LILLY KURIAN versus SR. LEWINA AND ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 15 September 1978 | [1979] 1 S.C.R. 820 | 1978 INSC 175
Key facts
- Decided
- 15 September 1978
- Bench
- Y.V. CHANDRACHUD*, R.S. SARKARIA, N.L. UNTWALIA, A.D. KOSHAL, A.P. SEN
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 728/1975
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1979] 1 S.C.R. 820
- Neutral citation
- 1978 INSC 175
Text of the judgment
. . .. '
sio
•
A
- -- .!
r
:..:
·-·-~·
~
LILLY KURIAN
-- .
,.
v.
0
.•. ' .-.
SR. LEWINA AND ORS.
.'
September 15, 1978
B
;;_·•.• _•
';
~' [¥. 'V. t11ANDRAc11uo, c.J., R. s. SARKARIA, N. L. UNTWALL\,
_; __: : . . .
A. D. KosHAL AND A. P. SEN, 11~1
--
c
. •. ·_o
•
:·
--
- .
-
.
'
.-
.
.
-
•
- .
•
·'
-
••
..
'! !
c.,~onstitution of India-Article 30(1)-Scope a1nbit and n1Jiure of ri§lit" of
linguistic und religiouJ mi1t0ri1ies-Whether regulatory restrictions can be imposetl
-Whai are the litnits.:.....Iriterference l\--·iih ·righ1·10 appoint and dtsniiss- .teaching
~nd otlier staff-1Yhether providing a right of appeal-against dismissal permissible~
The Appellarit Y.'as appointed·as PrinciPal--of uio"Si. Joseph Training ·coueg~
for \Vomen,\Ernakulam ill the Year ·_1957.~ -In~Octobcr~_t969,·there was:'. an
unfortunate lliCiderit bctWcen the Appellant and one.Rajaratnam a·lecturCr Of tlt.C
College" placed on deputation by the Governffi.Cnt. On thC b"asis of complaint'
by. Rajaratnam, the l\fmaging Board initiated disciplinary ·pr6ceedings .agaiJ¥t
the Apf>ellant.and appointed a retired Principal of a College-to be_an inquiry
D Officer. The Appellant did not participate in the proce6dingS. The Inqui_ry
Officer -held the Appellant guilty of. misconduct. A show cause . notice wit.3.
gi.ven to the Appellant. The AppcllMt however, filed a su.it challenging the
Validity of the proce"edings. An interim i.Ojunction was issued by the! Ch.ii Court
restraining the ~tanagement from implementing the decision, if any, taken· fu
the meeting. The l\fanaging Board after due notice to the· Appellant £60.nd
that the charges of misconduct .were proved.· Subsequently, the Court held that
E the dismissal of the Appellant \V<loS legal and proper. During this period theAppellant \\'M functioning as a Principal aD.d had sent two· communications· tO
the Secretary to the Goverfiment calling for termination of" deputation of Rajil~
ratnai:ri."' The ~fainaging Bo<ird vie\\·ed ihe sending Of these communications by
the ·.Appellant without reference to it as an act of insubordination, and there.fore,
decided to conduct inquiry against the Appellant and she -y..·as suspended pending
inquiry. A substitute Principal \Vas appointed. The Appellant filed: an appeal
F against the· Order of suspension and the Vice-Chancellor directed that the status
quo be maintained. The substitute Principal filed a suit for an injunction re:s:training the . appellant from functioning or interfering v.·ith the discharge of
duties of the substitute Principal which was granted by the ~funsif. The. ViCeChancenor by bis orders held that the orders of dismissal and suspension
passed against the Appellant were in breach of natural ju~tice. and fair play
and \Vere conseciuently illegal, null and void. He therefore, ilirected the
G ~fanagement to allow the _Appellant to function as Principal. The Kera-Ia
University Act, 1957 was enacted to reconstitute the University of Travancore
into a teaching University for the \vhole of the State of Kerala. The definifiorr
of "'teacher" in section 2(j) of the Act is wide enough to take in a Principail.
Section 19 empo\\·ers the Syndicate to make ordinances fixing the conditiOD.! of
service of teachers. The Ker.:..Ja University j\ct 1957 \Vas repealed by the Kerala
University Act, 1969. The earlier ordinances h:ive been saved and continued
JI under the new Act. Ordinarnce 33 provides for an appeal to the Vice-Chancellor
against any order passed by the Managemenf in respect of the penalties including
· penalty of dismis•al•
a
•
..
I
L1LtY KURIAN V, tli\ViNA
'
821
. The·Mana~ement filed a .suit in the Munsif's Court. The substitute Pflnoipal
also filed il further suit against the Appellant and the po<;tal authorities for
prohibitin& the postal authorities· from delivering and the Appellant from receiving
the articles addressed to the Principal of the College.
I\
The Trial Coun dismissed the suits holding that the Appellate power con'
ferred on the Vice Chancellor by ordinance framed by the Syndical~ was a valid
confermen~ of power and even after the commencement Of the Kerala University
Act, 1969, both the Vice-Chancellor and Syndicate had cc;>ncurrent powers of
Appeal. It, therefore, upheld the orders of the Vice-Ohancellor directing reinstatement of the Appellant in service. On appeal the District Judge held
that the orders of the Vice-C!llmcellor were perfectly valid and with junsdiction
and that his. direction to· the ManagementJ to continue the Appellant as Prine! raJ
was legal. The Kerala High Court 'reversed the judgment of the Courts below
holding that: the conferment by the Syndicate of the right to appeal to a teacb.:r
against the order of dismissal from service to the Vice-Chancellor cannot be
said to be in excess of the permissible limits of the power to prescribe the duties
and c-onJitions of service of teachers in private colleges in terms of s. 19(j) ot
the Kerala University Act, 1957, and the provisions for a right to appeal were
not violative of the rights guaranteed to the reiigious minorities under Anicte
30(1) and were, therefore, valid. According to the High Court although the
Vice Chancellor had the power to heM" an appeal against an order of dismissal
he did not have expressly or impliedly, the power to order reinstatement or
even to grant a declaration that the services of the appellant bad been wrongly
terminated. It was held that a statutory tribunal like Vice-Choo.ceUor could
not grant such a relief as the same would amount to specifically enforcing tfie
contract of service.
c
E
Disrriissing the appeals the Court,
•
A
HELD : I.' The expression conditions of Service includes everything from the
stage 'of oppointinent to the stage of termination of ser\."ice and even beyond
and relates to matters pertaining to disciplinary action. The High Court thus,
rightly held that the right of the appeal conferred by ordinance 33(4) forms
\,part of the conditions of service and is, therefo:-e, valid. [828F··G, 829A]
,,J · ;,,W.F. Province v. Suraj Narai11 75 I.A. 343, State of U.P. v. Babu Ra1i.< F
1
[1961] Z SCR 679 and State of M.P. and Ors. v. Shardul Singh, [1970] 3 S.CR.
302; relied on.
,
••
2. Protection of the minorities is an article of faith in the Constitution of
India. The right is subject to the regulatory power of the State. Article 30(1)
is not a charter for mal-administration; however reg'ulation, so th<f the right to
administer may be better exercised· for ·the benefits of the institlition, is permissible;. but ·the moment one goes beyond that 3.nd imposes what is in truth not a
inere regulation but an impairment of the right to· administer the Article co1nes
into play and the interference cainnot be justified by pleading the interests of
the general public, the interests justifying interference can only be the interests
of the n1iilority concerned. [837C-EJ
3. It is clear from the judgment in St. Xaviers College case that 7 out ot
9 judges held that the provisiO!ls containec\ i_n c[aijsei (b) of sub sections I ood 2
of Section 5l(A) of the Ac( therein'providing for the disciplinary control of Iii<>
20-549 SCI/78
G
e·
822
A
SUPREMI! COURT. REPOR.TS
[1979] 1 s.c.R.
B
M3I\3l1ement, over the staff pf its odueational institution wore not applicable
to an education institution established and managed by religious'aod linguistic
minorities. The reasons given by the majority were ~ the _power of the
1\-lanag~.ment to terminate the services of any member of the teachiiig or other
academic and non-academic staff was based on the relationship between the
employer and his employees and no encroachment can be made on Ihm right
to dispense with their servicee under the contract of employment, which was an
integral part of the right lo administer. [842B-D]
c
4. Tue High Court went wrong in holding that the Vice-Chancellor while
exercising the appellate powers under Ordinance 33(4) cannot Jirect reinstatement of a teacher or grant a declaration that his dismissal was wrongful.
It also fell into error in holding that the right of appeal before the ViceChancellor against the teachers of Private Colleges in the matter of suspension
and dismissal was not violative of the rights of religious minorities under
Article 30(1) of the Constitution. [829B-Q]
).
AJ11ned<1bad St. Xaviers College Society and Anr. v. State of GujaraJ and
Allf. [1975] I SCR 173; relied on.
D
5. Unlike Article 19, the fundarnontal freedom under Article 30(1) is
absolute in terms; it is not made subject to any reasonable restrictions of the
nature the fundamental freedoms enunciated in Article 19 may be subjected
to. ,All minorities, linguistic or religious have by article 30(1) an absolute
right to establish and administer educational institution of their- choice, and
any law or executive direction which seeks to infringe the substance of that
right under Article 30(1) wonld be to that extent void. [835F-G]
Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay, [1963) 3 S.C.R. 837.
E
F
G
6. The conferment of a right of appeal to an outside authority like the
Vice-Chancellor under Ordinance 33(4) takes away the disciplinary power of
a minority educational authority. The right of the Vice Chancellor to veto the
disciplinary power of the minority institution is a clear interference with its
right. It amounts to a fetter on the riiht of administration under Article 30(1).
[837E-G]
7. The power of appeal conferred on the Vice
Chancellor
in
ordinance rJ
33(4) is not only a grave encroachment on the right of the institution to en- '
forre and cover discipline in its administration but it is uncanalised and un~
guided in the sense that no 'restrictions' are placed on the exercise of the
power. The extent of the appellate power of the Vice Chancellor is unlimited
and undefined. The grounds on which the Vice Chancellor can interfere are
not defined and indeed, the powers are unlimited. He can even interfere agallist
the infliction of punishment. There is complete interference with the disciplinary power 6f a minority institution. In the absence of any guidelines, it
cannot be held that power of the Vice Chancellor under order 33(4)
was
merely a check on mal-administration'. The ratio of St. Xavier Colleges case
is fully applicable. [842G-H, 843A-B]
II
8. Accordingly, the judgment of the Hiah Court setting aside the two
orders of the Vice Chancellor upheld by this Court although for different
reasons. [844E-FJ
CIVIL APPELLATE JUIUSDICTION :. Civil Appeal Nos.
1975.
728-730 of
••
-»e--
LILLY KURIAN v. LEWINA (Seit, 1.)
823
· Appeals by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dllted
19-7-1973 of the Kerala High Court in S.A. Nos. 340 and 341/73
and A.S. No. 176/73.
M. K. Ramamurthy, Amicus Curiae, S. Balakrishnan, Amicus
Curiae, Miss R. Vaigai and Lilly Kurian (In person) for the Appellant.
V. A; Seyid Muhammed and K. R. Nambiar for the State of
A
B
Kerala.
\
L. N. Sinha (for RR l, 2 and 11 in CA 728), M. I. Joseph
• l'. P. Singh, (C.A. 729, 728 and 730/78) A. G. Pud·
(CA 729),
dissery (C.A. 730/75) and K. M. K. Nair for RR 1, 2, 11 and 12 in
C.A. 728, RR. 3, 11, 12 and 13 and RR 1, 3-5 in C.A. 730/75.
c
P. K. Keshava Pillai, Frank Anthony, M. K. D. Namboodiry,
K. R. Choudhury, Baby Krishnan, B. Parthasarthi and Panduranga
Rao for the Interveners.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
D
SEN, J.-These appeals by special leave directed against the Judg-
ment of the Kerala High Court dated July 19, 1973, raise a question
of far reaching importance. The question is whether an educational
institution established and managed by a religious or linguistic minority
is bound by the provisions of Ordinance 33 ( 4), Chapter LVII of tha
Ordinances framed ·by the Syndicate of the University of Kerala,
under section 19(j) of the Kerala University Act, 1957.
Smt. Lilly Kurian, the appellant herein, was appointed as Principal
of the St. Joseph Training College for Women, Ernakulam in the
year 1957. ·The College was established by the Congregation of the
Mothers of Carma!, which is a religious society of Nnus belonging to
the. Roman Catholic Church, and is affiliated to the University of
Kera.la. It is administered by a Managing Board, and the Provincial
of the Congregation is its President.
',)
On October 30, 1969, there was an unfortunate incident between
the appellant and one P. K. Rajaratnam, a lecturer of the College,
placed on deputation by the Govemmen!. On the basis of a complaint by Rajaratnam, the Managing Board initiated disciplinary proceedings against the appellant and appointed a retired Principal of
· the Maharaja's College, Ernakulam, to be the Enquiry Officer. The
appellant did not participate in the proceedings. · The attitude adopted
by the appellant·unfortunately was one of supreme indifference, taking
the stand that the Managing Board had no competence whatsoever
to initiate any such ·disciplinary action. Tllo Enquiry Qffic~r by hi&
E
F
G
H
824
.A
B
c
0
E
F
G
SUPRU1:E.. CQURT RE~ORT~
[197911 S.C.R.
report dated November 27, 1969,. held. the _appellant guilty of..misconduct. The Secretary of the Managing Board accordingly served her
with a notice dated December 2, 1969. stating that a meeting of the
Board was to be held on December 19. 1969, to consider the representation, if any, made by her and also the punishment to be imposed,
on the basis of the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer.
In the wake of the disciplinary action, on December 16, 1969,
the appellant filed a suit O.S. No. 819 of 1969 in the Munsiff's Court,
Ernakulam, challenging .the validity of the proceedings of the Managing Board. On December 19, 1969 the Munsiff issued an interim
injunction restraining the Management from implementing the decision,
if any, taken by it at the mee.ting to be held on that day. A meeting
of the Board had, in fact, been held and a decision was taken to
remove the appellant from service. The Provincial of the Congregation by virtue of her office as the President of the Managing Board,
by order dated January 2, 1970, dismissed the appellant from service.
It" was stated that the Managing Board had after giving due notice to
the appellant, and on a careful consideration of the enquiry report,
and the findings thereon, found th•at the charges of misconduct were
proved. The appellant was accordingly directed to handover all
papers, files, vouchers and documents connected with the College to
Sr. Lewina, Profossor, without further delay, stating that the order
for her dismissal from service would be implemented immediately
after the decision of the Munsiff on the applic>ation for temporary
injunction.
On January 17, 1970, the Munsiff held that the dismissal of the
appellant was free from any infirmity and was by the competent authority, that is the Managing Board, •and, therefore, she had no prbna
facie case. The Munsiff accordingly vacated the injunction with a
direction that temporary injunction already issued will remain in force
for two weeks to enable the appellant, if she wanted to move the ViceChancellor and obtain from him a stay of the order of dismissal. The
appellant had, in the meanwhile, on January 9, 1970; already. filed
an •appeal before the Vice-Chancellor under . Ordinance 33(4.),
'chapter LVII of the Ordinance framed by the Syndicate, against· the
order of dismissal. The Vice;Chancellor by his order dated January
24, 1970, staY,ed the operation of the order of dismissal. The suit
filed by the appellant was subsequently dismissed .bY the Munsiff as
withdrawn.
·
·
'C'.c
.~.
ff
It appears that the appellant was a)! t!i"wl,lile fuooti911ing.as principal of the College. It was brought to ·ligjlt,),hat she h~<l- sent two
communications ·dated October ·G,o; 1969, 'and.:No\'e!llb.er· 5,- 1969, to
)
LILLY KURIAN v. LEWINA
•
.
)
\
(Sen, !.)
825
the Secretary to the Government, Education Department, calling for
termination of deputation· of Rajaratnam, appointed as a Lecturer fn
the College by the Management, •as a result of which his deputation
was cancelled by the Government on December 9, I 969. The Managing Board viewed the sending 0f these communications by the appellant without reference to it as an act of insubordination, and, therefore, decided to conduct an enquiry against the appellant and she was
· suspended pending enquiry. A substitute Principal, Sr. Lewina, was
appointed and the appellant was relieved of the duties on April 10,
1970. On April 13, 1970 the appellant filed an appeal to the ViceChancellor against the order of suspension under Ordinance 33 (1) of
Chapter L Vil, and the Vice-Chancellor by his order dated April 20,
1970 directed that the status quo be maintained. In view of this
order, the Management was presumably apprehensive that the appellant might focce herself upon the College. The substitute Principal,
Sr. Lewina, appointed by the Management in place of the appellant
accordingly on July 2, 1970 filed the suit O.S. No. 405 of 1970 in
the Munsiff's Court, Ernakulam for an injunction restraining the appellant from functioning and from interfering with ·her discharging the
duties as Principal. The Munsiff granted a temporary injunction, in
the terms prayed for, which was subsequently confirmed.
A
D
The Vice-Chancellor, University of Kerala, by his two orders
dated October 19, 1970 held that the order of dismissal from service
E
and the order of suspension passed against the appellant were in
breach of the rules of natural justice and fmr play and were consequently illegal and null and . void, and accordingly direeted t.he
Management to allow her to function as Principal. Before the orders
were communicated, the Management filed the suit O.S. No. 110 of
I!
1970 in the Munsiff's Court, Ernakulam on Octob,r, 22, 1970, seeking
an injunction restraining the appellant from functioning as Principal
of the College and obtained a temporary injunction. While these two '•
injunctions were in force, the appellant wrote to the Superintendent
of the Post Offices demanding delivery of lett.ers addressed to , the
Principal at her residence. The non-delivery of letters creoated a dead- · 'G
lock in the administration of the College. On July 22, 1972, the
<ubstitute Principal, Sr. Lawine accordingly filed a suit O.S. No. 569
of 1972 in the Munsiff's Court, Ernakulam against the appellant and
the Postal Authorities -for prohibiting the one from receiving ~n·d the
other from delivering, thec'postal articles addressed to the Principal of
the College. All the tllree suits pending in the Munsiff's Court, Ernaku- H
lam were transfllffed/''by'th~' otiler of the District Judge, Ernakulam
to the !st Additional Sub-Court, Ernakulam for disposal.
I
826
SUPREME COURT 11.EPOll.TS
(1979) l s.c.11..
A
The trial court by its judgment dated December 6, 1972 dismissed
the suits holding that the appellate power conferred on the ViceChance!lor by els. ( 1) and ( 4) of Ordinance 33, Chapter LVII of the
Ordinance framed by the Syndicate under s. 19(j) of the Act, wasa
valid conferment of power on the Vice-Chancellor and even after the
commencement
of the Kerala University Act, ! 969, both the ViceB
Chancellor and the Syndicate had concurrent powers of appeal. It,
therefore, upheld the orders of the Vice-Chancellor directing reinstatement of the appellant in service. On appeal, the District Judge,
Ernakulam by his judgment dated March 17, 1973 held that the orders
of the Vice-Chancellor were perfectly valid and within jurisdiction,
c and that his direction to the Management to continue the appellant as
Principal in her office was also legal. He, accordingly dismissed the
appeals.
The Kerala High Court, however, by its judgment dated July 19,
1973 reversed the judgment and decree of the court below and decreed
the plaintiffs' suit holding that (i) the conferment by the Syndicate
D of a right of appeal to a teacher against his order of dismissal from
service to the Vice-Chancellor cannot be said to be in excess of the
pennissible limits of the power to prescribe the duties and conditions
of service of teachers in private colleges in terms of s. 19 (j) of
the Act, and (ii) the provisions for a right of appeal contained in
E Ordinance 33(1) and (4), Chapter LVII of the Ordinance were not
violative of the rights guaranteed to the religious minorities under
Article 30(1), and were, therefore, valid, following certain observations of its earlier Full Bench decision in V. Rev. Mother Provincial
v. State of Kera/a('). According to the High Court, although the
Vice-Chancellor had the power to hear an appeal against an order of
F dismissal under Ordinance 33(4), he had not, expressly or impliedly,
the power to order reinstatement or even to grant a declaration that
the services of the 'appellant had been wrongly terminated. It held
that a statutory tribunal like the Vice-Chancellor could not grant such
a relief as the same would amount to specifically enforcing the contract of service. In reaching the conclusion, the High Court observes
G that this, in effect, "amounts to eviscerating the right of appeal to the
Vice-Clrancellor, but the remedy lies elsewhere", in the light of the
authorities cited by it.
H
The Kerala University Act, 1957, "the Act", as the preamble
shows, was enacted to reconstitute the University of Travancore into
a teaching University for the whole of the State of Kerala. Section
2(a) defines "college" to mean a college maintained by, or affiliate<!
(I) I. L. R. f 196912 Kera la 642 ..
J.
•
LILLY KURIAN v. LEWINA (Sen, J,)
827
to the University. TI1e definition of "teacher" in section 2(j) of the A
Act is wide enough to take in a Principal, as any 'other person imparting instruction'. Section 5(viii) confers power on the University to
affiliate to itself colleges wit)lin the State in accordance with the conditions to be prescribed in the statutes regarding management, salary
aud terms of service of members of the staff, and other such matters,
and to withdraw affiliation from colleges. Section 15 (2)(ii) enjoins B
that the Senate shall make, amend or repeal statutes of its own motion
or on the motion of the Syndicate. The powers of the Syndicate are
enumerated in section 19, the relevant provisions of which read :
•
\
"19. Powers of the Syndicate-Subject to the provisions
of this Act and the Statutes, the _Executive Authority of the
University including the general superintendence and control
over the institutions of the University shall be vested in the
Syndicate; and subject likewise, the Syndicate shall have the
following powers, namely : (a) to affiliate institutions in accordance with the conditions prescribed in the Statutes;
c
D
(b) to make Ordinance and to amend or repeal the same;
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
(j) to fix the emoluments and prescribe the duties and
the conditions of service of teachers and other employees in Private Colleges."
The Kerala University Act, 1957 was repealed by the Kerala
University Act, 1969 which ca.me into force with effect from February
28, 1969. Section 75 (2) of the Act provides that the statutes, ordinances, rules and byefaws in force immediately before the commencement of the Act shall, in so· far as they are not inconsistent with its
provisions, continue to be in force unless they are replaced.
The material provisims of Ordinance 33, Chapter LVII of the
Ordinances framed by the Syndicate under section 19(g) are as
follows:-
••
"33 ( 1) Suspension : The management may at any time
place a teacher under suspension where a disciplinary proceedings against him is contemplated or is pending. He shall
be paid subsistence allowance and other allowances by the
management duriag the period of suspension at such rates as
may be specified by the University in each case. The teacher
E
F
G
H
828
A
B
[1979] 1 s.c.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
shall have. right to app·~al against the order of suspension to
the Vice-Chancellor of the University within a period of two
months from the date on which he receives the order of
suspension.
(2) Nature of pena!t•~s : The following penalties may
for good and sufficient reasms be imposed on a teacher by
the Ma'nagement :( i) Censure.
' ,t·
(ii) Withholding of increment
(iii) Recovery from pay of any pecuniary loss caused to
the institution/monetary value equivalent to the
amount of increment ordered to be withheld.
c
)~
•
(iv) Reduction to a lower rank i·a the seniority list or to
a lower grade or post
( v) Dismissal from service.
D
The Management shall b~ the Discipli'nary Authority in
imposing the penalties.
x
E
x
x
x
x
x
x
( 4) Appeal : A teacher shall be entitled to appeal to the
Vice-Chancellor of the University against any order pa55ed
by the management in respect of the penalties referred to in
items (ii) to (v). Such ·appeal shall be submitted within a
period of 60 days the appel\a·at receives the order of punish-
ment."
The expression "conditions of service" covers a wide , range, as
exphined by the Privy Council in N.W.F. Province v. Suraj Narain(')
F
which was approved by this Court in State of U.P. v. Babu Ram.(')
These decisions and ahso a later decision of this Court in State of M.P.
· & Ors. v. Shardul Singh(") have made it clear that the expression
'conditions of service' bcludes everything from the stage of appointment to the stage of terminatio'n of service and even beyond, and
relates to matt.ors pertaining to disciplinary action.' Thus, the expresG
sion 'conditions of service' as explained in the decisions of the Privy
Council and of this Court includes the power to take disciplinary
action. The rules regarding these matters are contaihed in Chapter
LVII of the Ordinances. The Management of a private college under
Ordinance 33 (2) i• constituted the appointing and the disciplinary
H
(1) 75 I. A 343.
(2) [1961] 2 S. C. R. 679.
(3) [1970] 3 . C. R. 302.
••
...
LILLY KURIAN
v. LEWINA (Sen, J.)
829
authority in respect of imposition of punishment. 111 the course of any
disciplinary proceeding, a right of appeal before the Vice-Chancellor is
given to a teacher dismissed from service under Ordinance 33(4) of
the Ordinances. The High Court thus rightly held that the right of
appeal conferred by Ordinance 33( 4) forms part of the 'conditions of
service' and, therefore, is valid.
\.
)
The High Court was, however. wro'ng in two ways. Firstly, it fell
hlto an error in holding that the Vic•,-Chancellor while exercising the
appellat!" powers under Ordinance 33 ( 4), had not the power to direct
reinstatement of a teacher or grant a declaration that his dismissal
was wrongful. It also fell into an error in holding that a right of appeal
before the Vice-Chancellor given to the teachers of private colleges
under Ordinance 3 3 ( 1 ) and ( 4) , h1 the matter of suspension and dismissal, was not violative of the rights of religious minorities under
article 30(1) of the Constitution.
Under Ordinance 33 ( 1), a teacher placed under suspension, has a
right of app,al agai\J5t the order of suspension to the Vice-Chancellor.
Uader Ordinance 33(4), a teacher shall be entitled to appeal to the
Vice-Chancellor against any order passed by the management in
resp,ct of penalties referred to in items (ii) to (v) of Ordinance
33(2). Merely because a right of appeal is provided without defining
the powers of the appellate authority, it cannot be implied that such
right does not include the power to direct reinstatement. The conferment of a power to hear an appeal necessarily invests the appellate
authority with tile power to annnl, vary or set aside the order appealed
from. Such power is incidental to or is implied in, the power to hear an
appeal. It necessarily has the power to grant an appropriate relief.
Indeed, the extent of tile appellate power under Ordinance 33(4) is
'not defined. When a teacher is dismissed from service, the ViceChancellor can not only direct reinstatement but also modify the
natu.re of punishment. The whole matter is at large before hinl.
In V. Rev. Mother Provincial v. State of Kera/a (supra) a Full
Bench of the Kerala High Court while dealing with section 56(4) of
the Kerala University AcJ., 1969, observed that the right of appeal to
the Syndicate, which being a large body comprising of as many as
seventeen members will be subject to pnlls and pressures, was not a
body which could be e·atrusted with a judicial. function of this nature.
In tilat view, it held that sub-~ection (4) suffers from the defect of the
appeal being to a forum which seems to be entirely unsuitable for the
purpose, being unreasonable, and so much against tile interests of the
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
830
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1979j I
SC R.
institution, that it can hardly be justified either as a regulation of, or as
a reasonable restriction on the power of the manag~mcnt. Incidentally,
it observed :
•
"Though the appeal lies not, as one would have expected, to a judicial or quasi-judicial tribunal but to an executive
body which, having regard to its comp<l6ition, would hardly
be able to produce what is ordinarily called a speaking
order."
c
The High Court has react more into the Full Bench decision than
there is, and from the mere observation that the proper remedy against
a;zy abuse of the disciplinary power would be an appeal, seem to
assume that a provision like Ordihance 33(4) would not affect the
right guaranteed to a minority under Article 30(1 ), in matters pertaining to discipline. On the contrary, the Full Bench observed :·--
D
"TI1e Vice-Chancellor can hardly be expected to have the
time to deal with such matters, and in any case, the lcY:lg
delay that will necessarily be involved would, by itself rehde-r
the managing body's powers of disciplinary control largely
ineffectual."
E
F
G
H
It is contended on behalf of the appellant that the right to administer guaranteed by Article 30( 1) of the Constitution does not carry
with it a 'right to maladminister'. It is urged that while autonomy in
admiitlstration means right to administer effectively and to manage and
conduct the affairs of the institution, the University will always have
a right to sec that there is no maladministraticm. If there is maladministration, the University must take steps to cure the same. The
right to administer is, therefore to be tampered with regulatory
measures to facilitate smooth administration. Regulations which will
serve the interests of the students, regulations which will serve the
interestl; of the teachers are of paramount importance under good
administration. Regulations b the interest of efficiency of teachers, diBcipline and fairness in administration are necessary for preserving harmony among affiliated institutiohs. It is urged that if the State has any
role to play in the system of general education, its power camiot be
confined merely to the laying down of a prescn'bed standard of education for minority educational institutions but should also extend to all
necessary measures to secure an orderly, efficient and sound admmistration of such institutions. Once the role of the State in the system of
general educ;ition is properly understood its regulatory power over the
minority educational institutions, it is submitted, would depend upon
the :iature or type of the educational institutions set up by a minority
a'nd all other relevant factors, and no universal or general test can be
'
..,,
LILLY KURIAN I', LEW!NA
831
laid down, The degree of permissive State control must depend upon
the circumstances of each case, The right under Article 30 (1) forms
part of a complex and inter-dependent group of diven;e social
interests, There cannot be any perpetually fixed adjustment of the right
and those social interests, They would need adjustment and readjustment from tim~ to time and in varying circumstances, Undoubtedly,
the management of a minority institution could not be displaced by the
regulat-Ory measure, But the State has a power to regulate through the
age::icy of the University the service conditions of teache11S and to
secure a fair procedure in the matter of disciplinary action against
them, These safeguards must necessarily result in the security of tenure
of teachers and must attract competent and qualified staff and thus
could ultimately improve the ~xcellence and efficiency of the educational institution,
\
'
,l
..
(Sen, J,)
It is further urged that the reconciliation of minority rights in
education with wider social and educational objectives is inevitably
necessary and this involves the judicial task of balancing the guaranteed rights under Article 30 (1) with social, national or educational
values sought to be regulated or protected by the impugned legislation,
It has to bo kept in mi:ld that today the education has to be so
designed which would subserve not only the well being of the citizens
in the intellectual, ethical and financial spheres but would inculcate
amongst tbem a scns•o of individual and social consciousness to contribute to the welfare ffnd prosperity of an egalitarian society, rt is,
therefore, urged that Ordinance 33 (4) , Chapter LVII of the Ordiuances framed by the Syndicate under s,l9(j) of the Act is not
violative of Article 30 (1) as it seeks to ensure justice and fair play
to the teachers against arbitrary actions of the management
It is next urged that the Vice-Chancellor,
while exercising his
uppellate power under Ordinance 33 ( 4) is i:ldeed clothed with tbe
State's inherent judicial power to deal with disputes lntween the
parties and determine them on the merits, fairly and objectively,
It is urged that the contention that the impugned order passed by
the Vice-Chancellor under Ordinance 33 ( 4) affects the fundamental
rights of minority religious institutions under Article 30(1), is based
on a complete misconception about the true nature and character of
judicial process and of judicial decisions, If this basic and judicial
aspect of the judicial process is borne in mind, it is submittted, it would
be plain that the decision given by th~ Vice-Chancellor cannot be said
to affect the fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 30(1), The
remedy for a person aggrieved by tl1e decision of a competent judicial
tribunal is to approach for redress a superior tribunal, if there be one,
A
:a
c
o·
E
F
G
II
832
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1979] I s.c.R.
Lastly it is urged that the rights of the religious and linguistic minorities in respect of their educational institutions, however, liberally
construed, cannot be allowed to dominate every other fundamental
rights, dil'.'clive principles of State policy and broad ideals of the
Constitution. Article 30 (I) enables the minorities to establish and
administer educaticmal institutions of their choice but it is said they
cannot be entitled to exact unjustifiable preferential or discriminatory
treatment for minority institutions so as to obtai·n benefits but to reject
obligations of statutory rights. We fail to see the relevance of these
submissions while adjudging the validity of Ordinance 33 (I) a:ad ( 4)
in the light of Article 30(1 ).
The appellant, who appeared in person, supplemented the arguments of the learned counsel appearing as amicus curiae and urged
that if the Court does not uphold the powers of the Vice-Chancellor
under Ordinance 33 ( 4) it would be ta:atamount to negation of the
State's regulatory power to prevent or cure the abuse of power by the
management and throw the teachers to their arbitrary actions without
any security of tenure. She urged that the religious, cultural a'nd
linguistic minorities though deserve a generous and sympathetic
treatment, cannot at the same time be absolved of their obligations to
conform to the norms of natural justice and fair employment.
In assailing the view of the High Court, learned counsel for the
Management contends that the right of administration of minority
educational institutions rests with the Management and the right of
appointment, suspension and dismissal of the staff also is part and
parcel of the administration. In a private college, t'he appointing and
disciplinary authority is the management. Ordinance 33 relating to the
service conditions of teach~rs in private colleges· authorises the \_
management to take any disciplinary proceedings. The University has
no power to interfere into the administration of the college or into the
disciplinary action taken agai'nst a member of the staff. The creation of
an appellate authority like the Vice-Chancdllor, which is an outside
agency, itself is an illegal abridgment of the right of management
enshrined in Article 30(1). That apart, directing a dismissed Principal,
who is the academic h~ad of the college, to hold office against the
wishes of the founders of the college without specific power in that
regard, is an anathema to the right of adminisiration guaranteed by
Article 30( 1) of the Constitution. If the Vice-Chancellor were to
have power of rebstatement of a dismissed teacher, the restllt would
be, in effect, appointing a person against the will of the founders of the
institution. The conferment of such a power on the Vice.Chancellor is
destructive of the right of management. In support of the contention
I
c
'
....
ULLY KURIAN
v.
LEWINA
l-·
(Sen, J.)
833
i
that Ordinance 33 (I) and ( 4) were violative of Article 30(1),
reliance was placed on the decision in Ahmedabad St. Xa.viers College
Society & Anr. v. State of Gujarat & Anr.(').
\.
Learned counsel for the interveners contends that the interposition
of an outside authority like the Vice-Chancellor, demits the entire
discipli:iary po'WW of a minority educational institution to the ViceChance,:lor. Under Ordinance 33 ( 4) the Vice-Chancellor has the
power to veto i:s disciplinary control. There is complete interference
with the disciplinary power of the minority institution. The State may
'regulate' the exercise of the right of administration, but it has no power
1o impose any "restriction' which is destructive of the right itself. In
matters relati"ag to discipli"ne, the process of decision musr be left to
1he institution. There is direct interference with this right. The post of
principal is of pivotal importance in the life of a college, around whom
wheds the tone and temper of the institution, on whom depends the
continuity of its traditions, maintena-:ice of discipline and the efficiency
of its teaching. The character of the institution depends on the right
choice of the principal by the management. The right to choose the
principal is perhaps the most importa1)J facet of the right to adminis'ter a college. In the same way, the right to dispense with the servio~s
of the principal is a:i equally important facet of the same right. The
imposition of any trammel, thereon, except to the extent of prescribing
the requisite qualifications and the experience or otherwise fostering
the interests of the institution itself, cannot but b" considered as a
violation of the right warranted under Article 30 ( 1) .
Learned counsel appearing for the State of Kerala, however, while
conceding that conferral of arbitrary and unguided powers on an out.L side agency like the Vice-Chancellor, would be destructive of the right
of management under Article 30 (I), contends that the power of the
Vice-Chancellor under Ordinance 33(4) to hear an appeal agai:ist an
order of dismissal does not suffer from this vice. He tries to limit the
appellate power of the Vice-Chancellor under.Ordinance 33(4) to a
case where the action of the management is ma/a fide or where the
order of dismissal is a nullity or where the management has acted i':t
breach of the rules of natural justice. When so read, it is urged, that
'
'
the conferment of the right of appeal to the Vke-Chancellor in case
of disciplinary powers of a minority educational institution, amounts
only to a regulation of such power, and, therefore, Ordinance 33 ( 4) is
not violative of Article 30 ( l ) .
Article 30( I) of the Constitution provides :(I) (19751 I S. C. R. 173.
A
n
c
D
E
F
G
H
4'c.io.-
-
834
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1979] l S.C.R.
"30. (1) All minorities, wheth::r based on religion or
language, shall have the right to establish and administer
educational institutions of their choice."
It is clear beyond doubt that Article 30 ( 1), though couched in
absolute and spacious terms in marked contrast with other fundamental
rights-in Part III, has to be read subject to the regulatory power of the
State. Though this Court has co·nsistenlly recognized this power of the
State as constituting au implied limitation up011 the right guaranteed
under Article 30 ( 1), the entire controversy has centred around the
extent of its regulatory power over minority educational institutions.
.
'
In re the Kerala Education Bill, 1957('), S. R. Das, C.J. explained
the co'ntent of the right under Article 30 ( 1) of the Ccrastitution, in
these words :-
"We have a~rcady observed that Article 30( I) gives
two rights to the minorities, (I) to establish and (2) to
administer, educational institutions of their choice. The right
to administer cannot obviously include the right to maladminister. The minority cannot surely ask for aid or recognition for a·n educational institutiO'n run by them in unhealthy
surroundings, without any competent teachers possessing any
semblance of qualification, and which does not maintain even
a fair standard of teaching or which teaches matters subversive o{ the welfare of the scholars. It sta'nds to reason, then,
that th~ constitutional right to administer an educational
institution of their choice does not necessarily militate
against the claim of the State to insist that in order to grant
aid the State may prescribe reasonable regulations to e'nsure
the excellence of the institutions to be aided."
Thus, a contention based on the absolute freedom from State
control of the minorifos' right to administer their educational institutions was expressly negatived in this case. The Court clearly laid down
a principle, ·namely, a regulation, which is not destructive or annihilative of the core or the substance of the right under Article 30(1),
could legitimately be imposed.
The right of a minority commuaity to establish and administer
educational institutions of their choice was subject matter of decision
by this Court in more than one case.
II
•
In Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai vc State of Bombay,(') Shah J. (as he
then was) speaking for the Court, negatived an argument advanced on
(I) [1959] S. C.R. 995.
(2) [1963] S. C.R. 837.
,
'
LILLY KURIAN
'
v.
LEWINA (Sen, J.)
835
behaif of the State that a law could not be deemed to be unreasonable
unless it was totally destructive or annihilative of the right under
Article 30 ( 1), stating :
\
·The right established by Art. 30(1) is a fundamental
right declared in terms absolute. Unlike the fundamental
freedoms guaranteed by Art. 19, it is '.not subject to reasonable restrictions. It is intended to be a real right for the protection of the minorities in the matter of setting up of
educational institutions of their own choice. The right is intended to be effective and is not to be whittled down by
se>-ealled regulative measures conceived in the interest not of
the minority educational institution, but of the public or the
nation as a whoie. If every order which while maintaining
the formal character of a minority institution destroys the
power of administration is held justifiable because it is in
the public or national i'.n~~rest, though not in its interest as an
educational institution, the right guaranteed by Art. 30 ( 1)
will be but a 'teasing illusion', a promise of unreality."
A
B
c
D
The learned Judge then we;it on to say :
..
•
"Regulation which may lawfully be imposed either by
legislative or executive action as a condition of receiving
grant or of recognition must be directed to making the institution while retaining its character as a minority institution
effective as an educational institution. Such regulation must
satisfy a dual test-the test of reasonableness, and the test
that it is regulative of the educational character of the institution and is conducive to making the institution an effective vehicle of education for the minority community or
other persons who resort to it."
Unlike Article 19 (1) the fundamental freedom under Article
30{1) is absolute in ~!rms; it is not made subject to any reasonable
restrictions of the nature the fundamental freedoms enunciated i'n
Article 19 may be subjected to. All minorities, linguistic or religious.
have by Article 30( I) an absolute right to estab'.ish and administer
educational rnstitutions of their choice; and any law or executive
direction which seeks to infringe the substance of that right under
Article 30(1) would to that extent b~ void.
The extent of the regulatory power of the State was explained by
Shah J ., thus :
"This, however, is not to say that it is not open to the
State to impose regulations upori the exercise of this right.
E
F
G
H
836
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[J 979] 1 s.c.R.
f
A
The fundamental freedom is to establish and to administer
educational institutions : it is a right to establish and
administer what are in truth educational institutions. institutions which cater to the educational needs of the citizens,
or sections thereof. Regulation made in the true interests of
efficiency of instruction, discipline, health, sanitation,
B
morality, public order and the like may undoubtedly be
imposed. Such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of the right which is guaranteed; they secure the proper functioning of the institution, in matters educational."
In Rev. Father W. Proost & Ors. v. The State of Bihar & Ors.( 1)
c Hidayatullah C.J. while dealing with Articles 29(1) and 30(1),
said :
"In our opinion, the width of Article 30(1) cannot be
cut down by introducing in it considerations on which Art.
29 ( 1) is based. The latter article is a general protection
which is given to minorities to conserve their language,
D
script or culture. The former is a special right to minorities
to establish educational institutions of their choice. This
choice is not limited to institution, seeking to conserve language, script or culture and the choice is not taken away if the
minority community having established a·n educational institution of its choice also admits members of other commuE
nities. That is a circumstance irrelevant for the application
of Article 30 (1) since no such limitation is expressed and
none can be implied, although it is possible that they may
meet in a iiven case."
Incidentally, in dealing with the right under Article 30(1) and
F the extent of the State's power of regulatory control of such right, this
Court in State of Kera/a v. V. Rev. Mother Provincial(') observed
"Administration means 'management of the affairs' of the
institution. This management must be free of control so that
the founders or their nominees can mould the institution as
they think fit, and in accordance with their ideas of how the
G
interests of the community in general and the institution in
particular will be best served. No part of this management
can be taken away and vested in another body without an
encroachment upon the guaranteed right.
ff
There is, however, an exception to this and it is that the
standards of education are not a part of management as such.
These standards concern the body politic and are dictated
(I) [1969} 2 S. C. R. 73.
(2) [1971] l S. C.R. 734. ·
)
..'
LILLY KURIAN
'
LEWINA (Sen, J.)
837
A
by considerations of the advancement of the country and its
people. Therefore, if universities establish syllabi for examinations they must be followed, subject however to special
subjects which the institutions may seek to teach, and to a
certain extent the State may also regulate the.conditions of
employment of teachers and the health and hygiene of stuB
dents. Such regulations do not bear directly up<in management as such although they may indirectly affect it. Yet the
right of the State to regulate e(lucation, educational standards
and allied matters cannot be denied. The minority institutions cannot be allowed to fall below the standards of exceUance expected of educational institutions, o'r under the
c
guise of exclusive right of management, to decline to follow
the general pattern.
While the management must be left
to them, they may be compelled to keep in step with others."
Projection of the minorities is an article of faith in the Constitution
of India. The right to the administration of-institutions of minority's
,choice enshrined in Article 30(1) means 'management of the affairs' D
,of the institution.
This right is, however, subject to the regulatory
power of the State. Article 30( I) is not a charter for maladministra'tion; regulation, so that the right to administer may be better exercised
for the benefit of the institution is permissible; but the moment one
goes beyond that and imposes, what is in truth, not a mere regulation
but an impairment of the right to administer, the Article comes in~ E
play and the interference cannot be justified by pleading the interests
of the general public; the interests justifying interference can only be
the interests of tbe minority concerned.
\
l
••
v.
The conferment of a right of appeal to an outside authority like the
Vice-Chancellor under Ordinance 33 ( 4) takes away the disciplinary
power of a minority educational authority. The Vice-Chancellor has , F
the power to veto its disciplinary control. There is a clear interference
with the disciplinary power of the minority institution.
The State
may 'regulate' the exercise of the right of administration but it has no
'}JOWer to impose any 'restriction' which is destructive of the right itself. The conferment of such wide powers on the Vice-Chancellor G
amounts in reality, to a fetter on the right of administration under Article 30(1). This, it seems to us, would so affect the disciplinary cont'TOl of a minority educational institution as to be sub\'ersive of its constitutional rights and can hardly be regarded as a 'regulation' or a
"restriction' in the interest of the institution.
In St. Xaviers College v. Gujarat (supra) a Bench of nine Judges, H
'by a majority of seven to two, held that clauses (b) of sub-sections ( 1)
:and (2) of s. 51A of the Gujarat University Act, 1949 were violative
'
·-·
838
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1979 j 1 s.c.R.
of Article 30(1). Section 51A(l) (b) enacts that no member of the
teaching, other academic and non-teaching staff of an affiliated college
shall be dismissed or removed or reduced in rank except after an
enquiry in accordance with the procedure prescribed in clause (a)
and the penalty to be inflicted on him is approved by the Vice-Chancellor or any other officer of the University authorised by the VieeChancellor in this behalf. Similarly, clause (b) of sub-section (2)
requires that such termination should be approved by the Vice-Chancellor or any officer of the University authorised by the Vic;.
Chancellor in this behalf.
)
It was argued that the requirement that such termination must be
with the approval of the Vice-Chancellor, creates a fetter in matters
relating to disciplinary control over the members of the teaching and
non-teaching staff.
The approval by the Vice-Chancellor, it was
said, may be intended. to be a check on the administration but there
were no guidelines provided and, therefore, clauses (b) of sub-section
(1) and (2) of section 51A cannot be said to be a permissive regulatory measure. These contentions were upheld by the majority.
While seven Judges who constituted the majority upheld the provisions of clauses (a) of sub-se.ction ( 1) and (2) of section 51A, as
they provided for a reasonab!e opportunity of showing cause against
a penalty to be imposed as being 'regulatory', they held that clauses (b)
of sub-sections (1) and (2) of section 51A of the Act, which confer
a blanket power on the Vic~Chancellor to interfere with the disciplinary control of the miinagement of a minority educational institution
over its teachers, make a serious inroad on the right of the minority
to administer an educational institution guaranteed under Article 30( 1).
appreciate the point involved, we may refer to certain passages
... of theTo judgment.
In dealing with the question, Ray C.J., with whom
G
H
Palekar, J. agreed, observed :
"In short, unlimited and undefined power is conferred
on the Vice-Chancellor. The approval of the Vice-Chancellor may be intended to be a check on the administration.
The· provision contained in section SlA, clause (b) of the
Act cannot be said to be ru permissive regulatory measure
inasmuch as it confers arbitrary power on the Vic~Chancel
lor to take away the right of administration of the minority
institutions. Section 51A of the Act cannot, therefore.
•
apply to minority institutions."
The provision for approval of the Vic~Chancellor was held to be
bad because it acted as a check on administration.
Further, it WR!f
..
LILLY KURIAN v. LEWINA
(Sen, J.)
839
held to confer arbitrary powers on the Vice-Chancellor because there
was no guidelines on the basis of which the Vice-Chancellor could
withhold his approval.
A
Jaganmohan Reddy J., speaking for himself and for Alagiriswami
J. agreed with the opinion of Ray C.J.
In explaining the extent of regulatory control, Khanna J. stated
\
"Although disciplinary control over the teachers of aminority educational institution wpuld be with the
governing
council, regulations, in any opinion, can be made for ensuring proper conditions of s_ervice of the teachers and for securing a fair procedure in the matter of disciplinary action
against the teachers.
Such provisions which are calculated
to safeguard the interest of teachers would result in security
of tenure and thus inevitably attract competent persons for
the posts of teachers. Such a provision would also eliminate
a potential cause of frustration amongst the teachers. Regulations made for this. purpose should 15e considered to be in
the interest of minority educational institi.Itions and as such
they would not violate article 30(1 )."
B
c
D
He accordingly upheld the validity of clause (a) stating :
"Clause (a) of sub-sections (1) and (2) of section SIA
of the impugned Act which make provision for giving a
reasonable opportunity of showing cause against a penalty to
be proposed on a member of the staff of an educational institution would consequently be held to' be valid."
But he held clause (b) to be invalid saying :
,
•<
"Clause (b) of those sub-sections which gives a power to
the Vice-Chancellor and officer of the Universi!y authorised
by him to veto the action of the managing body of an edncational institution in awarding punishment to a _member of the
staff, in my opinion, .interfere with the disciplinary control
of the managing body over its teachers. It is significant that
the power of approval conferred by clause (b) in each of the
two sub-sections of section SlA on the Vice-Chancellor or
other officer authorised by him is a blanket power. No guidelines are laid down fqr the exercise of that power and it is ndt
provided that the approval is to be withheld only in case the
dismissal. removal, reduction in rank or termination of service is mala fide or by way of victimisation or other similar
cause. The confern;ient of such blanket power on the Vice-
E
F
G
H
,,
840
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
,_,~
SUPREME COURT REPORfS
[ 1979] I s.c.R.
(
Chancellor or other officer authorised by him for vetoing
the disciplinary action of the managing body of an educational
institution makes a serious inroad on the right of the managing body to administer an educational institution.
Clause
(b) of each of the two sub-sections of section 51A should,
therefore, be held to be violative of article 30( 1) so far as
minority educational institutions are concerned."
It was held that clause (b) interferes with the disciplinary control
of the managing body over its teachers. The provision does not restrict its operation in cases of mala {ides or victimisation, etc. In other
words, the power of the Vice-Chancellor was complete. He could
refuse his approval on facts, that is to say, on reachbg a conclusion
that the action of the management was improper or invalid.
Mathew J., speaking for himself and one of us, Chandrachnd J.
(as he then was) observed :
"It was argued for the petitioners that clause ( 1) (b) of
s.51 A has the effect of vesting in the Vice-Chancellor a
general power of veto on the right of the management to
dismiss a teacher. The exact scope of the power of the ViceCha-:icellor or of the officer of the University authorised by
him in this sub-section is not clear. If the purpose of the
approval is to see that the provisions of sub-section 5 IA(l)
(a) are complied with, there can possibly be no objection
in lodging the power of approval even in a nominee of the
Vice-Chancellor. But a'n uncanalised power without any
guidelbe to withhold approval would be a direct abridgement
of the right of the management to dismiss or remov•e a teacher
or inflict any other penalty after conducting an enquiry."
J
The Learned Judge then proceeded to observe :
"The relationship between the management and a teach•er
is that of all employer and employee and it passes cme's
understanding why the management cannot terminate the
services of a teacher on the basis of the contract of employment. Of course, it is open to the State in the exercise of
its regulatory power to require that before the services of a
teacher are terminated, he should be given an opportu..'1ity of
being heard in bis defeilce. But to require that for terminating the services of a teacher after an inquiry has been
conducted, the management should have the approval of an
outside agency like the Vice-Chancellor or of his nominee
would be a'a abridgement of its right to administer the educational i'nsti tution. No guidelines are provided by the legis-
.'
•
/
LILLY KURIAN v. LEWINA (Sen, J.)
\
841
lature to the Vice-Chancellor for the exercise of his power.
The fact that the power can be delegated by the Vice-Chancellor to any officer of the University means that any petty
officer to whom the power is delegated can exercise a general
pow;:r of veto. There is no obligation under the sub-sections
(! )(b) and 2 (b) that the Vice Chanc~lor or his ':lominee
should give any reason for disapproval. As we said a blanket
power withO'Ut any guideline to disapprove the action of the
management would certainly encroach upon the right of the
management to dismiss or terminate the services of a teacher
after an enquiry."
A
He was of the opinioa that such a provision constitutes a direct
abridgement of the right of the management to dismiss or remove a
teacher or inflict any other penalty, after conducting an enquiry.
c
B
Dissenting, two of the other Judges, namely Beg. and Dwivedi,
J. struck a discordant note. Beg J. (as he then was) observed :
"Section SI A of the Act appears to me to lay down
general conditions for the dismissal, removal, reduction in
rank and termination of services of members of the staff of
all colleges to which it applies. Again, we have not to consider here either the wisdom or unwisdom of such a provision or the validity of any part of section SIA of the Act on
the grouad that it violates a'ny fundamentrll right other than
the ones ·conferred by Art. 30(1) of the Constitution."
D
E
Dwivedi J. sta~~d :
1
.'
"The purpose of s. SIA is to check this kind of misuse
of the right to fire an employee. So the Vice-Chancellor's
power of approval is not unguided and unreasonable. After
the Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor is the next highest officer
of the University. It should be presumed that in granting or
withholding approval 'he would act according to reason and
justice'.
When the matter goes before the Vice-Chancellor for
approval, both the management and the teacher or the member of the non-teaching staff should be heard by him. Hearing both parties is necessarily implied, because without hearing either of them it will be difficult for him to make up
his mi'.nd whether he should grant or withhold approval to
the action proposed by the managing body of the educational
instituti()';l. It would also.follow that while granting approval
F
G
H
842
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
l 19791 I s.c.R.
A
or disapproval, the Vice-Chancellor should record reasons,
for the exercise of his power is subject to control by courts.
The statute does not make his order final, and courts would
surely nullify his order if it is arbitrary, ma/a fide or illegal."'
•
An analysis of the judgments in St. Xaviers College's case (supra)
clearly shows that seve'n out of nin~ Judges held that the provisions
contained in clauses (b) of sub-sections (1) and (2) of section SIA
of the Act were not applicable to an educational institution established
and managed by religious or linguistic minority as they interfere with
the disciplinary control of the management over the staff of its educational institutioos. The reasons given by the majority were that the
power of the management to terminate the services of any member
of the teaching or other academic and non-academic staff was based
on the relationship between an employer and his employees and no
encroachment could be made o;i this right to dispense with their services under the contract of employment, which was an integral part
of the right to administer, and that these provisions conferred on the
Vice-Chancellor or any other officer of the University authorised by
him, uncanalised, ungnided and umimited power to veto the action6
of the management. According to the majority view, the conferment
of such blanket pow;:r on the Vice-Chancellor and his nominee was
an infringement of the right of administratioo guaranteed under Art.
30(1) to the minority institutions, religious and linguistic. The majority
was accordingly of the view that the provisions contained in clauses
(b) of sub-sections (1) and (2) of section 51A of the Act had the
effect of destroying the mi;:iority institutions's disciplinary control over
the teaching and non-teaching staff of the college as no punishment
could be inflicted py the management on a member of the staff unless
it gets approval from an outside authority like the Vice-Chancellor er
an officer of the University authorised by him. On the cootrary, the
two dissenting Judges were of the view that these provisions were permissive regulatory measures.
c
D
E
F
G
H
The power of appeal conferred on thoo Vice-Chancellor under
Ordinance 33 ( 4) is not only a grave encroachment on the institution's
right to enforce and ensure discipline in its administrative affairs but
it is uncanalised and unguided in the sense that no restrictioos are
placed on the exericise of the power. The extent of the appellate
power of the Vice-Chan<Xllor is not defined; and, indeed, his powers
are unlimited. The grounds on which the Vice-Chancellor can interfere in such appeals are also not defined. He may not only set aside
an order of dismissal of a teacher and order his reinstatement, but
may also interfere with any of the punishments enumerated in it~ms-
I
"
•
•
,
I ILLY KURIAN I'. LEWINA (Sen, J.)
S4J
(ii) to (v) of Ordinance 33(2); that is to say, he can even interfere
against the infliction of minor punishments. I'n the absence of any
guidelbes. it cannot b.: held that the power of the Vice-Chancellor
under Ordinance 33 ( 4) was merely a check on maladministration.
A
As laid down by the majority in St. Xavitrs College's case (supra),
such a blanket power directly interferes with the disciplinary control
of the managing body of a minority education institution over its
teachers. The majority decision i·a St. Xaviers College's case squarely applies to the facts of the present case and accordingly it must be
held that the impugned Ordinance 33(4) of the University of Kerala
is violative of Article 30 ( 1) of tl1e Constitution. If the conferment
of such power dn an outside authority like the Vice-Chancellor, which
while maintaining the formal character of a minority institutiaa d<IBtroys the power of administration, that is, its disciplinary control, is
held justifiable because it is in the public and national interest, though
not in its interest as an educational institution, the right guaranteed
by Article 30 ( 1) will be, to use the well-known expression, a 'teasing
..
!;l
l
illusion', a 'promise of unreality'.
A distinction is, homver, sought to be drawn between the provisions contained in clauses (b) of sub-sectiaa (1) a'nd (2) of section
51A of the Gujarat Univernity Act, 1949 which provided that no
penalty could be inflicted on a member of the teaching staff without
the prior approval of the Vice-Chancellor or his nominee, and that
contained in Ordinance 33 (4) which comers on the Vice-Chancellor
the power to hear an appeal against an order of dismissal. It is
said that while a provision making the prior approval of the ViceChancellor a condition precedent against dismissal, removal or
reduction in rank of an employee creates a fetter on the exercise
of a disciplinary control, which the employer undoubtedly
has, the provision comerring on the Vice-Chancellor a power to hear
an appeal leaves the power of the employer untouched. We are
afraid, the distinction tried to be drawn is without any basis.
••
We must, accordingly, hold that Ordinance·33(4), Chapter LVll
of tlle Ordinances framed by .the Syndicate of the University under
section 19(J) of the Kerala University Act, 1969 would not be
applicable to a'n educatio:aal institution established and managed by
a religious or linguistic minority like St. Joseph's Training College
for Women, Ernakulam.
Incidentally, the Kerala University Act, 1969 has been repealed
by the Kerala University Act, 1974, which has come into force with
effect from August 18, 1974. Section 65 of that Act confers power
on the Government to constitute a'<l Appellate Tribunal. Any
c
D
E
F
G
H
844
A
B
c
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1979] 1 s.c.R.
teacher aggrieved by an order in any disciplinary proceedings taken
against him may under section 60(7) appeal to the Appellate Tribunal and th~ Appellate Tribunal may, after giving parties an opportunity of beiag heard, and after such further inquiry as may be
necessary, pass such orders thereon as it may deem fit, including an
order of reinstatement of the teacher concerned. Section 61 of the
Act provides that (i) pending disputes between the management
of a private college and any teacher relating to the caaditions of
service are to be decided under and in accordance with the provisioll'S
of the Act, and (ii) past disputes of such nature which have arisen
after August 1, 1967, and had been disposed of before the commencement of the Act, shall, if the management or the teacher
applies to the Appellate Tribunal i'n that behalf withi·a thirty days
of the commencement of the Act, be reopened and decided in
accordance with the provisions of the Act. We have been informed
that the appellant has filed an appeal before the Appellate Tribullal,
Kerala under section 61 (a) of the Kerala Univernity Act. 1974.
We refrain from making a·ay observation with regard to that appeal.
We wish to say that the validity of sections 60(7), 61 and 65 was
not in question before us, and so we express no opinion in regard
theretQ.
The result, therefore, is that the appeals fail and are dismissed.
The judgment of the High Court setting aside the two orders of the
Vice-Chancellor of the University of Kerala dated October 19, 1970,
is upheld though on a different grou:ad, namely, the Vice-Chancellor
under Ordinance 33 ( 1) and ( 4) had no power to entertain the
appeals from the impugned orders of dismissal or suspension of the
appellant. The costs shall be borne by the parties throughout as
incurred.
We are thankful to Sri M. K. Ramamurthi, who appeared as an
amicus curiae for the appellant, for the able assistance he has re-a1
dered.
'
P.H.P.
S49SCl/78-2500 6-4-79-GIPF.
Appeals dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org