HARIDEV MISRA versus JAMUNADAS AGARWAL & ORS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 17 February 1989 | [1989] 1 S.C.R. 756 | 1989 INSC 63
Key facts
- Decided
- 17 February 1989
- Bench
- K. JAGANNATHA SHETTY*, A.M. AHMADI, KULDIP SINGH
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 912/1989
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1989] 1 S.C.R. 756
- Neutral citation
- 1989 INSC 63
Text of the judgment
Jpw‘msk
HARIDEV MISRA
v.
JAMUNADAS AGARWAL & ORS.
FEBRUARY 17, 1989
(K. JAGANNATHA SHE'ITY, A.M. AHMADI AND
KULDIP SINGH, JJ.]
U. P. Urban Building
(Regulation of
Letting Rent and Eviction)
default—
Landlora' raising a new plea that
tenancy was for furnished house—
Whether permissible to raise such
plea.
Act, I972—Secti0ns 3 (i) and 20(2) (a)——Eviction of tenant for
The respondent-landlord filed a suit for eviction of the
appellantstenant from the house in question on the
ground of failure to pay rent
and for realisation of arrears of rent. While the
respondent pleaded
that the rate of rent was Rs.70 per month, the
appellant contended that
it was only Rs.40 and not
Rs.70, and that he was paying Rs.30 per
month for the furniture, provided
by the landlord which he returned
sometime after the tenancy commenced.
The trial court dismissed the suit
‘l
holding that the rate of rent was
m“
Rs.40 per month and, as such, the
appellant was not defaulter. In the
revision filed by the respondent, the Revisional Court held
that the rent
was Rs.70
per month.
The appellant filed a writ petition before the
”\.A"‘
High Court, which
quashed the revisional order and remanded the case for
deciding the
revision petition afresh.Thereafter, the revisional court
again allowed
the revision.
The appellant challenged the revisional order
before the High
Court which dismissed the same.
In the appeal, by special leave, it was contended
on behalf of the
appellant-tenant that in the face of clear admission of the
respondent in
per month, and that the
amount of Rs.70 per month mentioned in the
rent note had been explained in the receipts, to be Rs.40 as house rent and Rs.30 for
1
\
the receipt, the rent of the house was Rs.40
furniture.
On behalf of the respondent, it was contended
756
that the tenancy
.-¢‘~"’~
HARIDEV MISRA v. JAMUNADAS AGARWAL
was
757
for a furnished building and failure to pay a part of the rent, in
of furniture, would attract the provisions of s. 20(2)(a) of
respect
the U.P. Urban Building (Regulation of Letting Rent and Eviction) Act,
1972 and the appellant was liable to be ejected. It was also contended
that the tenancy being of a furnished house the tenant could not under
law, unilaterally surrender part of tenancy.
if
—"
t
Allowing the appeal,
HELD: It was never the case of the respondent at any stage that
furnished house was given on rent to the appellant. In the notice before
filing the suit and in the plaint, it was specifically pleaded that rent of
the house was Rs.70 per month and the tenant was in arrears. In the
written statement, appellant took a clear stand that the rent of the
house was only Rs.40 and Rs.30 was for the furniture, which according
to him, was returned after the commencement of the tenancy. [760C-D]
In the face of clear pleadings on the record, it is impermissible to
raise the plea that the landlord rented a furnished house to the tenant.
It would be contrary to the pleadings. That apart, neither before the
trial court nor before the Revisional Court and not even before the High
Court this plea was raised. [760F]
The trial court relied upon the rent receipts, 39/C and 40/C,
produced by the appellant. It was clearly mentioned in the receipt 39/C
that Rs.40 were towards house rent and Rs.30 towards furniture
charges and Rs.3 towards water and electricity charges. The respondent admitted the contents of the receipt but explained that
Rs.30 towards furniture charges was mentioned at the request of the
tenant. [758G-H]
In the face of the clear admission by, the, respondent in the two
receipts, the finding of the Revisional Court that the monthly rent was
Rs.70 is erroneous. [759D]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 912
of 1989.
.
From the Judgment and Order dated 11.5.1988 of the Allahabad
High Court in Misc. W.P. No. 7886 of 1985.
Yogeshwar Prasad and Mrs. Shobha Dikshit for the Appellant.
758
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
.
[1989] 1 S.C.R.
Satish Chandra and Madan Lokur for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered
KULDIP SINGH, J.
by
Special leave granted.
This appeal arises out of a suit filed by respondent
(plaintiff)
landlord in the Court of Judge, Small Causes,
Gorakhpur, for eviction
of the appellants (defendant) tenant from the house in
question on the
ground of failure to pay the rent and for realisation of arrears'of rent
and electricity charges amounting to Rs.2,560.60. It was
pleaded that
the tenant was to pay a monthly rent of Rs.70
apart from Rs.3 per
month as water and electricity charges and was in arrears since
July,
1979 which he failed to pay. The appellant contested the suit
mainly on
the ground that the rate of rent was not Rs.70
per month but it was
only Rs.40 and besides that he was provided with furniture by the
landlord for which he was paying Rs.30 per month. His case further
was that some time after the
tenancy commenced, he returned the
furniture.
The Judge, Small Causes Court, by his
judgment dated 10th
November, 1983, dismissed the suit holding that the rate of rent was
Rs.40 per month and as such the appellant was riot a defaulter. The
respondent filed a revision which was allowed by the Additional District Judge, Gorakhpur. The Revisional Court held that the rate of
rent was Rs.70 per month. The
appellant filed a writ petition against
the revisional order before the Allahabed
High Court. The High Court
allowed the writ petition, quashed the revisional order and remanded
the case for deciding the revision
petition afresh. Thereafter, the
Revisional Court again allowed the revision and set aside the
judgment of the Trial Court and ordered
ejectment. The appellant again
challenged the revisional order by way of a writ petition before the
Allahabad High Court but the same was dismissed. Hence this
appeal.
The Trial Court primarily relied
upon documents 39/C and 40/C
produced by the defendants. Document 3910 is a receipt by the plaintiff wherein details of Rs.73 are
given. It is clearly mentioned in the
receipt that Rs.40 were towards house rent, Rs.30 towards furniture
charges and Rs.3 water and electricity charges. The plaintiff admitted
the contents of receipt 39/C but he
explained that Rs.30 towards fumiture charges were mentioned at the
request of the defendant. The
plaintiff strongly relied upon the rent note 97/C wherein monthly rent
of the house was mentioned at Rs.70. The Trial Court
rejected the rent
g
Vi ‘r
5
b
759
J.]
HARIDEV MISRA v. JAMUNADAS AGARWAL [SINGH,
the, defendant.
signed by
note on the ground that the same
Court diSmissed the
Trial
the
the
391C,
on
receipt
Basing its findings
on the other hand, found force in the conwas not
suit. The Revisional Court,
the
tention of the plaintiff that the rent note 97/C was signed by
of the plaintiff in
defendant. It was held that the admission, if any,
note 97/C and as such cannot
receipt 39/C is contradicted by the rent
thus differed from
be taken into consideration. The Revisional Court
the Trial Court and ordered ejectment.
Before us, the counsel for the appellant Shri Prasad contends
39/C
that in the face of clear admission of the respondent in the receipt
contends‘that
the rent of the house was Rs.40 per month. He further
been
has
explained by
consideration,
into
taken
if
even
the rent note,
to him Rs.70 per month
and
40/0
According
the receipts 39/C
to be
mentioned in the rent note has been explained in the receipts
the
in
force
find
Rs.40 as house rent and Rs.30 for the furniture. We
the
contention of the learned counsel. In the face of clear admission by
the Revisional'Court to
respondent in the two receipts the finding of
Faced with
the effect that the monthly rent was Rs.70 is erroneous.
the
respondent
this situation Shri Satish Chandra, learned counsel for
Urban Buildings
UP.
the
of
Section
to
attention
our
3(i)
invited
1972 (hereinafter
(Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act,
for a furnished
was
called ‘the Act’) and contends that the tenancy
in
respect of furniture
building and as such failure to pay even Rs.30
the Act and the
would attract the provisions of Section 20(2)(a) of
Section
and
20(2)(a) of
appellant is liable to be ejected. Section 3(i)
the Act are as under:
“Section 3(i) “building’s, means a residential
residential roofed structure and includes—
(i) any land (including any garden), garages
houses, appurtenant to such building;
(ii) any furniture supplied by the landlord
building;
(iii) any fittings and fixtures affixed
to
or
non—
and out-
for use in such
such building for
the more beneficial enjoyment thereof”.
of rent for
“Section 20(2)(a). “that the tenant is in arrears
same to
the
to
failed
has
pay
and
not less than four months,
service
of
date
the
from
month
one
the landlord within
demand.”
of
notice
upon him of a
760
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1989] 1 S.C.R.
Shri Satish Chandra
contends that definition of
building under
Section 3(i) includes
any furniture supplied
the landlord for
such building and as such
by
use in
non—payment of part of the rent meant for
furniture would amount to arrears
of rent and the
appellant having
pay the same is liable to be
In other words, he
ejected.
contends that it was a furnished
house which was let-out to the
failed
to
appel~
proposition of law canvassed
by Shri Satish Chandra on the basis of
Sections 3(i) and
of the Act, but
20(2)(a)
there is no basis for him in
the
present case to advance the
same.
It was never the case of
N .P.V.
Appeal allowed.
the
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org