. The maximum sentence in respect of the present crimes is two
years' rigorous imprisonment. As per the record, these crimes were
committed on the same day. Having considered the matters, we deem it
appropriate to direct that the sentences imposed in each of the cases,
i.e. (i) CC No.158 of2004, (ii) CC No. I 039 of2003, (iii) CC No. 390 of
2004 and (iv) CC No. 1168 of 2006 namely those at Sl.Nos.9 to 12
respectively as indicated in the sentence chart in the communication
dated 27.05.2016 shall run concurrently with the sentence imposed in
Crime No.8 which is currently operative. We grant this benefit in respect
of substantive sentences to the appellant but maintain the sentences of
fine and the default sentences. If the fine as imposed is not deposited,
the default sentence or sentences will run consecutively and not
concurrently.
I 0. The appeals are thus allowed in part and the orders of sentences
stand modified accordingly.
Ankit Gyan
Appeals partly allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org