GULAM MOHD. @ GULAL SHAIKH versus STATE OF GUJARAT
Supreme Court of India | Decided 11 November 2008 | [2008] 15 S.C.R. 1039 | 2008 INSC 1285
Key facts
- Decided
- 11 November 2008
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, P. SATHASIVAM
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1770/2008
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2008] 15 S.C.R. 1039
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 1285
Text of the judgment
..•-[2008] 15 S.C.R. 1039
).._
-(
GULAM MOHD. @ GULAL SHAIKH
v.
STATE OF GUJARAT
(Criminal Appeal No.1770 of 2008)
NOVEMBER 11, 2008
A
B
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND P. SATHASIVAM, JJ.]
'
~
~
--(
"
I~
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - s.439 - Prevention
of Terrorism Act, 2002 - s.49 - Bail - Grant of- Confession
purportedly recorded under s.32 of POTA - Bail applications
under the Acts - Rejected by trial Court - High Court affirming
same - Correctness of - Held: Correct - When applicant
was produced for confirmation of the so called confessional
statement, there was no plea that the same was obtained
under pressure - It was claimed that there was retraction If in reality there was no confession, the question of any
retraction did not arise.
The applicant was facing trial for alleged commission
of offence under Penal Code, Prevention of Terrorism
Act, 2002 (POTA) and Arms Act. A confessional statement
was purportedly recorded u/s.32 ofPOTA. The applicant
filed application uls.439 Cr.P.C. and s.49 of POTA, which
was dismissed by the Trial Court. High Court affirmed the
same. Hence the instant appeal.
c
D
E
F
Dismissing the appeal, the Court
~.~
_(
HELD: Two other factors need to be noted. When the
appellant was produced for confirmation of the so called
confessional statement there was no allegation that the
same was obtained under pressure. It is claimed that
there was retraction on 9.8.2003. If in reality there was no
confession, the question of any retraction does not arise.
[Para 8] [1043-D-E]
1039
G
H
1040
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 15 S.C.R.
State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu a/is Afsan Guru
(2005) 11 sec 600, referred to.
A..
·Case Law R~ference:
(2005) 11 sec· soo
B
referred to
para 9
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal
No. 1770 of2008.
From the final Juagment and Order dated 21.2.2006-0f the
High:Court of Gujarat at Ahmadabad in Criminal Appeal No.
C 1704 of 2004.
·
Nima Ramakrishnan and M.A. Chinnasamy for the·
Appellant.
D
Hemantika· Wahi for the Respondent
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by • ·
DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Leave granted.
, 2. Ch'allenge in 'this appeal fs to the order passed. by a
Division Bench of the Oufarat High Court dismis$ing the
Criminal Appeal No.1704 of 2004. Challenge before the High
Court was to· the order passed by learned· Specia1 Judge,
POTA, Ahmedabad .in· Criminal· Mis'cellaneous Application
No.2219 of 2004 irJ connection with I.GR. No.6 of2003 of DCB
F Crime Police Station, Ahmedabad City (presently numbered as
POTA Case N0.12. of2,003).
.
E
3. ·The background facts in a nutshell are as follows;
G
An application in terms of Section 439 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in ·Short 'Cr;P.C.') and Section 49
of the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 (in short 'POTA') was
filed. The applicant is facing trial for alleged· commission of
offences punishable under Sections 120-B, 121, 121A, 122;
H 123 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short 'IPC') and
..+.
-~.
,
s4
GULAM MOHD. @ GULAL SHAIKH v. STATE OF
GUJARAT [DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
1041
)...
~.
--(
--'(
. . . .-4
Sections 3(1)(A)(B), 3(3), 4, 20, 21(2) B, 22(3)(A)(B) of POTA
and Sections 25 ( 1)B, C, 27 and 29 of the Arms Act, 1950 (in
short 'Arms Act'). According to the applicant, on 3.4.2003 five
boys were picked up from a park of Ahmedabad City and on
4.4.2003 first information report was lodged wherein
commission of offences punishable under the POTA were
included. Case was registered as CR.No.6 of 2003. According
to the applicant he was picked up by the Crime Branch and
was kept in illegal custody .. Certain news items were published
in newspapers on 30.6.2003. It is pointed out that another coaccused under trial in another case was not produced. The
counsel appearing for him made a statement before the Court
that he was in illegal custody of Crime Branch. The name of
that co-accused is Rafiq and same stand was taken. Notice
was issued by the learned Additional Sessions Judge fixing the
date 16.7.2003. The appellant was shown to have been
arrested in the present case on 15.7.2003. A confessional
statement purported to have been recorded under Section 32
of POTA on 8.8.2003. The appellant does not know Gujarati
and, therefore, the question of making a confessional statement
does not arise and he did not sign before the Deputy
. Commissioner. Though he was produced before tne Magistrate
: for confirmation in terms of section 32(5) of POTA, he was
remanded to judicial custody. He made a retraction from the
so-called confession on 9.8.2003. It was pointed out that the
so-called confession under Section 32 of POTA is not
admissible as the provision is entirely diffe.rent from Section 15
of Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 The
trial Court rejected the application prima facie with the following
observations:
"If one looks at the confessional statement of the accused
himself it provides sufficient material to prima facie point
out his thick relations with the absconding accused Rasool
Khan @ Rasool Party. He not only has provided him huge
amount of money time and again but, he has worked at
his instance continuously and also made frantic hunt for
A
e
c
D
E
F
G
H
1042
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 15 S.C.R..
renting a godown for the purpose of hiding the weapons which were to be sent in large quantity from the time the
alleged conspiracy was hatched. Till the date of his arrest
he had been in constant touch with Rasool Party with
·. whom he a-ppears to have talked even· after he left the
country to base himself at Pakistan. His wife and children
with active connivance of this applicant accused could· ·
cross the border. He had helped him in executing the
various tasks in pursuance of the conspiracy hatched and
therefore, even without taking into consideration the
confessional. statement of others this prim a facie
sufficiently involves him to de~y him~he bail. The
statements of other witnesses and also of those witnesses
who have provided links to the alleged conspiracy also
prima facie.involve this applicant accused and therefore,
also he does not deserve the bail. The Court a_tso if looks
at statement of Kaleemullah one of the key accused in the·
instant case who is also an accused in the other matters,
his alleged role in the involvement at every stage .of
conspiracy and for its execution gets prima fa'cie ·
established.
His past criminal antecedent reflected by him in his
confessional statement also would not permit this Court to
grant him the t>ail as there would· be a fair possibility of
his not facing the trial. He may have been a TADA accused
and provided with the Regt.iiar Bail, but, in every case, the
facts will have to be considered from the documents_
adduced along-with the. charge-sheet and moreover,.
orders of his regular bail in the TADA matters are, not
before this Court for it to appreciate anything." ·
. 4. The order of rejection was challenged before the High
Court which, as noted above, dismissed the appeal.
5. In support of the appeal, learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that this Court has categorically held that
H the confession, if any, under Section 32 of POTA made by the
GULAM MOHD. @GULAL SHAIKH v. STATE OF
GUJARAT [DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
1043
)..
co-accused is not admissible. It was submitted that there was
retraction from the confession and, therefore, there was no
material before the trial Court to reject the prayer for bail.
j.
-~
6. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand
submitted that the role of the accused is clearly established.
His link with the absconding accused Rasul and Mufti Sufian
' is clearly established. There was recovery of country made
·revolver and live cartridges. It was pointed out that it was not
only the statement recorded under Section 32 of POTA but
other factors like recovery, and antecedents were also taken
into consideration.
7. It also referred to the evidence which indicated that the
appellant had collected money from one Mohd. Saiyed and
Tanvir and ultimately handed over the money to Mufti Sufian and,
therefore, it cannot be said that except the confession under
Section 32 of POTA, there is no other evidence.
8. Two other factors need to be noted. When the appellant
was produced for confirmation of the so called confessional
statement there was no allegation that the same was obtained
under pressure. It is claimed that there was retraction on
. 9.8.2003. If in reality there was no confession, the question of
any retraction does not arise.
.... ;--""
-
B
c
0
E
9. In State (NCT of Delhi) v. NavjofSandhu a/is Afsan
Guru (2005 (11) sec 600) it was noted at para 50 as follows:
~
A
"We are therefore of the view that having regard to all these
weighty considerations, the confession of a co-accused
ought not to be brought within the sweep of Section 32(1).
As a corollary, it follows that the confessions of the first and
second accused in this case recorded by the police officer
under Section 32(1 ), are of no avail against the coaccused or against each other. We also agree with the High
Court that such confessions cannot be taken into
consideration by the Court under Section 30 of the
F
G
H
1044
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 15 S.C.R.
Evidence Act The reason is that the confession made to
a police officer or the confession made while a person is
in policy custody, cannot be proved against such person, ·
not to speak of the co-accused, in view of the mandate of
r·
Sections 25 and· 26 of the Evidence Act. If ther~ is a
confession which qualifies for proof in accordance with the
provisions of the Evidence Act; then ·of course, ·the said
· confession could be considered against th~ co-accused
facing trial under POTA.But, that is not the case here."
.
..
. " 10.Above being the position, we dismiss the appeal. It is,
C however, to be noted that learned counsel for the respondent.
pointed out thatthe case is at the advance stage of trial. It would
be proper for the trial Court to conclude the. trial as· early as
possible.
11, The. appeal fails artd is dismiss~d.
0
D.G:
Appeal .dismissed .
.
'
)...
.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org