UNION OF INDIA versus MOHANLAL & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 28 January 2016 | [2016] 1 S.C.R. 651 | 2015 INSC 808
Key facts
- Decided
- 28 January 2016
- Bench
- T.S. THAKUR*, KURIAN JOSEPH
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 652/2012
- Citation
- [2016] 1 S.C.R. 651
- Neutral citation
- 2015 INSC 808
Text of the judgment
[2016) 1 S.C.R. 651
UNION OF INDIA
A
v.
MOHANLAL & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal No. 652 of2012)
JANUARY 28, 2016
B
[T. S. THAKUR, CJI. AND KURIAN JOSEPH, J.)
National Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 s.52A - Seizure, storage and disposal of psychotropic substances Standing Order 1189 dated 13.6.1989 prescribing procedure for
conducting seizure and disposal of the contraband - Standing orders c
dated 10.5.2007 a71d 16.1.2015 prescribing procedure for disposal
and destruction of seized contraband - Non-observance of uniform
practice or procedure by the States or the Central Agencies in the
matter of drawing samples - No provision in the Act regulating
storage of the contraband- Standing Order dated 16.1.2015 not D
superseding the previous Standing Order 1189 - Held: There is no
provision in the Act mandating taking ofsamples at the time of seizure
- There is conflict between statutory provision and the standing
order regarding taking of samples - Central Government directed .
to re-examine the matter and take suitable steps in this direction An application for sampling and certification needs to be made E
without undue delay and .the Magistrate on receipt of any such
application is expected to attend to ·the application within reasonable
period without undue delay - High Courts to keep a close watch on
the performance of the Magistrates - Central Government and the
State agencies have not established any notified storage faci/ity- F
godown for storage of seized drugs with proper system of supervision
and control over the stored drugs - Such failure shows a complete
failure bordering criminal negligence by officers who are supposed
to be taking action in this regard - Direction issued to the Central
Government and State agencies to set up adequate storage facilities
with effective supervisory and regulatory controls as prescribed G
under standing Order 1189 - The Standing Order 1189 would be
treated to have been superseded to the extent the subsequent
Standing Order dated 16.01.2015 prescribes a different procedure
for destruction/disposal of seized contrabands - Direction to dispose
of the contraband in the manner specified in the present judgment H
651
652
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] l S.C.R.
- The Chief Justices of the High Courts are requested to appoint a
Committee of Judges on the administrative side to supervise and
monitor progress made by the respective States in regard to the
compliance with the direction in the- present case.
Ad,journing the matter, the Court
HELD: 1.1 Section 52-A(l) of the National Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 empowers the Central
Government to prescribe by a Notification the procedure to be
followed for seizure, storage and disposal of drugs and
psychotropic substances. The Central Government have in
exercise of that power issued Standing Order No. 1189 which
prescribes the procedure to be followed while conducting seizure
of the contraband. Two subsequent stantling orders one dated
10.05.2007 and the other dated 16.01.2015 deal with disposal
and destruction of seized contraband and do not alter or add to
the earlier standing order that prescribes the procedure for
conducting seizures. [Para 11] [683-F-H]
1.2 Para 2.2 of the Standing Order 1/89 states that samples
must be taken from the seized contrabands on the spot at the
time of recovery itself. There is no uniform practice or procedure
being followed by the States or the Central agencies in the matter
of drawing of samples. This is, therefore, an area that needs to
be suitably addressed in the light of the statutory provisions which
ought to b" strictly observed given the seriousness of the offences
under the Act and the punishment prescribed by law in case the
same are proved. The Court proposes to deal with the issue in
an attempt to remove the confusion that prevails regarding the
true position as regards drawing of samples. [Para 11] [683-H;
684-A, DJ
1.3 Section 52A as amended by Act 16 of 2014, deals with
disposal of seized drugs and psychotropic substances. In view of
s. 52A(2)(c) no sooner the seizure is effected and the contraband
forwarded to the officer in charge of the Police Station or the
officer empowered, the officer concerned is, in law, duty hound
to approach the Magistrate for the purposes of (a) certifying the
correctness of the inventory (b) certifying photographs of such
drugs or substances taken before the Magistrate as true and (c)
to draw representative samples in the presence of the Magistrate
and certifying the correctness of the list of samples so drawn.
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL
653
These samples are then to be enlisted and the correctness of the
list of samples so drawn certified by the Magistrate. Thus, the
process of drawing of samples has to be in the presence and under
the supervision of the Magistrate and the entire exercise has to
be certified by him to be correct. The question of drawing of
samples at the time of seizure which, more often than not, takes
place in the absence of the Magistrate does not in the above
scheme of things arise. This is so especially when according to
Section 52-A(4) of the Act, samples drawn and certified by the
Magistrate in compliance with sub-section (2) and (3) of Section
52-A above constitute primary evidence for the purpose of the
trial. There is no provision in the Act that mandates taking of
samples at the time of seizure. That is perhaps why none of the
States claim to be taking samples at the time of seizure. [Paras
12, 13) (684-E; 685-G-H; 686-A-D]
1.4 A conflict between the statutory provision governing
taking of samples and the standing order issued by the Central
Government is evident when the two are placed in juxtaposition.
There is no gainsaid that such a conflict shall have to be resolved
in favour of the statute on first principles of interpretation but
the continuance of the statutory notification in its present form is
bound to create confusion in the minds of.the authorities
concerned instead of helping them in the discharge of their duties.
The Central Government would, therefore, do well, to re-examine
the matter and take suitable steps in the above direction. [Para
13] (686-E-F)
1.5. There is no manner of doubt that the seizure of the
contraband must be followed by an application for drawing of
samples and certification as contemplated under the Act. There
is equally no doubt thatthe process of making any such application
and resultant sampling and certification cannot be left to the whim•
of the officers concerned. The scheme of the Act in general a,- _
Section 52-A in particular, does not brook any delay in the matte;
of making of an application or the drawing of samples and
certification. While, there is no room for prescribing or reading a
time frame into the provision, an application for sampling and
certification ought to be made without undue delay and the
Magistrate on receipt of any such application will be expected to
attend to the application and do the needful, within a reasonable
period and without any undue delay or procrastination as is
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
654
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016) I S.C.R.
mandated by sub-section (3) of Section 52A. The High Courts
will keep a close watch on the performance of the Magistrates in
this regard and through the Magistrates on the agencies that are
dealing with the menace of drugs which has taken alarming
dimensions in the country partly because of the ineffective and
lackadaisical enforcement of the laws and procedures and cavalier
manner in which the agencies and at times Magistracy in the
country addresses a problem of such serious dimensions. [Para
14] [686-H; 687-A-D]
1.6 No sooner the seizure of any Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances is
effected, the same shall be forwarded to the officer in-charge of
the nearest police station or to the officer empowered under
Section 53 of the Act. The officer concerned shall then approach
the Magistrate with an application under Section 52A(ii) of the
Act, which shall be allowed by the Magistrate as soon as may be
required under Sub-Section 3 of Section 52A. The sampling shall
be done under the supervision of the magistrate. [Paras 19-20]
[695-B-D]
2.1 The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985 does not make any special provision regulating storage of
the contraband substances. All that Section 55 of the Act envisages
is that the officer in charge of a Police Station shall take charge of
and keep in safe custody the seized article pending orders of the
Magistrate concerned. There is no provision nor was any such
provision pointed out, prescribing the nature of the storage facility
to be used for storage of the contraband substances. Even so the
importance of adequate storage facilities for safe deposit and
storage of the contraband material has been recognised by the
Government inasmuch as Standing Order No.1/89 has made
specific provisions in regard to the same. Section III of the said
Order deals with "Receipt of Drugs in Godowns and Procedure"
which inter alia provides that all drugs shall invariably be stored
in "safes and vaults" provided with double locking system and
that the agencies of the Central and the State Governments may
specifically designate their godowns for storage purposes and
such godowns should be selected keeping in view their security
angle, juxtaposition to courts etc. [Para 15] [687-E-H; 688-A]
2.2 It is evident from a plain reading of para 3.2 of Section
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL
655
III of Order No.1/89 that storage of all drugs in safes and vaults
has been made mandatory and that agencies of the Central and
the State Governments h·ave been permitted to designate their
godowns for storage purposes. It is also clear that keeping in
view the importance of protecting the seized drugs against theft,
substitution or pilferage the Central Government has prescribed
that such godowns shall be placed under the overall supervision
and charge of a gazetted officer of the respective enforcement
agencies who shall exercise utmost care, circumspection and
personal supervision over the storage facilities. The provision
contained in paras 3.5, 3.6, 3.7 and 3.8 also are aimed at ensuring
that the godown or storage facility is satisfactory and those incharge of the same are made accountable for its upkeep and
effective management. Subsequent Notification including
Notification dated 16'' January, 2015 have in no way diluted the
above requirement. The result is that there is a statutory
framework which governs the storage of drugs and matters
relating and incidental thereto. [Para 15] [689-C-F]
A
2.3 The said statutory mechanism has been effectively
implemented by the Central Government agencies and by the
State Governments. It is evident from the responses received
from the State and the Central Government agencies that no
notified storage facility-godown has been established for storage
of the seized drugs. Even after a lapse of 26 years since Standing
Order No. 1189 was issued, the Central Government or its
agencies and the State Governments have paid little or no
attention to. the need for providing adequate storage facilities of
the kind stipulated in Standing Order No. 1/89 with the necessary
supervisory and other controls prescribed in Section III of the
said order. The failure on the part of the Central Government
and the State Governments to provide for such storage I·
defeated, if not completely negated the very purpose underlyir _,
the said notification and the provisions made therein. There is as
on date hardly any credible protection against theft, replacement,
pilferage and destruction of the seized drugs on account of the
wholly unsatisfactory and unscientific method of storage of drugs
and psychotropic substances. [Para 15] [689-F-G; 690-A-D]
2.4 There is a complete failure on the part of the Central
Government and its agencies as also the State Governments in
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
656
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] l S.C.R.
taking adequate steps for providing proper storage facilities with
proper system of supervision and control over the drugs that are
stored in the same. [Para 15] [690-F]
2.5 The fact that the States and the Central Government
agencies have accepted that no specific register is maintained by
the State Police and that general maalkhana register alone is being
maintained for the seized drugs shows the neglect of all concerned
towards this important aspect and the cavalier manner in which
the issue regarding storage of ceased drugs is approached by
them. Absence of periodical inspection of the storage facility
and the absence of any record suggesting that any inspection has
been carried out by any of the officers shows a complete failure
bordering criminal negligence by officers who are supposed to
be taking action in this regard but have failed to do so. (Para 15]
J690-H; 691-A-BJ
.
2.6 Appropriate directions are issued to the Central
Government agencies and to the States to set up adequate storage
facilities with effective supervisory and regulatory controls as
prescribed in Notification No. 1/89. [Para 16] [691-F]
2. 7 The Central Government and its agencies and so also
the State Governments shall within six months from the date of
the present judgment take appropriate steps to set up storage
facilities for the exclusive storage of seized Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances duly
equipped with vaults and double locking system to prevent theft,
pilferage or replacement of the seized drugs. The Central
Government and the State Governments shall also designate an
officer each for their respective storage facility aud provide for
other steps, measures as stipulated in Standing Order No. 1/89
to ensure proper security against theft, pilferage or replacement
of the seized drugs. [Para 20] [695-E-F]
2 .8 The Central Government and the State Governments
shall be free to set up a storage facility for each district in the
States and depending upon the extent of seizure and store
required, one storage facility for more thau one districts. (Para
20] (695-G]
3.1 Section 52A as amended provides for disposal of the
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL
657
seized contraband in the manner stipulated by the Government
under Clause 1 of that Section. Notification dated 16" January,
2015 has, in supersession of the earlier notification dated lO'h
May, 2007 not only stipulates that all drugs and psychotropic
substances have to be disposed off but also identifies the officers
who shall initiate action for disposal and the procedure to be
followed for such disposal. Para 4 of the Notification inter alia,
provides that officer-in-charge of the Police Station shall within
30 days from the date of receipt of chemical analysis report of
drugs, psychotropic substances or controlled substances apply
to any Magistrate under Section 52A(2) in terms of Annexure 2
to the said Notification. [Para 17] [691-G-H; 692-A-B]
A
3.2 The notification dated 16'h January, 2015 does not in
terms supersede Standing Order No. 1/89 insofar as the said
Standing Order also prescribes the procedure to be followed for
disposal of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled
Substances and Conveyances. Specific overriding of the earlier
Standing Order would have avoided a certain amount of confusion
which is evident on account of simultaneous presence of Standing
Order No.1189 and notification dated 16" January, 2015. To the
extent the subsequent notification prescribes a different
procedure, the earlier notification/Standing Order No.1/89 would
be treated to have been superseded. In order to avoid any
confusion arising out of the continued presence of two notifications
on the same subject it is clarified that disposal of Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances
shall be carried out in the manner specified/provided by this
judgment, till such time the Government prescribes a different
procedure for the same. [Para 19] [692-G-H; 693-D-E]
3.3 In respect of cases where the trial is concluded and
proceedings in appeal/revision have all concluded finally, before
29" May, 1989, it is directed that the Drugs Disposal Committees
of the States and the Central agencies shall take stock of all such
seized contrabands and take steps for their disposal without any
further verification, testing or sampling whatsoever. In the cases
where the drugs that are seized after May, 1989 and where the
trial and appeal and revision have also been finally disposed of,
The DDCs shall accordingly take stock of all such Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances in
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
658
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 1 S.C.R.
relation to which the trial of the accused persons has finally
concluded and the proceedings have attained finality at all levels
in the judicial hierarchy. The DDCs shall then take steps to have
such stock also destroyed under the direct supervision of the
head of the Department concerned. In the cases in which the
proceedings are still pending before the Courts at the level of
trial court, appellate court or before the Supreme Court, the heads
of the Department concerned shall ensure that appropriate
applications are moved by the officers competent to do so under
Notification dated 16" January, 2015 before the Drugs Disposal
Committees concerned and steps for disposal of such Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and
Conveyances taken without any further loss of time. [Para 19]
[693-i<; 694-A-D, F-H; 695-A)
4. The Chief Justices of the High Courts concerned are
requested to appoint a Committee. of Judges on the
administrative side to supervise and monitor progress made by
the respective States in regard to the compliance with the above
directions and wherever necessary, to issue appropriate directions
for a speedy action on the administrative and even on the judicial
side in public interest wherever considered necessary. [Para 21]
(696-B)
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal
No. 652 of2012
From the Judgment and Order dated 05.01.2010 of the High Court
ofM. P. in Criminal Appeal No. 193 of2008.
F
G
H
Ranjit Kumar, SG, Ajit Kumar Sinha, (A.C.), A. K. Panda, Binu
Tamta, Sushma Manchanda, Pravesh Thakur, Manish Vashishtha, D.S.
Mahra, Shreekant N. Terdal for the Appellant.
Sharwan Dogra, Adv. Gen., Suryanarayana Singh, Sr. Addi. Adv.
Gen., Gopal Singh, Rituraj Biswas, Sibo Sankar Mishra, Niranjan Sahu,
Pardeep Kumar (for Corporate Law Group), Hemantika Wahi, Jesal
Wahi, Preetika Dwivedi,Abhinav Mukerji, Ravi Prakash Mehrotra, Sanjay
Sharawat for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
T. S. THAKUR, CJI. I. When this appeal came up for hearing
before us on 11 'h April, 2012, it was contended by learned counsel for
the appellant-Union of India that Standing Order No. I of 1989 dated
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
659
13"' June, 1989 which prescribes the procedure to be followed for seizure,
sampling, safe keeping and disposal of the seized Drugs, Narcotics and
Psychotropic substances is being followed throughout the country. It
was also contended that Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue,
Government of India, has in terms of a Circular dated 23" February,
2011 impressed upon the Chief Secretaries and the concerned police
heads of the State Governments to ensure that instructions given and
the procedure prescribed in the Standing Order aforementioned was
strictly adhered to. These submissions notwithstanding, doubts about the
procedure being actually followed persisted. Pilferage of the contraband
goods and their return to the market place for circulation being a major
hazard, this Court appointed Mr. Ajit Kumar Sinha, Senior Advocate, as
Amicus Curiae, with a view to making a realistic review of the procedure
for search, disposal or destruction of the narcotics and the remedial
steps that need to be taken to plug the loopholes, if any.
A
2. On 3" July, 2012 this Court after hearing the Amicus Curiae
prima facie came to the conclusion that the procedure prescribed for the
destruction of the contraband seized in different States was not being
followed resulting in a very piquant situation in which accumulation of
huge quantities of the seized drugs and narcotics has increased manifold
the chances of their pilferage for re-circulation in the market. This Court
also noted a report published in the timesofindia.indiatimes.com under.
the heading "Bathinda's police stores bursting at seams with seized
narcotics" from which it appeared that large quantities of seized drugs
had accumulated over the years including opium, poppy husk, charas
etc. apart from modem narcotic substances. The report suggested that
39 lakhs sedatives and narcotic tablets, 1.10 lakhs capsules, over 21,000
drug syrups and 1828 sedative injections apart from 8 kgs. of smack and
84 kgs. of ganja were awaiting disposal in Bathinda Police stores alone.
The position was, according to Mr. Sinha, no better in other States
especially those situate along the international bprders. It was argued by
the Amicus Curiae that without proper data from the authorities
concerned, it was not possible to take stock of the magnitude of the
problem no matter challenges posed by rampant drug abuse had acquired
alarming proportions affecting the youth, some of whom are driven to
commission of crimes on account of deleterious effects of drug abuse.
B
c
D
E
F
G
3. It was in the above backdrop that by an order dated 3'' July,
2012 passed in Criminal Appeal No.652 of 2012 this Court directed
H
660
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] I S.C.R.
collection of information from the police heads of each one of the States
through the Chief Secretaries concerned in regard to seizure, storage,
disposal and destruction of the seized contraband and judicial supervision
over the same. Specific queries were formulated in the order passed by
us with a direction to the Chief Secretaries of the States concerned to
serve the same upon the Directors General of Police for a report to be
forwardf:d through the Registrars General of the High Courts of the
States concerned who were appointed Nodal Officers for that purpose.
Registrars General were also asked to independently secure from the
District and Sessions Judges concerned in their respective States, answers
to the queries specified under the head "Judicial Supervision". Chiefs of
Central Government Agencies viz. Narcotics Control Bureau, Central
Bureau of Narcotics, Directorate General of Revenue Intelligence and
Commissionerates of Customs & Central Excise including the lndian
Coast Guard were directed to issue similar queries to the officers
concerned and to submit their respective reports detailing the information
required in terms of the orders passed by this Court. The queries raised
by this Court were in the following words:
"12.J. Seizure
E
F
(i) What narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances (natural
and synthetic) have been seized in the last JO years and in
what quantity? Provide yearwise and districtwise details of
the seizure made by the relevant authority.
(ii) What are the steps, if any, taken by the seizing authorities
to prevent damage, loss and pilferage of the narcotic drugs
and psychotropic substances (natural and synthetic) during
seizure/transit?
(iii) What are the circulars/notifications/directions/guidelines,
if any, issued to competent officers to follow any specific
procedure in regard to seizure of contrabands, their storage
and destruction? Copies of the same be attached to the report.
G
12.2. Storage
(i) Is there any specified/notified store for storage of the seized
contraband in a State, if so, is the storage space available in
each district or ta/uka?
H
(ii) If a store/storage space is not available in each district or
taluka, where is the contraband sent for storage purposes?
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
Under what conditions is withdrawal of the contraband
permissible ani whether a court order is obtained for such
withdrawal?
(iii) What are the steps taken at the time ofstorage to determine
the nature and quantity of the substance being stored and
what are the measures taken to prevent substitution and
pilferage from the stores?
(iv) Is there any check stock register maintained at the site of
storage and if so, by whom? Is there any periodical check of
such register? If so, by whom? Is any record regarding such
periodic inspection maintained and in what form?
661
A
B
c
(v) What is the condition of the storage facilities at present?
Is there any shortage of space or any other infrastructure
lacking? What steps have been taken or are being taken to
remove the deficiencies, if any?
(vi) Have any circulars/notifications/directions/guidelines
been issued to competent officers for care and caution to be
exercised during storage? Ifso, a copy of the same be
produced.
D
12.3. Disposal/Destruction
(i) What narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances (natural
and synthetic) have been destroyed in the last JO years and
in what quantity? Provide yearwise and districtwise details
of the destruction made by the relevant authority. If no
destruction has taken place, the reason therefor.
(ii) Who is authorised to apply for permission of the court to
destroy the seized contraband? Has there been any failure or
dereliction in making such applications? Whether any person
having technical knowledge of narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances (natural and synthetic) is associated
with the actual process of destruction of the contraband?
E
F
G
(iii) Was any action taken against the person who should have
applied for permission to destroy the drugs or should have
destroyed and did not do so?
(iv) What are the steps taken at the time of destruction to
determine the nature and quantity of the substance being
H
662
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] I S.C.R.
A
destroyed?
B
(v) What are the steps taken by competent alllhorities to prevent
damage, loss, pilferage and tampering/substitution of the
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances (natural and
synthetic) during transit from point of storage to point of
destruction?
(vi) Is there any specified facility for destruction of
contraband in the State? If so, a list of such facilities along
with location and details of maintenance, conditions and
supervisory bodies be provided.
c
D
(vii) If a facility is not available, where is the contraband
sent for destruction purposes? Under whose supervision and
what is the entire procedure thereof?
(viii) Is any record. electronic or othen<•ise prepared at the
site of destruction of the contraband and by whom? Is there
any periodical check of such record? What are the ranks/
designation of the supervising officers charged with keeping
a check on the same>
12.4. Judicial supervision
E
F
G
(i) Is any inspection done by the District and Sessions Judge
of the store where the seized drugs are kept? If drugs are
lying in the store, has the Sessions Judge taken steps to have
them destroyed?
(ii) JS any report of the inspection conducted, submitted to
the Administrative Judge of the High Court or the Registry of
the High Court? If so, has any action on the subject being
taken for timely inspection and destruction of the drugs?
(iii) Are there any pending applications for destruction of
drugs in the district concerned, if so, what is the reason for
the delay in the disposal of such application?
(iv) What level officers including the judicial officers are
associated with the process of destruction?
H
(v) At what stages are the Magistrates/judicial officers/any
other officer of the court associated with seizure/storage/
destruction of drugs?
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
(vi) Are there any rules framed by the Court regarding its
supervisory role in enforcement of the NDPS Act as regards
seizure/storage/destruction of drugs?
663
A
(vii) What is the average time for completion of trial of NDPS
matters?"
4. In compliance with the above directions, reports have been
submitted by all the States except the States of Arunachal Pradesh,
Jammu and Kashmir, Dadar & Nagar Haveli, Lakshadweep, Nagaland
and Pondicherry. From a perusal of the reports so received the position
that emerges in regard to disposal/destruction of narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substance qua each State· for the last I 0 years may be
summarised as under:
B
c
DETAILS OF SEIZURE AND DISPOSAL OF DRUGS
(STATEWISE)
I.
ANDHRA PRADESH
Tgtal
Quantity
!!~strayed (in 10
vears\
39I0.70 Kg
Difference
Ganja
Total Quanti!x
Seized (In 10
years)
2,20,977.191 Kg
Opium
22.925 kg
0
22.925 Kg (I 00%)
Charas
6.5 kg
0
6.5 kg (JOO%)
Cocaine
851.0% kg
0
851.096 kg (I 00%)
85.125 kg+ 103
Capsules + 81
Injections 26
0
Item
.
_ Others
'·
D
217066.491 kg
(98.23%)
E
F
Amp
2.
ASSAM
(The Information pertains only to the period of 2010-2012)
Item
Total Quanti!l: Total Quantitv Difference
Seizeel (In 10 Destrol'.ecl (in
years)
10:1'.ears}
Ganja
203.54 Kg
136Kg
G
67.54 (33.18%)
H
664
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
Heroin
.614 kg
0
Opium
30gms
755662
0
41472 Nos.
Others
B
3.
(2016] I S.C.R.
.214 Kg
(34.853%)
30 !!!TIS {I 00%)
714190Nos.
(94.5%)
BIHAR
Item
c
D
Difference
Ganja
Total Quanti!l: Total Quantitt
Seized (!n 10 Destrol'.ed (in
vears)
lOvears)
45Kg
0
Heroin
3.74 kg
0
3.74 kg
Charas
48.853 kg
0
48.853 kg
Poppy
Straws
Methqu
alone
100 kgs
0
100 kgs
1676 kgs
0
1676 kgs
45 kg
Note:- No destruction of narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances have taken place at Patna zonal unit.
E
4.
CHHATTISGARH
.!W!!.
F
Ganja
Total Quantit~
Seized (In IO
years)
Total Quant it~
Destroyed (in 10
years)
Di[ference
1,03.622.140 kg
3281.570 kg
1,00,340 .57
(96.77%)
52098 (Nos)
(92.7%)
3.129 kg ( 100%)
Kg
G
H
Cannabis
Plants
Brown
Sugar
Opium
Opium
Ponov Plant
Green
Opium Plant
52478 (Nos)
380 (Nos)
3.120 kg
0
1.460 kg
1558 pieces
0
3600 kg
0
0
1.460 kg ( 100%)
1558 pieces
(100%)
3600 kg ( 100%)
5.
UNION OF !NOIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
665
CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE
A
Item
Opium
6.
Total Quantity
Seized (!n 10
vears)
367.007kg
Morphine
58.393 kg
Heroine
1658.099 kg
Ganja
484124.056 kg
Hashish
77350.076 kg
Cocaine
640.569 kg
Total Quantity Difference
Destroyed (in
10 years)
Destroyed
658.525 kg
more than
seized
190 kg+ 88930 58.203 kg
(99.6%)
Pcs lni ections
739.687 kg
918.412kg
(55.3%)
8,43,008.559
Destroyed
kg
more than
seized
12298.578 kg
Destroyed
more than
seized
640.569 kg
0
(100%)
B
c
D
CHANDIGARH
Total Quantity
Seized (!n 10
vears\
Contraband By relevant
authorities
3205.623 Kgs
Morphine
58.393 kg
Item
Heroine
1658.099 kg
Ganja
484124.056 kg
Total Quantity Difference
Destroyed (in
lOvearsl
900.179 Kgs
2305 .444 Kgs
(71%)
E
\ 90kg + 88930
Pcs Iniections
739.687 kg
F
8,43,008.559
kg
Hashish
77350.076 kg
12298.578 kg
Cocaine
640.569 kg
0
58.203 kg
(99.6%)
918.412 kg
(55.3%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
Destroyed
more than
seized
640.569 kg
(l 00"/o)
G
H
666
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
7.
•
B
•
DELHI
Delhi has provided two responses. One response has been
provided by the NCB, Delhi and the other by the police heads
of each of the district.
The response by NCB, Delhi is as follows:-
Item
Contraband
c
•
D
F
Contraband
(Hashish,
Cocaine,
Ganja,
Heroin etc.)
Contrabands
(Chemical
Substances in
Tablets,
lniections)
Difference
8211.4613
kg(92.34%)
I2tal Quagtijy Il!tal Quantijy
~ized (In IQ De~tr2yi:d (in
years)
10 years}
By
relevant
authorities
52944.577 kg
32443.456 kg
Qiffui:nce
1020669
1020669
(100%)
0
20500.601
(38.72%)
8.
DAMAN AND DIU
The UT Daman and Diu has informed the Total quantity by way of a
detailed chart:
lli.!!!.
G
Contraband
H
Total Quantity Total Quantity
Seized (In 10 Destroyed (in
vears\
10 vears\
8891.8373
680.376 kg
The Response by the police heads are as follows:-
lilln
E
[2016] l S.C.R.
Total Quantity Total Quanti!Y
Seized (In 10 Destroyed (in
10 l'.earsj
ll.!Wl
relevant
By
authorities
000 kgs
25.827 kgs
Difference
25.827 Kgs
(100%)
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
667
9.
DIRECTORATE OF REVENUE INTELLIGENCE
Total
Item
Quantitv Total Quanti~ Difference
Sei:red {!n 10 Destroyed {in
years) By relevant 10 years}
authorities
Contraband 174185.687kg
2859.448 Kg
171326.23
9 198.3%)
A
GUJARAT
• The Response of the state is divided into two parts.
•One has been provided by the office of the Ministry of Home Affairs.
• As per the said response the total amount of contraband seized
in 10 years are 28340.047 Kg. No division of the type has been
provided.
• The total destruction in the last IO years however is only 132.375 Kg
• The total amount of Contraband sti II in custody of the atrthorities is
28207.672 Kgs, i.e. 99.53% of the seized amount.
•The response of the NCB Zonal Unit is as follows:
B
10.
Item
Charas
Total Quantity
Seized {!n 10
vearS\
1421.14 kg
Opium
17.505 kg
Brown Sugar 2.03 kg
Heroin
3.066 kg
Others
3766.126 kg+
299 ltrs. + 1022
Tablets
Total Ouantitv Difference
Destroyed {in
10 vearsl
1406.084 kg
15.056 kgs
(98.9%)
17.505 kg
0
( 100%)
0
2.03 kg
( 100%)
0 (981 gms of 3.066 kg
(100%)
Heroin was
destroyed in
2000, however
all the seizures
have been made
oost2003)
525 kgs
3241.126 kgs
(86.05%) +
229 ltrs
( 100%)+
1022 Tablets
( 100%)
c
D
E
F
G
H
668
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] I S.C.R.
11.
GOA
The UT Chandigarh has informed the Total quantity by way.of a
detailed chart:
Item
Total Quantit:i: Total Quantit:i: Difference
Seized !}n 10 Destro:i:ed {in
:i:ears)
By 10 :i:ears}
relevant
authorities
Contraband 548.746 kg.>.
000 kgs
548.7476
kgs ( 100"/o)
12.
HARYANA
Total Quantit:i:
Item
Seized {In 10
vears\
2604.077 kg
Ganja
Total Quantit:i: Difference
Destro:i:ed {in
10 vears\
521.133 kg
2082.944 kg
(79%)
D
E
F
G
H
Charas
7252513 kg
533.46 kg
Opium
1086387 kg
1972.860
Smack
8200.00 kg
4169.919 kg
Heroine
1.046 kg
1.300 kg
Brown Sugar
2.001 kg
1.003 kg
Cocaine
325 kg
0
6719.053 kg
(92.64%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
4030.081 kg
(49.14%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
998 kg
(49.87°/o)
.325 kg
( 100%\
13.
HIMAO-IALPRADESH
1l1e State ofHimachal Pradesh has infom1ed the Total quantity
biyway of a detai'l ed c11art:
TQl:al Quantit:i: Total Quantitx Differenci:
Item
Seized (In 10 Destro:i:ed {in
10 vears)
vears\
15169.801
1856.913
17026.714
Contraband
(89.09%)
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJI.]
14
A
JHARKHAND
Ganja
Total Quantity
Seized (In 10
vears)
1793.381 kg
Opium
360.59 kg
Brown Sugar
1.576 kg
Heroine
546 kg
Item
669
Total Q!!antity Difference
Destro:i:ed (in
lOyears}
0 (area of
1793.381 kg
(100%)
cultivation has
been destroved)
360.59 kg
0
(100%)
l.576 kg
0
(100%)
0
546 kg
(100%)
B
c
KERALA
Item
Total Quanti!}: Total Quanti!l; Difference
Seized {In 10 Destro:i:ed {in
years}
10 years)
15.
Ganja
7588.543 Kg
2740.926 kg
Heroine
.536 kg
0
Hashish
12.368 kg
0
Charas
.063 kg
0
Brown Sugar
8.432 kg
12.058 kg
Opium
23.697 kg
0
16.
•
4847.617kg
(63.88%)
.536 kg
(100%)
12.368
(100%)
.063 kg
(100%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
23.697 kg
(100%)
D
E
F
KARNATAKA
The state of Karnataka divided its response in two parts. One is
seizure by Police and the Other is seizure by NCB
Item
Contraband
Total Quanti!Y
Seized {In 10
vears)
ByNCB
366.838 Kgs
By relevant
authorities
27291.633 Kl!S
Total QuantiJx Difference
Destro:i:ed {in
10 vears)
OOOkgs
12140.592
366.838
Kgs(l00%)
15151.041
(55%)
G
H
670
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
17.
Item
B
c
MAHARASHTRA
Total Quanti!Y
Seized (In IO
.
vearsl
(2016) I S.C.R.
Total Quanti!Y
Destroyed (in
10 vearsl
Difference
1,14,074 kg
(92.33%)
426 kg
(65.13%)
1893.165
(80.05%)
565.909 kg
(92.31%)
11.049 kg
(100%)
Ganja
1,14.082 kg
8750 kg
Heroin
654 kg
228 kg
Charas
2364.\XJ kg
471.735
Opium
613.044 kg
47.135 kg
Cocaine
11.049 kg
0 kg
18
MANIPUR
Item
Total Quantity Total Quanti!l' Difference
Seized (In 10 Destro:yed (in
years)
10 :years}
D
Heroin
37.534 kg.
12.498 kg
Ganja
45343.25kg
41963.389 kg
(Kindly reter
to the Notel
E
F
Opium
233.985 kg
233.985 kg
(100%)
3.05 kg(I00%)
3.05 kg
0
Hashish
Note: The Total amount of Ganja seized post 2005 was 25913.225
kgs and the same is still lying with the authorities since the last
pretrial disposal in 2005.
19. MADHYA PRADESH
•
Madhya Pradesh has divided its response in two pat1s. One
is seizure by Police and the other is seizure by NCB.
Item
G
Contraband
Tutal Quanti!Y
Seized {!n IO
vears) In Kus
By Police-
Total
004376.528
61384.805
BYNCB
H
0
25.036 kg
(66.072%)
3379.861 kg
(7.45%)
348 kg
Quantity Difference
Destroi;~ (in lO
Ki:s
vears) In Kus
By Police
By Police-
m
742991.723
Kgs (92%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
671
A
Ministr of Home Affairs NCB
20.
Total Quantity Total Quan tit)'.
Item
Seized {In 10 Destroyed {in 10
)'.ears)
!'.ears)
Difference
B
By relevant
authorities
Contraband
44 76.482 kgs
5344.12 Kgs.
867.638
(16%)
21.
ORISSA
•
Orissa has divided its response in two parts. One is se.izure
by Pol ice and the Other is seizure by Excise Officials.
Item
Contraband
Total Quan tit)'. Total Quan tit)'.
Seized {In 10 Destro:i:ed {in 10
years)
years)
Difference
By Police
88241.741 Kgs
0.000
Bv Excise
34520.854 Kgs
(100%)
0.000
By Police88241.741
Kgs
(100%)
By Excise
34520.854
Kgs
(100%)
22.
PUNJAB
Item
Tutal Quantity Total Quan tit)'.
Seized {In 10 Destroved (in lO
i:ears)
years)
Poppy Husk
8,93,948.452 kg
Onium
4936.031 ke
- -
Smack
-
---·~
-- - - -
20045.293 kg
c
D
Difference
E
F
4,00,678.069 kg
4,93,270.3
83 kg
(55.°17%)
965.818 k!!
3970.213
kg
-·---- . _(80.43%)
104.631 kg
19940.662
(99.47%)
G
H
672
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
23. RAJASIHAN
'Item
Tut al Quantity Total Quanti!:£ Difference
Seized {!n 10 Destroyed (in
years)
IO years)
Brown Sugar
146.996 kg
23.381 kg
Heroine
173.216 kg
3.25 kg
Smack
275.246 kg
82.423 kg
Opium
6687.081 kg
2006.745 kg
Charas
935.602 kg
1192.309
Ganja
176289.677 kg
2578.712 kg
Poppy Straw
99684.05 kgs
1.34,652.55 kg
c
D
E
F
G
[2016] I S.C.R.
123.615 kg
(84.094%)
169.966 kg
(98.12%\
192.823 kg
(70.05%)
4680.335 kg
(69.99%)
Destroyed
more than
seized
174250.965
kg (98.84%)
Destroyed
more than
seized.
24. SIKKIM
Item
Total Quanti!v Total Quanti!Y Difference
Seized (!n IO Destroyed (in
years)
Bv IO years)
relevant
authorities
N-IO Capsure
9156
**
Spasmo
Proxyvon
Cansule
Corex/
Phensidylerec
odex
Otllers
277367
••
3033
••
3033
(100%)
••
203.92gms .
9156
( 100%)
277367
(100%)
**The State Governn1ent of Sikkim has replied that the destruction rt done as
per the orders of the Trial Court on the conclusion of Trial. However, no
details related to disposal has been provided.
H
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
25.
673
A
TAMILNADU
tine
Total Quantit:y Difference
Total
Quan
Seized (!n 10 Destro:yed {in
vears)
10 vears)
19366.98 kg
637411.02 kg
Ganja(Dry 656778 kg
(97.051%)
+Green)
I
kg
12 kg
13
kg
Charas
(92.30%)
66.42 kg
66.425 kg
0
Heroin
Destroyed
15.4
kg
I
kg
Cocaine
more than
seized
0.015 kg
0
0.015 kg
Brown
( 100%)
Smmr
30.4
kg
l.738kg
29.262 kg
Opium
(96.25%)
I kg
JO kg
9 kg(90%)
Hash Oil
I 3627 vials
4095 vials
9532 vials
Tidigesic
(69.94%)
in.i.
I 12 amps
0
112amps
Norphine
( 100%)
9(100%)
9
0
Bosikka
4.5 I (kg or vial
Diazepam
9.085 kg+ 2706
not sure)
vials
Poppy
246.75 kg
125.05 kg
12l.7kg
Cap/Straws
(49.32%)
350 tabs+ 55
350 tabs+ 55 vials 0
Avil
vials
Item
26.
B
c
D
E
F
TRIPURA
Ganja
Total
Seized
vears)
9178.8
Ganja Dust
436 kg
Item
Quantitt Total Quantit:y Difference
(!n 10 Destro:yed {in
10 vears)
2642.5 kg
6536.3 kg
(71.21%)
349 kgs
87 kgs
(80.04%)
G
~
H
674
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
•
27. UITAR PRADESH
There is huge discrepancy between the Quantity seized and the Quantity
destroyed.
Opium
Total Quanti!l;
Seized {In lO
vearsl
1278.016 kg
Tgtal Quanlit~
Destroyed {in
10 vears)
198.025 kg
Smack
455.543 kg
244.443 kg
Heroin
503.664kg
13.759 kg
Ganja
92525.859
11,820.191 kg
Charas
9099.432 kg
2234.481 kg
Intoxicating
Powder (Cocaine)
Brown Sugar
3658.065 kg
1035.275 kg
51.455 kg
I.I kg
Posta Drug
16224.591 kg
5081.988 kg
.!1m!.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
[2016] I S.C.R.
28. UITARAKHAND
Total Quantitr Total Quantitr
lli!!!
Seized (In IO Des!ro~ed (in
vearsl
10 vearsl
1252.091 kg
330.459 kg
Charas
Doda
6783.765 kg
330.459 kg
Opium
28.899kg
1.859 kg
Heroine
154.454 kg
0
Intoxicating
224!3 Nos
4668 Nos.
Tablets
Ganja
ll21.740kg
508.300 kg
Smack
8.761kg+1022
packets
0.432 kg+ 530
Packets
Injection
1924 Nos
5 Nos.
Brown Sugar
.3 89 kg
0
J..!if(erenc£
1079.99 kg
(84.5%)
211.lkg
(46.3%)
489.905 kg
(97.2%)
80705.668 kg
(87.22%\
6864.951 kg
(75.44%)
2622.79 Kg
(71.69%)
51.355 kg
(99.8%\
11,142.603 kg
(68.67%)
Difference
921.632 kg
(73.60%)
6453.306
(95.12%)
27.04kg
(93.567%)
154.454 kg
(100%)
17745 Nos
(79.17%)
613.44 kg
(54.686%)
8.329 kg
(95.06%) + 492
Pkts 148.140%l
1919 Nos
(99.74%)
.389 kg (100%)
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
29
Item
A
WEST BENGAL
Total
Seized
Contraband
675
Quantit:Y
{In
10
l'ti!r~l D::r rs;levant
authn riths
88520.J JI 7 kg
Total
Quantitv
DestrOl'ed {in I 0
Difference
lill.W
0
88520.JJ 17
k[!(J00o/o1
Note:- West Be11gal ltas stated tltal it does not have atty i111111ediate records
B
available of destruction.
5. /11 regard to the storage of1VDPS ~;ubstances, !he State Governments and
the Central Agencies ha1'e furnished information ll'l11cli the learned Amicus
Curiae has tabulated as under:
Annexure D
Delhi Govt.
Yes. specified store for
storage of the seized
in
Delhi
contraband
Zonal Unit.
Imphal Go\•t.
Stored in god own
of NCB -1 after
sealing.
l\1eghalaya Go\'t.
Excise
Malkhana
is
generally used to store
contrabands.
All district Excise office
have
own
their
M alkhana rooms.
Himachal
c
G uiara t Govt.
specific
No
store.
Guwahati Govt.
NBC Gu wahati Zonal Unit
is running from a rented
house and one secured
room
is earmarked as
M izoram G O\'t,
storal!e nlace.
Tripura Govt.
s~ec ific
No specified store.
No
D
store
Uttar Pradesh
Govt.
UP
has
no
place
specific
for storage of
narcotic
the
drugs.
J\•I aha rash tra
Govt., Goa and
Daman Diu
No
specific
store
in
Maharashtra for storage.
In
Goa: Mala khan a
Police Station.
Cbhattisgarh
Govt.
separate
No
storage.
Rajasthan Govt.
Sikkim GO\'t.
llttarakhand Govt.
No specific store.
No storage.
No specific store.
Jbarkhand Govt.
Kerala Govt.
No specific store.
No
storae:e.
specific
at
Daman & Diu and Dadar
& Nagar Haveli: Kept in
M alkhn na Police Station.
Then sent to storage of
competent
Court
after
chargeshe et is filed.
A ndhra Pradesh
Govt.
No specified area.
Pradesh Govt.
No sp·ecified area.
E
F
G
Karnataka Govt.
No notified store.
H
676
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Orissa Govt.
Madhya Pradesh
Govt
Yes, NCB Zonal Unit No specific
Indore ahs ll'e II-secured store.
maalkhana
specific
(Submissions by NCB
Indore Zonal unit)
No specific Store for
storage after seizure by
Police
Station.
(Submissions by Police
Heads)
Punjab Govt.
Haryana Govt
No
store.
specified
D
Tamil Nadu
E
No Spedfic
space.
NCB, Jodhpur
Zone
F
storage
[2016] I S.C.R.
Bihar Govt
Patna Zonal Unit of NCB
has specified room
Withdrawal only under
order of the Court.
Chandigarh Govt.
Malkhana in all
police stations for
of
storage
contraband
Narcotics
Drugs
and Psychotropic
Substances.
A Room called Malkhana
is specifically designated
to keep
the
seized
contrabands.
Customs and
Central Excise
Directorate of Revenue
Intelligence
No specific storage
is available
own.
NCB, Chandigarh
Zone
No specific store of its
West Bengal
G
Yes, But no sub¥zone A separate room The seized goods are
available.
has been specified stored in Police Station
for storage of Malkhana under the charge
seized contraband.
of a designated Police
Officer and supeivision of
officer in charge of Police
Station.
H
6. Similarly, in answer to the query as to the steps taken at the time of
storage to detennine the nature and the quantity of the substance being
stored and measures to prevent substitution ancVor pilferage from the
stores, the State Governments have sent their replies which too have
been summarised by the Amicus Curiae in the following words:
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJI.]
A
ANNEXURE-F
iii.
Delhi
Govt.
Proper
entry in
1nalkha
na
register
and
malkha
na
incharg
e
and
proper!
y
locked
and
guarded
@Pg 10
of Delhi
Gort.
sub1niss
ion
What are the steps taken at the time of storage to
determine the nature and quantity of the substance being
store and measures to prevent substitution and pilferage
from stores?
Gujarat
Govt.
Writer
head
of
Police
station
maintains
Guwahati
Govt.
Imphal
Complete
process of
classificati
Complete
on and
Go,·t.
process of
classificati
on
and
weighing
weighing
of
drugs
-along with
complete
details.
All
subsequent
withdrawal
of drugs
along with
measures
of
prevention
of
and
pilferage
1nuddatnal
register
which
has
redisposition
are
also
mentioned
at
measures
of
prevention
of
pilferage
1nentioned
at
@ Pg. No.
l\'lizoram
Govt.
Utmost
care in
\Veighing
and
n1easurem
ents by
officer-incharge.
@page
IOI of
sub1n ission
s by
Mizora1n
Govt.
@
Pg.No.52
of
Imphal
register
@Pg.2
Guwahati
Govt.
Govt
submission
submission
1\1aharashtr
a Govt.,
Goa and
Daman Diu.
After
Contraband
Seizure
is
packed
the
and
kept
conccrne
safe
with
d drug is ,Mudden1al
weighed
Clerk
in
Subseque separate
11tly
a cupboard.
sa1nple is... @ Pg.6.
taken out
of
the Goa:
bag and Contraband
both arc
\Veighed
separate!
l-liin11ch·a1
Pradesh
Govt.
Cbhnttisg
a rh Go,·t.
NDPS is
seized by
investigati
ng ofl'icer.
After
san1ples
are taken,
the sa nle
is seized
by . 1.0.
affixing
his
seal and
latei
Details of
all steps to
determine
the nature
and
quantity
of
the
substance
being __
store and
of
Gujarat
of
Govt.
General
duty
of
detecting
officer to
weighi
seal
the
contra ban
d
\Vith
signatures
of civilian
\Yitnesses
with
proper
l! tta r
Pradesh
Govt.
c
ng
(q;Pg.No.
3 of
D
n by
Tripura
Govt.
E
submission
~ghalaya
B
register.
submissio ·
reflected
in
the
tnuddamal
74
Tripura
Govt.
Malkhana
officer
in charge
carefully
keeps the
contraban
ds in the
1nalkhana
after
maintaini
Govt.
entry in
677
o,vn
Andhra
Pradesh
G·ovt.
During
the
storage
the
details
F
are
entered
in
storage
roo1n
register.
St6re
G
y.
H
678
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
B
I
register - Both the
and Jock sample
it.
and main
@pg.7
stock are
Annex,wrapped
A-2
of in a piece
of cloth
Meghala
ya Govt. and
are
Submissi sealed.
I ~~----
c
D
E
F
G
Acc. To
Report of
Comm.
Of
Customs
@Pg.67:
Stored in
Central
Godown
in safes
and
vaults
with
double
locking
system
under
command
of
a
Gazetted
Officer..
sample is
sent
for
forensic
testing
and
the
Rajasthan
Govt.
Sikkim
·No specific
NDPS
is
packed
and
sealed
under
answer.
Ho\Vever
packing
H
The
main
packed is
sealed and
kept in the
malkhana.
packed and
sealed
at
the spot of
seizure.
[2016) I S.C.R.
resealed by
SHO
before
consigning
Entry
m it to the
Mudamma, safe
register to custody in
show chain police
of
malkhana
movements of
the
and
its Police
custody. @ Station
pg. 8.
@ Pg.No.3
Daman & of
HP
Diu
and Govt.
Dadar & submission.
Na gar
Haveli:
there
are
very
measures
room
to prevent
is duly
sealed
and
armed
guards
/station
watch
are
posted.
substitutio
and
n
pilferage
from
stores
elaborated
@ Pg.No.
3
of
submissio
ns
by
Chhattisga
rh Govt.
@
pg.no.
2
of
A.P.
Govt
submis
sion
re1note
@ Pg.6 of
subn1issio
ns by U.P.
Govt.
Govt.
chances of
substitution
I pilferage
as
the
, stored
goods are
subject to
periodical
inspection
Page 9 of
the
Response
Utta ra
khand
Govt.
Jharkhand
Govt.
Kera la
Govt.
Karnataka
Govt
NDPS
Material
During
sa1nple is
objects is
recovery a
sent to
sealed and
tbrensic
packed
pinch of the
substance is
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
679
A
resources
for storage
are
used
according·
to quantity
and nature
of
the
contraband
stamp of
IO ' and
nature and
quantity
recorded
in
presence
of
individual
@ Pg.No. witnesses.
2
of Page II of
submission the
by
Response.
Rajasthan
Govt.
laboratory.
For
preventing
substitution,
details
entered into
station dial)'
of
the
concerned·
police
station.
Complete
safety
measures
mentioned
in Annex-3
·with
the
govt.
submission.
properly.
tested with the
help of field
Page 9 of drug test kit
the
an
for
Response indicative test.
After positive
indicative
result,
the
officer makes
detailed
inventory. The
seized goods
are stored in
the
departmental ·
godown or the
judicial
godown and
only
a
B
c
D
representative
Page 5 of
-the
Response
sampk is sent
to
the
laboratol)' for
chemical
analysis.
@ pg. IO of
submission by
Karnataka ·
E
Govt.
-
F
·Bihar
Madhya
0 rissa
Pradesh . Govt.
Govt.
Govt.·
NCB Seized
Seized
By
Indore
drugs
drugs
Zonal
are
are
sealed
Office.
sealed
in such and ,
Seized
contraband a
produce
mannef ·d before
Punjab
Govt.
Haryan
a Govt.
.
Police
officials
deployed
·all
at
NDPS
Maalkha
na.
Weekly
and
fortnight
ly
reports
obtained
from all
(4randi
garb
Govt .
Seized
contraba
nd
is
safely
kept in
Malkha
na under
l6ck .
G
.
H
680
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2016] I S.C.R.
A
wrapped
B
c
D
E
F
G
1-1
in
as
tc the Court ~tores.
concerned No more
minimize and then ~ase
regarding
details
polythene and tl1e
stored in property
seized/
1nentioned
then in white chances o Maalkha ..egister
storage of
cloth before pilferage. na after No. 19is NDPS.
sealing and
entry in Jnaintained Stock
signing
it. After
registers.
Register is
Quality and producing
Procedure maintaine
an1ount
of tl1e seize< Pg. No. 3 ~s per and d by field
seized drug is goods
of
Punjab
units and
also
with
sub1nissi Police
periodical
mentioned in permissim on
by •ules 1934. checking
the packet.
of cour Bihar
nspection is done.
oy gazette
@ Pg. 5 of tl1e drug: Govt.
submissions
are
pfficers.
@pg. 121
by M.P. Govt deposited
r@pg.no. of
By
police u1
16andl7 submissio
heads
of maalkhana
pf
n
of
districts:
in seale<
~ubmissio Haryana
seizun condition
1 by
A
Govt.
memo is agai1 with
Punjab
prepared u/s 55 proper
Povt.
ofNDPS Act a entry ar>
the time 0 wider th•
storage in th< custody o
police statior Maa!khan
malkhana and a Officer.
sealed
b~
Station HouS< Page 2 anc
Officer.
3 of th<
Necessary
Response.
entries
ar<
made in tlu
Rojnamcha
and
seizec
prope1ty
register
1naintained in
the
polic'
station.
At page 4 o
the Response.
trans parent
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
Tamil
N adu
Directorate of
Revenue
Intelligence
No such
sealed
The
contained
containing the
seized goods is
handed over to
Custodian
under proper
documentation
The
inventory,
instance
has
arisen.
f
NCB
Zonal
Officer,
Jodhnur
As
per
Govem1ne
nt of India
Notificati
on,
circular
1/89 page
3 of the
Response.
seizure · memo
as well as the
paper seals on
the
sealed
container
are
duly signed by
the
pan ch
witnesses,
accused
and
seizing officer.
The custodian
are responsible
for appropriate
action
to
prevent
substitution
and pilferage.
West Bengal
NCR Zonal
Office,
Chandigarh
Customs
and
Central
Excise
The seized The seized
goods
are contraband
stored
lot is deposited
the
wise
and in
stored under godown/
proper lock malkhana
and
key on the basis
the
under
the of
supervision
particulars
of
ITBP ·mentioned
Guard. No in
the
other seizure
one
than
the memo/
store
in ·panchnama
Proper
charge
is
authorized
and secured
to enter the packing
and sealing
store.
of
the
Page 6 of contraband
the
ensures its
Response.
safety.
Page 11 of
the
Response.
The seized goods are packed labeled
and sealed by the Officer and are
handed over to the officer in charge
with copy of seizure list. Details are
also incotporated in the Malkhana
Register having counter signed of
dealing officer.
7. The reports submitted by the State Governments and the
Central Agencies further claim that stock registers maintained at the
storage sites are periodically checked by the staff mentioned in the reports.
681
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
682
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] I S.C.R.
Another question that was asked from the StatJ Governments and the
Central Agency relates to the condition of the storage facilities, shortage
of storage facilities, if any, and whether any steps have been taken or
are being taken to remove the deficiencies. Answers to those queries
suggest that no proper storage facilities are available in most of the
States. For instance, in Gujarat no special storage facility is available for
keeping the contraband, which is, therefore, stored in general muddamal
room. In Assam the NBC Guwahati Zonal Unit is said to be running
from a rented house and one secured room is earmarked for storage
with triple locking system under the supervision of the Superintendent.
In Imphal, the store room is overflowing with contraband. Since there is
shortage of space, pre-trial disposal process has been initiated to decrease
congestion in godowns. Although Mizoram Government claims that there
is no lack of storage facility, no information as to any specific storage
facility being earmarked for the purpose has been provided. In Tripura
the enforcement branch is said to be maintaining the malkhana used for.
storage of contraband~. In Himachal Pradesh there is no storage facility
except an old building used for the purpose, while in Chhattisgarh the
storage facility is satisfactory but not sufficient for bulk storage. Similarly,
Rajasthan has scarcity of storage facility. Jharkhand has no.separate
storage facility at all whereas Kerala has satisfactory storage facilities
only in some of the dis\ric.ts. In Orissa and Bihar the storage facilities
are totally insufficient and unsatisfactory. States of Haryana, Madhya
Pradesh, Goa, Daman Diu and Dadar & Nagar Haveli and Andhra
Pradesh claim to have no problems with storage facility while Tamil
. Nadu does not have any separate storage.
8. Directorate of Revenue Intelligence has not provided any
inforination while NCB Zonal Office, Jodhpur has no shortage of space.
NCB Zonal Office, Chandigarh has reported insufficiency of space and
has started the process for construction of a specified storage facility.
Customs and Central Excise Authority has reported that their godown is
full and no more space is available. ·
9. In answer to the question as to who is authorised to app!y to
the Court to destroy the seized contraband and whether there has been
any failure or dereliction in making such applications and whether any
person having technical knowledge of narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substance (natural and synthetic) is associated with the process of
destruction of the contraband: the reply submitted by the State
Governments suggest that different persons in different States have been
UNION OF !NOIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
683
authorised to make such applications to the Courts concerned except in
Tripura where no particular person is authodsed. In some cases Officerin- charge of the Police Station has been authorised while in others the
1.0. is also empowered to apply for permission to destroy the contraband.
In answer to the question whether any action has been taken against
anyone who should have applied for permission to destroy the narcotics
but had not done so, State Governments have all answered in the negative
implying thereby that either no dereliction of duty has occurred on the
part of any officer competent to apply for destruction or no action has
been taken for any such dereliction.
·
A
I 0. Similarly, regarding the steps taken at the time of destruction
to determine the nature and quantity of the substance being destroyed,
the reports submitted by the State Governments give varying answers.
There is no uniformity in the procedure adopted by those associated or
in charge of the process of destruction. The reports suggest as if adequate
steps are taken to prevent damage, loss, pilferage and tampering/
substitution of the narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances from the
point of search to the point of destruction but there is no uniformity or
standard procedure prescribed or followed in that regard. Having said
that we must mention that we are in these proceedings concerned with
the following three issues only for the present:
c
(i)
Seizure and sampling of the Narcotic drugs and
Psychotropic substances
(ii)
their storage and
(iii)
their destruction
Seizure and sampling:
11. Section 52-A(l) of the NDPS Act, 1985 empowers the
Central Government to prescribe by a notification the procedure to be
followed for seizure, storage and disposal of drugs and psychotropic
substances. The Central Government have in exercise of that power
issued Standing Order.No. 1/89 which prescribes the procedure to be
followed while conducting seizure of the contraband. Two subsequent
standing orders one dated 10.05.2007 and the other.dated 16.01.2015
deal with disposal and destruction of seized contraband and do not alter
· or add to the earlier standing order that prescribes the procedure for
conducting seizures. Para 2.2 of the Standing Order 1/89 states that
samples must be taken from the seized contrabands on the spot at the
B
D
E
F
G
H
684
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 1 S.C.R.
time of recovery itself. It reads:
"2.2. All the packages/containers shall be serially numbered
and kept in lots for sampling. Samples from the narcotic drugs
and psychotropic substances seized, shall be drawn on the
spot of recovery, in duplicate, in the presence of search
witnesses (Panchas) and the person from whose possession
the drug is recovered, and a mention to this effect should
invariably be made in the panchnama drawn on the spot. "
Most of the States, however, claim that no samples are drawn at the
time of seizure. Directorate of Revenue Intelligence is by far the only
agency which claims that samples are drawn at the time of seizure,
while Narcotics Control Bureau asserts that it does not do so. There is
thus no uniform practice or procedure being followed by the States or
the Central agencies in the matter of drawing of samples. This is,
therefore, an area that needs to be suitably addressed in the light of the
statutory provisions which ought to be strictly observed given the
seriousness of the offences under the Act and the punishment prescribed
by law in case the same are proved. We propose to deal with the issue
no matter briefly in an attempt to remove the confusion that prevails
regarding the true position as regards drawing of samples.
12. Section 52A as amended by Act 16 of 2014, deals with
disposal of seized drugs and psychotropic substa11ces. It reads:
"Section 52A : Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances.
F
G
H
(I) The Central Government may, having regard to the
hazardous nature of any narcotic drugs or psychotropic
substances, their vulnerability to theft, substitution,
constraints of proper storage space or any other relevant
considerations, by notification published in the Official
Gazette, specify such narcotic drugs or psychotropic
substances or class of narcotic drugs or class of psychotropic
substances which shall, as soon as may be after their seizure,
be disposed of by such officer and in such manner as that
Government may from time to time, determine after following
the procedure hereinafter specified.
(2) Where any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance has
been seized and forwarded to the officer-in-charge of the
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
nearest police station or to the officer empowered under
section 53, the officer referred to in sub-section (I) shall
prepare an inventory of such narcotic drugs or psychotropic
substances containing such details relating to their
description, quality, quantity, mode of packing, marks,
numbers or such other identifying particulars of the narcotic
drugs or psychotropic substances or the packing in which
they are packed, country of origin and other particulars as
the officer referred to in sub-section (I) may consider relevant
to the identity of the narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances
in any proceedings under this Act and make an application,
to any Magistrate for the purpose of-
685
A
B
c
(a) certifying the correctness of the inventory so prepared;
or
(b) taking, in the presence of such Magistrate, photographs
of such drugs or substances and certifying such photographs
as true; or
D
(c) allowing to draw representative samples of such drugs or
substances, in the- presence· of such Magistrate and certifying
the correctness of any list of samples so drawn.
(3) When an application is made under sub-section (2), the
Magistrate shall, as soon as may be, allow the application.
E
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 (1 of 1872) or the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (2 of 1974), every court trying an offence under this
Act, shall treat the inventory, the photographs of {narcotic
drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] and any list of samples drmvn under sub-section
(2) and certified by the Magistrate, as primary evidence in
respect of such offence.]"
F
13. It is manifest from Section 52A (2)(c) (supra) that upon seizure
of the contraband the same has to be forwarded either to the officer incharge of the nearest police station or to the officer empowered under
Section 53 who shall prepare an inventory as stipulated in the said
provision and make an application to the Magistrate for purposes of(a)
certifying the correctness of the inventory (b) certifying photographs of
such drugs or substances taken before the Magistrate as true and (c) to
G
H
686
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2016] I S.C.R.
draw representative samples in the presence of the Magistrate and
certifying the correctness of the list of samples so drawn. Sub-section
(3) of Section 52-A requires that the Magistrate shall as soon as may be
allow the application. This implies that no sooner the seizure is effected
and the contraband forwarded to the officer in charge of the Police
Station or the officer empowered, the officer concerned is in law duty
bound to approach the Magistrate for the purposes mentioned above
including grant of permission to draw representative samples in his
presence, which samples will then be enlisted and the correctness of the
list of samples so drawn certified by the Magistrate. In other words, the
process of drawing of samples has to be in the presence and under the
supervision of the Magistrate and the entire exercise has to be certified
by him to be correct. The question of drawing of samples at the time of
seizure which, more often than not, takes place in the absence of the
Magistrate does not in the above scheme of things arise. This is so
especially when according to Section 52-A( 4) of the Act, samples drawn
and certified by the Magistrate in compliance with sub-section (2) and
(3) of Section 52-A above constitute primary evidence for the purpose
of the trial. Suffice it to say that there is no provision in the Act that
mandates taking of samples at the time of seizure. That is perhaps why
none of the States claim to be taking samples at the time of seizure. Be
that as it may, a conflict between the statutory provision governing taking
of samples and the standing order issued by the Central Government is
evident when the two are placed in juxtaposition. There is no gainsaid
that such a conflict shall have to be resolved in favour of the statute on
first principles of interpretation but the continuance of the statutory
notification in its present form is bound to create confusion in the minds
of the authorities concerned instead of helping them in the discharge of
their duties. The Central Government would, therefore, do well, to reexamine the matter and take suitable steps in the above direction.
14. Mr. Sinha, learned Amicus, argues that if an amendment of
the Act stipulating that the samples be taken at the time of seizure is not
possible, the least that ought to be done is to make it obligatory for the
officer conducting the seizure to apply to the Magistrate for drawing of
samples. and certification etc.· without any loss of time. The officer
conducting the seizure is also obliged to report the act of seizure and the
making of the application to the superior officer in.writing so thatthere is
a certain amount of accountability in the ·entire exercise, which as at
present gets neglected for a variety of reasons. There is in our opinion
UNION OF INDIA v.. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJI.)
687
no manner of doubt that the seizure.of the contraband must be followed A
by an application for drawing of samples and certification as contemplated
under the Act. There is equally no doubt that the proc.ess of making any
such application and resultant sampling and certification cannot be left
to the whims of the officers concerned. The scheme of the Act in general
and Section 52-A in particular, does not brook any delay in the matter of
B
making of an application or the drawing of samples and certification.
While we see no room for prescribing or reading a time frame into the
provision, we are of the view that an application for sampling and
certification ought to be made without undue delay and the Magistrate
on receipt of any such applicaiion will be expected to attend to the
application and do the needful, within a reasonable period and without c
any undue delay or procrastination as is mandated by sub-section (3) of
Section 52A (supra). We hope and trust that the High Courts will keep
a close watch on the performance of the Magistrates in this regard and
through the Magistrates on the agencies that are dealing with the menace
of drugs which has taken alarming dimensions in this country partly
D
because of the ineffective and lackadaisical enforcement of the laws
and procedures and cavalier manner in which the agencies and at times
Magistracy in this country addresses a problem of such serious
dimensions.
• --~
STORAGE:
E
15. The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
does not make any special provision regulating storage of the contraband
substances. All that Section 55 of the Act envisages is that the officer in
charge of a Police Station shall take charge of and keep in safe custody ·
the seized article pending orders of the Magistrate concerned.·There is
F
no provision nor was any such provision pointed out to us by learned
counsel forthe parties prescribing the nature of the storage facilitfto be
used for storage of the contraband substances. Even so the importance
of adequate storage facilities for safe deposit and storage of the
contraband material has been recognised by the Government inasmuch
as Standing Order No.1/89 has made specific provisions in regard to the G
same. Section Ill of the said Order tleals with "Receipt of Drugs in
Godowns and Procedure" which inter alia provides that all drugs shall
invariably be stored in "safes and vaults" provided with double locking
system and that the agencies of the Central and the State Governments·
may specifically designate their godowns for storage purposes and such
H
688
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2016] I S.C.R.
godowns should be selected keeping in view their security angle,
juxtaposition to courts etc. We may usefully extract paras 3 .2 to 3.9
comprising Section Ill supra at this stage for ready reference:
"'3.2. All drugs invariably be stored in safes and vaults
provided with double-locking system. Agencies of the Central
and State Governments, may specifically, designate their
godowns for storage purposes. The godowns should be
selected keeping in view their security angle, juxtaposition
to courts etc.
3.3 Such godowns, as a matter of rule, shall be placed under
the over-al/ supenision and charge of a Gazetted Officer of
the respective enforcemellf agency, who shall exercise utmost
care, circumspection and personal supervision as far as
possible. Each seizing officer shall deposit the drugs fully
packed and sealed in the godown within 48 hours of such
seii'ure, with a forwarding memo indicating NDPS Crime No.
as per Crime and Prosecution (C & P Register) under the
new law, name of the accused, reference of test memo,
description of the drugs, total no. of packages/containers
ef£.
E
F
3.4 The seizing officer, after obtaining an acknowledgement
for such deposit in the format (Annexure-I). shall hand
acknowledged over such to the Investigation Officer of the
case along with the case dossiers for further proceedings.
3. 5 The officer-in-charge of the godown, before accepting
the deposit of drugs, shall ensure that the same are properly
packed and sealed. He shall also arrange the packages!
containers (case-wise and lot-wise) for quick retrieval etc.
3. 6 The godown-in-charge is required to maillfain a register
wherein entries of receipt should be made as per format at
Annexure-Il
G
H
3. 7 It shall be incumbent upon the Inspecting Officers of the
various Departments mentioned at Annexure II to make
frequent visits to the godowns for ensuring adequate security
and safety and for taking measures for timely disposal of
drugs. The Inspecting Officers should record their remarks!
observations against Col. I 5 of the Format at Annexure-ll.
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
689
3.8 The Heads·of the respective enforcement agencies (both
Central and State Governments) may prescribe such
periodical reports and returns, as they may deem fit, to monitor
the safe receipt, deposit, storage. accounting and disposal of
seized drugs.
A
3.9 Since the early disposal of drugs assumes utmost
consideration and importance, the enforcement agencies may
obiain orders for pre-trial disposal of drugs and other articles
(including conveyance, if any) by having recourse to the
provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 52A of the Act. "
B
It is evident from a plain reading of para 3.2 (supra) that storage of all
drugs in safes and vaults has been made mandatory and that agencies of
the Central and the State Governments have been permitted to designate
their godowns for storage purposes. It is also clear that keeping in view
the importance of protecting the seized drugs against theft, substitution
or pilferage the Central Government has prescribed that such godowns
shall be placed under the overall supervision and charge of a gazetted
officer of the respective enforcement agencies who shall exercise utmost
care, circumspection and personal supervision over the storage facilities.
The provision contained in paras 3.5, 3.6, 3.7 and 3.8 also are aimed at
ensuring that the godown or storage facility is satisfactory and those incharge of the same are made accountable for its upkeep and effective
management. Subsequent Notification including Notification dated 16"'
•
January, 2015 have in no way diluted the above requirement. The result
is that there is a statutory framework which governs the storage of
drugs and matters relating and incidental thereto. The question is whether
the said statutory mechanism has been effectively implemented by the
Central Government agencies and by the State Governments. Our
answer regretfully is in the negative. It is evident from the responses
received from the State and the Central Government agencies that no
notified storage facility-godown has been established for storage of the
seized drugs. Even the Narcotics Control Bureau has admitted to using
mallkhana of the Courts for storage of the seized drugs in certain cases
and in certain circumstances. The Customs and Central Excise
Department and DRI have also stated that they have no designated
storage facility for storage of contraband. The position in the States is
no different. Due to non-availability of any designated godown-facility
with adequate vaults and double lock system, the seized contraband is
stored in police maalkhana which is a common storage facility for all
c
D
E
F
G
H
690
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COlJf
REPORTS
[2016] l S.C.R.
kinds of goods and weapons seized in connection with all kinds of offences
including those specified by the !PC. This is a total.ly unhappy and
unacceptable situati_on to say the least. It is indeed unfortunate that
even after a lapse of26 years since Standing Order No. 1189 was issued,
the Central Government or its agencies and the State Governments have
paid little or no attention to the need for providing adequate storage
facilities Of-the kind stipulated in Standing Order No. 1189 with the
necessary supervisory and other controls prescribed in :'\ection Ill of the
said order. The result is that while Standing Order No. 1189 very early in
point oftirile recognized the need for providing adequate and effective
storage facilities by the States and the Central Government agencies,"·-the failure on the part of the Central Government and the State
Governments to provide for such storage has defeated, if not completely
negated the very purpose underlying the said notification and the
provisions made therein. There is as on date hardly any credible protection
againsttheft, replacement, pilferage and destruction of the seized drugs
on account of the wholly unsatisfactory and unscientific method of storage
of drugs and psychotropic substances whiclrat times hit the headlines in
newspapers on account of what is often described by the agencies as
"big catch" worth crores of rupees in the international market. Wh,at
has defied our understanding is the neglect on the part of the Central
Government and its agencies and the State Governments in realizing the
importance of the storJtge facilities and in providing for the same to
prevent hazardous and at times lethal substances with great potential to
do harm to those wh'o use the same from being replaced, pilfered, stolen
or siphoned out on account of very poor supervision, control or invigilation
over such storage facilities. The learned -amicus has in that view very
right!)' argued that there is a complete failure on the part of the Central
Government aod its agencies as also the State Governments in taking
adequate steps for providing proper storage facilities with proper system
of supervision and control over the drugs tharare stored in the same. It
was contended by Mr. Sinha, and in our Opi.(lion rightly· so, that the
cumulative effect of the reports submitted by the States and the Central
agencies is that only 16% of the contrabands seized between 2002 to
2012 have been actually disposed of. What happened td the remaining
84% of such seizures is anybody's guess and ifit is still lying in the police
maalkhana; why has nobody ever bothered to apply for their disposal _
according to the procedure established by law is hard to fathom. TJie
fact that the States and the Central Government agencies have accepted
UNION OF iNDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
691
that no specific register is maintained by the State Police and that general
maalkhana register alone is being maintained for the seized drugs shows
the neglect of all concerned towards this important aspect and the cavalier
manner in which the issue regarding storage of ceased drugs is
approached by them. Absence of periodical inspection of the storage
facility and the absence of any record suggesting that any inspection has
been carried out by any ofthe officers shows a complett>failure bordering
criminal negligence by officers who are supposed to be taking action in
this regard but have failed to do so.
A
16. The menace of drugs in this country, as observed earlier has
alanning dimensions and proportions. Studies based on conferences and
seminars have very often shown tliat the menace is deep rooted not
only because drug lords have the money power and transnational links
but also because the enforcement agencies like the Police and at times
politicians in power help them in carrying on what is known to be a
money spinning and flourishing trade. We only hope that the failure of
the Central Government agencies and the State Governments in providing
what is the .bare minimum in terms of infrastructure required to artest
the growing menace and prevent pilferage and re-circulation of drugs
back into the market is not oh account of any unholy connect between
the drug traffickers and the enforcement agencies. We woula comfort
ourselves by presuming them to be relatable only to apathy and
indifference and hopethl!tthe system does not get corrupted by continued
neglect lest all hopes are lost in the fight.against drug menace which are
eating into the vitals of our society. It is in that spirit that we deem it
necessary to issue appropriate· directions to the Central Government
agencies and to the States to set up adequate storage facilities with
effective supervisory and regulatory controls as prescribed in Notification
No. 1/89.
B
c
D
E
F
Disposal of Drugs:
17. Section 52A as amended provides for disposal of the seized ..
contraband in the manner stipulated by the Government under Clause I
of that Section: Notification dated 16"' January, 2015 has, in supersession G
of the earlier notification dated JOlhMay, 2007 not only stipulates that all
drugs and psychotropic substances have. to be disposed off but also
identifies the officers who shall initiate action fur disposal and the
procedure to be followed for such disposal. Para 4 of the Notification
inter alia, provides that officer-in-charge of the Police Station shall
H
692
SUPREME C01",f REPORTS
[2016) I S.C.R.
within 30 days from the date of receipt of chemical analysis report of
drugs, psychotropic substances or controlled substances apply to any
Magistrate under Section 52A(2) in terms of Annexure 2 to the said
Notification.
A
18. Sub-para (2) of Para (4) provides that after the Magistrate ·
allows the application under sub-section (3) of Section 52A, the officer
mentioned in sub para (I) of Para (4) shall preserve the certified inventory,
photographs and samples drawn in the presence of the Magistrate as
primary evidence for the case and submit details of seized items to the
Chairman of the Drugs Disposal committee for a decision by the
Committee on the question of disposal. The officer shall also send a
c copy of the details along with the items seized to the officer in-charge of
the godown. Para (5) of the notification provides for constitution of the
Drugs Disposal Committee while para (6) specifies the functions which
the Committee shall perform. In para (7) the notification provides for
procedure to be followed with regard to disposal of the seized items,
D while para (8) stipulates the quantity or the value upto which the Drugs
Disposal Committee can order disposal of the seized items. In terms of
proviso to para (8) ifthe consignments are larger in quantity or of higher
value than those indicated in the table, the Drugs Disposal Committee is
required to send its recommendations to the head of the department
who shall then order their disposal by a high level Drugs Disposal
E Committee specially constituted for that purpose. Para (9) prescribes
the mode of disposal of the drugs, while para (10) requires the Committee
to intimate to the head of the Department the programme of destruction
and vestthe head of the Department with the power to conduct a surprise
check or depute an officer to conduct such checks on destruction
operation. Para (11) deals with certificate of destruction while paras
F
(12) and (13) deal with details of sale to be entered into the godown
register and communication to be sent to Narcotic Control Bureau.
B
G
H
19. There are two other aspects that need to be noted at this
stage. The first is that notification dated I 6" January, 2015 does not in
terms supersede Standing Order No. I /89 insofar as the said Standing
Order also prescribes the procedure to be followed for disposal ofNarcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances.
Specific overriding of the earlier Standing Order would have avoided a
certain amount of confusion which is evident on account of simultaneous
presence of Standing Order No. 1189 and notification dated 16" January,
2015. For instance in para (I) of Standing Order No. 1189 only certain
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJI.]
693
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances enumerated therein could
be disposed of while notification dated l 6'h January, 2015 provides for
disposal ofall Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled Substances
and Conveyances. Again in terms of Standing Order No. I /89 the
procedure for making of application was marginally different from the
one stipulated in Notification dated 16"' January, 2015 not only insofar as
the procedure related to the officers who could make the application is
concerned but also in relation to the procedure that the DOC would
follow while directing disposal. In both the notifications are prescribed
the limits upto which the disposal could be directed. In case of excess
quantity the disposal under the Standing Order No. 1/89 had to be done
in the presence of the head of the Department whereas according to
notification of2015 in the event of excess quantity or value the disposal
has to be by a high !eve I Drug Disposal Committee to be constituted by
the head of the Department. Again while Standing Order No. 1/89
specifically required the approval of the Court for disposal, notification
dated 16'" January, 2015 does not stipulate such approval as a specific
condition. Be that as it may, to the extent the subsequent notification
prescribes a different procedure, we treat the earlier notification/Standing
Order No. 1/89 to have been superseded. In order to avoid any confusion
arising out of the continued presence of two notifications on the same
subject we make it clear that disposal ofNarcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
and controlled Substances and Conveyances shall be carried out in the
following manner till such time the Government prescribes a different
procedure for the same:
A
B
c
D
E
(1) Cases where the trial is concluded and proceedings in appeal/revision
have all concluded finally:
In cases that stood finally concluded at the trial, appeal, revision
and further appeals, if any, before 29'" May, 1989 the continued storage
of drugs and Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled Substances
and Conveyances is of no consequence not only because of the
considerable lapse oftime since the conclusion of the proce~dings but
also because the process of certification and disposal after verification
and testing may be an idle formality. We say so because ev.~n if upon
verification and further testing of the seized contraband in such already
concluded cases it is found that the same is either replaced,· stolen or
pilferaged, it will be difficult if not impossible to fix the responsibility for
such theft, replacement or pilferage at this distant point in time. That
apart, the storage facility available with the States, in whatever
F
G
H
694
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 1 S.C.R.
satisfactory or unsatisfactory conditions the same exist, are reported to
be over-flowing with seized contraband goods. It would, therefore, be
just and proper to direct that the Drugs Disposal Committees of the
States and the Central agencies shall take stock of all such seized
contrabands and take steps for their disposal without any further
verification, testing or sampling whatsoever. The concerned heads of
the Department shall personally supervise the process of destruction of
drugs so identified for disposal. To the extent the seized Drugs and
Narcotic Substances continue to choke the storage facilities and tempt
the unscrupulous to indulge in pilferage and theft for sale or circulation
in the market, the disposal of the stocks will reduce the hazards that go
with their continued storage and availability in the market.
(2) Drugs that are seized after May, 1989 and where the trial and appeal
and revision have also been finally disposed of:
D
E
F
G
In this category of cases while the seizure may have taken place
afterthe introduction of Section 52A in the Statute book the non-disposal
of the drugs over a long period of time would also make it difficult to
identify individuals who are responsible for pilferage, theft, replacement
or such other mischief in connection with such seized contraband. The
requirement of para 5.5 of standing order No. 1189 for such drugs to be
disposed of after getting the same tested will also be an exercise in
futility and impractical at this distant point in time. Since the trials stand
concluded and so also the proceedings in appeal, Revision etc. insistence
upon sending the sample from such drugs for testing before the same
are disposed of will be a fruitless exercise which can be dispensed with
having regard to the totality of the circumstances and the conditions
prevalent in the maalkhanas and the so called godowns and storage
facilities. The DDCs shall accordingly take stock of all such Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances in
relation to which the trial of the accused persons has finally concluded
and the proceedings have attained finality at all levels in the judicial
hierarchy. The DDCs shall then take steps to have such stock also
destroyed under the direct supervision of the head of the Department
concerned.
(3) cases in which the proceedings are still pending before the Courts at
the level of trial court~llate court or before the Supreme Court:
H
In such cases the heads of the Department concerned shall ensure
that appropriate applications are moved by the officers competent to do
UNION OF INDIA v. MOHANLAL [T. S. THAKUR, CJ!.]
695
so under Notification dated 16"' January, 2015 before the Drugs Disposal
Committees concerned and steps for disposal of such Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances taken
without any further loss of time.
A
20. To sum up we direct as under:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
No sooner the seizure of any Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic and controlled Substances and Conveyances
is effected, the same shall be forwarded to the officer incharge of the nearest police station or to the officer
empowered under Section 53 of the Act. The officer
concerned shall then approach the Magistrate with an
application under Section 52A(ii) of the Act, which shall be
allowed by the Magistrate as soon as may be required under
Sub-Section 3 of Section 52A, as discussed by us in the
body of this judgment under the heading 'sejzure and
sampling'. The sampling shall be done under the supervision
of the magistrate as discussed in paras 13 and 14 of this
order.
The Central Government and its agencies and so also the
State Governments shal I within six months from today take
appropriate steps to set up storage facilities forthe exclusive
storage of seized Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic and
controlled Substances and Conveyances duly equipped with
vaults and double locking system to prevent theft, pilferage
or replacement of the seized drugs. The Central
Government and the State Governments shall also designate
an officer each for their respective storage facility and
provide for other steps, measures as stipulated in Standing
Order No. 1/89 to ensure proper security against theft,
pilferage or replacement of the seized drugs.
The Central Government and the State Governments shall
be free to set up a storage facility for each district in the
States and depending upon the extent of seizure and store
required, one storage facility for more than one districts.
Disposal of the seized drugs currently lying in the police
maalkhans and other places used for storage shall be carried
out by the DDCs concerned in terms of the directions issued
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
696
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2016] 1 S.C.R.
by us in the body of this judgment under the heading
'disposal of drugs'.
21. Keeping in view the importance of the subject we request the
Chief Justices of the High Courts concerned to appoint a Committee of
Judges on the administrative side to supervise and monitor progress made
by the respective States in regard to the compliance with the above
directions and wherever necessary, to issue appropriate directions for a
speedy action on the administrative and even on the judicial side in public
interest wherever considered necessary.
22. List the appeal for final hearing now on an early date.
c
Kalpana K. Tripathy
Matter Adjourned.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org