THE APSRTC, REP. BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER AND ANR. versus M. RAMADEVI AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 25 January 2008 | [2008] 2 S.C.R. 22 | 2008 INSC 101
Key facts
- Decided
- 25 January 2008
- Bench
- ARIJIT PASAYAT*, P. SATHASIVAM
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 682/2008
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [2008] 2 S.C.R. 22
- Neutral citation
- 2008 INSC 101
Text of the judgment
[2008] 2 S.C.R. 22
- -{
-i..
A
THE APSRTC,. REP. BY ITS Gl!NERAL MANAGER
AND ANR.
v.
M. RAMADEVI AND ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 682 of 2008)
B
JANUARY 25, 2008
[DR. ARIJIT PASAYAT AND P. SATHASIVAM, JJ.]
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 -
s. 166:
C
Motor accident - Causing death of employee of
appellant-Corporation - MACT awarded compensation Appeal by Corporation before High Court - Claimants did not
prefer any appeal - High Court, holding that the award passed
by MACT was inadequate, enhanced compensation o Contention of Appellant-corporation that in absence of any
appeal by the claimants, High Court ought not to have
enhanced the compensation amount - Held: Under the Act,
there is no restriction that the MACT!Court cannot award· -,..
compensation amount exceeding the claimed amount E Function of the MACT!Court is to award 'Just" compensation
based on the evidence on record.
Motor accident - Causing death of 40 year old employee
of appellant-Corporation - Computation of compensation Multiplier - Held: Compensation to be awarded by adopting
F multiplier of 10 and not 12 as adopted by both MACT and
High Court.
Respondents filed claim petition under s.166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 seeking compensation for death
of an employee of appellant-Corporation in a motor
G accident. The Claims Tribunal awarded compensation by
taking the age of deceased as 40 years and his salary as
Rs.2,367/- per month and thereafter applying the multiplier
of 12. The Tribunal further awarded an amount of
Rs.20,000/- for non-pecuniary damages and consortium.
H
22
~
-.../.
_,,,_ .
,
THE APSRTC, REP. BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER
~ND ANR. v. M. RAMADEVI AND ORS.
):
'"'
•,
23
The total compensation amount was directed to be paid A
with interest @ 12% p.a. Appellant-Corporation filed
appeal before High Court, but the claimants-Respondents
did not prefer any appeal. The High Court held that the
award passed by the Tribunal was inadequate and
enhanced the compensation amount by taking the B
monthly pay of deceased as Rs.3,536/- and thereafter
adopting the multiplier of 12. The Court affirmed the
additional award of Rs.20,000/- by Tribunal for nonpecuniary damages and consortium but reduced the
interest payable on the total compensation amount from c
12% p.a. to 9% p.a.
The contention of Appellant-corporation is that in
absence of any appeal by the claimants-Respondents, the
High Court ought not to have enhanced the compensation
amount and that the High Court erred in adopting a higher D
multiplier.
___.
...,
~
-4
,.
I
-i
-<
Party allowing the appeal, the Court
HELD: 1. Under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 there is
no restriction that the Tribunal/Court cannot award E
compensation amount exceeding the claimed amount.
The function of the Tribunal/Court is to award "just"
compensation which is reasonable on the basis of
evidence produced on record. As provided under subsection (4) to Section 166 of the Act, even the report F
submitted to the Claims Tribunal under sub-section (6) of
Section 158 can be treated as an application for
compensation under the said Act. [Para 9] [26-C-E]
Nagappa v. Gurdial Singh and Ors. (2003) 2 SCC 27 4 -
~
~
.
r
relied on.
2.1. Considering the figure in Ex.A/7, the monthly
income is taken at Rs.3,000/- and after deducting 1/3rd
therefrom the annual contribution is fixed at Rs.24,000/-.
[Para 11] [26-G]
·G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
24
A
8
[2008] 2 S.C.R.
2.2. Adopting the multiplier of 10, the amount payable
to the claimants comes to Rs.2,40,000/- to that shall be
added the amount of Rs.20,000/- fixed by the Tribunal for
non-pecuniary damages and consortium as there was no
challenge by the Corporation to the award of such
amounts. Therefore, the entitlement of the claimant comes
to Rs.2,60,000/-. The interest rate of 9% fixed by the High
Court does not warrant any interference. [Para 12] [26-H;
27-A-B]
-f
*
'1
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 682
c of 2008.
From the final Judgment and Order dated 27.11.2003 of
the High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad
in Civil Misc. Appeal· No. 784 of 2002.
D
Ms. K. Radha Rani, P. Vijay Kumar and D. Mahesh Babu
for the Appellants.
G.V.R. Choudary and K. Shivraj Chaudhuri for the
Respondents.
E
...
,..
.....
Dr. ARIJIT PASAYAT, J. 1. Leave granted.
2. Challenge in this appeal is to the judgment of the learned
Single Judge of theAndhra Pradesh High Court. The appellantCorporation had filed an appeal before the High Court
F questioning correctness of the award made by the Motor
·Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-1st Addi. District Judge, R.R.
District at Saroornagar, Hyderabad (hereinafter referred to as
the 'Tribunal').
G
H
r-
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
,
,_
-{
'
}•)
3. Background facts are as follows:
A claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 was filed by the respondents claiming compensation
of Rs.5,00,000/- on account of the death of M. Nageshwar Rao
(hereinafter referred to as the 'deceased') in an accident on
18.5.1998. The deceased was working as a driver of the
-..(
I
F
~
f.I
}-THE APSRTC, REP. BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER
AND ANR. v. M. RAMADEVI AND ORS. [PASAYAT, J.]
25
~
•.
{
I
't
~
appellant-Corporation. In the claim petition it was stated that A
the because of the rash and negligent driving of the bus
No.A.P.10 Z 998 belonging to the Corporation which was being
driven in a rash and negligent manner, the deceased lost his
life. It was claimed that the deceased was 38 years of age and
was an employee of the Corporation and was earning salary of B
Rs.4,467.50 p.m. The appellant-Corporation filed its objection
before the Tribunal taking the stand that it was not liable to pay
any compensation. The quantum of salary claimed and the age
was also disputed.
c
--:~
4. The Tribunal obseNed that the age of the deceased
was 40 years of age and he was getting a salary of Rs.4,000/p.m. and after deduction his take home pay was Rs.2,367 /-and
the total emoluments was Rs.3,983/-. Applying the multiplier of
12 the entitlement was fixed at Rs.2, 16,000/-, in addition
Rs.15,000/- for non-pecuniary damages and Rs.5,000/- as D
consortium was awarded. Thus the total compensation awarded
was fixed at Rs.2,46,000/-. The same was directed to be paid
with interest@ 12% p.a.
5. The appellant-Corporation filed appeal before the High
Court. It is to be noted that the claimants did not prefer any
appeal. The High Court held that the award as made was
inadequate and just compensation was not awarded.
)'
r-
E
6. The High Court was of the view that the pay of the
deceased was Rs.3,536/- and not Rs.2,367/- as noted by the
F
Tribunal. Accordingly, it fixed the basic pay of Rs.3,500/- after
deducting 113rd towards the personal expenses. The monthly
contribution was fixed at Rs.2,333/- and the annual contribution
at Rs.27,996/-. The multiplier was taken at 12. Accordingly,
entitlement was fixed at Rs.3,35,952/- to which was added the
G
sum of Rs.20,000/- additionally awarded by the Tribunal.
7. In support of the appeal, learned counsel for the
appellants submitted that when there was no appeal by the
claimants in the appeal filed by the appellant-corporation, the
High Court should not have enhanced the amount. It was also
H
26
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2008) 2 S.C.R.
---+'
--i
A
submitted that the multiplier as adopted was high.
8. Learned counsel for the respondents on the other hand
submitted that there is no embargo on the Tribunal or the High
Court awarding compensation exceeding the amount claimed.
It was also submitted that the interest was reduced to 9% from
B 12% as fixed by the Tribunal. It was, therefore, submitted that
there was no infirmity in the High Court's order.
...
\.
1
9. In Nagappa vs. Gurdial Singh and Ors. (2003 (2) SCC
274) para 21 as follows:
c
"21. For the reasons discussed above, in our view, under
the MV Act, there is no restriction that the Tribunal/court
cannot award compensation amount. exceeding the
claimed amount. The function of the Tribunal/court is to
award "just" compensation which is reasonable on the
basis of evidence produced on record. Further, in such
cases there is no question of claim becoming time-barred
or it cannot be contended that by enhancing the claim
there would be change of cause of action. It is also to be
stated that as provided under sub-section (4) to Section
166, even the report submitted to the Claims Tribunal under
sub-section (6) of Section 158 can be treated as an
application for compensation under the MV Act. If required,
in appropriate cases, the court may permit amendment to
the claim petition."
.
D
E
F
G
10. The other question that remains to be adjudicated is
whether the income has been rightly adopted by the Tribunal
and the High Court was correct and whether the correct multiplier·
was adopted.
11. Considering the figure in the Ex.A/7 the monthly income
taken at Rs.3,000/- after deducting 1;3rct therefrom the annual
contribution is fixed at Rs.24,000/-.
12. Adopting the multiplier of 10, the amount payable to
the claimants comes to Rs.2,40,000/- to that shall be added the
H amount of Rs.20,000/- fixed by the Tribunal for non-pecuniary
J-
,...
',J
-..(
-.(
F
t--
THE APSRTC, REP. BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER
AND ANR. v. M. RAMADEVI AND ORS. [PASAYAT, J.]
27
damages and consortium as there was no challenge by the A
Corporation to the award of such amounts. Therefore, the
entitlement of the claimant comes to Rs.2,60,000/-. The interest
rate of 9% fixed by the High Court does not warrant any
interference. A sum of Rs.2,00,000/- has been deposited by
the Corporation pursuant to the direction given by this Court on s
19.7.2004. Admittedly, the same has been withdrawn by the
claimants. The balance amount shall be deposited by the
appellant-Corporation within six weeks from today. Tribunal shall
fix the terms for withdrawal/deposit of the amount in FDs as
c
deemed appropriate.
13. The appeal is allowed to the aforesaid extent. No costs.
B.B.B.
Appeal partly allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org