RAJIV ARORA versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 August 2008 | [2008] 12 S.C.R. 1026 | 2008 INSC 990
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 August 2008
- Bench
- S.B. SINHA*, CYRIAC JOSEPH
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5306/2008
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [2008] 12 S.C.R. 1026
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 990
Text of the judgment
..
[2008] 12 S.C.R. 1026
A
RAJIV ARORA
V.
"1c--
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No.5306 of 2008)
B
AUGUST 29, 2008
[S.B. SINHA AND CYRIAC JOSEPH, JJ.]
~
Air Force Rules; R.43:Court Martial - Charges of misconduct - Non-
c examination of witnesses - Effect of - Held: No reason has
· been assigned as to why the named witnesses who only could
prove the charge had not been examined in the Court Martial
proceedings - Since there has been a gross violation of the
principles of natural justice, the High Court should have
D exercised its power of judicial review - Before convening a
Court Martial proceeding, legal requirement therefor must be
satisfied - Satisfaction must be based on a finding that
evidence justified a trial on these charges - An order passed
without any evidence must be held to be perverse - Hence,
E. the impugned order in regard to Charge Nos. 1, 2, 3 cannot be
sustained as witnesses have not been examined to prove
these charges - Evidence - Principles of natural justice Compliance - Discussed.
Appellant, a commissioned Officer in the Indian Air
F Force, applied for premature retirement. A good conduct
certificate was issued by the office. However, a
disciplinary proceeding was initiated against him and a
charge-sheet was issued leveling 7 charges against him.
Later, a convening order was issued for trial by a General
G Court Martial. He filed an application for substitution of
the Judge Advocate. The application was rejected by the
authority. In the Court Martial proceedings the witness
named in respect of first three charges have not been
examined. Aggrieved, the employee filed a writ petition
1026
H
:-r·
"
-+
,I..
·k
RAJIV ARORA v. UNION OF !NOIA & ORS.
1027
-1·
for quashing the proceedings before the Court Martial,
which was dismissed by the High Court. Hence the
present appeal.
A
Partly allowing the appeal, the Court
..
'
;.
.
t.
,..,.
HELD: 1.1A plea that no prejudice has been caused 8
to the petitioner due to non-examination of the said
witnesses has been raised by respondents on the premise
that a report had been furnished, inter alia, in respect of
charge No.2 and the same has been produced in the
summary of evidence. Whether prejudice has been c
caused by non-examination of witnesses named in the
charge-sheet is essentially a question of fact. An inference
is required to be drawn having regard to the facts and
circumstances obtaining in each case. The charges
framed as against the appellant were specific. The
0
misconducts said to have been committed are in relation
to the persons named therein. No explanation has been
offered as to why the such witnesses could not be
examined. PW-7 was the custodian of the report. He was
not the maker thereof. Effective cross-examination could
have been done as regards the correctness or otherwise E
of the report, if its contents were to be proved. The
principles analogous to the provisions of the Indian
Evidence Act as also the principles of natural justice
demand that the maker of the report should be examined,
save and except in cases where the facts are admitted or F
the witnesses are not available for cross-examination or
similar situation. No reason has been assigned as to why
the named witnesses who only could prove the charge
had not been examined. Indisputably, they were the prime
G
witnesses. (Paras - 11,12,13) [1033,C-H; 1034,A-B]
1.2 The High Court in its impugned judgment
proceeded to consider the issue on a technical plea that no
prejudice has been caused to the appellant by such nonexamination. If the basic principles of law have not been
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1028
A
[2008] 12 S.C.R.
complied with or there 'has been a gross violation of the
principles of natural justice, the High Court should have
exercised its jurisdiction of judicial review. [para 14] [1034,C]
-
.....-
.
~
1.3 Before a court martial proceeding is convened,
legal requirements therefor must be satisfied. Satisfaction
B of the officer concerned must be premised on a finding
that evidence justified a trial on those charges. Such a
satisfaction cannot be arrived at without any evidence. If
an order is passed without any evidence, the same must
be held to be perverse. The High Court was not correct
c in opining that the appellant did not raise any objection
in tll~ said proceedings. Hence, the impugned judgment
in regard to the charge Nos.1, 2 and 3 cannot be sustained.
They are set aside accordingly. Since witnesses for proving
charge Nos.4 to 7 have been examined, the General Court
D Martial Proceedings shall continue in respect of charge
NosA to 7. (Paras - 14, 15 & 16) [1034,C-F] ·
CIVILAPPELLATE.JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 5306
·of 2008
E
-{-
!
"
From the final Judgment and Order dated 16.11.2006 of ·
the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WP ~C) No. 10271 of
2006
WITH
F
- ~- C.A. No. 5307 of 2008
:+ .
/>.
Major K. Ramesh (for Dr. Kailash Chand) for the Appellant.
Mohan Parasaran, ASG., P.. Narasimhan and B. Krishna
.
Prasad for the Respondents.
.
·G
The J'1dgment of the Court was delivered by
S.B.SINHA,_ J. 1.. Leave
granted.
.
.
2. While appeal arising OJ.Jt of SLP (C) No. 3385 of 2007
is_ directed against a judgment and· order dated 16.11.2006
passed
by the Div1sion Bench o'f the High Courfof Delhi whereby
H
~
f
I
RAJIV ARlSRA v. UNION OF ·INDIA & ORS.
[S.B.SINHA, J.]
1029
and whereunder a writ petition filed by the appellant herein
questioning the validity of a Court Martial proceeding has been
dismissed, appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.5916 of 2007 is
directed against the order dated 19th December, 2006 passed
in the review petition.
A ,
,, 3. We may, before adverting to the contentions raised by
th.e parties, notice the admitted fact of the matter.
8
4. Appellant was commissioned in the Indian Air Force on
_ or about 6.12.1985. He filed an application for posting to MOFT
Unit so as to enable him to fly MIG 21 Fighter Aircrafts. The
said application was rejected. He applied for premature
retirement. A good conduct certificate was issued in his favour.
However, a disciplinary proceeding was initiated against him
on or about 20.1.2006 in respect whereof a charge-sheet was
"FIRST
CHARGE
SECTION 65
AIR FORCE
ACT, 1950
AN ACT PREJUDICIAL TO GOOD
ORDER AND AIR FORCE
DISCIPLINE
-
At New Delhi on the night of 28/29 Apr. 05,
improperly introduced himself as husband
of Mrs. Ambika Singhania to Head
Constable Ranbir and Constable
· Dharmendeer, Police Personnel of Delhi
Police, knowing such statement.to.!>~ false.
'
'
c
D
In that he
E
F
SECON.D ·
BEHAVING IN A MANNER
CHARGE. · UNBECOMING THE POSITION AND
SECTION 45
CHARACTER OF AN OFFICER
AIR,,FORCE
In that he,
G
ACT, 1950
At New Delhi on the night of 28/29 Apr
05, used offensive language to Sh .
. Dependra Pathak, Deputy Commissioner r
of Police, South West District, New D.elhi
and behaved in a riotous manner.
H
1030
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS "
(2008] 12 S.C.R.
THIRD
INTOXICATION
CHARGE
In that he
SECTION 48
AIR FORCE AT New Delhi on the night of 28/29 Apr
05, was found in a state of intoxication.
ACT, 1950
ASSAULTING HIS SUPERIOR
FIFTH
OFFICER
CHARGE
SECTION·
In that he,
40(a) AIR
FORCE ACT, At Gandhinagar (Gujarat), on 06 Jan.06,
1950
assaulted Gp.Capt. SS Kothari (16788)
F (P) of Headquarter South Western Air
Command, Indian Air Force.
SEXTH
CHARGE
SECTION 45
AIR FORCE
ACT, 1950
BEHAVING IN A MANNER
UNBECOMING THE POSITION AND
CHARACTER OF AN OFFICER
In that he,
At Gandhinagar (Gujarat), on 06 Jan.06
at Officers' Mess Headquarter South
Western Air Command, Indian Air Force,
used offensive language to 707519
Sergeant Narender Kumar, Catering
Assistant of Headquarter South Western
Air Command, Indian Air Force and
behaved in a riotous manner.
ILL TREATING A PERSON SUBJECT
SEVENTH
TO THE AIR FORCE ACT BEING HIS
CHARGE
SUBORDINATE IN RANK
SECTION 47
AIR FORCE
In that he,
ACT, 1950
(ALTERNATIVE At Gandhinagar (Gujarat), on 06 Jan.06,
TO SIXTH
at the Officers' Mess Headquarter South
Western Air Command, Indian Air Force,
CHARGE)
ill-treated 707518 Sergeant Narender
tl
RAJIV ARORA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[S.B.SINHA, J.]
-~
1031
Kumar Catering Assistant of Headquarter
South Western Air Command, Indian Air
Force."
A
issued on 1.4.2006, the details whereof are as under :
5. A convening order was issued for trial by a General
Court Martial on 8.5.2006.
)..
6. A contention was raised as regards sustainability of the
first three charges, inter alia, on the ground that as the witnesses
named therein were not produced for cross-examination, the
purpose of continuing the General Court Martial proceedings
became frustrated. The same was rejected.
s
c
7. He filed an application for substitution of the Judge
Advocate. It was also disallowed.
8. On the aforementioned premise, the writ petition was
):
filed.
:.I.
,._:_ ..... '
~
D
9. Indisputably, the witnesses named in respect of first
three charges were not examined. Was it violative of Rule 43
of the Air Force Rules is the question.
E
It reads as under :
~,.
-(
.....
"43. Convening of General and District Courts-martial :
(1) An officer before convening a general or district courtsmartial shall first satisfy himself that the charges to be F
tried by the court-martial are for offences within the meaning
of the Act, and framed in accordance with Law, and that
the evidence justifies a trial on those charges, he may
amend the charges if he deems fit, and if not so satisfied
order release of the accused, or refer the case to superior
G
authority.
(2) He shall also satisfy himselfthat the case is a proper
one to be tried by the description of court-martial he
p~~poses to convene.
H'
1032
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 12 S.C.R.
(3) The officer convening the court-martial shall appoint or
detail the officers to form the court and may also appoint
or detail such waiting officers as he thinks expedient. He
may also where he considers the services of an interpreter
to be necessary, appoint or detail an interpreter to the
court.
~--
c
D
(4) After the convening officer has appointed or detailed
the officers to form a court-martial under Sub-rule (3),
convening order of the court-martial and endorsement on
the charge sheet for trial of the accused by the courtmartial may either be signed by the convening officer or
by a staff officer on his behalf. The charge sheet on which
the accused to be tried, the summary of the evidence and
convening order for assembly of court-martial shall then
be sent to the senior officer of court-martial and the Judge
Advocate, if appointed."
Rule 57 of the Rules enables the accused to object to the
charge, inter alia, on the ground that it does not disclose an
offence under the Act or is not in accordance with these Rules.
E
F
G
H
10. It is not in dispute that such an objection was taken by
the petitioner, stating :
"It would be ironical and amazing to state that the cause
of action relating to first three charges pertain to when I
was posted at AIR HQ at New Delhi and for the last one
year no cognizable action was taken against me. Now in
the absence of any Court of Inquiry or formal marshaling
of evidence in the Summary of Evidence, I am being
prejudiced by facing these charges which have cropped
up for the first time in the Court: Martial itself which is in
violation of all the aforementioned AF Rules and the
principles of Natural Justice. Inter alia, the Fourth to Seventh
Charges hv.ve been made out after analyzing the evidence
in the Summary of Evidence but in the First three charges
not a single prosecution witness had deposed in the
Summary of Evidence which is open to verification. I was
RAJIV ARORA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
[S.B.SINHA, J.]
It
-:y
~~
)~
~
,.
-+
1033
also given a Good Conduct Certificate by my CO.
A
3. Therefore, I pray in all humility that the Convening orde~s
of the General Court Martial is not only based on sum ma~
of evidence but it also lacks jurisdiction as the only
competent authority to convene the GCM is an officer ~f
the rank of Air Marshal in the appointment of AOC-in-C
and this power and the warrant cannot be delegated to
any Staff Officer as has been done in this instant case fof
which there are enough case laws on the subject which
the respected Judge Advocate is well aware of."
B
11. Respondents never denied or disputed the said
contentions. It is, however, urged that no prejudice has been
caused to the petitioner due to non-examination of the said
witnesses during the summary of evidence. Such a plea has
been raised on the premise that a report had been furnished~
inter alia, in respect of charge No.2 by Shri Dipendra Pathak
and the same has been produced in the summary of evidence
by Sq. Ldr. T.S. Reddy who was the custodian thereof.
c
D
12. Whether prejudice has been caused by nonexamination of witnesses named in the charge-sheet is E
essentially a question of fact. An inference is required to be
drawn having regard to the facts and circumstances obtaining
in each case. The charges framed as against the appellant ·
were specific. The misconducts were said to have been
committed are in relation to the persons named therein. In the F
proceedings, seven witnesses were examined, namely, Air
Commander M. Bhandari, Sgt. Narender Kumar, Flight
Lieutenant S. Dasgupta, Gp. Captain S.S. Kothari, Gp. Captain
P.W. Amberkar, Gp. Captain S.C. Kabra and Sqn. Leader T.S.
Reddy.
G
13. No exp!anation has been offered as to why the
concerned witnesses could not be examined. Shri Reddy, PW7 was the custodian of the report. He was not the maker thereof.
Effective cross-examination could have been 'done as regards
the correctness or otherwise of the report, if the contents of H
1034
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
,.,.
[2008] 12 S.C.R.
them were proved. The principles analogous to the provisions
of the Indian Evidence Act as also the principles of natural
justice demand that the maker of the report should be examined,
save and except in cases
where the facts are admitted or the
-...c:_. witnesses are not available for cross-examination or similar
situation. No reason has been assigned as to why the named
witnesses who only could prove the change had not been
examined. Indisputably, they were the prime witnesses.
v-
I
;-
#
B
14.The High Court in its impugned judgment proceeded
to consider the issue on a technical plea, namely, no prejudice
c. has been caused to the appellant by such non-examination. If
the basic principles of law have not been complied with~_or
·there has been a gross violation of the principles of nafural
justice, the High Court..should have exercised its jurisdiction of
. judicial review. Before a court martial proceeding is convened,
D legal requir:ements therefor must be satisfied. Satisfaction of
toe officer concerned must be premised on a finding that
evidence justified a trial on those charges. Such a satisfaction
cannot be arrived at without any evidence. If an order is passed
without any evidence, the same must be held to be perverse.
E
...
~
,,_
;..
15.The High Court was also not correct in opining that the
appellant did not raise any objection in the said proceedings.
16. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the impugned
judgment in regard to the charge Nos.1, 2 and 3 cannot be
F. sustained. The,y are set aside accordingly. It has not been
disputed that witnesses for proving charge Nos.4 to 7 have
been examined. The General Court Martial Proceedings shall
continue in respect of charge Nos.4 to 7 and ·not in respect of
charges No.1 to 3. Appeals are allowed to the above extent
with costs. Counsel's fee. assessed at Rs.50,000/-.
G
Appeal partly allowed.
S.K.S.
I
.•
)
-f,
...
~
~
·r.
,.
..r
I
I
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org