STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS. versus DR. SHRI HARI SHANKAR VAIDHYA AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 7 April 1997 | [1997] 3 S.C.R. 697 | 1997 INSC 386
Key facts
- Decided
- 7 April 1997
- Bench
- K. RAMASWAMY, D.P. WADHWA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2878/1997
- Disposal
- Leave Granted & Disposed off
- Citation
- [1997] 3 S.C.R. 697
- Neutral citation
- 1997 INSC 386
Text of the judgment
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.
v.
DR. SHRI HARi SHANKAR VAIDHYA AND ORS.
A
APRIL 7, 1997
[K. RAMASWAMY AND D.P. WADHWA, JJ.]
B
Service Law :
Maharashtra State Govemment Civil Service (Pension) Rules, 1982:
Teachers working in aided educational institutions like Ayurvedic C
Unani and Homeopathic Colleges-Applicability of the Rules for giving
benefit of Pension and Gratuity Schemes-Government directed to consider
extension of the said benefits to the teachers in a phased manner.
State of Maharashtra v. Manubhai Pragaji Vashi & Ors., (1995) 5 SCC D
730 & State of H.P. v. H.P. State Recognised & Aided Schools Managing
Committees & Ors., [1995) 4 SCC 507, referred to.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 2B78-79
of 1997.
From the Judgment and Order dated 14.6.96 of the Mumbai High
Court in W.P. No. 3508 of 1992.
E
V. Mohta and D.M. Nargolkar for the Appellants.
Dushyant A. Dave and Mrs. M. Karanjawala for the Respondents.
F
The following Order of the Court was delivered :
Leave granted. We have heard learned counsel on both sides.
These appeals by special leave arise from the judgment of the
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court, made on June 14, 1996 in Writ
Petition No. 3508/92 and Writ Petition No. 2645/90.
The admitted position is that the respondents are the teachers working in Ayurvedic, Unani and Homeopathic private aided educational institutions. One of the questions which requires examination is : whether
697
G
H
698
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1997) 3 S.C.R.
A they are eligible for pension and gratuity scheme on par with state Govern-
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
ment Civil Servants under the Maharashtra State Government Civil Service
(Pension) Rules, 1982, (for short, the 'Rules'). Admittedly, per se, the Rules
do not apply to them. Pursuant to the recommend·itions made by UGC,
the Government of Maharashtra by its Resolution dated May 26, 1981 have
adopted the uniform pay-scales being paid to the non-teaching staff and
teachers working in aided educational institutions, i.e. Ayurvedic, Unani
and Homeopathic colleges. By another Resolution dated July 29, 1983, they
extended the benefit to the non-Government organisations on par with the
Government organisations. Since the Government have not extended the
benefit of pension and gratuity scheme, a writ petition was filed in the High
Court in that behalf. The High Court has disposed it of in the impugned
order. Thus, these appeals by special leave.
As regards the grant-in-aid, this is not in controversy and, therefore,
we need not go into the question. The only question is : whether the
respondents are entitled to the pension and gratuity on par with Government servants? Shri Mohta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State,
has contended that in view of the huge financial outlay, the Government
has been, in a phased manner, extending the benefits from time to time
and, therefore, the direction cannot be given to tide down the hands of the
Government to extend all the benefits to all of them at a stretch. Shri D .A.
Dave, learned senior counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, has
contended that when the grant-in-aid and the pension were not being
extended to the teachers working in the private law colleges, the High
Court has given direction to extend the benefit which was affirmed by this
Court in State of Maharashtra v. Ma11ubh_ai Pragaji Vashi & Ors., [1995) 5
SCC 730. Therefore, the same benefit may be extended to them. He also
cited State of H.P. v. H.P. State Recognised & Aided Schools Managing
Committees & Ors., (1995) 4 SCC 507 wherein this Court has directed to
extend grant-in-aid to the private educational institutions, middle-class and
lower middle-class aided schools.
In view of the respective contentions, the only question that arises
for consideration is : whether the High Court would be justified to grant
the pension and gratuity scheme to the teachers working in the Ayurvedic,
U nani and Homeopathic aided institutions. It is seen that pursuant to the
direction issued by this Court, the pension and gratuity scheme were
extended to the Law Colleges from 1995. Whether the scheme could be
699
STATEv. H.S. VAIDHYA
extended or not is a question of an executive policy and the Court would A
not take the responsibility of directing the Government to extend the
policy. Court requires examination as to how tke policy laid down is being
worked out. It is stated that since huge financial outlay is involved in
extending the benefits and the Government is not intending to deny the
benefit to the segment of the teachers, we appreciate the stand taken by
the Government. The Government is, therefore, directed to consider ex- B
tension of the benefit of pension and gratuity scheme to the teachers
working in the Ayurvedic, Unani and Homeopathic aided educational
institutions in a phased manner, as was done with respect to the other aided
institutions.
The appeals are, accordingly, disposed of. No costs.
G.N.
c
Appeals disposed of.
.,.c.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org