ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTD. versus COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE & CUSTOMS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 March 2007 | [2007] 4 S.C.R. 553 | 2007 INSC 352
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 March 2007
- Bench
- S.H. KAPADIA*, B. SUDERSHAN REDDY
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 465/2002
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [2007] 4 S.C.R. 553
- Neutral citation
- 2007 INSC 352
Text of the judgment
ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTD.
A
v.
COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE & CUSTOMS
MARCH 29, 2007
[S. H. KAPADIA AND B. SUDERSHAN REDDY, JJ.]
-...
l'
....
~
Customs Act, 1962--Customs duty-Exemption from-EntitlementExpansion of Fertilizer Project by assessee---Goods imported for such project
entitled to benefit of Project Import Assessment and benefit under Notification
specifying 'nil' rate of duty in respect of goods required for fertilizer plantAssessee seeking 'Essentiality Certificate' in respect of 6 MW Captive Power
Plant as part of the entire capital goods for the project-Sponsoring Ministry
granting the certificate in respect of the Power Plant as well-Revenue
denying the exemption on the Power Plant-Order of Revenue upheld by the
authorities and courts belo~n appeal, held: when the sponsoring Ministry
certifies that such Power Plant was essential for the project, the Revenue
cannot go behind such certificate and deny the benefit ofexemption-Customs
Exemption Notification No. 11197 dated 1.3.1997-Project Import
Regulations-Customs Tariff Act, 1975-Heading 98.01.
B
C
D
Customs Tariff Act, 1975-Heading 98.01-Nature and interpretation
of the Heading-Held: The heading is a specific entry-It is neither general
nor residuary entry-It should be interpreted liberally as it deals with
industrialization-It has to be read in the context of the exemption
Notification-Customs Exemption Notification No. 11197 dated 1.3.1997.
E
Assessee was the manufacturer of fertilizers. It obtained registration
of all its imports required for expansion of its fertilizer project under the
provisions of Project Import Regulations, 1986. The goods imported for such
expansion were entitled to the benefit of Project Import Assessment under
Heading 98.01 of Schedule to Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and also to the benefit
of Customs Exemption Notification No. 11/97 dated 1.3.1997. The Notification
specified nil rate of duty in respect of "goods required for fertilizer plant".
The assessee gave its project report to the sponsoring Ministry under the
Regulations, seeking 'Essentiality Certificate'. It was indicated therein that
for the expansion of the fertilizer project they also needed 6 MW Captive
F
553
G
H
554
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2007) 4 S.C.R.
A Power Plant for continuous flow cf electricity which was required for the
B
C
project. The sponsoring Ministry by the 'Essentiality Certificate'
recommended the Power Plant as part of the entire capital goods required by
the assessee for substantial exapansion of the fertilizer project. Revenue
denied the assessee the benefit of 'nil' duty in respect of the Power Plant and
held the same liable to duty at 20% to 2% and additional duty of 13% holding
that fertilizer project and the Captive Power Plant were two distinct projects
so far as the rate of duty was concerned. All the Authorities below as well as
Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal upheld the view of
the Revenue. Hence the present appeal.
Allowing the appeal, the Court
HELD: 1.1. The assessee had given to the sponsoring Ministry its entire
Project Report. In that they had indicated that for the expansion of the
fertilizer project they needed an extra item of capital goods, namely, 6MW
Captive Power Plant. In their application, the assessee had made it clear that
D the fertilizer project was dependent on continuous flow of electricity, which
could be provided by such Captive Power Plant. Therefore, it was not open to
the Revenue to reject the assessee's case for nil rate of duty on the said item,
particularly when the certificate says so. Essentiality certificate must be
treated as a proof of fulfilment of the eligibility conditions by the. importer
for obtaining the benefit of the exemption notification. The essentiality
E certificate is also a proof that an item like Captive Power Plant in a given
case could be treated as capital goods for the fertilizer project. It would depend
upon the facts of each case. If a project is to be installed in an area where
there is shortage of electricity supply and if the project needs continuous
flow of electricity and if that project is approved by the sponsoring Ministry
p saying that such supply is needed them the Revenue cannot go behind such
certificate and deny the benefit of exemption from payment of duty or deny nil
rate of duty. Once an essentiality certificate was issued by the sponsoring
authority, it was mandatory for the Revenue to register the contract.
[Para 10) (564-G-H; 565-A, B, C, DJ
G
Commissioner of Customs (Imports), Mumbai v. Tullow India Operations
Ltd, [2005] 13 SCC 789 and Asiatic Oxygen Ltd v. Assistant Collector of
Customs, (1992) 57 ELT 563, relied on.
1.2. It cannot be said that the sponsoring Ministry had not applied its
mind to the list appended to the essentiality certificate. All the items in the
H
ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTD.'" COMMNR. OF CENTRAL EXCISE& CUSTOMS [KAPADIA, J.]
555
list annexed to the certificate have been certified and recommended by the
sponsoring Ministry as the entire capital goods required for the substantial
expansion of the fertilizer project. Therefore in this case, 6 MW Captive
Power Plant is one of the items out of 14 items constituting capital goods
required substantial expansion of the fertilizer project, and, therefore, it fell
under serial no. 226(i) as goods required for the fertilizer project entitled to
the benefit of nil rate of duty. (Para 11) (565-E, F; 566-A, BJ
2. Heading 98.01 is a specific entry. It is not a general entry. It is not
a residuary entry. It needs to be liberally interpreted as it deals with
industriali7.ation. It has to be read in the context of the exemption Notification
No. 11/97. (Para 12) (566-C)
A
B
C
Appraiser, Madras Customs v. Tamil Nadu Newsprint Papers Ltd, [1988]
36 ELT 272, relied on.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 465 of2002.
From the final Order No. C-1/3653/WZB/2001 dated 15.11.2001 in Appeal D
No. C/277/01-Bom passed by the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate
Tribunal, West Regional Bench at Mumbai.
K.N. Bhatt, U.A. Rana and Abhishek Rao (for Mis. Gagrat & Co.) for
the Appellants.
·E
K. Radhakrishnan, P. Narasimhan and B. Krishna Prasad for the
Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
KAPADIA, J. l. This statutory appeal is filed by the assessee-Zuari F
Industries Ltd. under section 130 E of the Customs Act, 1962 directed against
Order dated 15.11.2001 passed by Customs, Excise & Gold (Control) Appellate
Tribunal ("CEGAT'') in appeal No. C/277/01-Bom denying the assessee the
benefit of exemption under Notification No. 1111997 dated 1.3.1997. The appeal
involves the issue as to the rate of duty applicable to the imports made for (J
expansion of a Fertiliser Project.
2. Assessee is the manufacturer of fertilizers at their facility at Goa. It
obtained registration of all their imports required for expansion of their fertilizer
project under the provisions of the Project Import Regulations, 1986 (for short
"the PIR"). In respect of the said expansion, the goods imported were entitled
H
556
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2007] 4 S.C.R.
A to the benefit of Project Import Assessment under Heading 98.01 of the
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and correspondingly the company
was entitled to the benefit of customs exemption Notification No. I 1197 dated
1.3.1997. The said notification specified nil rate of duty in respect of"goods
required for fertilizer plant". Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilisers was the duly
constituted Sponsoring Authority under the said PIR. The said Ministry had
issued a certificate dated 22. l 0.1997 (Essentiality Certificate) to the effect that
the import of capital goods for expansion of the fertilizer project stood examined
and the list of goods annexed to the certificate had been attested from the
essentiality angle by the Deputy Secretary to the Government of India. At this
stage, it may be noted that in. their application for issuance of essentiality
certificate, the assessee had stated that on account of load shedding in the
concerned area, a Captive Power Plant was essential for the substantial
expansion of the fertilizer project. By the said essentiality certificate dated
22. l 0.1997, the sponsoring Ministry requested the Customs to exempt the
customs duty on import of equipments by the assessee vide Notification No.
11197. The said certificate indicated vide item nos. 14.a and 14.b, a 6 Mega
Watt Captive Power Plant. The essentiality certificate 'recommended' the said
Captive Power Plant as part of the entire capital goods required by the
assessee-company for substantial expansion of the fertilizer project.
3. As stated above, the dispute which arises in the present case is the
rate of duty applicable to the imports made by the assessee for the fertilizer
project. According to the Department, the goods imported under serial nos.
14.a and 14.b of annexure 'A' to the essentiality certificate did not fall under
serial no. 226(i) of the said notification no. 11197 and, therefore, the assessee
was not entitled to the benefit of nil rate of duty in respect of 6 MW Captive
Power Plant. According to the Department, items 14.a and 14.b fell under serial
no. 226(iii) which statedthat Captive Power Plants of 5 MW or more are liable
to duty at 20% + 2% and additional duty of 13%. By the impugned order of
adjudication, the Adjudicating Authority held that 6 MW Captive Power Plant
imported under Heading 98.01 as part of the fertilizer project, in terms of the
essentiality certificate, cannot be given the benefit of nil rate of duty, which
was available only to fertilizer projects. In other words, according to the
Department, the fertilizer project and the Captive Power Plant are two distinct
and separate projects as far as the rate of duty was concerned. This contention
of the Department has been accepted by all the authorities below. It has been
conftnned even by the CEGAT vide the impugned judgment dated 15 .11.200 l.
4. Heading 98.0l is a specific entry. It is not a general entry. It is not
ZUARIINDUSTRIESLID.". COMMNR.OFCENTRALEXCISE&CUSTOMS[KAPADIA,J.)
~-
557
residuary entry. It finds place in the exemption notification no. 11/97. Project
imports fall under this entry. It is for this reason that Entry 98.01 is said to
be a specific entry.
A
5. We quote hereinbelow the relevant entry of the Notification No. 11/
<J7.
"S
No.
....
226
...
;.
Chapter
or
heading
No. or
subheading
no.
98.01
Description of goods
Standard
rate
Addi.
Duty
rate
Conditi on
No.
B
c
70
Goods required for
i) fertilizer projects;
Nil
Nil
ii) coal mining projects;
2()0/o
Nil
iii) captive power plants
of 5 MW or more;
20%
13%
iv) power generation
projects including gas
turbine power projects
(excluding captive power
plants set up by projects
engaged in activities other
than in power generation);
20%
Nil
v) power transmission
projects of 66 KV and
above;
20%
vi) Other industrial plants
or projects."
200/o
D
E
10%
F
13%
6. We also quote hereinbelow the Essentiality Certificate dated 22.10.1997
along with the attested copy of list of capital goods to be imported for the
expansion of the fertilizer project.
G
-,....
H
558
SUPREME COURT RE?ORTS
A
[2007) 4 S.C.R.
"No. 15027/1197-FP-III
Government of India
Ministry of Chemicals & Fertilisers
Department of Fertilisers.
Dated 22nd October, 1997
B
To
The Assistant Commissioner of Customs, Mormugao, GOA-803
c
Subject: Customs duty exemption for import of capital goods for
substantial expansion of existing NPK Plant by Mis Zuari
Agro Chemicals Ltd. At Zuarinagar, Goa.
Sir,
D
E
I am directed to say that Mis Zuari Agro Chemicals Ltd. has
proposal for the Substantial Expansion of existing NPK. Plant at
Zuarinagar, Goa. To implement the project, they require to import
capital goods. The matter has been examined in the Department. The
list of goods has been attested on essentiality angle by Shri S.
Chandra, Deputy Adviser (F), who is equivalent to the rank of Deputy
Secretary to the Government of India. The attested copy of list of
goods valued at a CIF of US $ 544359.60 +FF 4760042.80 + FM
12764000 (C&F Mumbai) is sent herewith.
2. You are requested to exempt the customs duty on import of
equipments being made by Mis Zuari Agro Chemicals Ltd. under
Custom Notification No. 11/97 dated 01.03.1997.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/(A.K. Sinha)
Development Officer
Tel:3383829
F
G
Encl: Attested list is enclosed.
Copy to: Mis Zuari Agro Chemicals Ltd., 505 Surya Kiran, 19, Kasturba ·
Gandhi Marg, New Delhi-110001
H
Sd/(A.K. Sinha)
Development Officer"
ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTD.''- COMMNR. OFCENlRALEXCISE&CUSTOMS [KAPADIA,J.)
>-
559
"LIST OF GOODS AND SPARES TO BE IMPORTED FOR EXPANSION
OFNPKPLANT
Qty.
S.No. Description
Vendor
I.a)
Mis
3
Yokogawa Nos
Electrical
Corpn,
2-9-32
Nakacho,
MusahinoShi,
Tokyo 180,
Japan
5183.00
- do -
518.30
....
1.b)
2.a)
...
2.b)
3.a)
3.b)
4.a)
~
;.
4.b)
Microprocessor
based Dot
Printing
Recorder with
Battery
backup
Spares for
above.
Current to
Pneumatic
Signal
Converter (l/P
Converted)
Spares for
above
Magnetic
Flow meter
(Remote Type)
Assembly with
Converter &
Signal cable.
Spares for
above.
Vibrating
Screen
complete with
static dust
casting motor
& other
accessories
Spares for
above
- do -
Lot
13
nos.
Total C&F
Price US $
A
Total C&F Total C&F
Price FF
Price FM
(Finish
Marks)
B
c
7582.00
D
758.20
- do - do -
Lot
6
nos.
18026.00
E
1802.60
- do Mis
Chauvin
S.A.,
l3a 25
Rue
Alfred
De Vigny,
BP 242638034
Grenoble,
Cedex
2, France.
- do -
Lot
4 nos.
1076250.00
F
G
l Lot
107625.00
H
560
A
5)
B
5.a)
c
5.b)
5.c)
D
5.d)
5.e)
E
5.f)
6.a)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Centi fugal
Pump with
motor,
flexible
coupling
mounted on
common
frame.
Mis A.R.
Wilfley
and Sons,
Inc Post
Box No.
2330,
Denver,
Coloradi
80201,
U.S.A.
Phosphoric
acid
(H3P04)
supply
pump.
Scrubber
Effluent
Pump
Fummes
Scrubber
Liquor
pump
- do -
Dryer
Scrubber
Liquor
pump
Molten
Urea
pump
Spares
for above
Ammonia
Sparger
F
6.b)
6.c)
G
6.d)
H
6.e)
Dryer
Knocker
Oversize
Crusher
with Motor,
Base frame
and Remote
Control
Scrubber
Liquor
Sprayer
Spares
for above
[2007) 4 S.C.R.
136425.00
--..<:
2 nos.
,.:
- do -
2 nos.
- do -
2 nos.
- do -
2 nos.
- do -
2 nos.
- do -
Lot
Mis Maguin I no.
S.A. 2, Rue'Pierre Semard,
02800
Charmes,
France
5 nos.
- do - do -
2 nos.
- do -
1 no.
- do -
I Lot
..,
13642.50
2313320.00
.,,.
.-1·
:<"
231332.20
l
ZUARIINDUSTRIESLID.r. COMMNR.OFCEN1RALEXCISE&CUSTOMS{KAPADIA,J.)
7.a)
Butyll Rubber
Panels with
Polyster
Polyamide
Carcass
~
91718.00
B
c
Spares for
above.
- do -
1 Lot
9171.80
8.a)
Dryer pipe
Reactor
(Dual pipe
cross Reactor)
Mis Situb 1 no.
S.A.,
76430
Tancarville,
St. RomainDe-Colbose,
B.P. 123,
France
357000.00
8.b)
Spares for
above
- do -
1 Lot
35700.00
9.a)
Link Chain
No. 6859
R with
attachments
Mis
900
Jeffrey
Ft.
Chain
Corporation,
2307
Maden
Drive,
Morristown,
Tennessee
37813,
U.S.A
- do 550
Ft.
-~
..
~
9.b)
-,.....
A
Mis
24
Welby
nos.
S.A.,
Z.I.
Voie
No. 5,
10, Rue
Claude
Chappe,
BP-53,
76302
Sotteville,
Les Routen
Cedex,
France
7.b)
.-'
9.c)
Link Chain
No. 9118
P with
attachments
Link Chain
- do No. 698A
with attachment
561
D
40100.00
F
58150.00
G
1225 170850.00
Ft.
H
562
A
9.d)
9.e)
Sprockets
Spares for
above.
IO.a) Ball Lift
check
valve
B
c 10.b) Spares for
above.
I I.a) Control
Valve
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
- do - do -
8 nos.
Lot
[2007] 4 S.C.R.
-<~
42050.00
31115.00
10 nos.
Mis
Guichon
International
S.A.,
Industrial
Valves, Rue
De ChoudyBP 401,
73104 Ax
Les Bains
Cedex,
France
Lot
- do -
6429.40
Mis
199769.00
64294.00
~
9 nos.
Dresser
Products
Inds. Ltd.,
Division
Masoneilan,
4, Place de
Saverne,
929?1 Paris
La Defense
Cedex,
France.
>-.
)._
E
11.b) Spares for
above.
12.a) Flap
Valve
F
G
H
12.b) Spares for
above.
13.a) Bulk Solid
Recycle
Flow
Measurement
- do -
I Lot
55875.00
Mis
2 nos.
192324.00
Vraco
SA, Zacles
Gatins,
3 AV-Du
Garigiliano,
France,
~
...
- do -
I Lot
Mis
l no.
Ramsey,
Sydney
Office,
Sydney
Box RA,
Teren
Point,
19232.40
16507.00
)f"
ZUARIINDUSTRIESLID.1•. COMMNR.OFCENTRALEXCISE&CUS'IOMS[KAP/.DIA.J.~
13.b) Spares for
above.
14.a) Equipment
for 6 MW
Power Plant
consisting One
(l) Wartsila
Vasa l8V32LN,
Diesel
Generating set
with auxiliary
equipment.
14.b) Spares for
above.
563
A
NSWAustralia
2229
- do -
Lot
Mis
Lot
1650.00
11382000.00
Wartsila
Diesel,
Wartsila
Diesel
Oy., P.O.
Box 252,
Fin-65 l 00,
B
Vaasa,
Finland
- do -
Total without the spares
Total Spares
Total with Spares
l Lot
494873.00
49486.60
544359.60
1382000.00
4294677.00 11382000.00
465365.80
1382000.00
4760042.80 12764000.00
This is to certify that the above goods are most e.ssential for the
substantial expansion of the NPK plant of Zuari Agro Chemicals Ltd.,
at Zuarinagar, Goa and are hence eligible for nil rate of Customs Duty
under Customs Notification No. 11/97 dated 01.03.1997.
For ZUARI AGRO CHEMICALS LTD.
Sd/(Resident Director)
c
D
For ZUARI AGRO CHEMICALS LTD.
Sell
(S.K. Chatterjee)
E
Vice President-Technical"
7. There is no dispute regarding other items mentioned in the list.
Regarding those items, the Department has accepted that they have been
attested by the Sponsoring Ministry. According to the Department, the only
dispute is with regard to the Captive Power Plant. According to the Department,
Captive Power Plant needs to be segregated from the fertilizer project on the
ground that the fertilizer project can work even without the Captive Power
Plant and that the output from the fertilizer project can be produced even
without the Captive Power Plant. According to the Department, the power
plant is a separate project by itself. According to the Department, the power
plant is not a component or an integral part of the fertilizer project. According
to the Department, 6 MW Power Plant consisted of a generating set which
operated on diesel. According to the Department, even if on the technical side
a Captive Power Plant constituted an aid to the working of the fertilizer project
F
G
H
564
A
B
C
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2007) 4 S.C.R.
still for the purposes of chargeability one has to go by the strict interpretation
of the exemption notification no. 11/97 under which the rate of duty is nil for
the fertilizer project whereas it is 20% for the power generation project.
According to the Department, since fertilizer project and power generation
project are two different and independent projects, the assessee was not
entitled to claim nil rate of duty in respect of 6 MW Captive Power Plant.
8. On the other hand, on behalf of the assessee, the case put up before
all the authorities was that, once an Essentiality Certificate was issued by the
Sponsoring Ministry, it was not open to the Revenue to go behind that
certificate. According to the assessee, an essentiality certificate constituted
a proof of fulfilment of the eligibility conditions by the importer for obtaining
the benefit of exemption notification. According to the assessee, project
imports fell under a specific Heading 98.01. According to the assessee, the
import of capital goods indicated in the list annexed to the essentiality
certificate showed that the sponsoring Ministry cleared the project on the
footing that, in this particular case, looking to the ground reality in the area
in which the plant was located, in which there was paucity of electricity, 6MW
Captive Power Plant was an essentiai requirement for expansion of the fertilizer
project. According to the assessee, the essentiality certificate along with the
attested list constituted a proof of the need to expand the fertilizer project and
for that Captive Power Plant was an essential part. According to the assessee,
it was not open to the Revenue to say that the Captive Power Plant was not
an essential requirement for the expansion of the fertilizer project, once an
essentiality certificate stands issued by the sponsoring Ministry. In this
connection, reliance is placed by the assessee on the judgment of this court
in the case of Commissioner of Customs (Imports), Mumbai v. Tullow India
Operations Ltd., reported in [2005] 13 SCC 789. Reliance is also placed by the
assessee on the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Asiatic
Oxygen Ltd. v. Assistant Collector of Customs, reported in 1992 (57) ELT 563.
9. We find merit in this civil appeal filed by the assessee for the
following reasons.
G
H
10. Firstly, on the facts we find that the assessee had given to the
sponsoring Ministry its entire Project Report. In that report they had indicated
that for the expansion of the fertilizer project they needed an extra item of
capital goods, namely, 6MW Captive Power Plant. In their application, the
assessee had made it clear that the fertilizer project was dependant on
continuous flow of electricity, which could be provided by such Captive
Power Plant. Therefore, it was not open to the Revenue to reject the assessee's
-<" •
:A""·
\
-
ZUARIINDUSTRIESLID. v. COMMNR.OFCENTP.ALEXCISE&CUSTOMS [KAPADIA,J.]
"Y-
.
J.
. -'\
565
case for nil rate of duty on the said item, particularly when the certificate says
so. In the judgment of this Court in the case of Tullow India Operations Ltd.
(supra), this Court held that essentiality certificate must be treated as a proof
of fulfilment of the eligibility conditions by the importer for obtaining the
benefit of the exemption notification. We may add that, the essentiality
certificate is also a proof that an item like Captive Power Plant in a given case
could be treated as capital goods for the fertilizer project. It would depend
upon the facts of each case. If a project is to be installed in an area where
there is shortage of electricity supply and if the project needs continuous
flow of electricity and if that project is approved by the sponsoring Ministry
saying that such supply is needed then the Revenue cannot go behind such
certificate and deny the benefit of exemption from payment of duty or deny
nil rate of duty. To the said effect is the judgment of the Calcutta High Court
i~ the case of Asiatic Oxygen Ltd. (supra) in which it was held that the object
behind the specific Heading 98.01 in Customs Tariff Act, 1975 was to promote
industrialization and, therefore, the heading was required to be interpreted
liberally. It was further held that, once an essentiality certificate was issued
by the sponsoring authority, it was mandatory for the Revenue to register the
contract.
A
B
c
D
~-
l>~
~'
t
~
......,,.
11. Secondly, before us, it has been vehemently urged that although the
essentiality certificate stood issued by the sponsoring Ministry, there is nonapplication of mind by that Ministry with regard to the list of items appended
to the certificate. According to the Department, the said list has not been
countersigned by the competent authority in the sponsoring Ministry. We do
not find any merit in the said contention. The list consists of 14 items. The
Department has accepted 13 out of 14 items as capital goods required for the
fertilizer project, therefore, it cannot be said that the sponsoring Ministry had
not applied its mind to the list appended to the essentiality certificate. This
point needs further clarification. The power plant in the conceptual sense or
in the technical sense is certainly different from the fertilizer plant. However,
when we come to Heading 98.01 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, the
assessment is for the Project. As stated above, Heading 98.01 is the specific
entry applicable in the case of the Project Imports. An item like a power plant
could be in ~ given case an independent Plant. Generally, it is a stand-alone
equipment. However, when it becomes a part of the entire Project/System, the
same power plant can also become one of the items of capital goods. The
essentiality certificate given by the sponsoring Ministry has treated Captive
Power Plant, in this case, as "capital goods" along with 13 other items. The
assessee has also treated the Captive Power Plant as one of the capital goods
E
F
G
H
566
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2007) 4 S.C.R.
A required for the expansion of the fertilizer project. In the above circumstances,
B
C
all the items in the list annexed to the certificate have been certified and
recommended by the sponsoring Ministry as the entire capital goods required
for the substantial expansion of the fertilizer project. Therefore, in our view,
the assessee is right in its contention that, in this case, 6 MW Captive Power
Plant is -0ne of the items out of 14 items constituting capital goods required
for the substantial expansion of the fertilizer project, and, therefore, it fell
under serial no. 226(i) as goods required for the fertilizer project entitled to
the benefit of nil rate of duty.
12. Before concluding, we may point out that, on behalf of the
Department, a large number of authorities were cited on interpretation of
entries in the Customs Tariff Act, 1975. It is not necessary to examine those
authorities on interpretation. Suffice it to state that, Heading 98.0 I is a specific
entry. It is not a general entry. It is not a residuary entry. It needs to be
liberally interpreted as it deals with industrialization. It has to be read in the
context of the above Notification No. 11/97.
D
E
p
G
H
13. In the case of Appraiser, Madras Customs v. Tamil Nadu Newsprint
Papers Ltd, reported in (1988) 36 EL T 272 it has been held that Heading 84.66
(now 98.01) is not a residuary heading or a general heading relating to any
class of goods. It is the specific entry introduced with a purpose and it relates
to goods imported for initial setting up of a unit or a substantial expansion
of an existing unit. It was held that when an importer registers a contract
under the specific entry no. 84.66 (now 98.01), all the goods imported by him
under that contract will be subjected to duty only as per that entry and it will
not be open for the Revenue to pick out some of the goods imported under
that contract and impose a different rate of duty on the footing that they are
covered by a different heading. If the conditions prescribed under Heading
84.66 are satisfied, the duty shall be imposed on the goods under the said
Heading 84.66 as if the said goods formed the composite unit. In that case
there was another Heading 84.31 which referred also to 'paper making
machinery'. The Department contended that duty was payable on the said
item under Heading 84.3 l. It was held by Madras High Court that even ifthe
rate of duty under Heading 84.31 was different from the rate of duty under
Heading 84.66, still the rate applicable to the paper making machinery imported
for producing papers under the PIR has to fall under specific Heading 84.66
(now 98.01) and not under Heading 84 .31, even if paper making machinery
came under both the headings. This is because once an item is imported
under Project Imports then that items will fall under the specific entry because
,__
ZUARllNDUSTRIESLTD.1'. COMMNR.OFCENTRALEXCISE&CUSTOMS[KAPADIA.J.]
567
that item is imported as a part of composite unit (see para 10). In our view,
the said judgment of the Madras High Court on interpretation of Heading
98.01 is squarely applicable to the present case, particularly on the
interpretation of the entries in the Customs Tariff Act, 1975.
14. For the above reasons, we set aside the impugned judgment of the
CEGAT dated 15.11.2001 in appeal no. C/277/01-Bom and accordingly the
assessee's appeal stands allowed with no order as to costs.
K.K.T.
Appeal allowed.
A
B
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org