STATE OF ORISSA AND ORS. versus BALRAM SAHU
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 January 2009 | [2009] 1 S.C.R. 655 | 2009 INSC 77
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 January 2009
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, A.K. GANGULY
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 444/2009
- Disposal
- Disposed off
- Citation
- [2009] 1 S.C.R. 655
- Neutral citation
- 2009 INSC 77
Text of the judgment
[2009] 1 S.C.R. 655
STATE OF ORISSA AND ORS.
A
V.
BALRAM SAHU
(Civil Appeal No. 444 of 2009)
JANUARY 27, 2009
..
.A
B
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND ASOK KUMAR
GANGULY, JJ.)
(OR/SSA) P. W.D. CONTRACTORS REGJSTRA T/ON
RULES, 1967:
c
r. 11 (a) - Cancellation of contractor's licence - Set aside
by High Court for non-issuance of notice to contractor HELD: High Court in its earlier order had specifically directed
that before cancellation and forfeiture of security deposit,
notice was to be given - It would be open to State Government
to issue a notice in terms of order passed by High Court and
decide the matter after affording an opportunity of hearing to
the contractor - Natural Justice.
D
In a writ petition filed by the respondent, the High
Court, on 13.5.2004, directed that without issuing a show
cause notice to him and without giving him an
opportunity of hearing, his licence as Super Class
Contractor would not be cancelled. By order dated
7.10.2005 respondent's licence was cancelled under Rule
11 (a) of P.W.D. Contractors Registration Rules, 1967. The
respondent challenged the said order in another writ
petition wherein the stand of the appellant- State was that
a show cause notice had been issued to the respondents
on 21.2.2004. The High Court by its order dated 9.2.2007
allowed the writ petition holding that after the order dated
13.5.2004 no notice was issued. Aggrieved, the State
Government filed the appeals.
655
E
F
G
H
656
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2009) 1 S.C.R.
Disposing of the appeals, the Court
HELD: The order dated 13.5.2004 passed by the High
Court was very specific to the effect that before
cancellation and forfeiture of security deposit, notice has
to be given. That admittedly has not been done. In the
8
circumstances, the order of the High Court impugned in
the instant appeals shall remain operative. It is open to
the appellant-State to issue notice in terms of the order
passed by the High Court and to decide the matter in
accordance with law after affording an opportunity to the
C respondent. [Para 5) [658-D-F]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 444
of 2009.
0
From the Judgment and final Order dated 9.02.2007 of the
High Court of Orissa at Cuttak in W.P. (C) No. 13432 of 2005.
WITH
C.A.No 445 of 2009.
E
Siboo Sankar Mishra for the Appellant.
Akhilendra K. Mahapatra and Pankaj Kumar Singh for the
Respondent.
F
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Leave granted in both the
Special Leave Petitions.
2. The controversy in the two appeals lies within a very
G narrow compass. Writ Petition No.3445 of 2004 was filed by
the respondent before the Orissa High Court, inter-alia, with a
prayer that his license as a Super Class Contractor should not
be cancelled by the respondent No.2 i.e. Chairman of the
Committee of Chief Engineers and Engineers in Chief, Orissa.
H The Writ Petition was filed under the apprehension that his
"'
STATE OF ORISSA AND ORS. v. BALRAM SAHU
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
657
license was likely to be cancelled. The High Court disposed
of the Writ Petition by order dated 13.5.2004 after hearing
learned counsel for the writ petitioner and learned Government
Advocate with a direction that without issuing show cause notice
to the writ petitioner and without giving him a fair opportunity
of hearing, his license as Super Class Contractor shall not be
cancelled and his security deposit shall not be forfeited.
3. Several miscellaneous cases were thereafter filed by
the respondents. By order dated 7 .10.2005 the Chairman of
the aforesaid Committee directed cancellation of respondent's
license under Rule 11 (a) of P.W.D. Contractors Registration
Rules, 1967 (in short the ·Rules'). This was questioned by the
respondent by filing a writ petition taking the stand that the order
was passed by the Chief Engineer, but no notice was issued
prior to passing of the order. The High Court by order dated
9.2.2007 allowed the Writ Petition, quashing several orders
passed on the ground that before the cancellation was done,
no notice was given. Reference was made by the present
appellants to notice purportedly issued on 21.2.2004. It was
stated that before the order was passed by the High Court in
Writ Petition No.3445/2004, a show cause notice had already
been issued. The respondent filed a rejoinder affidavit taking
the stand that after the order was passed on 13.5.2004 in the
earlier writ petition, no notice was issued. The High Court
noticed that before cancellation of the license no notice had
been issued and the previous writ petition was disposed of with
a specific direction that without notice and grant of fair
opportunity of hearjng license shall not be cancelled and the
security shall not be forfeited. Undisputedly, after the date of
the High Court's order, no notice was issued. Thereafter, several
miscellaneous cases were filed for extension of time. An
application was also filed for modification of order passed on
9.2.2007 by the High Court. But the High Court by order dated
25.6.2008 rejected the same and further directed the present
appellants to implement the order dated 9.2.2007.
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
658
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2009] 1 S C.R.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant-state and its
functionaries submitted the earlier writ petition was disposed
of without issuance of notice and the High Court should have
taken note of the fact that prior to the date of order, notice had
been issued.
B
5. Learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand
submitted that the High Court specifically directed that before
cancellation and forfeiture notice has to be given. Even though
notice was not formerly issued in the earlier petition, learned
Government Advocate appeared for the State and its
C functionaries. He did not bring to the notice of the High Court
that any show cause notice was issued on 21.2.2004. The
matter was disposed of on 13.5.2004 i.e. after about three
months. It was pointed out that the cancellation order was
passed on 7.10.2005. Before that also there was no prayer
D made to modify the earlier order. It was never the stand of the
State and its functionaries about the issuance of notice on
21.2.2004. We find that the stand taken by the respondent is
factually correct. The order dated 13.5.2004 was very specific
to the effect that before cancellation and forfeiture of security
E deposit, notice has to be given. That admittedly has not been
done. In the circumstances we dispose of both the appeals with
a direction that the impugned order of the High Court shall
remain operative. It is open to the appellant-State and its
functionaries to issue notice in terms of the order passed by
F the High Court in Writ Petition No.3445/2004 and after grant
of opportunity, decide the matter in accordance with law. The
appeals are accordingly disposed of.
R.P.
Appeals disposed of.
..
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org