STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. versus CHANAN MAL ETC.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 18 March 1976 | [1976] 3 S.C.R. 688 | 1976 INSC 58
Key facts
- Decided
- 18 March 1976
- Bench
- A.N. RAY*, M. HAMEEDULLAH BEG, R.S. SARKARIA, P.N. SHINGAL
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 840/1975
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1976] 3 S.C.R. 688
- Neutral citation
- 1976 INSC 58
Text of the judgment
688
A
STATE OF HARYANA & ANR.
V,
CHANAN MAL ETC.
March 18, 1976
B
[A. N, RAY, C.J., M. H. BEG, R. S. SARKARIA AND P. N. SHINGHAL, JJ.]
A1ines and Minerals (Regulation and Developn1en1) Act, 67 of 1957Section 16(1)(b)-Scop• of,
Haryana Minerals (Vesting of Rights) Act, 1973-J/ repugnant to the prorisions of Central Act.
C
Mandamus-Issue of-Petitioner should first call upon the authority to discharge legal obligation.
State111e11t of
Objects and Reasons-When could be used in interpreta-
tion.
f'•lew qucs!ions---JVhen COt{ld be raised.
D
E
F
On the strength of entries in the (wajib-ul-arz) (village administration papers)
of some villages the State Government considered itself to be the owner
of saltpetre deposits. By a notification it declared safipetre as a minor mineral
and auctioned the mines in accordance with the Punjab ~Iinor Minerals Concessions Rules, 1964 made under the provisions of the Mines and Minerals
(Regulation and Developn1ent) Act _67 of 1957. In a writ petition the High
Court held that, unless the mineral deposits were specifically mentioned in the
Wajib-ul-arz _Qt a village, as having vested in the State, their ownei·ship would
still remain vested in the {ormer proprietors according to the record of rights.
To meet this situation, the State legislature passed the Haryana Minerals
(Vesting of Rights) Act, 1973. Since the owners of the lands had haphazardly
created lessee rights in contravention of the Punjab Rules, 1964, t\vo notifications were issued \Vith the object of the conservation as well as of scientific exploitation of mineral resources. By , one notification-- the State Government
purported to acquire rights to saltpetre· in the lands and by the second it
announced that certain saltpetre bearing areas would be auctioned.
In a writ petition under J\rt. 226, the High Court held (i) that in view of
the declaration contained in s. 2 of the Central Act the field covered by the
impugned Act was already fully occupied by the Central legislation so that the
State Act was inoperative and void for repugnancy and quashed the two notifications; 3.nd (ii) that rights in such lands had continued to vest in the former
owners of estates despite acquisitions of other parts of their estates.
The respondents in the a-Qpeals containded that the declaration in s. 2 of
the Central Act that it was expedient in the public interest that the Union should
take under its control the regulation of mines and the development of minerals
would become unwGrkable if the provisions of the State Act \Vere _permitted
to operate.
G
H
While the appeals were pending writ petitions were filed in this Court under
Article 32. The petitioners in the first batch of writ petitions have asserted
rights as holders of mining leases granted by persons who had been entered as
proprietors of estates in the record of rights and that the State under the
State Act had \\-Tongly acquired the right to mineral deposits in their forn1er
lands. It was contended that the effect of the State Act was only to change the
ownership without interfering with the regulation of leasehold or licensee ·rights
in minerals under the- Central Act.
Allowing the appeals of the State and dismissing the writ petitions,
HELD: (i) The Haryana Minerals (Vesting of Rights) Act, 1973, is
valid, as· it is not, 1in any way, repugnant to the provisions of the Mines and
•
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
(Beg, J.)
689
1'.Iinerals (Regulation of Development) Act 67 of 1957. made by Parliament.
Ownership rigIJts could be and have been validly acquired by the State Government under the State Act. [710G]
I
•
(iii) Any petitioner who applied fur a' wril or unler in the natuie of J.
mandamus should, in compliance with a well-known rule of·practice, ordinarily,
first call upon the authority concerned to discharge its legal obligation and show
that it had refused or neglected to carry it out within a reasonable time before
applying to a court for such an order even \vhere the alleged obli~ation is
established. [71 IB)
'
r
•
(ii) No rights are shown by any petitioner to have been conferred upon
him under any lease or licence executed in accordance with the provisions
of the Central Act, but, any petitioner, either before the Hiuh Court ·or in this
Court, who can establish any such right governed by the~ provisions of the
Central Act 67 of 1957 may take such proceedings before an appropriate court.
as may still be open to him under the law, against any such action or Government notification as is alleged to infringe that right. [71 OHl
1. (a) It is difficult to sustain the respondents' contention that the provisions of the Central Act would be really unworkable by mere change of ownership of land in which mineral deposits were found. The character of the
State Act has to be judged by the substance and effect of its provisions and not
n1crely by the purpose given in the Statement of Objects and Reasons. [706C]
(b) The provisions of the Central Act show that subject to the overall supervision of the Central Government the State Government ha~ a sphere of its
own powers and can take legally specified actions under the Central_ Act and
rules. Thus, the whole field of control and regulation under the provisions of
the Central Act cannot be said to he reservecl for the Central Government. [698BJ
(c) The stated objects and reasons of the State J\ct showed that the acquisition was to be made to protect the mineral potentialities of the land and to
ensure their proper development and exploitation on scientific lines. If this
wa.s the actual purpose behind the Act it did not materially differ from that
which could be said to lie behind the c:entral Act. [692E]
(d) The provisions contained in s. 16 ( 1) (b) show that Parliament ics~lf
contemplated state legislation for vesting of lands containing mineral deposits
in the State Government. It only required that rights to mining granted in
such land should be regulated by the provisions of Act 67 of 1957 as amended in 1972. This feature could only be explained on the assumption that
Parliament did not intend to trench upon powers of State legislatures under
entry 18 of List II read with entry 42 of List Ill. Again, s. 17 of the Central
Act shows that there \Vas no intention to interfere \Vith vesting of lands i.n the
States by the provisions of the Central Act. t707B-C]
(e) There is no force in the contention of the responderits that the vesting
contemplated bys. 16(l)(b) as it no\v stands must b~ of "estates" of proprietors or lands of tenureholders under some legislation for agrarian reform.
Article 31A of the Constitution is not confined to legislation for agrarian
reform. Agrarian reform is only oile of the possible or alternative objects of
such acauisition. Tt need not be the exclusive or only purpose of State legislation contemplated by s. 16 ( 1) (b) of the Central Act. Power to legislate
for the acquisition of the whole of an estate or 'tenure· \Vould include the power
to legislate for any part of it. [707 D-E]
_..-<(
A
B
c
U
E
F
G
Hingir-Ra1npur Coal Co. Ltd. & Ors. v. The State of Orissa & Ors.,
[1961) 2 S.C.R. 537; State of West Bengal v. Union of India, [19641 1 S.C.R.
371; Stale of Orissa v. M. A. Tulloch & Co., [1964] (4) S.C.R. 461 & Baijnath Kedia v. The State of Bihar, [1970] 2 S.C.R. 100, held inapplicable.
(2) The lessee and licensee rights governed by the Central Act or rules
are not covered by the State Act. It is clear from s. 3 (2) of the State Act
that the provisions of this Act were to be read subject to the provisions made
by or unde-i: the Central Act. The State Act did not and could not upso facto
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
690
A
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
tern1inate either lcs~ce or licensee rights which were subsisting on the date when·
the State Act. came into force.
On the other hand. s. 9 of the Central Act
56 of 1972, whi~h amende~ s. J6 of. the principal Act, made it imperativefor such lessee nghts as existed 1n estates (which had vested in a State Government) to be brought into conformity with the Central Act. Therefore. if
the:e \verc no lessee or licensee rights of mining in minor minerals on land
wh1c.h \Vere actually regulated by the provisions of the· Central Act they would
continue. [708H1
B
D
'(3) In the second b::itch of petitions, the only dispute between the parties
related to the vesting of ownershio rights in minor minerals in those plots.
The petitioners have come to this Court as lessees and not ns owners. Rights
of former owners have l;>een validly terminated by the State A.ct. It is difficult to make out from these petitions how any lessee rights acquired by the
petitioners theinselves under any law subsisted or were affected by the notifications. [710E-F]
(4) The statement of objects and reasons is relevant when the object or·
purp05e of an enactment is in .dispute or uncertain. It c_an never override
the effect \vhich follows logically from the explicit anU unmistakable language
of its substantive provisions. Such effect is the best evidence of intention. A,
statement of objects ~nd reasons is not a part of the statute, and. therefore,.
it is not even relev~nlt in a case in which the language of the operative parts:
of the Act le11ves no reyorn. what.-;oever, to doubt what was meant by the legis.-
lators.
[706D~ll]
Jn the instant case it j5 not disputed that the object and effect of thcr
State Act was to acquire proprietary rights to miner.al depos~ts in "la?d':.
Its provisions, ho,vever, do not mention leasehold or licensee rights. This ts
so because these rights were governed by the Central Act 67 of 1957.
F
( 5) It is not correct to say that any nc\v question wa.s al19wed to. be
raised simply because the parties were permitted to place their points of vieyt
on the same auestion after taking into account the changes brought about In
Ai.:t 67 of 1957 bv Act 56 of 1972 and ho\V earlier decisions of this Court,
which \Vere given before tbe amendments came into force, could be at all
helpful in d~ciding the questions. The Court is bound to take judicial notice
of the law as it exists and not the law as it once was. [706GJ
CIVIL
APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 840 to 860'
of 1975.
G
From the Judgments and orders dated 7-5-74, _27-8-74, 2-9~74 and
10-9-74 of the Punjab and Haryana High Court m ClVll Wnt Nos.
1133, 1118, 1180, 1208, 1225, 1226, 1231, 1238, 1277, 1251.
1352/74 and 1188, 1198, 1221/74 and L.P.As. Nos. 395 and 399'
of 1974 respectively and
Writ Petitions 1309-1318 and 1371-1373/75
H
).
In the instant case, however, it was not shown how the notification of
auctions of mining rights <i.ffected any subsisting rights of any alleged Jessee
or licensee. It has not b:!cO shown that any lessee or licensee asked the State ·
Governn1ent to carry out any statutory or contractual -6bligation before he
invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court or this Court. The essential
a\'ermenh to dbclose subsisting rights or the locus standi of the pttitioncrs
\Vere \\·anting in these petitions. r709Al
c
\
(Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India)
M. C. Bhandare, (In Cas. 844-860/75) and L. N. Singhvi (In·
all Writ Petitions) and R. N. Sachthey for the Appellant and Respon-dents.
•
+
•
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL (Beg, ].)
691
S. Gopal Singh and P. Keshwa Pillai for 1he Petitioners in W.P.
1371-73/75.
A
Horh,?11s Singh Manvah for the Petitioners in W.P. 1371-73/75.
1
~
k K. Sen, Kapil Sibbal, S. K. Jain and S. S. Khanduja
Respondents excepting C.As. 852, 853 and 855/75.
for
the
Na:u1it Lal for the Intervener in C.A. 845/75 Ch. Dhyan Singh
..
etc .
Tk Jurlgmcnt or the Court was delivered by
t
•
llEG, J. The seventeen appeals before us by the State and by
the Director of Industries of Harvana, after certification under Article 133 ( 1) (a) (b) of the constitution, are directed against a Judgment of
the H'gh Court 01" Pu:ijab and Haryana on Writ Petition of owners ot
lands and lessees of mineral rights in land seeking reliefs in the nature
of Mandamus to enforce fundamental rights conferred by Article
31(2) and to restrain the Government of Haryana from taking any
action to implement two notifications void' (i) No. 1217-2-1-B-II74/7622 dated the 20th February, 1974; and, (ii) No. GIG/SP I Aue/
1173/3075-C, dated the 22nd February, 1974, after .declaring. the
Haryana '.\1inerals (Vesting of Rights) Act, 1973 (hercmafter referred
to as 'the Haryana Act') .
Under the notification of 20th February, 1974, the State Government purported to acquire rights to Saltpetre, a minor mineral in the
land described in a schedule appended to the notification issued in
exercise oi' power conferred by Section 3, sub. section (i) of the
Haryana Act. By the notification of 22nd February, 1974, the State
Govcr11111..;nt •announced to the general public that certain saltpetre
bearing areas in the State of Haryana, mentioned therein, would be
auctioned on the dates given there. The notifications have not been
placed before us. But, from the avcr1nents in the sta:cn1ents on
behalf of the State and on behalf of some of the respondents in the
affidavits supporting their respective cases in proceedings for a stay
of the operation of the High Court's judgment, it appears that the
intention of the State was to acquire Saltpetre deposits in lands whose
owners had granted mining leases claimed by petitioners in the High
Court to be· subsisting. The auctions advertised were probably of
fresh lessee rights. Whether the auctions were to be of ownership or
lessee rights in lands, the result was that one owner or one lessee was
to be substituted by another in each case as a result of acquisition and
sale. The State was to get the difference between the price of acquisition and amount realised on sale of each part sold.
The apparent
effect of mere change of owners or lessees was that the State of Haryana
would benefit financially from the acquisitions and sales, although the
object of the Haryana Act was said to include conservation as well as
"scientific exploitation" of mineral resources. The case of the appellant State also seemed to be that the owners of lands had "haphazardly"
created lessee rights in contravention of the Puniab Minor Minerals
Concession Rules, 1954, made under the provisions of the Mines and
Minerals (Regulation of Development) Act 67 of 1957 (hereinafter
c
D
E
F·
G
H'
692
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
'
referred to as the Central Act'). Learned Counsel for the appellant
State contended that the Haryana Act was only meant to supplement
and not supplant the Central Act. The State claimed to be dealing
with lessee rights under the Central Act and not under the Haryana
Act at all.
\
The case of the petitioners in the High Court was :
8
c
If)
E
F
G
H
Firstly, that the Haryana Act was beyond the competence of the
State Legislature inasmuch as the field in which this Act operated was
necessarily occupied already by the provisions of the Central Act
enacted under entry No. 54 of the Union List (List I) of the Seventh
Schedule to the Constitution which reads as follows :
..
"54. Regulation of mines and mineral development to
the extent to which such regulation and development under
the control of the Union is d~clared by Parliament by law to
be expedient in the public interest".
Secondly, that the purported acquisition under the Haryana Act
offended the provisions of Article 31 (2) inasmuch as it was neither for
a public purpose nor for adequate compensation, the provision for
compensation in the Act being, according to the petitioners, illusory.
A Division Bench of the High Court allowed the Writ Petitions
and quashed the impugned notifications after declaring the Act to be
ultra-vires. It also held that the Haryana Act violated Article 31 (2J.
It found the compensation provided by the Haryana Act to be grossly
low and illusory, although its view was that, judging from the statement of reasons and objects of the, Haryana Act, a public purpose was
made
out.
The
stated reasons
and
objec~
of
the
Haryana Act showed that the acquisition was to 'be made to protect
the mineral potentialities of the land and to ensure their proper development and exploitation on scientific lines. If this was the actual
purpose behind the Haryana Act it did not materially differ from that
which could be said to lie behind the Central Act.
The real question, however, was not whether any of the purposes
of the two Acts were common but whether the provisions of the Central Act so operated as necessarily to exclude, in carrying out their
objects, the operation of the State Act. The High Court had held that,
in view of the declaration contained in Section 2 of the Central Act,
and decisions of. this Court in the Hingir-Rampur Coal Co. Ltd. &
Ors. v. The State of Orissa & Ors.(1), State of West Bengal v. Union
of Jndia( 2 ), State of Orissa v. M. A. Tulloch & Co.( 3 ), and Baijnath
Kedia v. The State of Bihar('), the field covered by the impugned
Act was already fully occupied by the Central Legislation so that the
State Act had to be held to be inoperative· and void for repugnancy.
Section 2 of the Central Act lays down :
"It is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public
interest that the Union should take under its control the
(1) [1961] 2 S.C.R. 537.
(3) [1964] 4 S.C.R. 461.
(2) [1%4] 1 S.C.R. 371.
(4) [1970] 2 S.C.R. 100.
+
•
Hf·,RYANA V. CHANAN MAL (Beg, J.)
693
/
regulation of mines and the development of minerals to the
extent hereinafter provided".
I
A
Section 3 (a) of this Act says :
·' 'minerals' includes all minerals except mineral oils;"
Section 3 (c) reads :
•
" 'mining lease' means a lease granted for the purpose of
undertaking mining operations, and includes a sub-lease
granted for such purpose";
B
Section 3 (d) enacts :
" 'mining operations' means any operations undertaken
for the purpose of mining any mineral;"
c
Section 3 ( e) elucidates :
+
•
'· 'Minor minerals' means building stones, gravel ordinary
clay, ordinary sand other than sand used for prescribed purposes, and any other mineral which the Central Government
may, by notification in the official Gazette, declare to be a
minor mineral";
D
Section 3 (g) indicates :
" 'prospecting licence' means a licence granted for
purpose of undertaking prospecting operations;"
the
Section 3 (b) enacts :
" 'prospecting operations' means any operations undertaken for the purpose of exploring locating or proving mineral deposits;"
E
·
Section 3 ( i) lays down :
" the expressions, 'n1ine' and 'owner', have the meanings
assigned to them in the Mines Act, 1952".
•
Sections 4 to 9 of the Central Act deal with General Restrictions
on Prospecting and Mining operations. Section 4 indicates that all
prospecting and mining operations will be governed by the Central
Act. But, Section 4A, introduced by Section 2 of the Central Act 56
of 1972, lays down :
"4A(l) Where the Central Government after consultation with the State Government, is of opinion that it is expedient in the interest of regulation of mines and mineral
development so to do, it may request the State Government
to make a premature termination of a mining lease in respect
ot any mineral, other than a minor mineral, and, on receipt
of such request, the State Government shall make an order
making a premature termination of such mining lease and
granting a fresh mining lease in favour of such Government
~ompany or corporatinn owned or controlled by Government as it may think fit" .
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
,c
.D
.E
[1976) 3 S.C.R.
SectioQ 5 concerns restrictions on the grant of prospecting licences
or mmmg leases. It shows that these will be granted by the State
Government and the Central Government was to give its approval in '\
.certain specified cases only. Section 6 indicates areas for which a
prospectmg licence or mmmg lease or more than one licence or lease
may be granted in any one State. The Central Government could
make exceptmns to this rule. Section 7 limits duration of a prospecting licence, which is evidently to be granted by the State Government,
•
to one year for mica and two years for other mmerals, subject to
renewai, and, in the. case of scheduled minerals, subject to
approval by Central Government for each grant or renewal. Similarly, Section 8 provides penods of grant and renewal of leases by the
State Government. Section 9 deals with Royalties in respect of
mining leases. Section 9A is conc_erned with the Dead rent to be paid
by the lessee to the State Government subject to the regulation of it
by the Central Government.
Sections 10 to 12 of the Central Act contain procedure for obtaining prospecting licences or mining leases in land in which mineral
rights vest in the Government. It is true that it is not specified here
in which Government rights to minerals in any land vest. But, the
machinery proyided for applications and for maintaining the registers
of applications for prospecting licences and mining leases shows that
it is the State Government which will be concerned with this matter
subject to the provisions of Sections 10 to 12 of the Act.
•
•
Rules for regulating the grant of prospecting licences and mmmg
leases are to be made by the Central Government according ·to the
detailed provisions of Section 13 and Section 13A. Section 14, however, lays down :
"14. The provisions of Sections 4 to 13 (inclushe) shall
not apply to quarry leases, mining leases, or other mineral
concessions in respect of minor minerals".
Section 15 makes it clear that it is the State Government which has
the power to make rules for regulating the grant of quarry leases,
mining leases, or other mineral concessions in respect of ''minor minerals" and for purposes connected therewith.
Section 16(1) of the Central Act enacts : "J 6(1 )(a)
All mining leases granted before the commencement of the
Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Amendment Act, 1972, if in force at such commencement, shall be
brought into conformity with the provisions of this Act, and
the rules made thereunder, within six months from such
commencement, or such further time as the Central GoYcrnment may, by general or special order, specify in this
behalf.
(b) Where the rights under any mining lease, granted
by the proprietor of an estate or tenure before .the commencement of the Mines anrl Mtnerals (Regulation and
Development) Amendment Act, 1972, have vested, on or
/
>--
•
..
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
I
(Beg, J.)
695
A
after the 25th day of October, 1949, in the State Government in pursuance of the provisions of any Act of any Provincial or State Legislature which provides for the acquisition of estates_' or tenures or provides for agrarian reforn1,
such mining lease shall be brought into conformity with the
provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder within
six months from the commencement of the Mines and
Minerals (Regulation and Development) Amendment Act.
1972, or within such further time as the Central Government
may, by general or special order, specify in this behalf'.
B
~Section
16(2) provides for rules to be made by the Central Gcvern.ment to carry out the purposes of Section 16 (!) .
Special powers of Central Govemljlent in respect of mining operations in certain lands are provided for in Section 17. Clause (!) of
this Section reads : -
C
" 17 ( 1) The provisions of this Section shall apply in respect of land in which the minerals vest in the Government
of a State or any other person".
·Clause (2) of Section 17 provides ·for undertakings by the Central
Government, in consultation with the State Government, of prospecting or mining operations "in any area not already held under any
prospectmg licence or mining lease .... ". Section 17 ( 3) makes the
Central Government liable in such cases to pay the State Government
prospe~ting· fee, royalty, surface rent, or dead rent, as the case n1ay be,
at the same rate at which it would have been payable under this Ac,
if such prospecting or mining operations had been undertaken by a
private person under a .prospecting licence or mining lease. Section
D
E
17 ( 4) contains pov./crs of the Central Government, in consultation
with the State Government, to prohibit grant of prospecting or n1ining
.leases in any area spccified in a notification.
Section 18, dealing with the development of minerals cnacl3 :
"18(1) It shall be the duty of the Central Governn:ent
to take all such steps as may be necessary for the conservation and development of minerals in India, and for that pmpose the Central Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, make such rnlcs as it thinks fit.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such rules may provide for all
or any of the following matters, namely : (a) the opening of new mines and
the
regulation
of
or
collection
of
F
G
n1ining operations in any area;
(b) the regulation of the excavation
minerals from any mine;
.( c) the measures to be taken by owners of mines fer tlic
purpose of hencficiafon of ores, including the provision of suitable contrivances for such purpose;
l
H
696
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1976] 3 S.C.R.
(d) the development of mineral resources in any area;
( e) the notification of all new borings and shaft sinkings
and the preservation of bore-hole records, and specimens of cores of all new bore-holes;
B
\
(f) the regulation of the arrangements for the storage of
minerals and the stocks thereof that may be kept by
any person;
c
(g) the submission of samples of minerals from any mine
by the owner thereof and the manner in which and
the authority to which such samples shall be submitted; and the taking of samples of any minerals
from any mine by the State Government' or any
authority specified by it in that behalf; and
(h) the submission by owners of mines of such special
or periodical returns and reports as may be :;pecified,
and the form in which and the authority to which
such returns and reports shall be submitted.
D
F
F
G
H
_.+.
(3) All rules made under this section shall be binding
on the Govermnent".
It should be noted that Section 18 set out above empowers the
Central Government to make rules for the "conservation and development of minerals in any part of India". The State Government is not
even entitled under Central Act to be consulted about this subject,
but it is bound by the rules made on it by the Central Government.
The term "Government'', according to Section 3 (23) of the General
Clauses Act, includes both the Central Government and a State
Govcrnn1ent.
~
Section 1 SA, sub-section ( 1) ·inserted by Section 11 of the Act of
56 of 1972, does, however, require consultation with the State
Government on one matter. It says :
"18.A(l) Where the Central Government is of opinion
that for the conservation and development of minerals in
India, it is necessary to collect as precise information as
possible with regard to any mineral available in or under any
land in relation to which any prospecting licence or mining
lease has been granted, whether by the State Government or
by any other person, the Central Government may authorise
the Geological Survey of India, or such other authority or
agency as it may specify in this behalf, to carry out sucjI
detailed investigations for the purpose of obtaining such
information as may be necessary :
Provided that in the cases of prospecting licences or
mining leases granted by a State Government, no such authorisation shall be made except after consultation with the
State Government".
•
HARYANA v. CHANAN MAL (Beg, J.)
The remaining clauses (2) to ( 6) of Section 1SA deal with the consequences of the authorisation of investigation by the Central Government and matters connected therewith. The proviso to clause ( 6)
dealing with the costs of investigation enacts : -
I
"Provided that where the State Government or other
person in whom the minerals are vested or the holder of any
prospecting licence or mining lease applies to the Central
Government to furnish to it or him a copy of the report
submitted under sub-section (5), that State Government or
other person or the holder of a prospecting licence or mining
lease, as the case may be, shall bear such reasonable part o!
the costs of investigation as the Central Government may
specify in this behalf and shall, on payment of such part of
the costs of investigation, be entitled to receive from the
Central Government a true copy of the report submitted to
it under sub-section (5) ".
•
I
t
•
...
B
c
Miscellaneous provisions are contained in Sections 19 to 33 of the
Central Act. Here, Section 19 lays down:
"19. Any prospecting licence or mining lease granted,
renewed or acquired in contravention of the provisions of
this Act or any' rules or orders made thereunder shall be void
and of no effect".
Section 20 enacts :
'·20. The provisions of this Act and the rules made
thereunder shall apply in relation to the renewal aflcr the
commencement of this Act of any prospecting licence or
mining lease granted before such commencement as
'i
A
E
they
apply in relation to the renewal of a prospecting licence cc·
n1!n!r;g lease granted after such commencement".
Section 21 provides for penalties for anyone who contravenes the provisions of Section 4( I) of the Act. Among these miscellaneous pro-
visions is S·xtion 25 recast by Section 14 of Act 56 of 1972. ll lays
down that :
"Any rent, royalty, tax, fee or other sum due to the
Government under this Act or the rules made thereunder or
under the terms and conditions of any proS}Jecting Ecencc or
mining lease may, on a certificate of such officer as may be
specified by the State Government in this behalf by general
or special order, be recovered in the same manner as an
F
G
arrear of land revenue".
-~
Section 25, sub-section (2) shows that these dues are to be specified
either by the Act or by the Rules made thereunder or under the terms
and conditions of any prospective licence or mining lease. The control, however, is of officers appointed by the State Government.
Section 26 provides for delegation of the powers . of the Central
Government by notification in the official Gazette to either the State
Government or any officer or authority either subordinate to the
12~608SC!/76
H
698
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
Central Government or the State Government. Section 30 shows that
the orders made by the State Government or other authority in exercise of powers by or under the Central Act are revisable by the Central Government. Hence, the provisions of the Central Act show
that, subject to the overall supervision of the Central Government, the
State Government has a sphere of its own powers and can take legally
specified actions under the Central Act and rnles made thereunder.
Thus, the whole field of control and regulation under the provisions of
the Central Act 67 of 1957 cannot be said to be reserved for the
Central Government.
\
'
•
As indicated above, there have been some very significant changes
by the Central Act 56 of 1972. These seem to us to make it necessary to reconsider the effect of the declaration contained in Section 2
of the Central Act ·as interpreted by the decisions of this Court so far.
Before outlining the provisions of Haryana Act, we may indicate the
position resulting from the four decisions mentioned above relied
upon by Punjab & Haryana High Court.
In llingir-Rampur Coal Co's case (supra), the validity of the
Orissa Mining Areas Development Fund Act, 1952, was questioned
on the ground that it authorised the State of Orissa to impose a cess
on the valuation of the minerals. The State of Orissa had relied upon
entries 23 and 66 of the State List (List II) of the Seventh Schedule.
Entry 23 of List II is :
•
"Regulation of mines and mineral development subject
to the provisions of List I with respect to regulation and
development under the control of the Union".
And entry 66 of List II is :
"Fees in respect of any of the matters in this list, but
not including fees taken in any court".
F
G
H
The petitioning Coal Co. had relied on entry 84 of List I of the
Seventh Schedule empowering the Parliament alone to impose excise
duty on tobacco and other manufactured goods with the exception of
It had
Alcoholic liquor, opium, Indian hemp, and other narcotics.
also cited, in support of its case, entry 52 of List I of "Industries, the
control of which by the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be
expedient in the public interest". Furthermore, the Coal Company
relied on entry 54 of List I relating to Mines and mineral develop··
ment, already set out above. This Court held that the imposition of
t11c ccss under the State enactment was really a fee falling within
entries 23 and 66 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. It held that the
State Act was neither hit by entry 54, read with Mines and Minerals
Development Act 3 of 1948, nor by entry 52 of List I. The decisi0n
in that case turned on an interpretation of Article 372 of the Constitution. It was held that a declaration in the Act of 1948 could not be
equated with a declaration made by the Parliament in a post-Constitution enactment in terms of entry 54 of List I. It was, therefore, not
really a decision on the effect of Section 2 of the Central Act 67 of
1957.
•
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
(Beg, J.)
699
The State of West Bengal v. Union of India (supra) was the case
of a suit filed by the State of West Bengal against the Union. It was
contended, on behalf of West Bengal State, that the Coal Bearing
Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957, enacted by Parliament, proposing to acquire certain coal bearing areas in the State, did
not apply to areas owned by the State itself, and, in the alternative,
that, even if it did so apply to areas owned by the State of West
Bengal, it was beyond the legislative competence of Parliament be~ause
entry 42 in the Concurrent List (List Ill) did not authorise an acquisition of property already vested in the State although this entry in the
Concurrent List merely reads : "acquisition and requisitioning of
property''. It was urged there that, without a constitutional amendment, Parliament could not acquire the property of the State of West
Bengal under the provisions of the impugned Act. It was held there
(at p. 417) :
I
•
I
1
" ... the power of the Union to legislate in respect of
property situate in the States even if the States are regarded
qua the union as Sovereign, remains unrestricted, and the
State property is not immune from its operation. Exercising powers under the diverse entries which have been
referred to earlier, the Union Parliament could legislate so as
to trench upon the rights of the State in the property vested
in them. If exclusion of State property from the purview of
Union legislation is regarded as implicit in those entries in
List I, it would be difficult if not impossible for the Union
Government to carry out its obligations in respect of matters
of national importance".
Learned Counsel for the appellant State before us has relied upon
the case of State of West Bengal (supra) for contending that the
powers of the State of Haryana to acquire land are not impaired by
the declaration contained in the Central Act. He cited the rule of
construction stated there as follows (at p. 393) :
"Unless a law expressly or by necessary implication so
provides, a State is not bound thereby. This well recognised
rule applies to the interpretation of the Constitution. Therefore, in the absence of any provision express or necessarily
implying that the property of the State could be acquired by
the Union, the rights claimed by the Union to legislate for
acquisition of State property must be negatived."
Applying this rule, he contends that the powers of the State Government to acquire land are left intact by the Central Act 67 of 1957.
Learned Counsel for the respondent, however, relied on another
passage in the State of West Bengal's case (supra) to submit that
legislative power for acquisition of minerals for their development and
conservation must be deemed to be vested in Parliament now even if
the mineral resources are situated in the State. He quoted (at p.
~6):-
"By making the requisite declarations under Entries 54
of List I, the Union Parliament assumed power to regulate
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
700
A
B
c
lJ
E
l
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
mines and minerals and thereby to deny to all agencies not
under the control of the Union, authority to work the
mines. It could scarcely be imagined that the Constitution
makers while intending to confer an exclusive power to work
mines and minerals under the control of the Union, still
prevented effective exercise of that power by making it
impossible compulsorily to acquire the land vested in the
States containing minerals. The effective exercise of the
power would depend-if such an argument is acccptcd-noL
upon the exercise of the power to undertake regulation and
control by issuing a notification under Entry 54, but upon
the will of the State in the territory of which mineral bearing
land is situate. Power to legislate for regulation and development of mines and minerals under the control of the
Union, would by necessary implication include the power to
acquire mines and minerals. Power to legislate for acquisition of property vested in the States cannot therefore be
denied to the Parliament if it be exercised consistently with
the protection afforded by Art. 31."
\
..
t
ln the two cases discussed above no provision of the Central Act
67 of 1957 was under consideration by this Court. Moreover, power
to acquire for purposes of development and regulation has not been
exercised by Act 67 of 1957. The existence of power of Parliament
to legislate on this topic as an incident of exercise of legislative power
on another subject is one thing. Its actual exercise is another. It is
di!licult to see how the field of acquisition could become occupied by
a Central Act in the same way as it had been in the West Bengal's case
(supra) even before Parliament legislates to acquire lanci in a State.
Atlcast until Parliament has so legislated as it was shewn to have
done by the statute considered by this Court in the case from West
Bengal. the field is free for State legislation falling under the express
provisions of entry 42 of List III.
Jn State of Orissa v. M. A. Tulloch & Co. (supra) the provisions
of the Central Act 67 of 1957 were considered by this Court directly.
In this case, the legality of certain demands as fee under the Orissa
Act 27 of 1952, the validity of which had been upheld by this Court
in Hingir-Rampur Coal Co.'s case (supra), came up for consideration again in the light of the provisions of the Central Act 67 of 1957.
It \Vas contended on behalf of the StJ.te of Orissa that thl~ objects and
G
H
purposes of the Orissa Act and of lhc Central Act were entirely distinct and different so that they could validly co-exist since neither trespassed into the field of the other. It was pointed out there that this
Court had indicated, in the Hingir-Rampur Coal Co.'s case (supra)
that, ii the declaration in the 1948 Act relied upon by the petitioner
in that case had been made after our Constitution became operative)
the position would have been different. Reliance was placed upon
the provisions of Section 18 of the Central Act to hold (at p. 477)
"Rcpugnancy arises when two enactments both· within
the competence of the two Legislatures collide and when the
•
l!ARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
I
•
(Beg, J.)
70 I
Constitution expressly or by necessary implication provides
that the enactment of one Legislature has superiority over
the other than to the extent of the repugnancy the one
supersedes the other. But two enactments may be repugnant to each other even though obedience to each of them
is possible without disobeying the other. The test of two
legislations containing contradictory provisions is not, however, the only criterion of repugnancy, for if a competent
legislature with a superior efficacy expressly or impliedly
evinces by its legislation an intention to cover the whole
field, the enactments of the other legislature whether passed
before or after would be overborne on the ground of repugnance.
Where such is the position, the inconsistency is
demonstrated not by a detailed comparison of provisions o[
the two statutes but by the mere existence of the two pieces
of legislation. In the present case, having regard to the
terms of S. 18 ( 1) it appears clear to us that the intention of
Parliament was to cover the entire field and thus to leave
no scope for the argument that until rules were framed,
there was no inconsistency and no superscssion of the State
Act".
•
i
A
B
c
D
It was also held there (at p. 4 78) :
"If by reason of the declaration by Parliament the entire
subject-matter of conservation and development of minerals'
has been taken over for being dealt with by Parliament.
thus depriving the State of the power which it therefore
possessed, it would follow that the 'matter' in the State List
is to the extent of the declaration, subtracted from the scope
and ambit of Entry 23 of the State List. There would,
therefore, after the Central Act of 1957 be 'no matter in the
List' to which the fee could be related in order to render it
.valid".
In Baij11ath Kedia's case (supra), the proviso (2) to Section 10(2)
of the Bihar Land Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1964 (Bihar Act 4
of 1965) and a sub-rule of Rule 20, added on December 10, 1964,
by a notification of the Governor to the Bihar Minor Mineral Rules,
1961, came up for consideration.
Under the Bihar Land Reforms
Act, 1950, the former landlords had ceased to have any interest from
the date of vesting so that their rights as lessors under the mining
leases granted by them in their "estates" became vested in the State
of Bihar under Section 19 ( 1) of the Land Reforms Act; and, by
Section 10(2) of that Act, the terms on which the lands were held on
leases between the original lessors and lessees became binding on the
State Government under the impugned proviso to Section 10(2),
amounting to alteration of the terms of the leases executed by the
original lessors, the former landlords, additional demands were made
upon lessees. The State Government had also relied upon a sub-rule
added to Rule 20 framed under Section 15 of the Central Act 67 of
1957. This Court, after examining the relevant provisions of the
E
F
G
H
702
A
B
SUPRE~fE
COURT REPORTS
(1976] 3 s.c.R.
Central Act, held, relying on Hingir-Rampur Coal Co.'s case (supra)
and M.A. Tulloch Co.'s case (supra), as follows (at p. 113) :
"The declaration is contained in s. 2 of Act 67 of 1957
and speaks of the taking and the control of the Central Government the regulation of mines and development of minerals to the extent provided in the Act itself. We have thus
not to look ontside Act 67 of 1957, to determine what is
left within the competence of the State Legislature but have
to work it out from the terms of that Act".
Alter referring to what was decided in the earlier cases,
said (at p. 114) :
c
D
this
Court
"These two cases bind us and apply here. Since the
Bihar State Legislature amended the Land Reforms Act
after the coming into force of Act 67 of 1957, the declaration in the latter Act would carve out a field to the extent
provided
in
that
Act
and
to
that
extent
entry 23 would stand cut down. To sustain the amendment the State must show that the matter is not covered by
the Central Act. The other side must, of course, show that
the matter is already covered and there is no room for
legislation".
It added (at p. 114-115) :
E
F
G
H
''We have already analysed Act 67 of 1957. The Act
takes over the control of regulation of mines and development of minerals to the Union; of course, to the extent provided. It deals with minor minerals separately from the
other minerals. In respect of minor minerals it provides in
s. 14 that ss. 4-13 of the Act do not apply to prospecting
licences and mining leases. It goes on to state in s. 15 that
the State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, make rules for regulating the grant of prospecting ·
licences and mining leases in respect of minor minerals and for
purposes connected therewith, and that until rules are made,
any rules made by the State Government regulating the grant
of prospecting licences and mining leases in respect of minor
minerals which were in force immediately before the commencement of the Act would continue in force. It is admitted
that nu such rules were made by the State Government.
It
follows that the subject of legislaion is covered in respect of
minor minerals by the express words of s. 15 (1). Parliament has undertaken legislation and laid down that regulation of the grant of prospecting licences and mining leases
in respect of minor minerals and for purposes connected
therewith must be by rules made by the State Government.
Whether the rules are made or not the topic is covered by
Parliamentary legislation and to that extent the powers of
State Legislature are wanting. Therefore, there is no room
for State Legislation''.
\
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL (Beg, J.)
703
In Baijndth Kedia's case (supra), this Court also said (at p. !Hi)
I
•
"We have already held that the whole of the legislative
field was covered by the Parliamentary declaration read with
provisions of Act 67 of 1957, particularly s. 15. We have
also held that entry 23 of List II was to that extent cul
down by entry 54 of List J. The whole of the topic of minor
minerals became a Union subject. The Union Parliament
allowed rules to be made but that did not recreate a scope
for legislation at the State level. Therefore, if the old leases
were to be modified a legislative enactment by Parliament on
the lines of s. 16 of Act 67 of 1957 was necessary. The
place of such a law could not be taken by legislation by the
State Legislature as it purported to do by enacting the second
Proviso to s. 10 of the Land Reforms Act. It will further
be seen that Parliament ins. 4 of the Act 67 of 1957 created
an express bar although s. 4 was not applicable to minor
minerals. Whether s. 4 was intended to apply to minor
minerals as well or any part of it applies to minor minerals
are questions we cannot consider in view of the clear declaration in s. 14 of Act 67 of 1957 that the provisions of ss. 413 (inclusive) do not apply. Therefore, there does not
exist any prohibition such as is to be found in s. 4 (1) Proviso in respect of minor minerals. Although s. 16 applies to
minor minerals it only permits modification of mining leases
granted before October 25, 1949. In regard to leases of
minor minerals executed between this date and December
1964 when Rule 20(1) was enacted, there is no provision
of law which enables the terms of existing leases to be
altered. A mere rule is not sufficient''.
A
c
D
E
Again, referring to the earlier decisions it said (at p. 117) :
"On the basis of those rulings we have held that the entire
legislative field in relation to minor minerals had been withd(awn from the State Legislature. We have also held that
vested rights could only be taken away by law made by a
competent legislature. Mere rule-making power of the State
Government was not able to reach them. The authority to
do so must, therefore, have emanated from Parliament. The
existing provision related to regulation of leases and matters
connected therewith to be granted in future and not for alteration of the terms of leases which were in existence before Act
67 of 1957. For that special legislative provision was necessary. As no such parliamentary law had been passed by the
second sub-rule to Rule 20 was ineffective. It could not
derive sustenance from the second Proviso to s. 10( 2) of the
Land Reforms Act since that proviso was not validly enacted."
The question which arises before us now is whether, possibly as a
rcsuit o[ the decision of this Court in Baijnath Kedi<ts case (supra),
the Parli1ment had not amended the law, as we find it in the present
F
G
H
704
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
Section 16 ~f the Act 67 of 1957, as amended by Act 56 of 1972, so
as to undo its effect. If that amendment is in response to the need
pointed out in Baijnath Kedia's case (supra) would it not cover the
provisions of the Haryana Act now before us ?
The preamble to the Haryana Act states that it is :
B
"An Act to vest the mineral rights in the State Govt.
and to provide for payment of amount to the owners of
minerals and for other matters connected therewith."
\
'
•.
The crucial section is S. 3 of the Haryana Act which runs as follows :
c
D
E
F
G
H
"S. 3 Vesting of minerals in State Government.-( 1)
The State Government may, from time to time, by notification, acquire the right to any minerals in any land and the
right to the minerals specified in the notification shall, from
the date of its publication; vest in the State Government.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for
the time being in force, on the publication of the notification
under sub-section (1), the right to the minerals in the land
specified in the notification shall vest absolutely in the State
Government and the State Government shall, subject to the
provisions of the Mines and Minerals (Regulation and Development) Act, 1957, have all the powers necessary for the
proper enjoyment or disposal of such right.
+
( 3) The right to the minerals in the land includes the
right of access to land for the purpose of prospecting and
working mines and for the purposes subsidiary thereto including the sinking of pits and shafts, erection of plants
and machinery, construction of roads, stacking of minerals
and deposits of refuse, quarrying and obtaining building and
road materials, using water and taking timber and any other
purpose which the State Government may declare to be subsidiary to mining.
( 4) If the State Government bas assigned to any person
its right over any minerals, and if for the proper enjoyment
of such right, it is necessary that all or any of the powers
specified in sub-section (2) and (3) should be exercised, tbe
Collector may, by an order in writing subject to such conditions and reservations as he may specify, delegate such powers
to the person to whom the right has been assigned".
Other provisions of the Haryana Act are not material. Section 1
merely gives the Act its title and Section 2 deals with definitions.
Section 4 relates to compensation. Section 5 provides for references
oi disputes about compensation to Civil Courts. Section 6 applies
Civil procedure to compensation proceedings. Section 7 provides for
appeals. Section 8 contains the necessary powers of the State Government to frame rules. These provisions exhaust the Act.
•
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
(Beg, J.)
7 05
Saltpetre was declared a minor mineral by notification No. 1{31) A
65-MII on 21st January, 1967. Its deposits are said to have been
found in 63 8 villages of Haryana. It appears that the State of Haryaua
considered itself to be the owner of these deposits on the strength of
1
entries in the records of rights (Wajib-ul-arz) of these villages and
used to auction them in accordance with the Punjab Minor Mmerals
Concession Rules, 1964. But, on 25th May, 1971, the Punjab &
Haryana High Court held on a Writ Petition (C.W. No. 122l of B
1971), that unless the mineral deposits are specifically mentioned in
the Wajib-ul-arz of a village as having vested in the State, their ownership would still remain vested in the former proprietors mentioned as
owners of their lands in a Wajib-ul-arz. As a result of this decision,
the right to Saltpetre deposits was found to be vested in individual
proprietors of their estates and Gram Panchayats in about 600 out of
638 villages. It is stated that, in order to meet this situation., the c
Haryana Act No. 48 of 1973 was framed and passed. The President
of India gave his assent to it on 6th December, 1973. It was thus
( a logical corollary of land reforms. Apparently, there was no
\ conflict between the State and the Union Government on the policy
underlying the Act.
·
D
The arguments advanced on behalf of the appellant State were :
•
•
Firstly, that the Central Act does not purport to cover or operate
upon the power to acquire ownership in minerals which are part of
"land". The relevant entry for exercise of legislative power to acquire
property is entry 42 in the Concurrent List (List III) of the Seventh
Schedule. The Central Act purports to have been made in exercise of
the power under entry 54 of List I for regulation and development of
mines, whereas the Haryana Act operates in the distinct and separate
field of acquisition of property.
"
Secondly, minerals being part of "land" in the State, within the
competence of the State Legislature to legislate upon, under entry 18
of the State List (List II), legislation falling substantially under this
head, read with entry 23 of the State List and entry 42 of the Concurrent List (List III), should not be invalidated unless we are compelled
to do so.
Thirdly, entry 54 of List I, set out above would naturally cover
only those parts of the field of acquisition, in accordance with rules of
interpretation indicated in State of West Bengal's case (supra), which
are expressly excluded from this special field by the Central Act.
Particularly, as acquisition belongs to a different head in the concurrent field, on which there is neither a Central Act for acquiring ownership of mineral deposits nor any express provision for it in Act 67 of
1957, there could be no question of the exclusion of the power of
the State Legislature to pass the impugned Act. There was thus no
imavoidable conflict between it and the State Act.
Fourthly, the impugned Act is protected from any challenge on the
ground of inadequacy of compensation or the unreasonableness of
the principles contained in Section 4 ( 1) of the Haryana Act, as the
•
E
•
F
G
H
706
A
B
' SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1976] 3 S.C.R.
acquisition of parts of estates of former proprietors of land falls under
Article 3 lA.
On the other hand, the learned Counsel for the respondents has
urged that the cases before us are covered completely by the decisions '
of this Court discussed above, and, in particular by those in Tulloch
)
Co's., case (supra) and Baijnath Kedia's case (supra). It is urged
that, when acquisition is only a nieans of conservation or development
of mineral resources, even this field must be held to be necessarily
excluded by the declaration in Section 2 and other provisions of Central Act 67 of 1957 which will become unworkable if the provisions.
of the Haryana Act were permitted to operate.
It seems difficult to sustain the cas~ that the provisions of the
Central Act would be really unworkable by mere change of ownership
of land in which mineral deposits are found.
We have tojudge the
· character of the Haryana Act by the substance and effect of its provisions and not merely by the purpose given in the statement of reasons
and objects behind it. Such statements of reasons are relevant when ~
the object or purpose of an enactment is in dispute or uncertain. They
can never override the effect which follows logically from the explicit
D and unmistakable language of its substantive provisions. Such effect
is the best evidence of intention. A statement of objects and reasons is
not a part of the statute, and, therefore, not even relevant in a case
in which .the language of the operative parts of the Act leaves no room
whatsoever, as it does not in the Haryana Act, to doubt what was
meant by the legislators. It is not disputed here that the object and
effect of the Haryana Act was to acquire proprietary right to mineral
E deposits' in "land".
Its provisions, however, do not mention leasehold
or licensee rights. Obviously, this is so because these rights are gov. crned by the Central Act 67 of 1957.
c
•
F
G
H
As we found nothing in the judgment under appeal or in the arguments advanced by either side to indicate that the effect of Act 56 of
1972 which had amended Act 67 of 1957 had been specifically noticed,
we considered it necessary to hear further arguments with a view te>
giving parties an opportunity of showing us how earlier decisions. when
the provisions introduced by Act 56 of 1972 were not there, could be at
all helpful in deciding the question now before us. One of the objections taken before us, at the further hearing given to the parties, was
that we should not allow a new point to be argued. We do not think
that any new question was allowed by us to be raised simply because
we have permitted parties to place their points of view on the same
question after taking into account some changes in the Central Act.
Indeed, we are bound to take judicial notice of the law as it exists
after its amendment. We can only apply the Jaw as it exists and not
the Jaw as it once was. No party could justifiably complain that it
was given an additional opportunity to meet what follows from the
amended law even if the effect of the amendment was not noticed
earlier.
We are particularly impressed by the provisions of Sections 16 and
17 as they now stand. A glance at section 16 ( 1 )(b) shows that the
.
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL
I
.
(Beg, J.)
707
Central Act 67 of 1957 itself contemplates vesting of lands, which had
belonged to any proprietor of an estate or tenure holder either on or
after 25th October, 1949, in a State Government under a State enactment providing for the acquisition of estates or tenures in land or
for agrarian reforms. The provisions lay down that mining leases granted in such land musl be brought into conformity with the amended law
introduced by Act 56 of 1972. It seems to us that this clearly means that
Parliament itself contemplated State legislation for vesting of lands containing mineral deposits in the State Govt. It only required that rights
to mining granted in such land should be regulated by the provisions
of Act 67 of 1957 as amended. This feature could only be explained
on the assumption that Parliament did notjntend to trench upon powers
of State Legislatures under entry 18 of List II, read with entry 42
d List Ill. Again, Section 17 of the Central Act 67 of !957 shows
that there was no intention to interfere with vesting of lands in the
States by the provisions of the Central Act.
The only answer given on behalf of the respondents to this contention is that such vesting as it contemplated by Section 16(1) (b)
of the Ccmral Act, as it now stands, must be of "estates" of proprietors
or lands of tenure holders under some legislation for agrarian reform.
We arc unable to find any force @ this contention. Article 31 A of
the Constitution is not confined to legislation for agrarian reform.
Agrarian reform is only one oF the possible or alternative objects of
such acquisition. It need not be the exclusive or only purpose of
State legislation contemplated by Section 16 (1) (b) of the Centml Act.
And, power lo legislate for the acquisition -0f the whole of an estate
or "tenure'' would include the power to legislate for any part of it.
Writ Petition Nos. 1309 to 1318 and 1371 to 1373 of 1975,
directed against the provisions of this Act, have also been placed before
us for arguments and appropriate orders. The petitioners in these
cases assert rights as holders of mining leases granted by persons who
had been entered as proprietors of estates in the records of rights in
various villages. The rights of persons so entered (in a "Wajib-ulal'L'') to mineral deposits in their former lands have been acquired by
the State under the Haryana Act. According to the Haryana State,
the Act was passed so as to, inter-alia, change the law as declared by
the Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case reported in AIR 1972
P&H p. 50. According to the view of the High Conrt, rights in such
lands had continued to vest in former owners of estates despite acquisitions of other parts of their "estate". The effect of the Haryana Act
was, it was urged, only to change the ownership without interfering
with the regulation of leasehold or licensee rights in minerals under the
provisions of the Central Act 67 of 1957. The Haryana Act expressly slates that it operates subject to the overriding provisions of Act 67
of1957.
•
·
Dr. L. M. Singhvi, appearing on behalf of the State of Haryana, in
the Writ Petitions under Article 32, submits : Firstly, that the legislative competence of the State Legislature, under entry 23 of List II
is subjected to entry No. 54 of List I only "to the extent to which"
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
708
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
Parliament chooses to take upon itself the regulation of mines and
minerals and no more. Secondly, in arriving at a decision on the extent to which Parliament has, removed regulation and development of
mines from State control, strict construction ought to be adopted so
that, without a specific and clear declaration by Parliament, ousting
the power of State Legislature to deal with vesting of land in the State
Government, it should not be assumed that the legislative power of the
State to acquire what is "land" had been taken away. Thirdly, Parliament having legislated specifically only in order to regulate the grant
of nlining leases and concessions, irrespective of the ownership of the
lands in which mining leases and concessions are granted, the clear
legislative intent of Parliament, gathered from the Central Act 67 of
1957 itself, also was to exclude the topic of acquisition of ownership
and other rights in land, apart from those of holders of mining leases
and licences, from its purview. Fourthly, the majority view in the
State cf West Bengal's case (supra) should be read in the context of
the particular Act considered there under which the Union Govt. had
been given powers of acquiring lands belonging to the State of West
Bengal. No such Central Act is before us for interpretation. Even if
the power was vested in the Parliament to acquire land as an incident
of regulation and development of minerals, that power not having
been exercised at all by Act 67 of 1957, it was not permissible to
assume any conflict between the Central Act 67 of 1957 and the
Haryana Act. Fifthly, D. M. Collieries & Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Burdwan Division('), following 66 C.W.N. ·P· 304=AIR
1960 Cal. 646, could be relied upon to urge that States had not Jost
their legislative competence altogether to acquire lands in which mineral
rights could be granted. Examples of such acquisitions were : section
10 of the Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950, Section 5(2) of the West
Bengal Estate Acquisition Act, 1953 (as amended by Act 22 of 1964)
Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957 : Coaking Coal Mines (Nationalisation) Act 1972, and Coal Mines, (Nationalisation) Act, 1973. In any case, until Parliament legislates to
acquire ownership of mineral. deposits in a State, this field cannot be
said to be occupied merely because of the declaration in Act 67 of
1957 which contains nothing whatsoever about the ownership of
minerals. Sixthly, the. provisions of Act 67 of 1957 also show that
the power of granting leases and concessions in respect of mineral
deposits is left largely to State Government.
\
There is, however, one argument advanced on behalf of holders
of leases or licences of mining rights which must be upheld. It 1s
that Jessee and licensee rights, governed by the provisions of Acl
67 of 1957 or rules made thereunder, are not covered by the Haryana
Act. It is clear from Section 3 (2) of the Haryana Act itself that
the provisions of this Act arc to be read subject to the provisions
made by or under the Central Act.. Mor~over, the Harya~a Act
does not and cannot ipso facto termmate either Jessee or licensee
rights which were subsisting on the date when the Harvana Act
came into force. On the other hand, section 9 of the Central Act
(\) 78 C.W.N. 44.
.,,
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL (Beg, /.)
709
56 oi" 1972, which amended section 16 of the Principal Act (Central
Act 67 of 1957), made it imperativ.e for such lessee rights as existed
in estates, (which had vested in a State Government) to be brought
into conformity with the Central Act. Obviously, therefore, if there
arc any lessee or licensee rights of mining in minor minerals on land
which were actually regulated by the provisions of the Central Act
67 of 1957, they will continue.
Although, this is a legally correct
contention, it was not shewn to us how the notification of auctions of
mining rights affected any subsisting rights of any alleged lessee or
licensee. The facts of no individual case W('re placed before
us. Wc do not know which respondent in the appeal
or which
petitioner in Writ Petitions before us has any subsisting rights governed by any of the provisions of the Central Act or rules made thereunder. It has also not been shewn to us that any lessee or licensee
asked the State Government to carry out any statutory or contractual
obligation before he invoked the Writ jurisdiction of the High Court
or of this Court. Thus, essential averments to disclose subsisting
rights or the locus standi of the petitioners are wanting here.
I
•
..
In Writ Petitions No. 1309-1318 and 1371-1373 of 1975, the
pctit;onerc; only assert that they are lessees of minor minerals holding
righh under registered leases executed by the owners of minor
minerals. But, they do not state whether their leases are governed
by or have been brought into conformity with the provisions of the
Central Act
"
Anncxure 'A' is the notification, dated 10th April, 1974, assailed
by petitioner in this Court. Its purpose is stated in the follo\ving
"
A
B
c
D
E
tl'fll1\ :
"la exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (I)
o[ Section 3 of the Haryana Mineral (Vesting of Rights) Act,
1973, the Governor of Haryana hereby acquires the right
to the minerals, mentioned in column 6 of the schedule
given below in the land specified in column 5 thereof".
~
The schedule contains a large number of khasra numbers of plots
in various villages covered by the notification.
Another notification of 11th September, 1975,
the p2titioncrs in this Court says :
challenged
by
""It is hereby notified for the general public that Minor
Mineral quarries of Gurgaon District, as per particulars
given below, will be put to auction on 11-10-1975 in the
oJlice of Senior-District !ndustrics Officer, Faridabad, at
iO A.M.".
.
Thcrc·aftcr, follows the names of 139 villages in Tehsil Gurgaon under
the heading "Name of Quarry". Under the next heading. "Name
of the Minor Mineral", occur the words "Road metal and stone."
H
710
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1976] 3 S.C.R.
The notification then proceeds to say :
"The terms and conditions of the auction are
below : -
B
given
\
(i) Each bidder shall be required to deposit a sum of Rs.
200 in cash as earnest money, with the Presiding Officer
before participating in the auction.
(ii) The period of contract shall commence from the date
of execution of the agreement to the 21st March, 1977.
~
(iii) Other terms and conditions of auction shall be the same
as contained in the Punjab Minor Mineral Concession
Rules, 1964, as adopted by Haryana Government.
c
D
E
F
(iv) The highest bidder shall be entitled to obtain shortterm permits from ·the date of auction till the date of
acceptance of his bid by the competent authority. Therefore, he will not have any right to revoke his officer.
Any other information he had from the Senior District
Officer, Faridabad.
Industries
(B. L. MITTAL)
Director of Industries, Haryana".
Some of the numbers given in the first notification correspond
with the number of plots in respect of which the petitioners ~llege to
be lease-holders. A perusal of the petitions and the counter-affidavits
filed in reply on behalf of the State of Haryana shows that the only
dispute between the parties relates to the vesting of ownership rights
But, the petitioners have come
in a minor mineral in these plots.
Rights of former owners
before us as lessees and not as owners.
have been validity terminated by the Haryana Act. We arc unable
to make out, from these petitions how any Jessee rights acquired by
the petitioners themselves, under any law subsist or are affected by
the notifications mentioned above.
"
We proceed to record our conclusions a:s follows :
G
H
1. The Haryana Minerals (Vesting of Rights) Act, 1973, is
valid, as it is not, in any way, repugnant to the provisions of the
Mines and Minerals (Regulation of Development) Act 67 of 1957,
made by Parliament. Ownership r;ghts could be and have been
validity acquired by the Haryana Govt. unecr the Haryana Act.
2, No rights are shewn by any petitioner before us to have been
conferred upon him under any lease or licence executed or brought
in accordance with the provision of the Central Act 67 of 1957, but,
any petitioner, either before the High Court or in this Court, now
before us, who can establish any such right governed by the
provisions of the Central Act 67 of 1957 may take such proceedings
before an appropriate Court, if so advised, as may still be open to
him under the Jaw, against any such action or Govt. notification as
..
HARYANA V. CHANAN MAL (Beg, J.)
711
is alleged to infringe that right. We are unable to find any such
right in any writ petition, as framed, now before us.
I
3. Any petitioner who applies for a writ or order in the nature
of a mandamus should, in compliance with a well known rule of
practice, ordinarily, first call upon the authority concer,1ed to discharge its legal obligation and show that it has refused or neglected
to carry it out within a re!ISonable time before applying to a Court
for such au order even where the alleged obligation is established .
•
A
B
•
Accordingly, subject to the observations made above, we allow
Civil Appeals Nos. 844-860 of 1975, and set aside the judgment and
orders of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana and dismiss the
Writ petitions.
~
•
We also dismiss the Writ Petitions Nos. 1309-1318 and 13711373 of 1975, subject to the observations made above, filed ·in this
Court.
Parties will bear their own costs.
P.B.R.
•
..
.
Appeal allowed &
Petitions dismissed.
c
•
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org