M. NARAYANA RAO versus G. VENKATA REDDY & OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 September 1976 | [1977] 1 S.C.R. 490 | 1976 INSC 209
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 September 1976
- Bench
- HANS RAJ KHANNA*, N.L. UNTWALIA, JASWANT SINGH
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 583/1974
- Disposal
- Disposed off
- Citation
- [1977] 1 S.C.R. 490
- Neutral citation
- 1976 INSC 209
Text of the judgment
490
A
M. NARAYANA RAO
v.
B
G. VENKATA REDDY & OTHERS
and vice versa
September 3, 1976
[H. R. KHANNA, R. S. SARKARIA AND JASWANT SINGH, JJ.]
c
D
E
F
G
H
Election-Representation of the People A.ct, 1951-Sec. 123(2)-,S'ec.
100(1)(b)-Corrupt Practice-Undue influence-Conduct of Election Rules 1961
-Rule 39(2) (b)-Ballot paper containing mark on the reverse of the symbolCan be rejected a3 invalid-Charge of corrupt practice-If of quasi criminal
nature-Degree of proof-Interference with appreciation of evidence by Hi!?h
Court-Whether election result can be li1?ht/y i'ntufered with.
For the election to the Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly out of 6
candidates 4 withdrew and Reddy aind Rao were the only contestants. Rao was
elected by a margin of a few hundred votes. Reddy challenged election of Rao
by filing an election petition in the High Court on several grounds of corrupt
practice, as well as on the ground that there were mistakes in counting of the
votes. Reddy in his election petition besides asking for the setting aside of the
election of Rao also claiimed that he should be declared elected in his place.
The High Court ordered a recount of votes. However, even after the recount,
Rao had still majority of votes in his favour although the margin was reduced.
The Election Petitioner contended that he was the sitting member and WllS
Yery popular and that he lost election on account of undue influence, force ood
viofonce on a large scale used by Rao. It was alleged that about 200 supporters
of Rao· with the active assistance of respondent No. 2, one of the candidare.,
who had withdra.wn, threatened, beat and threw stones at the voters and supporters of Reddy; that as a result of the violence the polling had to be stopped
and the polling took place later on; that about 300 supporters of Rao armed
with sticks, iron rods and other weapons surrounded the hotel where Reddy was
staying and forced him to go out and severely assoolted him; that Reddy had
to be removed to hospital. In the election petition allegations were made
against Rao almost under every sub-section of Section 123 of the Act. But
the only corrupt practice found by the High Court against Rao was the commission of corrupt practice of undue influence within the meaning of Section
123 (2). The High Court, therefore, set a.side the election of Rao. The High
Court, however, did not grant the declaration in favour of Reddy since
according to the High Court it was not found that but for the corrupt practice
Reddy would have secured the majority votes. Both Rao and Reddy, therefore,
filed appeal& in this Court.
Allowing the appeal of Rao and dismissing the appeal of Reddy.
HEID : (1) That the charge of commission of corrupt practice hll.! to be
proved and established beyond doubt like a criminal charge or a quasi-criminal
charge but not exactly in the mooner of establishment of the guilt in a criminal
prosecution giving the liberty to the accused to keep mum. The charge has to
be proved on appraisal of the evidence adduced by both sides especially by the
election petitioner. [500 F-G]
(2) That the election held and results declared on the choice of the voters
should not be lightly interfered with or set aside by a court of law. After all,
in the holding of a fresh election are involved numerous botherations, tremendous expenses, loss of public time and money and the uncertainty of the public
representation from a particular constit.uency. [500 G-H]
(3) A charge of corrupt practice is easy to level but difficult to prove. If
it is sought to be proved only or mainly by oral evidence wit&out there being
contemporaneous documents to support it, court should be very careful in scru-
1
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
491
A
tinizing the oral evidence and should not lightly accept it unless the evidence is
credible, trustworthy, na.tural and showing beyond doubt the commission of
corrupt practice, as alleged. [501 A-BJ
( 4) That, this Court ordinarily and generally does not, as it ought not to,
interfere with the findings of fact recorded by the High Court unless there are
compelling reasons for tll.c same, especially findings recorded on appreciation of
oral evidence. [501 BJ
(5) This Court, however, does not approve, of the finding recorded by the
High Court on a misreading or wrong a.ppreciation of the oral evidence especially
when it is unsupported or runs counter to the contemporaneous documentary
evidence.
B
[501 B-C]
(6) It must always be borne in mind that the consequences of setting aside
of an election on the ground of corrupt practice are very serious for the candidate
concerned a.s well as others involved in it. A court, therefore, should reach
its conclusion with care and caution taking into consideration the broad probabilities, the natural conduct of the persons involved and the special situation in
which a corrupt practice is alleged to have been co,mmitted. [501 C-E]
c
On appreciation of evidence the Court found that the High Court wrongly
ca.me to the conclusion that the corrupt practice was committed either by Rao
or his agent; that the main story set up by Reddy does not find support from
llilY of the contemporaneous documents including statement of Reddy himself.
The genesis of the> disturbance was the alleged assault on the two boys by the
Reddy group. The disturbances before the election did take place but it was
, not a one sided affair. Both sides were responsible for entering into clashes.
The High Court committed a grave error in placing reliance on such intrinsically and inherently weak pieces of oral evidence as against the contemporaneous
documents. [501 H, 505F, 506A, G, 507 CJ
No corrupt practice was established to have been committed by any person
with the consent of respondent Rao or bis election agent. The High Court,
therefore, wrongly declared election of Rao to be void under Section 100(1)
(b ). [508 F]
D
E
The ballot papers on which the marks were put on the reverse side of the
symbol and not on the obverse side were rightly rejected. Rule 39(2)(b) of
the Conduct of Election Rules 1961 requires the elector to make a mark on the
ballot papec on or near the symbol of the candidate for whom he intends to
vote. On a plain reading of the said rule that the voter is to make the mark
on the ballot paper and not behind the ballot paper. [509 B-E]
~
F
Swarup Singh v. Election Tribunal AIR 1%0 Allahabad 66 and Dhanpati/a/
v. Harislngh, AIR 1969 Rajastban 92, overruled.
A. V. Palaniswami v. The Election Court (District Munsif), Tripura and
others (1973) 2 Madras Law Journal 60 and Mr. Sykes v. Mr. Mc. Arthur, 4
D'Malley and Hardcastle 110, approved.
CrvIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 583 and 686
G
of 1974.
AppeaJ. from the Judgment and Order dated 28-2-74 of the Andhra
Pradesh High Court in Eleetion Petition No. 1/72 and
Civil Appeal No. 686 of 1974.
From the Judgment and Order dated 28-2-74 of
Pradesh High Court in Election Appeal No. 52/73.
the Andhra
M. C. Bharulare, K. Krishna Rao, K. Rajirulra ClwudhaJ·y
Mrs. Veena Devi Khanna for the Appellant in CA 583/74.
and
H
492
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977) 1 S.C.R.
A. K. Sen, I. Kotireddy and G. N. Rao, for Respondent No. 1
in C.A. 583/74 and also for the Appellant in C.A. 686/74.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
UNTWALIA, J. These are two appeals under section 116A of the
Representation of People Act:, 1951-hereinafter referred to as the
Act, arising out of an election dispute concerning the election held
on the 5th and 8th of March, 1972 to the Andhra Pradesh Legislative
Assembly from Purchur Constituency. Six persons had filed nominations for standing as candidates at the election. Four of them, who
were impleaded as respondents 2 to 5 in the election petition, withdrew in time and did not contest the election. The only two persons
left in the field for a straight contest were the two appellants in the two
appeals namely M. Narayana Rao, appellant in Civil Appeal No. 583
6£ 1974-hereinafter referred to as Rao or respondent no. 1 (for
brevity, the respondent) according to his position in the election petition and G. Venkata Reddy, appellant in Civil Appeal 686 of 1974hereinafter to be called Reddy or the election petitioner. Rao was
declared elected on the 11th March, 1972 by a margin of a few
hundred votes.
Reddy challenged his election by filing an election
petition under the Act on several grounds of corrupt practices said to
have been committed by or on behalf of Rao as also on the ground
that several malpractices and mistakes had taken place in the counting
of the votes. Reddy in his election petition besides asking for the
setting aside of the election of Rao, also claimed that he should be
declared elected in his place. A learned single Judge of the Andhra
Pradesh High Court in a very long, elaborate, exhaustive, which at
times was exhausting, judgment has accepted the case of the election
petitioner in regard to one type of corrupt practice having been committed on behalf of the respondent and set aside his election. Rao
bas preferred the appeal from the said order. A recount of the votes
polled was ordered by the learned Judge and even after re-examination of the validity or invalidity of certain votes, he found on recount,
that Rao had still majority of votes in his favour although the margin
was further reduced. In that view of the matter, Reddy's prayer for
being declared elected was refused by the High Court. Hence Reddy's
appeal. Both the appeals arising out of the same election petition
have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common
judgment.
We would like to state at the outset that even in regard to .tbe
limited questions which fell for our determination in these appeals, the
judgment of the High Court is so lengthy and cumbersome, at times
suffering from unnecessary repetitions and discussions, that while discussing the main issues in these appeals, we have not thought it necessary to meet and deal with all the reasonings of the High Court although in arriving at the decision we-have taken them into consideration. If we do so, our judgment will also be unnecessarily very long.
But we must record our appreciation for the tremendous labouc put in
the High Court by lawyers on either side and the very great pains
which the learned Judge has taken in preparing a careful and exhaustive judgment both on facts and in law.
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
493
Reddy contested the election as a candidate of the Indian National
Congress Party and Rao was an Independent candidate. Reddy's
election symbol was "Cow and Calf" while that of Rao was a "Tractor". The polling in the Constituency was held on the 5th of March,
1972. Due to disturbances at the 8 polling booths at Chinna Ganjam
with which we shall be concerned in Rao's appeal, polling had to be
postponed to the 8th of March, 1972 on which date the polling was
completed at Chinna Ganjam. At the counting of votes done on the
1 lth of March, 1972 the Sub Collector, Ongole, who was the Returning Officer of the Constituency, found that Rao had polled 31,038
votes while the votes polled by Reddy were only_ 30,728. Approximately 1,398 votes were declared as invalid by the Returning Officer.
It may just be stated here that the total. number of electorates in
Purchur Constituency was 77,932. Votes polled were quite a good
number amounting to 63,164.
In short the election petitioner's case was that being a sitting member of the Assembly from the Purchur Constituency he was very popular and had great chances of success in the election in question. The
respondent, his supporters and agents felt that the election petitioner
could be defeated only by use of undue influence, force and violence
on a large scale and not by a fair election. With that end in view it
was averred by Reddy in his election petition that one Sri Mandava
Sitaramayya, an influential worker of his was assaulted at Purchur on
the 2nd of March, 1972 by Yarlagadda Subbarao, brother-in-law of
the respondent. Although the beating of Sitaramayya and the illegal
activities of the respondent were brought to the notice of the Deputy
Superintendent of Police and Sub Collector, Ongole at 7.00 P.M. on
the 4th of March, 1972 when they were camping at Purchur and they
were requested to take adequate precautions for I!_ fair and free poll,
the Deputy Superintendent of Police failed to do so. By the 4th ot
March, 1972, according to the case of Reddy, the atmosphere was
thick with rumours that he and his men would be beaten and done to
death, his supporters and voters would be prevented from exercising
their franchise and that in these endeavours of Rao he and his agents
had the full support and cooperation of the Police Department headed
by Shri A. Gopal Reddy, Deputy Superintendent of Police. Chinna
Ganjam and its surrounding villages, Reddy claimed, lay in his strong~
hold area. Rao and his agents under the umbrella of protection of the
police started an orgy of violence particularly in Chinna. Gan jam and
its surrounding villages. On the 4th of March, 1972 the respondent
collected his agents and supporters at his election office at Chinna Ganjam and instructed them to go ahead by using undue influence, violence and force to prevent the voters from casting their votes and not
to allow peaceful conduct of the poll at Chinna Ganjam.
The case of Reddy, the election petitioner, further was that on the
morning of the 5th of March, 1972 Rao's supporters, about 200 in
number, gathered from various villages with the active assistance of
J. S. Krishnamurthy (respondent no. 2 in the election petition-one
of the candidates who had withdrawn) and Muddarla Rangarao of
Alankar Theatre, Inkollu, started threatening, beating and stone pelting
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
494
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977] 1 S.C.R.
A
of the voters and supporters of Reddy in Chinna Ganjam near the
polling station and elsewhere. This mob, amongst onhers, included
the 18 persons mentioned in paragraph 8 ( f) of the election petition.
As a result of the violent activities of the supporters of the respondent
and the panic created thereby, the polling at Chinna Ganjam which had
started at 7.30 A.M. on the 5th of March, 1972, was stopped between 9.00 A.M. and 11.30 A.M. When it was resumed again a
B 11.30 A.M. the electors were all scared and there was poor response
from them. Rao's agents again started an orgy of violence at about
mid-day. Voters who were waiting at the polling booths were
threatened and dispersed and when Reddy's supporters including Marri
Subba Reddy of Mnnnamvaripalem were attempting to infuse confidence in the voters, the mob consisting of persons wearing badges with
"Tractor" symbol, rushed upon the innocent voters and forced them
c to flee for their lives. This was all done with the active support of
the police. During the afternoon disturbances, Reddy's case has been,
the police most unjustly opened fire upon the dispersing and fleeing
persons killing outright Marri Subba Reddy and seriously injuring
Komatla Ramachandra Reddy, a resident of Pedda Ganjam, an innocent passerby.
Reddy's case further runs thus. He went to Chinna Ganjam at
D
about 2.00 p.m. on the 5th of March, 1972 and when he was taking
coffee in a hotel, the hooligans numbering in all abou~ 300 engaged
by Rao including the 18 persons named in paragraph 8(f) of the
election petition armed with sticks, iron rodes and other weapons
surrounded the hotel, forced Reddy to come out and severely assaulted
him. Reddy had to be removed first to Chirala Government Hospital
E Md finally to Guntur Hospital where he remained under treatment for
a few days. As a result of the violent disturbances created by Rao's
agents and supporters at Chinna Ganjam the voting was postponed to
March 8, 1972 and completed on that date.
The election petitioner had also taken a stand in his election petition that the respondent and his supporters went round canvassing
from 3.00 p.m. on the 5th of March, 1972 that Reddy was dead or
F was sure to die and there was no use casting votes in his favour. The
panic created by the respondent and his men prevented several voters
from exercising their franchise or coerced them to cast their votes in
favour of the respondent. Certain other allegations were made in the
election petition alleging that the respondent had utilised the services
of a Government servant, and had indulged in other various types of
malpractices. It is not necessary to refer to them in any detail as the
G Trial Judge has not accepted the election petitioner's case in regard
to the said allegedly corrupt practices. The findings of the High
Court were not challenged by Reddy before us. We may, however,
state in passing that reckless allegations were made by Reddy against
Rao alleging the commission of corrupt practices within the meaning
of almost every sub-section of section 123 of the Act. But the only
one found by the High Court against Rao is the commission of corrupt
practice of undue influence within the meaning of sub-section (2) of
H
section 123.
Reddy in his election petition alleged Commission of several malpractices, mistakes and irregularities in the counting of the votes ..
'
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
495
Several of his valid votes were said to have been wrongly rejected,
several of the invalid votes were wrongly counted for Rao and so on
and so forth. He asserted that ~he Returing Officer had wrongly turned
down his request for a recount and if recount is ordered by the Court
it would be found that he had polled the majority of votes. Upon such
allegat:ions, the details of some of which but not of all, were given in
the election petition, Reddy claimed a declaration for himself of having
been elected t:o the Legislative Assembly from Purchur.
B
On the pleadings of the parties the High Court framed several
issues and the relevant ones for the disposal of these appeals are the
following:
"1 (a) Whether the allegations made in paragraph 8(a)
to (k) of the petition constitute corrupt practice of and 'Undue Influence' envisaged under Sec. 123(2) of the Representation of the People Act, and the 1st respondent himself or
his agent or any other person with his consent or that of his
election agent committed the same ?
c
(b) If the allegations made in paragraph 8(a) to (k) of
the petition be true, is the election of the 1st respondent
liable to be set aside on the ground of commission of corrupt
practice, namely exercise of 'Undue Influence' envisaged
under S. 123(2) of the Representation of the People Act?
D
(c) Whether any such corrupt practice if proved to have
been committed by an Agent of the 1st respondent, other
than his Election Agent, has materially affected the result
of the Election in so far as it concerns the 1st respondent'?
6(a) Whether the allegation that the Returning Officer
and his staff committed several mistakes and irregularities in
the matter of counting, bundling, rejection and reception of
votes as alleged in paragraph 9(a) to (k) of the petition is
true?
(b) Whether 472 votes said to have been cast in favour
of the petitioner were rejected on the ground that the mark
waa put on the back on the ballot papers and whether such
rejection is improper and void ?
E
F
G
(c) Whether the pleading in paragraph 9(b) of the petition is liable to be struck down for not furnishing the particulars such as serial numbers of ballot papers etc., ?
( d) Whether the allegations regarding the irregularities
and violations in the rejection or reception or counting of
votes made in paragraph 9(c) to (k) of the petition are
vague and are liable to be struck down for want of material
particulars ?
H
496
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977) 1 s.c.R.
( e) Whether the improper reception of void votes or improper rejection of valid votes and mistakes if any in counting of votes has materially affected the result of the election ?
7 (a) Whether the order of the Returning Officer reject:
ing the request of the petitioner for recount of votes is erroneous and contrary to law? If so what is its effect ?
B
C
n
(b) Whether in the circumstances mentioned in paragraphs 9(a) to (k) of the petition the petitioner is entitled
to scrutiny of ballot papers and recount of votes by this
Court?
8. Whether the election of the 1st respondent is liable to
be set aside on any of the grounds alleged in the petition ?
9. Whether the petitioner is entitled to be declared duly
elected candidate to the Purchur Constituency ?"
The High Court states in its judgment :
"Issues l(a), (b) and (c) relate to the allegations in
paragraphs 8(a) to (k) of the election petition. They
cover several allegations of .corrupt practice of undue influence envisaged by section 123 (2) of the Act."
For the sake of convenience the learned Judge split up issue 1 (a) incidence-wise with reference to each of the alleged ones. It would be
useful to quote the split up issues from the judgment of the High
Court.
1 (a)(i) Whether the allegation made in paragraph
8 (c) of the election petition riz., the attack on Mandava
E Seetaramayya, an influential worker and supporter of the
petitioner _on 2-3-1972 by Yarlagadda Subbarao of Karamchadu is true ?
1 (a) (ii) Whether the allegations made in paragraph
8(f) of the election petition that on the night of 4-3-1972 the
1st respondent collected his agents and supporters in Chinna
F
Ganjam at his election office and instructed them to use undue influence, violence and force in preventing the voters
from exercising their franchise and peaceful conduct of the
· poll is true ?
G
H
1 (a) (iii) whether the allegation contained in paragraph
8(g) of the election petition that the 1st respondent's agents,
workers and supporters including the 18 ~rsons named in
the said paragraph started threatening, beating and pelting
stones on the voters and supporters of the petitioner at
Chinna Ganjam Polling Stations and as a consequence thereof the polling was stopped and the voters were prevented
from casting their votes between 9.00 A.M. and 11.30 A.M.
1 (a) (iv) ·Whether the polling was resumed at 1 l.30A.M.
and the 1st respondent's agents again started an orgy of
violence by the 1st respondent's agents, workers and supporters including those named in paragraph 8(f) of the
r-.
I
M. NARAYANA RAO
v. G. VENKATA REDDY
(Untwalia, J.)
497
election petition and several others wearing "Tractor Badges"
and disturbed the polling and forced the voten to flee away
without casting their votes and the police most unjustly
opened fire upon the fleeing persons as alleged in paragraph
8(h) of the election petition?
1(a)(v) Whether the petitioner was attacked by the 300
persons as alleged ii' paragraph 8(i) of the election petition?
1 (a)( vi) Whether as alleged in paragraph 8(i) of the
petition a little later some of the petitioner's voters were
threatened and beaten by the 1st respondent's supporters including the persons mentioned in paragraph 8(f) of the
petition?
1 (a) (vii) Whether the allegation in paragraph 8(j) that
the 1st respondent and his agents workers and supporters
went round canvassing from about 3.00 P.M. on 5-3-1972,
that the petitioner was dead or was sure to die and as such
there was no use of casting votes in his favour, is true?
1 (a) (viii) Whether as a result of the above incident
several wters failed to cast their votes even at the repoll held
on 8-3-1972 ?"
Although the High Court has found that Yarlagadda Subbarao
and four others beat Mandava Seetaramayya, it could not be established that they were the agents of Rao or had attacked him with his
consent. Issue no. 1 (a) (i) was decided against the election petitioRer. The finding of the High Court on Issue no. 1 (a)(ii) is as
follows:
"From the above discussion, it is established that the 1st
respondent came to his election office at Chinna Ganjam on
the night of 4-3-1972 accompanied by R.W. 13, Ravipudi
Venkatadri, Respondent No. 2, and one Muddana Rangarao.
It is also established that at his election office, Koyi Mohanarao, Karanam Balaram, Karanam Nayudamma, Karanam
Ankamma, Muddana Madana Mohana Rao, Parvathareddy
Narasimharao, Parvathareddy Satyanarayana, Parvathareddy
Sriramayya, Ghanta Subbayya, Thumalapenta Venkateswarulu, Thummalapenta Venkateswamy, Ghunta Venkateswarulu, Narahari Venkatasubbarao, Chunduri Radhabishna
Murty, B. P. R. Vittal were present alongwith some other
persons whose names are not specially mentioned by any of
the witnesses.
It is also proved as alleged in paragraph 8(f) of the election petition that in the presence of the abovementioned persons, the 1st respondent instructed and advised those persons and others present there "to go a~ead bthy using unfrdue
influence, violence and force in preventmg
e voters om
exercising their right of franchise and the peaceful conduct
•of the poll as otherwise he had little chance of success."
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
, H
498
A
B
c
D
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1977] 1 S.C.R.
Issue no. 1 (a) (iii) was also decided against the respondent and it
was held:
"Though the petitioner's deposition in this behalf is based
only on the information furnished ~y the other witness~s
whose evidence has already been discussed, the other evidence discussed above clearly establishes that Koyi Mohana
Rao, Karnam Nayudamrna, Karanam Balaram, Karanam
Ankamrna, R.W. 13, Ravipudi Venkatadri, B.P.R. Vittal,
Chunduri Radhakrishna Murty, Muddana Madana Mohana
Rao, Parvathareddy Narasimha Rao, Munsif of Sobhirala and
his sons, Satyam, Sriramulu his grandson Ghanta Subbayya
and Thummalapenta Venkataswamy, Narahari Venkata
Subbarao and Thummalapenta Venkateswarlu and some
other people of Chirala and other villages over 100 in number pelted stones and disturbed the voters in the queues
at the polling booths of Chinna Ganjam as a result of which
polling was suspended f!rom 9.30 A.M. to 11.30 A.M.
While deciding this issue presence of a few persons named in paragragh 8(f) of the election petition was not found as persons taking
part in the disturbance.
On Issue no. l(a)(iv) the finding of the High Court is:
E
F
G
H
"From the evidence discussed above, I find that the polling which was resumed at about 11.30 A.M., continued
peacefully till about 2.00 P.M., thereafter the polling was
disturbed by the persons who are found under Issue no.
1 (a) (iii) to have disturbed the polling in the morning by
violence alongwith others which constituted a mob of nearly
300 persons armed with sticks and stones, they pelted stones
at the queues of the voters standing near the polling booths
causing injuries to one Kanna Nagayya and thus scared
them away. The Police apprehending further danger opened
fire resulting in the death of Marri Subba Reddy and injuries
to Komatla Ramachandra Reddy (P.W. 33). The persons
among others whose identity is clearly established by the
evidence discussed above in the commission of the act of
undue influence are (1) Koyi Mohana Rao, (2) Karanam
Nayadamma. (3) Karanam Balaram, (4) Karanam
Ankamma, (5) R.W. 13, Ravipudi Venkatadri, (6) B. P. R.
Vittal, (7) Chunduri Radhakrishna Murty, (8) Muddana
Madhana Mohana Rao, (9) Parvathareddy Narasimha Rao,
Munsif of Sobhirala and his sons, (fO) Satyam, (11) Sriramulu, (12) his grandson Ghanta Subbayya, (13) Thummalapenta Venkwataswamy, (14) Narahari Venkata Subba
Rao and (15) Thummalapenta Venkateswarlu."
Issue no. 1 (a) (v) was also decided against Rao, the respondent
and it was found :
"From the evidence discussed above, in my view, it is
established beyond all reasonable doubt that the petitioner
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VEN.KATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
499
was attacked after he ran out of P.W. 12's hotel and covered
a distance of about 10 to 12 yards towards the Railway level
crossing; he was attacked by an armed mob of over 100 persons some of whom were wearing "Tractor badges" and
among the assailants of the petitioner were ( l) Koyi
Mohana Rao of N agendla, Mangali Krishna of Chirala,
Karnam Balaram of Thimma Samudram, . Parvathareddy
Narasimha Rao, Village Munsif of Sobhirala, Thummalapenta Venkataswamy of Sobhirala, Parvathareddy Sriramayya
and parvathareddy Satyanarayana the sons of Parvathareddy
Narasimha Rao, the Village Munsif of Sobhirala."
A
8
Case against two of the alleged assailants namely Karnam Nayudamma
and Pallapolu Venkateswarlu were not accepted.
In regard to Issue no. 1'(a) (vi) the learned Judge held against the
election petitioner stating "In this state of evidence, I am reluctant to
act on the solitary statement of P.W. 41 and hold this allegation
proved."
c
Issue no. 1(a) (vii) was also decided against the election petitioner
and the learned Judge stated :
"I, therefore, hold that the petitioner has failed to prove
that the 1st respondent or his supporters spread the rumour
of the attack on and the death of the petitioner and that
thereby number of Congress voters left the queues at the
polling booths without casting their votes."
Under Issue no. 1 (a) (viii) the findings recorded
Court against the election petitioner are :
by the High
D
E
In view of the above discussion, it cannot be held that
several hundred voters failed to cast their votes even at the
re-poll on 8-3-72 on account of the fear engendered by the
violence perpetrated by the 1st respondent or his agent8 or
supporters on 5-3-72."
Having thus recorded the findings under the various sub-issues under
Issue no. 1 (a) the Court proceeded to advert to the discussions of
1 (b) and ( c) and came to the conclusion :
"In view of the above discussion, I hold that the acts of
'corrupt practice' were committed by the persons abovenamed with the consent of the 1st respondent and therefore
the election of the 1st respondent is liable to be declared
void under s. 100 (1) (b) of the Act. His election is also
liable to ~e declared . void because his election agent,
R.W. 13 is found guilty of corrupt practice of undue influence. The election of the 1st respondent is liable to he
declared void without the further proof that the result of the
election has been materially affected. Issue 1 (b) is answered
accordingly."
In regard to Issue no. 1 ( c) the High Court came to the conclusion
that though some of the persons who committed the corrupt practice
F
G
H
500
A
B
c
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977] l S.C.R.
of undiie influence on 5-3-1972 were agents of the respondent, if
R.W. 13, Rao's election agent, would not have been among them and
if Rao's consent to the acts of those others were not established, the
election of the respondent could not have been set aside because there
was no prQ<>f that the result of the election had been materially affected on account of the commission of those corrupt practices. But
since the Court found that undue influence on the 5th March had been
co_mrnitted not only with the consent of the respondent but also by his
election agent himself-he being present at Chinna Ganjam on that
date, the election of Rao was frt to be declared void wit;hout any proof
of the result having been materially affected. The Uigh Court, if
correct on facts, was undoubtedly right in law.
The High Court had decided issue No. 7 in favour of the election
petitioner and ordered recount. After a detailed discussion of the
various aillegations made in connection with the malpractices and mistakes committed in the counting of the votes under the various subissues of issue no. 6, the final conclusion of the High Court was that
out of 31,038 votes counted for Rao by the Returning Officer, two
had to be deducted as on recount the number was found less and on
various grounds mentioned in the judgment, 129 more were directed
to be deducted from Rao's count thus leaving the net result of 30,907
valid votes in favour of Rao as per the decision of the High Court.
For the reasons given in its judgment the High Court held that 27
votes ought to have been counted for Reddy which were wrongly not
counted. Thus adding those 27 to his original figure of 30,728 the
total valid votes, according to the High Court polled by Reddy were
30,755-still short by 100 and odd from those of Rao.
We first take up Civil Appeal 583 of 1974 filed by Rao.' The
principles of illw governing election disputes and especially in regard
to the charge of a commission of corrupt practice are well established
by several decisions of this Court-many of which have been noticed
in the judgment of the High Court 'also. We do not propose to refer
to any. We shall, however, keep the following principles in view in
relation to this appeal :
(1) That the charge of commission of corrnpt practice has to
G
H
be proved and established beyond doubt like a criminal
charge or a quasi-criminal charge but not exactly in the
manner of establishment of the guilt in a criminal prosecution giving the liberty to the accused to keep mum. The
charge has to be proved on appraisal of the evidence
adduced by both sides especially by the election
petitioner.
(2) That the election held and results declared on the choice
of the voters should not be lightly interfered with or set
aside by a court of law. After all, in the holding of a
fresh election are involved numerous botherations, tremendous expenses, loss of public time and money and the uncertainty of the public representation from a particular
Constituency.
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
501
(3) A charge of corrupt practice is easy to level but difficult
to prove. If it is sought to be proved only or mainly
by oral evidence without there being contemporaneous
documents to support it, court should be very careful in
scrutinizing the oral evidence and should not lightly accept
it unless the evidence is credible, trustworthy, natural and
showing beyond· doubt the commission of corrupt practice,
as ~lleged.
A
B
(4) That, this Court ordinarily and generally does not, as it
ought not to, interfere with the findings of fact recorded
by the High Court unless there are compelling reasons for
the same, especially findings recorded on appreciation of
oral evidence.
(5) This Court, however, does not approve of the finding
recorded by the High Court on a misreading or wrong
appreciation of the oral evidence especially when it is
unsupported or runs counter to the contemporaneous
documentary evidence.
'
(6) It must always be borne in mind that the consequences of
setting aside of an election on the ground of corrupt practice are very serious for the candidate concerned as well
as others involved in it. A court, therefore, should reach its
conclusion with care and caution taking into consideration
the broad probabilities, the natural conduct of the persons
involved and the special sifuation in which a corrupt
practice is alleged to have been committed.
....
In the background of the above principles we proceed to examine
whether the finding of the High Court against appellant Rao on some
parts of issue no. 1 resultiµg in the declaration of his election as void
is sustainable. Broadly speaking, the findings against him are ( 1)
that he had created a tense situation to bring about the defeat of Reddy
before the holding of the poll on the 5th March, 1972; (2) that he
had come to Chinna Ganjam in the night .of the 4th March at about
9.00 p.m. in the company of his election agent Venkatadri and had
instructed his workers to create violence, use force and not allow a
free poll at chinna Ganjam; (3) that Rao's election agent Venkatadri
was present in Chinna Ganjam on the 5th March and had taken active
part in the disturbances created on the date of the poll; ( 4) that Rao's
election agents, workers and supporters including more than 100 from
outside Chinna Ganjam were responsible for creating violent disturbances both in the morning as also in the afternoon on the date of poll i.e.
5th March, 1972; (5) that as a result of the police firing one person
on the side of Reddy was killed· and another was seriously injured.
But it may pointedly be stated here that there is no finding recorded
by the learned Judge that the police was in league with Rao and
had deliberately fired on the fleeing party of Reddy; ( 6) Reddy was
assaulted by the workers and supporters of Rao ·at about 2.00 p.m.
near· the Railway crossing in the hotel of P.W. 12 Satyaitarayana;
(7) the respondent bad not been able t() establish that he had not come
c
D
E
F
G
H
502
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977) J S.C.R.
to Chinna Ganjam i~ the night of 4th <_:>f March and had gone somewhere else or that his case of the genesis of the occurrence which led
to the disturbances on th 5th March was true.
, Apart from some witnesses being different, here or there, most of
lne witnesses to prove the case of Reddy apropos the findings above,
are common and they are P.Ws 12, 29, 30, 31, 32, 42 besides P.W. 27
Reddy himself.
Shorn of details we shall examine. the main ingredients of the ca~e
to see how far they have been proved to bring home the charge of
commission of corrupt practice on the part of Rao. As usual there
must have been some tension in the Constituency because it was a
straight contest and neck to neck fight, as the results show, between
Reddy and Rao. Chinna Ganjam was not the only place where Reddy
hoped to get an absolute majority of votes. The results indicate,
although there is no separate counting of the votes polled at each booth
these days, that in some parts of the Constituency Reddy must have
polled majority of the votes and in some parts Rao must have done so.
How is it then that Rao took into his head to create disturbances at
Chinna Ganjam only ? Sitaramayya, as the finding of the High Court
is, was assaulted by some person on the 2nd of March. That must
have put Reddy on his guard to meet any eventuality of force. After
all he was a sitting member belonging to the ruling party who, we are
told, was in power in the State of Andhra Pradesh at the time of the
election in question. It is difficult to accept or imagine that any
police officer especially a person of the rank of a Deputy Superintendent
of Police or the police in general would have gone against Reddy
and favoured and sided with Rao. On the face of it, it was almost
an absurd story and the High Court could not persuade itself to accept
it.
On 2-3-1972 Reddy had asked for police bundobust at several
places (vide Ext. A-97, letter dated 2-3-1972) but 'had not included
Chinna Ganjam in the list of those places. In the evening of the 4th
March, 1972, as the evidence adduced on behalf of Reddy shows, be
was present in the travellers' bungalow at Purchur wherein were also
staying the Returning Officer, the Deputy Superintendent of Police and
others. There is no evidence to show, that on receipt of the information from P.W. 31 as to what had happened in the election office of
Rao in the night of the 4th March, Reddy contacted the Returning
Officer or the Deputy Superintendent of Police and informed them
about the alleged design of Rao and the instructions issued by him
in that regard. It is no doubt true that there were some persons
working for Rao at Chinna Ganjam who did not belong to that village
but were outsiders. That by itself does not justify the inference that
Rao had collected a mob of outsiders to create violence. Rao was
ill-advised to deny in his written statement that the 18 persons named
in paragraph 8(f) of the election petition were his workers or supporters. But they were so working from before at Chinna Ganjam as
admitted by P.Ws 12, 29, 31 and 32.
One thing is clear from the evidence in this case that inhabitants
of Sobhirals a hamlet of Channa Ganjam, which is mostly inhabited by
Telgas, had enmity with Reddy. Chinna Ganjam lay within the
'.....
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY ( Untwalia, !.)
503
Panchayat Samithi of Jetapafom of which Ronda Ramaswami Reddy
was the President. He was an influential man on the side of Reddy.
He had created several enemies including Balaram. Sobhirala people
were inimically disposed towards him as· he had not allowed them to
have a .separate Gram Panchayat. In this background, we proceed
to examine the documentary evidence first to find out whether the
allegations made by Reddy against Rao as toJ.he alleged happenings
on the 4th and 5th of March, '72 are correct or not. If correct, they
were very important events and they must have found place in one
document or the other. But conspicuously they are absent.
i
..
A
B
In this connection we would first refer to Ext. A-271-the Returning
Officer's Report dated 5-3-1972. In the report it is mentioned that
Chinn:i Ganjam village is a troublesome village and not that Rao had
made it troublesome just before the day of poll. Additional police c
bundobust was asked for in this village. It further mentions that at
aqout 10.00 A.M. there were clashes outside the polling station when
agents of both the candidates were present and on account of the
disturbances, voters were not turning up. After the voting was
resumed, for sometime, it went on peacefully, but at 3.45 P.M. the
Returning Officer received a phone message from the Election Deputy
Tehsildar, Chirala from Chinna Ganjam that polling was adjourned by D
all the Presiding Officers at 2.45 P.M. "consequent on the opening of
fire by the police on an unruly mob gathered at the Polling Stations
which has resulted in injuries to two persons of whom one was reported
to have been seriously injured". This report further mentions that the
election to Purchur Assembly was a straight contest between Reddy
and .Rao and on a complaint made by two boys of Rao's group at
about 10.00 A.M. that Sri Ramaswami Reddy, President, Panchayat E
Samithi, Vetapalem and a few of his followers had assaulted them,
"both sides gathered in large numbers and prepared for a clash."
Relating to the afternoon incident the report states : "The people
belonging to both the parties are said to have begun to reassemble near
the Polling Stations with sticks and stones. They exchanged blows
with sticks and hurled stones at each other." Then the report
procee¢1s-"Apprehending danger to the Polling Material and polijng F
personnel the Presiding Officers are reported to have closed the doors
of the Polling Stations". The report further states : "Apprehending
danger to his life as also to the Polling parties, and danger to the
polling material, the Inspector opened fire on the mob".
It is to be emphasised that if the story set up by Reddy as to
the happening in the election office of Rao in the night of the 4th
March had any semblance of truth, the Returning Officer must have
learnt if from Reddy either the same night at travellers' bungalow at
Purchur or on· the 5th March before he sent his report to the
Election Commission. It was neither alleged nor found that the
Returning Officer had any animus against Reddy or was favourably
disposed towards Rao. The version given in the report speaks a
volume .
We would now refer to Ext. A-106-the First Information Report
drawn on the statement of the Inspector of Police, Chirala, camping
at Chinna Oanjam, in connection with the firing case. This was drawn
16-JJ04SCI/76
G
H
504
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977) 1 S.C.R.
up at 5.15 P.M. on the 5th of March, 1972. · Before we· advert to
some portions of this First Information Report, an admitted position
of the topography may be stated which emerged from the evidence.
Th.er~ were 8 polling booths in Chinna Ganjam situated in two school
bu~dmgs.. On the Western side of the building is a road and the
Rail~ay line. On th.e N?rth~rn side of .the Raiway line is a railway
crossmg west of which 1s village Sobhirala and near the Railway
crossing is the hotel of P.W. 12. Workers and supporters of Reddy
admittedly were on the eastern side at or near about the time of
disturbances and those of Rao were on the western side-mostly on
the road. In this background, let us see what the Inspector states
in Ext. A-106. He say_:; that on receipt of the information about the
disturbances at Chinna Ganjam D.S.P. Ongole and he started from
Purchur and picked up a striking force on the way. When they
reached China Ganjam t11ey "found a large gathering on th~ road
and also on the eastern side of the High Court beyond the High
School premises." One Balaram of Thimmasamudram was leading
the gathering, which was on the west of the High School compound.
On being enquired by the Inspector he said that men of Reddy had
assaulted their people. This was in conection with the assault on
Maddana Madana Mohan Rao and Maddana Ramasinga Rao-the two
boys on the side of Rao. Statement of Ramasinga Rao recorded by
the Inspector is Ext. B-27. Entry on the basis of this statement in
the police papers is B-28. The F.I.R. then states : "At about 2.45
p.m. the mob began gathering in large numbers on bofu fue sides
and hurling stones at each other. Ramaswamy Reddy was in the
mob, which was hurling stones ........ The mob belonging to both
the. candidates viz., Sri Gade Venkata Reddy and Maddukuri Narayana
was determined in fueir violent attitude and advanced towards the
polling station to break open the same to enter into it to commit all ·
unruly acts." This report states that in all three rounds were fired.
In the first Information Report as drawn originally 4 persons are
named as accused, 3 belonging to the party of Rao and Ramaswamy
Reddy-a staunch and influential helper of Reddy. The case diary
Ext. A-107 of the same date shows the total number ofl accused as
42, including the four mentioned earlier. Mr. M. C. Bhandare,
counsel for Rao and Mr. A. K. Sen, counsel for Reddy drew our
attention to this list of 42 persons which almost evenly included as
members of the mob persons of both sides.
It is remarkable that though Ronda Ramaswami President of the
Panchayat Samithi, Vetapalem is shown as one of the leading member
in the firing case, no where is to be found in any paper fue name
of Venkatadri-the eleetion agent of Rao. No paper mentions even
his presence at Chinna Ganjam on the 5th of March. Now comes the
most important document-,-statement of Reddy himself recorded at
5.55 p.m. on 5.3.1972 by a Second Class Judicial Magistrate which
could be treated as a dying declaration, if unfortunately, Reddy would
not have survived, but the injuries inflicted on him were not so
severe as to result in his death. On the basis of this statement,
later, a formal First Information Report was drawn up. This is
..
'
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATY REDDY (Untwalia,
J.)
505
Ext A-100. In answer to the Magistrate's question as to how did
Reddy receive injuries he n~rated the story that when he came to
Chinna Ganjam and Ongole road junction he heard that some 200 persons were brought for hire from Chirala, Thimmasamudram and other
villages to disturb polling as he commanded 85% of electorate there.
The persons who are said to have collected the mob are Mohan Rao,
Mangali Krishna Balaram, Krishna Murthy Babu of Chirala, RaghaB
v~iah, Radha K~ishnamurthy of Thimmasamudram, Rangarao,
Cmema hall propnetor of Inkollu and Nayudamma, President of
Chintagumpalli village. Neither Raci is mentioned nor Venkatadri's
name is mentioned as the persons who had collected the mob there.
If there was any semblance of truth in the Reddy's version of what
happened on the night of the 4th in the election office of Rao,
Reddy could not have missed to refer to that incident. If Venkatadri c
was present at Chinna Ganjam on the 4th or the 5th March, his
name would have found first in the statement of Reddy. We deplore
and deprecate the assault on Reddy-a fact which has been found
to be true by the High Court. We were informed and copies of the
judgments were tried to be filed before us showing that all the cases
have ended in acquittal and no person has been convicted of the
alleged offences. But that apart, we reiterate, even at the risk of D
repetition, that the main story set up by Reddy as to what happened
·On the 4th night as also on the morning of the 5th and afternoon
does not find support from any of the contemporaneous documentsnot even from the statement of Reddy himself. The statement of
Ramasinga Rao was entered in the Station House General Diary,
Vetapalem and it is Ex~. A-128. The entry is Ext. B-27. The
E
Entry of report is Ext. B-28.
Although it is unfortunate that on behalf of Rao neither of the
two boys said to have been assaulted nor any body else was examip.ed
to prove the incident of assault on them which led to the further
disturbances on the 5th of March, _1972 at Chinna Ganjam, the contemporaneous documents do indicate that the genesis of the disturbance was the alleged assault on the two boys. It does not appear F
to be a case where a false story of assault on two boys was made
a pretence. to start assault at Reddy's workers and voters. Hardly
any voter was injured or examined to state that a planned attempt
was made on behalf of Rao to prevent the voters from casting their
votes in favour of Reddy.
Let us now see what kind of oral evidence is there to prove the G
incident. As to what happened in the Rao's elec.tion o!lice at C.hinna
Ganjam in the night of 4th March, P.W. 32 Raiu Bah Reddy 1s the
primary witness of the alleged episode. He had a bunk near the
election offices of the two candidates. We regret to find that Rao
had in the beginning denied that h~ had any election office at
~hinna Ganjam but he was constrained to admit that such a~ office
had been opened by his supporters. We also do not appreciate the H
attempt on the part of Rao in challenging the claim of P.W. 32 of
his running a beedi bunk at Chinna Ganjam near the houses where the
election offices of the two candidates hi,td been set up. Nevertheless
506
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977) 1 S.C.R.
the story told by P.W. 32 is too imaginative and unreal to inspire· any confidence., The High Court, in our opinion, was wholly
wrong in accepting his evidence to be true. He (P.W. 32) says that
he saw the respondent coming in a car on the 4th of March, 1972
to Chinna Ganjam between 8.30 and 9.00 p.m. to his election office.
He was asked to bring sodas to his election office. He took two
dozens of soda bottles to Rao's office and there he heard him saying
"If Congress votes are polled I am sure to lose and requested them to
see that votes arc not polled if necessary even by violence". He
names certain persons present there. Thereafter he was asked to take
some soda bottles to the Congress election office of Reddy. There
P.W. 31 asked him "You had been to the election office of the
first respondent, what is going on there ?". The said sodawala replied "that the first respondent was telling that if all the votes in
Chinna Ganjam are polled he was sure to be defeated and even by
resorting to violence they should sec that votes are not polled". Is
it a natural story ? Is it at all believable ? Was this conspiracy for
creating violence at Chinna Ganjam suddenly and so openly hatched
up in the Rao's election office at Chinna Ganjam and in the presence
of so many persons ? Was it so done uttering every relevant word ·
of the conspiracy in the presence of the sodawala and making it
audibly to him ? Is it possible to believe that the sodawala passed
on the words of the conspiracy to create violence at Chinna Ganjam
in a cavalier and casual manner on the query of P.W. 31 ? All
these questions posed abcive are suggestive of one and one answer
only. The whole story smacks of nothing but untruth. It could
never have happened in the manner stated by P.W. 32. P.Ws. 29,
30, 31 and 42 who claimed to have heard this story from the soclawala are all out to support Reddy on any version and they cannot
fare any better, if the most unnatural story told by sodawala is too.
big to swallow and too' incredible to accept. In disagreement with
the findings of the High Court, we hold that Reddy has failed. to
prove that Rao and Venkatadri came to Chinna Ganjam in the evening of the 4th March, 1972 or that they instructed their agents and
workers to deliberately create violence on the date of poll. We also
hold tha~ Venkatadri was not present at Chinna Ganjam on the 5th of
March and had no part to play in the disturbances which took place
on that date.
It is no doubt true that disturbances did take place at · Chinna
Ganjam on the 5th of March. It was not a one side affair. Both
sides were responsible for entering into clashes. The High Court
has lightly brushed aside one very significant fact in this connection
and which is a very telling one. How is it that in the police fire two
persons were injured-one of whom died, and both of them were
men of Reddy? In the circumstances, is it possible to accept that
the police fired only on the fleeing party of about 2,000 persons ? The
evidence on the side of Reddy shows that they did not aim any firing
on the aggressors and attackers-the men of Rao who all were on
the western side. Unless one could go to the absurd extent of saying
that members of .the police force had also joined hands with the mob
of Rao one has got to conclude that, mainly, aggressors and attackers.
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
.
507
were the persons on the side of Reddy. They w~re the source. of A
danger and terror t_o the polling staff and. t~e matenals of the pollmg
booths and the police had to open fire aii:img at t~em for the protection of the polling staff and the matenals. It 1s b~cause of that
reason that by the police firing two persons on the side. of. Reddy
only were injured and none on the side of Rao. W,e are mclmed. to
think strongly and justifiably that because ~f the d1stu~ances ~h1ch
took place on the 5th of March, 1972 both m the mornmg and m the B
afternoon at Chiima Ganjam, Reddy felt it advisable to make a mountain out of it, and apart from many other unsustainable allegations
of corrupt practices, which are made against Rao, he made _use of
the incident of disturbances on the date of poll at Chinna Ganiam to
connect Rao and his election agent with them. Without alleging their
active participation or consent he had no material to succeed merely
on the ground of disturbances. And that led him to invent two tissues
of untrue stories---one the alleged talk by Rao in his election office
in the night of the 4th March and the other the presence of Venkatadri at Chinna Ganjam on the 5th. In our opinion none of the two
stories has any semblance of truth. The High Court committed a
gross error in placing reliance upon such intrinsically and inherently
weak pieces of oral evidence as against the contemporaneous documents. The reports Exts. A-374 to A-381 of the Presiding Officers D
of the Polling Station at Chinna Ganjam do not throw any further
light except that due to rioting polling had to be adjourned. The
total number of electors in Chinna Ganjam was about 6000 and odd
and as we have said above even assuming that a large majority of
this was to cast their votes in favour of Reddy, by creating disturbances at Chinna Ganjam and preventing the voters from casting their
votes in favour of Reddy or forcing ,them to cast them in favour of E
Rao, Rao could not have imagined to succeed in the election. There
is no evidence to indicate what was the estimated strength of Rao
and Reddy in the remaining 67,000 votes which were to be cast at
several booths other than those at Chinria Ganjam. The date of poll
being the 5th of March in the entire Purchur Constituency it was not
possible even to estimate as to what actually .had happened in other
booths to induce Rao to plan the creation of disturbances at Chinna F
Ganjam.
c
We do not agree with the finding of the High Court on issue
No. 1 (a) (iii) that the polling had to be suspended because Rao's
people over 100 in number pelted stones and disturbed the voters in
the queues at the polling booths of Chinna Ganjam. We arc of the
opinion that it was a spontaneous trial of strength on both sides in
which were involved persons on the side of Reddy led by Ronda
Ramaswami Reddy and several others who were helpers and workers of Rao. The under-current of their participation in the disturbances was their previous enmity as already alluded to. Similarly
we do not agree with the finding of the High Court as recorded under
issue no. 1 (a) (iv). If 300 persons armed with sticks and stones
pelted stones on the queues of the voters then some of them must
have b~n injured by the police firing. But none was injured. No
~espons1ble government servant has been examined to say anything
m support of Reddy's story of the disturbances. We were informed
G
H
508
A
B
c
D
. E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977] 1 S.C.R.
by Mr. Bhandare that a magisterial enquiry into the incident had
been made. An .InsI?e<:tor General of Police, Andhra Pradesh had
also ~eld an e~quuy m respect of the disturbances which took. place
at. Chmna Gan1am on the 5th of March. By filing an affidavit in the
High Court Ra? wanted the reports of the Magistrate and the Inspector
General o~ Pohce !O be produced. But they were not made available
as accordmg to h!lll 0e reports must have stated matters going in
favour of Rao ~d agamst Reddy. Coming to the finding of the High
Court apropos 1Ssue no. 1 (a) (v) we want to merely observe that
Red~y must have ~een attacked by the mob in which must have been
~ao s men. But it was not as a result of any conspiracy instructions or consent of Rao or his. election agent. At or about' the time
when the clashes on the .two sides were at their peak at about 2.00
p.m.-the mob on the side of Reddy was on the eastern side and
that. of Rao was on the western side. Apprehending police firing or
~n its start the mob fled helter skelter. The mob on the western
side mu.st have fled towards village Sobhirala for their safety Ia the
~ay, they came across Reddy and assaulted him. While co~demning
m ~e strong~t language the assault on Reddy, whoever were resp~ns1ble for this, we d~ not find good reasons to connect the assault
with Rao or Venkatadn.
The High Court has presumed .consent of the respondent 'in what
happened on the 5th of March at Chinna Ganjam because of the respondent's application Ext. A-273 in connection with the release of
an Ambassador car MSM 2383 engaged in his election campaign
which had been seized by the police while parked at the railway
gate of Chinna Ganjam. It was just a coincidence that at the time
the assault was made on Reddy, the car happened to be there. The
presence of Badugu Subbarao either in the car or near it again may
be an isolated act of Badugu Subbarao but the gap to connect the
incident directly or indirectly with Rao to say that it was done with
his consent is too big to be filled in by reference to the seizure of the
car and the prayer of release of the Ambassador car.
For the reasons stated above, we hold that the High Court bas
not decided issue no. l(b) correctly. No corrupt practice was established to have been committed by any person with the consent of the
respondent or by his election agent and the election of Rao, therefore,
was wrongly declared to be void under section 100 (1) (b) of the
Act.
Even so, we had to consider whether Civil Appeal 686 of 1974
filed by Reddy is fit to be allowed. Rao may not be guilty of havin~
committed any corrupt practice yet, if on recount it could be found
that Reddy had polled majority of votes, he could succeed in both
the appeals. Mr. Sen, learned counsel for appellant Reddy made his
submissions in regard to two types of ballot papers only and urged
that if we were to hold in his favour in that regard the result of the
counting would definitely tilt in favour of Reddy as he will have
polled more votes than those polled by Rao. For the reasons to be
hereinafter stated, we do not accept the argument of Mr. Sen to be
well founded and correct and hold that the result of the number of
M. NARAYANA RAO v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Untwalia, J.)
-~
509
votes polled by each candidate arrived at by the High Court is correct
an~ does not call for any interference by this Court. -
A
B
..
The first objection raised on behalf of Reddy relates to rejection
of 338 votes apparently appearing to have been cast in his favour
but were rejected. on the ground that the marks given on them were
on the reverse side of the symbol and not on the obverse side.
Several such V?tes apparently cast in favour of Rao were also rejected.
Mr. Serr submitted that 338 votes ought to have been treated as validly
polled by Reddy. We do not accept this contention to be sound. In
our opinion the High Court has rightly maintained their rejection.
Rule 39(2) (b) of the Conduct of Election Rules 1961-hereinafter
'
referred to as the Rules, requires :
7
(2) The elector on receiving the ballot paper shall forthwith;
c
(a) proceed to one of the voting compartments;
(b) .there ·make a mark on the ballot paper with the
instrument supplied for the purpose on or near the
symbol of the candidate for wliom he intends to
vote;"
On a plain reading of the said rule it is clear that the voter has to
make the mark on the ballot paper and not behind the ballot paper.
The symbols are given on the obverse or the front side of the ballot
paper and the requirement of the rule to mark on the ballot paper
on or near the symbol of the candidate for whom the elector intends
to vote necessarily means marking on the obverse side either on the
symbol itself or so near it as to clearly indicate the intention of the
voter. Putting a mark on the reverse side even though because of
the thinness of the paper the symbol may be visible is far from complying with the requirement of the rule. Such a mark will make the
ballot paper in substance and in effect bearing no mark at all within
the meaning of clause (b) of sub-rule (2) of rule 56 of the
Rules "or bearing a mark indicating the vote thereon placed in such
a manner as to make it doubtful to which candidate the vote has
been given justifying its rejection under clause ·( d). Mr. Sen called
our attention to the recent amendment of the Rules made in 1974
wherein it has been clearly specified that the mark must be put on
the face of the ballot paper and also that the ballot paper must be
rejected if it does not bear a mark on the face, and submitted that
on the language of the rules as they stood at the relevant time in
this case ballot papers bearing mark on the reverse side against the
symbol of a particular candidate indicating the choice of the voter
could not be rejected as invalid. We think that the amendment of
the rule merely clarifies· what was intended earlier and does not make
any change or departure from the previous position. Since some High
Courts had taken a contrary view while considering the rules or
similar rules, for the sake of clarification and precision, it appears to
us, that amendment of the rule became necessary. A single Judge of
the Andhra Pradesh High Court dealing with similar Gram Pan<:hayat
Rules had taken a contrary vliew in W.P. 2851/70, decided on l0-121970. The learned Judge followed the decision of the. Allahabad
D
E
F
G
H
510
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1977] 1 S.C.R.
High Court in Swarnp Singh v. Election Tribunal(') and a decision
of the Rajasthan High Court in Dhanpatlal v. Harisingh(2). We
hold that the view expressed in those cases is not correct. On the
contrary the decision of the Madras High Court in A. V. Palania-
wami v. The Election Court (District Munsif), Tiruppur and others(")
B
c
D
E
in this regard expresses the correct opinion. The point in that case,
has been well discussed with reference to various authorities both in
India and other countries. We would like to refer to the. dictum
of Baron Pollock in Mr. Sykee v. Mr. Mc Arthur( 4 ) wherein it has
been said that the mark must be on the face of the ballot paper and
that the vote bearing cross on the back being not in compliance with
the Act was rightly rejec_ted. On the basis of the decision aforesa.id
as also on some others a passage is to be found at page 140 m
Halsbury's Laws of England, Third Edition, Vol. 14 to the following
effect :
"A ballot paper marked on the back only should not
be counted, even though the mark shows .through the paper
on to the front".
The High Court has noticed in its judgment paragraph 17 (k) of
Chapter VIII of the Hand Book issued and published by the Election
Commission in 1972 for the guidance of the Returning Officers.
While indicating the procedure for counting, the Returning Officers
have been instructed to reject a ballot paper when there is no mark
at all on the front or when the mark is in blank area, that is to say
at the back or entirely in the shaded area. It is no doubt true that
the binding directions either generally or specially could be issued by
the Election Commission under sub-rule (1) of Rule 56. Sub-rule
(2) does not speak about the issuance of any such directions. Even so in our opinion the administrative instructions issued
by the Election Commission give a clue to the interpretation of rule
39(2) and rule 56(2) of the Rules. The instructions so issued are
in consonance with the interpretation of the rules aforesaid as put by
us.
Rao
The second objection relates to the acceptance in favour
two groups of ballot papers-one group consisting of 186 votes and the
other 262 votes. The High Court has separately dealt with them in
its judgment. Out of 186 votes Ext. X-26 contains 135 votes,
X.27-11 votes, X.28-38 votes. X.29-one vote and X.30-one vote.
Out of the other group Ext. X.31 contains 241 votes, X.32 one vote
and X.33-20 votes. The High Court has mentioned the different
types of defects which remained on the two groups of ballot papers
aforesaid. Broadly speaking the defects were an infraction of rule
38(1) of the Rules making them liable to be rejected under clause
(h) of sub-rule (2) of rule 56. But then under the first proviso to
sub-rule (2) it has been stated :
"Provided that where the returning officer is satisfied
that any such defect as is mentioned in clause (g) or clause
(h) has been caused by any mistake or failure on the part
of
F
G
H
(!) A.I.R. 1960 All. 66.
(2) A.LR. 1969 Rajasthan, 92.
(3) ()973) 2 Madras Law Journal, 60
(4) 4 O'Malley and Hardeastle, 110.
+
M. NARAYANA RAO
v. G. VENKATA REDDY (Vntwalia, J.)
511
of a presiding officer or polling officer, the ballot paper shall
not be rejected merely on the ground of such defect."
On a consideration of the evidence adduced by the parties and
the broad probabilities and the circumstances of the case the High
Court has come to the conclusion, and in our opinion rightly, that
the said two groups of ballot papers were rightly not rejected by the
Returning Officer and were correctly counted for Rao. The Returning
Officer while accepting a ballot paper, even though, he does so under
the proviso aforesaid, is not required to record any reasons for
acceptance. Reddy had not made out any case that any objection
had been taken on his behalf as respects the acceptance of the above
mentioned votes of the two groups. No objection was specifically
raised in the election petition that any of the ballot papers counted
in favour of Rao should have been rejected under rule 56(2) (h) or
that it could not be accepted under the proviso. Reddy seems to have
fished in troubled waters because of the order of recount made by the
High Court in connection with some other defects which justified the ·
making of such an order. The finding of the High Court in clearest
term, which could not be assailed before us with any success, is as
follows:
"Having regard to the above discussion, it cannot be
held that in the instant case the ballot papers which did not
contain both the distinguishing mark and the signature of
the Presiding or Polling Officer or where either the signature
or the mark was not present were accepted by the Returning
Officer, without satisfying himself as to whether that defect
was due to the mistake or the failure of the Presiding Officer
or Polling Officer. As that is not established and as it is,
als.o clear to the Court from the record placed before it, that
these defects have occurred only due to the failure of the
Presiding Officer and further as there is no doubt as to the
genuineness of these ballot papers, it is held that the ballot
papers were rightly accepted by the Returning Officer."
In our judgment !he High Court is right in arriving at the r~spective
figure~
A
B
c
D-
E
F .
of valid votes polled by the two candidates after recount as
per the order of the High Court and in arriving at the conclusion
that Rao had polled the majority of the votes.
For the reasons stated above we allow Civil Appeal No. 583 of
1974, set aside the judgment and order of the High Court declaring
the election of M. Narayana Rao-the appellant in that app~al, void.
We dismiss Civil Appeal No. 686 of 1974 filed by C. Venkata Reddy.
Taking into consideration the totality of the circumstances of the case,
we shall make no order as to costs in either of the two appeals.
C.A. 583 of 1974 allowed.
P.H.P.
+
C.A. 686 of 1974 dismissed.
G
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org