ANIL GILURKER versus BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA GRAMIN BANK & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 15 September 2011 | [2011] 12 S.C.R. 618 | 2011 INSC 690
Key facts
- Decided
- 15 September 2011
- Bench
- R.V. RAVEENDRAN*, A.K. PATNAIK
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7864/2011
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [2011] 12 S.C.R. 618
- Neutral citation
- 2011 INSC 690
Text of the judgment
[201.1] 12 S.C.R. 618
A
ANIL GILURKER
v.
BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA GRAMIN BANK & ANR.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 7864-7865 of 2011)
B
SEPTEMBER 15, 2011
[R.V. RAVEENDRAN AND A.K. PATNAIK, JJ.]
C
D
E
F
G
H
Service Law - Dismissal from service - Allegation
against appellant, Branch Manager in the Bank that he
sanctioned and distributed loans to brick manufacturing units
but did not disburse the entire loan amount to the borrowers
and misappropriated part of the loan amount - Issuance of
charge-sheet - Punishment of removal of service imposed
by the disciplinary authority and the same was upheld by the
appellate authority- Writ Petition by appellant - Single Judge
of the High Court holding that there were no specific charges
in the charge-sheet, quashed the order of removal from
service and issued direction for reinstatement of the appellant
in service with continuity in service - Division Bench of the
High Court directed the disciplinary authority to consider the
inquiry report, the evidence recorded by the Enquiry Officer
and the documents relied upon in the charge-sheet and take
a fresh decision in accordance with law - On appeal, held:
Charges should be specific, definite and giving details of the
incident which formed the basis of charges and no enquiry
can be sustained on vague charges - On facts, a plain reading
of the charges and the statement of imputations show that
only vague allegations were made against the appellant - No
statement of imputations giving the particulars of the loan
accounts or the names of the borrowers, the amounts of loans
sanctioned, disbursed and misappropriated were furnished to
the appellant - Thus, the order of the Division Bench is set
aside and that of the Single Judge is restored - Direction of
the Single Judge to pay Rs. 1.5 lacs to the appellant as
618
ANIL GILURKER v. BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA 619
GRAMIN BANK & ANR.
compensation in lieu of arrears of salary is deleted.
Surath Chandra Chakrabarty v. State of West Bengal
(1970) 3 SCC 548: 1971 (3) SCR 1; Sawai Singh v. State of
Rajasthan (1986) 3 SCC 454: 1986 (2) SCR 957; Union of
India and Ors. v. Gyan Chand Chattar (2009) 12 SCC 78:
2009 (10 ) SCR 124 - referred to.
A
B
Case Law Reference:
1971 (3) SCR 1
Referred to
Para 4
1986 (2) SCR 957
Referred to
Para 4
2009 (10) SCR 124
Referred to
Para 4
c
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.
7864-7865 of 2011.
D
From the Judgment & Order dated 28.04.2010 of the High
Court of Madhya Pradesh, Principal Seat at Jabalpur, M.P.
Passed in W.A. Nps. 57 and 82 of 2010.
_
Ravindra Shrivastava, Anup Jain, Kunal Verma for the
Appellant.
E
Akshat Shrivastava, P.P. Singh, Pooja Shrivastava for the
Respondents.
The following order of the Court was delivered by
F
ORDER
A. K. PATNAIK, J. 1. Leave granted.
2. These are appeals against the order dated 28.04.2010
of the Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Writ
Appeal No.57 of 2010 and Writ Appeal No.82 of 2010.
3. The facts very briefly are that on 03.05.1984 the
appellant was appointed as a Branch Manager in the Bilaspur
G
H
620
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2011) 12 S.C.R.
A Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank by way of direct recruitment and
he successfully completed the period of probation. While he
was working on the post of Branch Manager in Branch Patewa,
he sanctioned and distributed loans to a large number of brick
manufacturing units under the Integrated Gram Development
B Programme. The disciplinary authority placed the appellant
under suspension and issued a charge-sheet dated
31.01.1989 against him for misconduct punishable under
Regulation 30(1) of the Staff Service Regulations. In the chargesheet, it was alleged that the appellant sanctioned and
c distributed loans to a large number of brick manufacturing units
in a very short period of time, but had not in fact disbursed the
entire loan amount to the borrowers and part of the loan amount
was misappropriated by him. The appellant was asked to
submit his written defence in reply to the charges. On
11.02.1989, the appellant submitted his written defence
0
denying the allegations made in the charge-sheet. An Inquiry
Officer enquired into the charges against the appellant and
submitted his report with a finding that the witnesses produced
by the Bank had·not said that what was actually advanced was
less than the loan amount, and although there were some
E serious irregularities, the charge of financial corruption against
the appellant had not been proved. The disciplinary authority
in his order dated 10.09.1991 disagreed with the findings of
the Inquiry Officer and held that the charge of financial corruption
against the appellant had been proved and that the appellant
F had not only violated the Rules of the Bank, but had also tried
to cause financial loss to the Bank and by abusing his position,
had lowered down the reputation of the Bank. In the order dated
10.09.1991, the disciplinary authority proposed to impose the
punishment of removal of the appellant along with forfeiture of
G the contribution of the Bank to the Provident Fund of the
appellant under Section 50(1) of the Staff Regulations. By the
order dated 10.09.1991, the disciplinary authority directed that
a copy of the order and report of the Inquiry Officer be sent to
the appellant to show-cause why he should not be punished as
H
ANIL GILURKER v. BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA 621
GRAMIN BANK & ANR. [A.K. PATNAIK, J.]
proposed. On 18.09.1991, the appellant submitted his reply to
the show-cause notice and on 25.11.1991, the disciplinary
authority passed the order of removal. Aggrieved, the appellant
filed an appeal against the order of the disciplinary authority,
but the appeal was dismissed by the appellate authority.
4. The appellant then filed a Writ Petition before the
Madhya Pradesh High Court challenging the order of removal
passed by the disciplinary authority. After the reorganization of
the Madhya Pradesh in the year 2000, the Writ Petition was
transferred to the Chhattisgarh High Court and was heard by a
learned Single Judge of the Chhattisgarh High Court. The
learned Single Judge in his judgment dated 22.02.2010 found
that in the charge-sheet, there is no reference to any specific
documents or to the names of the persons who had not been
given the loan amounts and accordingly took the view that in
the charge-sheet there were no specific charges. Relying on
the decisions of this Court in Surath Chandra Chakrabarty v.
State of West Bengal [(1970) 3 SCC 548], Sawai Singh v.
State of Rajasthan [(1986) 3 SCC 454] and Union of India &
Ors. v. Gyan Chand Chattar ((2009) 12 SCC 78], the learned
Single Judge held that when the charges levelled against the
delinquent officer in the charge-sheet were vague and not
specific and the entire enquiry is vitiated. The learned Single
Judge quashed the orders of the disciplinary authority and the
appellate authority and directed reinstatement of the appellant
in service with continuity in service and without loss of seniority
in the post to which he would be entitled to. The learned Single
Judge further directed that the appellant will be entitled to
compensation of Rs.1.5 lacs in lieu of arrears of his salary.
A
8
C
D
E
F
5. Aggrieved by the order of the learned Single Judge
granting only Rs.1.5 lacs as compensation in lieu of arrears of G
salary, the appellant filed Writ Appeal No.57 of 2010 and
aggrieved by the impugned order of learned Single Judge in
the Writ Petition quashing the orders of the disciplinary authority
H
622
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2011] 12 S.C.R.
A and the appellate authority, the respondents filed Writ Appeal
No.82 of 2010. After hearing the Writ Appeals, the Division
Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court held in the impugned
order that the charges against the appellant as described in
the charge-sheet were not vague as on the basis of documents
B mentioned in the charge-sheet, it has been alleged that the
appellant had sanctioned the loans and had shown the loans
only on paper but had not actually disbursed the loans to the
borrowers. The Division Bench of the High Court, however, held
that as the disciplinary authority had disagreed with the findings
c in the inquiry report, ·he should have furnished his reasons for
the disagreement to the appellant before passing the order of
punishment. The Division Bench of the High Court further held
that the disciplinary authority cannot conduct further enquiry suo
motu to fill up the lacuna in the enquiry. The Division Bench of
the High Court allowed both the appeals and directed that the
0
disciplinary authority will consider the inquiry report, the
evidence recorded by the Enquiry OffiC'er and the documents
relied upon in the charge-sheet and take a fresh decision in
accordance with law. The Division· Bench of the High Court
further observed in the impugned order that if the disciplinary
E authority takes a view on reconsideration of the matter not to
take any further action against the appellant, he shall be given
all the consequential benefits along with reinstatement.
6. We have heard Mr. Ravindra Shrivastava, learned
F counsel for the appellant and Mr. Akshat Shrivastava, learned
counsel for the respondents, and we are of the considered
opinion that the Division Bench of the High Court was not
correct in taking a view in the impugned order that the charges
against the appellant were not vague. The English translation
G of the charges and the statement of imputations extracted from
the charge-sheet dated 31.01.1989 served on the appellant is
reproduced hereinbelow:
H
ANIL GILURKER v. BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA 623
GRAMIN BANK & ANR. [A.K. PATNAIK, J.]
Charge Sheet No. D/A/756 dated 31.1.89
. Statement of imputations
Whila working as Branch
Manager in Branch Patewa, in
the first quarter of the year
1988, have sanctioned and
distributed loan of brick
manufacturing in large number
under the Integrated Gram
Development Programme by
committing unauthorized
irregularities contrary to the
rules and interest of the bank
and administration. In most of
these loan cases you have
shown cash distribution of the
entire loan and has given only
one minor__part of the loan
amount to-· the Borrower in
cash and from the balance
amount, some amount. has
been deposited in their saving
accounts
(deducting
contribution amount equivalent
to the amount for closing the
loan account) and the
remaining amount has been
grabbed· by you. branch
employees and in collusions
with the Gram Sewaks. After a
very little time adjusting the
contribution amount in these
loan accounts, you have
withdrawn the amount from the
Saving Accounts of the
A
Charge
Tempted with his malafide
intention serious violation of
the Rules and interests of the
Bank and Administration, in
a very short period of time
sanction the loan of Brick
manufacturing in large scale
under the "I. Gram. Dev.
Prog." And distributed and
in most of the loan cases,
without actually distribution
of the entire loan amount,
you have completed the
documentary proceedings,
and showing the cash
distribution of the entir~ loan
amount, only a minor· share
of the loan has been given
cash to the concerned
borrower and from the
remaining amount some
amount has been deposited
in the account of the
borrower and the balance
amount in connivance with
otlier persons have been
grabbed. With the intention
to cover up your this act, only
after a few time of the loan
distribution, you have
withdrawn the amount from
the saving accounts of the
concerned borrowers and
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
624
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
concerned borrowers, you
have closed most of the loan
accounts much before the time
fixed for the repayment.
[2011] 12 S.C.R.
most of the accounts have
been closed before time. As
such for the fulfillment of your
personal gain you have
deliberately misused the
position of your post and has
committed
financial
corruption in large scale.
From which cause serious
shock the interests of the
bank administration and the
borrower also, the reputation
of the bank has also been
lowered down. Your this act
is a misconduct under
Sections 17, 19 and 30(1) of
the Employees Collection
Service Regulations.
7. A cplain reading of the charges and the statement of
imputations reproduced above would show that only vague
E allegations were made against the appellant that he had
sanctioned loans to a large number of brick manufacturing units
by committing irregularities, but did not disburse the entire loan
amount to the borrowers and while a portion of the loan amount
was deposited in the account of the borrowers, the balance was
F misappropriated by him and others. The details of the loan
accounts or the names of the borrowers have not been
mentioned in the charges. The amounts of loan which were
sanctioned and the amounts which were actually disbursed to
the borrowers and the amounts alleged to have been
G misappropriated by the appellant have not been mentioned.
8. We also find that along with the charge-sheet dated
31.01.1989 no statement of imputations giving the particulars
of the loan accounts or the names of the borrowers, the amounts
H of loans sanctioned, disbursed and misappropriated were
ANIL GILURKER v. BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIA
GRAMIN BANK & ANR. [A.K. PATNAIK, J.]
625
furnished to the appellant, and yet the disciplinary authority has A
called upon the appellant to submit his written defence
statement in reply to the charges. We fail to appreciate how
the appellant could have submitted his written statement in
defence in respect of the charges and how a fair enquiry could
be held unless he was furnished with the particulars of the loan 8
accounts or the names of the borrowers, the amounts of loan
sanctioned, the amounts actually disbursed and the amounts
misappropriated were also furnished in the charge-sheet.
9. As has been held by this Court in Surath Chandra
Chakrabarty v. State of West Bengal (supra):
C
"5 ...... The grounds on which it is proposed to take action
have to be reduced to the form of a definite charge or
charges which have to be communicated to the person
charged together with a statement of the allegations on [J
which each charge is based and any other circumstance'
which it is proposed to be taken into consideration in
passing orders has also tQ be stated. This rule embodies
a principle which is one of the basic contents of a
reasonable or adequate opportunity for defending oneself.
If a person is not told clearly and definitely what the
allegation~ are on which the charges preferred against him
are founded he cannot possibly, by projecting his own
imagination, discover all the facts and circumstances that
may be in the contemplation of the authorities to be Festablished against him .... ."
10. This position of law has been reiterated in the recent.
case of Union of India & Ors. v. Gyan Chand Chattar (supra)
and in Para 35 of the judgment as reported in the sec, this
Court has observed that the law can be summarized that an G
enquiry is to be conducted against any person giving strict
adherence to the statutory provisions and principles of natural
justice and the charges should be specific, definite and giving
details of the incident which formed the basis of charges and
H
no enquiry can be sustained on vague charges.
626
A
s
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2011] 12 S.C.R.
11. We, therefore, allow these appeals, set aside the
impugned order of the Division Bench and restore the order of
the learned Single Judge. Considering the peculiar facts and
circumstances, we delete the direction of the learned Single
Judge to pay Rs.1.5 lacs to the appellant as compensation in
lieu of arrears of salary and we are also not inclined to grant
any backwages to the appellant. There shall be no order as to
costs.
N.J.
Appeals allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org