MOHAN LAL & ANR. versus AJIT SINGH AND ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 2 May 1978 | [1978] 3 S.C.R. 823 | 1978 INSC 99
Key facts
- Decided
- 2 May 1978
- Bench
- P.N. SHINGAL*, D.A. DESAI
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 377/1975
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [1978] 3 S.C.R. 823
- Neutral citation
- 1978 INSC 99
Text of the judgment
823
MOHAN LAL & ANR.
v.
A
AJIT SINGH AND ANR.
May 2, 1978
[P. N. SIIINGHAL AND D. A. DESAI, JJ.]
B
Evidence Act, 1872-S.114 (a)-Presumption to be drawn against the
accused is a niatter lvhich depends on the circumstances of each case.
Crin1inal Procedure Code, 1973, s. 313-It is permissible to accept that part
of the staten1ent which accords with the evidence on the record and ta act upon
it-Evidence-f"'inger print evidence at crime, scenes, reliability of.
Nishan Chand (deceased), son of appellant l\fohan Lal, resident of Roran\vali, was the Secretary of Roranwali, and Phulukhere Co-operative Societies.
Respondent Ajit Singh, Nishan Chand's friend, was the Secretary of Roranwali
Patti Sikhan Co-operative Society. He also lived in village, Roranwa.li, with his
maternal Uncle Gurdial Singh who was the viilage Chairman. On June 17,
1974 both Nishan Chand and the respondent left for villages Lambi and Malaut
on the farmer's bicycle for depositing the moneys realised on account of the
dues of the Co-operative societies. They did not, howev'er, return to Roranwali
that night. On the next day, Satpal, the younger brother of Nishan Chand,
found the bicycle of his brother lying at some distance from the boundary of
the village near a culvert and his brother's body in a field at a short distance
from there anci informed his father Mohan Lal. Mohan Lal and his brother
Dharam Chand went to the place where the dead body lay. The dead body
had· many in1uries, and a blood stained blade of a knife (Ex. P3) was
lying near it. A black piece of cloth "fifty" was lying at some distance on the
road, and as it was worn by Ajit Singh the_ previous day, a report was lodgca
with the police.
Ajit Singh was arrested on 21st June, 1974 and on his information that be had buried a sum of 41.00/~ and a gold ring in his purse, tied
in a handkerchief, near the 'J.rater lift. and had concealed the blood stained
clothes and a shoe inside the heap of· cotton 'sticks' in a kiln on a road, the
Police recovered those articles at his instance. The bundle of currency .notes
which was recovered at the instance of the respondent contained one currency
note of Rs. 100/- \Vhich was suspected to have fingerprints. Ajit Singh '\\'as
tried· ·and was convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge of offences under
ss. 302, 392 and 397 I.P.C. The Additional Sessions Judge sentenced him to
death for the offence under secton 302 I.P.C. a:nd to rigorous imprisonment
for flve years and seven vears respectively for the offences under sections 392
and 397 J.P.C. On appeaJ, the High Court gave him the benefit of doubt and
acquitted him. Mohan Lal (father of the deceased) and one Surinder Kuniar
filed the present appeal, by special leave.
Allowing the appeal, the Court,
'
•
j
~
(
l
.;
c
D
E
F
IIELD : (I) While considering the statement of the accused under section
313 Cr!. P.C .. 1973 it is permissible to reject the exculpatory part .of the statement if it is disproved. by the evidence on record, and to acts upon it. l832 BC]
:\Tishfkant Jha v. State of Bihar [1969] 2 SCR 1033~ Applied.
(2) The evidence on record \Vas sufficient to sbo'v that the staten1ent of
the respondent which led to the recovery of certain articles was not only voluntary but fell within the purview of section 27 of the Evidence Act in as much as
the ''fact discovered" was the place from which the various articles were produced by the respondent and his knowledge of it. Moreover the actual recovery
of the currency qotes. the ring (be~ring the initials of the deceased) ~nd the
purse (containing a libi;ary card having the address of the resl?on9ent) in pursuance of the information given by the respondent, and at his instance, was
sufficient -marantee of the truth of that information and it could safely have
been relied upon by the High Court. [834 C-D]
(3) There is no gainsaying the fact that a majority ?f. fingerprints fo'!nd at
crime scenes or crime articles are partially smudged, and 1t 1s for the expenenced
and skilled fingerprint expert to say whether a mark is usable as fingerprint
G
H
824
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1978] 3 S.C.R.
evidence. Similarly it is for a competent technician to examine and give his
opinion whether the identity can be established, and if so whether that can be
done on eight or even less identical characteristics in an appropriate case. Jn
this case there was the categorical statement of the Director, Finger Print
Bureau, Phillaur, that one particular impression on the currency note was photographically enlarged alongwith the right middle finger impression of the res~
pendent, that it was comparable, and there existed not less than eight points of
similarity i.e. mat9hing characteristic details in their identical sequence, without
any discordance, between its comparable portion and the corresponding portion
of the photographically enlarged right middle finger impression. The Director
graphically showed the eight points of similarity i~heir same form and position
and indicated the nature, direction and sequence of each point. He clearly stated
that so many points of similarity could not be found to occur in impressions
of different thumbs and fingers and that they were identical and were of one and
the same person. [840 F-G, 841 D-E]
( 4) The recovery of incriminating articles in pursuance of the respondent's
information is an important piece of evidence against him. The question whether
a presumption should be drawn against him under illustration (a) of section
114 of the Evidence Act is a matter with depends on the evidence and the
circumstances of each case. The nature of the recovered articles, the manner
of their acquisition by the owner, the nature of the evidence about their identification, the manner in which the articles were dealt with by the accUsed, the
place and the circumstances of their recovery, the length of the intervening period
and the ability oi; otherwise of the accused to explain the recovery, are some of
those circumstances. All these factors were· against the respondent.
[841 G-H, 842 A]
D
Baiju @ Bharosa v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1978] 2 SCR 594 reiterated.
(5) The ring (Ex. Pl) was made of gold and bore the initials of the
deceased, and the goldsmith was able to establish that it belonged to the
deceased. It was found tied in a handkerchief alongwith other two highly
incriminating articles, namely, the finger marked currency note and the respon·
dent's own purse about whose identity there could possibly be no reason for any
doubt. The respondent knew that he would be suspected of the crime because
E the deceased was last seen in his company, and the fact that he buried the
articles near the water lift in the. middle of the way leading from Khankanwali
to his village shows that he wanted the articles to lie there until he could feel
reassured enough to dig them out. It so happened however that he was suspected from the very beginning, was arrested within four days and gave the informa·
tion within the next two days which led to the discovery of an important fact
within the meaning of section 27 of the Evidence Act. It must therefore be
held that the incriminating articles were acquired by the respondent at one and
the same time and that it was he and no one else who had robbed the deceased
F of the money and the ring and had hidden them at a place and in a manner
which was known to him. Then there is the further fact that the respondent
was unable to explain his lJOSSession. All these facts were not only proof of
robbery but were presumptive evidence of the charge of murder as well.
[842 B·Fl
Wasim Khan v. The State of U.P. [1956] SCR 191; Tulsiram Nanu v. The
State, AIR 1954 SC 1; Sunder/al v. The State of M.P., AIR 1954 SC 28 Alisher
v. State of TJ.P. [1974] 4 SCR 254; and Baiju @ Rharosa v. State of M.P.,
G [1978] 2 SCR 594 reiterated.
(6) The High Court committed serious errors in reading the evidence on
the record and very often based its findings on mere conjectures. Its finding that
the prosecution had failed to "connect the accu~ed with the. commission o! the
crime" was quite incorrect and must be set aside. Reasoning of Hirrh Court
e.xamined with reference to the direct and circumstantial evidence on record.
[838-C-D]
c
H
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Criminal Appeal No. 377
of 1975.
From the Judgment and Order dt. 9th July, 1975 of the Punjab
and Haryana High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 1423 of 1974.
~
I.
•~
f
~~
'1.
'•'
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
825
S. C. Manchanda and N. K. Agarwal for the Appellants.
A
D. Mookerjee, S. K. Mehta, K. R. Nagaraja and P. N. Puri for
Respondent No. 1
I
Hardev Singh for Respondent No. 2.
The Judgment o~ the Conrt was delivered by
7·'
•
-
r\
...
1
•
--·
\
SmNGHAL, J.-This appeal by special leave is directed against
the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Conrt dated July 9,
1975, giving beaefit of doubt to respondent Ajit Singh (hereinafter
referred to a~ the respondent) and acquitting him of offences under
sections 302, 392 and 397 I.P.C. for which he was convicted by the
The
Addi,tional Sessions Judge of Faridkot on Oc;:>ber 31. 1974.
Additiomil Sessions J udgc had sentenced the respondoat to death
for the offence under section 302 I.P.C. and to rigorous imprison·
ment for five years and seven years respectively for the offences under
sections 392 anc.I 397 J.P.C.
Nishan Chand (deceased); son of appellant Mohai' Lal (P. W. 5).
was a resident of Roranwali. He was Secretary of Roramval; and
The respondent was Nishan
Phulu Khera Co-operative Societies.
Chand's friend and was Secretary of Roranwali Patti Sikhan Cp-opcrative Society.
He also used to live in village Roranwali with his
malernal-unclc Gurdial Singh who was the village Chairman.
B
c
D
It is alleged that Nishan Chand and the rcsponde11t left together E
on June l 7, 1974, for villages Lambi and Malout on Nisban Chand's
•
bicycle. as they had to deposit the money realised hy them.
They
Mohan Lal's other
did not however return to Roranwali that •night.
s<1n Satpal, who was studying in Class VIII in a_school at Sikhanwala,
saw Nishan Chand's bicycle lying at some distance from the boundary
of village Roranwall, near a culvert, on the "pakka" road leading to
.....
Sikhanwala, and he also saw a man lying dead in a field at a short dis-. F
tance from there.
As the dead body
appeared
to be
"'
of Nishan Chand, Satpal went back to his house and informed his
father Mohan Lal (P. W. 5) at about 7 a. m. Mohan Lal (P. \V. 5)
~"
and his brother Dharam Chand (P. W. 8) went to the place where the
;
dead body was lying. It had many injnries and a blood stained
I
A black piece ,of cloth
blade of knife ( E~. P. 3) was lying near it.
'
("fifty")
was
!yin!!
at
some
distance
towards
the
road.
As Nishan G
~
Chand used lo bring home the monev of the societies some times.
Mohan Lal rnspected that the respondent might have murdered him
It seemed to him that the black piece of
cloth
for the money.
(''fifty") belonged to the respondent which he was . wearing on the
previous morning. Mohan Lal therefore left for police station Lambi,
which was at a distance of about 9 miles from the place of occurancc.
As he found Sub-inspector Harnek SinQh (P. W. 19) at Sikhanwnfa H
bus stand. he reported the matter to him at about 9.30 a.m.
The
Sub-Inspector recorded. Mohan Lal's statement and sent it along with
constable Mal Singh to police station Lambi for registering a case.
•
"'
..
l..
~
~ ,.. .
I
2-329 SCI/78
826
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1978] 3 S.C.R.
S. I. Harnek Singh went to the place of occurrence with Mohan
Lal and found Dharam Chand (P. W. 8) and Nishan Chand's mother
Smt. Agyawanti near the dead body. He found foot-prints two of
bare foot and one with the shoe near the dead body.
The blade
of knife (Ex. P. 3) was also found lying near the dead body and a
shoe was found lying in the water channel at a distance of 7 or 8
'karams' The small piece of black cloth ("fifty") (Ex. P. 4) was
found lying at a distance of 25 or 30 'karams' from the dead body.
The Sub-Inspector recorded the statement of Smt. Agyawanti. He
lifted moulds of the foot-prints and took them in his possession. The
blood stained blade of knife (Ex. P. 3) was also taken in possession
vide memorandum (Ex. P. K.) and was sealed. The Sub-Inspector
tonk the shoe also in his possession.
He prepared an inquest report and sent Nishan Chand's dead body for post-mortem examination.
Dr. P. K. Narang (P. W. 1) of Civil Hospital Gidderbaha examined
the dead body and found 12 injuric~, all of which were ante-mortem.
The doctor found that Nishan Chand's death was due to the injuries
to vital organs \Of the brain as a result of injuries Nos. I and 2 which
were as follows,-
t
!
"(i) A stab wound with clean cut edges 2. 5x0.5 cm. on
the front of left side of forehead just above the eye
brow. Blood stained brain matter was coming out
of the wound. Bone underneath was cut, and the
wound was directed backwards and downwards .
(ii) A stab wound 3.5Xl cm. with clean cut edges on
the left temporal region of head 7 .5 cm. above the
ear, directed downwards and inwards. Bone unde;neath was cut."
...
The medics! officer expressed the opinion that these two i·njuries were
individually sufficient to canse death in the prdinary course of nature.
F
G
H
It was found during the course of the investigation that Nishan
Chand had collected the dues of the co-operative societies from Atma
Singh, Avtar Singh and Balli Singh and others on June 17, 1974, and
had gone with the respondent to deposit the same in the Central Cooperative Bank, Malout. Inspector Gurdial Singh (P. W. 14) of
the Co-operative department had also gone there to attend a meeting
of his department.
Nishan Chand
and
the
respondent
met him
after
3 p.m.
and asked him to get the
2000/- deposited in the Bank.
He
sum of about Rs.
could not however succeed in .depositing the mioney as the cash had
been closed by that time. It i"s alleged that Nishan Chand collected
Rs. 4156/- and that he and the respondent met Darshan Lal (P. W. 6)
at Lambi at 6.30 o.m.
The prosecution has relied on the statement
of Darshan Lal (P. W. 6) for the subsequent conduct of the respondent and has Jed its evidence to show that he was searched bnt could
not be found.
He was arrested on June 21, 1974, at about 8 p.m,
ne"r vi!JaQe Fatuekhera.
He was interrogated bv the Investigatin~
Ofllcer and is alleged to have made statement Ex.P.O. on June 23,
1974, to the effect that he had buried a sum of about Rs. 41001- and
-
-.
\
•
•
'
,,.
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
827
;~·
?\
~\
- •
.-.1
)
.
•
•
a gold ring in his purse tied in a handkerchief uear the water litt
in the middle of the way leading from village Khankhanwali to Roranwali which he could recover, and that he had kept concealed his clothes
and one shoe under the heap of cotton "sticks" in a kiln on
the
road outside Khankhanwali village which also he could recover. The
respondent's statement to that effect was recorded in the presence
of witnesses Balbir Singh (P. W. 7) and Avtar Singh. The respondent then went to the place near the heap of cotton "sticks" and
recovered the blood stained clo!hes Ex. P. 5 to P. 7, which were in
·jhola' Ex. P. 8, along with a shoe. The recovered articles were
taken in police custody vide memorandum Ex. P. Q. 'lt is fiirther
alleged. that the respondent went to the place near the water lift and
dug out a handkerchief which contained currency notes of Rs. 4142/gold ring Ex. P. 1 and purse Ex. P. 9. One currency note No. AD
53007632 <.>f Rs. 100/- (Ex. P. 10), which was at the top of the
bundle of currency notes, had some blood stained fingerprints. The
purse (Ex. P. 9) was of plastic on which Government College,
Mukhtsar, was written in Punjabi and English and it contained a library
card of R.S.D. College, Ferozepur, which contained the address of
the respondent written in English. The ring was of gold and weighed about 3 grams. The initials 'N. C.' were inscribed on it. All
the articles were sealed and were taken in possession vide memorandum Ex. PR. Mohan Lal (P. W. 5) ha~ identified the ring to be that of
his son Nishan Chand which he was wearing when he left the house.
Kartar Singh (P. W. 17) of village Lambi has stated that he prepared
the ring for Nishan Chand 8 or 9 months before his statement and
had made the inscription as desired by him.
A
The Sub-Inspector made an application before Magistarte Mukhtiar Singh (P. W. 3) on JU!le 28, 1974, for taking the moulds of the
foot-prints of the responde11t. The moulds prepared by him were
not found fit for comparison and were again taken on July 4, 1974 in
They were sent
the presence of Magistrate Dina Nath (P. W. 2).
for comparison to the Director of Forensic Laboratory who has made
his report Ex. P. FF stating that the impressions on the crime mould
were found to tally with the test moulds.
E
Finger impressions (Ex. PF/2) of the respondent were also taken
by Magistrate, Mukhtsar, and were sent for comparison along with the
finger impression on the currency note of Rs. 1001- (Ex. P. 10) to
The Director's report
the Director Fingerprint Bqreau, Phillaur.
Ex. P. BB is on the record. He photographically enlarged the impressions and expressed the opinion that there were eight points of similarity in respect of the form and the position, which were graphically
shown by him in his report, and that the nature, direction and sequence
of each p0int had been indicated in its relevant circle.
According
to the expert, so many points of similarity could not be found to
occur in the impressions of different fingers and that they were "identical or are of one and the same person''. The expert ignored the
of~er impre>sions which were sufficiently smud,ged or were partly
interfered with bv the design and the printed writing of the currency
note or were faint.
B
c
D
F
G
H
828
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS.
£1978) 3 S.C.R.
-~·
The respondent was ,medically examined on the wry next day
of hrs arrest and th~. medical officer's report E~. P .F has been placed
on the rcc'?rd, accoramg to which he had three simple lacerated wounds
of a durat~on of more than 48 hours on the left ring finger.
As ha·s been sfated, the Additional Sessions Jndge of Faridkot found
the respondent gmlty of the offences under sections 302, 392 and 397
I.P C.
As the High Court has set aside the conviction by its impugned 1udgment dated July 9, 1975, by giving the benefit of'doubt to the
respondent, Mohan Lal (P. W. 5), father of Nishan Chand (deceased),
and one Surinder Kumar have filed the present appeal by special
leave.
-~
'·~
. -
The High Court has examined the question of motive first of all
and has referred to the good relations between the rcsoondent and
the deceased.
It has also made a mention of the statement of the
re,pondent that he and the deceased left village
Roranwali on the
bicycle of the deceased, for Malout, on June 17, 1974, at about 7.30
a.m.
The High Court has then examined the evidence of the prosecution regarding the alleged collection of Rs. 42561- by Nishan Chand
from four persons on June 17. 1974. and his failure to deposit the
same in the Central Go-operative Bank at Malout and has taken the
view that the collection of the money by Nishan Chand had not been
proved and that the motive for the crime had not been established.
,.
I
I
;
·-
'
The first item of collection relates to the recovery of Rs. 2000 /from Avtar Singh (P. W. 10) at Malout on June 17, 1974. Avtar
Singh has stated that he had taken a loan from the Co-operative So·
E ciety of his village and had been asked by the deceased to repay it.
He promised to make the repayment at Malout Mandi. 1Ie took his
wheat there pn June 17, 1974. and asked his commission agent to
pay Rs. 20001- to the deceased.
Rs. 20001- were accordingly paid
He has further
stated
by his commission agent to the deceased.
that one Atma Singh (P. W. 12) paid Rs. 623/- in his presence to
Nishan Chand.
Avtar Singh hpwever did not obtain a receipt for
F the payment from Nishan Chand. The High Court has disbelieved the
payment because the name of the commission agent was not disclosed
by Avtar Singh and he d.id not take any receipt or the signature of
Nishan Chand in his bahi in token of the payment. The prosecution
examined Behari Lal (P. W. 26) as the commission agent who had
made the payment of Rs. 20001- on behalf of Avtar Singh to the
deceased. The witness produced his bahi entry Ex. P. W. 26/ A in resG pect of the payment, but the High Court rejected the evidence because
the signature of Nishan Chand was not obtained by Behari Lal.
As
it was possible for the High Court to take that view, we would leave
it al that.
Atma Sin~h (P. W. 12) has stated that he paid Rs. li23/- to the
deceased on June 17, 1974, at 2 p.m. after obtaining the money from
the firm of Shadi Ram Amar Nath of Malout. Avtar Singh
H (P. W. 10) has also stated about the making of that payment hy Atma
Singh m his presence. but the High Court has rejected the evidence
for want of Nishan Chand's receipt for the payment, ancf tlie failure
••
.
.,
-
\
•
•
•
'
........
MOHAN LAL v. AJJT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
829
to cxammc someone on behalf of the firm which had made the payment. Herc again, it cannot be said that the view taken by the
High Court was not possible, and we wonld therefore not disturb i.ts
finding in this respect also.
l-.
/
,,\
•
\
- ..,.
1
.- ~
The prosecution, however, examined Balli Singh (P. W. l 1) who
stated that he paid Rs. 856/- to the deceased on June 17, 1974, vide
:receipt Ex. PS at Malout at 2 p.m. after obtaining the money from
his commission agent. It was stated in the receipt that the payment
had been made by way of recovery of the loan from Balli Singh. It
was not disputed that the receipt was signed by Nishan Chand, and
it is not disputed before us that the name has wrongly been printed
as Nishan Singh in the paper hook. The High Court however rejected the evidence on the ground that Balli Singh did not state who
wrote the receipt Ex. PS and that it bore the signature of Nishan
Chand. We have gone through the statement of Balli Singh and we
have no doubt that it shows that the payment of Rs. 856/- was made
to the deceased vide receipt Ex. PS. There was as such no• justification
for insisting on the disclosure of the name of the scribe of the receipt;
or the production of other evidence to prove the signature of Nishan
Chand thereon. There was also no justification for the High Court
to reject the evidence merely because of the failure to examine a
witness from the shop of the commission agent who had made the
payment. It has to be appreciated that there was in fact no crosscxamlnation worth the name regarding Balli Singh's statement about
' his liability to pay Rs. 856/- to the, Co-operative Society, and tbe
payment of that money by him to the deceased against receipt Ex. PS.
A
B
c
D
E
The prosecution. has, all the same, relied on the statement of
Inspector Gurdev Singh (P.W. 14) who was Inspector of Co-operative Societies at Lambi, to prove the signature of the deceased on
receipt Ex. PS. The High Court has rejected his evidence to this effect
on the ground that the witness did not state that he had seen Nishan
Chand signing and writing, and could identify his signature, and also
because he did not state that "in the ordinary course of business
documents purported to be written by Nishan Chand had been habitually submitted to him." We have gone through the statement of
Gurdev Singh (P.W. 14). He was the Inspector of Co-operative
Societies, Lambi, and Nishan Chand was the Secretary of two Co()perative Societies within his area. The witness was therefore in a
position to state that receipt Ex. PS was in the hand writing of Nishan
Chand and he in fact made a clear statement to that effect in the trial
court. H the defence had any reason to think that he -was not a
competent witness for the purpose of expressing an opinion under
~ection 47 o[ the Evidence, Act, it was open to it to cross-examine him
on the point. The fact however remains that this was not done.
•
'·'-""'
It would thus appear that the High Court could not have rejected the evidence which was furnished by the prosecution in regard
to the payment of Rs. 856/- by examining Balli· Singh (P.W. 11)
and Gurdev Singh (P.W. 14) and by producing the original receipt
F
G
H
830
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1978] 3 S.C.R.
Ex. PS, and we have no hesitation in holding that the finding of the
trial court in regard to that payment was correct and must be restored.
Evidence has also been led to prove the payment of Rs. 667 /to the deceased by one Budh Singh on June 17, 1974, vide pass book
entry Ex. P. 11. It was stated by Gurdev Singh (P.W. 14) that the
entry in the pass book had been made in the hand writing of Nishan
Chand, but the High Court rejected that evidence for the reason
already stated. As there was no justification for doing so, we would
restore the finding of.the trial court regarding that item of payment as
well.
The High Court has gone to the extent of basing its finding to thC"
contrary for the further reason that Mohan Lal (P.W. 5), who was
the father of the deceased, did not state that receipt Ex. PS and the
pass book Entry Ex. P. 11 were written and signed by his son Nishan
Chand. The High Court however forgot that Mohan Lal was an
illiterate man who had thumb-marked even the first information
report Ex. P.G./l and was not in a position to make a statement
regarding the hand-writing or the signature of his son on t!:e two
documents.
So even if the items of Rs. 2,000/- and Rs. 623/- are left out,
the fact would still remain that the deceased had a sum of abcut
Rs. 1533/- with him at the time of his murder. The High Court
has brushed aside the prosecution evidence in this respect by observing that none of the witnesses has deposed that the respondent was
with the deceased at the time when the payments were made to him.
Here again, the High Court lost sight of the statement of Inspector
Gurdev Singh (P. W. 14) who as the Inspector of Co-operative Societies must have known the Secretaries or the societies within his
jurisdiction. He has stated that a meeting was called by the Joint
Registrar of Co-operative Societies at Mafout on June 17, 1974, and
tha.t the deceased and the respondent met him in the Central C!>operative Bank at Malout after 3 p.m. The deceased asked him to
get the mm of more than Rs. 2,000 /- deposited in the bank and the
witness told him that as the cash had been closed by that time, the
money could not be deposited. He has further stated that the
deceased then told him that he would deposit the amount of
Rs. 5,000/- the next day as 1w had some more recoveries to make.
No effective cross-examination was directed against the statement of
the Inspector to this effect, and no effective argument has been made
before us why he should not have been believed. The High Court
thus failed to read the statement of Gurdev Singh correctly even
though it had a direct bearing on the question of the respondent's
knowledge of the money in the possession of the deceased. Its finding to the contrary must be set aside and it must be held that the
prosecution has succeeded in proving its case about the respondeni's
knowledge that the deceased had collected at least Rs. 2,000/- by the
time he met Inspector Gurdev Singh some time after 3 p.m.
~
(.,
,.
1
I
>-
~-
'
•
•
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
831
The High Court has exami~d the question whether there was
evidence to prove that the respondent had absconded after the incident, and has found that it could not be said that he did so to conceal
his guilt. He was arrested on June 21, 1974, and it appears that the
intervening delay would not by itself be evidence of his guilt.
\
¥'
'
I
•
•
•
While dealing with the evidence that the deceased was last seen
in the company of the respondent, the High Court has made a
reference to the statement of Mohan Lal (P,W. 5) and to the respondent's admission that he had gone with the deceased, on his
bicycle, to Malout, on June 17, 1974, The prosecution has examined
Darshan Lal (P.W. 6) in regard to their movements at about 6 p.m.
in Lambi and has placed reliance on the statement of Pritam Smgh
(P.W. 9) about their movements within a short distance of village
Roranwali. We think that the view taken by the High Court m
regard to the evidence of the~e two witnesses is justified and does not
call for interference.
But the High Court went wrong in finding that there was no cw1dence to prove that the accused was seen with the deceased "before
or after the occurrence," There could possibly be no evidence to
prove that the respondent was seen with the deceased "after" the
occurrence i,e, after his death and the prosecution cannot be blamed
for its inability to -produce any such evidence. The prosecution has
however led its evidence to prove that the deceased was last seen in
the company of the responden\, and it will be enough to ref~r to two
basic facts in this respect- Firstly, the respondent has· adniittcd-in
his statement in the trial court that he and Nishan Chand first went
to Lambi on June 17, 1974; and he did not deny that they went
the.re on Nisl]an Chand's bicycle at about 7.30 a.m. He has also
admitted that he was with Nishan Chand at Malout upto 10 a.m.
He claimed that he went to village Ferozepur thereafter to meet his
elder brother, but that was a matter for hilll to prove, and thereby
establish a good defence. The fact however remains that he did not
do so and his learned counsel has not thought it possible to explain
why he could not examine his own brother to establish that olea, or
to invite our attention to any other evidence that may have been led
in that behalf. Secondly, the High Court Jost sight of the fact that
Inspector Gurdev Singh (P. W. 14) of the Co-operative Societies.
Department had clearly stated that he went to Malout OJli J unc 17,
1974 to attend the meeting which had been called by the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies and that the respondent and the
deceased met him there after 3 p.m. in the Central Co-operative
Bank He has further stated that the deceased asked him to get the
sum of Rs. 2,000/- deposited in the bank, but that could not be done
as the cash had been closed. The witness has stated that a meeting
was actually held in the Rest House that day and that he had gone
to the Bank to collect the figures of recovery for purposes of that
meeting, The presence of. the de~eased. and ,the respondent was
therefore quite natural as 1t explams their anxiety to make as much
recovery as possible before the meeting. As has been sho:vn, there
was no reason for disbelieving the statement of Gurdev Smgh, and
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
832
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1978] 3 S.C.R.
the _High Coun clearly misread the record in respect of a material
particular m holdmg that there was no evidence to prove that the respondent was last seen in the company of the deceased.
An attempt was made to argue that if the statement of the respondent is to be considered at all. it must be taken as a whole and that
it is not permissible to act upon one portion of the statement which
shows the presence of the respondent in the company of the deceased,
and leave out those portions which arc exculpatory. It will be
enough to say that the matter has been examined by this Court in
Nishi Kant Iha v. State of Bihar('), and as the evidence on the
record disproves the exculpatory part of the respondent's statement
in the trial court, it is clearly permissible to accept that part of the
statement which accords with the evidence on the record, and to act
upon it.
Another important piece of evidence against the respondent was
his statement Ex. P-0. dated June 21, 1974, under section 27 of the
Evidence Act and the recoveries which were made iii pursuance
thereof. The statcincnt was recorded by Sub-Inspector Hai·nek Siiigh
(P.W. 19) in the presence of Avtar Singh and Balbir Singh (P.W.
7). The prosecution gave up Avtar Singh on the ground that he ha'J
been won over, but Balbir Singh and Harnek Singh were examined
in the trial court. The High Court however rejected the entire evidence in that respect on the ground that the statements of these two
witnesses were contradictory and inconsistent with each other and
held that the making of disclosure statement and the alleged recovery
were "concocted by the police." The only contradiction which has
been pointed out by the High Court is that while according to Harnck
Singh the interrogation of the respondent started on June 23, 1974
at about 12 noon and continued for two hours, Balbir Singh has
stated that he and Avtar Singh reached the police station at about
12.30 p.m. and the respondenj was interrogated for about 5 or 7
minutes in their orcsence and that he did not make the disclosure
statement. The High Court has stated further that Balbir Singh has
claimed that he advised the respondent to give the articles which he
Jrnd in his possession, and then he made the disclosure statement.
~reference to the statements of Harnck Singh (P.W. 19) and Balbir
Singh (P.W. 7) shows however that there is no contradiction or
inconsistency between them. Balbir Singh (P.W. 7) has clearly
stated that when he reached the police station at about 12.30 p.m.
the respondent was being interrogated there. His further statement
that the respondent was interrogated for five or seven minutes in his
presence, cannot therefore belie the statement of Harnek Smgh tnat
the interrogation lasted for about two hours. The Hi!!h Court therefore misread the evidence in this respect. The High Court also misread the statement of Balbir Singh when it observed that he had
admitted that he did not "know" whether the disclosure statement
(Ex. P.O.) was recorded at the police station before the articles were
recovered or thereafter. Here again a reference to Balbir Singh's
statement shows that what he stated was that he did not "remember"
(I) [1969] 2 S.C.R. 1033.
1
..,
(.,
~
("
'
t-
'.
•
•
MOHAN LAL l'. AJIT SINGll
(Shinghal, J.)
833
if the disclosure statement was recorded before or after the recovery.
He however proved statement Ex. P.O. and admitted that he attested
it. He also stated that his own statement was recorded after the
recovery. It was not found possible to point out any inconsistency in
his version in that statement and his statement in. the trial court.
The High Court, therefore, clearly fell into an error of record in
reaching the .conclusion that the statement of the Sub-Inspector was
belied by the statement of the witness.
The High Court has observed in this connection that Balbir Singh
(P.W. 7) has stated that there were certain footprints near the place
where the money was recovered, but no moulds were prepared by
the police even though it was incumbent for it to do so. We have
gone through the statement of Balbir Singh, but he has not made any
If however anything turned on the failure to take
such statement.
the moulds of the footprints at the place where the money was recovered, the proper course for the defence was to cross-examine the
Investigating Ofiicer concerned in that respect, but that was not done.
The High Court has disbelieved the statement of Balbir Singh
(P.W. 7) for the further reason that he had been convicted on some
occosions and his explanatioa that he had gone to the police station
to inquire from the Sub-Inspector whether they should continue to
depute men to keep watch on electricity installations and the SubInspector's reply in the negative. had not been entered in the record
of the police station. The High Court has obviously relied in this
respect on Balbir Singh's statement that no entry was made in the
daily diary about his visit and inquiry from the Sub-Inspector, but it
was not noticed by the High Court that Balbir Singh was not iii a
position to depose anything about the making er not making of an
entry in the police diary. That was a matter which could be established by cross-examining the Sub-Inspector or by producing any
other evidence which could show that the entry had not been made in
the daily diary. So here again the High Court cannot be said to
have read the evidence on the record correctly.
~
(
••
The High Court has gone to the extent of recording a finding that
the disclosure statement Ex. P.O. was involuntary as the respondent
was "interrogated for several 11 ours after his arrest'', and was hit by
section 24 cf the Evidence Act. The fact however remains that even
tile respondent has not stated that he was compelled to make the
disclosure statement. and there is no other evidence to show that this
was so. The High Court has arrived at its conclusion to the contrary
on the basis of the statement of Harnek Singh (P.W. 19). The
relevant portion of that statement reads as follows,"On 21st June, 1974, I interrogated him where he was
arrested. He was then taken to Roranwali and was interrogated there in the presence of many persons. From there
we returned to police station at I 0-30 P.M. On 22nd June,
1974 he was again interrogated at the police station. But
no other person was present at the time of the interrogation. He did not give any disclosure statement that day.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
834
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1978] 3 s.c.a.
He was interrogated regarding the handle of the knife. On
23rd June, 1974 I started interrogating the accused at about
12 noon. The witnesses came to the police station of their
own accord. I interrogated him for about two hours."
Three fact~ therefor~ emerge from the statement : (i) that the total
penod of mtcrrogat10n was about two hours, (ii) the interrogation
was made m th.e presence of many persons, and (iii) the interrogation was regardmg the discovery of the handle of the knife of which
th~ blade was found lying near the dead body. There was thus no
evidence on the reco.rd to justify the finding of the High Court that
the respondent was mterrogated for several hours and that his disclosn~e statement was involuntary so as to attract section 24 of the
Evidence Act. .As it is, the evidence on the record was sufficient to
silo"'. that the statement was not only voluntary bnt it fell within the
purview of section 27 of the Evidence Act in as much as the "fact
discovered" was the place from which the various articles were produced by the respondent and his knowledge of it. As the information given by the respondent related to that important fact, it was
clearly admissible under section 27 of the Evidence Act. Moreover
the actual ifecovery of the currency notes, the ring and the purse in
pursuance of the information given by the respondent, and at his
instance, was sufficient guarantee of the truth of that information and
it could safely ·have been relied upon by the High Court. The High
Court misread the evidence on the record in taking a contrary view.
The disclosure statement led to the recovery of clothes in bag
Ex. P. 8 and a shoe underneath the cotton 'sticks' in the kiln near
the 'phirni' of village Khankhanwali vide memorandum Ex. P.O.
Then there was the recovery of a bundle of currency notes of the
value of Rs. 4142/- on top of which was the currency note Ex. P. 10
of Rs. 100/- which was suspected to have some fingerprints, the ring
Ex. P. 1 bearing the initials cl Nishan Chand, and the purse Ex. l>. 9
containing the library card of R.S.D. College, Ferozcpur, with the
address of the respondent. All these were found tied in a handkerchief. which was dug out by the respondent at a place near the
water lift in the middle of the way leading from village Khankhanwali
vide memorandum Ex. P.R. The High Court brushed aside all this
highly incriminating evidence simply on the ground that the respondent ha~ stated (in his statement under section 313 Cr.P.C.) that
the purse was taken by the Sub-Inspector at the time of his arrest and
he had obtained Rs. 4000/- from his. relations on the pretext that
he would get him discharged but later on ~astened .a false case on
him. The High Court went on to say that 1t was highly doubtful 1f
the respondent would have buried such a big amount of money and
the ring in a field situated in anot~e'. village :when he could hayc
concealed them in the land or bmldmg of his maternal-uncle 111
village Roranwali. The High Court lost sight of the fact that while
on one side there was the testimony on oath which was subjected to
cross-examination on the other there was the bare statement of the
accused. The High Court could not reasonably haye ~oubted ~e
recoveries simply because the property was found buned m a field 111
!{
(,,
' ('
I'
t-
MOHAN LAL V. AJIT SINGH (Shingha/, J.)
•
835
another village and not in the land or building of his maternal uncle.
As is obvious, the reasoning of the High Court was nothing more
than a conjecture, for which there was no evidence or justification.
The respondent was anxious to hide the ill gotten property as soon
as possible, and the fact that it was recovered in pursuance of his information under section 27 of the Evidence Act, and at his instance, by
his digging out the place where it lay buried, was quite sufficient to
prove the genuineness of the recovery. It appears that as the High
Court had reached the conclusion that the information under section
27 was involuntary and was not admissible in evidence, it did_ not
find it possible to attach any importance to the recovery of the articles
in pursuance of that information.
A
The High Court has disbelieved the statements of Mohan Lal
(P.W. 5) father of the deceased, and Kartar Singh (P.W. 17) goldsmith of Lambi, that ring Ex. P. 1 belonged to the deceased. The
statement of Mohan Lal has _been disbelieved on the ground that he
did not know the name of the person who prepared it, he could not
tell the date of its preparation, he did not identify the ring at ·a!est
identification and he did not state in the .first information report that
his son Nishan Chand was wearing the ring. We have gone through
the evidence and it appears that the High Court did not read it
correctly. Mohan Lal has stated that the ring was got prepared by
his son Nishan Chand in village Lambi two or four months before the
incident. He was not therefore in a position to name the goldsmith
or to give the date of its preparation. The ring was not put up for
test identification and there was therefore no evidence to show that
Mohan Lal did not identify it "from the other rings of the same
kind". As regards the omission from the first information report
of the fact regarding the wearing of the ring by Nishan Chand, the
High Court did not take into consideration that part of Mohan Lal's
statement where he had stated that as his wife did not tell him that
Nishan Chand was wearing the ring, he could not mention that fact
in the report. Moreover his wife did not accompany him to the
police station.
c
The High Court disbelieved the statement of Kartar Singh (P.W·
17) for the reason that he did not pay income-tax or sales-tax and
had admitted that there was no special mark on the ring to show that
it had been prepared by him. In taking that view the High Court
Jost sight of fhe fact that Kartar Singh was a goldsmith of a village like
Lambi and, in the absence of the evidence to the contrary, he could
not have been disbelieved merely because he did not pay income-tax
or sales-tax. The statement of Kartar Singh that he prepared ring
Ex. P. 1, eight or nine months before the recording of his statements
at the instance of Nishan Chand, and that the inscription ~thereon was
made under Nishan Chand's instructions, was quite clear and categorical, and could not have been rejected in the absence of evidence
to the contrary. It is true that the ring did not bear any spe6al
mark to show its preparation by the witness, but the High Court did
not read that part of Kartar Singh's statement where he had stated
that he had started working as a goldsmith from the age of 12 years
B
D
E
F
G
H
836
A
c
D
E
F
G
H
[J 978] 3 S.C.R.
a.nd that although he had prepa:ed many rings, he could tell which
rmg_was p_rep?red by him on_see1~ it: There was therefor.e no justificat10n fo1 re1ectmg Kartar Smgh s evidence and for doubbmg him as
· ·
a "highly unreliable" witness.
.
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
As has been stated, the purse Ex. P.9 was also recovered at the
m~tance of the. respondent along with ring Ex. P. 1 and the currency
notes and the fact of its recover7 could not have been rejected merely
on the basis. of the respondents statement under section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure that it had been taken by the Sub-Inspector from his pocket at the time of his arrest. Apart from the fact
that the explanation of the respondent was quite improbable, we find
tliat he has not found it possible to establish it by any evidence on
the record. The purse was of black coloured plastic on which
Government College, Mukhtsar, was written in Punjabi and English
and it contained a library card of R.S.D. College, Ferozepur. ~ on
which the address of the respondent was written in English. The
fact that the purse was found tied in the same handkerchief along
with the ring Ex. p. 1 and the currency notes, could leave no room
for doubt that it belonged to the respondent and all the recovered
articles were in his possession soon after the' incident.
As has been stated, the bundle of currency notes, which was
recovered at the instance of the respondent contained the'-hiin<lred
rupee currency note (Ex. P. 10) No. AD 53007632 with fingerprints thereon. The High Court rejected that important piece of
evidence on the ground that Balbir Singh (P. W. 7) did not state
that the currency note had fingerprints, it was not explained wh\ the
currency note was not sent to the Finger Print Bureau immedwtclv.
why it was sent there after the arrest of the respondent alongwith
his specimen impressions, and also because there was no proof that
the specimen fingerprint impressions were of the respondent and there
was no evidence to ,show on what date they were taken. The High
Court has once again made a reference to the statement of the respondent under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure that
the Police took his fingerprint impressions on the currency note while
he was in police custody, and rejected the report (Ex. P. BB) of the
Director Finger Print Bureau, Phillaur.
We have gone tl1rough the statement of Balbir Singh (P.W, 7)
and we find that he has clearly stated that "one currency note co~
tains fingerprint marks". The High Court therefore misread the evidence in this respect also.
The other reason about not sending the currency note to the
Finger Print Bureau until after the arrest of the respondent, is equally
untenable because the High Court lost sight of the fact , that the
currency note was recovered on June 23, 1974, only after the arrest
of the respondent, and there was. nothing wrong _if it was sent. alongwith his specimen fingerprmts wh~ch had necessanly to be obtamed bv
making an application to a magistrate.
;{
·~
1
..
('
~j.
-
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH
).~
y
•
-
1'
.4
•
•
••
(Shinghal, J.)
837
The specimen impressions Ex. PF/2 of the fingers of the respondent
were taken by the Muktsar Magistrate on June 28, 1974. Question
No. 28 was asked of the respondent whether that was so, and he
gave a categorical reply that the evidence in that respect was "correct".
The High Court therefore again did not read a material part of the
record in taking the contrary vi<;w. The High Court seems to have
accepted the statement of the respondent that the Police took -11is
finger impressions on the currency note while he was in Police custody, bu\ it not only lost sight of the fact that there was no evidence
to that effect, but also of the fact that the prosecution had succeeded
in proving the recovery by the reliable evidence on the record. Moreover if the Police had forcibly taken the fingerprints, none of them
would have been faint or smudged or on the printed or written portion
of the note.
It will be recalled that Dr. P. K. Narang (P.W. 1) performed the
post-mortem examination on the body of Nishan Chand, and the
High Court has taken the view that his evidence showed that the
injuries could not have been inflicted with the knife of which Ex.P. 3
was the blade and that "possibly three types of weapons were nse<l to
cause injuries". We have gone through the statement of Dr. Narang
(P.W. 1). What he has stated is that some of the injuries were
caused hy a sharp pointed weapon, one injury by a sharp-edged
weapon and injuries Nos. 10. 11 and 12 by a blunt weapon. The
witness clarified that injuries Nos. 11 and 12 could be caused by a
fall. and injury No. l 0 being a linear abrasion could be caused by
the point of any substance. As regards the incised injuries, the wit11ess has stated that it was not necessary that the stab wounds could
have been caused by a weapon of which both the edges were sharp.
The presence of those injuries could not therefore justify the inference
of the High Court that they required three types of weapons. Blade
(Ex.P. 3) was sent to the Chemical Examiner to the Government of
Punjab and his report Ex.P. AA contains a diagram of its shape,
which clearly shows that it was a peculiar blade with a pointed end
as well as a sharp blade. The High Court therefore erred in holding
•h~t the injuries which were found on the person of the deceased
could not have been inflicted with a knife having Ex.P. 1 as its blade.
The High Court rejected the prosecution evidence for the further
reason that the bicycle of the deceased, which was lying on the road.
was not in a damaged condition and did net have blood stains, and
also because the respondent could not have dragged the deceased
alone to a distance of 50 or 60 'karams' and inflicted all the injuries
with his knife. Herc again, the High Court went beyond the record
because it was not the case of the prosecution that the bicycle \Vas
damaged at the time of the incident, or that it was stained with blood,
or that the incident took place near the place where the bicycle was
found by the witnesses so as to have blood stains near it. It was
also not the case of the prosecution that the respondent dragged the
deceased to a distance of 50 or 60 'kararns' from the road. As
regards the infliction of the injuries by the respondent singly, there
was no reason for the High Court to think that was not possible.
Blade of the knife was recovered near the dead body of Nishan
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
838
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME C-OURT REPORTS
[ J 978] 3 S.C.R.
Chand, without the handle, and it is not disputed before us. that it
was stained with human blood. We have made a reference To the
diagram of the knife and the fact that it had a pointed end and a
sharp edge. Dr. Narang (P.W. 1) has stated that the first two
injuries were stab wounds on the left side of the fore-head and the
left temporal region, and were indivitlually suflicient to cause death.
They could be caused by a sharp pointed weapon and there was
nothing to prevent a single person from inflicting one of those injuries
initially and disabling the victim of his capacity to resist thereafter.
It is the case of the prosecution that the deceased and the respondent
were friends and were moving abont on the bicycle of the decca;c<l.
The deceased must therefore have been caught unawares when the
respondent dealt him the first fatal blow on a vital part of t11c body
and would not have been in a position to resist him thereafter. The
handle of the knife gave w_ay, and that also showed that it was used
with force.
It would thus appear that the High Court committed the aforesaid serious errors in reading the evidence on the record and very
often based its findings on mere conjectures. Its finding that the
prosecution had failed to "connect the accused with the commission
of the crime" is quite incorrect and must be set aside''.
The evidence against the respondent in this case is circumstantial.
We have discussed a part of it while examining the findings of the
High Court, and it will be enough to mention those facts and circumstances which have been established against the respondent beyond
any doubt.
It has been stated by Mohan Lal (P.W. 5) that his son Nishan
Chand and the respondent had good relations with each other and
that they left for Malout on June 17, 1974, together, on Nishan
Chand's bicycle. This has in fact not been disputed before us. Wc
have examined th.e evidence regarding the collection of at least
F Rs. 1523/- by Nishan Chand from Balli Singh (P.W. 11) and Budh
Singh and have given our reasons for the finding that the deceased
had at least that much money with him when he and the respondent
met Inspector Gurdev Singh (P.W. 14) at Malout. The prosecution
has in fact Jed its evidence to prove that the deceased had collected
Rs. 4156/- on that day, but as a matter of abundant caution we have
left out two of those collections in holding that at least Rs. 1523/G had been collected by him. We have also made a mention of Gurdcv
Singh's statement that the deceased asked him to get a sum of more
than Rs. 2000/- deposited in the Central Co-operativ<j Bank at Malout
in the presence of the respondent and ms inability to do so as the
cash had been closed. The allegation of the prosecution that the respondent committed the murder of Nishan Chand for the purpose of
robbing him of the money has been established by the fact that
H Rs. 4142/- were actually recovered at the instance of the resoondent.
in pursuance of the information furnished by him in Ex. P. o. on
June 23, 1974, and at his instance within two days of his arrest.
:r
·\
'<
~
-
{'
t·
...·
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
,_..,.
r
¥
',
~
•
~
.~
839
The respondent has himself admitted that he and the deceased A
went to village Lambi on June 17, 1974, at 7.30 a.m. and then went
to Malout. Inspector Gurdcv Singh (P.W. 14) has stated that his
moresaid talk with Nishan Chaud in the presence of the respondent
took place when they met him at Malout after 3 p.m. on June 17,
1974. The respondent stated, in the trial court that he left Nishan
Chand at Malout at 10 a.m. He did not however lead any evidence
to prove his contention, which has in fact been disproved by the B
statement of Inspector Gurdev Singh that they were together with him
until some time after 3 p.m. that day. The deceased was not seen
alive after he had met Inspector' Gurdev Singh in the company of the
respondent and the categorical statement of the Inspector Gurdev
Singh that they both went away leaves no room for doubt that was
the last occasion when they were seen together. Mohan Lal (P.W.
5) has stated that neither his son Nishan Chand nor the respondent C
returned to the village in the evening, and the next day his son's
bicycle was found lying on the "pakka" road going from Roranwali
to Sikhanwala and Nishan Chand's dead body was also found nearby.
The respondent tried to take the plea, in his statement in the trial
court, that he was at F erozepur on the night of the alleged incident D
as he had gone there to meet his cider brother who was a conductor
in the Punjab Roadways. He did not however lead any evidence in
support of that statement. On the other hand, Sub-Inspector Hamek
Singh (P.W. 19) has stated that after recording the first information
report he made a search for the respondent in villages Roranwali and
Khankhanwali and even stayed in village Khankhanwali for the night.
He has stated further that the respondent could be arrested only on E
June 21, 1974, at about 8 p.m. near village Fatuekhera. The respondent has not succeeded in explaining his absence or his movements during the intervening period and has failed in his attempt to
establish his presence at Ferozepur on the fateful night. A halting
attempt was made by the respondent to set up the explanation tho!
he was produced before the police on June 18, 1974, by hi~ relation
F
Hazra Singh, but he did not find it possible to establish it also.
•
•
We have referred to our finding that the respondent voluntarily
made the disclosure statement Ex.P.O. on June 23, 1974, and
Rs. 4142/- in currency notes (including currency note Ex.P. 10
having fingerprints), ring Ex.P. 1 and purse Ex.P. 9 were recovered
in pursuance o~ that information, tied in a handkerchi_ef, when the G
respondent dug them out from a place near the water lift in the middle
of the way going from Khankhanwali to Roranwali. The ring
Ex.P. 1 bore the initials of the name of the deceased and the purse
Ex. P. 9 contained enough particulars to show that it belonged to the
respondent and to no ooe else. In fact the identity of the purse, as
kis own property, has been admitted by the respondent in his <Mement in the trial court where he merely contended that the nurse
containing bi's address was taken bv the Sub-Tnsoector from his pocket H
at the time of his arrest. As has been stated, he could not establish
that contention, and we have no doubt that it is quite false.
840
A
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS ·
[J 978] 3 S.C.R.
As regards the recovery of Rs. 4142/-, all that the respondent
could contend was that after his arrest the Sub-Inspector asked his
relations to give him Rs. 4000/- on the pretext that he would act
him discharged from the case, and that his relations contributed the
amount and handed it over to the Sub-Inspector who later on "foisted
the amount on me to implicate me falsely in this case." Apart
from the fact that the respondent has not led any evidence to prove his
contention, we find that the prosecution has succeeded in proving
beyond doubt that the hundred rupee currency note !'10~ AD
53007632, which was on the top of all the currency notes- wliich
were recovered .at the instance of the respondent, bore fingerprints
at least one of which has been found to be of the respondent and of
no one else.
c
D
We have given our reasons for rejecting the statement of the respondent that the police got his finger impression on the currency
not•" while he was in custody at the police station. The respondent
was an educated man who was employed as the Secretary of the local
Co-operative Society and who had an influential maternal uncle. The
police could not therefore hav•o obtained his fingerprints in the maimer
alleged by him and the respondent wou:d have resisted any such
attempt to create irrebuttable evidence against him of a serious charge
like murder and he or his unck would have exposed it immediately.
We have examiocd the evidence of the prosecution regarding the
taking of specimen fingerprints of the respondent, their comparison and
examination with the fingerprint on the currency note by the Director,
E Fing"r Print, Bureau, Phillaur. and his report Ex. P. BB. As the impression mark A on the currency note was partly smudged and partly
on the design a'nd the printed writing, it was photographically enlarged
along with the right middle finger impression of the respondent, and
the two photographic enlargements were marked Al A and I/I respectively. The Director has given the opi'nion that the photographically
enlarged impression marked A/ A was "partly smudged but.
otherwise. it is comparable and there exist sufficient (not
F less than 8) points of similarity i.e. matching ridge characteristic
details in their identical sequence. without any discordances. between
its comparable portion and tho corresponding portion of the photographically enlarged right middle finger impression of A.iit Singh marked
I/I." The Director has further stated that he had graphical:y show'n
the 8 points of similaritv "in their same form and position" and had
G indicated the "nature, dirzction and sequence of each point" in its
relevant circle. He has exprerned the categorical opinion that so many
points of similarity could not be found to occur i'n impressions of
different thumbs and fingers and that thev \Wre therefore "identical"
or were "of one and the -sa1ne person." There were other impressions
also on the currency no1·'s. but thev were either sufficiently smudged
awl nartlv interfered with by the design a'nd the printed matter or were
sufficiently faint and were rejel'ted as unfit for comparison.
H
Nothing substantial has been urged to challenge the opinion of the
Director of the Finger Print Bureau, and all that has be•en argued is
~
,
i
~
I:
t·
·~
MOHAN LAL V. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, J.)
.....
J:
-
""~~
~
I
-1
841
ihat as there were only 8 points of similarity, ther•.o was not enough
basis for the expert's opinion about the identity of the fingerprints.
Reference in this connection has been made to B. L. Saxena's "Jdentification of Handwriting, Disputed Documents, Finger Pri·nts, Foot Prints
and Detection of Forgeries'', 1968 edition, page 247, Walter R. Scott's
"Fingerprint Mechanics" page 62, and M. K Mehta's "The Identification of Thumb Impressions and the Cross-Examination of Finger
Prillt ExP'.orts" 2nd edition, page 28. We have gone through these
books but they do not really support the argument of the learned
counsel for the respondent. While referring to the old practice of
looking for a minimum of 12 identical characteristic d•etai!s, Saxena has
admitted that the modern view is that six points of similarity of pattern
are sufficient to establish the identity of the fi'ngerprints. Walter Scott
has stated that "as a matter of practice, most •experts who work with
fingerprints constantly satisfy themselves as to identity with eight or
even six points of identity. Mehta has also stated that iri the case
-0f blurred impressions the view of some of the Indian experts is that if
there were three identical points, they would be sufficient to prove the
identity.
Th~re is no gainsaying the fact that a majority of fingerprints found
at crime scene or crime articles are partially smudged, and it is for the
experienced and skilled fingerprint expert to say whether a mark is
usable as fingerprint evidence. Similarly it is for a competent technician to examine and give his opinion whether the identity can be established, and if so whether that can be done Dn eight or even less identical characteristics in an appropriate case. As has been point•od out,
the opinion of the Director of the Finger Print Bureau in this case is
clear and categorical and has been supported by adequate reasons. We
have therefore no hesitation in accepting it as correct.
• j.
A
B
c
D
E
•
It will be recalled that the explanatioll of tho respondent about the
recovery of Rs. 41421- from his purse Ex. P. 9 is quite unsatisfactory.
He has not found it possible to give any explanation why the deceased's
ring Ex. P. l was found tied with tho~o articles in his handkerchief.
We have no doubt that the recovery of these articles is a strong piece
-0f circumstantial evidence against him.
~
·~
'
'
""
I
't
·-
....
The prosecution recoverod some blood stained clothes and shoes
ulso ail~ led its evidence regarding the taking of the moulds, and their
-comparison. We do not however think it necessary to examin1~ it as
it cannot be said to be quite clear.
The recovery of the incriminating articles in pursuance of the respondoont's information is an important piece of evidence against him.
As has been held by this Court in Baiju alias Bharosa v. State of
Madhya Pradesh('), the question whether a presumption should be
drawn against the respondent under illustration (a) of section 114 of
the Evidence Act is a matter which depends on the evidence and the
circumstances of each case. The nature of the recovered articles, the
manner of their acquisition by the owner, the natnre of the evidence
(1) [1978] 2 SCR. 594.
3-329 SCI/78
p
G
H
' 842
SUPREME COURT REPORTS·
(1978] 3 S.C.R.
A
about their identification, the manner in which the articles were dealt
with by the accused, the place and the circumstances of their recovery,
the length of the intervooibg period and the ability or otherwise of the
accused to explain the recovery, are some of those circumstances. As.
the ring Ex. P. 1 was made of gold and bore· the initials of the deceased,
and the goldsmith Kartar Singh (P.W. 17) had established its identity,
there could be no doubt whatsoever that it belonged to the deceased.
B It is also a matter of great significance that it was found tied in a
handkerchief alongwith the other two highly incriminating articles,
namely, the finger marked cnrrency note Ex. P. 10 and the respondent's purse Ex. P. 9 about whose identity there can possibly be no
reason for any doubt. The re!!pondent knew that he would be ·suspected of the crime because the deceased was last seen in his company,
and the fact that he buried the articles near the water lift in the middle
C of the way leading from Khankhanwali to his village Roranwali snows
that he wanted the articles to lie there until he could feel reassured
enough to dig them out. It however so happened that he was suspected from the very beginni"ng, was arrested within four days and
gave the information within the next two days which led to the discovery of an important fact within the meaning of section 27 of the
D Evidence Act. It must therefore be held that the incriminating articles
were acquired by the respondent at one and the same time and that
it was he and no ane else who had robbed the deceased of the money
and the ring and had hidden them at a place and in a manner which
was known to him. Then there is the further fact that the responde"nt
was unable to explain his possession of the ring and the money and
did not even attempt to do so. The currency note Ex. P. 10 was found
E on the top of the bundle of currency notes of the value of Rs. 41421-,
and we have given our reasons for holding that it bore the respondent's
fingerprint. It will be recalled that the deceased was undoubtedly in
possession of currency notes because of the realisation he had made
from the debtors of the Co-operative Society only a little while earlier,
and the fact that the respondent hid the notes after tying them in a
handkerchief, shows that he knew that their possessions with him would
F be incriminating and unexplainable. The intervening period between
the loss of the money and the ring by the d·~ceased and their recovery
was not more tha"n six days, which was quite a short period. All these
facts were not only proof of robbery but were presumptive evidence
of the charge of murder as well. Rerereuce in this connection may be
made to the decisions in Wasim Khan v. The State of Uttar Pradesh('),
Tulsiram Kanu v. The State,(2) Sunder/al v. The State of Madhya
G Pradesh("), Alisher v. Statte of Uttar Pradesh (') and Baiju alias
Bharosa v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (supra).
In fact it has not been disputed before us that if the respo~dent's
possession of the incriminating articles was held proved, the crrcumstantial evidence against him would be sufficient to justify the trial
H
(I) [1956) S.C.R. 191.
(2) AIR 1954 S.C. I
(3) A.LR. 1954 S.C. 28.
(4) [1974) 4 s.c.c. 254.
;~
,..
~I
-
t
i
f·
•
'
7
~
r '
•
•
'\
-~
•
'
.
MOHAN LAL v. AJIT SINGH (Shinghal, !.)
843
court's :finding that he was guilty of the offence under section 302 for
colilmitting the murder of Nishan Chand and the offence of robbery
under section 392 read with section 397 I.P.C.
F1>r the reasons mentioned above, the appeal is allowed, the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside and respondent Ajit
Singh is convicted of the offunces under sections 302 and 392/397
I.P.C. In the circumstances of the case, we think it sufficient to sentence him to imprisonment for life for the offence under section 302
I.P.C. and to imprisonment for seven years for the offence under section 392/397 I.P.C. Both the sentences will run concurrently.
s.R.
Appeal allowed.
A
B
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org