BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL versus STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 28 November 2008 | [2008] 16 S.C.R. 769 | 2008 INSC 1363
Key facts
- Decided
- 28 November 2008
- Bench
- D.K. JAIN*, V.S. SIRPURKAR
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1264/2005
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2008] 16 S.C.R. 769
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 1363
Text of the judgment
[2008] 16 S.C.R. 769
.. -t
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL
A
v.
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
(Criminal Appeal No. 1264 of 2005)
NOVEMBER 28, 2008
B
[D.K. JAIN AND V.S. SIRPURKAR, JJ.)
I
'"
t
.{
'~
I
"'"'
Penal Code, 1860:
s.302 r.w. s.34- Conviction under, by trial Court- High
Court ignoring minor contradictions in testimony of witnesses
and affirming conviction - Justification of- Held: Courts below
justified in not rejecting evidence of witness merely on account
of some contradictions - The contradictions were not directly
related to the incident - Omissions of not mentioning exact
portion of the body of deceased where shot was fired not
significant as there was no omission as regards the fire by
accused on the deceased - Evidence of two eye witnesses
corroborated by medical evidence - Conduct of witness in
going to the house of his uncle instead of reporting incident
to police not unnatural, and would not impair creditworthiness
of his evidence.
c
D
E
Evidence:
...
--(
_...
-'
Discrepancies/contradictions in the testimony of witness
- Effect on prosecution case - Held: Not fatal unless
contradictions are material - Only when discrepancies in
evidence are materially incompatible with the credibility of
witness, same should be discarded.
Conduct of witness - Post event conduct - Held: Varies
from person to person - Different persons would react
differently on seeing any serious crime.
F
G
According to prosecution, father of accused 2 was
769
H
770
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 16 $.C.R.
A leader of one party and the deceased was leader of
another party. Accused 1 and 3 were cousins of accused
2 and the accused 4 was known to them. There was
grudge between the two rival partie~. On the fateful day,
10, the Sarpanch ofvillage, PW·deceased alongwith
26
and
PW-11,
the
driver
of the jeep was travelling in a
B
jeep. On the way deceased stopped the jeep. He got
down and started talking to wife of PW-26. Another jeep
came there. All the four accused got down from the jeep.
Accused 1 was armed with a pistol. Accused 2 was
c holding dagger. Accused 3 grabbed the deceased from
behind and accused 2 gave a da,gger blow on his
stomach. When the deceased fell down accused 1 fired
a bullet shofat hi's chest. Ori seeing the assault, PW-10
ran away out of fear. PW-11, the driver of the jeep also fled
from the scene and went to the house of his uncle and
D
narrated the entire incident to him. The police officer
received a phone call from an unknown· person about the
murder of deceased.
+ ..
pw.
t
'f
>
,
... )
)If
The Trial Court convicted all the four accused under
E s.302 IPC read with s.34. The conviction of accused 1appellant and accused 2 was confirmed by the High
Court. Hence the instant appeal.
Dismissing .the appeal, the Court
F
HELD: 1.1. Some discrepancies in the ocular account
of.a witraess, unless those are vital, cannot per se affect
.the credibility of the evidence of the witness. Unless the
contradictions are material, the same cannot be used to
jettison the evidence in its entirety.Tri'lial discrepancies
G ought not to obliterate an otherwise. acceptable evidence.
Merely because there is inconsistency in evidence, it is
not sufficient to impair the credibility of the witness. U is
only when discrepancies in the evidence of a witness are
so incompatible with the credibility of his version that the
H
,
)...
.._
I
~.
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL v. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA
court would be justified in discarding his evidence. [Para
12] [777 -B-D]
.. t
...
t
·'
"f
,,.
...
~
-
771
A
1.2. Both the courts below found that the evidence
of eye-witnesses, PW-10 and PW-11 was creditworthy
and held that the minor contradictions in their testimony B
were not sufficient to affect the credibility of their
evidence. In the light of the evidence of P.W-10 and PW11, High Court was right in holding that the contradictions
were not directly relating to the incident and could not be
said to be material contradictions affecting the credibility
c
of the evidence of both the eye witnesses. Similarly, the
so-called omission of not mentioning the exact portion
of the body of the deceased where the shot was fired
cannot be said to be a significant omission because there
was no omission as regards the firing by the appellant
on the deceased. In his testimony, PW-10 gave graphic D
details of the occurrence. Similarly, PW-11, the driver of
the jeep, in his evidence, narrated the incident which
corroborated with the version of PW-10. The evidence of
these two witnesses stood corroborated by the medical
evidence, which clearly showed that several blows were E
given to the deceased by jamiya (dagger) and a fire arm
injury was also found over the abdomen of the deceased.
The conduct of PW-11 in going to the house of his uncle
instead of reporting the incident to the police was not
unnatural, impairing the creditworthiness of his evidence. F
The post-event conduct of a witness varies from person
to person. It cannot be a cast iron reaction to be followed
as a model by every one witnessing such event. Different
persons would react differently on seeing any serious
crime and their behaviour and conduct would, therefore, G
be different. Therefore, having witnessed a dastardly
murder, it was not unnatural for the said witness to go to
his uncle. The courts be~ow were justified in not rejecting
his evidence merely on that score. [Paras 10, 11and15]
[776-D; 778-F-H; 779-A·D]
H
772
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 16 S.C.R.
~
!Iii
I
A
State of U.P. v. M.K. Anthony (1985) 1 SCC 505;
Appabhai & Anr. v. State of Gujarat (1988) Supp. SCC 241
and Rammi @ Rameshwar v. State of M.P. (1999) 8 SCC
.,
I'
+ ..
649; relied on.
~
I
Case Law Reference:
B
(1985) 1 sec 505
relied on
I
Para 13
J
,
c
'"'-~---
(1988) supp. sec 241
relied on
Para 14
(1999) a sec 649
relied/on
Para 15
.'
1-
\
I
r•
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal
No. 1264 of 2005.
I
I'
~
From the Judgment and final Order dated 26-27.8.2004
of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Criminal Appeal
D No. 686 of 1988 ..
~
_ Ashok K. Srivastava, B.P. Suryawanshi, Sushil Karanjkar
and Venkateswara Rao Anumolu for the Appellant.
~
.
¥
E
Anjani Kumar Mishra and Ravindra Keshavrao Adsure for
the Respondent.
r,
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
D.K. JAIN, J. 1. This appeal arises out of the judgment
F. ren~ered by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, in Criminal
Appeal No. 686 of 1988, confirming the conviction of the
appellant for offence under Section 302 read with Section 34
of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short 'IPC').
I
I
,.,,_
'
2. As many as f9ur accused came to be tried by the Addi.
G Sessions Judge, Solapur in Sessions Case No. 198 of 1987.
These persons were Babasaheb Apparao Patil - Accused No.
1, Tanaji Manikrao Patil - Accused No. 2, Appasha Dharmarao
Patil·- Accused No. 3 ·and Prakash Limbanna Koli - Accused
No. 4. The Trial Court convicted all the accused for the said
c
~
..
t
'
~
H
·,
~
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL v. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA [D.K. JAIN, J.]
"' +
-"
,>
.....
,,
~
1
773
offence and sentenced them to suffer rigorous imprisonment
for life and to pay a fine of Rs.1000/- each, with default
stipulation. All the convicts preferred an appeal to the High
Court. Although accused No. 2 and 4 expired during the
pendency of the appeal, yet the High Court dealt with their
appeals as well. The High Court confirmed the conviction of the
appellant herein and accused No. 2 but acquitted the remaining
two accused, giving them the benefit of doubt.
3. According to the prosecution in village Boramani,
District Solapur, there are two rival parties. Manikrao Patil was
the leader of one party and the deceased - Baburao Vibhute
was the leader of the other party. Tanaji Manikrao Patil Accust:3d No. 2 is the son of Manikrao Patil. Babasaheb
Apparao Patil-Accused No. 1 and Appasha Dharmarao Patil
- Accused No. 3 are cousin brothers of Tanaji. Prakash
Limbanna Kali-Accused No. 4 is not related to other three
accused but was known to them. On 7th June, 1989, one
Abhimanyu Rama Bhagare had assaulted the said Manikrao
Patil, father of Accused No. 2 by using a Sattur. Abhimanyu was
a good friend of the deceased Baburao 'vibhute. Manikrao
suspected that assault on him by Abhimanyu had been
instigated by the deceased Baburao and therefore, he held a
grudge against him.
4. On 19th June, 1986, the deceased - Baburao Vibhute,
Sid ram Birajdar (PW-10) Sarpanch of village Boramani,
Prakash Rajguri (PW-11 ), driver of the deceased and one
Suresh Rokade left for Solapur by jeep because the deceased
had some work there. On completion of the work, at around
3.00 p.m. they started the return journey. On their way, they
stopped at hotel Khansaheb to take some snacks. But since
vegetarian snacks were not available, they procured beer from
outside and had it in the hotel. At the hotel, Prakash (PW-11)
saw Shivaji Rajguru (PW-26). who was in the service of the
deceased and had owed some money to him. He, accordingly
informed the deceased, who demanded money from Shivaji but
A
B
c
D
E
..
F
·:_~~
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
774
[2008] 16 $.C.R.
A on his failure to oblige him, he belaboured him and made him
sit in the jeep to take him to his village. When the jeep came
near the village of Shivaj\, .his wife (PW-19) stopped it. The
deceased got down from ttie jeep and was talking with the wife
of Shivaji. While the conversation was going on, anotherjeep
B came from the side of Solapur. All the four accused got down
from the jeep. Accused No. 1 was armed with a pistol; Accused
No. 2 got down wielding an instrument like jamiya (dagger);
Accused No. 3 came to the rear side of the jeep of the
deceased and grabbed him from behind; Accused A-2 gave
a
c dagger blow on his stomach. When the deceased fell down
on the ground, Accused No. 1 fired a bullet shot at his chest.
On seeing the assault, Sidram {PW-10) ran away out of fear.
/>J. a nearby petrol pump, he boarded a truck and reached
Hyderabad. Prakash (PW-11) the driver of the jeep, also fled
.o from the scene and on reaching Solapur, he wentto the house
of his· uncle (PW;.18) and narrated the entire incident to.him.
F
_.,J,~'*\
l~~
G
H
r
'f
1Ud v-:1~u~:JP
·
E
+ ..
5. On 19th June, 1986 itself, at about9.10 p.m., a pnone
call was received by· CPI Bhaskar Patil (PW-28) from an
unknown person informing him about the murder of Baburao
Vibhute. The said informant is stated to have disclosed that the
mur~er had been committed, by Babasaheb Patil - Accused No.
1 and Tanaji Patil - Accused No. 2. PW-28, after making the
entry in the station diary regarding the telephonic message,
conveyed the information to PSI Annasaheb Patil (PW-33),
attached to the Taluka police station within whose jurisdiction
the murder had been committed. On receiving the information,
the police sprung into action. At the place of occurrence,
Panchnama of the scene of occurrence was prepared, the jeep
and some articles alongwith the dead body were seized. The
body of Baburao was sent for post mortem. At the civil hospital,
Dr. Kanki (PW-20) performed the post mortem and found a~
many as 15 injuries.·on the person of the deceased. The injuries
included a fire arm injury over abdomen near left postal margin,
four deep incised wounds over abdomen, four stab wounds over
chest, one incised wound over left side at lumber region and
...
"~,
..,.._
,._
~
....._
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL v. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA [D.K. JAIN, J.]
.. +
'f
775
exit wounds of pellets. Lungs, kidneys, liver, spleen were also
injured. Doctor opined that these injuries were sufficient to
cause death and the death was caused on account of shock
and haemorrhage and due to injuries sustained by the
deceased over abdomen, chest and to visceral organs. On
completion of investigations, which included recording of
confessional statements of Accused No. 2 and Accused No.
4, who also produced the weapons of offence (2 daggers and
one country made pistol), chargesheet was filed against all the
accused.
6. The accused abjured their guilt and accordingly, the trial
was held. The prosecution examined as many as 33 witnesses
to support its case. No evidence was produced in defence.
Upon consideration of the evidence, as noted above, the trial
court convicted all the four accused for offence punishable under
Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC. Appellant's
(Accused No. 1) conviction having been confirmed by the High
Court, he has come up before us in this appeal. The other
convict - Accused No. 2 expired during the pendency of his
appeal in the High Court.
A
B
c
D
E
-t
7. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the
trial court as also the High Court committed serious error in
relying on the wholly unreliable testimony of PW-1 O and PW11, examined by the prosecution as eye-witnesses, inasmuch
as there are contradictions and discrepancies in their evidence.
It was argued that the story of PW-10 going to Hyderabad is
inherently improbable and was a make up to cover the delay
of three days in recording of his sta~ement by police on 23rd
June, 1986. It was also submitted that it was very improbable
that Prakash (PW-11), an employee of the deceased, stated
to have seen the entire incident did not disclose the name of
the accused to his uncle Kisan lngale (PW-18) when he met
him immediately thereafter and furthermore instead of reporting
the occurrence to the police he went to his uncle's house and
narrated the incident to him. It was pleaded that all the accused
F
G.
H
776
A
8
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 16 S.C.R.
had been falsely implicated on account of rivalry between the
two factions in the village.
+ ,I• i
8. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State, on
the other hand, supported the judgment of the High Court and
submitted that the evidence of the two eyewitnesses, coupled
with the medical evidence and the recovery of weapons of
offence clea·rly prove the case against the appellant.
9. Having carefully gone through the judgments of the
courts below, we feel that in the light of the evidence on record,
the view taken by the High Court is correct.
10. As- noted earlier, the mainstay of the prosecution is the
testimony of Sid ram (PW-10) and Prakash (PW-11) who
claimed to be eye witnesses of the occurrence. Both the courts
D below have found their evidence creditworthy and have held that
the minor contradictions in their testimony were not sufficient
to affect the credibility of their evidence. The discrepancies in
the evidence of PW-10 highlighted before lhe High Court on
behalf of the appellants were: (i) his non-mentioning of nonavailability of vegetarian food in the hotel and drinking of beer
E
as recorded in his statement by police (ii) belabouring of Shivaji
by Baburao after returning to the hotel. Similarly, the alleged
omissions. on which emphasis was laid were : (i) nonmentioning of the deceased falling on his back after receiving
the first jamiya blow and (ii) the firing of bullets at the chest of
F the deceased. As regards PW-11, the alleged contradictions
were again with regard to his going to the market to purchase
beer and the deceased, Sidram and Suresh having beer at the
hotel. The stated omission was again abo,ut the bullet being
fired at the chest of the deceased.
G
11. As already noted, the High Court has come to the
conclusion, and in our opinion, rightly, that the contradictions
brought on record pertaining to the bringing and drinking of
beer are not directly related to the incident and cannot be said
to
be material contradictions. Similarly, the alleged omission
H
...
'f
"')f-
\j.-
t
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL v. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA [D.K. JAIN, J.]
I.
+
....
·-'f
777
relating to the firing being on the chest of the deceased has
also been held to be not a material omission because there is
no omission in the statement as regards the firing by the
appellant on the deceased.
A
12. It is to be borne in mind that some discrepancies in
the ocular account of a witness, unless these are vital, cannot
per se affect the credibility of the evidence of the witness.
Unless the contradictions are material, the same cannot be used
to jettison the evidence in its entirety. Trivial discrepancies ought
not to obliterate an otherwise acceptable evidence. Merely
because there is inconsistency in evidence, it is not sufficient
to impair the credibility of the witness. It is only w~" n
discrepancies in the evidence of a witness are so incompatible
with the credibility of his version that the court would be justified
in discarding his evidence.
B
c
D
1
~
~
13. In State of U.P. Vs. M.K. Anthony , this Court indicated
the proper approach which needs to be adopted while
appreciating the evidence of a witness. It was observed as
under:
"While appreciating the evidence of a wJ!.ness, the
approach must be whether the evidence of the witness
read as a whole appears to have a ring of truth. Once that
impression is formed, it is undoubtedly necessary for the
court to scrutinise the evidence more particularly keeping
in view the deficiencies, drawbacks and infirmities pointed
out in the evidence as a whole and evaluate them to find
out whether it is against the general tenor of the evidence
given by the witness and whether the earlier evaluation of
the evidence is shaken as to render it unworthy of belief.
Minor discrepancies on trivial matters not touching the core
of the case, hyper-technical approach by taking sentences
torn out of context here or there from the evidence,
attaching importance to some technical error committed
~
• .,
....
1.
(1985) 1 sec 50·5.
E'.
F
G
H
778
'A
c
E
[2008} 16 S.C.R.
by the investigating officer not going to the root of the
matter would not ordinarily permit rejection of the evidence
as a whole. If the court before whom the witness gives
evidence had the opportunity to form the opinion about the
general tenor of evidence given by the witness, the
appellate court which had not this benefit will have to
attach due weight to the appreciation of evidence by the
trial court and unless there are reasons weighty and
formidable it would not be proper to reject the evidence
on the ground of minor variations or infirmities in the matter
of trivial details. Even honest and truthful witnesses may
differ in some details unrelated to the main incident
because power of observation, retention and reproduction
I
differ with individuals."
B
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
14. In Appabhai & Anr. Vs. State of Gujarat2, this Court
had again emphasized that while appreciating the evidence,
the court should not attach undue importance to minor
discrepancies. The discrepancies which do not shake the basic
version of the prosecution case may be discarded. Similarly,
the discrepancies which are due to normal errors of perception
or observation should not be given importance. The Court by
calling into. aid its vast experience of men and mgtters in
different cases must evaluate the entire material on record as
a whole and should not disbelieve the evidence of a witness
altogether, if it is otherwise trustworthy.
+~
'\
":f-
/
,,,
.....
:;-
F·
15. Having gone through the evidence of PW-10 and PW11, we a~e in complete·agreement with the High Court that the
aforenoted contradictions are not directly relating to the incident
and cannot be said to be material contradictions affecting the
credibility of the evidence of both the eye witnesses viz. PWG
10 and PW-11. Similarly, the so-called omission of not
mentioning the exact portion of the body of the deceased where
the shot had been fired cannot be said to be a significant
omission.because there was no omission as regards the firing
H
2.
1988 (Supp) sec 241.
,._
·ft.....
t
BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL v. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA [D.K. JAIN, J.]
j.
-r
~
J
.>
t
'
_..,
by the appellant on the deceased. In his testimony, PW-10 has
given graphic details of the occurrence. Similarly, PW-11, the
driver of the jeep, in his evidence, has narrated the incidence
which corroborates with the version of PW-10. The evidence
of these two witnesses stands corroborated by the medical
evidence, which clearly shows that several blows were given
to the deceased by jamiya (dagger) and a fire arm injury was
also found over the abdomen of the deceased. The conduct of
PW-11 in going to the house of his uncle instead of reporting
the incident to the police cannot be said to be unnatural,
impairing the creditworthiness of his evidence. The post-event
conduct of a witness varies from person to person. It cannot
be a cast iron reaction to be followed as a model by every one
witnessing such event. Different persons would react differently
on seeing any serious crime and their behaviour and conduct
would, therefore, be different. (See: Rammi@ Rameshwar Vs.
State of M.P. 3). Therefore, having witnessed a dastardly murder,
it was not unnatural for the said witness to go to his uncle and,
therefore, the courts below were justified in not rejecting his
evidence merely on that score.
16. Thus, we are unable to ayree with learned counsel for
the appellant that the trial court as well as the High Court have
failed to appreciate properly the evidence on record. We are
convinced that the conclusions of the courts below, that the
appellant had committed the offence of murder of Baburao
Vibhute, are supported by acceptable evidence. We do not find
any legal or factual infirmity in the impugned judgment
warranting interference. The appeal is dismissed accordingly.
D.G.
"
-'"
iiiiii'i:..
-f
3.
I
t
779
(1999) a sec 649.
Appeal dismissed.
A
B
c
D
E
F
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org