ANIL KUMAR SHAHI AND ORS. versus PROF. RAM SEVAK YADAV AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 24 July 2008 | [2008] 11 S.C.R. 211 | 2008 INSC 860
Key facts
- Decided
- 24 July 2008
- Bench
- S.B. SINHA*, LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1124/2000
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2008] 11 S.C.R. 211
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 860
Text of the judgment
[2008] 11 S.C.R. 211
4
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI AND ORS.
A
v.
PROF. RAM SEVAK YADAV AND ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 1124 Of 2000)
~
'
JULY 24, 2008
).
B
[S.B. SINHA AND LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, JJ.]
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971: s.2(a) - Wilful violation of
order of Court - Invocation of contempt jurisdiction under the
Act - Scope of - Held: While exercising jurisdiction under the c
Act, it is not open to the court to pass an order, which would
materially add to or alter the order, for alleged disobedience
of which contempt jurisdiction was invoked - When the Court
directs the authority to consider a matter in accordance with
law, it means that the matter should be considered to the best " D
of understanding by the authority - Mere error of judgment
with regard to the legal position cannot constitute contempt of
court- There is no willful disobedience if best efforts are made to comply with the order- Constitution of India, 1950 - Article
129.
E
In an I.A. filed by the petitioners, this Court on
7.3.2006 held that it was not open to the respondents to
raise a fresh controversy on facts before this Court and
directed the respondents to implement the order of Mohd.
A/tat dated 10.1.2001 and 20.2.2002 and apply the same F
eligibility criteria as decided by this Court in these orders.
This Court directed respondents to pass appropriate orders giving reason as to why petitioners were not considered and disclose the marks obtained by them as well
as cut off marks beyond which candidates were called G
for interview.
....
In compliance with this order,· the respondents
passed an office order dated 7.4.2006 taking a stand that
petitioners were found ineligible and therefore not called
211
H
212
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008) 11 S.C.R.
"
A
for interview and that the order· of this Court dated
20.2.2002, and 10.1.2000, are applicable to only those can·- · di dates who had appeared in the interview. Hence the
contempt petitions.
In reply to the contempt petitions, the Chairman of
UPPSC in his affidavit submitted that he has highest regard for the orders passed by this Court and has taken
necessary action in compliance of order dated 7.3.2006
.- .and that he never intended to disobey orders of this Court
may amount to contempt of orders of this Court.
c which
He further submitted that in compliance of orders of this
Court, the petitioners had made representation and Commission passed office order dated 7.4.2006 on its interpretation of order dated 20.2.2002 passed in Mohd. Altaf
case in which it was ordered that orders would be appliD cable to all conceq1ed who appeared in the interview.
However, after rejection of representation of the petiticners, the Commission realised that order dated 20.2.2002
should be made applicable to petitioners due to their
higher marks than the cut off marks. It was further subE mitted that having regard to various orders passed by this
Court, Commission had· disclosed the marks to petitioners· and subsequently called them for ·interview. All the
petitioners appeared for·the interview~· The Commission
accordingly revised the Combined Merit List of PCS Examination-1997
and included the petitioners in Eligibility
F
List of 1997 along with other candidates. It was submitted that Commission was not in a position to recommend
the candidature of petitioners as they belonged to ·1997
examination and in absence of vacancies, their candidaG ture could not be recommended as directed by this Court.
The Secretary, UPPSC gave similar statement in a separate-affidavit. The Chairman and Secretary UPPSC placed
Chart showing vacancy position as obtaining in the. year
1996, 1997 and 1998 giving .details of selection for the
H various posts.
.....
t
I
8
~
.,.._
....
,_
....
,_I-
>-
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
SEVAK YADAV & ORS.
213
Dismissing the Contempt Petitions, the Court
A
HELD: 1. The UPPSC has satisfactorily explained
that the advertisement of 548 posts was made as per the
requisition of the State Government which numbers were
later on found to be wrong, because 216 vacancies which
8
were advertised in 1996 batch, were wrongly included in
548 vacancies. The vacant posts for 1997 batch were only
332 and not 548 and with 111 vacancies carried forward
from 1996 batch, the total vacancies in 1997 were 443.
[Para 25] [240-F,G]
c
2. A cursory glance of the Contempt of Courts Act,
1971 and the provisions thereof makes it abundantly clear
that the Act has been brought in the Statute book to define the limit and powers of certain Courts punishing for
contempt of courts and it has laid down the procedure
for exercise of such powers. Contempt of Court has been
defined under Section 2(a) of the Act, to mean civil contempt or criminal contempt. 'Civil Contempt' has been
defined under Section 2(b) of the Act to mean 'wilful disobedience of any judgment, decree, '~rection, order, writ
or other process of court of willful breach of undertaking
given to a court.' It is by now well-settled under the Act
and under Article 129 of the Constitution of India that if it
is alleged before this Court that a person has willfully violated its order it can invoke its jurisdiction under the Act
to enquire whether the allegation is true or not and if found
to be true, it can punish the offenders for having committed 'civil contempt' and if need be, can pass consequential orders for enforcement of execution of the order, as
the case may be, for violation of which, the proceeding
for contempt was initiated. In other words, while exercising its power under the Act, it is not open to the court to
pass an order, which will materially add to or alter the order, for alleged disobedience of which contempt jurisdiction was invoked. When the Court directs the authority to
consider a matter in accordance with law, it means that
o
E
F
G
H
1,:
"
214
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
A
the matter should be considered to the best of understanding by the authority and, therefore, a mere error of
judgment with regard to the l~gal position cannot constitute contempt of court. There is no willful disobedience if
~
best efforts are made to comply with the order. [Para 26]
B [241-D,E,F,G, 242-A,B]
3. Having considered the entire factual backdrop of
the matter and giving due consideration to the various
orders passed by this Court in this case and having considered the detailed explanations given by the Chairman,
C UPPSC, Secretary, UPPSC, and Deputy Director [Education] in their re~pective affidavits which are quite satisfactory and further examination of the details of year-wise
vacancies position for the posts in question stated in the
Chart submitted by the UPPSC, it cannot be said that a
0 deliberate circumvention and dubious method was
adopted by the contesting respondents to avoid implementation of the judgments/orders of this Court nor the ·
facts and circumstances mentioned above would establish that the contesting respondents have willfully or deE liberately disobeyed the judgments/orders of this Court
dated 07 .03.2006 and 09.03.2007 as alleged by the petitioners. In terms of the order dated 07 .03.2006, the respondents have passed an appropriate order which was communicated to the petitioners. The UPPSC have placed on
record all the relevant documents relating to these proF ceedings as directed by this Court in its order dated
09.03.2007. [Para 27] [242-B,C,D,E]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Contempt Petition
(C) No. 91 of 2006
G
IN
Civil Appeal No. 1124 of 2000
WITH
H
Contempt Petition (C) No. 162 of2007 In Contempt P. (C)
No. 91 of 2006
!
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
215
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
In C.A. No. 1124 of 2000
Jyotindra Misra, AG., Shail Kumar Dwivedi, AAG., Collin
Gonsalves, Harish N. Salve, Mohit Chaudhary, .Manish Jain,
Pradeep Chandel, Puja Sharma, Vandana Mishra, Vibha
Dwivedi, R.K. Gupta, S.K. Gupta, Arun Yadav, A.N. Bardiyar,
Rakesh Kumar Singh, Jitendra Kumar, G.D. Singh, Shrish
Kumar Misra, Ajay Kumar Singh and Gunnam Venkateswara
Rao for the Appellant.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.
A
8
c
Contempt Petition (C) 91 of 2006
1. This is a petition under Article 129 of the Constitution of
India read with Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971
preferred by Anil Kumar Shahi, Ghanshyam Singh, Davendra 0
Singh and Raj Narain Lal, petitioners herein, inter a/ia praying
for the following reliefs:-
"(a) initiate contempt proceedings against the
contemnors for their willful disobedience and uphold
the majesty of this Hon'ble Court; and/or
(b)
direct the respondents to disclose the marks
obtained by the petitioner as well as cut-off marks
beyond which the candidates were called for
interview; and/or
(c)
quash order dated 7.4.2006 passed by the
respondent no. 2 which is in contravention of the
order dated 7.3.2006 passed by this Hon'ble Court;
and/or
(d)
direct the respondents that if the candidates are
found to have obtained equal to or more than cut-off
marks, then to call the candidates for interview and
recommend the candidates;. and/or
(e)
direct the respondents/U. P. Government that
E
F
G
H
216
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
thereafter to appoint the candidates in order of their
post of preference as was submitted by the
-candidates during the mains examination; and/or
(f)
B
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
pass such other or further orders as this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances
of the present case."
2. Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the filing of the
present petition are as under:C
D
E
F
G
The petitioners and other candidates had appeared in the
preliminary and main examinations for the year 1997 conducted
by the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission ['the UPPSC']
for the posts of Principal, Government Inter College (Boys and
Girls) and Senior Lecturer in District Education and Training
Institutes along with other posts in the State of U.P. and a combined State/Upper Subordinate Services. A group of candidates
appearing for various posts for the years 1996 and 1997 filed
writ petitions before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.
The High Court in the case of Tutsi Ram and Ors. v. State of U.
P & Ors. [Writ Petition N0.40849 of 1977] while dealing with
the case of 1996 batch was pleased to decide the issue with
regard to the eligibility criteria. Aggrieved thereby, a number of
special leave petitions were preferred by the candidates before this Court.
3. The writ petition filed by the petitioners for the posts of
Principals and Senior Lecturers was dismissed by the High
Court with a short order which reads as under:"The facts ofthe case are covered by the judgment of this
Court in Tulsi Ram and others vs. State of U.P. & Others
in Writ Petition No. 40849 of 1997 decided on 13.5.98.
The writ petition is disposed of on same condition and
direction as in aforesaid judgment."
H
4. The judgment in Tulsi Ram's case (supra) was chal- .
lenged before this Court in a group of matters. By an order made
/
..
217
ANIL KUMAR SHAH! & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
v>-
on 10.01.2001 in Civil Appeal Nos. 961-962/1999, Civil Appeal No. 1124 of 2000 filed by the present petitioners, was
delinked from the said group of matters.
A
5. In Civil Appeal Nos. 961-962/1999, titled Mohd. A/tat &
Ors. v. Public Service Commission & Anr this Court decided
B
the question of law that was raised in the aforesaid case of
Tutsi Ram. The controversy in Tutsi Ram's case centered round
the interpretation of the eligibility criteria for holding the posts.
The eligibility criteria as advertised/notified read as under:
c
~
-,...!
"(3) For the Post of Principal, Government Inter College
(Boys/Girls) and Senior Lecturer in District Education and
Training Institute - (1) Post Graduate degree from a
recognised university or any degree equivalent thereto
recognised by the Government. (2) L.T. Diploma from
Education Department of U.P. or B.T. or B.Ed. or any other D
degree of University equivalent thereto. (3) At least three
years' of teaching experience as head of any Senior
Secondary or normal School or three years experience of
or normal School or three years experience of teaching
Intermediate or higher classes or in C.T. or L.T. Training
E
Post Graduate College as lecturer."
6. It was the case of the petitioners before the High Court
that experience contemplated by the above-said eligibility criteria No. 3 was not restricted to teaching in Government schools,
while the UP Public Service Commission was of the view that F
the teaching experience could be counted only if it was in a
Government School. This controversy was resolved and settled
finally by this Court in Mohd. Altaf's case (supra) by holding that
the Lecturers having three years teaching experience in CT/LT
colleges in Training Colleges were also eligible, since the Rules G
nowhere prescribed that teaching experience should be that of
a teacher in Government College or aided or unaided Government College or institution. Further, it was observed that teaching experience may be from any Higher Secondary School or
High School or from an institute having Intermediate or Higher H
.z218
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
Classes. Having laid down the law, the UPPSC was directed to
implement and carry out the directions of the High Court and
prepare a list of eligible teachers for being appointed to the
post advertised within a stipulated period. After the list was prepared in accordance with the directions given by this Court on
March 14, 2001, the appeals came up for hearing and disposed
of by a final order made on 20th February, 2002 and in the coneluding paragraph of the order, it is said:-
--4.""
'~
"Lastly, it is clarified that the directions issued by this Court
on 10.1.2001 as well as today would be implemented in
favour of all the eligible candidates."
~
It was observed in the order dated 10.01.2001 :-
D
E
F
G
H
"The aforesaid direction is to be considered in the light of
the discussion in the judgment, which specifically provides
that if the teachers who have been substantively appointed
in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the
Regulations framed thereunder are not paid the salary
from the public treasury as those institutions were not given
maintenance grant/grant-in-aid it cannot be blamed for
the lapse on the part of the State Government and such
teacher cannot be excluded for being considered to be
appointed. The learned counsel for the parties have
pointed that most of the matters filed by the teachers are
with regard to this clause. It is their contention that if this
direction as explained in the body of this judgment stands
implemented most of the matters may not survive."
7. The petitioners thereafter made an application, IA No.
4 of 2003 before this Court placing on record the various orders passed in Mohd. Aitaf's case with a prayer that their appeals be also allowed in terms of the orders of this Court dated
10.01.2001 and 20.02.2002 made in C.A. Nos. 961-962/1999
and for consequential directions as prayed for by them. While
opposing the prayer made in IA No. 4, the UPPSC filed a counter
affidavit in which they have raised a fresh issue that the petitioners were not included in the list of successful candidates
)..
. I-
>---
,,...
'
/
t--~
~
219
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
because they had failed to qualify the written examination and, A
therefore, there was no occasion at all to call the unqualified
candidates for interview. This stand, however, has been denied
by the petitioners in the rejoinder affidavit, wherein it is pointed
out that the UPPSC had wrongly included the names of the candid ates in the select list, who were originally not even notified in B
the Official Gazette Notification. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, this Court on March 07, 2006 held:"In our view, it is not open to the respondents to raise a
fresh controversy on facts before this Court for the first
time. We are informed, and it is not disputed before us,
that the respondents did not file a counter affidavit before
the High Court opposing the averments made in the writ
petition, nor have they done so before us. The new case
sought to be set out, about the appellants not having been
qualified in the main examination, appears for the first
time in reply to IA 4. Since there has been no investigation
of facts in this case, we decline to entertain this controversy.
_,..
c
D
In the result, the appeal is allowed to the extent of directing
the respondents to implement the orders in Mohd Aftaf E
dated 10.01.2001 and 20.2.2002 (C.A. Nos. 961-962/
1999) and apply the same eligibility criteria as decided
by this Court in the aforesaid orders to the case of the
appellants. If it is the case of the respondents that the
appellants did not qualify in the main examination and,
F
therefore, they were not called for the interview, it is open
to the respondents to pass appropriate orders giving the
reason as to why the case of the appellants has not been
considered and disclose the· marks obtained by them as
well as cut-off marks beyond which the candidates were
called for interview. It will be equally open to the appellants G
to challenge such an order, if passed by the UPPSC.
The learned counsel appearing for the UPPSC states that
they have already filed a list of candidates whose cases
had been considered pursuant to the direction of this Court.
H
220
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008) 11 S.C.R.
...i._.,.-
A
B
As indicated earlier, this controversy being raised for the
first time before this Court, we decline to go into it and
leave it open.
Since the matter has been considerably delayed, the
respondents are directed to pass appropriate orders and
communicate them to the appellants within a period of
four weeks from today.
'r
I
)._
The appeal is accordingly allowed with no order as to
costs."
c
D
E
F
8. It appears from the record that in compliance with the
above-extracted order of this Court, the contesting respondents
took some decision, which according to the petitioners, is manifestly in violation of the tenor and spirit of the order of this Court.
In this petition, it is stated that the respondents for the first time
in their Office Order dated 7.4 2006 took a different stand, which
reads as under:"Because during the relevant time according to experience
contemplated by the eligibility criterion No. 3 as set by the
Commission, the petitioners were' found ineligible,
therefore they were not called for interview and in view of
the observations ma.de by Hon'ble Supreme Court in order
dated 20.2.2002, the order dated 10.1.2000 and
20.2.2002 are applicable to those candidates who had
appeared in the interview. Therefore in the expressed
situation; it has been decided by the Hon'ble Commission
that in view of the order dated 20.2.2002 passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court it is impossible to call the
candidates for interview."
9. It is further stated that in view of the above stand of the
respondents, it is clear that the respondents are guilty of wilful
and deliberate contempt of this Court as they are time and again
changing stands, so as to misguide this Court and are not disclosing the marks obtained by the petitioners, as well as cut-off
H marks beyond which the candidates were called for interview
G
~
)..._-
...
)..
.l
221
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
despite unambiguous directions passed by this Court. It is also A
stated that this is not the first time when the respondents are
deliberately flouting and circumventing the orders passed by
this Court. This Court in its earlier judgment dated 28.11.2001
passed in the case of Mohd. A/tat (supra) while dealing with
similar situation was pleased to record and observe as under:- B
".... It appears that the UPPSC is interested in suppressing
some facts from the court as well as from the candidates
who appeared in the examinations for some ulterior
purpose. From a constitutional functionary like Public
Service Commissions much higher standards are
expected not only by the Courts but also by the Public at
large. If there is a mal-administrations at the level of Public
Service Commissions there would be rampant favoritism
in making appointments to the service of the state. Despite
our various orders making abundantly clear, today also D
the affidavit which is filed on behalf of the UPPSC is not
complete and contains half truth ...... In our view, this is an
absurd stand because it is the duty of the Public Service
Commissions to declare on the Notice Board result
indicating marks with all other relevant details. In such E
examinations transparency is expected and results cannot
be kept secret. ... Here also the UPP SC wants to play
with the court ..... The Chairman and the Secretary of the
UPPSC are directed to deposits with the registry cost of
10,000/- each for wasting the court time. Such costs shall F
be paid by the concerned personally and not by the
Commission."
c
)
--~
10. It is further the case of the petitioners that the conduct
of the contending respondents speaks of bias and mala tides
on their part and they on one pretext or the other have tried to G
exclude the petitioners from their lawful claim of appointment.
11. The contempt petition was listed before this Court on
8.5.2006 when this Court passed the following order:''Issue notice returnable in the month of July, 2006.
H
222
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
~-
Mr. Shail Kumar Dwivedi, the learned counsel, appears
and accepts notice for U.P. Public Service Commission.
Personal presence of respondent Nos. 1 and 2 is dispensed with for the time being."
B
C
12. The matter came up before this Court on number of
dates and for one reason or the other at the request of the
learned counsel for the U.P. Public Service Gommission and
the State of U.P., the matter continued to be adjourned from
time to time. On 9.3.2007, this Court directed the respondentU.P. Public Service Commission to bring on record the documents showing recommendations by it. Thereafter, it was on
November 14, 2007 that this Court passed the following order:-
,
>--
;
"Put up this matter on 16.11.2007forfurtherhearing at 1.30 p.m.
D
E
On that day the Secretary of the Education Department,
State of U.P. as also the Secretary of the U.P. Public
Service Commission shall personally remain present in
the Court with all requisite files.
In the first half, the said documents would be given to the
learned counsel for the petitioners for inspection.
A chart showing the vacancy position as obtaining in the
F
G
H
years 1996, 1997, 1999 shall be separately prepared. A
Chart shall also be prepared showing the filling up of the
vacancies in respect of those years separately including
the fact as to whether any of those posts have been fille.d
up from amongst the reserved category candidates.
It will further be shown as to how and in what manner the
State in spite of order of this Court, directed the vacancies
to be carried forward despite the fact that
recommendations were made for filling up the vacancies
by the Commission.
The list of 443 candidates in whose favour the
recommendations have been made shall be produced
before this Court."
~-
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
223
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
Contempt Petition No. 162 of 2007:
A
13. In this petition, the petitioners inter a/ia pray for the
following reliefs:"(a) initiate contempt proceedings against the
contemnors for their willful disobedience and uphold
the majesty of this Hon'ble Court; and/or
(b)
direct the respondents to recommend the names of
the petitioners in terms of the order dated 9.3.2007;
and/or
B
c
(c)
direct the respondents/U.P. Government that
thereafter to appoint the candidates in order of their
post of preference as was submitted by the
candidates during the mains examination; and/or
(d)
pass such other or further orders as this Hon'ble D
Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances
of the present case."
14. On 16.11.2007, an application for exemption from personal appearance of Dr. (Prof.) Ram Sewak Yadav, Chairman E
of U.P. Public Service Commission and Dr. J.B. Sinha, Secretary U.P. Public Service Commission, was allowed. The matter
was ordered to be listed on 1Oth December, 2007 at 1:30 p.m.
and in the meantime the State of UP was asked to allow the
learned counsel for the petitioners as also the petitioners to F
inspect the record which was produced before this Court on
that day. When the matter was called for hearing on 8.2.2008,
this Court made the following order:"Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned senior counsel handed over
chart to us showing the discrepancies as obtaining in the G
records maintained by the State of Uttar Pradesh and UPPSC.
Mr. H.N. Salve, learned counsel prays for some time to
respond to the said Chart. Mr. Shrish Kumar Misra, learned
counsel also joins Mr. Salve, learned counsel in making
the said prayer.
H
224
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
..
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
-'""' ·~
A
List of 443 candidates for the 1997 batch, as directed, be
furnished to Mr. Colin Gonsalves.
Issue notice on the application for intervention/direction.
B
r-
Personal app~arance of the alleged contemnors is
dispensed witn till further orders.
)._
E
I
Put up after two weeks."
c
D
E
F
G
H
15. Du'ring the pendency of the contempt petitions, I.A.
No. 12 was filed by Mani Ram Singh praying for intervention
and, making oral submissions in regard to his claim for appointrrient against the above said post.' Notice on this application
w~s issued on 8.2.2008. qne application for impleadment in
the contempt peti!ions was filed by Jamna Prasad Gangwar
with a prayer to issue direction to the State of U.P. to appoint
him and other eligible candidates belonging to the reserved
categories of 1996 batch to the posts of Principal of Inter College (Boys/Girls) in the State of U.P. within 15 days and submit
its c~mplianc;e.
16. In reply to the Contempt Petition © No. 91 of 2006
and LA. No.12 of 2008, three sets of separate affidavits were
filed by,the respondents. Prof. Ram Sevak Yadav - respondent
No.1 herein, Chairman _U.P. Public Service Commission,
Allahabad, in his affidavit at the outset, submitted that he has
the highest regards for the orders passed by this Court and he
has taken necessary action in compliance of the order dated
07.03.2006 passed by this Court in C. A. No. 1124 of 2000.
However, in compliance thereto, if there be any kind of discrepancy, bona fide omission or inadvertence in paying due regard
to the order bf this Court, he subrriitted his unconditional and
unqualified apologyforthe same. Further, he submitted that he
shall do everything in due compliance of the orders of this Court
~s may be directed and the Commission being a constitutional
body is duty bound to comply with the orders of this Court. He
also submitted that he being the Chairman of the Commission
has never intended to disobey or to disrespect the orders of
II-
\--;
...
LI'--
r
..._
>---
I
~
-~
r
I
...
)-
..J
225
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
this Court or to do anything, which may amount to contempt of A
the orders of this Court. He submitted that in compliance .of the
orders of this Court, the petitioners made representation to the
Commission and the Commission passed an Office Order on
07.04.2006 on its interpretation of the order dated 20.02.2002
passed by this Court in Civil Appeal Nos. 961-962of1999 titled B
Mohd. Altaf & Ors. v. Public Service Commission & Anr., in
which it was ordered that the orders would be applicable to all
concerned who appeared in interview on the relevant date. As
the petitioners in the present case had not been called for interview till the passing of the order dated.20.02.2002, their case
could not be considered. However, after rejection of the representation of the petitioners, the Commission realised that the
order dated 20.02.2002 should be made applicable to the petitioners due to their higher marks than the cut-off marks. Accordingly, the Commission took necessary steps by deliberat- D
ing upon the whole matter in accordance with the orders dated
10.01.2001, 20.02.2002, 28.11.2002, 28.08.2003 and
07.03.2006 passed by this Court. He submitted that in Contempt Petition No.372 of 2002 in Civil Appeal No.962 of 1999,
Shamim Khanam v. K. B. Pandey and other connected matE
ters, this Court was pleased to consider the cases of all the
candidates who had appeared in the years 1996, 1997 and
1999 Examinations for appointment to the post of Principals in
the Government Colleges. The relevant extract of the directions
contained in the order dated 05.08.2003 reads as under:-
c
,J
F
,..
~
"It is ordered that the candidates who had appeared in the
year 1996, 1997 and 1999 would be considered for
vacancies existing as on 30.06.2003 in accordance with
the merit list prepared of all the eligible candidates for the
various years."
G
17. It is stated that in the said Contempt Petition a
clarificatory order dated 28.08.2003 was passed by this Court,
which reads as under:"It is further made clear that appointment to these 97 posts
H
226
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
4...,,-4'.
A
B
would be after earmarking the reserved categories and
thereafter on the basis of merit list prepared by the U. P.
Public Service Commission for the year 1996 examination.
If other vacancies still remain, appointments would be after
taking into consideration merit list of 1997 examination
and thereafter 1999 examination result."
18. The first respondent further submitted that having regard to the various orders passed by this Court, the Commission had disclosed the marks to the petitioners and subsequently
called them for interview scheduled to be held on 14.07.2006
c in the Office of the Commission at Allahabad. All the petitioners
appeared before the Interview Board of the Commission. The
Commission accordingly revised the Combined Merit List of
PCS Examination-1997 for the category of Principals on
14.07.2006 itself. The placement of the petitioners in the aforeD said Combined Merit List has been stated at SI. Nos. 54, 156,
118 and 104 respectively. The petitioners have been included
in the Eligibility List of 1997 along with other candidates. It is
submitted that the Commission is not in a position to recommend the candidature of the petitioners to the State GovernE ment for the following reasons:(i)
F
(ii)
f
I
l
L
~,I.__
r..._
.~
l
I
~
The order dated 28.08.2003 passed by this Hon'ble
Court requiring the recommendation against the
existing vacancies for the candidates of the 1996
examination first and thereafter for the candidates of
1997 examination.
G
The petitioners belong to 1997 examination and in
absence of vacancies, their candidature cannot be
recommended as directed by this Hon'ble Court vide
order dated 28.08.2003.
H
(iii) - The State Govt. vide its letter dated 11.05.2006
addressed to the Commission had already
communicated that the State Govt. had decided not
to fill up the remaining 45 vacancies on ad-hoc basis.
Even if the State Govt. had permitted to fill up the 45
I
I-
1..-
).. - 4--I
r
r
I
)--
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
227
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
vacancies on ad-hoc basis it would have gone to 70 A
candidates of 1996 examination in terms of the order
passed by this Hon'ble Court on 28.08.2003.
Therefore, in any case, it would not be possible to
make a recommendation in respect of the petitioners
who are eligible candidates of 1997 examination." B
19. Dr. J. B. Sinha, Secretary, UPPSC, filed a separate
affidavit in which he pleaded identical statement as stated by
the Chairman of the Commission. In rejoinder, the petitioners
reiterated the averments made in the Contempt Petition. Dr. J.
B. Sinha, Secretary, UPPSC, in his additional affidavit stated C
that in compliance with the judgment dated 07 .03.2006 passed
by this Court the petitioners were also placed in the list of eligible Teachers for appointments in the revised list drawn on
14.07.2006. A meeting in this regard was held in the Office of
the State Government on 07.03.2007. The State Government·-D
has not appointed all the eligible candidates for the examination held in the year 1996. He submitted that no appointment
has been made from merit list of eligible candidates for 1997
and 1999 examinations, which had been prepared pursuant to
the orders dated 10.01.2001 and 20.02.2002 passed by this E
Court. He also stated that the Commission vide its letter dated
23.03.2007 addressed to the Secretary, Government of U. P.,
sent the revised merit list dated 14.07.2006 as well as Notification of the Commission dated 25.07.2006 for taking necessary
action at State Government level. He also submitted that there F
is no willful disobedience to the judgment/orders of this Court
and he bow down before the majesty of this Court. He tendered
his unconditional apology for any inaction on the part of the
Commission or on his part in-person in understanding the true
meaning of the judgment of this Court. Copies of the revised G
combined merit list of the PCS Examination, 1997 (Main) issued on 14.07.2006 for the posts of Principals along with combined merit list of PCS Examination, 1996 (Main) eligible candidates in terms of order of this Court dated 14.08.2003 are
placed on record.
H
.
).
228
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
--' ~~
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
20. Ms. Gayatri Adult, Deputy Director (Services-I), Directorate of Education, Allahabad, in compliance to the order of
this Court dated 29.08.2007, filed affidavit on behalf of the State
of U. P. and Directorate of Education, Allahabad, (Respondent
Nos. 3 & 4) stating therein that 50 posts of Principals, Government of Inter College (Boys and Girls) and 47 posts of Senior
Lecturers in District Institutes of Education Training were lying
vacant as on 28.08.2003. This Court vide order dated
28.08.2003 was pleased to direct the State of U. P. to fill 52
posts of Principals strictly on the merit list submitted to this Court
and regarding remaining 45 posts, it was ordered to leave the
same to the State Government to fill them on ad-hoc basis. The
Statement Government made appointments of 50 candidates
strictly on the basis of merit list. Two posts of reserved category
could not be filled as no eligible SC candidates were found.
However, the State Government did not make appointments
against the 45 remaining posts as there is no provision for
making appointment on ad-hoc basis in U. P. Educational (General Educational Cadre) Service Rules, 1992. She submitted
that after 27.08.2007, 41 vacancies arose against the posts of
Principals on account of promotion of 4'1 Principals to the post
of District Inspector of Schools and out of 41 posts, 35 posts
are to be filled against the reserved category candidates selected in the year 1996 and the remaining six to clear the backlog posts, are lying vacant. She submitted that out of 47 newly
upgraded posts of Principals in the Colleges, 50% posts of Principals were to be filled by promotion and the remaining 50% by
direct recruitment on the basis of the examination conducted
by the UPPSC. She submitted that as on 28.10.2007 when this
affidavit was filed, there were 29 vacancies of Principals, which
are to be filled by direct recruitment and in addition thereto, 3
posts of Senior Lecturers D.l.E.T. are also lying vacant. Further,
it is submitted that in the year 1997 the State Government sent
requisition for selection of 443 posts of Principals/Senior Leeturers/D.l.E.Ts. and the UPPSC after selecting the candidates,
recommended their names for appointment against the required
443 posts. She also submitted that the National Council for
l,c
,_
)..
~
~
._
I~
~
I
••.
~
)>-
,.
,_
~·
,..
ANIL KUMAR SHAH! & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
229
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
Teachers Education has prescribed new educational qualification for appointment to the post of Senior Lecturers for 0.1.E.T.
and the minimum qualification is M.Ed. which earlier was B.E.d.
,,.
~
A
21. In reply to I.A. No. 12 of 2008, Prof. Ram Sevak Yadav,
Chairman, UPPSC, Allahabad, submitted that the applicantB
Mani Ram Singh is placed at Serial No.75 of the Combined
Merit List of PCS Examination, 1996 (Main) eligible candidates.
The Commission vide its letter 132/9/E-2/97-98 dated
01.10.2003 had sent recommendation of 52 candidates. Further 2 posts of Scheduled Tribe candidates could not be filled
c
as suitable candidates were not available in any of the recruitment years 1996, 1997 and 1999. Later on, the State Government informed the Commission vide its letter No.315/15-1-088(3)/03 dated 05.02.2008 that out of 52 candidates only 46
candidates could get appointment against the posts in question. -Four candidates could not join their place of posting, so D
the State Government decided to fill those four vacancies [2
General + 2 OBC] from the eligibility list of 1996 Examination,
which is under consideration of the Commission. He stated that
as far as 45 unfilled vacancies are concerned, State Government decided vide its letter No.15/24/97-ka-4-06 dated E
11.05.2006 not to fill those vacancies. On similar line, counter
affidavit has been filed by Shri Santosh Kumar Srivastava, Secretary, UPPSC, Allahabad. Along with their affidavits, copy of
confidential letter dated 01.10.2003 written by Shri Pawan
Kumar, Secretary, UPP SC, Lucknow, to the Secretary, Person- F
nel Section-4, Government of U.P., Lucknow, sending recommendations according to the result of 52 vacancies of tne post
of Principals/Senior Lecturers on the basis of merit list of 120 .
new eligible candidates of Principal Examination, 1996, in compliance with the orders of this Court dated 28.08.2003 giving G
details of the division of the vacancies occurred year-wise upto
30.06.2003 and the number of candidates selected in General
and Reserved categories.
22. Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned Senior Advocate-for the
petitioners, contended that the Chairman of UPPSC, the Sec-
H
230
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
A
retary of UPPSC and the Department of Education of the U.P.
Government have willfully and deliberately disobeyed the orders dated 07.03.2006 and 09.03.2007 passed by this Court.
He submitted thc;it despite the order in Mohd. Altaf's case laying down the eligibility criteria, the respondents intentionally reB fused to apply the same criteria as decided by this Court in the
case of the petitioners herein. This Court vioe order dated
07.03.2006 directed that the law laid down in Mohd. Altaf's_case
would apply in the case of the petitioners as well, but the rec spondents firstly took the stand that the petitioners have not
qualified the written examination and later on, they have admitted that the petitioners had qualified in the written examination,
but they had not appeared in the interview. He submitted that at
least the respondents have entirely taken a.new stand that there
o existed no vacancies against which the petitioners could be
appointed. He has brought to our notice the order dated
28.1_1.2001 passed by this Court in Civil Appeal Nos.961-962
of 1999 titled Mohd. A/tat & Ors. v. Public Service Commission & Anr whereunder strictures were passed against UPPSC
E for acting arbitrarily, for showing "rampant favourtism" for taking an "absurd stand" and for "playing with the court by taking
the stand that there are no vacancies." The learned senior counsel has relied upon the statement of the then Education Minister made in the U. P. Legislative Council stating that there were
F 113 vacancies for the year 1996, 164 vacancies for the year
1997 and 90 vacancies for the year 1999 as on 03.03.2005 as
. per Annexure R-3 attached with the rejoinder to contend that
the stand of the respondents that there are no vacancies available against which the petitioners can be appointed, is absoG lutely incorrect and in violation of the order of this Court.
23. In compliance with the order dated 14.11.2007, Mr.
Harish N. Salve, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the Chairman and the Secretary, UPPSC, has placed before
H us Chart showing vacancy position as obtaining in the year 1996,
>, ).
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
231
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
1997 and 1999. The details of 1996, 1997 and 1999 selection A
for the post of Principals in Government Inter Colleges (Boys and
Girls) and for the post of Senior Lecturer in District Education &
Training Institutes before 28.08.2003 are given as under:"Break-up for the year 1996, 1997 and 1999 vacancies
YEAR
VACANCY
POSTS
SELECTED
POSTS
CARRY FORWARD POSTS
216-105 =111
1996
216
105(104+1)
1997
443 (332 + 111)
279(19+124+ 443-279=164
B
c
124+12)
1999
64 General Recrument 54
64-54=10
1999
164 (Special Recruitment) 75
113-75=38
164-51 *
D
=113
=Vide High Court
order in Writ Petition
No. 26986/1998 section
for 51 posts stayed.
Hence, selection for
113 was made.
51*
AFTER 28. 08. 2003:
~ "4
E
F
97 - Vacancies were informed by the Government vide
letter dated 19.09.2003 out of which 50 names were
recommended as per directions of Hon'ble Court in the
order dated 28.08.2003
FRESH ELIGIBILITY LIST AFTER HON'BLE
SURPEME COURT ORDER DATED 28.08.2003.
G
YEAR 1996
List of 120 candidates (pg. 193-197) all categories
H
232
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008) 11 S.C.R.
i) Break-up of 120 candidates
"O
,_
S.No. Requisition
received from ...... (/")
Q)
the Govern- 0 .......
0 ctl
ment
z :S!
-ctl,_
.E c
c
..r: (/")
~ ~
120
-
1
"O
ctl
"O
Q)
"O
Q)
:J
"O
3:
.¥.
u
Q)
(/")
Q)
Q) ......
ctl
:J
"O (/")
co,_ Q)
(/")
(/")
.¥.
,_
ctl
..r: (/")
(.9
ctl
(f) ()
..r: .0
u ·;::
(f) f-
.E
u
Ou
0:::
52
22
Nil
46
Q)
Q)
Q)
Q)
(/")
......
ctl
Q)
YEAR 1997
c
List of 154 candidates (pg. 206-212) all categories
i) ~reak-up of 154 candidates
D
S.No. Requisition
received from ...... (/")
Q)
the Govern- 0 .......
0 ctl
ment
z :S!
-
E
"O
"O
,_
ctl
3:
"O
-ro,_
:J
"O
(/")
.E c
~~
c
..r: (/")
1
2
F
u
Q)
Q)
Q) ......
Q)
.¥.
"O
Q)
ctl
Q)
co,_ Q)
Q)
Q)
(/")
......
ctl
Q)
ctl
(f) ()
..r: .0
u ·;::
(f) f-
..r: (/")
(.9
u
154
121
07
Nil
26
Merit List re- 158
vised
on
14.07.2006
YEAR 1999
125
07
Nil
26
Q)
(/")
.¥.
,_
ctl
(/")
:J
"O (/")
0 u
E
0:::
List of 98 candidates all categories
i) Break-up of 98 candidates
G
S.No. Requisition
received from ...... (/")
Q)
the Govern- 0 .......
0 ctl
ment
z :S!
-
H
1
"O
"O
,_
ctl
3:
"O
-ctl
,_
Q)
c
"O
Q.)
(/")
Q)
Q) ......
..r: (/")
.E c
~ ~
(.9
u ctl
(f) ()
98
53
14
Q)
u
"O
Q.)
:J
.¥.
ctl
"O (/")
Q)
co,_ Q)
(/")
:J
(/")
Q)
Q)
..r: .0 . ..r:
(/")
u ·;::
(f) f-
0 u
Nil
31
......
ctl
(/")
.¥.
,_
ctl
E
Q)
0:::
;~ ~
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
233
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
Note: In compliance of Hon'ble Supreme Court order dated
28.08.2003 only 50 candidates recommended from the
eligible candidates of the year 1996 as per vacancy
informed by State Government on 19.09.2002.
A
Break-up for year 1996 vacancies for the post of Principals
in Government Inter Colleges (Boys & Girls)
B
S.No. Requisition
received from
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z
-
2
Selected
3:
"O
Q)
Q)
"O Q)
"O (/')
c:
.l::
.l:: .c
~a..
<.9
en o en ~ Ou c:::
216
108
104
101
Q)
Q)
::I
(/')
3.
Carry for- 111
ward vacan,
cies
06
(/')
CtS
::I
Q)
ca..... ""(/')(I)
<..> ·c
:5 CtS
46
04
58
03
Nil
Nil
Q) ......
(/')
(..) CtS
+ 1*
)
.:.c::
(..)
"O
-.....CtS
m
enen
...... 0
1
"O
.....
CtS
43
Q)
Q)
(/')
.:.c::
.....
CtS
c
E
Q)
*1
(one)
General General vacancy reserved as
per orders of Hon'ble
High Court of
Subhash Babu Vs.
U.P.P.S.C. & Ors.
04
58
Details of vacancies filled-up by 1997 Examination
D
E
F
Government sends requisition for 548 posts of Principals
in Government Inter Colleges (Boys & Girls) and for the
posf of Sr. Lecturer in District Education & Training
Institutes. Thereafter, Government vide letter no. 1978/151-97-8(2)/95 T.C., dated 05th September, 1997. Informed G
U.P.P.S.C. that 548 posts includes 216 posts for which
requisition has already been sent to the U.P.P.S.C. in 1996
as a result of which only 332 vacancies are available for
1997 Examination and 111 carry forward vacancies of
1996 Examination are available. Details break-up of these H
posts were sent by Government Letter No. 2561/15-1-96-
234
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
8(2)/95, dated 19th August 1996.
Total no. of posts 332 are bifurcated as below:Principals -146 (19 for Plain Cadre+ 127 for Hill Cadre)
Sr. Lecturers-186 (162 for Plain Cadre+ 24 for Hill Cadre)
B
Carry forward vacancies of 1996 Exam. For (Principals)
Hill Cadre - 111 Posts
Total No. of Vacancies (146+186+111)=443 for which
selection was made.
A.
c
D
S.No. Requisition
received from ..,_
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z U)
ro Ci)
0
~Cl..
1
2
19
19
"O
.....
ro
"O
"O
Q)
ro
.....
::I
3:
~
()
Q)
U)
::I
"O
U)
c
Q)
Q) -U)
..r:
Q)
Q)
(9
Cf) ()
Cf)
I-
09
09
04
04
Q)
Q)
"O
..a
u ro ..r:
u ·c
Nil
Nil
ro
co U)
Q)
.....
Q)
..r:
0-
U)
U)
ro
()
~~
.....
ro
E
Q)
a::::
06
06
~
ro
"O.
-ro
.....
Q)
c
Q)
"O
Q)
:5 U)
Q)
"O (/)
.c ..a
u ·c
u ro
(9
Cf) ()
Q)
Cf)
~
()
~
•::I
Q) -U)
..r:
"O
J..
3:
~
Q)
ro
co U)
Q)
.....
Q)
..r:
U)
U)
I-
- ro
Ou
1
2
127
Carry forward 111
vacancies of
1996 exam.
63
06
27
43
02
04
35
58
3
Total
238
69
70
06
93
4
Selected
124
for- 114
Carry
warded vacancies
69
Nil
26
44
01
05
28
65
5
U)
~
Details of 127 Posts for Principals (Hill Cadre)
S.No. Requisition
received from ..,_
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z (/)
ro Ci)
G
H
Selected
B.
E
F
Details of 19 posts for Principals (Plain Cadre)
U)
~
.....
ro
E
Q)
a::::
'
...
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
235
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
~
C.
Details of 162 Posts for Sr. Lecturers (Plain Cadre)
"O
,_
S.No. Requisition
ro
3:
received from
~
"O
"O
(..)
the Govern- 0
Q)
Q)
en
ro
0
en ~
,_
::; en ::J
ca
ment
Q)
z en ,_Q)ro
,_
"O Q) "O en
ro
Q) ......
Q) Q)
Q) en
(ij ii)
c
E
.s::
en .s:: .0 .s:: en
...... 0
Q)
u ro (..) .;:: - ro Q)
Cl) 0
Cl) I0 (..) n:::
~a... (9
A
- -
1
81
34
03
44
2
Selected
124
81
18
Nil
25
3
Carry Forward 38
vacancies
Nil
16
03
19
D.
)
162
B
c
Details of 24 Posts for Sr. Lecturers (Hill Cadre)
S.No. Requisition
received from
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z en
ro ii)
...... 0
~a...
-
1
"O
,_
ro
D
3:
"O
-0
::; en
::J
Q)
ro
.....
Q)
c
-0
Q)
Q) ......
~
(..)
-o en
Q) Q)
.s::
.0
(..) .;::
Cl) I-
ro
..... en
Q)
.s:: en
-0 (..)
ro
Q)
ca enQ)
CJ
.s:: en
u ro
Cl) 0
24
12
05
Nil
07
Q)
2
Selected
12
12
Nil
Nil
Nil
3
Carry Forward 12
vacancies
Nil
05
Nil
07
en
~
,_
ro
E
Q)
n:::
Details of Vacancies filled-up by 1999 Examination
· (Special Recruitment)
E
F
A. Details of 164 Posts for Principals (Plain Cadre)
G
H
236
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
S.No.
I
Q)
......
Q)
..c
CE0
c
·- 0
Q)
-0
......
-
ro
~
-0
0
-ro
E 0
.!!? -o E z (J)
::I Q) Q)
C" > > ro en
0
Q) · - 0
n:: ~ (.'.) ~ CL
164
~..::::
B
1
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
......
~
-0
Q)
(.)
Q)
::I
-0
(J)
co
::I
-0
(J)
Q)
Q)
c
Q)
Q) -(J)
..c
..c ..a
(.'.)
U) l )
U)
0
65
08
Q)
Q)
u ro
Remarks
co (J)Q)
......
Q)
..c
(J)
(J)
u ·c - ro
I- 0 (.)
91
Vide High Court
order in Writ Petition
No.
26986/ 1998 selection for 51
posts stayed.
Hence, selection for 113 was
made.
c
D
B.
Selection for 113 posts:Principals - 63 (Hill Cadre)
Sr. Lecturers-50 (38 for Plain Cadre+ 12 for Hill Cadre)
E
F
i)
Break up for post of Principals - 63 Hill Cadre
S.No. Requisition
received from
(J)
Q)
the Govern- 0 ........
o ro
ment
z~
-
G
H
ro
~
-0
-ro
......
Q)
~
-0
(.)
ro
Q)
Q)
::I
-0
(J)
(J)
Q)
Q) .......
::I
-0
(J)
Q)
Q)
(J)
co Q)
..c ..a
E
I-
0
(3
n::
c
..c
~ ~
U) l )
63
0
24
03
36
Q)
u ro
......
m
(J)
(J)
(.'.)
c
(J)
~
......
Q)
..c
-0
~
1
-0
......
u ·c
U)
........ m
2
Selected
44
0
20
01
23
3
Carry Forward 19
0
04
02
13
Q)
~-
....
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
237
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
i) Break up for post of Sr. Lecturers - 38 PlainCadre
S.No. Requisition
received from ..... (/)
the Govern- 0 . Q)
o ro
ment
z :S!
-
-
1
"'O
A
"'O
'-
"'O
"'O
ro
::; (/)
::::J
Q)
c
0
ro
Q)
Q)
'-
ro
3:
..lo::
"'O Q)
"'O (/)
..c .c
(..) ·;::
(J) I-
Q)
Q)
(/)
CD
(/)
..lo::
'Q)
Q)
(/)
0-
ro
(..)
ro
E
2 c
~~
c:>
Q) ..c
(/)
u ro
(J) 0
38
0
16
03
19
Q)
..c (/)
2
Selected
31
0
12
Nil
19
3
Carry Forward 07
0
04
03
Nil
'-
B
Q)
Cl'.'.
c
i) Break up for post of Principals - 12 Hill Cadre
S.No. Requisition
received from ..... (/)
the Govern- 0 . Q)
o ro
ment
z :S!
-
"'O
"'O
Q)
ro
'-
ro
3:
..lo::
ro
Q)
::::J
(/)
(/)
'-
'Q)
Q)
(/)
..c (/)
0
E
Q)
0
0:::
c
c:>
(J)
0
..c .c
(..) ·;::
(J) I-
12
0
05
Nil
07
Q)
Q)
u ro
"'O (/)
Q)
Q)
..lo::
CD
2 c
~ ~
"'O
::::J
D
(..)
(/)
"'O Q)
Q) -(/)
..c
-
1
"E
ro
2
Selected
Nil
0
Nil
Nil
Nil
3
Carry Forward 12
0
05
Nil
07
ro
Details of vacancies filled-up by 1999 Examination
(General Recruitment)
E
F
Special Selection for 64 posts which are bifurcated as below:-
A. Details of 64 posts for Principals (15 for Plain Cadre
+ 49 for Hill Cadre)
G
H
238
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
i) Break up for post of Principals - 15 for Plain Cadre
S.No. Requisition
received from
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z
....ro
"O
-
B
D
2
Selected
F
G
ro
.....
"O
~
;:j
.:¥:.
"O
(!)
en
"5
u
ro
cn en
..... (!)
© en
.c
_. en
ro
c:
(!) -en
.c
i2
a..0
"O en
(!) (!)
.c .0
(9
(f) ()
(f)
15
08
03
Nil
04
15
08
03
Nil
04
en
(!)
(!)
"O
(!)
u ro
u ·;::
I-
0
(.)
en
.....
ro
E
.:¥:.
(!)
0:::
ii) Break up for post of Principals - 49 for Hill Cadre
"O
.....
S.No. Requisition
ro
received from
~
.:¥:.
"O
"O
0
u
the Governen
~
ro
~
0
.:¥:.
;:j
(() en
;:j en
.....
ment
z en ro.....Q)
(!)
"O (!) "O en
..... en ro
(!) (!)
(!)
(!)
ro en c: .cu enro .cu .0
E
_. en
ro (!)
- o Q)
·;:: .c
(9
(f) u
(f) Ii2 a..
0 u 0:::
-
1
E
~
ro en
1
c
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
49
25
11
01
12
2
Selected
39
24
05
Nil
10
5.
Carry forward
vacancies
10
01
06
01
02
Hon'ble High Court vacated the stay order passed in Writ
Petition No. 26986/1998 on 16.03.2001 as a result of 51
posts which were of Hill Cadre after creation of Uttaranchal
State U.P.P.S.C. unable to fill up the aforesaid vacancies.
U.P. Government vide its letter No. 2513/15-1-200327(40)/02 dated 19th September, 2003 informed that there
are 97 vacancies available till 30th June, 2003. Details cf
abovementioned posts as follows:-
Principals Government Inter College (Boys & Girls) ]
Total Post - 50
H
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM 239
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
A
Sr. Lecturer in Education & Training Institutes:
Total 97 vacancies
Total Post - 47
Principals Government Inter College (Boys & Girls):
Total Post - 50
B
i) Break-up of 50 post for Principals Government Inter
College (Boys & Girls)
S.No. Requisition
received from
the Govern- 0
ci
ment
z en
ca Ci.i
0
~ Cl.
-
"O
,_
ca
-
"O
"O
t>
Q)
Q)
ca
c:o,_ enQ)
~
::s en
"O Q)
::s
-o en
c
Q) -(/)
..c
(.9
(f) (.)
..c .0 ..c en
t> ·;::
- (.)
ca
(f) f- 0
Q)
Q)
u ca
Q)
Q)
Q)
1
50
26 13
02
09
2
48
Selected
Carry Forward 02
vacancies
26 13
Nil
09
Nil Nil
02*
3
c
3:
~
en
Nil
'-
en
,_
~
ca
E
Q)
a::
D
*No ST
can didate was
available
E
Sr. Lecturer in Education & Training Institutes
Total Post - 47
i) Break-up of 47 posts for Sr. Lecturer in Education &
Training Institutes
S.No. Requisition
received from
the Govern- 0
0
ment
z
"O
,_
ctS
-
3:
en
(ij
,_
Q)
"O
"O
::s en
::s
~
Q)
"O Q)
c
Q) ..c
~ 0...
(9
Cf)
47
35 08
ct! (i.i
0
1
F
Q)
t>
en
ca
0
"O
Q) "'
Q)
..c .0
t> ·;::
~
t>
ca
"'ct!
c:o,_ Q)en
~
Q)
E
en
en
..c
_. ca
Cf) f-
0 ()
03
01
G
,_
Q)
a:
H
240
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
2
Selected
02
02
Nil
Nil
Nil
3
Carry Forward 45
vacancies
33
08
03*
01
*No
ST
candidate was
anailable
24. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners contended
that as per the vacancies indicated in the above-stated Chart,
General Category appointments for 1996 batch were overstated and Reserved Category appointments were understated, thus, the seats available to the General Category were
not completely reflected in the said Chart. According to the
petitioners, transfer of Reserved Category candidates getting
age relaxation, lower cut-off marks in Preliminary Examination
and also in Main Examination coupled with fees relaxation
D cannot validly be transferred to General Category. The
petitioners also contended that neither UPPSC nor the Deputy
Director of Education in their affidavits have whispered a word
about any mistake having occurred while giving 548 vacancies
in advertisement issued on 01.01.1997 and the stand now taken
E in the chart that 548 vacancies for 1997 batch was wrongly
published in the advertisement can now be accepted.
c
25. Having gone through the details of vacancies for the
years 1996, 1997 and 1999 for the post of Principals and Senior
Lecturers in District Education & Training Institutes, as shown
F
in the above-extracted Chart, we find that the UPPSC has
satisfactorily explained that the advertisement of 548 posts was
made as per the requisition of the State Government which
numbers were later on found to be wrong, because 216
vacancies which were advertised in 1996 batch, were wrongly
G included in 548. vacancies. The vacant posts for 1997 batch
were only 332 and not 548 and 111 vacancies carried forward
from 1996 batch, the total vacancies in 1997 were 443. The
petitioners also contended that 14 new District Institutes of
Education & Training have come into existence, thus, creating
H 84 more vacancies for the post of Senior Lecturers and the
y
r-
I.-
•
;-~·
I
~
,.._
,.
)I
1-.""
.
'
'
~
F
;...
'
,_ ~
-'.
;.
'I
'· "
....
ANIL KUMAR SHAHI & ORS. v. PROF. RAM
241
SEVAK YADAV & ORS. [LOKESHWAR SINGH PANTA, J.]
petitioners' version is that there are, in all, 180 total vacancies
for General Category (46 unfilled for 1996 batch, 41 from 1997
batch less (requisitioned) and 93 from 1997 batch (persons not
joined). The petitioners have also submitted a chart in which
they have given position of additional seats becoming available
due to various miscellaneous reasons as on date in addition to
the seats which still remained to be filled from the list of
successful/recommended candidates of 1997 batch. As per
the Chart produced before us, the petitioners have stated that
there are as many as 338 total vacancies for general category
available with the State of U.P. against which the four petitioners
who filed Civil Appeal No.1124 of 2000 can be conveniently
adjusted/appointed and the stand of the respondents not
appointing the petitioners against the available posts is wholly
unwarranted and unjustified. We regret our inability to accede to
the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners.
A
B
c
D
26. A cursory glance of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971
and the provisions thereof makes it abundantly clear that the
Act has been brought in the Statute book to define the limit and
powers of certain Courts punishing for contempt of courts and
it has laid down the procedure for exercise of such powers.
Contempt of Court has been defined under Section 2(a) of the E
Act, to mean civil contempt or criminal contempt. 'Civil Contempt' has been defined under Section 2(b) of the Act to mean
'wilful disobedience of any judgment, decree, direction, order,
writ or other process of court of willful breach of undertaking
given to a court.' It is by now well-settled under the Act and un- F
der Article 129 of the Constitution of India that if it is alleged
before this Court that a person has willfully violated its order it
can invoke its jurisdiction under the Act to enquire whether the
allegation is true or not and if found to be true it can punish the
offenders for having committed 'civil contempt' and if need be,
G
can pass consequential orders for enforcement of execution of
the order, as the case may be, for violation of which, the proceeding for contempt was initiated. In other words, while exercising its power under the Act, it is not open to the court to pass
an order, which will materially add to or alter the order for alleged disobedience of which contempt jurisdiction was invoked. H
\
242
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 11 S.C.R.
__..
_,
'
-
A
When the Court directs the authority to consider a matter in
accordance with law, it means that the matter should be considered to the best of understanding by the authority and, therefore, a mere error of judgment with regard to the legal position
cannot constitute contempt of court. There is no willful disobeB dience if best efforts are made to comply with the order.
27. Having considered the entire factual backdrop of the
matter and given our due consideration to the above extracted
various orders passed by this Court in this case and having consid~red the detailed explanations given by the Chairman,
UPPSC, Secretary, UPPSC, and Deputy Director [Education] in
their respective affidavits as noticed above which in our view are
quite satisfactory and further examination of the details of yearwise vacancies position for the posts in question stated in the
above-extracted Chart submitted by the UPPSC, it cannot be
D said that a deliberate circumvention and dubious method was
adopted by the contesting respondents to avoid implementation
of the judg~ents/orders of this Court nor the facts and circumstances me~tioned above would establish that the contesting respondents have willfully or deliberately disobeyed the judgments/
orders of this Court dated 07.03.2006 and 09.03.2007 as alE leged by the petitioners. In terms of the order dated 07 .03.2006,
the respondents have passed an appropriate order which was
communicated to the petitioners. The UPPSC have placed on
record all the relevant documents relating to these proceedings
as directed by this Court in its order dated 09.03.2007.
,.._
c
...
F
28. In the result; there is no merit in these contempt petitions and they are, accordingly, dismissed. We, however, make
it clear that the contesting respondents are not precluded from
considering the legitimate claims ofthe petitioners as well as
the applicants who have filed Interlocutory Applications before
G this Court if they are otherwise eligible in accordance with law.
As no substantive relief, as prayed for by the applicants in their
applications, can be granted to them in these contempt proceedings these applications shall stand disposed of.
H
D.G.
Contempt Petitions dismissed.
~
,_.
....
~~
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org