K. SAGAR, M.D., KIRAN CHIT FUND MUSHEERABAD versus A. BAL REDDY & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 11 June 2008 | [2008] 9 S.C.R. 1129 | 2008 INSC 748
Key facts
- Decided
- 11 June 2008
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, P.P. NAOLEKAR
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1498/2005
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [2008] 9 S.C.R. 1129
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 748
Text of the judgment
[2008] 9 S.C.R. 1129
--
'I'
K. SAGAR, M.D., KIRAN CHIT FUND MUSHEERABAD
v.
A. BAL REDDY & ANR.
(Civil Appeal No. 1498 of 2005)
JUNE 11, 2008
A
B
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND P.P. NAOLEKAR, JJ.]
Consumer Protection Act, 1986:
Jurisdiction - Dispute between Chit Fund and its prized
subscriber - Jurisdiction of Consumer Forums - Held: The
issue of jurisdiction of Consumer Forum in entertaining disputes in question was raised before the State Consumer Commission but it was not considered by it - Revision Petition
dismissed by National Consumer Commission even without
referring its earlier decision on the issue - Hence, the matter D
remitted to State Consumer Commission to decide the issue
relating to jurisdiction.
c
The question which arose for determination before
this Court in this appeal was as to whether the Consumer
Forums have jurisdiction to entertain dispute between the
Chit Fund and its subscriber/subscribers.
-
>-
Appellant-Chit Fund contended that the Consumer
Forums have no jurisdiction to entertain the dispute between a chit fund and one of its prized subscribers or
between the prized subscribers.
E
F
Respondents-subscribers submitted that this issue
was not specifically raised before the Forums below and
therefore should not be entertained.
Partly allowing the appeal, the Court
G
HELD: 1. It is not correct as contended by the respondent No. 1, the subscriber, that the question of jurisdiction was not raised before the Consumer Forums. In
H
1129
1130
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 9 S.C.R.
A fact the State Commission observed that since the respondents before it i.e. functionaries of the chit fund were
not consumers, the issue regarding jurisdiction cannot
be adjudicated in the appeal before it. The National Commission unfortunately does not appear to have referred
B to its earlier decision while dismissing the revision petition. In the aforesaid background, this Court is of the view
that the issue relating to jurisdiction has to be decided by
the forums first. Hence, the impugned order of the National Commission confirming the order passed by the
c State Commission is set aside and the matter is remitted
to the State Commission to consider the question of jurisdiction. (Paras - 7, 8 and 9) [1132-D,E,F & G]
2. It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any
opinion on the merits of the case. (Para - 9) [1133-A]
D
CIVILAPPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1498
of 2005
From the final Order dated 12.4.2004 of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in ReviE sion Petition No. 1227 of 2001
L. Roshmani (for M/s. P.S.N. & Co.) for the Appellant.
A. Bal Reddy Respondent-in Person.
F
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Dr. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Challenge in this appeal is to
the order passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal
.. Commission, New Delhi (in short the 'National Commission').
Before National Commission challenge was to the order passed
G by the Andhra Pradesh State Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission, Hydrabad (in short the 'State Commission'). By
·its order dated 19.6.2001 the State Commission allowed the
appeal filed by the respondent No.1 (hereinafter referred to as
the 'Complainant'). The District Forum II Hyderabad had disH missed the complaint filed by the complainant.
-
'I
K. SAGAR, M.D., KIRAN CHIT FUND MUSHEERABAD 1131
v. A. BAL REDDY [Dr. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
2. Factual scenario giving rise to the revision before the A
National Commission is as follows:
The complainant joined as a member in Chit Fund Co. of
which opposite party No. 1 is the Managing Director and opposite party No. 2 is the manager. The present appellant was running a chit for Rs.1 lakh with monthly p.ayment of Rs.5,000/- for B
20 months in the year 1995. He was a prize bidder subscriber.
He was paid Rs.60,000/- by cheque. The complainant defaulted
after paying for 11 months from January, 1996. When the present
appellant issued a notice to him demanding an amount of
Rs.79,300/-, the complainant replied that out of the chit amount
of Rs. 70,000/-, the present appellant paid only Rs.60,000/- and
the balance of Rs.10,000/-was payable to him with interest and
that since he paid Rs.54,700/- already, he is ready to pay the
balance of Rs.45,300/- in instalments. The complainant appreached the District Forum for a direction to the opposite par- D
ties to pay Rs.14,000/- to him.
c
r
t
"
3. Though the appellant i.e. Kiran Chit Fund accepted membership of the complainant to the Chit Fund, it took the stand
that the prize amount has been paid to M/s Kiwanis Finance
Pvt. Ltd. as per the authorization letter of the complainant an no E
due certificate was also given to the complainant. There was
exchange of affidavits. The District Commission proceeded on
the basis that admittedly the commission was a defaulting prized
subscriber. It also held that there was no scope of taking any
action on the complaint. Accordingly, the complaint was dis- F
missed. In appeal, the State Commission took the view that a
sum of Rs.45,300/- was to be paid to the complainant. It took
the view that whether the chit fund was a consumer cannot be
adjudicated in the appeal. Accordingly the appeal filed by the
complainant was allowed. The National Commission was of the G
view that in the cheque somebody had added some figures but
who did the mischief was not known. However since somebody
has committed the mischief, the revision petitioner before it
cannot be granted any benefit. The revision petition was accordingly dismissed without cost.
H
J
'
1132
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 9 S.C.R.
4. In support of the appeal, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the Consumer Forums have no jurisdiction
to entertain the dispute between a chit fund and one of its prized
subscribers or between the prized subscribers.
5. Strong reliance was placed on a decision of the Na-
B tional Commission in M/s Dwarkadish Chits Pvt. Ltd. and Anr.
vs. Sanju Ram Aggarwal in First Appeal No. 590 of 1992 decided on 131h January, 1995 reported in (1986-96) National
Commission and SC on Consumer Cases 2469(NS).
c
D
E
F
6. Learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 who appeared
in person took the stand that this issue was no specifically raised
before the forums below and therefore should not be entertained.
7. We find that M/s Dwarkadish Chits' case (supra) dealt
with the issue of jurisdiction under the Consumer Protection Act,
1986 (in short the 'Act') as to whether the Consumer Forums
established under the Act have jurisdiction to entertain dispute
between the chit fund and one of its prized subscriber or between the subscribers. It is not correct as contented by the respondent No. 1 that the question of jurisdiction was not raised.
In fact the State Commissioner observed that since the respondents before it i.e. functionaries of the chit fund were not consumers, the issue regarding jurisdiction cannot be adjudicated
in the appeal before it. The National Commissioner unfortunately
does not appear to have referred to its earlier decision while
dismissing the revision petition_
-f
. ,...
8. In the aforesaid background, we are of the view that the
issue relating to jurisdiction has to be decided by the forums
first.
G
H
9. We therefore, set aside the impugned order of the National Commission confirming the order passed by the State
Commission, and remit the matter to the State Commission to
consider the question of jurisdiction. To avoid unnecessary delay
let parties appear before the State Commission without further
y
K. SAGAR, M. D., KIRAN CHIT FUND MUSHEERABAD 1133
v. A. BAL REDDY [Dr. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J.]
Y
notice on ? 1h of July, 2008 so that the date of hearing can be
fixed. We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case. The parties are permitted to produce certified copy of the judgment so that necessary follow up
action can be taken.
A
10. The appeal is allowed to the aforesaid extent with no
order as to costs.
8
S.K.S.
Appeal partly allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org