M/S. GOETZE (INDIA) LTD. versus EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION
Supreme Court of India | Decided 7 July 2008 | [2008] 10 S.C.R. 190 | 2008 INSC 773
Key facts
- Decided
- 7 July 2008
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, P. SATHASIVAM
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8432/2001
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [2008] 10 S.C.R. 190
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 773
Text of the judgment
[2008] 10 S.C.R. 190
A
M/S. GOETZE (INDIA) LTD.
v.
EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION
(Civil Appeal No. 8432 of 2001)
B
JULY 7, 2008
ff
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND P. SATHASIVAM, JJ.]
Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948
s.45(A) - Employer's contribution - Delayed payment
c of - Liability of employer to pay interest - Held: Liability to
pay interest is statutory- There is no power of waiver- Therefore, any question of compromise or settlement, does not
arise-Interest.
The demand raised by the respondent-Corporation
for contribution under the Employees' State Insurance Act,
1948 on the component of efficiency bonus was challenged by the appellant-employer and ultimately the latter agreed to pay and paid the same. Thereafter the Corporation demanded payment of interest on the amount
E
paid belatedly, which was questioned by the appellant in
a writ petition before the High Court. The stand of the
appellant was that the amount was paid under a compromise arrived at between the parties as was apparent from
the order of the ESI Court to the effect that thereafter nothF ing was payable by the appellant. The case of the Corporation was that there was statutory liability to pay the interest and, therefore, there was no question of any compromise to waive the interest. The High Court dismissed
the writ petition. Aggrieved, the employer filed the instant
G appeal.
D
Dismissing the appeal, the court
HELD: 1.1. As there was delay in making the payment of the contribution, the Corporation issued notice
H
190
...y-•
f...-~~
M/S. GOETZE (INDIA) LTD. v. EMPLOYEES STATE
191
INSURANCE CORPORATION [DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
on 29.6.1990 at the first instance. Thereafter the order was A
passed under Section 45(A) of the Employees' State Insurance Act,1948 on 23.7.1992. The same was challenged
before the ESI Court in which an interim stay was granted
on 9.10.1992. During the pendency of the matter there
was re-verification and the quantum payable by the ap- B
pellant was worked out. The liability to pay interest is
statutory. There is no power of waiver. The question of
any compromise or settlement does not really arise.
[Para 6] [194-D-F]
1.2. Even otherwise, the order of the ESI Court re- C
ferred to and relied upon by the appellant is of no assistance in this regard. It only noted statement of the appellant that he had deposited contribution payable. The reference to "no further due" is obviously relatable to the
contribution payable and nothing beyond that. [Para 6] D
[194-F-G]
CIVILAPPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 8432
of 2001
From the final order dated 19/12/2000 of the High Court
of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in C.W.P. No. 13918/
2000
E
M.L. Varma, Meera Mathur and Satya Mitra for the Appellant.
I
- ..-
C.S. Rajan, Annupam Mishra and VJ. Francis for the Respondent.
F
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Dr. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Challenge in this appeal is to
be order passed by a Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana
High Court dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellant.
G
2. Controversy lies within a very narrow compass.
Employees State Insurance Corporation (in short the 'Corporation'), the respondent herein raised a demand for contribu-
H
192
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 10 S.C.R.
·f-...:.
A
s
c
tion under the Employees State Insurance Act, 1948 (in short the
'Act') on the component of efficiency bonus for the period January
1988 to September, 1989 by order dated 23.7.1992. The demand was challenged before the ESI Court under Section 75 of
the Act. Pending the proceedings before the ESI Court, Corporation by letter dated 1.3.1997 asked for production of record for the
purpose of re-verification for the period from 1989 to 1991 and
from 1992 to 1994 to determine the amount payable.
!' ·
The respondent Corporation on re-verification determined
the actual amount payable as follows:
(a) 1/88 to 3/89 as Rs.2,26,454/(b) 4/89 to 3/94 as Rs.5,28,071/Total
D
Rs.7,54,525/-
Appellant agreed to pay the contribution and paid the same
in October/November, 1997.
Appellant took the stand that there was a bonafide dispute about eligibility. Since eligibility to "efficiency bonus" under the scheme was subject to attendance of 50 days in a quarE ter is payable and paid quarterly. Appellant took the stand that it
falls outside the definition of wages under Section 2(22) of the
Act. Appellant took the plea that its stand was supported by a
judgment of this Court in Whirlpool of India Ltd. v. Employees'
State Insurance Corporation [2000(3) SCC 185]. The ESI Court
F disposed of the matter on 6.1.1998 taking note of the stand of
the appellant that it had deposited the definite amount after reverification and the bank guarantee furnished by the appellant
was released. On 11.1.2000 the Corporation wrote a letter to
the appellant demanding payment of interest on the amount paid
G to the Corporation for the period from 1988 to 1994 as covered
by order dated 6.1.1998 and directed payment of interest
amounting to Rs.4,61,825/-. The appellant questioned the demand before .the High Court by filing a writ petition. The
appellant's stand was that a compromise had been arrived at
H as is apparent from the order of the ESI Court to the effect that
>,
1.-
MIS. GOETZE (INDIA) LTD. v. EMPLOYEES STATE
193
INSURANCE CORPORATION [DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
nothing was payable by the appellant. Corporation took the
stand that the liability to pay interest was statutory and, therefore, there could not have any compromise~ In any event the
submission of the appellant that nothing further was payable as
ESI contribution was noted and therefore, the bank guarantee
was released. There was no question of any compromise to
waive the interest which is not statutorily permissible. The High
Court accepted the stand and dismissed the writ petition.
A
B
3. In support of the appeal learned counsel for the appellant
submitted that there was an order of stay and therefore the question of any int~rest does not arise. Further when the counsel for • C
the Corporation himself stated that nothing further was payable,
it clearly indicated that there was a statement on the compromise for waiver of interest. It was pointed out that with a view to
buy peace the appellant had agreed to pay the amount though
this case was clearly covered by Whirlpool's case (supra).
D
-I
\
4. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand
submitted that there is no question of any compromise to waive
interest because the same is statutorily payable. There cannot
be any compromise without any authority when there is no provision for any compromise or statement. It is therefore stated
that the High Court's view is right.
5. In order to appreciate rival submissions it would be necessary to take note of few provisions, Sections 39 and Regulations 31 and 31A reads as follows:
E
F
"Section 39- Contributions
xx
-l
xx
xx
5(a) If any contribution payable under this Act is not paid
by the principal employer on the date on which such
contribution has become due he shall be liable to pay
simple interest at the rate of 12% per annum or at such
higher rate as may be specified in the regulations tiil the
date of its actual payment."
G
H
194
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 10 S.C.R.
"Regulation 31 - Time for payment of contribution
A
An employer who is liable to pay contributions in respect
of any employee shall pqy those contributions within 21
days of the last day of the calendar month in which the
contributions fall due;
. B
Provided that where a factory/establishment is permanently
closed, the employer shall pay contribution on the last day
of its closure."
"Regulation 31A - Interest on contribution due, but not
paid. in time
C
An employer who fails to pay contribution within the periods
specified in regulation 31, shall be liable to pay interest at
the rate of 12% per annum in respect of each day of default
or delay in payment of contribution."
D
::;,.
6. As there was delay in making the payment of the~~ontribution the Corporation had issued notice on.~9.6.199d;~ the
first instance and thereafter the order was pa~sed under Section 45(A) of the Act on 23.7.1992. The sam'ewas challenged
E before the ESI Court in which an interim stay was granted on
9.10.1992. During the pendency of thtatter there was re-verification and the quantum payable b~:~ ·e appellanJ was worked
out. The liability to pay interest is statutory. There is no power of
waiver. The question of any compromise or settlement does
.F not really arise. Even otherwise the''order of the ESI Court referred to and relied upon by the appellant is of no assistance to
the appellant. .It only noted statement of the appellant that he
had deposited contribution payable. The refere.nce to "no further due" ·is obviously rel~table to the contributibn~P,ayable and
nothing beyond that.
G.
7. Above being the position, the app,eal is· sans merit, deserves dismissal, which we direct. There shajl be no order as
to costs.
·Y .. ,
. /.
H
R.P.
'
...
I
>-
...
,;-
y~
\.
t
,!. -~ ·"
,.
'Appeal 'dis~,issed.
fl
'7
~
!-
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org