PRAMOD KUMAR versus STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
Supreme Court of India | Decided 1 July 2013 | [2013] 8 S.C.R. 323 | 2013 INSC 390
Key facts
- Decided
- 1 July 2013
- Bench
- B.S. CHAUHAN*, DIPAK MISRA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 562/2010
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2013] 8 S.C.R. 323
- Neutral citation
- 2013 INSC 390
Text of the judgment
[2013] 8 S.C.R. 323
PRAMOD KUMAR
v.
STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
(Criminal Appeal No. 562-563 of 2010)
JULY 1, 2013
A
B
[DR. B.S. CHAUHAN AND DIPAK MISRA, JJ.]
Penal Code, 1860 - ss. 302 & 1861332 - Murder Prosecution version that country-made pistol was fired by the
accused that caused injuries to the deceased - Tenability - C
Held: Tenable - Deceased and the accused were grappling
with each other - Country~made pistol seized from accused,
which was in working order - Prosecution version that all of a
sudden, the accused brought out his country-made pistol and
fired from close range clearly established by evidence - D
Defence plea that while grappling, the position changed and
bullet fired from the service revolver of PW-8 hit deceased not
acceptable - No material to prove that gun shot was fired from
the weapon of PW-8 - Evidently, the shot was fired from the
country-made pistol seized from the custody of accused- E
appellant - Arms Act, 1959- ss.25 and 27.
,
Evidence - Witness - Official witnesses - Testimony of
police official - Appreciation - Held: Witnesses from the
department of police cannot per se be said to be untruthful
or unreliable - It would depend upon the veracity, credibility F
and unimpeachabi/ity of their testimony - It cannot be said
that the whole case should be thrown overboard because of
non-examination of independent witness and reliance on the
official witnesses - On facts, the official witnesses examined
in support of the prosecution, stood embedded in their version G
- Despite searching cross-examination, none of the witnesses
gave way to any tergiversation, thus, no reason to discard
them.
323
H.
324
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 8 S.C.R.
On the instructions of SI PW-9, the Head Constable
PW-8 and Constable 'M' went to the house of 'C' where
appellant, a proclaimed offender was hiding. The
appellant was asked to surrender, but, he allegedly took
out a knife and tried to assault but was caught hold of
by 'M' from the rear and both of them grappled with each
other for some time. PW-8 thereafter snatched away the
knife from the hands of appellant but, at that juncture, the
appellant allegedly took out a country-made pistol (desi
katta) and fired at 'M' and the bullet hit him in the stomach
area. 'M' was taken to the hospital where he died due to
the bullet injury.
The appellant was convicted by the courts below. He
challenged his conviction before this Court, contending
that 1) apart from the police officials, no other
independent witness had been examined; and that 2) the
appellant was not responsible for causing injury on the
deceased 'M'; on the contrary, it was PW-8 who intended
to fire at the appellant when the deceased and the
accused were grappling, but the bullet hit the deceased.
E
Dismissing the appeals, the Court
F
G
H
HELD: 1.1. In the plea advanced under Section 313
CrPC, it has been stated by the accused-appellant that
as the public became angry due to the conduct of PW-8,
they assaulted him and in order to save him, the
investigating agency chose not to cite any independent
witness though many witnesses were present who had
seen the occurrence. There is no denial of the fact that
the occurrence had taken place in the house of 'C' who
has turned hostile. His turning hostile does not affect the
case of the prosecution. The witnesses from the
department of police cannot per se be said to be
untruthful or unreliable. It would depend upon the
veracity, credibility and unimpeachability of their
testimony. There is no absolute command of law that the
.
PRAMOD KUMAR v. STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
325
police officers cannot be cited as witnesses and their
testimony should always be treated with suspicion.
Ordinarily, the public at large show their disinclination to
come forward to become witnesses. If the testimony of
the police officer is found to be reliable and trustworthy,
the court can definitely act upon the same. If, in the course
of scrutinising the evidence, the court finds the evidence
of the police officer as unreliable and untrustworthy, the
court may disbelieve him but it should not do so solely
on the presumption that a witness from the department
of police should be viewed with distrust. This is also
based on the principle that quality of the evidence weighs
over the quantity of evidence. [Para 1O] [322-C-D, F-G;
333-A-B]
1.2. It cannot be said that the whole case should be
thrown overboard because of non-examination of
independent witness and reliance on the official
witnesses. The trial Judge and the High Court, after x-ray
of the evidence of the witnesses, have come to the
conclusion that appellant was a proclaimed offender;
that information was received by the competent authority
that he was hiding in the house of 'C'; that a team had
gone to apprehend him; that 51 PW-9 along with other
members Qf the team waited at a distance of 100 yards
and 'M' went to the house of 'C'; that the accused was
found on the verandah of the house and was asked to
surrender but he immediately took out a knife from his
shirt pocket; that before he could inflict a knife blow, he
was overpowered by 'M' and there was a grapple
between the two; and 'M', receiving a bullet injury, fell
down and eventually succumbed to the injuries in the
hospital. Appellant has received some injuries, but that
would not be a ground for discarding the prosecution
version and acceptance of the plea of the defence. The
evidence on record is required to be scrutinized and
appreciated. The witnesses, namely, PW-6, PW-8, PW-9,
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
326
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 8 S.C.R.
A PW-11 and PW-16, who have been examined in support
of the prosecution, have stood embedded in their version.
PW-8 has vividly described the occurrence and the
graphic description has not been, in any manner, dented
in spite of the roving cross-examination. Despite
B searching cross-examination, none of the witnesses has
given way to any tergiversation. When their testimony has
not been varied from any spectrum, there is no reason to
discard them. Thus, the contention that there should have
been examination of independent witnesses to
c corroborate the evidence of tlie police officials has to be
treated as mercurial. [Para 11] (333-C-H; 334-A-B]
Kashmiri Lal v. State of Haryana 2013 AIR SCW 3102 relied on.
D
State of U.P. v. Anil Singh 1988 Supp SCC 686: 1988
Suppl. SCR 611; State, Govt. of NCT of Delhi v. Sunil and
another (2001) 1 sec 652: 2000 (5) Suppl. SCR 144 and
Ramjee Rai and others v. State of Bihar (2006) 13 SCC 229:
2006 (5) Suppl. SCR 240 - referred to. ·
E
2.1. On a perusal of the evidence and the FSL report
relating to the country-made pistol, Ext. F-1, seized from
the accused, it is manifest that the fire arm country-made
pistol .303 bore was designed to fire a standard .303
. cartridge and that the pistol was in working order. Its test
F fire was also successfully conducted and the empty
cartridge of .303 bore, Ext. C-1, found in the chamber of
the country-made pistol was the empty cartridge fired
from the country made pistol. Therefore, to say that no
shot was fired from the country-made pistol is belied and
G the prosecution version that it was the country-made
pistol which was fired by the accused that cau&ed
injuries to the deceased deserves acceptance. [Para 12]
(334-D-F]
2.2. From the post-mortem report, it is clear that the
H bullet injury was from front to back. It is not in dispute that
PRAMOD KUMAR v. STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
327
the deceased and the accused were grappling. The
version of the prosecution in that all of a sudden, the
accused brought out his desi katta and fired from a close
range. This has been clearly established by the evidence.
The submission that while grappling the position changed
and the bullet fired from the service revolver of PW-8 hit
the deceased, cannot be given any acceptance as the desi
katta was seized from the accused and the weapon, as
opined in the FSL report, is the desi katta and further
there is no material to prove that gun shot was fired from
the weapon of PW-8. Thus, it is clear as crystal that the
shot was fired from the country-made pistol seized from
the custody of the accused-appellant. [Para 13] [334-F-H;
335-A-B]
A
8
C
Case Law Reference:
1988 Suppl. SCR 611
referred to
Para 10
2000 (5) Suppl. SCR 144
referred to
Para 10
2006 (5) Suppl. SCR 240
referred to
Para 10
2013 AIR sew 3102
relied on
Para 10
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal
No. 562-563 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 16.03.2007 of the
High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in Crl. A. No. 828 of 2003
and Crl. MB No. 1756 of 2005.
D
E
F
Dr. V.P. Appan for the Appellant.
R. Nedumaran, Sadhana Sandhu, D.S. Mahra, Anil Katiyar
for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DIPAK MISRA, J. 1. On 19.3.1999, SI Prahlad Singh
along Ct. Baljit Singh went to Village Gittorni where Inspector
Mohd. Iqbal, PW-16, had reached along with his staff. After
some time, ACP, Delhi Cantt., arrived at the spot. On enquiry,
G
H
328
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 8 S.C.R.
•
A
8
C
D
E
F
G
H
they came to know that one constable of P.S. Hauz Khas,
namely, Maharaj Singh, having suffered a gun shot injury, had
been taken to the hospital. The Head Constable Samar Singh
narrated the occurrence to the effect that he along with other
officials had received information about the prese·nce of
Pramod Kumar, a proclaimed offender of PS Hauz Khas, was
hiding in the house of Chander Pal and about 4.30 p.m., they
reached Village Gittorni and as per the instruction of SI
Jaswinder Singh, he and Ct. Maharaj Singh went to the place
to obtain information about the presence of Pramod Kumar and
SI Jaswinder Singh waited along with the staff at a distance of
100 meters from the house of Chander Pal. When he and
Maharaj Singh. reached near the house of Chander Pal,
accused Pramod Kumar was standing outside the room.
Maharaj Singh disclosed his identity to him and asked him to
surrender, but, Pramod Kumar, instead of surrendering, took
out a knife from his shirt pocket with his left hand and tried to
assault. However, immediately he was caught hold of by
Maharaj Singh from the rear and both of them grappled with
each other for some time. The Head Constable, Samar Singh,
tried to snatch the knife from the hands of Pramod Kumar and
ultimately he was successful in snatching away the knife from
his hands but, at that juncture, Pramod Kumar took out a desi
katta and fired at Maharaj Singh and the bullet hit in the
stomach area. Hearing the sound, the villagers surrounded and
assaulted Pramod Kumar. During that time, SI Jaswinder
Singh came to the spot along with his staff and injured Maharaj
Singh was taken to the hospital. Desi katta and knife which
were seized from the accused were given to the 10 by Samar
Singh. As further revealed, accused Pramod Kumar was
apprehended and five cartridges were recovered and on the
basis of the statement of Samar Singh, an FIR was registered
under Section 307 of the Indian Penal Code (for short "IPC").
When Maharaj Singh succumbed to his injuries, the case was
converted to one under Section 302 IPC. The bullet that had
hit the stomach of the deceased was kept in a sealed cover
and the same was sent to F.S.L. Malviya Nagar and ultimately,
:f
:I
PRAMOD KUMAR 'v. STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
[DIPAK MISRA, J.]
329
on completion of the investigation, charge-sheet was filed in the
competent court which, in turn, committed the matter to the
Court of Session. Be it noted, after hearing the accused,
charges under Sections 186/332 and 302 IPC were framed
and separate charges under Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms
Act, 1959 were also framed against the accused-appellant.
A
B
2. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
3. The prosecution, in order to establish its case;
examined 19 witnesses and got number of documents
exhibited.
C
4. The accused, in his statement under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (herein after CrPC), denied
the entire allegations and pleaded that he was absolutely
innocent. It was his further plea that one person caught hold of o
him and pushed him and started assaulting him. At that stage,
he got up a.nd grappled with that person who twisted his hand.
The other person accompanying the first person gave him a
kick and took out some weapon and fired at him, but he saved
himself. The bullet hit the person who had caught hold of him E
and receiving the bullet injury, he fell down and later on, he learnt
that he was Maharaj Singh and the person who had fired was
Samar Singh. The neighbours, who had collected, started
assaulting Samar Singh. Thereafter,. many other police officials
entered his room and beat him as a result of which his right F
leg was severely fractured and the plaster remained for eight
months. That apart, 23 stitches were put on his head due to
the beatings given by the police. He had become unconscious
on the spot after receiving injuries. When he regained
consciousness, he found himself in Safdarjung Hospital. It was
his further plea that to save the police official Samar Singh, the · G
investigating agency had falsely implicated him. He had also
taken the plea that they had got his signatures on blank papers
at the Police Station. Sanjay, who was brought by the police,
had witnessed the entire episode. The police deliberately did
H
330
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 8 S.C.R.
A · not cite any one from the public as witness as they gave beating
to Samar Singh. Chander Pal was not present at his house
on that day as he had gone out with his van. He came to know
later on that the house of Maharaj Singh was at a distance of
50 yards from the place of occurrence, i.e., house of Chander
B Pal.
5. The defence, in order to substantiate its plea, examined
one witness, namely, Sanjay.
6. We have heard Dr. V.P. Appan, learned counsel for the
C
0
E
F
G
H
appellant and Mr. R. Nedum·aran, learned counsel for the
respondent.
7. Two fundamental points that have been urged before us
are that apart from the police officials, no other independent
witness has been examined and that the appellant was not
responsible for causing injury on the deceased. On the contrary,
it was the Head Constable Samar Singh who intended to fire
at the accused when the deceased and the accused were
grappling, but the bullet hit the deceased. Elaborating the said .
contention, it is canvassed by the learned counsel that to hide
the atrocities of the police, the case has been foisted, but the
learned trial Judge as well as the High Court failed to
appreciate the same in proper perspective which makes the
judgments absolutely faulted.
8. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent would
contend that the post mortem report and the weapons seized
would clearly show that the bullet was not fired from the pistol
of Samar Singh but from the desi katta which was seized from
the custody of the accused. It is also contended that the plea
taken under Section 313 CrPC is fundamentally incredible and
it only shows a figment of fertile imagination of the accused as
such a situation could never have occurred.
9. To appreciate the aforesaid submissions, it is necessary
to reproduce the autopsy report brought on record and proven
PRAMOD KUMAR v. STATE (GNCT) .OF DELHI
[DIPAK MISRA, J.]
331
by Dr. O.P. Murli, PW-3, which is as follows: -
A
"One lenear cresentric abrasion measuring 3 x 8 ems, 2 x
7 ems. and 1 x 3 ems with bruising in and around.
Gun shot entry wound of 2.5 x 1 ems. Over front of right
side abdomen 5 ems. above the embilicus 1 cm from mid
line, 21 ems. from right nipple and 45 cml? above right sole.
Margines were inerted blackened and surrounding hairs
showed singeing, abdominal fact (omentum) protruded
with effusion of blood in and around underneath the
tissues. Omentum and small intestine were lacerated and
showing cavitation consequent upon the fire arm injury with
full of abdominal cavity blood bruising was also also seen
in other parts of intestine. Fire arm exit wound of 1 x t.5
cm. over the back side of right side abdomen 6.5 ems.
from midline 3 ems. from waist line 20 ems. From right
back bone anble margines averted and protruded wound
communicating with the entry and all intervention structure
were lacerated and injury effect. All organs were pale.
Rest was NAO.
Clothing examination : One shirt was having a tear of 2.5
x 2.3 ems. soaked in block showing fire arm effect and-the
bullet entry had also fractured one button and half was
present. The hole of the shirt was 28 ems. from lower
margine on right side. The back part of the shirt shows
corresponding to the exit wound of size 1 x 7 ems on the
right lower part 18 ems from the margine. The direction
of wound was from front to back and slight above to down.
The underneath banian showed tear of 1 x 7 cm on the
back front tear was cut in the casualty.
B
C
D
E
F
G
Blood soaked pants and underwear
Opinion:
Death. in this case was due to haemorrhage shock as
H
332
A
8
C
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 8 S.C.R.
result of gun shot injury which was sufficient to Cquse death
in the ordinary course of nature and was fired from a close
range showing powder and heat effect."
From the aforesaid report, it is quite clear that the death was
due to bullet injury and the direction of the wound was from front
to back and slight above to down. We shall dwell upon this
aspect when we deal with the said point.
10. We shall deal with the first contention first. In the plea
advanced under Section 313 CrPC, it has been stated by the
accused-appellant that as the public became angry due to the
conduct of Samar Singh, they assaulted him and in order to
save him; the investigating agency chose not to cite any
independent witness though many witnesses were present who
had seen the occurrence. There is no denial of the fact that
the occurrence had taken place in the house of Chander Pal
who has turned hostile. However, from his testimony and other
evidence brought on record, it is evident that the occurrence
took place in his house. His turning hostile does not affect the
case of the prosecution. The witnesses from the department
of police cannot perse be said to be untruthful or unreliable. It
would depend upon the veracity, credibility and
unimpeachability of their testimony. This Court, after referring
to State of U.P. v. Ani/ Singh 1, State, Govt. of NCT of Delhi v.
Sunil and Another2 and Ramjee Rai and Others v. State of
Bihar, has laid down recently in Kashmiri Lal v. State of
Haryana 4 that there is no absolute command of law that the
police officers cannot be cited as witnesses and their testimony
should always be treated with suspicion. Ordinarily, the public
at large show their disinclination to come forward to become
witnesses. If the testimony of the police officer is found to be
reliable and trustworthy, the court can definitely act upon the
1.
1988 SUPP. sec 686.
2.
(2001) 1 sec 652.
3.
(2006) 13 sec 229.
H 4. 2013 AIR sew 3102.
PRAMOD KUMAR v. STATE (GNCT) OF DELHI
[DIPAK MISRA, J.]
.333
same. If, in the course of scrutinising the evidence, the court
finds the evidence of the police officer as unreliable and
untrustworthy, the court may disbelieve him but it should not do
so solely on the presumption that a witness from the department
of police should be viewed with distrust. This is also based
on the principle that quality of the evidence weighs over the
quantity of evidence.
11. Thus, the submission that the whole case should be
thrown overboard because of non-examination of independent
witness and reliance on the official witnesses cannot be
accepted. Presently, we shall proceed to deal with the veracity
and acceptability of the testimony of the witnesses. The
learned trial Judge and the High Court, after x-ray of the
evidence of the witnesses, have come to the conclusion that
Pramod Kumar was a proclaimed offender; that information
was received by the competent authority that he was hiding in
the house of Chander Pal; that a team had gone to apprehend
him; that SI Jaswinder Singh along with other members of the
team waited at a distance of 100 yards and Maharaj Singh went
to the house of Chander Pal; that the accused was found on
the verandah of the house and was asked to surrender but he
immediately took out a knife from his shirt pocket; that before
he could inflict a knife blow, he was overpowered by Maharaj
Singh and there was a grapple between the two; and Maharaj
Singh, receiving a bullet injury, fell down and eventually
succumbed to the injuries in the hospital. It is not in dispute
that Pramod Kumar has received some injuries, but that would
not be a ground for discarding the prosecution version and
acceptance of the plea of the defence. The evidence on record
is required to be scrutinized and appreciated. The witnesses,
namely, Baljit Singh, PW-6, Samar Singh, PW-8, Jaswinder
Singh, PW-9, Rajbir Singh, PW-11 and Md. Iqbal, PW-16, who
have been examined in support of the prosecution, have stood
embedded in their version. The witness, Samar Singh, PW8, has vividly described the occurrence and the graphic
description has not been, in any manner, dented in spite of the
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
334
A
B
C
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
· [2013] 8 S.C.R.
roving cross-examination. It is apt to note that despite
searching cross-examination, none of the witnesses has given
way to any tergiversation. When their testimony has not been
varied from any spectrum, there is no reason to discard them.
Thus, the contention that there should have been examination
of independent witnesses to corroborate the evidence of the
police officials has to be treated as mercurial. Therefore, we
unhesitatingly repel the said submission.
12. The next limb of argument pertains to the nature of
weapon that has caused the injury on the deceased and the
circumstances and the position in which the injury was caused.
The first plank of this argument of the learned counsel for the
appellan~ is that the deceased has been fired at by Samar
Singh from his service revolver. On a perusal of the evidence
and the FSL report relating to the country-made pistol, Ext. F1, seized from the accused, it is manifest that the fire arm
country-made pistol .303 bore was designed to fire a standard
.303 cartridge and that the pistol was in working order. Its test
fire was also successfully conducted and the empty cartridge
of .303 bore, Ext. C-1, found in the chamber of the country-made
pistol was the empty cartridge fired from the country made pistol.
Therefore, to say that no shot was fired from the country-made
pistol is belied and the prosecution version that it was the
country-made pistol which was fired by the accused that caused
injuries to the deceased deserves acceptance.
13. The second plank of this limb of proponement is that
the accused-appellant could not have fired at the stomach
region of the deceased. From the post-mortem report, it is clear
that the bullet injury was from front to back. It is not in dispute
G that the deceased and the accused were grappling. The
version of the prosecution in that all of a sudden, the accused
brought out his desi katta and fired from a close range. This
has been clearly established by the evidence. Learned counsel
would submit that while grappling the position changed and the
H bullet fired from the service revolver of Samar Singh hit the
PRAMOD KUMAR v. STATE (GNC'r) OF DELHI
[DIPAK MISRA, J.]
335
deceased. In our considered opinion, such a submission
cannot be given any acceptance as the desi katta was seized
from the accused and the weapon, as opined in the FSL report,
is the desi katta and further there is no material to prove that
gun shot was fired from the weapon of Samar Singh. Thus, from
the aforesaid, it is clear as crystal that the shot was fired from
the country-made pistol seized from the custody of the accusedappellant. Hence, the plea that there was a gun shot from the
revolver of ~amar Singh while the accused-appellant was
grappling with the deceased being absolutely mercurial in
nature is rejected.
14. In view of the aforesaid premised reason(), the appeals,
being sans substance, stand dismissed.
B.B.B.
Appeals dismissed.
A
s
c
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org