HDFC BANK LTD. versus J.J. MANNAN @ J.M. JOHN PAUL & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 16 December 2009 | [2009] 16 S.C.R. 590 | 2009 INSC 1314
Key facts
- Decided
- 16 December 2009
- Bench
- ALTAMAS KABIR*, DEEPAK VERMA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2415/2009
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [2009] 16 S.C.R. 590
- Neutral citation
- 2009 INSC 1314
Text of the judgment
(2009] 16 (ADDL.) S.C.R. 590
A
B
HDFC BANK LTD.
v.
J.J. MANNAN @ J.M. JOHN PAUL & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal No. 2415 of 2009)
~
.
DECEMBER 16, 2009
[ALTAMAS KABIR AND DEEPAK VERMA, JJ.]
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973:
c
D
E
F
G
H
s. 438 - Anticipatory bail - Scope of - HELD: High Court,
while granting anticipatory bail to accused, worded its order
in such a way that it could be, and wa~ interpreted by all
concerned to mean that accused was not required to even
appear and surrender before court during entire investigation
stage and trial - Such kind of order is not contemplated uls
438 - No blanket order could be passed uls 438 to prevent
the accused from being arrested at all in connection with the
case - Order of High Court modified to the extent that
accused shall surrender before trial court forth with and pray
for regular bail.
On a complaint made by the appellant-Bank that it
had been cheated of Rs.2,04,40,000/- by respondent no.
1 and others, an FIR was drawn up accused on 12.6.2006
against the persons named in the complaint, for offences
punishable u/ss. 419, 420, 468, 473 read with s.120-B IPC.
Respondent no. 1 applied for and was granted
anticipatory bail u/s 438 CrPC by the High Court by its
order dated 3.7.2006.
In the instant appeal filed by the Bank, it was
contended for the appellant that the High Court
misapplied the provisions of s.438 CrPC and could not
have granted a blanket order of anticipatory bail upto the
end of the trial. It was submitted that respondent no. 1
590
,.. .
A •.
)
'(
...
HDFC BANK LTD. v. J.J. MANNAN @ J.M. JOHN
PAUL & ANR.
- J
591
never appeared in court even once, at any stage of the
case, and did not even surrender and obtain regular bail.
A
Partly allowing the appeal, the Court
""
-· ,/..
'
\
'
HELD: 1.1. Section 438 Cr.P.C. contemplates arrest
at the stage of investigation and provides a mechanism
for an accused to be released on ba'i'I should he be
arrested during the period of investigation. Once the
investigation makes out a case against him and he is
included as an accused in the charge-sheet, the accused
has to surrender to the custody of the court and pray for
regular bail. On the strength of an order granting
anticipafdry bail, an accused against whom charge has
been framed, cannot avoid appearing before the trial
court. [Para 15] [598-A-C]
1.2. In the instant case, the role of respondent No.1
in the entire episode did not entitle him to the relief of
anticipatory bail, much less a blanket order of bail. The
High Court worded its order in such a way that it could
be interpreted to mean, as has been done by all
concerned, that respondent No.1 was not required to
even appear and surrender before the court during the
entire investigation stage and the trial. Taking advantage
of the same, respondent No.1 has successfully avoided
the court from the very initial stage of investigation and
even the trial. Such kind of an order is not contemplated
u/s 438 Cr.P.C. as has been repeatedly explained by this
Court. [Para 14] [596·G-H; 597-A-C]
Adri Dharan Das vs. State of West Bengal 2005 (2)
SCR 188
(2005) 4 SCC 303; and Salauddin Abdulsamad
Shaikh vs. State of Maharashtra 1995 ( 6 ) SMi>pl. SCR
556 (1996) 1 sec 667-- relied on.
=
y
B
c
D
E
F
G
=
Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia vs. State of Punjab 1980 (3)
H
592
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2009] 16 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
SCR 383 = (1980) 2 SCC 565; and Savitri Agarwal & Ors.
vs. State of Maharashtra & Anr. 2009 (10) SCR 978
JT
2009 (9) SC 460 = (2009) 8 SCC 325, referred to.
=
1.3. The order of the High Court dated 3rd July, 2006,
is modified to the extent that respondent No.1 shall
8
surrender before the trial court forthwith and pray for
regular bail. The trial court shall dispose of the application
on merits, in accordance with law, before proceeding
further with the trial. [Para 16) [598-D-E]
c
Case Law Reference:
2005 (2) SCR 188
D
;.
relied on
para 11
1995 (6) Suppl. SCR 556 relied on
para 11
1980 (3) SCR 383
referred to
para 12
2009 (10) SCR 978
referred to
para 13
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal
No. 2415 of 2009.
E
From the Judgment & Order dated 3.7.2006 of the High
Court of Judicature at Madras in Criminal Original Petition No.
15217 of 2006 and Crl. M.P. No. 3784 of 2006.
,l
Manik Karanjawala for the Appellant.
F
Rajiv Dutta, K.P. Narajanan, Anukul Raj, K.K. Mani, S.
Thananjayan for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
G
H
ALTAMAS KABIR, J. 1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal has been filed by the H.D.F.C. Bank Ltd.
(hereinafter referred to as "the Bank") against the judgment and
order dated 3rd July, 2006, passed by the Madras High Court
in Crl.M.P.No.3784 of 2006 and Crl.O.P.No.15217 of 2006,
.
HDFC BANK LTO. v. J.J. MANNAN @ J.M. JOHN
PAUL & ANR. [ALTAMAS KABIR, J.]
, I
.J
593
allowing the application filed by the Respondent No.1 under
Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.) for
grant of anticipatory bail to him.
3. According to the Bank, the Respondent No.1 in his
capacity as the Managing Director of the Mannan Construction
Corporation Private Limited, a company engaged in the
execution of Highway Contracts and contracts of the Public
Works Department (hereinafter referred to as "the Company"),
along with one Mis. Immanuel Projects Private Ltd., applied for
a loan of Rs.2,03,40,0001- (Rupees Two Crores, three lakhs
and forty thousand) only, for purchase of 6 Krishna Electronic
Sensor Paver Finishers from one Mis. Krishna Engineering
Works in Ahmedabad. The said loan was duly sanctioned and
after signing of necessary Agreements and other documents,
six cheques for the loan amount of Rs.2,03,40,0001-, drawn in
the name of Mis. Krishna Engineering Works, were handed over
to the Respondent No.1 on 9th March, 2006. Subsequently, by
a letter dated 24th May, 2006, the Bank informed Mis. Krishna
Engineering Works in Ahmedabad that a sum of
Rs.2,03,40,0001- had been disbursed to them on account of the
Respondent No.1 and requested them to confirm receipt of the
same. Mis. Krishna Engineering Works wrote back to the Bank
stating that it had not received any payment on account of Mr.
J.M. John Paul.
A
B
C
D
E
\
4. The Bank thereupon caused enquiries to be made and
came to learn that no machineries had, in fact, been purchased
by the Respondent No.1, and that the Respondent No.1 had
colluded with Mis. Immanuel Projects Private Limited and their
Directors and one Mr. R.I. Jambert Mathuram with the intention
of cheating the Bank and in the process had committed
offences punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and
120-B Indian Penal Code.
5. The Bank filed a complaint with the Commissioner of
Police, Egmore, Chennai-600008 on 27th May, 2006, setting
out the facts relating to sanction of the loan and the handing
F
G
H
594 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2009] 16 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
A
B
c
over of the six Banker's cheques in the name of M/s. Krishna
Engineering Works. The complaint also contained the manner
in which the Respondent No.1 had opened a fictitious account
with l.C.l.C.I. Bank, Tuticorin Branch, in the name of M/s.
Krishna Engineering Works and deposited the cheques meant
for supply of road construction equipment by Krishna
Engineering Works of Ahmedabad. Thereafter, the said
amount was encashed and transferred to M/s. Matrix
Enterprises having its office at No.41, C.G.E. Colony, 5th
Street, Tuticorin-628 003, which was holding an account in the
Tuticorin Branch of l.C.l.C.1. Bank. The said amounts were again
transferred to the account of M/s. Delta Enterprises, also having
its office at No.41, C.G.E. Colony, 5th Street, Tuticorin, with the
Tuticorin Branch of the LC.LC.I. Bank.
.
\
>
6. After the aforesaid transactions, the moneys were finally
D credited to the account of the Respondent No.1 in the same
.
\
Branch of the l.C.l.C.I. Bank. It was also found on enquiry that
the addresses of all the above-mentioned companies were that
of the residence of the Respondent No.1, Mr. J.M. John Paul.
E
F
G
H
7. F.l.R. No.157 of 2006 dated 12th June, 2006, was
drawn up on the basis of the aforesaid complaint against the
Respondent No.1 and others by the Central Crime Branch,
Chennai, under Sections 419, 420, 468, 473 read with Section
120B Indian Penal Code.
8. The Respondent No.1 thereupon filed an application in
the Madras High Court under Section 438 Cr.P.C. for grant of
Anticipatory Bail and the learned Single Judge of the said High
Court, by his order dated 3rd July, 2006, allowed the same upon
holding that since the investigating agency had already seized
all relevant and vital documents and had recorded the
statements of all the important witnesses, the custodial
interrogation of the Respondent No.1 was not required.
9. The present appeal has been filed by the Bank for
cancellation of the Anticipatory Bail granted to the Respondent
(
-r
, I
HDFC BANK LTD. v. J.J. MANNAN @ J.M. JOHN
PAUL & ANR. [ALTAMAS KABIR, J.]
595
No.1.
.
-~
\
mir
y
10. On behalf of the Union of India it was contended that
in the facts of the case, the High Court had erred in allowing
the Respondent No.1's application under Section 438 Cr.P.C.
since he had allegedly master-minded the fraud and having
regard to the gravity of the offence alleged, the Anticipatory Bail
granted to him was liable to be cancelled. Mr. Lalit submitted
that the Respondent No.1 had misappropriated what was meant
to be paid to the supplier of the road construction equipment,
in a planned manner and the whereabouts of the moneys was
yet to be ascertained.
11. Mr. Lalit submitted that the provisions of Section 438
Cr.P.C. had been misapplied by the High Court in this case,
since there was sufficient material on record to prima facie
indicate that the Respondent was a direct player in the
fraudulent episode, and, in any event, the High Court could not
have granted a blanket order of Anticipatory-Bail upto the end
of the trial. Mr. Lal it submitted that in view o{ the impugned order,
the Respondent No.1 had never appeared 1n Court even once,
at any stage of the case, and had not even surrendered and
obtained regular bail. Mr. Lalit referred to the decision of this
Court in Adri Dharan Das vs. State of West Bengal [(2005) 4
sec 303], wherein it was categorically indicated that
Anticipatory Bail had to be given for a limited duration so as
to enable the accused to move for regular bail under Section
437 Cr.P.C. Reference was also made to the decision of this
Court in Sa/auddin Abdulsamad Shaikh vs. State of
Maharashtra [(1996) 1 sec 667] where the same essentials
have been reiterated.
12. Appearing for the Respondent No.1, Mr. Rajiv Dutta,
learned Senior Advocate, submitted that except for wild
allegations made against the Respondent No.1, nothing
incriminating had been found against him. Mr. Dutta urged that
the Respondent No.1 had been granted Anticip<1lory Bail as far
back as on 3rd July, 2006, and he had never misused the
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
596
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2009] 16 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
-
\
A
B
c
privilege and had co-operated with the investigating agencies
all through. Furthermore, the trial had already commenced and
several witnesses had been examined and there could,
therefore, be no justification for cancelling the Anticipatory Bail
granted to him by the High Court more than three years ago.
Referring to the decision of the Constitution Bench in the case
of Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia vs. State of Punjab ((1980) 2 SCC
565), wherein the application of Section 438 Cr.P.C. had been
considered in detail, Mr. Dutta submitted that the said provision
had been interpreted to be a beneficent provision relating to
personal liberty guaranteed
under Section 21 of the
\
Constitution. Mr. Dutta submitted that the Constitution Bench had
observed that since denial of bail amounts to deprivation of
personal liberty, the court should lean against the imposition of
unnecessary restrictions on the scope of Section 438 Cr.P.C.
D
13. Reference was also made to the decision of this Court
in the case of Savitri Agarwal & Ors. vs. State of Maharashtra
& Anr. [JT 2009 (9) SC 460 (2009) 8 SCC 325), where the
various decisions in this regard, with special emphasis on
Sibbia's case (supra) as also Adri Dharan Das's case (supra),
E were referred to. Their Lordships took note of the fact that the
provisions of Section 438, as amended, had not yet been
notified and that as a result the old provision continued to be in
force. Hence, the earlier decisions would continue to be relevant
to the facts of this case. Mr. Dutta submitted that having regard
F to the views expressed by this Court in no uncertain terms,
prayer for Anticipatory Bail should not be refused and, in any
event, in this case Anticipatory Bail had already been granted
more than three years ago and hence the submissions now
being made as to when Anticipatory Bail should be granted
G have become irrelevant.
>
.
~
=
14. Having carefully considered the submissions made on
behalf of the respective parties and the decisions referred to
in support of their respective cases, we are of the view that the
role of the Respondent No.1 in the entire episode did not entitle
H
I
'f
..
• t
. ~'
-- Ji
HDFC BANK LTD. v. J.J. MANNAN@ J.M. JOHN
PAUL & ANR. [ALTAMAS KABIR, J.]
597
him to the relief of Anticipatory Bail, much less a blanket order
of bail. However, t_hat is now a closed chapter. But what is of
relevance is whether the High Court should have worded its
order in such a way that it could be interpreted to mean, as has
been done by all concerned, that the Respondent No.1 was not
required to even appear and surrender before the Court during
the entire investigation stage and the trial. Taking advantage
of the same, the Respondent No.1 has successfully avoided
the Court from the very initial stage of investigation and even
the trial. Such kind of an order is not contemplated under
Section 438 Cr.P.C. as has been repeatedly explained by this
Court. The said position has been clearly enunciated in Adri
Dharan Das's case (supra). Furthermore, it has also been
consistently indicated that no blanket order could be passed
under Section 438 Cr.P.C. to prevent the accused from being
arrested at all in connection with the case. To avoid such an
eventuality it was observed in Adri Dharan Das's case (supra)
that Anticipatory Bail is given for a limited duration to enable
the accused to surrender and to obtain regular bail. The same
view was reiterated in Salauddin's case (supra) wherein it was,
inter alia, observed that Anticipatory Bail should be of limited
duration only and primarily on the expiry of that duration or
extended duration, the Court granting Anticipatory Bail should
leave it to the regular court to deal with the matter on an
appreciation of evidence placed before it after the investigation
has made progress or the charge-sheet is submitted.
A
B
c
D
E
F
>
l
15. The object of Section 438 Cr.P.C. has been
repeatedly explained by this Court and the High Courts to mean
that a person should not be harassed or humiliated in order to
satisfy the grudge or personal vendetta of the complainant. But
at the same time the provisions of Section 438 Cr.P.C. cannot
also be invoked to exempt the accused from surrendering to
the Court after the investigation is complete and if charge-sheet
is filed against him. Such an interpretation would amount to
violence to the provisions of Section 438 Cr.P .C., since even
though a charge-sheet may be filed against an accused and
G
H
598
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2009) 16 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
A
charge is framed against him, he may still not appear before
the Court at all even during the trial. Section 438 Cr.P.C.
contemplates arrest at the stage of investigation and provides
a mechanism for an accused to be released on bail should he
be arrested during the period of investigation. Once the
B investigation makes out a case against him and he is included
as an accused in the charge-sheet, the accused has to
surrender to the custody of the Court and pray for regular bail.
On the strength of an order granting Anticipatory Bail, an
accused against whom charge has been framed, cannot avoid
C appearing before the trial court. If what has been submitted on
behalf of the appellant that the Respondent No.1 has never
appeared before the trial court is to be accepted, it will lead to
the absurd situation that charge was framed against the
accused in his absence, which would defeat the very purpose
of Sub-Section (2) of Section 240 Cr.P.C.
0
16. Having regard to the above, the order of the High Court
dated 3rd July, 2006, is modified to the extent that the
Respondent No.1 shall surrender before the Trial Court forthwith
and pray for regular bail and the Trial Court shall dispose of
E the same on merits, in accordance with law, before proceeding
further with the trial.
17. The appeal is allowed to the above extent.
F
R.P.
Appeal Partly allowed.
f-
" •.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org