MOHD. SHAHBUDDIN & ORS. versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 22 January 1975 | [1975] 3 S.C.R. 306 | 1975 INSC 12
Key facts
- Decided
- 22 January 1975
- Bench
- P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY*, P.N. BHAGWATI, P.K. GOSWAMI
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 12/1972
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [1975] 3 S.C.R. 306
- Neutral citation
- 1975 INSC 12
Text of the judgment
3QG
A
MOHD. SHAHBUDDIN & ORS.
v.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
January 22, 1975
f P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY, P. N. BHAGWATI AND P. K. GOSWAM1,, JJ.J
States Reorganisation Act 1956-Equatio11 of posts how far cmz court
interfere-Wh&ther decisions taken at the Chief Mi11isiers' co11ference must be
co111plied with--!/ equation ca11 be based on irrelerant and irrational com'iderations or erroneous assumptions.
The validity of the equation of posts of graduate teachers allotted to ih1~ new
State of Mysore constituted under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. was
challenged. The new State of Mysore was formed comprising the territories of
the existing States of Mysore, Coorg, and part3 of existing States of Hyderabad,
Madras and Bombay. The graduate teachers in each of the 5 integrating areas
were divided into two grades a lower grade and a higher grade as g:vrn
below:
B
C
---·--------~-~--
Higher Grade
Lower Grade
Integrating area
]}
Mysore
Rs. 60-150
Rs. 130-200
Coorg
Rs. 80-220
Rs. 100-300
Bo;nbay
Rs. 70-200
Rs. 210-300
Madras
Rs.
85-175
Rs. 165-245
Rs. 130-190
Rs. 154-275
Hyderabad
E
--------~----
On the constitution of the various new States the qtte.stion of equation of
posts. ~bsorption of ?er:vice personnel in the eguated posts ~nd the de~e.rmi
nation of mter se semonty cropped up. A meeting of the Chief Secretam:s of
these States was held at Delhi in May, 1956, at the invitation of the Central
Go1ernment. The. following decisions were taken at that meeting :
"It was agreed that in deter.mining the equation
ing factors should be borne in mind : -
of
posts·,
the
F
follow·
1,i) the natme and duties of a post;
I ii) th~ responsibiliiies and powers exerciscJ by the officer holding a post:
the extent of tenitorial or other charge held or responsibilities discharged;
(}
(iii) the minimum qualifications. if any, prescribed for recruitment to the
~est;
fi1) the salary of the post.
It was agreed that in determining relatil'e seniority as betwee~ two persons
holding posts declared equrvalenr to each other, and drawn from different States
the following points should be taken into account : Ci) lenoth of continuous service, 1'hethcr temporary or permanent, in a
pa;ticulc\i· graue; this should exduJe pcrioJs for which an appointment is held in· a purely stop-gap or fo1 tmtous arrangement:.
H
SHAHBUDDIN V, UNION
A
I.ii) age of the person; other factors being equal for instance, seniority
may be determined on the basis of' age,
It was also agreed that as far as possible, the in.ter se seniority of
drawn from the same State should not be disturbed.
B
c
D
E
307
otlkers
In February, 1958, the provisional inter-State list of teachers in the graduate
tutorial cadre for new Mysore State was prepared. This list was prepared on
the basis that the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade. of Rs. 154-275
were equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200,
while. the posts of ex-Coo'rg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300
were equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150.
The Coorg teachers in. the grade of Rs. 100-300 were dissatisfied with the
equation of their posts with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs.
60-150. They, therefore, filed a Writ. Petition in the High Court o~ Mysore.
One of the contentions of the petitioners was upheld by the High Court in
the year 1%4 and the State Government was directed to prepare a provisional
inter-State seniority list of teachers. in the graduate tutorial cadre. Pursuant to
the mid direction the State Government prepared a provisional Inter-State
July, 1964. Thereafter a final inter-State
seniority
seniority list in
Iist of teachers
in
the
graduate
tutotrial
cadre
was prepared in
December, 1966, which was different from provisional list prepared in 1964.
In the final seniority list the equation of posts was different from the one proposed in the provisional inter-State seniority list. The ex-Hyderabad and Coorg
teacl)e.rs filed a petition in the High Court of Mysore for quashing and setting
a'ide the equation of posts on which the final inter-State seniority was based.
The High Court by its judgment delivered in 1969 allowed the writ pdition on
the ground that the seniority list was pr_epared without giving any opportunity
to ex-Hyderabad teachers. and· 'that vitiated the equation of posts. After considering the representations filed by all the teachers concerned a provisional
inter-State seniority list was published in November, 1969. Though the claim
of the ex-Hyderabad teachers was not accepted in toto, they were satisfied with
the decision of the Central Government cont~ined in the provisional list puhlished in 1970. The ex-Coorg teachers were dissatisfied and, therefore, they
made r~presentatiom complaining against the decision of the Central Government. In December. 1971, the.final Inter-State seniority list was published. The
final list varied the equation to the disadvantage of the ex-Hyderabad teachers
as compared to the provisional list The ex-Hyderabad teachers and ex-Coorg
teachers therefore, filed the present petition in this Court.
It was contended before this Court by the ex-Hyderabad teachers :
F
(I) Equation of posts in the final list different from the provisional list
made by the Central Government was without giving :1ny opportunity to the Hyderabad teach~rs to make a proper representation and
was in violation of the principles of natural justice.
( 2) The Central Government failed to take into account the 4 factors
decided upon at the Chief Secretaries Conference;
G
H
( 3) The equation of posts made by the Central Government was based
on erroneous assumptions and· irrelevant considerations and dis-.
closed non-application of mind to the material and relevant facts.
HELD : The power to determine equation of posts belon$s to the Central
Government under section 115(5) of the States Reorganisation Act and this
re" er must be exercised by the Central Government after giving an opportun it-, tc) the allocated Government servant to make representations in regard to
thi,; m~,tter. The Central Government is bound to have regard to the 4 factors
de;:idecl upo1'1 at the Conference of the Chief Secretaries held in l\fay, 1956 in
detern•ining equation of posts. It is not open to the court to consider wheth~r
the equation of posts made by the Central Government is right or wrong if
those 4 factors have been proper!;' taken into account. Wh;lt the court can
<;eru!inise is only whether the 4 factors agreed upon at .the Chief Sccre1:1r;es
C0cfo"''nce ha,·e been properlv taken into accoun•. If the court find5 that one
308
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 3 s.c.R.
or more of these 4 factors have been 'gnored the court can strike down the
equation of posts made by the Central Government. The Court can also interfere if it finds that th'-'! decision of the Central Government in regard to the
equation of posts is maiafide or without application of mind. The Court may
also intervene if it com~s to the conclusion that the decision of the Central
Government is based on irrelevant considerations or wrong assumptions or that
it is so irrational or per:<erse that no reasonable person properly instructt!d and
taking into acc:ount relevant factors could possibly arrive at it. [316H-.317E]
HELD FURTHER : The ex-Hyderabad teachers, did make representatien
after the judgment of the High Court delivered in 1969 and the Government
took those representations into cornideration before making the final list. It
is not possible to say that the decision was taken by the Central GovernmeBt
without giving an opportunity to the ex-Hyderabad teachers to make a proper
representation or that there was auy violation of the principles or natural
justice. [3190~-G]
HELD FURTHER :-The final seniority list does not give the reasons which
weighed with the Central Government in making the equation of posts. Howe\er, in the counter-affidavit filed in this Court on behalf of the Government
reasons have hcen disclosed why the equation of oosts was done in the manner
given in the final list. The Central Government in determining equation of posts
omitted to take into account the relevant considerations and failed to apply the
criteria of the first and second factors decided at the Chief Se:retaries meeting.
The Central Govt. d cl not compare the post of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the
grade of Rs. 154-275 and the ex-Bombay. ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers
in the higher grades on lhe basis of the criteria of the first and second factors.
The Central Government also il?Jlored ~!together the fourth factor, narndv. the
salary of the post. The equation had to be done by reference to the four criteria
laid down in the Conference of the Chief Secretaries. It was immaterial w:ltether
the grades which were sought to be equated were initial recruitment grades or
promotional °'rades. There was no requirement either of law or of principle
that one initial recruitm1~nt grade could be equated only with another initial
recruitment grade or that one promotional grade could be equated with only
another promotional grade. Even factually the Central Government was not
right in saying that the ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-275 was not a promotional grade but an initial recruitment grade for trained graduates. [3 l9H320B; 321H; 323F-G; 324 E-G; 326C-G]
HELD FURTHER : The Central Government failed to take into ac:rnunt
an important and ~levant consideration, namely, that of the qualifications
required for recruitment to the posts sought to be equated. At any given point
of time, there was always a large number of untrained graduates in the exMysore grade of Rs. 6()-150 whereas in ex-l:Iyder~bad all teachers in the
grade of Rs. 150-275 were trained graduates. [329 E-F]
HELD FURTHER : The equation of posts made by the Central Government
is illegal and invalid in so far as it relates to the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers
in the grade of Rs. 154--275. The iinal seniority list is also set aside to the
extent it relates to the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs.
154-275. and the Central Government is directed to make fresh equation of posts
after taking into account all relevant facts having material bearing on the qU;!stion
anr' in the light of the observations contained in the judgment. [329H-330EJ
HELD FURTHER·. The case of ex-Coorg teachers stands on ,ne same footing
as that of ex-Hyderabad teachers in some materia: respects. The Central Govern:
men! failed to take into account the four criteria laid down in the Chief Secretaries Conferen:,e. The Central Government also proceeded on an erroneous
basis. These infirmities vitiated the equation of posts. The equation of posts
as also final seniority list are based upon it, in so far as they relate to the posts
of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 are therefore quashed and
set aside the Central Government is directed to make f1nh equation of posts and
after taking into account all relevant facts havinrr material bearine on the
question and :n the li~ht of the observations contained in the judgment. [331K-.D: 332A-BJ
A
B
c
[)
E
F
G
H
SHAHBUDDIN v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
A
ORIGINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION :
149 of 1972.
'
309
Writ Petition Nos. 12 &
Petitions Under Article 32 of the Constitutio11.
D. V. Patel and K. N. Bhatt, for the petitioners (in WP. J\o.
72).
12/
B
11. B., P. P. Bhopa1111a and Narayan Nettar, for the petitioner (In
WP. No. 149/72).
5. N. Prasad and R. N. Sachthey, for respondent No. 1 (In WP.
No. 12/72).
c
K. S. Puttaswamy Govt. Ad1,ocate for Karnataka and M. Veerappa,
for r~spondents Nos. 2 & 3 (In WP. No. 12/72).
S. S. Jaya/i and B. P. Singh, for respondents Nos. 4-9, 10-12 &
14 (ln \VP. No. 12/72) and respondent Nos. 4-9 (Jn WP. No.
149/72).
Narayan Ne/tar, for respondent No. 13 (In WP. No. 12/72).
D
. S. N. Prasad and R. N. Sachthey, for respondent No. 1 (In WP. No.
149 /72).
M. Veerappa, for Respondents Nos. 2 & 3 (In WP. No. 149/72).
The Judgment of the Couruwas delivered by
E
F
G
H
BHAGWATI, J.--The short question tha~ arises for consideration in
these petitions is as to the validity of the equation of posts of graduate
teachers allotted to the new State of Mysore constituted under the
States Reorganisation Act, 1956. This A<.:t re-drew the boundaries
of the different States in India with effect from .1st November, 1956
and inter alia a new State of Mysore was formed comprising the territories of the existing States of Mysore and Coorg, four districts in the
existing State of Bombay, three districts in the existing State of
Hyderabad and one district in the existing State of Madras. Prior
to the reorganisation, each of these five integrating areas, which went
to make up the new State of Mysore, had a different set up of school
administration. The schools in the Mysore and Coorg areas were
classified into Primary schools, Middle schools and High schools. In
the Bombay and Madras areas,. the schools were classified into Primary schools and Secondary schools and in the Hyderabad area the
classification was into Primary schools, Middle schools and composite
schools. The Secondary schools in the Bombay and Madras areas and
the composite schools in the Hyderabad area comprised the same classes
<ts the Middle schools and High Schools in the Mysore and Coorg areas
The posts of teachers in these schools were inter-changeable with the
posts in the Inspectorate Branch in the Education Department and
the Training Institutions and they belonged to common cadres. We
shall, for the sake of convenience, refer to the persons occupving the
posts of teachers in these schools as also the persons occupying COP-
310
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 3 s.c.R.
responding posts in the Inspectorate Branch and the Training Institution as "graduate teachers". These petitions are concerned only with
graduate teachers so described and, therefore, we shall confine our discussion fo them alone.
The graduate teachers in each of the five integrating areas were
divided into two grades, a lower graue and a higher grade and the
pay scales of these two grades differed from one integrating area to
the other as shown by the following particulars :
Integrating area
Lower Grade
Higher Grade
A
B
c
~·-
My;,ore
Rs. 60-150
Rs. 130-200
Coorg
Rs. 80-220
Rs. 100-300
Bombay
Rs. 70-200
Rs. 210-300
Madras
Rs. 85-175
Rs. 165-245
Hyderabad
Rs. 130-190
Rs. 154-275
D
There was alsu one post of Principal, Janatha College in the C:oorg
area prior to the reorganisation which carried a pay scale of Rs. 200300. This was a college· started on an experimental basis under the
Five Year Plan and the post of Principal was created as a temporary
post under a Government Order dated 7th March, 1955.
E
On the constitution of the new State of Mysore by corning together
d these five integrating areas, a question arose as to how the graduate
teachers allotted to the new State of Mysore from these five integrating
ar~as silould be adjusted so as to form an integrated service in the
new State of Mysore and it was, therefore, necessary to decide where
and at what place they should be adjusted in the constitution of the
new service. This process necessarily involved equation of posts,
absorption of service personnel in the equated posts and the deterirnnation of inter se seniority. Now, this was not a problem confini~d to
one service or one State alone and principles had, therefore, to be
evolved which would be uniformly applicable in relation to integration
of services in all the States which were going to be affected by the
reorganisation. A meeting of the Chief Secretaries of these States
wJs accordingly held at Delhi on 18th and 19th May 1956 at the
invitation of the Central Government. Certain decisions were taken
at this meeting as to the general principles 'that should be observed w!th
regard to the work of integration of the services. The Government
of India, by their letter dated 3rd April, 1957, informed the State
F'
G
H
SHAHBUDD!N v. UNION (Bhagwati, !.)
A
B
311
Governments that they had decided that the work of integration of
services should be dealt with by the State Governments in the light ot
general principles already decided at the meeting of the Chief Secre·
taries. The State Governments were also informed that the Central
Government was constituting Advisory Committees for assisting them
in dealing with the representations by the officers affected by the reorganisation. The principles for determining equation of posts and
inter se seniority of allocated Government servants reached at the confrrc;;.:e of the Chief Secretaries were as follows :
· "It was agreed that in determining the equation of posts,
the following factors should be borne in mind : -
c
(i) the nature and duties of a post;
(iil the responsibilities and powers exercised by the officer
holding a post; the extent of territorial or other charge
held or responsibilities discharged;
(iii) the minimum qualifications, if any, prescribed for
recruitment to the post;
D
(iv) the salary of the post;
It wac agreed that in determining relative seniority as
between two persons holding post a declared equivalent to
each other, and drawn from different States, the following
points should be taken into account : (i) Length of continuous service, whether temporary or
permanent, in a particular grade; this should exclude
periods for which an appointment is held in a purely
stop-gap or fortuitous arrangement;
F
(ii) age of the person; other factors being equal, for instance, seniority may be determined on the basis of
age.
Note :
It was also agreed that as far as possible, the
inter se seniority of officers drawn from the same State should
not be disturbed.
G
H
Though these principles were laid down as far back as 18th and'.
19th May, 1956, long prior to the reorganisation, neither the Centrar
Gowrnment nor the State Government took any steps for the purpose
of determining the equation of posts of graduate teachers and their
i111er se seniority. On 3rd February, 1958, the Director of Public
lnstruction circulat::d a Provisional Inter State List of teachers in the
graduate tutorial cadre and this list was prepared on the basis that the·
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were
equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130200, while the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100300 were equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of
Rs. 60-150. Presumably, on the assumption that this list would
312
· SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 3 s.c.R.
be finalised at an early date by the Central Government, the State
Go\lernment made temporary promotions to Class II Gazetted posts
on the basis of this list and some of the ex-Hyderabad teachers i11 the
grade of Rs. 154-275 were consequently promoted to Class II Gazetted posts and out of them a few were even promoted to Class l posts
in an officiating capacity. So far as the Coorg tea:::hers in the grad~
of Rs. 100--300 were concerned, they were dissatisfied with the
equation of their posts with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade
of Rs. 60-150 and they accordingly challenged this list by filing Writ
Petition No. 603 o_f 1961 in the High Court of Mysore. Om: of the
contentions raised by them was that this list circulated by the Director
of Public Instruction had no validity, since the power to determine
c4ua1i1JJ1 of posts and inter se seniority of allocated teachers in the
i;radmil·~ tuwrial cadre was vested in the State and the State Government. should, therefore, be directed to prepare a provisional Inter State
SeniC'fity List in accordance wit.h the requirements of the Act. This
contention was upheld by a Division Bench of the High Court by a
judgment dated J 2th June, 1964 and the State Government was directed to prepart: a provisional Inter State seniority list of teachers in the
graduate tutorial cadre. Pursuant to this direction of the High
C011rt :he State Government prepared a Provisional Inter StatP. Seniority List and published it under a notification dated 2nd July, 1964.
This Provisional Tnter State Senioritv List was based on equation of
posts ,set out in Annexure II to the "List. The posts of ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 and the posts of cx-Coorg
teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 as also the post of Principal,
.fanatha College in th1: grade of Rs. 200-300 were equated with the
posts of ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 210-300, the posts
0f ex-Madras teachers in the grade of Rs. 165-245 and the posts of
ex-Mysore. teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200, while the posts of
ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-190 and the posts of
ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 80-220 were equated with
the posts of ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 7b-200. the
posts of ex-Madras teachers in the grade of Rs. 85-175 and the posts
of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade uf Rs. 60-150. It was on the
basis of this equation of posts that the seniority of teachers in the
graduate tutorial cadre was determined under the Provisional Inter
State Sesnority List published by the State Government.
The petitioners in Writ Petition No. 12 of 1972 (hereafter referred to as the ex-Hyderabad petitioners) are all graduates of recognised universities and they also hold the degree of H.T. or B.Ed. and
are accordingly trained graduate teachers. The ex-Hyderabad petitioners were originally appointed in the erstwhile State of Hyderabad
in posts in the grade of Rs. 130-190 and subsequently in course of
time they were promoted strictly in accordance with the principle of
seniority-cum-merit to the grade of Rs. 154-275 on various dates
before 1st November, 1956. The ex-Hyderabad petitioners were
thus in the grade of Rs. 154-275 a:t the time of the reorganisation
when thry were allocated to the nrw State of Mysore from the cxHyderabad area. Since the posts held by the ex-Hyderabad petitioners
were equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs.
A
B
c
D
G
H
I-
SHAHBUDDIN v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
313
I 30-200 under Annexure II to the Provisional Inter State Seniority
List and their seniority vis-a-vis the other allocated teachers was.
determined on the basis of such equation of posts, they did not have
any grievance with the Provisional Inter State Seniority List and they
accordingly did not make any representation to the State or Central.
Government against it.
The petitioners in Writ Petition No. 149 of 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the ex-Coorg petitioners) are also graduates of recognised
universities and hold the degree of B.T. or B.Ed. and are trained graduate; teachers. Out of them, petitioners Nos. 1 to 3 were originally
appointed in the grade of Rs. 80-220 but on ootaining the degree of
B.T. rhey were promoted to the grade Rs. 100-300. Petitioners
Nos. 4 to 15 were trained graduates directly appointed in the grade of
Rs. 100-300. Petitio,ners Nos. 16 to 27 were originally appointed in·
the grade of Rs. 80-200, but they subsequently obtained the degree
of B.T. and were accordingly promoted to the grade of Rs. 100-300.
And similarly, petitioner's Nos. 28 to 33 were originally appointed in.
the grade of Rs. 80-220 as untrnined graduates but on obtaining the
degr5e of B.T. they were promoted in the grade of Rs. 100-300. The
ex-Coorg petitioners were thus all in the grade of Rs. 100-300 at
the time of reorganisation when they were allocated to the new State
t'f Mysore from the ex-Coorg area. They also did not make any representation against the Inter State Provisional List published by the
State Government as the posts held by them were equated with those
of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 and they were
satisfied with that equation and the inter se seniority based upon it.
The State Government thereafter by a notification dated 27th
December, 1965 published the final Inter-State Seniority List of teachers in the graduate tutorial cadre in exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution and in accordDiice with the decision of the Government of India under the provision
of section 115 (S) of the Act. The ex-Hyderabad and the ex-Coorg
petitioners were surprised to find that this Final Inter State Seniority
List was based on an equation of posts which was different from the
one proposed in the Provisional inter State Seniority List. The final
Inter State Seniority List classified the posts of teachers into three
cndrcs, the first being promotional cadre, . the second being intermediate cadre and the third. being initial recruitment cadre. The posts
of ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 210~300, the posts of
ex-Madras teache.rs in the grade of Rs. 165-245, the posts of exMysorc teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 and the post of Principal. Janatha College in. the grade of Rs. 200-300 were equated
and placed in promotional cadre, while the .posts of ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 150--275 as well as the grade of Rs. 130190 and the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grades of Rs. 110-300
as well as the grade of Rs. 60-200 were equated with the posts of
ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 70'-200, the posts of exMadras teachers in· the grade of Rs. 85-175 and the posts of exM:vsore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150 and placed in the initial
recruitment cadre. The result of this equation of oosts was that the
ex-Hyderabad petitioners who were in the grade of Rs. 154-275 and·
314
SUl'REME COURT REPORTS
(1975) 3 S.C.R.
A
the ex-Coorg petitioners who were in the grade of Rs. 1.00-300 were
;pushed down in seniority by hundred of places and their future prospects of promotions were seriously prejudiced.
The ex-Hyderabad petitioners along with some other ex-Hyd1)ra·
bad teachers thereupon filed a petition in the High Court of Mysore
for quashing and setting aside the equation of posts on which the final
Inter State Seniority List was bas1~d. There were several grounds on
which the validity of the equation of the posts was challenged but one
,ground which appealed to the High Court was that since the equation
of posts made in the Provisional Inter State Seniority List was not disadvantageous to the ex-Hyderabad teachers and they were satisfied
with it, they' did not make any representation placing all the relevant
facts in regard. to their case before the Central Government and the
.change in equation of posts in the final Inter State Seniority Listwhich was disadvantageous to }he ex-Hyderabad teachers-was thus
without any opportunity to them to have their say in the matter and
that vitated the equation of posts. The High Court on this view, by
an order dated 8th January, 1969, set aside the equation of post~ on
the basis of which the Final Inter State Seniority List was prepared ;:md
.directed that "that part of the Final Inter State Seniority List which
referred to the ex-Hyderabad teachers should be made again by the
Central Government after consideration of all the relevant facts and
circumstances and the ex-Hyderabad petitioners and all others who
were likely to be affected by the determination to be made by the
·central Government should submit their representations in regard to
this matter within a month from the date of the order of the High
Court.
The ex-Comg teachers also filed similar petitions in the High
Court of Mysore challenging the validity of equation of posts made in
the Final Inter State Seniority List -since the posts held by them were
equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60_:.:t 50
·and that was done by th::: Central Government without giving any
opportunity to them to make a representation. The High Court, by an
order dated 24th February, 1969, set aside the equation of the posts
of cx-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 with those of exMysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150 on the ground that the
Central Government had departed from the equation of posts made in
the Provisional Inter State Seniority List without giving any opportunity to the ex-Coorg teachers to make representations against such
departmc and directed that the Central Government should make a
prnrcr equation of posts. after giving to' the ex-Coorg teachers an
opportunity to make representations in regard to the matter.
Pursuant to the orders of the High Court dated 8th January, 1969
and 24th February, 1969 the ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of
Rs. 154-275 and the ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300
made representations to the Central Government contending that the
posts held by them should be equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers
'in the grad·:: of Rs. 130--300 and placed in promotional cadre. The
,.
c
D
E
F
G
H
SHAHBUDD!N v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
315
Central Government after considering these representations as also
representations received from other allocated teachers arrived at a ten- .
tative decision in ~egard. to the equation of posts and on the basis of
such tentative decision a Provisional Inter State Seniority List was
published by the State Government by a notification dated 20th
November, 1970. The equation of posts on the basis of which this
Provisional Inter State Senioiity List was prepared was set out in
Annexure I to the List. The posts of ex-Coorg t_eachers in the grade
of Rs. IG0-300 were equated with tho.se .of ex-Mysore teachers in
the grade of Rs. 60-150 and placed in category II which corresponded
to the initial recruitment cadre. However, so far as the posts of
ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were concerned,
they were treated as a special class and it was decided that "it is not
necessary to equate this post in Catego~y II, but for purposes of prornoti0n to the next higher Category, the teachers who were in the scale
of R3. 154-275 may be placed "en-bloc" immediately above the first·
teachers from Hyderabad in the scal_e of Rs. 130-190 who finds place
in C;;tc-gory II, thus maintaining the parent State Seniority · of the
teachers coming from the former State of Hyderabad." Vide note at
the foot of Annexure I to the Provj_sional Inter State Seniority List.
Though the claim of the ex-Hyderabad teachers to equation of
their posts with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130200 in· Category I, which corresponded to the promotional grade, was
not accepted by the Central Gov·ernment, they were satisfied with the
decision of the Central Government to place the en-bloc immediately
above the first ex-Hyderabad teacher in the grade of Rs. 130-190
and <hey accordingly did not make any representation to the Central
Government contending that the posts held by them should be equated
with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 and
placed in Category I. The ex-Coorg teachers were, however, dissatisfied with· the decision of the Central Government equating the posts
held by them with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs: 60150 in C§ltegory II and, therefore, they made representations complaining against the decision of the Central Government and submitting
that the posts held by them should be equated with those of ex-Mysore
teachers in the grade of Rs. l'J0-200 and placed in Category I. It
appears that the ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150
also made representations to the Central Government since the effect
of placing the ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154--:Z75
en-bloc immediately above the first teacher from the ex-Hyderabad in
the grade of Rs. 130'--190 was to push them back in seniority below ·
the ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275. The Central
Government after considering all these representations received from
different classes of allocated teachers as also the representations submitted by the ex-Hyderabad and the ex-Coorg teachers pursuant to the
directions contained in th~ orders of the High Court dated 8th
January, 1969 and 24th February, 1969 determined the equation of
posts and in accordance with this determination the State Governm'!nt
by a notification dated 9th December, 1971 published the Final Inter
State Seniority List. This Final Inter State Seniority Lisralso, like the
earlier one, classified the posts into Promotional cadre, Intermediate
316
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975J 3 s.c.R.
cadre and Initial Recruitment cadre. The posts of ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 as well as the posts of ex-Coorg
teachers in the grade of Rs. 100--300 were equated with the posts of
cx-Bomb.iy teachers in the grade of Rs. 70-200, the posts of the exMadras teachers in the grade of Rs. 85-175 and the posts of exMysore teachers in the grad~ of Rs. 60-150 and placed in the Initial
Recruitment cadre, while~ tl)e post of Principal, Janatha College in the
grade of Rs. 200-300, the posts of ex-Bombay teachers in the grade
of Rs. 210-300, the posts of ex-Madras teachers in the grade of
Rs. 165-245 and the posts of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of
Rs. 130-200 were equated and placed in the promotional cadre. The
r1~sult was that though prior to the reorganisation the ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154--275 and the ex-Coorg teacher~ in
the grade of Rs. 100-300 were eligible for being considered for pro~
motion to the post of m:ad Master which was a Class II Gazetted post
they could now hope to reach the post of Ifead Master only after
being first promotedto the Promotional cadre, which would mean that
they would have to await their turn until after all the teachers in the
Promotional c.adre were either promoted or rejected and moreover
th.-:ir seniOrity was seriously prejudiced and their future emoluments
considerably affected.
The ex-Hyderabad petitioners being aggrieved by the equation of
posts made in the Final Inter State Seniority List perferred Writ P1~ti
tion No. 1Tof 1972 in this Court challenging the validity of the equation i» so far as the posts held by ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade
of Rs. 154-275 were equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in
the grade of Rs. 60-150 and classified under the Category of Initial
Recruitment cadre. The contention of the ex-Hyderabad petitioners was that the posts held by the ex-Hyderabad teachers in
the grade of Rs. 154-275 should have been equated wicll those of
eK-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 and placed in the
Promotional cadre. Similarly, the ex-Coorg teachers also filed Writ
Pctitic111 No. 149 of 1972 in this Court challenging the validity of the
<:qt.ation made in the Final Inter State Seniority List in so far as the
posts held by the ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300
wt~re equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-·
150 and placed in the Initial Recruitment cadre. They also contended
that the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. l00-300
should have been equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the the
grade of Rs. 130-200 and treated as belonging to the Promotional
cadre. The question we are called upon to consider in these two writ
petitions is whether the claim made by the ex-Hyderabad petitioners
and the ex-Coorg petitioners c~n be sustained.
Before we proceed to examine the merits of the claim of the ex~
Hyderabad and the ex-Cpor.E? petitioners, it would ·be convenient first
to consirler the gl'ound on which an equation of posts made by the
Central Government may be challenged. It is now well settled that the
pow~r to determine equation of nosts belonj!s to the Central Govern-.
ment under section 115(.5) of the Actaoo this·power·must.be.exei:
cised by the Central Government after giving an opportunity to the
A
B
c
D
E
F
SHAHBUDD!N I'. UNION (Bhagwati, 1.)
A
B
c
D
E
317
allocated Government servants to make representations in regard to
this matter. This Court pointed out in Union of India v. P. K. Roy(l)
that a decision taken by the Central Government without giving an
opportunity to the officer:s affected to make representations would be
invalid and that was· affirmed by this Court in the subsequent aecision
in Union of India v. G. R. Prabhavalkar("). This Court also laid down
in t 1• I?a1ialt Raj v. Union of India(l) and Union of India v. G. R. Pra·
l>lwv•1//;,ire) that the Central Government is bound to have regard to
the four factors decided upon at the conference of the Chief Secretaries
held on 18th and 19th May, 1956 in deterrilining equation of posts and
if these four factors have been properly taken into account, the
decision of the Central Government cannot be assailed. It is not open
to th~ Court to consider whether the equation of posts made by the
Central Government is right or wrong. That is a matter exclusively
within the province of the Central Government. What the Court can
scrutinise is only whether the four factors agreed upon at the Chief
Secretaries' conference have been properly taken into account. If the
Court finds that one or mor·~ of these four factors have been ignored ..
the Court can strike down the equation of posts made by the Central
Government. The C~urt can also interfere if it finds that the decision
of the Central Government in regard to the equation of post.~ is maJa
fitle or .without application of mind. The Court may also in a proper
case intervene if it comes to the conclusion that the decision of the
Central Government is based on irrelevant considerations or wrong
assumptions or that it is so irrational or perverse that no reasonable
person properly instru,etcd and taking into account relevant fac~ors
could possibly arrive at it. This is the narrow and limited field within
which th::: supervisory jurisdiction of the Court can operate.
H'rit Pt!tition No. 12 of 1972
G
H
The first ground on which the ex-Hyderabad petitioners sought to
challenge the equation of posts, in so far as the posts held by them
in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were equated with the posts of ex-Mysore
tcaeh:~rs in the grade of Rs. 60--150 and placed in the Initial Recruitment Cadre, was that the equation of posts was made by the Central
Govanment without giving any opportunity to the ex-Hyderabad petitioners to make a proper representation. The argument of the exHydernhad petitioners was that the Provisional Inter State Seniority
Lbt published on 20th November, 1970 gave them a special position
on equation of posts and placed them en-bloc immediately above the
first teacher from Hyderabad in the grade of Rs. 130-190 in the initial Recruitment Cadre ~d since they were satisfied with this equation
they did not make any representation to the Central Government, b~t
the Central Government altered this equation to their prejudice in the
Final Inter State Seniority List without giving any opportunitv to thelll
to make a representation sh6wing why they should not be equated with·
ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60--:150 in the Initial Recruit~
mcnt Cadre but should be equated with ex-Mysore teachers in the grade
~~.~ti .. 1~0-200 in the Promotional Cadre. The. equation of posts in
(1). [1968]2. S. C.R. 186.
(2) [1973} 4 S. C. C. 183.
(3) [1973] 1 s. c. c. 61.
6-423SCij75
JIB
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975) 3 S.C.R.
•J;.: J·iiJ~d lntL~r State Seniority List, in so far as it. related to the
n-Hyd,·rnbad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275, was, therelorc, c(.llHcndccl the ex-Hyderabad petitioners, in violation of the
principks oi natural justice and was on that account liable to be
·~u":,i::cd and i:ct aside. Now, it is true that the .ex-Hyderabad petitioners were prepared 1to accept the equation of posts made in the Provisional Inter State Senio1ity List though it did not go as far aS; to
sa'.isfy the full extent of their claim and they accordingly did not ritake
any representation complaining against such equation of posts and
claiming that the posts held by them in the grade of Rs. 154---275
should be equated with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of
Rs. 130-200 and placed i'n the Promotional cadre. The only representat:on mad(: by the ex-Hyderabad petitioners to the Central Government was the one produced by the learned counsel appearing on b~
half of the State Government pursuant to the directions given by us
and that representation showed that though the ex-Hyderabad petitioners felt that the equation of posts made in the Provisional Inter
State Seniority List was not correct and it placed them in a slightly
disadvantageous position. they were, "in the interest of common good
and amicable settlement", prepared to accept it and they according! y
requested the Central Gov·~rnment to treat the Provisionai Inter Stale
Seniority List as final and irrevocable and to publish it as the Final
Inter State Seniority List. The Central Government, however, changed
the equation of posts proposed in the Provisional Inter State Seniority
List to the detriment of the ex-Hyderabad petitioners by pulling them
down and equating them with ex-Mysore teachers in the grade: of
Rs. 60-150 in the Initial Recruitment cadre. Obviously, this could
not be done without ~jvfag an opportunity to the ex-Hyderabad petitioners to make a proper representation. That was the barest minir11um
requirement of th~ principles of natural justice. This requirement was
dearly satisfied. Though the ex-Hyderabad petitioners did not make
any representation to the Central Government in regard to thdr c:laim
to equation of posts subsequent to the publication of the Provisional
f nter State Seniority List, there were representations made by t:ltont
earlier in pursuance of the directions giv1~n by the High Court in its
judgment dated 8th January, 1969. The ex-Hyderabad petiticmocs
admitted in paragraph 3 ( 11) of the petition that they had made rc:pre.sentations to the Central Government subsequent to the judgmeflt of
the High Court dated 8th Jal).uary, 1969 and the equation of posts was
tentatively decided by the Central Oovernm~nt "after hearing the
representations from all'~. which would include their representations
as well. So also in paragraph 5 of the petition the ex-Hyderabad
teachers referred to the. representations made by them to the Central
Government subsequent to the judgment ·of the High Court dated 8th
January, 1969 and sta•ed that in these representations, they had placed
all relevwt facts and materials before the Central Government with
.a view w
substantiating their claim to equation of the
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SHAHBUDD!N v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
8
c
[)
E
F
G
H
319
posts held by them with those of ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs.
130 299 in the Promotional cadre. The Central Government also affirmed in paragraph 3 of the affidavit in reply filed by A. R. Ailawadi, Under
Secretary to the Government of India, Cabinet Secretariat that representations had b~cn made by the ex-Hyderabad teachers pursuant to the
directions given by the High' Court in its judgment dated 8th January,
1969. It was after considering all these representations received pursuant
to the.directions contained in the judgment of the High Court dated 8th
January, 1969 "the recommendations of the SAC on those representations as also the representations received against the revised provisional
ISS list of the graduate tutorial cadre published in November 1970 and
the recommendations of the SAC on those representations, by the application of the relevant factors and in particular, the four criteria for determination of equation of posts" that the Central Government decided the
equation of posts forming the basis of the Final Inter State Seniority List.
This is clear from the preamble to the notification dated 9th December,
1971 publishing the Final Inter State Seniority List as also from paragraph 3 of the affidavit in reply filed by A. R. Ailawadi on behalf of the
Central Government. The Central Govcrnm~nt, therefore, had before it
the representations of the ex-Hyderabad teachers claiming equation of
the posts held by them in the grade of Rs. 154-275 with those of exMysorc teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 in the Promotional c!ldre
and it was after considering these representation that the Central
Uov~rnmcnt decided that the posts held by the ex-Hyderabad teachers
in 'the grade of Rs. 154-275 should be equated not with the posts of
ex-Mysore te1chers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 in the Promotional
cadre as claimrd by them, but with the posts of ex-Mysore teachers
in the grade of Rs. 60-150 in the nitial R~cruitment cadre. It is in
these circumstances not possible to say that the decision in regard to
equation of posts in the Final Inter Seniority List was taken by the
Central Government without giving an opportunity to the ex-Hyderabad petitioners to make a proper repre-sen'ation or that there was any
violation of the principles of natural justice in reaching such decision.
That takes us to the next ground of challenge against the validity cl
the equation of posts in so far as the ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade
of Rs. 154-275 are concerned. The ex-Hyderabad petitioners contended
that in determining the equation of posts the Central Government had
failed to take into account the four factors decided upon at the Chief
Secretaries Conference and that in any event the equation of posts made
by the Central Government was based on erroneous assumptions and
irrelevant considerations and disclosed non-application of mind to the
material and relevant facts. Now the notification-dated 9th December,
197 I, setting out the equation of posts, does not give the reasons which
320
~UPREME
COURT REPORTS
[ 1975] 3 s. c.R.
weighed with the Central Government in making the equation of posts
and in the absence of reasons. It might have been difficult for the exHyJerabad petitioners to substantiate this ground of challenge, but fo:tunately the Central Government has, in the affidavit in reply filed on
its behalf by A R. Ailawadi, disclosed the reasons why it made the
equation of posts in the manner it did. We must, therefore, proceed
·to examine th1~e reasons and see how far they introduce any infirmity
in the equation of posts.
The decision of the Central Government giving its reasons fo:r the
equation of posts may be set out in the words of the Central Government itself as re-produced in paragraph 15 of the affidavit in reply
made by A.R. Ailawadi :
"The main points raised in the representations reeeiv'd
against the revised[ provisional list of 1970 are that the posts
of Teachers in the grades of Rs. 130-190 and Rs. 80-220
from Hyderabad and Coorg respectively should be put in a
separate lower category and that the posts_ of Teachers from
Hyderabad in the scale of Rs. 154-275 should be equated
with the posts-of teachers from other integrating areas without any special treatment. The Coorg Teachers in the scale
of pay Rs. 18().300 have claimed higher equation whereas the Hyderabad Teachers have, by and large, supported
the tentative equation of posts suggested by the Central
Government.
On the: basis of all the material available with the Central Government it is observed that in the case of none of
these seven posts are all the four criteria admittedly higher
or lower than the others. If, therefore, 3 of the 4 criteria
are by and large, similar, the posts would have to be equated.
· Broadly speaking, the teachers in all these grades were either
teaching High School and Middle School classes, or doing
inspection work. It is seen that the duties, etc. of the
Hyderabad Inspectorate in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were
some what inferior to those of their counter-parts i.n Mysore,
Bombay, Madras and Coorg. In respect of minimum qualifications prescribed for recruitment to the po~ts, the Hyderaabad and Coorg teachers in the grades of Rs. 130•190 and
Rs. 80-220 respect.ivel y, were less qualified than the other
teachers. Regarding scales of ray, the Hyderabad and Coorg
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 and Rs. 100-300 respectively were in a better scale than the other teachers, but
c
D
E
F
G
H
SHAHBUDD!N v. UNION (Blzagwati, J.)
J2 l
the scales of pay of the Hyderabad and Coorg teachers in the
grade of Rs. 130-190 and 80-200 were better than those of
the Mysore, Bombay 'and Madras teachers in the grade of Rs.
60-150, 70-200 and Rs. 85-175 respectively. It is thus seen
that, by and large, in three out of the four criteria for determining the equation of posts, the several posts included in
the Initial Recruitment Cadre are quite comparable.
·C
After careful consideration of all the relevant factors
and in particular, the fojlI criteria for determination of the'
equation of posts, the Central Government have decided
that the equation of posts adopted for drawing up the ISS
List published in 196~ referred to in paragraph 2 supra is
the most reasonable one for drawing up the final ISS List of
the Graduate Tutorial Cadre as on 1st Novem~er, 1956. The
State Government may, therefore, adopt that equation for
the preparation of the final ISS List of the Graduate Tutorial Cadre as on -.1-11-1956."
· It would be seen that the Central Government took the view that if
the posts were found similar on an application of three out of the
four factors settled at the Chief Secretaries' Conference, they should
be equated. The Central Government then proceeded to apply these
E factors for the purpose of determining the equation of posts. So far
as the first factor, namely, the nature and duties of posts and the
second factor, namely, the responsibilities and powers appertaining to
the posts, are concerqed, the Central Government pointed out that
"the teachers in all these grades were either teaching High School and
Middle School classes, or doing inspection work" and then observed
.F
that "the duties, etc. of the Hyderabad Inspectors in the grade of
Rs. 154-275 were some what inferior to those of their counter-parts
in Mysore, Bombay, Madras and Coorg". Now, the ex-Hyderabad
Inspectors in the grade of Rs. 154-275 constituted but a fraction of
the ex-Hyderabad teachers in that grade and the majority of the exHyderabad teachers in that grade were teachers teaching in the composite schools corresponding to the Middle and High Schools of the
erstwhile State of Mysore. No comparison of the nature and duties
or responsibilities of the posts was, nowever, made between the exHyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 on the one hand
and the ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 210-300, ex-Madras
H teachers iil the grade of Rs. 165-245 and ex-Mysore teachers in the
grade of Rs. 130-200 on the other. The criteria of the first and the
second factors were not applied qua ex-Hyderabad teachers teaching
322
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] 3 s.c.R.
in the composite schools who constituted a large bulk of ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154- 275 and it was not said by the Central
Government that either the nature or the duties or responsibilities
of their posts were inferior to those of the posts of ex-Bombay teachers
in the grade of Rs. 210-JCoO, ex-Madras teachers in the grade of
Rs. 164-245 and ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200.
The Central Government did not take up this position even in the
affidavit in reply made by A.R. Ailawadi on its behalf. The only
assertion which the Central Government made in this affidavit was
that "the nature of duties and responsibilities etc. attached to the posts
of teachers in Hyderabad in the scale of Rs. 154-275 were similar to
those of teachers of Mysore in the scale of Rs. 60-150, of Bombay
in the scale of Rs. 70-200 and of Coorg in the scale of Rs. 1CU-300".
Vide paragraph 21. We do not think this ex-post facto statement
made in the affidavit c.an be relied upon the justification of the equation of posts because what we have to consider is what were the factors
aetuall) taken into z.ccount in determining the equation of posts and
whether any of them were relevant or irrelevant and whether any
relevant factors wer.:: omitted from consideration. There is nothing
in the decision of the Central Government to show that this factor
relating to comparison of the nature, duties and responsibilities of
the posts between ex-Hyderabad teachers in the gr-ade of Rs_. 154-275
-apart from ex~Hyderabad Inspectors and other allocated t:':achers
was at any time taken into account by the Central Government.. Even
if we accept the statement made in the affidavit at its face value, it
cannot carry the matter any further, because it merely speaks of
similarity of the dutie:s and responsibilities of the posts of ex-Hyderabad
teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 with those of the posts of exBombay, ex..Madi:as and ex-Mysore teachers in tte lower grade and
does ll.)t seek to compare the nature, duties and responsibilities of the
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 with
those of the posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers
in the higher grade. It may be argued that the duties and responsibilities of rh~ posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers
in the higher grade were superior to those of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras
and ex-mysore teachers in the lower grade, and therefore, when the
Central Government found that the duties and responsibilities of the
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were
similar to those of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teaclhers in
the lower grade. it must follow a fortiorori that they were inferior to
those of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the higher
grade and hence the former posts could not be equated with the latter.
But this argument cannot be sustained because the premise on which
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SHAHBUDD!N v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
323
it is based is non-existent. It does not appear from the decision of
the Central Government, nor is there anything in the affidavit or A.R.
Ailawadi to sl:low that the duties and responsibiliti·~s of the posts of
cx-0uam1y, ex-MaJras and ex-Mysore teachers in the higher grade
were superior to those of the posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and exMysore teachers in the lower grade. In fact, the Central Government
B 'tatcd in paragraph 16 of the affidavit of A. R. Ailawadi in reference
to the posts in the higher grade : "In the States of Mysore, Madras
and Bombay certain percentage of posts of graduate tutorial cadre
were treated as selection grade posts, the p:ircentage in Mysorn being
20%, in Bombay 3% and in Madras 33-1/3%, and these pcJSls were
not attached. to any particular Institution or office. "Persons in the
c initial recruitment category were given this selection grade on the basis
of seniority-cum-merit". If this is true, it wot1ld mean that the posts
of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the higher grade
were in the nature of selection grade posts and the teachers in the
lower grade were, on the principJe of seniority-cum-merit, given the
higher grade, but they remained in the same posts discharging the
()
same duties and responsibilities. It would seem that the posts in the
higher grade were thus not promotional posts, distinct and separate
from the posts in the lower grade. The posts were the same and the
duties and responsibilities were the same, but the teachers who were
in the lower grade given the higher grade on the principle of senioritycum-merit.
This would be evident from the order of the Government
1:
of Mysore dated 21st Septe'mber, 1947 set out in paragraph 8 of the
affidavit in reply filed by respondent No. 8, Appendix 9 to the Bombay Educational Manual referred to in paragraph 9 of that affidavit
and the position in r·~gard to the Education Service in the erstwhile
State of Madras as set out in paragraph 10 of that affidavit. It is
F obvious that the Central Government, in determining the equation of
posts, omitted to take into account these relevant considerations and
failed to apply the criteria of the first and second factors in the light
of the material facts placed before it.
G
H
The Central Government in its decision then proceeded to consider the criterion relating to the third factor, namely, the minimum
qualifications prescribed for recruitment to the posts and observed
that "the Hyderabad and Coorg teachers in the grades of Rs. 130-190
and Rs. 80-220 respectively were less qualified than the other teachers". It is difficult to see the logic or relevance of this observation.
What the Central Government was concerned to inquire was as to
what were the posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers
to which the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. t=-4275 could be regarded as similar from the point of view minimum
•
324
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 3 s.c.R.
qualifications prescribed for recruitment to the posts. It may be that
the ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-190 were less
qualified than the ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in
the lower grade, but that could have no bearing on the question as to
whetha ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 were
superior or inferior to the ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore
teachers in the higher grade from the point of view of qualifications.
The Central Government ought to have considered whether there was
any comparison between the posts of ex-Hydarabad teachers :in the
grade of Rs. 154-275 and the posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and
ex-Mysore teachers in the higher grade on the criterion of minimum
qualifications required for recruitment to the posts. This, unfortunately, as the deCision of the Central Government shows, it fail.ed to
do. There is nothing in the decision of the Central Government which
would indicate even remotely that the Central Government applied its
mind to the criterion of minimum qualifications and compared the
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 with those
of other allocated teachers in the higher grade from the point of view
of this criterion. ·
So far as the criterion relating to the fourth factor, namely, the
salary of the posts is concerned, the Central Government was constrained to admit that the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade
{)f Rs. I 54-275 carried a higher P"Y scale than those of ex-Bombay.
ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the lower grade and even the
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 130--190 enjoyed
a b-:ttcr pay scale than those of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore
teachers in the lower grade. Judged by this criterion, therefore, the
posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154--275 could
not possibly have been equated with those of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras
and ex~Mysore teachers in the lower grade but the Central Government ignored this criterion altogether and pinned its decision only oa
the other three criteria which also, as pointed out by us above, were
either not applied at all or improperly applied.
A
B
c
D
E
F
(;
There can, therefore, be no doubt that if we test the validity of the
equation of posts by reference only to the reasons given by the Central
Government in its decision as reproduced in paragraph 15 of the affilfavit of A.R. Ailawadi, the equation of posts made by the Central
Government cannot stand in so far as ex-Hyderabad teachers in the
grade of Rs. 154--275 are concerned. But the Central Government
in the aw:davit. of A.R. Ailawadi gave certain further reasons _justifying
the equation of posts made by it and though the decision of the Central
H
SHAHBUDDJN v. UNION (Bha~1"ati, ], )
A
:B
c
D
E
F
G
H
ns
Government does not show that these reasons actually weighed with
the Central Government, we would proceed to examine their ccn . ::i:ness.
The contention of the Central Governm.cnt, as ~ct out in the affidavit of A.R. Ailawadi, was that the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in
the grade of Rs. 154-275 did not belong to th1~ promotional c:tdre
but were meant only for the initial recruitment of trained graduates
and hence they were rightly classified under the Jnitial Recruitment
cadre. The strongest reliance in support of this contention was placed
on the Cadre and Recruitment Rules of the Hyderabad Educatilmal
Service made by the Rajpramukh on 29th October, 1953. It wus
pointed out by the Central Government that according to the ~~yd~ra·
bad Cadre and Recruitment Rules, the highest grade in the subordinate services was that of teachers in the grade of Rs. 280--:345 a.;fri
that was to be filled by promotion of teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-;,.
275 and the next lower grades were those of teachers in the _grades of
Rs. 154-275 and Rs. 130-190 and these were "to be fiJi~d
:dinarily by direct recruitment by selection by a select committee" :tJJd
so far as the minimum qualifications for recruitment to these gradt'.s
were concerned, a candidate had to be a trained graduate for recruit·
n1ent to the grade of Rs. 154-275 while for recruitment to the grad~
of Rs. 130-190 it was enough if he was merely a graduate Qr a
trained intermediate. The Central Government submitted on the basis
of these pro.visions in the Hyderabad Cadre and Recruitment Rules
that the grade of Rs. 154-275 was not a promotional grade but it
was as much an initial recruitment grade as the grade Of Rs .. 130190, the only difference being that the minimum qualification for recruitment in the former was that the candidate should be a trained
graduate while in the later, he could be an untrainied grdauate or a
trained intermediate. The only promotional grade, according to the
Hyderabad Cadre and Recruitment Rules was that of teachers in the
grade of Rs. 280-345. That was the reason why, contended the
Central Government, the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade
of Rs. 280-345 were equated with the posts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras
and ex-Mysore teachers in the higher grade-which were in the Promotional cadre, while the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grades
of Rs. 154-275' and Rs. 130-190 were equated with the posts or
ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the lower grade
which constituted Iriftial Recruitment cadre. This contention, plausible though it may seem, is, in our opinion, fallacious, inasmuch as it
is based on misconception of the true nature of the equation of posts
;md disregard of the actual and historical facts obtaining in regard to
I
326
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] 3 S.C.R.
the ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-,275 and the ex-Mysore grades
of Rs. 60-150 and Rs.. 130-200.
It is clear that what the Central Government was required to do
for the purpose of bringing about the integration of the services was to
determine the equation of posts of a1located Government se•rvants
coming from different integrating areas. The equation that was to be
made by the .Central Government was of posts and since posts would
be in different grades, the equation of posts would necessarily involve
the equation of grades. This equation had to be done by reference to
the four criteria laid down at the conference of the Chief Secretaries.
It was immaterial whether the grades which wer.e sought to be equated
were initial recruitment grades or promotional grades. There was no
requirement either o[ law or of principle that one initial recruitment
grade could be equated only with another initial recruitment grade, or
that one promotional grade could be equated only with another promotional grade. The four criteria which were to be applied for the purpose of determining the equation were those laid down at the Conference of the Chief Secretaries and if these four criteria were satisfied,
then in a given case an initial recruitment grade could be equated to
a promotional grade and vice-versa. We do not, therefore, think that
the Central Government was right in taking the view that the ex·
Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-275 could not be equated with the exBombay grade of Rs. 210-300, ex-Madras grade of Rs. 165--245
and ex-Mysore grade of Rs. 130-200 because the former was an
initial recruitment grade while the latter were promotional grades. That
was not a correct test to be applied in determining the equation of
posts.
A
B
c
I>
E
But apart from this objection as a matter of law, we do not think F
the Central Government was right in saying that the ex-Hyderabad
grade of Rs. 154--275 was not a promotional grade but nn initial recruitment grade for trained graduates. We will first consider the position prior to the making of the Hyderabad Cadre and Recruitment
Rules of 29\h May, 1953. There are several orders commencing
from 17th October, 1951 and ending with 12th December, 1954,
Annexures Fl to F4 to the petition, which clearly show that ex·
G
Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 130--190 were promoted to
the grade of Rs. 154--275. All the forty-three. ex-Hyderabad petitioners were originally appointed in the grade of Rs. 130-19{} and
subsequently on obtaining B.T. or B.Ed. degrees, they were promoted
to the grade of Rs. 154-275 in accordance with the principle of
seniority-cum-merit and this is borne out bv the orders of promotion
passed in the case of each of them. In fact; as pointed out by the ex- H
Hvderabad petitioneni in paragraph 4(2) of the petition. all the1 exHyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-275, except two, were "
promotecs from the grade of Rs. 130-190. The proceedings rdatmg
SHAHBUDDIN v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
A
327
to the order of the Government of Mysore dated 11th March, I 96G
Anilexure G-1 to the petition, a:lso show~d that, in the ex-Hyderabad
area, trained graduates in the grade of Rs. 130-190 were promoted
to the grade of Rs. 154--275. So also the letter dated 22nd December, 1962 addressed by the Director of Public Instruction, Andhra
Pradesh to the Secretary to the Hyderabad Karoataka Teachers U mon
Annexu~e G2 to the petition pointed out that generally, in the exB
Hyderabad are::i., trained graduates were not appointed direc ly in the
grade of Rs. 154--275 and "only untrained graduates were appoint~d
in the sca;e o'f Rs. 130-190 and thereafter they were selected for
B.Ed. training as per seniority and after they had compeleted B.Ed.
training, they were promoted to the trained graduates scale of Rs. 154
-2"/5 as per seniority". Similarly, the letter dated 21st January, 1966
the Depµty Secretary to Government oi Andhra Pradesh to tbe
c of
Accountant General, Andhra Pradesh, Annex,ure G3 to the petition,
also asser.ted that the ex-Hyderabad teachers who were in the grade of
Rs. 130-190 prior to the reorganisation were "eligible for promotion
to the next higher scale of Rs. 154--2 75 in case of their first promotion after 1st November, 1956". Then there is also an order of the
Government of Mysore dated 28th August, 1961, Annexure G4 to the
petition, which said that Shri Vasant Rao Patil was promoted from
D
the grade of Rs. 130-190 to Rs. 154-275 along with eleven other ·
teachers. And, lastly, the letter dated 30th December, 1954 addressed
by tht: Director of Public Instruction, Andhra Pradesh to the Seeretary,
Hyderabad Karnataka Teachers Union, Annexure GS to the petition.
affirmed in terms clear and explicit that the duties of the posts of
teachers were the same in the grade_ of Rs. 154-275 as in the grade
E · of Rs. 130-190 and the grade of Rs. 154--275 merely constituted u
"higher category to which trained graduates in the grade of Rs. 130190" we:e eligible for promotion. It wou'd, therefore. be seen that
right upto the time of the making of the Hyderabad Cadre a.,d Rpcruit·
ment Rules and even thereafter, the ex-Hvderabad grade of Rs. 154275 was a promotional grade and save in two exceptional cases, no
direct recruitment was ever made t.o this grade. The entry in the
grade of Rs. 154-275 was alwavs by way of promotion of trained
F
graduates from the grade of Rs. 130-190. Jt is true that the Hyd~rabad Cadre and Recruitment Rules provided that the nosts 0f te~chers
_in the !!rark of Rs. 154-275 sh'lll be filled ordinarilv by direct recruitment but in fact no eirect recruitment was ever made to this wade.
The word 'ordinarily' left it ooen to the Government to aooo.int a
teacher to the 1rrade of Rs. t 54-275 otherwise than by direct recruitG ment and in fact, as the various documents to which wl' hw• iust
referred show, aooointments to the grade of Rs. 154-275 were made
by promotion of trained graduates from thP. rrrade of Rs J '.ln-190
even after the making of the Hvderabad Cadre and Recruitm,.nt R111es.
The oosition which prevailed at the time of •he reornanisation therefore. was th1t the ex-Hvrler>1bad gradP- of Rs. 1"4-275 w'ls in fact
and in rea1itv a promotional 1rrade consistin!! who11v of prornn•<>•s ffflm
the grade of Rs. t'.10-1 <JO save in two excentional cas•s. W,, fa;l to
H
sec how th~ Central Gov•rnm~nt co11lrl hw,. ip-n0rpt1 th" st,,.Jr r•ality
l'r thi~ situation and proceeder! on a purelv theoretical basis wholly unt elated to the facts and concluded that the ex-Hyderabad grade of
328
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[197 5J 3 s.c.R•
.Rs. 154-275 was an initial recruitment grade for trained graduates as
distinct from a promotional grade.
We find from the equation of posts. made in the Final Inter State
Seniority List as also from the affidavit of A.R. Ailawadi that, according to the Central Government, the ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 280345 was a promotional grade for ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade
of Rs. 154-275 and "the te?o::hers in the grade of Rs. 154-275 h<:d
to pass norina.lly through the selection grade of Rs. 280-345 before
cnteri1;g the Class 11 Gazetted cadre" and the posts in the ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 280--345 were, therefore, rightly equated with those
.of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the higher grad~.
This stand of the Central Government is clearly untenable. It is clear
fp:im the letter dated 21st October 1954, addressed by the Secretary .to
the Government of Hyderabad Education Department to the Director
·Of Public Instruction, Annexure G-6 to the petition, that the ex_:Hydenbad grade of Rs. 280--345 was a selection grade : it was "nc:it · <1
separate grade by itself but only an extension of existing grade" <Of
Rs. 154-275 in which it was necessary to reach the maximum before
. aspiring to the next ladder. The same position was reiterated by .the
Government of Andhra Pradesh in its order dated 12th March, 1959.
Annexure G-7 to the petition where it was stated that lhe ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 280--345 was not a separate cadre by itself but only
a continuance of the grade of Rs. 154-275 "a little over the maximum
of the time scale of the grade". The Jetter dated 23rd January, 1950
addressed by the Director of Public Instruction, Hyderabad to ~he
Principals and Head Masters, Anncxure G-S to the petition, al;o
pointed out that for the purpose of promotion to Class II Gazi:tted
cadre the date o( entry into the grade of Rs. 154-275 wculd b,~ en
the basis of seniority of teachers "irrespc.ctive of the grades in which
they have worked, though they might be working either in the grade of
Rs. 154-275 or Rs. 280-345". So also, the Jetter dated 8th February, 1964 addressed by the Director of Public Instruction, Bangal.ore,
Annexurc G-7 to the petition, n:iterated that the grade of Rs. 280-345 was only a side grade intended for officials who have reached the
maximum in the grade of Rs. 154-275 and they would have no pre ..
ference over their seniors working in the grade of Rs. 154-275 am~
seniority in the grade of Rs. 154-275 would be the only criterion for
Class II Gazetted promotion and one need not be promoted to the side
grade to get eligibility for Class II Gazetted promotion. It would be
seen from these documents that the ex-Hyderabad f!rade of Rs. 280-345 was merely a selection grade and not a promotional grade and the
next higher grade of nmmotion from the grade of Rs. 154-275 was
· Class II Gazetted grade and promotion to that higher grade was not
from the selection irrade of Rs. 280--345 but from the grade of Rs.
154-275 on the basis of seniority. The Central Government was.
therefore. clearly in error in taking the view that the ex-Hvdernbad
grade of Rs. 230-345 was a oromotional grade in between the grnde
of Rs. 154--275 and Class II Gazetted !!rade. If the next higher grade
above the grade of Rs. 154-275 was Class II Gazetted grade. it would
~be a serious matter for consideration whether the grade of Rs. 154-
A
B
c
D
E
c
H
SHAHBUDDIN v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
·A
275 should not be equated with the ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and exMysore-h1gher grades whlch. were immediately be10w Class 11 Gazetted
grade in those respective States.
Lastly, it may be pointed out that there is one rather important afid
rekwant consideration which the Central Government seems to have
fa.iieu to take inro account and that relates to the qualifications reqwred
B
for recruitment to the posts sought to be equaLeO. There was no
dispute that for recruitment, whether by promotion or otherwise, to the
ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-275 it was essential that a teacher
shouJd be a trained graduate and in practice all teachers promoted to
that grade and even the two exceptional direct recruits were trained
graduates. .But so far as the ex-Mysore grade of Rs. 60--·150 is
even an untrained graduate could be appointed under Note.
c concerned,
A ~o the order of the State Government dated 21st September, 1947
set out in paragraph 8 of the affidavit in reply of respondent No. 8 and
in fact a large number of untrained graduates were appointe{I in this
grade. The practice followed was to appoint untrained graduates since
trained graduates were not available and then to depute them for training in B.T. oourse at Government costs. The result was that at any
given point of time there was abr'ays a large number of untrained
0
graduates in the ex-Mysore grade of Rs. 60-150. It is highly revealing to nqte that out of about 700 ex·Mysore teachers in the grade ·of
Rs. 6Q-.:..150 allocated to the State of Mysore, there were admittedly
as many as 343 who were untrained graduates and 20 more were also
untrained but they were undergoing training on deputation. It is difficult to see how, apart from the disparity in the pay scaics, the cxI:: Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-275, where the minimum qualification
of trained graduate was always insisted on and followed, could be
equated with the ex-Mysore grade of Rs. 60--150 where the minimum
qualification of trained graduate was not a sine qi{} non for recruitment and in fact more than half the number of teachers were untrained
graduates. It may be noted that untrained graduates in the grade of
Rs. 60-150 were not only entitled to their usual increments but they
r could also be promoted to the next higher grade elf Rs. 130-200.
There were admittedly at the time of reorganisation 26 out of t 67 ex- ·
Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200, who were untrained
graduates. Similarly, in the erstwhile Bombay State also, minimum
qualifictaion of trained graduate was not necessary for recruitmeht to
the grade of Rs. 70-200. If a candidate was a trained graduate, he
was given an advance increment, but even without being trained, hi:
G could gain admittance in the grade. Vide Appendix 9 to the Bombay
&location Manual and Rule 131 in Section VIII of the Bombay Civil
Services Classification and Recruitment Rules set out· in paragraph 9
of lhc affidavit in reply filed by respondent No. 8. How then could. be
ex-Hyderabad grade of Rs. 154-275 be equated with the ex-Born.bay
gfade of Rs. 70--200, when the minimum qualification for recruitc
ment in the former was that the candidate should be a trained graduate
H while in the latter; ·he could just be an ordina.tj graduate?
We arc, therefore, of the view that Jhc equation of posts made by
the Central Government was illegal and invalid in so far as it related
331)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 3 S.C'.R.
to the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the g:adc of Rs. 154-275.
We accordingly set aside the equation of posts as also the Final lnter
State Seniority List bas~d upon it to the extent that it relates to
the posts of ex-Hyderabad teachers in the grade of Rs. 154-257 acnd
direct the Central Government to make fr.:sh cquati•Jn of posts alter
taking into account ail relcvanl facts l::aving materia.l bearing on !he
{jucstion and in the ligh, of the observations contaii1cd in this ju:lgm:nt.
A
B
Writ Petition No. !49 of 1972
The case of the ex-Coorg petitioners stands on the same footin&
as tnat ot the ex-Hyderabad p~tition.ers in some ma.erial respe<:ls.
l!l the first place, it does not appear from the decision of the Central C
Government that for the purpose of determining the proper equation
of th~ posts of cx-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300, the
Central Government apphed the criteria of the first and the second
factors by making a comparison of the nature, duties and resporisibilities of the posts. In fact, the statement of the Central Governmi:mtin its decision that "the duties etc. of the Hyderabad Inspectors in
the grade of Rs. 154-275 were somewhat inferior to those of their D
counter parts in Mysore, Bombay, Madras and Coorg" proceeded on
the hypo hesis that the duties and responsibilities of the posts of (~X- ·
Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 were similar to those of
the pvsts of ex-Bombay, ex-Madras and ex-Mysore teachers in the
high.:r grade. Secondly, the criterion of the third factor, namely, the
minimum qualifications required for recruitment to the posts was also
not applied by the Ccnt:ral Government for the purpose of determin- E
ing t:1c equation of the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of
Rs. 100-300. All that was sta'ed by the Central Government in its
decision was that the ex ..Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 80-220
w1~re less, qualifi1!<1 t~an the other teachers. But that had no bearing
on the question of qualifications for the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in
the grade of Rs. 100-300. lt was common ground between , the
parties that the minimum qualification required for recruitment to F.
the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 was
that the candidate should be a trained graduate. However, so far as
the posts of ex-Mysore tieachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150 and exBombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 70-200 were concerned, it
was not a minimum qualification that the candidate should be a
trained graduate but it was en,ough if he was an untrained graduate.
Vlde. the relevant discussion in Writ Petition No. 12 of 1972. It
G
would thus seem that thiere was no equivalence between the posts of
ex~Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 and those of r;X~ysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 60-150 and ex-Bombay teachers
m the grade of Rs. 7~-200 from the poi:nt of view of the criterion
.of minimum q~al~tions required for recruitments to the posts. This
rmportant cons1d1~rat10n, however, seemed to have been omitted to be
taken into account by the Central-Government. So also the Centt'lll 11
Gc>vernment faikd to take into account the criterion of the fourth
factor, namely, the salary attached to the posts, for the posts of
L
SJIAllBUDDIN v. UNION (Bhagwati, J.)
331
ex-Coorg teachers in t:1e grade of R:;. 100-300 undeni.ably carried
a h1gner pay scale than the posts of eJ.1-Mysore teachers Ill the grade
of Ks. 6U-150, ex-Bombay teachers in tne grade of Rs. 70--200
and ex-Madras teacriers m the grade of Rs. 85-175. In fact, the
pay sca.e of the posts of ex, Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100jOU was in some respects even better than that of ex-Mysore teachers
in the grade of Rs. 130-200. lt appears from the affidavit in reply
filed by S. Kannan, Deputy Secretary to the Government of India,
Cabinet Secretariat on benalf of the Central Government, that the
m.l.in consH.leration which prevailed with the Central Government in
equating the posts of ex-Cuorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100--300
with those ot ex-Bombay teachers in the grade of Rs. 70-200, exMadras teachers in the grade of Rs. 85-175 and ex-Mysore teachers
in the grade of Rs. 60-150 was that these were all initial recrui,ment
c grades, and the posts of ex-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100300 could not be equated with those of ex-Bombay teachers in . the
grade of Rs. 210-300, ex-Madras teachers in the grade of Rs. 165245 and ex-Mysore teachers in the grade of Rs. 130-200 becam1e
the former bdonged to the initial recruitment grade, while the Jattor,
to promotional grades. But as pointed out by us above, this was not
a valid consideration which should have guided the Central GoverntD
m~nt in determining the equation of posts. The Central Government
ought to have taken into account the four criteria laid down at the
conference of the Chief Secretaries and determined· the equation of
posts by reference to those criteria. It may also be pointed out that
the next higher grade above the ex-C.Oorg grade of Rs. 100-300
was Class II Gazetted grade and not the grade of Rs. 200--300,
which was a special grade for the Principal, J anatha C.Ollege started
as an experimental measure for a period of one year. Promotion to
Class II Gazetted grade was from the grade of Rs. 100--300 11.nd
it was not necessary for a teacher in the grade of Rs. 100--300 to
be appointed Principal, Janatha College in the ;grade of Rs. 200300 in order to aspire for promotion to Class II Gaetted grade. That
is obvious from the order o~ the Government of Coorg, dated 27th
June, 1956, Annexure 8 to the petition, promoting B. Suryanarain
F Rao and S. S. Krishna Rao from the grade of Rs. 100--300 to Qus
II Gazetted post of Head Master. The grade of Rs. 200300 attached to the post of Principal, Janatha College was, therefore.
not a promotional grade but a special. grade which did not give its
incumbent any preference over the teachers in the grade of Rs. 100---. 300. The Central Government was clearly in error in proceeding on
th~ basis that "in between the posts of trained graduates, Assistants and
G
Sub-Divisional Inspxtors on the one hand (in grade Rs. 100-300) and the posts of :Head Masters of Government High Schools
and the Principal of Basic Training College. Kadige on the other) in the
grade of Rs. 250--10--350), the intennediate promotional post was
that of Superintendent, Janatha College, Kudige in grade Rs. 20010--300" and on that basis equating only the oost of Principal,
Janatha College in the grade of Rs. 200-300 with the posts of exH Bombav, ex-Madras awl e~ysore teachers in the higher grade.
Tbese infirmities vitiated the equation of posts made by the Central
Government.
A
:132
SUJ>Rll.ME COURT REPORTS
l 1975] 3 s.c. R.
We, therefore. set aside the equation of posts as also the Fi.nal
Jnier State Seniority List based upon it in so far as they relate to the
posts of cx-Coorg teachers in the grade of Rs. 100-300 and direct
the Central (J{)vernment to make fresh equation of posts after taking
into account all relevant facts having material bearing on the question
and in the light of the observations contained in this judgment.
The first respondent will pay the costs of the petitioners in each
of these tv:o writ petitions.
P.H.P.
Petitions allowed
A
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org