JASBIR SINGH versus TARASINGHAND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 21 September 2015 | [2015] 10 S.C.R. 61 | 2015 INSC 684
Key facts
- Decided
- 21 September 2015
- Bench
- KURIAN JOSEPH*, ARUN MISHRA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1241/2015
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [2015] 10 S.C.R. 61
- Neutral citation
- 2015 INSC 684
Text of the judgment
[2015] 1O S.C.R. 61 ·
JASBIR SINGH
A
v.
TARASINGHAND OTHERS
(Criminal Appeal No. 1241 of 2015)
SEPTEMBER 21, 2015
B
[KURIAN JOSEPH AND ARLIN MISHRA, JJ.]
Sentence/Sentencing:.Appea/ by complainant against
the alleged lenient view taken by High Court with regard to
the sentence - Conviction of respondents ulss. 466, 467,
468, 471, 120-8, /PC for committing forgery of documentsSentence imposed upon respondents-accused ranging from
1 to 3 years - Challenge to the quantum of sentence Respondents underwent 4-5 months in custody- High Court D
reduced sentence to period already undergone Complainant's appeal - Held: Unless there are mitigating
circumstances, the appellate/revisional court will not be
justified in arbitrarily reducing the sentence awarded by the
trial court - When the appellatelrevisional court reduces the E
sentence, the factors leading to such reduction should be
reflected in the order- Punishment must be appropriate and
proportional to the gravity of the offence committed - In view
thereof, impugned order is set aside and matter remitted to
High Court.
F
c
Allowing the appeal and remitting the matter to the
High Court, the Court
HELD: The prescribed maximum punishment for G
offence under Section 466 of IPC is seven years and fine;
under Section 467 of IPC, it is imprisonment for life or
. imprisonment for ten years and fine; under Section 468
of IPC, it is seven years and fine and under Section 471
of IPC, it is two years or with fine or both. The gravity of H
61
62
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2015] 10S.C.R.
A the offence, the mitigating factors and circumstances like
parties buying peace, parties settling the disputes and
getting reconciled, victim subsequently becoming part
of the family, victim showing interest in getting monetarily
compensated, etc., the motive for commission of the
B crime, the manner in which it was planned and committed
are factors that help the court to discern and decipher
the appropriate purpose of punishment and to enter a
satisfaction that justice has been done. Unless there are
mitigating circumstances which were omitted to be noted
C by the trial court, the appellate/revisional court will not
be justified in arbitrarily reducing the sentence awarded
by the trial court. And in any case, when the appellate/
revisional court reduces the sentence, the factors leading
to such reduction should be reflected in the order. [Paras
0
9 and 10] [65-C, E-H]
Jameel v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2010) 12 SCC
532: 2009 (15) SCR 712 - relied on.
E
Case Law Reference
2009 (15) SCR
712
relied on.
Para 11
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal
F Appeal No. 1241 of2015.
From the Judgment and Order dated 16.07.2013 of the
High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in Criminal
Revision No. 1072 of 2013.
G
Gagan Gupta for the Appellant.
Jayant K. Sud, Addi. AG, Jasleen Chahal, Asst. A.G.,
Ajay P. Tushir, K. K. Mohan, Kuldip Singh, forthe Respondents.
H
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
JASBIR SINGH v. fARASINGHAND OTHERS
63
KURIAN, J.: 1. Leave granted.
A
2 The de facto complainant has come up in appeal
aggrieved by the alleged lenient view taken by the High Court
in the impugned judgment with regard to the sentence.
3. The party-respondents were tried under Sections 466, B
467, 468, 471, 1208 of the Indian Penal Code (45of1860)
(hereinafter referred to as 'IPC') for having committed a serious
offence of forgery of documents in order to grab the property
of one Harbans Singh. The trial court imposed the following
sentence:
C
"Name of
Section
R.I.
Fine (Rs.)
In Default
Accused
Partapa
4661PC
2 years
500/-
One month
Tara Singh
466/120-B
1 year
500/-
One month
467 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
468 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
471 IPC
2 years 500/-
One months
Bhajan Singh 467 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
468 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
Charan Dass 467 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
468 IPC
3 years 1000/- Two months
467 IPC
3 years 1000/-
468 IPC
3 years 1OOOi- Two months"
Dalbir Singh
D
E
F
Two months
4. The appeal by the party-respondents was dismissed. G
In Revision, it appears the challenge was limited only to the
quantum of sentence. As a matter of fact, notice issued by this
Court is limited to the question of quantum of sentence only.
The party-respondents mainly contended on prolonged trial .
and their advanced age. To quote the relevant submissions:
H
64
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
"... Learned counsel for the petitioners contends that the
petitioners are facing agony of trial since registration of
the FIR i.e. 25.6.1996 and they are in the age group of
45 to 58. Learned counsel further contends that the
petitioners are first offenders, they are neither previous
convicts nor are having any criminal background. Learned
counsel prays that keeping in view the age of the
petitioners and also the fact that they have already
suffered a lot of mental agony as they are facing trial since
1996, their sentence, therefore, be reduced to the period
already undergone by them .... "
B
c
[2015] 10 S.C.R.
5. The High Court passed the following order:
D
E·
F
G
H
"Heard the arguments advanced by learned counsel for
the parties and have also gone through the contents of
the FIR.
Keeping in view the submissions made by learned
counsel for the petitioners that the petitioners are first
offenders and are not having any criminal background
and are facing agony of trial since registration of FIR i.e.
25.6.1996, the present petition is partly allowed. The
judgments passed by Courts below qua conviction are
upheld and sentence of the petitioners is reduced to the
period already undergone by them."
6. The actual period undergone by the party-respondents
is as follows, as noted in the impugned judgment:
"As per the custody certificate issued by Jail
Authorities, as on 24.05.2013, the custody period/
actual period undergone (excluding remission) of
the respondents is:
Tara Singh
4 months 26 days,
Bhajan Singh
5 months 24 days,
Charan Dass
5 months 26 days,
Dalbir Singh
5 months 24 days."
JASBIR SINGH v. TARA SINGH AND OTHERS
[KURIAN, J.)
65
Learned Counsel for the party-respondents submits that A
they have undergone a few more days incarceration in the jail.
7. The appellant submits that the offences being grave
in nature, the High Court should not have let them go lightly.
8. Heard the learned Counsel appearing for the partyrespondents as well.
B
9. The prescribed maximum punishment for offence
under Section 466 of IPC is seven years and fine; under Section
467 of IPC, it is imprisonment for life or imprisonment for ten C
years and fine; under Section 468 of IPC, it is seven years
and fine and under Section 471 of IPC, it is two years or with
fine or both. The trial court, having regard to the very same
submissions made before the High Court, passed the
0
sentence which we have extracted above.
10. Though it is not possible for this court to lay down
strict principles on sentencing in the absence of a sentencing
policy for the State, certain indicators need to be borne in mind
by the Courts. The gravity of the offence, the mitigating factors E
and circumstances like parties buying peace, parties settling
the disputes and getting reconciled, victim subsequently
becoming part of the family, victim showing interest in getting
monetarily compensated, etc., the motive for commission of F
the crime, the manner in which it was planned and committed,
the prescribed punishment and the social abhorrence of the
offences are but a few of them. These factors would help the
court to discern and decipher the appropriate purpose of
punishment and to enter a satisfaction that justice has been G
done. Unless there are mitigating circumstances which were
omitted to be noted by the trial court, the appellate/revisional
court will not be justified in arbitrarily reducing the sentence
awarded by the trial court. And in any case, when the appellate/
revisional court reduces the sentence, the factors leading to H
such reduction should be reflected in the order.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
66
[2015] 10 S.C.R.
A
11. In this context, it would also be profitable to refer to
Jameel v. State of Uttar Pradesh 1, where this Court held
that the punishment should reflect the society's cry for justice
against the criminais. To quote
s
"14. The general policy which the courts have followed
with regard to sentencing is that the punishment must be
appropriate and proportional to the gravity of the offence
committed. Imposition of appropriate punishment is the
manner in which the courts respond to the society's cry
for justice against the criminals. Justice demands that
courts should impose punishment befitting the crime so
that the courts reflect public abhorrence of the crime.
C
o
12. Jn the above circumstances, the appeal is allowed
and impugned judgment is set aside. The matter is remitted
to the High Court for passing an appropriate order in the case
in accordance with law.
Devika Gujral
1
(2010) 12 sec 532
Appeal allowed & matter remitted back to High Court.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org