SUBHASH CHAND JAIN versus 1ST ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE SAHARANPUR AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 24 February 1989 | [1989] 1 S.C.R. 837 | 1989 INSC 71
Key facts
- Decided
- 24 February 1989
- Bench
- R.S. PATHAK*, M.M. DUTT, M.H. KANIA
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1728/1989
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1989] 1 S.C.R. 837
- Neutral citation
- 1989 INSC 71
Text of the judgment
SUBHASH CHAND JAIN
v.
lST ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE
SAHARANPUR AND OTHERS
A
FEBRUARY 24, 1989
r;
B
t
[R.S. PATHAK, CJ, M.M. DUTT AND M.H. KANIA, JJ.]
-~
U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction)
Act, 1972-S.20(4)-Tenant's right to claim relief against eviction on
payment of entire arrears of rent on or before the first date of hearingRequirement of strict compliance.
~
c
j(
•
·+-'
i
Respondent-owners' suit for recovery of arrears of rent was
decreed ex-parte when the appellant-tenant failed to appear in the suit;
however, on a subsequent application made by him the decree was set
aside on 24.3.1977. The appellant made a deposit of Rs.2,912 on
30.5.1977 stating that the said date was the first date of hearing in the
suit. The appellant, who had first stated that he was not obliged to
deposit the entire arrears as they were barred by time, later on prayed
for amendment of his pleadings and sought to deposit the time-barred
arrears on 29.9.1977, but the deposit was actually made on J.10.1977.
The Court allowed the prayer for amendment but the Additional District Judge held that the appellant was liable to be evicted from the
premises since he had failed to deposit the entire arrears on or befo~e
30.8.1977 which was the date of first hearing in the suit in terms of
s. 20(4) of the U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and
Eviction) Act, 1972. The appellant's writ petition challenging the
aforesaid finding was dismissed by the High Court.
Dismissing the appeal,
E
F
,.
__.,
D
HELD: As the suit was in the nature of a small cause suit, and as
the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act did not contemplate the fixation
of any date for settlement of issues, it must be taken that 30.8.1977 was
the date of first hearing in the suit, and inasmuch as the entire amount
due as arrears of rent had not been deposited within time, the High
Court was right in dismissing the Writ Petition. [839D]
G
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1728
of 1989.
From the Judgment and Order dated 15.4.1982 of the Allahabad
837
H
838
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1989] 1 S.C.R.
High Court in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 6324 of 1980.
R.K. Garg, M.K.D. Namboodiri and S. Balakrishnan for the
Appellant.
S.N. Kaicker, Pradeep Kumar Jain for the Respondents.
B
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
PATHAK, CJ Special leave granted.
c
D
E
F
G
H
This tenant's appeal by special leave arises out of a suit for ejectment and recovery of arrears of rent and damages.
The suit was brought by the respondents who claimed that a shop
owned by them had been let to the appellant, that the appellant had
fallen in arrears of rent from 1 February, 1968 and had not paid the
arrears, notwithstanding a notice of demand dated 8 January, 1975
served on the appellant. The suit was decreed ex parte by the Trial
Court and the decree was set aside by the first Appellate Court. In writ
Petition before the High Court, it was urged on behalf of the appellant
that the appellant had deposited the arrears of rent under sub-s. (4) of
s. 20 of the U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent &
Eviction) Act, 1972, and that therefore the Court should have made an
order relieving the appellant against his liability for eviction on the
ground of arrears of rent. The High Court noted that the suit was filed
on 12 February, 1975 and as the appellant did not appear on 4 April,
1975, the day fixed in the summons, the suit proceeded ex parte and
was decreed. The High Court also noticed that upon subsequent application made by the appellant the ex parte decree was set aside on 24
March, 1977, and on 30 May, 1977, the fresh date now fixed, the
appellant made a deposit of Rs.2,912 accompanied by an application
stating that the said date was the first date of hearing and he was
making a deposit of the entire arrears of rent. The appellant first
stated that he was not obliged to deposit the entire arrears of rent as
they were barred by time. However, the appellant prayed for amendment of his pleadings. On 29 September, 1977, the appellant sought to
deposit the time barred arrears also and got the tender passed for that
purpose. In pursuance of the tender the amount was deposited on 1
October, 1977. The amendment application was allowed, but when the
matter came before the learned First Additional District Judge, he
took the view that the appellant had failed to comply with the condilions of sub-s. (4) of s. 20 of the Act. He-held that 30 August, 1977 was
S.C. JAIN v. ADDL. DIST. JUDGE IPATIJAK, CJJ
839
the date of first hearing in the suit within the meaning of sub-s. (4) of A
s. 20. He recorded that the parties did not dispute that the time barred
arrears claimed by the respondents were also required to be deposited
under sub-s. (4) of s. 20. As the time barred arrears had been
deposited by the appellant on 1 October, 1977 only, the High Court
took the view that the entire arrears of rent had not been deposited on
or before the date of first hearing. The High Court declined to go into B
the further question whether the deposits made by the appellant on I
October, 1977 ought to relate back to 29 September, 1977. In the
result the High Court dismissed the Writ Petition.
,We have heard learned counsel for the parties and we see no
reason to take a different view from that adopted by the High Court. C
The High Court was plainly right in holding that 30 August, 1977 was
the date of first hearing in the suit. As the suit was in the nature of a
small cause suit, and as the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act did not
contemplate the fixation of any date for settlement of issues, it must be
taken that 30 August, 1977 was the date of first hearing in the suit, and
inasmuch as the entire amount due as arrears of rent had not been D
deposited within time, the High _Court was right in dismissing the writ
petition".
Accordingly the appeal is dismissed but there is no order as to
costs.
H.L.C.
E
Appeal dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org