T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD & ANR. versus T.N .. ELECTRICITY BOARD THOZHILALAR AYKKIYA SANGAM
Supreme Court of India | Decided 14 February 2008 | [2008] 2 S.C.R. 945 | 2008 INSC 194
Key facts
- Decided
- 14 February 2008
- Bench
- A.K. MATHUR, AFTAB ALAM
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1279/2008
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [2008] 2 S.C.R. 945
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 194
Text of the judgment
[2008] 2 S.C.R. 945
T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD & ANR.
A
v.
T.N ..ELECTRICITY BOARD THOZHILALAR AYKKIYA
SANGAM
(Civil Appeal No. 1279 of 2008)
-
~
FEBRUARY 14, 2008
a
(A.K. MATHUR AND AFTAB ALAM, JJ.)
~
Service Law
Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Service Regulations, 1967:
,,.
'•
c
Note-3 - Prescribing criteria of N. T. C. or N.A. C.
Certificate for post of Helper - Further laying down that
"candidates holding N. TC.IN.A. C. recruited as Helper shall
not be eligible for internal selection to post of Junior Assistant
D
and Typist including Steno-typist" - HELD: The TN. Electricity
Board has, on a rational basis, decided to lay down a
qualification for appointment to the post of Helper i.e. NTCI
NAC, and provided a channel of promotion for such persons
to the higher post on technical side - Such provision cannot
be said to be ultra vires Articles 14, 16 and 19(1 )(g) of the E
Constitution - This is a policy decision of Board and it is the
Board who has to decide suitability and channel of promotion
for such post - It is prerogative of Board to decide that what
shall be the channel of promotion for technical and for non
technical persons - Constitution of India - Articles 14, 16 and F
19(1 )(g) - Administrative Law - Policy decision of
administrative authority
P. U. Joshi and Ors: Vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad
and Ors. 2003(2) sec 632 - relied on.
l~
G
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction : Civil Appeal No. 1279 of
2008.
From the final Judgement and Order dated 20/04/2006 of
945
H
946
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008] 2 S.C.R.
the High Court of Judicature at Madras in W.A. No. 1692/1999.
k-
P.H. Parekh, E.R. Kumar, Shakun Sharma,Arjun Garg (for
Mis Parekh And Co.) for the Appellants.
V. Shekhar, Gulnar, G. Umapathy, Rohit Singh and Rakesh
B
K. Sharma for the Respondent.
The following Order of the Court was delivered
,._ "!!-
We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
c
Leave granted.
This appeal by special leave is directed against the order
passed by the Division Bench of the Madras High Court dated
20th April, 2006 whereby the Division Bench has affirmed the
order passed by the learned Single Judge where the learned
D Single Judge has struck down Note 3 of the Tamil Nadu Electricity·
Board Service Regulation, 1967 (hereinafter referred to as the
"Regulations") and directed that all the persons who were
appointed Helpers may be considered for the post of Junior
Assistant and other administrative posts.
E
Aggrieved against the said order of the Division Bench,
the present SpeCial Leave Petition has been filed.
1,
For disposal of this appeal, it is necessary to refer a few
facts:F
Petition No.3314 of 1993 was filed by the Tamil Nadu
Electricity Board Thozhilalar Aykkiya Sangam, represented by
its General Secretary praying that Note 3 of the Regulation may
be declared as ultra vires being violative of Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution.
G
The grievance of the Sangam was that the classification
of candidates, holding l.T.I. Certificates and who have got
National Trade Certificate/National Apprenticeship Certificate
(NTC)/NAC) and recruited as Helpers in Regular Works
Establishment
(REW) as a distinct class is not based on any
I
H
11
..,,
I'...-
\
~,·
--{
T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD & ANR. v. TN. ELECT.
BOARD THOZHILALAR AYKKIYA SANGAM
...._
...
~
, .....
·~
•
-
947
intelligible differentia, which has rational nexus to the objective A
of selection to the post of Junior Assistant/Assessors, etc. It is
also their grievance that in view of the above mentioned Note 3,
the members of their Association are debarred from applying
for the post of Junior Assistant along with other similarly placed
candidates, possessing lesser qualification.
B
It was· also alleged by Electricity Board that the nature of
work and channel of promotions to the Helpers in Regular Works
Establishment is entirely different from that of Junior Assistant/
Typist/Assessors. According to them, the Helpers are utilized
for field work of technical nature and their channel of promotion c
is Wireman, Lineman, Foreman and Junior Engineer whereas,
Junior Assistants are posted for clerical works in office in
Administrative and Accounts Cadre and their channel of
promotion is Assistant, Administrative/Accounts Supervisor and
D
Assistant Administrative Officer/Assistant Accounts Officer.
Therefore, channels of promotions for these Helpers was
in technical side. It was submitted that this was a policy decision
taken by the Board in pursuance of the office order dated 23rd
May, 1986 on recommendations of Government. Henceforth the
post of Helper i.e. Fitter, Turner, Machinist etc. will be recruited E
out of the persons who possess N.T.C. or N.A.C. certificates
awarded by the National Council for Training and Vocational
Trade. Consequent to this resolution of the Board the T.N. Service
Reg_ulations were amended and Note 3 was inserted in those
regulations. Therefore, after the insertion of Note 3 the criteria F
for selection for the post of Helper is that the incumbent should
have the N.T.C. or N.A.C. certificate issued by the National
Council for Training and Vocational Trade and it was also clearly
stipulated in the resolution of the Board dated 23rd May, 1986
that "the candidates holding N.T.C./N.A.C. recruited as Helper G
shall not be eligible for internal selection to the post of Junior
Assistant and Typist including Steno-Typists".
This resolution of the Board was incorporated in the
regulation in the same terms. Note 3 reads as under:-
H
'}948
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008f 2 S.C.R.
"National Trade Certificate/National Apprenticeship
Certificate candidates recruited as Helpers shall not be eligible
for internal selection to the post of Junior Assistants and Typists
including Steno-Typists."
Therefore, this is a matter of policy decision taken by the
Board that henceforth the persons holding N.T.C./N.A.C.
appointed as Helpers will have the channel of promotion to the
technical post and not to the administrative post. It is true that
prior to 1986 the persons who were appointed as Helpers were
also appointed as Junior Assistants and Technicians in the
office. After the decision taken by the Board Helpers have been
appointed who only possess the N.T.C./N.A.C. certificate. The
Board has now channelised the promotions of these persons in
the category of technical posts and not in the administrative
posts.
.lo-
--
~
:1
D
This is a policy decision taken by the Board and it has
been incorporated in service regulation. Therefore, the
candidates were recruited on the post of Helper possessing
this qualification, their channel of promotion is only to technical
post and there cannot be any doubt about it. This was a
E categorical policy decision taken by the Board and therefore,·
the channel of promotion of these persons now will be only to
the technical post and not to the administrative post. Therefore,
this provision which has been made in the service condition
cannot be said to be discriminatory or arbitrary or violative under
F Article 19(1 )(g) in any manner. This is policy decision of the
Board and it is the Board who has to decide that who will be
suitable for the post and what should be the channel of promotion
for such post. It is not for the incumbent serving as a Helper to
insist that the Board should amend the Regulation which suits
G him. It is the prerogative of the Board to decide that what shall
be the channel of promotion for technical and for non technical
persons. In this case the Board has decided on a rational basis
that the· channel of promotion of technical persons will be on
technical side and not on the administrative side.
H
a
)..
'
v·
\
l
-f'
•
T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD & ANR. v. T.N. ELECT.
BOARD THOZHILALAR AYKKIYA SANGAM
--
....
\
~
949
In this connection, our attention was invited to the decision
of this Court in the case of P.U. Joshi and others versus
Accountant General, Ahmadabad and others reported in
2003(2) SCC 632 ~nd this Court has very categorically stated
that "There is no right in any employee of the State to claim that
rules governing conditions of his service should be forever the
same as the one when he entered service for all purposes and
except for ensuring or safeguarding rights or benefits already
earned, acquired or accrued at a particular point of time, a
government servant has no right to challenge the authority of
the State to amend, alter and bring into force new rules relating
to even an existing service."
. Therefore, in this view of the matter that the Board has
decided to lay down a qualification for appointment to the post
of Helper i.e. NTC/NAC and provided a channel of promotion
for such persons to the higher post on technical side, such
provision cannot be said to be ultra vires of Articles 14, 16 and
19(1)(g).
A
B
c
D
Consequently, we allow this appeal, set aside the order of
the learned Single Judge and also the order of the Division Bench.
E
of the High Court.
No order as to costs.
R.P.
)~
Appeal allowed.
F
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org