D.M. BELGAMVALA versus TAMILNADU REAL ESTATES (P) LTD.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 24 November 2010 | [2010] 13 S.C.R. 1072 | 2010 INSC 808
Key facts
- Decided
- 24 November 2010
- Bench
- MARKANDEY KATJU, GYAN SUDHA MISRA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 13740/2010
- Disposal
- Hearing Adjourned
- Citation
- [2010] 13 S.C.R. 1072
- Neutral citation
- 2010 INSC 808
Text of the judgment
[2010] 13 (ADDL.) S.C.R. 1072
A
D.M. BELGAMVALA
v.
TAMILNADU REAL ESTATES (P) LTD.
(I.A. No. 2/2010 in S.L.P. (C} No. 13740/2010 etc.)
B
NOVEMBER 24, 2010
[MARKANDEY KATJU AND GYAN SUDHA MISRA, JJ.]
Administration of Justice:
c
0
E
Abuse of process of court - SLP against eviction of tenant
dismissed by Supreme Court - Tenant filing an undertaking
to vacate the premises - Thereafter tenant filing the
interlocutory application for a direction that he need not to
vacate the premises till the disposal of the review petition or
in the alternative stay of dispossessin may be granted HELD: The application is a sheer abuse of the process of the
court - The tenant be evicted from the premises forthwith by
using police force, ignoring the stay of eviction stated to have
been passed by the High Court - Rent Control and Eviction.
JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE:
Stay order - Granted by High Court - Long after
dismissal of tenant's SLP against eviction, by Supreme Court
- HELD: This was not expected of the High Court - Judicial
F discipline requires that High Courts should not try to override
orders passed by Supreme Court - Rent Control and
Eviction.
CONTEMPT OF COURT:
G
H
Contempt of Order of Supreme Court - SLP against
e.:iction on the ground of reconstruction of the old premises
dismissed by Supreme Court - Tenant furnishing an
undertaking to vacate the premises - Thereafter,
1072
D.M. BELGAMVALA v. TAMILNADU REAL ESTATES 1073
(P) LTD.
Commissioner of Municipal Corporation revoking the
premission to demolish the premises - HELD: The
Commissioner of the Municipal Corporation is hand-in-glove
with the tenant and it is for this reason that he has passed this
collusive and contemptuous order merely to get over the
order of Supreme Court dismissing the Special Leave Petition
- Issue contempt of court notice to the Commissioner of
Municipal as well as to the trying to set at naught the order of
the Supreme Court - Rent Control and Eviction.
A
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : I.A. No. 2 of 2010.
c
B
IN
S.L.P. (C) No. 13704 of 2010
From the Judgment & Order dated 18.2.2010 of the High
Court of Judicature at Madras in C.R.P. (NPD) No. 3081 of
2009.
D
K.K. Mani, Abhishek Krishna for the Petitioner.
V. Ramasubramanian for the Respondent.
E
The following Order of the Court was delivered
ORDER
This is a typical case of a litigant trying to take this Court
for a ride.
In this case, the landlord had filed an eviction peition
against the petitioner-tenant which had been decreed by the
courts below, including the High Court. The eviction was
granted on the ground that the building in question is more than
100 years old and needed demolition and fresh construction.
The Special Leave Petition (C) No. 13704 of 2010 filed by the
petitioner against the order of the High Court was dismissed
by this Court by order dated 14.5.2010 and the petitioner
F
G
_Ii
1074 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2010] 13 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
A
(tenant) was granted six months time from 14.5.2010 to vacate
the premises in question subject to filing ususal undertaking
before this Court. The petitioner had furnished the undertaking
to vacate the premises in question as directed by this Court.
Despite this undertaking, the petitioner has not vacated,
and instead he has filed this application on 12.11.2010 praying
for a drection that the petitioner need not vacate the suit
premises till the final orders passed in the Review Petition of
in the alternative grant stay of dispossession of the petitioner
C from the suit premises.
8
In our opinion, this application is a sheer abuse of the
process of thE;! court.
Along with the application an order dated 18.06.2010 of
the
Commissioner,
corporation of Chennai has been filed
0
purporting to revoke the permission to demolish the property
in question. We are of the opinion that the Commissioner,
Corporaion of Chennai is hand-in-glove with the petitioner and
it is for this reason that he has passed this collussive and
E contemtuous order dated 18.06.2010 merely to get over our
order dismissing the Special Leave Petition on 14.05.201.
Issue contempt of court notice to the Commissioner,
Corporation of Channai as well as to the petitioner in this case
to show cause why they should not be punished for contempt
F of court for trying to take this court for a ride and set at naught
our order dated 14.5.2010.
We further direct that the petitioner be evicted from the
premises in question forthwith by using police force Ignoring the
G order of stay of evicicn which we are informed has been passed
by he High Court. If the petitioner or anyone tries to obstruct
this order, he should know now that he will definitely be sent to
jail. There is a limit of tolerance by this Court and the petitioner
has crossed that limit.
H
D.M. BELGAMVALA v. TAMILNADU REAL ESTATES1075
(P) LTD.
We are informed that the petitioner had, long after we
dismissed the Special Leave Petition on 14.05.2010,
approached the Madras High Court and obtained a stay of
eviction. We are surprised that the Madras High Court has
flouted the order of his Court dismissing the Special Leave
Petition on 14.05.2010. This was not expected of the High
Court. Judicial discipline requires that the High Courts should
not try to override orders passed by this Court. Such defiant
attitude of the High Courts will not be tolerated by this Court.
With these observations, the interlocutary application is
dismissed.
Copy of this order be sent to the Registrar General of the
Madras High Court who will place it before the Chief Justice
··of the High Court. The Registrar General will send a report to
this Court mentioning how and why a stay order was granted
by the High Court despite our order dated 14.05.2010.
A
8
C
D
Contempt Petition No. 289 of 2010 in Special Leave
Petition (C.) No. 13704/2010.
E
Contempt Petition is aken on board.
We are informed that this contempt petition in the Special
Leave Petition (C.)' No. 13704/2010 has been filed by he
respondent herein. The, order passed in the interlocuory
application above will also 'govern this contemp petition.
·,
Issue notice.
List the contempt petition on 12.01.2011.
R.P.
Matter adjourned.
F
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org