PHILLIPPA ANNE DUKE versus THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU
Supreme Court of India | Decided 21 May 1982 | [1982] 3 S.C.R. 769 | 1982 INSC 55
Key facts
- Decided
- 21 May 1982
- Bench
- O. CHINNAPPA REDDY*
- Bench size
- 1
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) No. 271/1982
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1982] 3 S.C.R. 769
- Neutral citation
- 1982 INSC 55
Text of the judgment
ae
PHILLIPPA ANNE D
:
UKE
.
प्र
7
.
| THE STATE OF TAMIL
4
NADU& ORS’
|
क्र, 71982...
i
है
elem i,
et
B
| [O. Cumnappa REpp
y, J]
PeConservation offf Forel;Foreign Excha |:
nge and Prevention of Smuggl
ट ing Activit
»
OS. 8 and 77 and Constitution of
india, 1950, Article 22 (5).
Advisory Board—Legal répratehiait
on
detenu—Grant of. Sacility—When arises,
.
|
ies
«
or ‘frriend} i
i
?
oe
:
न
v
wi
Detention order—Representation of the
detenu to the Central Government—
at is—Bout De Papiere to Prime Mintster—Pet
itions memorial to Minister—
Whether statutory representation.
है
न
+
*
The two petitioners who were British nationals and friends and
collabora-
tors in smuggling enterprises were detained under the provis
ions of the Conserva-
“on of Foreign Exchange
and Prevention
of Smuggling
Activities Act 1974
for
smuggling electronic equipment and goods worth several lakhs of tupees in secret
.compartments and hidden cavities of a Mercedez Benz van.
The High Court dismissed their petitions for release from detention,
D
-
~
In their writ petitions under Article 32 it was contended that ; (1) the
representation made by them to the Centra] Government to revoke the orders of
detention as 1008 back as March 1982 remained undisposed of and oa this ground
alone bey were entitled to be
released; (2)
the
Bout De
Papier presented to the
Prime Minister of India during her visit to England pointing out that the order
of detention passed against the petitioners might be lifted and the deteaus be cither released or charged and brought to trial without delay, had not been disthe
नल सन
कपिल मत before
to be represented
bosed of; : and (3) that they bad been denied the rightTe
Advisory
Bourd by ao Advocate or at least by
denied a ceanies
Advisory Board.
to make ao appropriate
Dismissing the petitions,
Mae
tio
and effective representation to the
:
G
whatever source aie we
HELD है (1) Representations from
tao
the eon,
of
department
other
€ver officer of one or
fepresentations to the Government under the CO
A.
4
visit to
he Prime Minister during her
to the
(2) The Bout De Papier eT tedes
d to the External Affairs Minist ry by
Britain and the subsequent reminder q
FR
H
‘
~
770
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1982] 3 s.c.p.
?
the British High Commission are not representations to the Central Government,
They were merely diplomatic communications between the Governments of the
two countries which will be answered through appropriate diplomatic channels in
proper time.
Such diplomatic communications between one country and another
cannot be treated as representations to the statutory
the COFEPOSA.
3(i)
_
[771 G-H; 772 A-E]
The Advisory Board consisting
authorities functioning under
*
of three
Judges of the High Court
considered it unnecessary and inadvisable to allow legal representation to the
That was a matter for decision of the Advisory Board and this Court
detenus.
its judgment
in place of the
Boards judg-
gt
i
ee
0००
would not be justified to substitute
ment, [774 C]
(ii) A ‘friendly’ representation would have been provided by the Board
had it been demanded. But it was not for the Advisory Board to offer ‘friendly’
representation to the detenus without being asked for. [774 D-E]
In the instant case the order of detention made on January 7, 1982 was
considered by the Advisory Board on February 8, 1982 and its report showed
that the detention was justified. [775 C-D]
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION; Writ Petition (Criminal) Nos. 27!-272
of 1982.
(Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India)
Ram Jethmalani and Miss Rani
Jethmalani
for the
Petitioner. |
R.K. Garg and A.V. Rangam, for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered
by
_CHINNAPPA Reppy, J. Richard
Beale
and
Paul Duncan
Zawadzki, two British nationals, said to be friends and collabora-
tors in smuggling enterprises are
now under detention
under the’
Provisions of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention
of Smuggling Activities Act, Richard Beale arrived at Madras from
Singapore on December 11, 1981, He brought with hin a Mercedez
Benz van. On examination by the customs authorities. the van was
found
to have
secret compartments
and
hidden cavities:
It was
‘laced and Jined, as it were,
with all manner of electronic equipment
and goods worth several Jak
hs Ms rupees. Richard Beale was interro-
gated and made a statemen
ement.
eed
arrived
meals
in lodia
Pgs sag
was also intero बाद, |
siifaa Hlexi
Pp
ile was arrested and produced before
Magistrate of Madras. His friend and
Zawadzki,
who
had
separately
दि
to contact Richard Beals.
83
6 , laterकमarrested
and produced
before the MetroSgistrate. Orders of detention under the COFEPOSA
—
.
79)
PHILLIPPA ANNE ४, TAMIL NADU (Chinnoppa Reddy, 2)
were made
against both of them on January 7, 1982 and grounds
High Court
of Tamil
their
applications
oem,
Court
ark,
were
seeking
Constitution,
malant
order.”
and
duly
were
served
on them.
The detenus moved
Nadu for their release
dismissed.
They
Habeas
Corpus
Writs
of
they may
be
have
from detention,
now
come
under Art.
the
but
ms this
32 of the
The two petitions were argued {together by Shri Jethconvenienty
disposed
of by & single
:
The first submission of the learned Counsel was that the
representation made by the detenus to the Central Government to
revoke the orders of detention so long back as March, 1932 remain-
ed
undisposed of
detenus were
my ' attention
Central
till
this day and on that ground alone, the
entitled to be~ released. Shri
Jethmalani drew
099. 11 of the COFEPOSA which enables the
Government
to revoke
or
modify
an order of detention
made by .the
State
Government or its officers and to the
decisions of this Court laying down that delay by the Central
Government im dealing with representations of the detenu would
also
detention
the
entail
invalidating itself. Apart
from the fact
that there is no proper foundation for the submission, Lam not
satisfied that there is any merit in the submission. The Writ
no hint
Petitions were filed on March 12, 1982 and there was then
The counter-affidavit on behalf of the State of
of this submission.
on April 5, 1982, Thereafter, the clerk
filed
Tamil Nadu was
has sworn to an ellidavit
of the learned Counsel for the Petitioners
mentioning the facts giving rise to the present Ppl
the Prime oes ° owe
appears from the affidavit that wheo
cents Pear en a
was recently in Baglaad, 3 pee
delegation
tion
and
accompanying
without
trial of Richard
suggesting
detenus
delay.
er, ©
either
that
Be
the oo
i
Te
ड़
Duncaa Zawadzki
at 1 गहरे! and We
ता डा
com tel
os cant
Commission in
High
aoe ©
released oF charged
bat the British
Hi
al Affairs, Sore a
De Papiere preseated to
appears f
It further
dd
India also 8601
India, aad nae
the pee
iene
pene
ia Britain during her visit to that
ci
to Shri Jethmalapi, the Bout De st gel
uen
in Britaio and the asubseq
"Minister"s delegation sion
see
op
constitute
Commis
High
सात
_
eee
reminder by t eevee Government demanding their rian
tation to the
Saar
no dou
that a
terms of the provisions of the राह सो न nagic
Bout: De Papier and
the reminder,
diplomat
_
OQ
of detention
i
172 -
&
7 # SUPREME COURT REPORTS
पर
[1982] 8.¢ ९.
communications that they are between the Governments of the
‘two countries,
will be attended to and answered through appropriate diplomatic channels in proper time and with necessary.
expedition.
_ But | find it difficult to treat such diplomatic communi-
cations between one country and another as representations to the
statutory
authorities
functioning
under the
COFEPOSA, as
representations. which require
immediate consideration by
the
statutory authorities and which if aot considered immediately, would
entitle the detenus to be set at liberty. Nor is it possible to
treat the countless petitions, memorials and representations which
are everywhere presented to the Prime Minister and other Ministers as statutory appeals or petitions, statutorily obliging them to
consider and dispose of such appeals and petitions in the manner
provided.
Ministers,
by
statute.
No
doubt
as leaders in whom
the Prime
the people
Minister
and other:
have reposed faith and
confidence, will deal with such appeals and petitions with due and
deserved despatch.
But quite obviously that will not be because
hey are discharging statutory obligations.
It is not also possible to
treat representations from whatever source addressed to whomso-
ever officer of one or other department of the Government as a
representation ‘to the Government requiring the appropriate
authority under the COFEPOSA to consider’ the matter.
I do
not consider that the Bout de Papiere presented to the Prime
Minister during her visit to Britain and the subsequent reminder:
addsesed to the External Affairs Ministry
by the British High
Commission are representations to the Central Government which
are required
COFEPOSA
to be dealt with
in the manner provided
¢
by the
It was next submitted by the learned Counsel that the
Chief Minister, who according to the Rules of Business of the
Government of Taniil Nadu, was required to deal with matters
telating to preventive
detention
neither applied his mind
to the
©
making of the orders of detention,
nor ,considered the representation of the detenus himself. The relevait files have been produced
by the learned Counsel for the State of Tamil Nadu and on perusing
them, I find
Counsel. —
¢
Hi
:
no
substance
The submission
which
in
the
was
most
submission
of the
strenuously
Urged
‘learned
by
the
learned counsel was that the detenus had been denied the right to
PHILLIPPA ANNE vy. TAMIL NADU (Chinnappa Reddy, J.)
773
be represented before the Advisory Board by an Advocateor at
least by a friend and that they were thus denied the right to make a
proper and effective representation to the Advisory Board.
was sufficient, said the
learned
Counsel,
to vitiate
This
the detention.
The learned Counsel urgkd that the detenus were foreigh nationals
and they-were under a handicap being ignorant of the laws and
procedurés of this country. To deny legal representation to them
was an unreasonable exercise of the discretion vested in the Advisory ~
Board to permit or not to permit legal representation. According
to the learned Counsel, this was a clear case where legal representation should have been permitted. “In any case, it was urged, the
detenus ought to have been offered at least ‘friendly’ representation,
if not legal representation.
Reliance was placed upon the following
observations of the Constituyjon Bench ia A.K. Roy vy, Union of
India :()
|
“Another aspect of this matter which needs to be
mentioned is that the embargo on the appearance of legal
practitioners should not be extended
so as
to
prevent
the
detenu from being aided or assisted by 4 friend who, in
truth and substance, is not a legal practitioner. Every
person whose interests are adversely affected asa result of
the proceedings which have 8 serious import, is entitled to
be heard in those proceedings and be assisted bya friend.
A detenu, taken straight from his cell to the Board’s room,
may lack the ease and composure to present his point of
view. He may be “tongue-tied, nervous, confused or
wanting in intelligence’ (see Pett v. Greyhound Racing
Association Ltd., 1969,
1 QB 125), and if justice
is to he '
done, he must at least have the help of a friend who can
--
_ assist him to give coherence to his stray and wandering
ideas, Incarceration makes
a man and his thoughts dishe-
velled.
Just as a pergsgn who is dumb ig entitled, as he
must, to be represented by a person who has speech,
even
case is entitled to take the aid and advice of a person
who
80,
a person who finds himself unable
to present
his
own
is better situated to appreciate the facts of the case
and the language of the law. Yt may be that denial of
legal
representation is
(1) ALR. 1982 S.C. 710.
~
not denial
of
natural. justice
©
. ११4
SUPREME COURT REPORTS.
per
se,
and,
therefore,
if a statute
[1988] 3 8.०.४. |
excludes
that
faci-
lity expressly, it would not be open to the Tribunal to allow
it. Fairness, as said-by Lord Denning M.R., in Maynard
v. Osmond [197] 1 QB 240, 253, can be obtained
without
legal,representation.
But, it is not fair, and the statute |
does not exclude that right, that the detenu should not even
” be allowed to take the aid of a friend.
Whenever
the Advisory Boards must grant that facility.”
demanded,
In the present case, the Advisory Board consisting of three
Judges of the High Court of Taniil-Nadu considered it unnecessary
and inadvisable to allow legal
representation to the detenus
It was
a matter for the decision of the Advisory
Board
and-I do not think I will be justified in substituting my judgment in
the place of their judgment.
The detenus were heard personally by
the Advisory Board.
After seeing and hearing them personally also,
the Board did not feel it nécessary- to provide. legal representation
to them which they would certainly have done if they had
thought
.that the detenus appeared to require such representation. Regarding
representation by a friend, there was never any such demand by the
detenus. A ‘friendly’ representation would certainly have been
provided if-it had been so demanded.
It was not. for the Advisory
Board to offer ‘friendly’ representation to the detenus even if the
latter did not ask for it. Relying upon a sentence in the counterAffidavit of Shri Thiru Bhaskaran that representation not only by a
lawyer, but by a friend was also considered not necessary. by the
Advisory Board, it was argued that the Advisory Board had, without
warrant, refused even friendly representation. Shri Thiru Bhaskaran
was speaking for the State of Tamil Nadu and not for the ‘Advisory
Board. I have perused the file of the Advisory Board which was
produced before mé and I have also perused the
communications
addressed by the Advisory Board to the Government of Tami Nadu
and to the detenus. I do not find the slightest hint of a demand 07
‘friendly’
representation or its denial anywhere.
The Advisory
Board was neither asked nor did the Board deny any ‘friendly
representation
A‘charge was made against the Advisory Board that there
inequality of treatment.
It was
said that while.
कि
authority was allowed to be represented by its.officers
the detenus were allowed no
~
representation.
the
was
detaining
and advisers,
There is no substance
PHILLIPPA ANNE y. TAMIL NADU (Chinnappa Reddy, J.)
in this charge.
775
From the affidavit of the Chairman of the Advisory:
Board, I find that all that happened was that some
customs
officers
produce the
perusal
by
_ were allowed to be present in the. corridor'so as to enable them to
Board.
baseless,
The
relevant
files whenever
charge
of inequality
ay
required
of
for
treatment
x
is,
the ~
therefore,
है
Yet another submission of the. learned Counsel was that the
Advisory Board failedto consider the question whether the deten-
tion continued 10 0६. justified on :the date of the reportof the Advi-
sory Board, even if it was justified on the dateof the making of the
order of detention,
The order of detention
was made on 7.1:82 and
the consideration by the Advisory Board was on 8.2.82. The passage
of time was not so long nor had any circumstances intervened to
justify any compartment-wise’ consideration of the justification for
~ the detention on the date of the making of the order of detention
and on the date of the réport of the Advisory Board.
In the
ciscumstances of the case,I think that the report of the Advisory
Board that. there was sufficient cause for ‘the detention of Richard Beale. and
Paui
detention was
Duncan Zawadzki
found by
necessarily
the Board to be justified
implied
that
the
on the date of its
report.as also on the date of the making of the order of detention.
A complaint was also made that the. Advisory Board carried on
its correspondence with the detenus through the Government.” This,
it was stated, gave riseto a suspicion that everything was done by
the Board at the behest or in ‘consultation with the Government.
This complaint is wholly unjustified. As already mentioned by me,
the Advisory Board consisted of three Judges of the High Court of
Tamil Nadu and as explained by the Chairman in his Affidavit, the
correspondence etc. is carried.on through the Government because
the Board has no separate administrative office of its own. All the
points urged on behalf of the detenus fail and the petitions are,
therefore,. dismissed.
_NLV.K,
ह
.
Petitions dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org