T. VENKATA NARAYANA AND ORS, versus SMT. VENKATA SUBBAMMA (DEAD) AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 29 March 1996 | [1996] 3 S.C.R. 1042 | 1996 INSC 461
Key facts
- Decided
- 29 March 1996
- Bench
- K. RAMASWAMY, G.B. PATTANAIK
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7107/1996
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1996] 3 S.C.R. 1042
- Neutral citation
- 1996 INSC 461
Text of the judgment
!'
A
T, VENKATA NARAYANA AND ORS,
v.
SMT. VENKATA SUBBAMMA (DEAD) AND ORS.
MARCH 29, 1996
B
fK. RAMASWAMY AND G.B. PATIANAIK, JJ.j
Evidence Act, 1872:
C
D
E
S.65--Secondary evidence-Suit for injunction by plaintiff restraining
the defendant from alienating the prope1ty--Defendant claiming the suit
property as her absolute estate got under a conzprOn1ise decree between the
pa1ties in an earlier sllit-Pending suit defendant died-Legal representatives
came on record claiming throllgh a Will alleged to have been executed by the
defendant-Tliey alleged that 01igina/ Will had been lost and sougl!t to adduce
seconda1y evidenc~T1ial court refused pennission to adduce seconda1y
evidence-High Court allowed adduction of secondmy evidence-Held, High
·Colat conunitted e1ror of law and ju1isdiction in directing adduction of
secondmy evidence in suit for injunction to prove Will alleged to have been
executed by defendant-Effect of the compromise decree fa the subject matter
of the pending suit-'-Whatever 1ights were available to the defendant thereunder would be available to the legal represe/lfatives-lt would be open to
respondent to establish her rights, if any, under the Wilf-But the trial in the
suit would be li111ited to the jnterpretation of the con1pro1nise decree.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7107 of
1996.
F
From the Judgment and Order dated 5.11.93 of the Andhra Pradesh
High Court in C.R.P. No. 1935 of 1992.
Ms. Gunwant Dara and P. Gaur for the Appellants.
G
P.S. Narasimah and V.G. Pragasam for the Respondents.
The following Order of the Court was delivered :
Leave granted.
H
We have heard the counsel on both sides.
1042
y
T.V. NARAYANAv. VENKATASUBBAMMA
1043
Admittedly, T. Ramesh Chandra Chowdhry and his mother Smt. T. A
Venkata Subbamn1a had a compromise in a suit for partition between
A
"'
them. Compromise decree came to be passed on August 28, 1969 by the
District Court, Khammam. It would appear that thereafter when Smt.
Vcnakata Subbamma was attempting to alienate the properties given to her
under the compromise decree, the appellants filed 0.S. No. 313/89 in the B
Court of the District M unsif at Khammam for a perpetual injunction
restrainng her from alienating the property. The contest in the suit centers
round the question whether Yenkata Subbamma got an absolute estate
under the compromise decree so as to enable her to alienate the properties
to third parties or she had a limited estate thereunder covered under
Section 14(2) of Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Pending suit, she died. C
Respondents have come on record under Order 22 Rule 4 CPC claiming
that Venkata Subbama had executed a Will in her favour. It was also
further contended that she had lost the original will and sought to adduce
secondary evidence under Section 65 of the Evidence Act. The District
Munsif and refused to permit her to adduce secondary evidence. Thereon D
the matter was carried in revision. The High Court of AP. in the impugned
order made in C.R.P. No. 1935/92, dated November 5, 1993 directed
adduction of secondary evidence. Thus, this appeal by special leave.
The only question is ; whether the respondent is entitled to adduce
secondary evidence to prove the alleged will said to have been executed by E
Venkata Subbainma in her favour? The admitted position is that in partition suit, after the Succession Act came into force, namely, August 28, 1969
Venkata Subbamma had compromised with her son and obtained a decree
with convents contained therein. What is the effect of that decree is the
subject matter in the pending suit. Whatever rights that were available to
her thereunder would be available to the respondent who has come on
F
record as leg~l representative. The mere suit for injunction cannot be
converted into a suit for probation of a will whereat the will is to be proved.
If the will is to be proved according to law, it has to be by way of probate
in the court having competency and jurisdiction according to the procedure
provided under the Indian Succession Act. Thal procedure cannot be G
converted in a suit for mere injunction as a probate suit and direct the
parties to adduce evidence, be it primary or secondary evidence as the
circumstances may warrant. The High Court has committed error of law
and jurisdiction in directing adduction of secondary evidence in the suit
for injunction to prove the will alleged to have been executed by Venkata
Subbamma.
H
1044
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1996} 3 S.C.R.
The appeal is accordingly allowed. The order of the High Court is set
aside and that of the District Munsif is confirmed. It would be open to the
respondent to establish her rights, if any under the \vilI, in accordance \vith
law, but the trial in the suit \Vlltild, as state<l earlier, be litnited lo the interpretation of the compromise decree. No costs.
B R.P.
Appeal allowed.
•
"f
~
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org