DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS. versus DINESH CHANDER NANDA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 8 September 2010 | [2010] 10 S.C.R. 1101 | 2010 INSC 584
Key facts
- Decided
- 8 September 2010
- Bench
- P. SATHASIVAM*, ANIL R. DAVE
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7465/2010
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2010] 10 S.C.R. 1101
- Neutral citation
- 2010 INSC 584
Text of the judgment
.:,.
I
[2010] 10 S.C.R. 1101
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS.
A
v.
DINESH CHANDER NANDA
(Civil Appeal No. 7465 of 2010)
SEPTEMBER 08, 2010
B
[P. SATHASIVAM AND ANIL R. DAVE, JJ.)
Jammu and Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995 - Articles 56
and 119 - Suit by architect against trust claiming certain
amount towards professional charges - Issue as regards
maintainability/limitation - Contention by the trust that suit is
governed by Article 56 and was barred by limitation on 'the
date of its institution - Courts below holding that suit is
governed by Article 119 and not Article 56 - Interference with
- Held: Not called for - Services provided by architect are
taxable under the Service Tax laws - Term 'work done' as
appearing in Article 56 does not apply to architect providing
services for a fee, thus Article 56 not applicable.
Words and Phrases: Terms 'price' and 'work done' Meaning of - In the context of Article 56 of the Jammu and
Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995.
The respondent-architect .filed a suit against the
appellant-trust claiming certain amount towards
professional charges including interest for various
projects. During the pendency of the suit, the respondent
filed application for the amendment of the plaint. The
issue was raised regarding the maintainability/limitation
of the application. The trial court held that the case was
governed by Article 119 and not by Article 56 of the
Jammu and Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995 and allowed the
amendment to the plaint. The appellant-trust filed a
revision petition. The appellant-trust contended that the
suit was governed by Article 56 of the Act and the same
1101
C
D
E
F
G
H
1102
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[201 OJ 10 S.C.R.
A was barred by limitation on the date of its institution. The
High Court upheld the order passed by the trial court.
Therefore, the appellant-trust filed the instant appeal.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court
B
HELD: 1.1 The term 'work done' as appearing in
Article 56 of the Jammu and Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995
does not apply to the respondent, who is an architect
providing services for a fee. [Para 12] [1110-F-G]
c
1.2 The term 'price', as appearing in Article 56 of the
Act, is to be understood in common parlance/ordinary or
normal sense. It takes its colour from the meaning
attached to the term 'price' in the Articles immediately
preceding 'Articles 52 to 55'. 'Price' does not cover the
services
provided by the professionals such as architect,
0
lawyer, doctor etc., as professionals charge a 'fee'. Also,
the term 'work done' in Article 56 will not be applicable
to professionals such as architect, lawyer, doctor etc. as
these professionals render services to their clients. The
E remuneration of a professional is in the form of a 'fee'
and, therefore, it cannot be said that the professional
earns a 'price'. In common usage, the term 'price' refers
to goods sold. The term 'price' is used in Articles 52 to
55 in correlation to goods delivered, goods sold and
delivered and trees or growing crops sold. In the said
F way, 'price' would take a similar meaning when used in
Article 56. [Paras 8 and 9] [1110-F-G]
Websters Encyclopedic Unabridged Dictionary;
"Chambers Twentieth Century Dictionary; Law Lexicon by P.
G Ramanatha Iyer 2nd Edn. 1997 - referred to.
1.3 The specific treatment of attorneys/vakils who
provide professional services is a reflection of the
intention of the Legislature to treat the services provided
H
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS. v.
DINESH CHANDER NANDA
1103
by professionals differently from work done by others.
The word 'price' was never intended to be used
synonymously with the word 'fee' and, therefore, the fee
charged by an architect for services rendered by him
would not be covered under Article 56 of the Act. In the
instant case, the trial court as well as the High Court
made a clear distinction between the terms 'work done'
and 'services'. The 'work done' would refer work done by
masons such as land filling or engineering projects etc.
[Para 11) [1109-F-H; 1110-A]
1.4 The services provided by an architect are taxable
under the Service Tax law. Whereunder the architects are
considered as persons providing a service and are liable
to pay service tax. The term 'work done' has not been
defined anywhere. [Para 12) [1110-D]
1.5 The claim of the respondent that the profession
of an Architect is one such service, hence Article 56 is
not applicable, is accepted. There is no error in the
conclusion arrived at by the trial court and upheld by the
High Court. [Para 16) [1112-E-F]
A
8
c.
D
E
Kaviraj Baroda Kant Sen vs. Court of Wards in Charge
of Baraon Estate AIR 1931 All. 752; Kakodonga Tea Estate
vs. J.N. Saikia AIR 1973 Gau. 27 - approved.
F
Case Law Reference:
AIR 1931 All. 752
Approved.
Para 14
AIR 1973 Gau. 27
Approved.
Para 15
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.
7465 of 2010.
From the Judgment & Order dated 18.10.2007 of the High
Court of Jammu & Kashmir at Jammu in Civil Revision Petition
bearing C. Rev. No. 177 of 2005.
G
H
1104
A
SUPREME. COURT REPORTS
[2010] 10 S.C.R.
Ashok Mathur, Anshul Narayan for the Appellants.
V. Giri, Rohit Bhat, Vikas Mehta for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
B
P. SATHASIVAM, J. 1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 18.10.2007 passed by the High Court of Jammu &
Kashmir at Jammu in Civil Revision No. 177 of 2005 whereby
C the High Court dismissed the revision filed by the Dharmarth
Trust (hereinafter referred to as "the Trust")-appellants herein.
3. Brief facts:
(a) The Respondent, a qualified, registered and licensed
D Architect, is engaged in his professional business in the name
of Mis Nanda Designers Consortium having its office at 60
Purani Mandi, Jammu. On 19.10.1992, he was engaged by the
Trust for the purpose of providing professional consultancy
services as an architect for various projects at different sites
E in Jammu. As per the terms of the said contract, a fee of 2.5%
of the total project cost was fixed for providing such-services.
F
(b) On 14.12.1993, the appellants-Trust telephonically
communicated the respondent not to work further for their
projects and terminated his services as an Architect. A formal
communication was also served on 16.01.1994 regarding the
termination of his services.
(c) On 16.10.1996, the Respondent served a legal notice
to the Trust claiming compensation amounting to Rs.
G 38,77,263.75 towards professional charges including interest
thereon for various projects. After not getting any reply from the
Trust, after a gap of four years, on 29.01.1998, a suit was filed ·
by the Respondent in the Court of the 1st Additional District
Judge, Jammu, claiming an amount of Rs, 43,30,797/-. During
H
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS. v.
1105
DINESH CHANDER NANDA [P. SATHASIVAM, J.]
the pendency of the suit, on 08.02.1999, the Respondent filed
an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure for amendment in the Plaint. On 22.09.1999, the
Trust filed their reply objecting to the maintainability of the
application. By order dated 08.10.1999, the trial Court allowed
the application. Challenging the said order, the Trust filed Civil
Revision No. 162 of 1999 before the High Court praying that
the trial Court had committed an error in law by allowing the
amendment in the plaint without addressing the legal issue
regarding its maintainability. The High Court, vide order dated
19.07.2001, disposed of the civil revision petition filed by the
Trust and remanded the matter back to the trial Court to
address the legal issue regarding maintainability/limitation.
Thereafter, on 27.09.2005, 1st Additional District Judge framed
the issue and passed an order holding that the case is
governed by Article 119 and not by Article 56 of the Jammu &
Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as "the
Act") and consequently, allowed the amendment to the Plaint.
(d) Challenging the said order, the Trust filed Civil Revision
No. 177 of 2005 before the High Court. Vide order dated
18.10.2007, the High Court dismissed the revision and upheld
the order dated 27.09.2005, passed by the 1st Additional
District Judge. Aggrieved by th~ said order, the Trust has filed
this appeal by way of special leave before this Court.
4. Heard Mr. Ashok Mathur, learned counsel for the
appellants and Mr. V. Giri, learned senior counsel for the
respondent.
5. The short question that arises for consideration in this
appeal is whether the suit filed by the respondent-Architect is
covered under Article 56 of the Act or whether the said suit is
covered under Article 119 of the Act.
6. The Trial Court and the High Court have held that the
suit is covered by Article 119 of the Act. According to the
appellants, the suit filed by the respondent-Architect is governed
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
1106
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2010] 10 S.C.R.
A by Article 56 of the said Act and the same was barred by
limitation on the date of its institution. On the other hand, the
submission of the respondent is that the same was covered by
the residuary Article 119 which provides for a period of 6 years
on the ground that the nature of services provided was
B professional services and the remuneration for the same being
termed as 'fee' and the same does not fall within the expression
'price' for 'work done'.
7. Article 56 and Article 119 of the Schedule to the Jammu
C and Kashmir Limitation Act, 1995 provides as follows:-
D
Article For the price of work done by Three
56
the Plaintiff for the Defendant Years
at his request, where no
time has been fixed for
payment.
When the
work is
done.
Article Suit for which no period
119
of limitation provided
elsewhere in the Scheduel.
When the
right to sue
accrues.
Six
Years
E
8. The term 'price', as appearing in Article 56, is to be
understood in common parlance/ordinary or normal sense. It
takes it colour from the meaning attached to the term 'price' in
the Articles immediately preceding 'Articles 52 to 55'. 'Price'
F does not cover the services provided by the professionals such
as Architect, Lawyer, Doctor etc., as professionals charge a
'fee'. Also, the term 'work done' in Article 56 will not be
applicable to professionals such as Architect, Lawyer, Doctor
etc. as these professionals render services to their clients. The
G remuneration of a professional is in the form of a 'fee' and
therefore, it cannot be said that the professional earns a 'price'.
In common usage, the term 'price' refers to goods sold. For
illustration, the term 'price' is defined in Section 2 (10) of the
Sale of Goods Act, 1930 as "price" means the money
consideration for a sale of goods.
H
•
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS. v.
1107
DINESH CHANDER NANDA [P. SATHASIVAM, JT--
9. The word 'price' according to Websters Encyclopedic
Unabridged Dictionary means:
"Price- 1. the sum or amount of money or its equivalent
for which anything is bought, sold, or offered for sale 2. a
sum offered for the capture of a person alive of dead: The
authorities put a price on his head. 3. the sum of money,
or other consideration, for which a person's support,
consent, etc., may be obtained, esp. in cases involving
sacrifice of integrity: They claimed that every man has his
price. 4. that which must be given, done, or undergone in
order to obtain a thing: He gained the victory, but at a
heavy price. 5. Odds (def.2). 6. Archaic, value or worth:
The price of an honest man is beyond measure. 7. Archaic,
great value or worth (usually prec by of): Among the
inventory were many articles of price. 8. at any price, at
any cost, no matter how great: There were no bananas to
be had at any price. He would have his own way at any
price. 9. beyond or without price, of incalculable value;
priceless: The crown jewels are beyond price.-v.t. 10. to
fix the price of. 11. to ask or determine the price of: We
spent the day pricing furniture at various stores.
A
B
C
D
E
"Chambers Twentieth C_entury Dictionary defines "price"
to mean:
"The amount, usually in money, for which a thing is sold or
offered; that which one for goes or suffers for the sake of
or in gaining something: money offered for capture or killing
of anybody; that for which one can be bribed; betting odds;
value."
According to P. Ramanatha Iyer, Law Lexicon (2nd Edn.
1997),
"the term 'price' is the value which a seller places upon his
goods for sale. It is not a fixed or unchangeable thing. It
may be one thing today and another tomorrow and one
F
G
H
1108
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2010] 10 S.C.R.
valuation to one customer and a different one to another
on the same day or hour. Whether a seller asks any one
to give is the price until he changes it for another. The price
asked is changed to another price, the former price is no
longer an existing fact."
The Law Lexicon also defines the term 'price' as
"the sum or amount of money or its equivalent, which a
seller asks or obtains for goods in market-the
exchangeable value of a commodity-and hence, as used
in a contract providing for the sale of articles at a fixed
price, and that if the price falls below such fixed price, a
rebate will be given ... "
"The term 'price' is sometimes also used for "work done"
in the context of work done by masons such as land filling
etc. or engineering contracts. In view of the above, the term
'price' is in common usage used in correlation to either
goods bought or sold or work done."
There is further indication of this word in the Act itself. The
E setting of Article 56 i.e. immediately after Articles 52 to 55 is
important. Articles 52 to 55 uses the expression 'price'. These
are reproduced hereinbelow:Three
years
upon.
The date of
the delivery of
goods.
G
Article For the price of goods sold Three
. and delivered to be paid
years
53
for after the expiry of fixed
period of credit.
When the
period of credit
expires.
H
Article For the price of goods sold Three
and delivered to be paid for years
54
by a bill of exchange, no
such bill being oiven.
When the
period of the
pro posed bill
elapses.
F
..
Article For the price of goods
52
delivered where no fixed
period of credit is agreed
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAM MU & ORS. v.
DINESH CHANDER NANDA [P. SATHASIVAM, J.)
Article For the price of trees or
growing crops sold by the
55
plaintiff to the defendant
where no fixed period of
credit is agreed upon.
Three
years
1109
The date of the
sale
A
B
The term 'price' has been used in Articles 52 to 55 in correlation
to goods delivered, goods sold and delivered and trees or
growing crops sold. In this way, 'price' would take a similar
meaning when used in Article 56.
10. The intention of the Legislature can also be
ascertained by referring to Article 114 of the Act where the
Legislature has specifically provided for the period of Limitation
for suits filed by an attorney/vakil. Article 114 is as follows:-
c
D
Six The date of the
Article By an attorney or vakil for
114 his costs of a suit or a
Years termination of the
particular business, there
suit or business,
being no express agreement
or (where the
as to the time when such
attorney or vakil
costs are to be paid.
properly
discontinues the
suit or business)
the date of such
discontinuance.
E
11. As rightly pointed out by Mr. Giri, learned senior
counsel for the respondent that the specific treatment of
attorneys/vakils who provide professional services is a reflection
of the intention of the Legislature to treat the services provided
by professionals differently from work done by others. The word
'price' was never intended to be used synonymously with the
word 'fee' and, therefore, the fee charged by an Architect for
services rendered by him would not be covered under Article
56 of the Act. In the case on hand, the Trial Court as well as
the High Court have made a clear distinction between the terms
G
F
H
1110
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2010] 10 S.C.R.
'work done' and 'services'. The 'work done' would refer work
done by masons such as land filling or engineering projects etc.
12. It is useful to refer to the tax treatment of Architects
under the Service Tax Law. Chapter V of the Finance Act, 1994,
B which contains the law relating to Service tax in India defines
an "architect" in Section 65(6) as:-
C
0
E
F
"any person whose name is, for the time being, entered in
the register of architects maintained under section 23 of
the Architect Act, 1972 and also includes any person
engaged in any manner, whether directly or indirectly, in
rendering services in the field of architecture."
It is brought to our notice that the services provided by an
architect are taxable under the Service Tax law. Under the
Service Tax Laws, the architects are considered as persons
providing a service and are liable to pay service tax. The term
'work done' has not been defined anywhere. We have already
pointed out the dictionary meaning to the definition of 'work'.
The Law Lexicon defines 'work' as:"the word "work" has a very wide meaning. It is really used
in two senses of bestowing labour and that upon which
labour has been bestowed. When used in plural the word
certainly means some outstanding or important result of
the labour that has been bestowed and large industrial and
scientific establishment are called works"
We have already referred to Articles 52 to 55 which are placed
above Article 56. It is clear that the term 'work done' as
appearing in Article 56 does not apply to the respondent, who
G is an architect providing services for a fee.
13. It is also pointed out that Article 56 of the Act is a
verbatim of Article 18 of the Indian Limitation Act, 1963. Article
18, in turn is the same as Article 56 of the old Indian Limitation
Act, 1908.
H
DHARMARTH TRUST J & K JAMMU & ORS. v.
DINESH CHANDER NANDA [P. SATHASIVAM, J.]
1111
14. The High Court of Allahabad in Kaviraj Baroda Kant
Sen vs. Court of Wards in Charge of Baraon Estate, Al R 1931
All. 752, as early as in 1931, while interpreting Article 56 of the
Indian Limitation Act, 1908 has stated as follows:
A
" ..... it is difficult to apply Article 56 which relates to a suit
for the price of work done by the Plaintiff for the Defendant
at his request. No special article appears to be applicable
to a claim by a medical practitioner for recovery of his fees
for attendance on a patient. The residuary Article 115
which applies to all breaches of contract, would therefore
apply, for there was undoubtedly a contract, at east, an
implied one, to pay the fee, and the non-payment of that
fee amounted to a breach for which the plaintiff would be
entitled to compensation. In Harish Chander Surmah vs
Brojonath Chackerbutty [1870] 13 W.R. 96 a suit for
recovery of compensation for the fees of a medical
practitioner was held to lie under the corresponding article
of the Limitation Act then in force"
B
15. The High Court of Gauhati in Kakodonga Tea Estate
vs. JN. Saikia, AIR 1973 Gau. 27, has also held that "a suit to
recover unpaid professional fees by a Chartered Accountant
falis under Article 113 and not under Article 18 or Article 55 ... ".
The High Court of Gauhati furth~r specifically held as follows:
"8. It is easy to assume that very deep thought must have
been devoted by the Legislature in giving shape to the
various Articles of the old as well as the new Limitation
Act. It is equally legitimate to assume that the words of
each Article must have been used in their commonly
accepted connotation unless contrary intention is
expressed in the body of the Act just as is apparent from
Section 2 wherein certain expressions have been defined
to mean something less or more than what their commonly
known attributes are. The expression "price" used in Article
18 must, therefore, be taken to convey the commonly
C
D
E
F
G
H
1112
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2010] 10 S.C.R.
accepted sense implicit in it. According to the Chambers
Twentieth Century dictionary the word "price" means: the
amount. usually in money, for which a thing is sold or
offered; that which one forgoes or suffers for the sake of
or in gaining something: money offered for capture or killing
of anybody: that for which one can be bribed; betting odds;
values. In common parlance what a client pays to a
professional person like an Advocate and a CA is
described as "fee" and not "price". Likewise, what a
patient pays to a medical-man for the services rendered
to him by the latter is called "fee" and not "price". Therefore,
it would be unduly straining the expression "price" used in
Article 18 if it were held synonymous in connotation with
the fee paid to an Advocate, a Medical-man or a CA. For
this reason alone, I believe, Article 18 does not provide
for a suit for the professional fee of the nature just
stated ..... "
A
B
c
D
16. We agree with the ratio laid down by the Allahabad
and Gauhati High Court relating to Article 56 of the Indian
Limitation Act, 1908 that the term "price of work done" cannot
E be made applicable to professions where the professionals
merely provides services for a "fee". We accept the claim of
the respondent that the profession of an Architect is one such
service, hence Article 56 is not applicable to the present case.
Both the Trial Court as well as the High Court has arrived correct
F conclusion.
17. In the light of the above discussion, we do not find any
error in the conclusion arrived at by the Trial Court and affirmed
by the High Court. Consequently, the appeal fails and the same
is dismissed with no orders as to costs. We further make it
G clear that our conclusion is confined to the interpretation relating
to limitation and we have not expressed anything on the merits
of the claim made by the parties.
N.J
Appeal dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org