RAVINDRA & ASSOCIATES versus UNION OF INDIA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 21 October 2009 | [2009] 15 S.C.R. 335 | 2009 INSC 1193
Key facts
- Decided
- 21 October 2009
- Bench
- MARKANDEY KATJU, A.K. GANGULY
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2726/2004
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [2009] 15 S.C.R. 335
- Neutral citation
- 2009 INSC 1193
Text of the judgment
[2009) 15 (ADDL.) S.C.R. 335
_,
I
...
)
"
RAVINDRA & ASSOCIATES
v.
UNION OF INDIA
(Civil Appeal No. 2726 of 2004)
OCTOBER 21, 2009
A
B
[MARKANDEY KATJU AND ASOK KUMAR
GANGULY, JJ.]
->
Arbitration:
c
Award by arbitrator- Interference with, by court - Scope
of - Construction contract - Completed by contractor within
stipulated time - As regards payments, dispute arose between
parties and contractor filing a claim before arbitrator Arbitrator awarding a certain amount to contractor with simple D
interest @ 18% for pre-reference period, pendent elite and
from date of award till date of decree/payment - Award made
rule of the court by Principal Sub-Judge - Interest on amount
awarded reduced to 12% - High Court allowing appeal of
employer - HELD: High Court has wrongly interfered with the
E
findings of fact recorded by arbitrator - Arbitrator made the
award after considering respective claims of parties Judgement of High Court set aside - Contractor would be
entitled to interest@ 12% as awarded by Principal SubJudge.
I
-~
• +
F
"'
_,t
State of Rajasthan vs. Puri Construction Co; J.:td. (1994)
6 SCC 485; Trustees of Port of Madras vs. Engineering
Construction Corporation Ltd. (1995) 5 SCC 531; EOG India
Ltd. vs. Bhagwati Oxygen Ltd. (2007) 9 SCC 503 and G. Ram
Chandra Reddy & Company vs. Union of India & Anr. (2009) G
6 sec 414, relied on.
Ramnath International Construction (P) Ltd. vs. Union of
India (2007) 2 SCC 453, distinguished.
335
H
336
SUPREME"COURT REPORTS [2009r1s. (ADDL.) S.C.R.
-: ~ Case Law Reference:
A
B
(1994) s sec 48~
relied on
(1995) 5 sec 531 ·: ·
relied on·
Para 5
(2007) 9 SCC 503 . · - relied orL
Para 5
Para 5
.''
(2009).'6 1SCC·:414 Ct'·/ relied~on·~:-.: .."1.. ::.1"Para 5
i~ t
:· .. _;f)i. 'ft D
(2007) 2 SCC 453
distinguished
Para 7
C
I
i
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.
2726. of 2004.
;<1(/""'G
't~ ~. '.~;·
-- _ <__,,_,,.,,·,'U
....,,.~.••\"~L
,
....
.~~. tj.
_...,.J._ -_ .. _
'.:"'"
,·:'~'From the uudgmerit &10rder dated-15:1.2003· of the High
Court·of Kerala~at~Ernakulam iffMisc,\Firsf.Appea1 No. 53.:of
I
~' - - ' .., . . •
h.,.
-~
1998 "·(8.')·.·, - ....~~-..·''.·-','.' f'.'·
D :..· ;~<-.:· .;
"'Y~~ :..'"~r ::. J---~
:~:.; I''"":.~ . ~. :._, 1 ·v~'J ..,;:f::.i
.... ~-,..:
· ...:. Sudhir 9ha.ridr~ •.:_Mu~esh Jai_n,J~tpal Saha ~nd ~sha Jain
MadanJor the ~ppell~nt;_;, "'':<., . ~~.... •\' .. r- ,'. • -~. :
v
,
~·. )~":"':...;
i~ .'.j"\ .,...i.+,..,
f,.-
-
'i'••
! •
. '·
._ ·-
; .
• '
"'
~ -~
.
r:
'
'"'> '•· -'.""'"-.-·
...
~-
-.. -~ .... - • ,,
~
. . ·.Mohan' Jain: AS~~~Dihesh Tha~tir, Indra ·sawhney; Rohini
Muktferjee,vSubasll
Kaushik,' Rekha F>anciey:~n'Ci ·s-Jshrria ·suri
""' l 't'i
'
.
E to~ t~~.R,es~o~~e.~!:' · 1: :; ,_ .-· • • ~, ··, ~:. ·~ ·:~'.} •• ;
, .. · ,
·~
'!' .. -
"._.,
.,
,
~"
.
'
,, ...
•
'·
'~
"';.,.._
• • • . - •.
r.~fhecfollowifl'gl:Order' 'Of the Court was ·delivered;
r~
~r·.:
'\',,..._;.>··
.~~--
-
'...:~. . .
,. _ ...·,\
,~,~~
_~_~'--
~ .·\;\'"•:::-:""'·';;,.,.
1...
}"''
F
1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
··~~~;1·r-~
c_:~
. . . _.J •. 1.>1~\~· ....... :.:. ... ~ .·~
..
'·~, .~~\; h~~-
:~
'":. .• ~ -~
, .2 .. :Th1s appeal by special
leave
has. ".:;:t-:been'filed, against
ther-1
v
•
. -. .
J , r
judgment. and; order, dated J 1.5.1.2003 .of the
.Higli.
Court
of
,J , __ .
• · ...,.
Kerala at Ernakulam~whereby
the
High
.Court ~~has
allowed
the
~·~~
~_,
f
.... ...
~~\<'
·\l~~., -('..
G ~RP..~~I ~i.l~d !>Y~!~~ re~P.qf'!d~nt he!e}p~ ~~~!.n~t ~~,~.,?rd~r,.~dC!_t~d.
9.10.1996 of the Principal Sub Judge, ~ochL:.o,-. .·•i·· .Y t. cl
;
• '
.,..
•
•
•
•
•
;. '
-
,j.
.......
~...
':'""".
-..~'
·
...._;j"
1
_,
+
#·Y
- •
~4
~_,..-..-
-·
·•
••
.,/!'
\.•
.:..
•
•
¥.
\ """"'""
\,
1
!
, • • .... ,..
< •::':'
0.\
· " ' · ....
\..,
'
~
~
•-
~
•
~
.I
••.
~
l
I
,
•
,,,.
!
'
, . r·c,3.iLf appe~.~ that.t~~"~ppe~tant.YJ.a~ fl~a~d-~d a,con~r,act for
construction of married accommodation for., petty:
officers
of the
.A·::J.,. l
...
Navy at Rameswaram, Koclii. The value of the worl< awarded
1.1- •..,•., __.,~jl~lt,'°'·~~--
H
l..,-i::.._~
~'.,V
b
....L
RAVINDRA & ASSOCIATES v. UNION OF INDIA
was Rs. 5,44,47,087/-. The work which commenced on
24.12.1990 had to be completed by 23.6.1993 and admittedly
it was completed by the said date.
f
-;
...
~~
..
337
4. Disputes arose between J:he parties and the parties
invoked the arbitration clause provided in the General
Conditions of Contract. The claimant-appellant made claims
under 25 heads. The arbitrator awarded to the claimant a sum
·-of Rs. 70,94,265/- and allowed simple interest at the rate of
18% from the date of accrual for cause of action till date of
reference, from the date of reference till date of award and from
the date of award till the date of decree or date of payment
whichever is earlier. An application by the appellant-claimant
was filed before the Principal Sub Judge, Kochi to make the
award a Rule of the Court. The respondent-Union of India also
filed an application for setting aside the award of the arbitrator.
The Sub-Judge allowed the application of the appellant and
made it a Rule of the Court, but awarded 12% interest on the
amount awarded from the date of decree till realization and
dismissed the application of the respondent-Union of India.
Aggrieved against the order dated 9.10.1996 of the Sub-Judge,
Kochi the respondent herein preferred an appeal before the
High Court which has been allowed by the impugned judgment
and order. Hence, the present appeal.
B
c
D
E
~
--+
5. In our opinion, the High Court wrongly interfered with the
arbitration award and practically acted as a Court of Appeal,
which it could not do (See : State of Rajasthan vs. Puri
Construction Co. Ltd. (1994) 6 SCC 485; Trustees of Port of
Madras vs. Engineering Construction Corporation Ltd. (1995)
5 SCC 531; EOG India Ltd. vs. Bhagwati Oxygen Ltd. (2007)
9 SCC 503 and G. Ram Chandra Reddy & Company vs.
Union of India & Anr. (2009) 6 SCC 414).
6. As regards the allegation that while in the contract
mixture provided for in the contract is M/15, but in fact, M/20
was used, it has been held by the arbitrator that this was done
at the insistence of the Department. The arbitrator also held that
~
A
F
G
H
33~
A
8
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2009] 15 (ADDL.) S.C.R.
the relevant drawing for M/15 mixture and the drawing relied
upon by the respondent did not find place in the list of drawings
forming part of the tender documents. Hence, in our opinion,
the High Court has wrongly interfered with the findings of the
arbitrator as regards claim Nos. 1 and 9.
7. As regards claim No. 10(b) relating to payment of overtime to labour it has been contended by the learned counsel
for the appellant that there was a delay in supply of stores by
the respondent and therefore the labour had to be retained for
a longer period of time than envisaged under the contract and
hence overtime charges had to be paid to the labour.
8. In this connection, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent has· relied upon the decision of this Court in the
case of Ramnath International Construction (P) Ltd. vs. Union
D of India (2007) 2 SCC 453. We have gone through the said
decision. In our opinion that decision has no application to the
case at hand as in that case the contractor sought and obtained
extensio'n of time for execution of the contract whereas in the
present case neither extension of time was sought for, nor in
fact,
granted for completion of the contract. Hence, the
E
aforesaid decision is clearly distinguishable. Clause 11 (c) of
the General Conditions of Contract has no application in this
case at all.
9. As regards Claim No. 12 relating to difference in price
of wood frames for doors and windows, it is stated that no doubt
the contract provided for teak wood but it was changed to
second class hard-wood at the insistence of the Department.
The High Court has in this regard relied upon the decision of
the Board of Officers who has made its assessment by relying
G upon Clause 62(G) of the General Conditions of Contract which
provided that the decision of the Garrison Engineer would be
final unless it was set aside in appeal. In the present case, the
price was not fixed by the Garrison Engineer at all. Moreover,
the Board of Officers had made an inquiry in the matter after
H three vears and the arbitrator, in our opinion, rightly held that
F
),•
~-~
t
..
RAVINDRA & ASSOCIATES v. UNION OF INDIA
339
=$
;
such an inquiry was of no consequence.
A
10. As regards Claims No. 20 and 23 relating to escalation
in prices of material, in our opinion, the arbitrator has given his
findings of fact and the High Courtmisread Clause 18 of the
Special Conditions of Contract.
.
....
-;
..
-¥
11. For the reasons given above, we are of the opinion
that the High Court has wrongly interfered with the arbitration
award. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed and the impugned
judgment and order is set aside.
12. We may also point out that in para 12 of the judgment
there appears to be a typographical error inasmuch as the
Principal Sub-Judge Kochi has reduced the interest from 18%
to 12% and not 10%, as wrongly recorded in the impugned
judgment. We make it clear that the appellant is entitled to
interest @ 12%, as awarded by the Principal Sub Judge, Kochi.
,_ ·.
Appeal allowed. No order as to the costs.
R.P.
.. ..,
Appeal allowed .
8
c
D
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org