SUBHASH CHANDRA SINGH versus DHEEMANT SINGH & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 20 April 2009 | [2009] 6 S.C.R. 724 | 2009 INSC 562
Key facts
- Decided
- 20 April 2009
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, A.K. GANGULY
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 787/2009
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [2009] 6 S.C.R. 724
- Neutral citation
- 2009 INSC 562
Text of the judgment
[2009) 6 S.C.R. 724
#
t-
A
SUBHASH CHANDRA SINGH
v.
DHEEMANT SINGH & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal No. 787 of 2009)
B
APRIL 20, 2009
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND ASOK KUMAR
GANGULY, JJ.]
Bail - Requirement of recording reasons while directing
grant of bail - Unnatural death of wife within 7 years of
marriage - Criminal proceedings against husband - He
sought bail - High Court granted bail by a non-reasoned
order - Challenge to - Held: There is a need to indicate in
the order, reasons for prima facie concluding why bail was
being
granted particularly where the accused was charged of
D
having committed a serious offence - Any order de hors
such reasons suffers from non-application of mind - Matter
remitted to High Court for fresh consideration and disposal
by a reasoned order - Penal Code, 1860 - s.3048 E Evidence Act, 1872 - s.1138.
c
Respondent no.1 's wife died within 7 years of
marriage. The death was unnatural. Criminal proceedings
were initiated against respondent no.1 whereupon he
sought bail from the High Court. The High Court
F observed that the provisions of s.1138 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 was not applicable and that it was not
a case punishable under s.3048 IPC and granted bail to
respondent no.1 by a practically non-reasoned order.
Hence the present appeal.
G
Allowing the appeal, the Court
HELD: 1.1. Even a cursory perusal of the High
Court's order shows complete non-application of mind.
H
724
.
'
..
~
I._
~
SUBHASH CHANDRA SINGH v. DHEEMANT
SINGH &ANR.
1
~·
.
~
..
~
.....
,.
725
Though detailed examination of the evidence and
elaborate documentation of the merits of the case is to
be avoided by the Court while passing orders on bail
applications, yet a court dealing with the bail application
should be satisfied as to whether there is a prima facie
case, but exhaustive exploration of the merits of the case
is not necessary. The court dealing with the application
for bail is required to exercise its discretion in a judicious
manner and not as a matter of course. [Para 4] [727-8-D]
1.2. There is a need to indicate in the order, reasons
for prima facie concluding why bail was being granted
particularly where an accused was charged of having
COIT!mitted a serious offence. It is necessary for the c9urts
dealing with application for bail to consider among other
circumstances, the following factors also before granting
bail, they are: I) the nature of accusation and the severity
of punishment in case of conviction and the nature of
supporting evidence; ii) reasonable apprehension of
tampering of the witness or apprehension of threat to the
complainant; iii) prima facie satisfaction of the Court in
support of the charge. Any order dehors such reasons
suffers from non-application of mind. [Paras 5 and 6]
[727-D-H; 728-A]
Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh and Ors.
(2002)3 SCC 598; Puran etc. v. Rambilas and Anr. etc.
(2001) 6 SCC 338; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan
alias Pappu Yadav & Anr. JT 2004 (3) SC 442 and Anwari
Begum v. Sher Mohd. 2005 (7) SCC 326, relied on.
2. The High Court's order is a bundle of confusion.
On one hand it noted that there was no dispute that the
death had taken place within seven years of the marriage
and that it was unnatural death. Having said so, it is not
understood as to how the High Court observed that the
provisions of s.1138 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 are
not applicable and this is not a case punishable under
A
8
c
D
E
F
G
H
726
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2009] 6 S.C.R.
s.304~ IPC. Th.at being so the impugned order of the High
court is set aside and the matter is remitted to it for fresh
consideration and disposal by a reasoned order. [Para 8]
[728-B-E]
8
c
Case Law Reference :
(2002) 3 sec 598
relied on
· Para 6
(2001) s sec 338
relied on
Para 6
JT 2004 (3) SC 442
relied on
Para 6
2005 (7) sec 326
relied on
Para 7
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal
No. 787 of 2009.
·
D
E
From the Judgment & Order dated 30.10.2007 of the High
Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Crl. Misc. Bail Application
No. 15520 of 2007.
....
Swaraj Kaushal, Dr. Monika Gusain and Hariom
Yaduvanshi for the Appellant.
U.U. Lalit, Reetesh Singh, Jhanvi Wona and Surya Kant
for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
F
...
DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Leave granted.
2. Challenge in this appeal is to the the order passed by
a learned Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court granting
bail to the respondent No.1. The appeal is by the father of the
G Shobhna (hereinafter referred to as the 'deceased') who was
married to the respondent No.1. It is stated that the death took
place within seven years of the marriage and it was unnatural
death. The High Court by a practically non-reasoned order
granted bail. It is pointed out by learned counsel for the
H appellant that no reason has been indicated for directing grant
1'. ,..
..-
SUBHASH CHANDRA SINGH v. DHEEMANT
SINGH & ANR. [DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
727
of bail and even the conclusions are contradictory in terms.
3. Learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 on the other
hand submitted that the bail was granted on 3oth October, 2007.
There is no allegation that the accused respondent No. 1 has
misused the liberty after release on bail. The charge sheet has
already been submitted and the investigation is over. The
accused was in custody for more than five months .
.>-
~
~
5. There is a need to indicate in the order, reasons for
prima facie concluding why bail was being granted particularly
where an accused was charged of having committed a serious
offence. It is necessary for the courts dealing with application
for bail to consider among other circumstances, the following
factors also before granting bail, they are:
1. The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment
in case of conviction and the nature of supporting
evidence;
L
B
4: Even a cursory perusal the High Court's order shows
complete non-application of mind. Though detailed examination
of the evidence and elaborate documentation of the merits of
the case is to be avoided by the Court while passing orders
on bail applications, yet a court dealing with the bail application
should be satisfied as to whether there is a prima facie case,
but exhaustive exploration of the merits of the case is not
necessary. The court dealing with the application for bail is
required to exercise its discretion in a judicious manner and
not as a matter of course.
.
A
2. Reasonable apprehension of tampering of the witness
or apprehension of threat to the complainant;
c
D
E
F
G
3. Prima facie satisfaction of the Court in support of the
charge.
6.Any order dehors such reasons suffers from nonH
728
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[20091 6 S.C.R.
A application of mind as was noted by this Court, in Ram Govind
Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh and Ors. [(2002) 3 SCC 598],
Puran etc. v. Rambilas and Anr. etc. [(2001) 6 SCC 338)] and
in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan alias Pappu
Yadav & Anr. [JT 2004 (3) SC 442].
B
7. The above position was highlighted by this Court in
Anwari Begum v. Sher Mohd. (2005(7) SCC 326).
8. As rightly submitted by the learned counsel for the
appellant, the High Court's order is a bundle of confusion. On
C one hand it is noted that there was no dispute that the death
had taken place within seven years of the marriage and that it
was unnatural death. Having said so, it is not understood as to
how the High Court observed that the provisions of Section
113(B) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (in short the 'Evidence
D Act') are not applicable and this is not a case punishable under
Section 304 B IPC. That being so we set aside the impugned
order of the High Court and remit the matter to it for fresh
consideration and disposal by a reasoned order.
E
9. The Appeal is allowed.
BBB.
Appeal allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org