STATE OF MYSORE versus ANANT VINAYAK PATWARDHAN
Supreme Court of India | Decided 26 February 1974 | [1974] 3 S.C.R. 460 | 1974 INSC 41
Key facts
- Decided
- 26 February 1974
- Bench
- KUTTYIL KURIEN MATHEW*, A. ALAGIRISWAMI
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1741/1967
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [1974] 3 S.C.R. 460
- Neutral citation
- 1974 INSC 41
Text of the judgment
460
STATE OF MYSORE
v.
ANANT VINAYAK PATWARDHAN
Februan 26, 197~
A
[K. K. MATHEW AND A. ALAG!R!SWAMI, JJ. J
Bo111bay Merged Terri1ories Miscellaneous Alienation Abolition Act, 1955,
Section 11-Tainat (Casli Allowance) granted to respondents ancestors by
tlie Pesliwas-Allowa11ce co/ltinued b_v- Ruler of Ja1nkhandi under terms of
11·eaty with East India Co.-S11bseque111ly Ruler of Jamkl1andi converted allow'11lCe to one for Jife-Whetl1er, cash allowance payable was permanent and
hereditar)'-Comtnutation amount whether deductible fro1n cash allowance for
B
paynzerit of comve11sa1ion.
The respondent's ancestors had been granted a cash allowance called Tainat
by the Peshwas. After the defeat of the Peshwas by the British, by the Treety
of Gulgallee with Jamkhandi dated 6-6-1819 by the then Governor of Bomba1
on behalf of the East lndia Co. one of the terms which were granted to
Gopalrao Jamkhandikar was rec(\rding the terms which he held from the Govt.
of His Highness the Pesbwa, for the payment of his contingent (apparently
army) out of his personal allowance. It stated that he was to continue all
allowances and no complaints on this befl(l were to be suffered to reach the
Government. The allowance to the resi,x>nden.t's ancestors was ooe such
allowance. The extract from the Petha Khata wahi of 1942·43 shows that the
grant was permanent. Bl).t in 1944, the then Ruler of Jamkhandi converted
the allowance to one for life. After the Jamkhandi State was merged in the
State of Bomba}', the Bombay Legislature passed the Bombay Merged Terri·
torits Miscellaneous Alienation Abolition Act, 19$5. The respondent filed an
application on 21·7·1956 under section 17 of· that Act claiming that the cash
allowance payable was both pennanent and hereditary but that he learnt that
the Ruler of Jamkhandi had passed an order that the ·said allowance be
continued till his (applicant's) life time when the same .was continued to him
after the death of his father. He mentioned that he had moved the Rajasaheb
by an application which was not disposed of. HeJ therefore, claimed that he
wouJd be entitled to seVC}l times the cash allowance, permanent on the basi..'1
that it was permanent oi ·in the alternative to three tlfncs the ci&)t allowance
on the basis that it was -payable for life. However, by this time, the Ruler
of 1amkhandi was no longer a Ruler and was not in a position to be of any
assistance to the respondent on the basis of his application. The A~istant
Commissioner of Jamkhandi passed en order granting a sum equal to three
times the annual sum which the respondent was receiving. On appeal by the
respondent to the Appellate Tribunal, the Tribunal held that the Ruler of
Jamkh•ndi had sovereign J)()Wer and was the fountain head of alt sources of
authority, that is. executive, judiciary and legislature and be could change the
Tainat cash allowance at his sweet will and pleasure. The Tribunal accordingly
dismissed the appeal.
respandent thereupon filed a writ petition before
the High Court. The High Court directed that a sum equll .to seven times
the annual ca"h allowance be paid to the resnondent on the basis that the
grant was hereditary. Th~ State Government thcreupan appealed by a special
leave to this Court.
c
D
E
F
ne
G
.Allowing the appeal,
HELD : (I) The constitutional position of the Ruler of every one of the
Jndian States before their integration with the rest of India and comina. into
force of the Constitution of India was that he enjoyed uncontroUcd sovereign
powers and there were no constitutional limitations upon his authority
to act in any Of the three capacities of legislature, executive and judiciary.
It follows, therefore, that if the Ruler of Jamkhandi bad changed the perma·
nent cash allowance granted to the respondent·~ 11.ncestnrs to one for life, it
is legally valid and il cannot be questioned. [463 A-"Bl
H
MYSORE v. A. v. PA TWARDHAN (A lagiriswami, J. )
on.
,
B
Anieer-up-Nissa Btgu1n v. MtJ/1b"otib Begum, A.I.R. 1955_ S.C. 352, relied
(II) The Tainat allowance being service allowance the deduction of the
com.mu'!ltion amount is f9r the payn1ent to tbe person - Who was doing. the
se~v1ce 10 place of the cash allowance -holder. That is why what was being
-paid to the respondent year after year was the cash allowance minus the
commutation amount. The commutatiori ariiount is, therefore, deductible from
the cash allowance while calculating the compensation i)ayablc to the
respondent. [463 D-E]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil
\967.
c
D
E
F
G
H
4 61
Appeal No.
1741 qi
Aooea! bv .soecial leave. from iudgment and order dated the -30th
November, 1962 of the Mysore Hiilh Court at Bangalore in Writ Petition No. 777 of 1961.
·
V. K. Krishna Menon, M. V'eerappa and S. P. Singh, for the appellant.
R. B. Datar and M. L. Verma, for tbe respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered byALAGIRisWAMI, J.-The respondent's ancestors had been granted
a cash allowance called Tainat by the Peshwas. ·After the defeat of
the. Pesh was by the. British, by the Treaty of Gulga!lee with Jamkbandi
dated 6-6-1819 by the Hon'ble Mr. Elphinston, Governor of Bombay
on behalf of the East India Company one of the terms which .were
gran,ted tc, Gopalrao J amkhandikar was regarding the terms which he
hell! ft om the Government of His Highness the Peshwa, for· the paymeru: of·bis contingent (apparently army) of his personal allowance.
It stated that he was to continue all allowances and no complaints on
this head were to be suffered to reach the Government (East India
cOlnpany). The allowance to respondent's ancestors was .oµe such
allowance. This allowance seems t9 have amonnted to .a sum of
Rs. 2010/- minus a sum of Rs. 240/- being the commutation amount
as shown in Petha Khata Wahi Extract of 1942-43. That exact also
shows that this grant was iiermanent. But. in 1944 the then ruler of
Jamkhandi seems to have ·converted this... 3Jiowance to one for life.
After the Jamkhandi·State was mer~ed in the State of Bombay, the
Bombay. Leiislature .passe.d the. Bombay, Merged territories Misci:l~
laneous. Alienations. Abolition Act, 1.955. The r~clent filed an
application on 21-'7'1956 nnder s. 11 of. that 11ctbefore the Assistant
Commissipner .. Jamkhandi clai\llin~ ·that the cash allowance payable
was both permanent and hereditary but ·that he learnt th.at.the ruler of
Jamkhandi had passed an order that the. :said . cash .allowance be
continued till his (applicant's\ life time when the same Was continuell
to him after the death of his father. .He m~tioned that .he had ·Jllaved
the Raiasabeb bv an aoolicatiori which was not finally disposed of.
He. therefore, claimed that Ile would· be entitled to Rs. 21.000/- 'at
7 times ofthe cash ·allowance on (Jie·basis that it was Rs. 3,0QO/- a
vear and. oermanent or in .the a1te~native t-0 Rs. . 9,0Q-Or: being
three times the cash .. allowance on die · basis that it was
payable for Jife. It would be nP\)reciated 'that by this time \he Ruler
of Jamkhandi was no longer .a ll\11er and was certaiit1y not in a i><lsb
17-L954SupCl/74
t&2
'SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 19741 3 S,C.R.
W>~ to be of any .assistance to .the respondent on the basis of his appli- A
cation. The AssJStant Conuwssioner passed an order granting a sum
<If ~· 5172-12-0 being three times the annual sum of Rs. 1724-4-0
which the· respondent was receiving. The respondent then filed an appeal to the Mysore Revenue Appellate Tribunal as by that time the
a{Ca. had become part of the Mysore State. In that appeal he mentioned that through mistake his name has been recorded as holder of
the Tainat cash allowance for life only. He also .mentioned that his B
apPlication to the Rajasaheb of J amkhandi for correction of the mistake was still pending even though the state of Jamkhandi was merged.
~ Tribunal dealt with the argument before it on behalf of tile respondent to the efieet that the ruler of J amkhandi had no power to change
the cash allowance to. one for life ~ according to his own earlier order
passed in. the year 1909-10 it was permanent and in the view that .the
ruler of J amkhllndi had sovereign powers and was the tountain hea.d c
of all source of authority, that is. executive, judiciary and legislature,
he could change the Tainat cash allowance at his sweet will and pleasure, dismissed the appeal. The respondent thereupon filed a writ
petition No:· 777 before the High Court of My8ore. There also he
atalcd- that through mistake his name was recorded as the holder of the
Cash. allowance for life only, and also urged that the ruler of the JamD
ldiandi>State had no Power to interfere with the Tainat cash allowance.
The Hiab Court diU not deal with the question whether· the Ruler of
lamliliandi had, in' 1944, the powei'to convert a hereditary grant to
one for life but directed that a sum of Rs. 14,070 being seven tnnes
the annual cash allowance of Rs. 2,010 be paid to the respondent on
the basis that the grant was hereditary. This appeal is against thai
1wlgment .and order of the High Court.
E
We are of opinion that clearly the decision of the Mysore High
Court is wrong. In Ameer-un-Nissa Begum v. Mahboob Begum (AIR
}!1~5 SC 352) this Court stated the constitutional position of the Nizam
of' R~erabad in these words :
" .... It cannot be dispute that prior to the integration of
Hyderabad State with the Indian Union and the coming into
F
force of the Indian Constitution, the Nizam of Hyderabad enjoyed uncontrolled sovereign powers. He was the supreme
legislature the su1>reme judiciary and the supreme head of
the executive. and there were no constitutional limitations
uoon his authority to act in any 'of these capacities. The
'Firmans were expressions of the sovereign will of the
Nizam and they were bindin~ in the same way as any other
G
law;-nay, they would override all other law.s which were in
con,fiict with them. So, long as a particular 'Fueman' held the
field, that alone would ~overn or regulate the rights of
the parties concerned, though it could be annull.ed or l!lodi·
lied by a later 'Firman' at any time that the Ntzam wtlled.
The Nizam was not only the supreme legislature, he was
the fountain of justice as well. When he constituted a new
Court, he could, according to ordinary notions, be dcc~ed to
have exercised his legislative authority. When agam he
H
MYSORE
v. A. V. PATWARDHAN (Alagiriswami, /.)
463
A
affirmed or reversed a judicial decision, that may appropriately be described as a judicial act. A rigid line of delllarcation, however. between the one and the other would
from the verv natlire of things be •not .iustified or even
possible."
B
Indian States before their integration with the rest of India and com~
ing into force of the Conslitution of India. It follows therefore that
if the ruler of Jamkhandi hid changed the p~anent cash allowance
That sets out the constitutional position of the ruler of every of the
c
D
.E
F
granted tC' the respondens's ancestors to one for life it is legally valid
and it cannot be questioned. The extract from the Jamkhandi State
Gazelle dated 7-8-1920 publishing rules regarding ca;h allowance itself shows that those rules cancelled the earlier rules and tliose rules
also could be appropriately cancelled ·by the subsequent rules. Any
application made by the respondent to the former .ruler of Jamkhandi
after the State was merged in Bombay State will not help him. The
ruler !J;id by that time lost all his powers. The decision of the Mysore
Revenue Aj>peUate Tribunal is, therefore, right.
There is only one small point which has got to be mcntione,J. The
compensation allowed was three times the cash allowance. As already
mentioned the Petha Khata Wahi extract shows tho allowance at Rs.
2010.80 minus Rs. 240.00 being the commutation amount. These allowances being service allowances, the deduction is for the paJyment to
the person who was doing the service in place of the cash allowance
holdec. That is why what was being paid to the respondent year
after vear was the cash allowance minus commutation amount. The
Mvsore High Court was. therefore, wrong in holding that this sum of
Rs .. 240 cannot be· deducted from the cash allowance while calculatin2 the compensation payable to the respondent.
We must mention that when this appeal was ta<en up for hearing
Mr. Datar apl'l:aring for the respondent con(ended lhat as this Court
in M.P. State v. Ranojirao (1968 3 SCR 4119) has held that the Ma<lh~a Pradesh Abciition of Cash Grants Act violates Art. 19(1)(!) or
Art. 31(2) of the Constitution, and so struck it down, the Bombay
Merged Territories Miscellaneous Alienation Abolition Act is also
liable to be struck down on the same ground. He, therefcre, wanted
that h< shuuld be given the liberty to move the High Court for striking
do\vn the Act under consideration in this case.
G
H
\\'c do not propose
to express any opinion as to whether it would be open him to do so in
tl1e backt;round of this case. There is nothing to prevent him f!'Ot'1
filing on appbcation if he is so advised.
Jn the result this appeal is allowed and the judgment and order of
the High Court of Mysore set aside. As the special leave was granted
oa the condition that the appellant would in any event pay to the resp0ndent his of the appeal, the appellant shall pay the respondent's
costs.
S.B.W.
J8-L954SupCI /74
Appeal allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org