FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA versus THANESWAR KALITA AND ORS. ETC.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 6 March 1995 | [1995] 2 S.C.R. 516 | 1995 INSC 162
Key facts
- Decided
- 6 March 1995
- Bench
- K. RAMASWAMY, B.L. HANSARIA
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4029/1995
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1995] 2 S.C.R. 516
- Neutral citation
- 1995 INSC 162
Text of the judgment
FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA
A
v.
THANESWAR KALITA AND ORS. ETC.
MARCH 6, 1995
B
[K. RAMASWAMY AND B.L. HANSARIA, JJ.]
Service Law
Seniority-Adhoc appointment-Appointment de hors the Rules-Con-
C tinuance on service for a long time--Regularisation-Adhoc period cannot be
counted towards seniority.
D
The respondents were appointed on adhoc basis de hors the rules.
They continued for a long time due to non-availability of the direct recruit
candidates. In petitions filed by the respondents, the High Court directed
the appellant to treat the entire period of adhoc service of the respondents
on regular basis entitling them to seniority and other benefits. Against the
decision of the High Court appeals were preferred in this Court.
Allowing the appeals, this Court
E
·
F
HELD: 1. If the appointments are not made in accordance with rules,
though the appointees might have continued for a ling time, the entire
period of service would be fortuitous and so would not be counted towards
seniority. The respondents were not promoted according to rules. Though
they have continued for a long time, the entire length of service should be
considered as fortuitous ,and should not be counted towards their
seniority. The High Court, therefore, was clearly in error in directing to
treat their entire service as on regular basis. [517-E-F-518-A]
The Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers' Association and Ors. v. State
G of Maharashtra, AIR (1990) SC 1607, relied on.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 4029-30
of 1995.
H
From the Judgment and Order dated 13.5.1991 and 3.7.9_f--0f the
Assam High Court in C.R. No. 793/89 & 4466 of 1991.
·
516
'
517
F.C.I. v. T.KALITA
A
V.C. Mahajan and K.R. Nagaraja for the Appellant.
r
S.K. Nandy for the Respondents.
The following Order of the Court was delivered :
B
Leave granted.
/
>
....(,
We have heard the counsel on both the sides. These appeals arise
from the orders of the High Court of Guwahati dated 15.5.1991 and
3.7.1992 in Civil Rule Nos. 793/89 & 4466/91. The ·Division Bench of the
High Court directed the appellants to treat the entire period of ad hoc
service of the respondents on regular basis and further declared that they
must be deemed to have been in continued service as Assistant Managers
w.e.f. 30th August, 1973 and are entitled to seniority and also to other
benefits. Calling in question these orders, these appeals have been filed.
c
I
,,
,
/
"'(
--..........
It is not in controversy that the respondents were appointed on ad
hoc basis de hors the rules. In view of the judgment of the Constitution
Bench of this Court in The Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers' Assn. and
Ors. v. State of Maharashtra, AIR (1990) SC 1607 and several decisions
following that, it is settled law that if the appointments are made according
to rules, though initially on ad hoc basis, and are continued for long time,
on regularising the service, the entire period of temporary service would
be counted for seniority. If such appointments are in excess of quota, the
officiating period would not be treated for seniority, as the appointments
then become fortuitous; and the persons appointed in excess of the quota
are not entitled to count the entire period of service for seniority. The
condition precedent being that the appointments are made within quota
and are made in accordance with rules. In other words, if the appointments
were not made in accordance with rules, though the appointees might have
continued for a long time, the entire period of service would be fortuitous
and so would not be counted towards seniority.
In this case, admittedly, the promotion of the respondents was not in
accordance with rules; but they were delayed on ad hoc basis due to the
exigencies of non-availability of the direct candidates. Thereby, it is clear
that the respondents were not promoted according to rules. In other words,
they were promoted de hors the rules. Though they have continued for a
long time, the entire length of service should be considered as fortuitous
D
E
F
G
H
518
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1995) 2 S.C.R.
A and should not be counted towards their seniority. The High Court, therefore, was clearly in error in directing to treat their entire service as on
regular basis.
The appeals are allowed accordingly. It is needless to mention that
from the date of the regularisation to service as per rules, the respondents
B are entitled to all the benefits. It is made clear that by the circulars issued
by the Corporation, the pay drawn by the respondents during this period,
stands protected. No costs.
T.N.A.
Appeals allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org