MD. JAMILUDIN NASIR versus STATE OF WEST BENGAL
Supreme Court of India | Decided 10 October 2014 | [2014] 14 S.C.R. 180 | 2014 INSC 707
Key facts
- Decided
- 10 October 2014
- Bench
- F.M. IBRAHIM KALIFULLA, SHIVA KIRTI SINGH
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1240/2014
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [2014] 14 S.C.R. 180
- Neutral citation
- 2014 INSC 707
Text of the judgment
[2014] 14 S.C.R. 180
A
MD. JAMILUDIN NASIR
v.
STATE OF WEST BENGAL
B
(Criminal M P. Nos. 14533-14534 of 2014)
h
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 1240-1241 of2010)
OCTOBER 10, 2014
c
D
E
[SHIVA KIRTI SINGH AND
FAKKIR MOHAMED IBRAHIM KALIFULLA, JJ.]
Penal Code, 1860 -: Waging of war against State Judgment dated 21.05.2014 reported in [2014] 14 S.C.R. 1
- Corrections to be carried out in terms of Annexure Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions allowed accordingly.
CRIMINALAPPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal M. P.
Nos. 14533-14534 of 2014 in Criminc1I Appeal Nos. 12401241 of2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 05.02.2010 in DR.
No. 2/05 of the High Court of Calcutta.
WITH
Crl. M. P. Nos. 14373-14374 of 2014 in Criminal Appeal
Nbs.1242-1243of2010.
F
Ms. Manika Tripathy Pandey, Adv. for the Appellant.
-Anip Sachthey, Saakaar Sardana, Advs. for the
Respondent.
The following Order of the Court was passed:
ORDER
1. Having heard counsel for the parties and having
perused the office report dated 09.10.2014 and the Report of
H
180
MD. JAMILUDIN NASIRv. STATE OF WEST BENGAL
181
the Registry dated 9.10.2014, in compliance of our order dated
1.9.2014, we find that the necessary corrections may be
carried out in terms of Annexure "A' of the Report dated
9.10.2014.
A
2. The Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions are, accordingly,
allowed.
B
ANNEXURE-'A'
PROPOSED CORRIGENDUM TO THE JUDGMENT &
ORDER DATED 21ST MAY. 2014 PASSED BY THIS C
HON'BLE COURT IN CRL.APPEAL NOS.1240-1241 OF
2010 ENTITLED MD. JAMILUDDIN NASIR VERSUS STATE
OF WEST BENGALAND CRL. APPEAL NOS.1242-1243 OF
2010 ENTITLEDAFTABAHMEDANSARl@AFTABANSARI
VERSUS STATE OF WEST BENGAL
D
[ S.No. Typograpt1icall
Factual Errors
21 Indian Penal
Code
38 H. Jawaharlal
2
I
Nehru Road.
-A7 - Nush rat
13
Alak
1- 4.
A7 - Nush rat
Alak
near to
5.
L
I
6.
7.
Calcutta City
Police
20 01.2002
8.
23 02.2002
9.
Asif
10.
Exhibit 4611
Page No.
Co1Tect Position
Page No. 2. 9th line from the
top
Page No. 2. 5th line from the
bottom
Page No.3. 5th Line from the
top
Page No. 4. 10'' Line from
the top
Page No.9, 1O'h Line from
the top
Page No. 12. 9'" Line from
the top
Page No. 13, 61h line from
the bottom
Page No. 14. S" Line from
•
the bottom
Page No. 14, 4" Line from
the bottom
Page No. 14, 3'' line from
the bottom
307 Indian Penal
Code
·38A, Jawaharlal
Nehru Road
A7 - HasratAlam
A7 - HasratAiam
at
I
E
JI F.
Hazaribagh Police
28.01.2002
22 03.2002
G
Aftab
Exhibit 46
H
182
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2014) 14 S.C.R.
A
11.
12.
Pakistan's
national flaa
SDJM
13.
Judicial
14.
15.
Judicial
Maoistrate
he filed
16.
Central
17.
Judicial
18.
19.
22.02.2002
Tl1e appellant
20
Exhibit-46/1
21.
Exhibit-4511
22.
Exhibit-4511
23.
Hazrat Imam
24
22 02.2002
25.
Exhibit-46i1
26.
Exhibit -4511
27.
Exhibit-46/1
28
Exhibit-4611
29.
Exhibit -XXVI
30.
Exhibit. XXVll
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
.....
Page No. 15, 4m line from 'Pakistan's national
the too
ftaa" to be omitted
Page No. 20, 11th line from MM
the top
Page No. 23 9th line from Metropolitan
the too
'
Page No. 32. 2nd line from Metropolitan
the too
Maoistrate
Page No. 37, 1Z'· line from he was released
the top
Page No. 43. 14111 line from Criminal
the ton
Page No. 49, 4t11 line from Metropolitan
the top
Pane No. 62 last line
27 02.2002
Page No. 65, 3'0 & 4'° line 'the Appellant' lo be
from the top
omitted & word
'who' added
Page No. 76, Sth line from Exhibit-46
tl1e too
Page No. 78, 3ra line from Exhibit-45 ·
the botto"1
Page ~o ·81, 5th line frolTI · ~xhibit-45
the too
Page No. 83. 5th line from Hassan Imam
the top
Page No. 85, 41h line from 22.01.2002
the bottom
Page No. 87. 5th line from Exhibit-46
the bottom
Page No 89. 1•t line from Exhibit-45
t11e bottom
Page No. 90. 1'1 line from Exhibit- 46
the top
Page· No. 97, 3rd ltne from Exi1ibit- 46
the bottom
Page No. 103, 2nd line from Exhibit-XXIV
the too
Page No. 103, 3ro line from Exhibil- XXVI
the top
MD. JAMILUDIN NASIR v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL
31.
32.
f-2,
I -l
:)5
36.
O"
..n .
38.
•
39
40.
41
-12
43.
44
-15.
46.
47.
48.
-19
50.
Page No. 105, 3"' line from
the too
ExhibitPage No. 105. 6"• line from
XXV1li
the top
21 012002
Page No. 105. 3~ line from
t11e bottom
21.01.2002
•0 age No. 106. 5'' line from
the bottom
Rippon . Street Page No. 108. 7'' line from
Circular
Road 1he bottom
Crossina
Exhibit-P-4
Page No. 109, 6" line from
the bottom
officer in-Charge_ Page No 121. 3"' line from
the bottom
26.02.2002
Page No. 123. F line from
the bottom
P\'\ls-37 Pl/11-37 Page ~Jo. 126. 311 & 9'' line
from the bottom
a diary
Page No 128. 4:h line .fron1
maintained by
the top
deceased Asif
15~'' January
Page No 145 12" line from
the top
flat
Page "Jo. 146. 7" line from
the bottom
and nowAftab
Page No. 149. 4" tine from
has bee11
the top
apprel1endea on
13.oz, 2002 he
·was free
Asif
Page No. 153, 4" line from
the bottom
Exhibit-46/1
Page No. 162, 11 00 line from
the top
Imam Hussain
Page No. 1G2, 6'' line from
t11e bottom
corps
Poge No. 162, 4" line from
the bottom
Sadakat's
Page No. 165. 10" line from
the bottom
Cl1ambal
Page No. 165 7" &.- 8" line
from the bottom
express 1159
Uttar Pradesh
Sadakat's name Page No. 165, 7" line from
the bottom
Exl1ibit - XXiX
Exhibit - XXVlil
183
A
Exhibit - XXIX
22.01.2002
22.012002
B
Russet Street
crossing
Exhibit -63
officer in-charge-ii
c
26.04.2002
PWS-47 PW-47
Aftab
D
16'' January.
flag
·on 13 03.2002: to
be omitted.
E
Aftab
Exhibit-4G
F
Hassan Imam
Cops
Zatlld's
G
Cl1ambat express
1159up.
In Zal1id's name
H
,SUPREME COU~T RJ:PORTS
184
A
51
52.
.53
B·
5-l
55.
56
Nidhi Jain
Exhibit 46/1
(2014) 14 S.C.R.
Page 167 5"· line from the Cxhitdt- -113
bottom
Page 168, 2"' line from the
top
lmmam >-lussain Page 170 1P line from the
top
Exhibit -l6i1
Page 171 5'" line from t11e
bottom
24 01 .2002
Page No. 187. 7" line from
the bottom
Around 13
Page No. 189, 1O"· line from
·the bottom
number of
oersonnel
Exhibit 46!1
--
Exhibit -46
Hassan immam
t:Xl1iblt 46
26.01.2002
Around 15 number
of personnel
C~.MPs allowed.
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org