JANKI PRASAD PARIMOO & ORS. ETC. ETC. versus STATE OF JAMMU & KASHMIR & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 10 January 1973 | [1973] 3 S.C.R. 236 | 1973 INSC 5
Key facts
- Decided
- 10 January 1973
- Bench
- S.M. SIKRI*, A.N. RAY, D.G. PALEKAR, M. HAMEEDULLAH BEG, S.N. DWIVEDI
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 175/1971
- Disposal
- Case Allowed
- Citation
- [1973] 3 S.C.R. 236
- Neutral citation
- 1973 INSC 5
Text of the judgment
236
JANKI PRASAD PARIMOO & ORS. ETC. ETC.
A
v:.
STATE OF JAMMU & KASHMIR & ORS.
January 10, 1973
{S, M. SIKRI, C.J., A. N. RAY, D. G. PALEKAR, M. H. BEG AND
S. N, DWIVEDI, JJ.]
B
The Jammu & Kashmir Civil Services Classification Control and
Appeals) Rules 1969-Selection for promotion of teachers to JJOtlS of
Jieadmaster and higher posts-Selection to be on merit-c="'eniority
basis--Selection on basis of interview only without ·taking into aceount
.character roll and confidential reports of candidates and by adopting o very
·/ow curting score cannot he upheld.
Jammu & Kashmir Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Restl"'
vation Rules) 1910-Backward clarses, what are-Principles for deter·mining-Rules whether violative A.rt. 16(4), Constitution of India.
On 14·6-1956 the State of Jammu & Kashmir promulgated the
Jammu & Keshmir Civil Services (Classification O>ntrol & Appeals)
Rules 1956. Rule 19 provided that re,.rvation was permitted to be
made in favour of any backward class which in the opinion of the
Government, was not adequately represented in service, Rule 25(2)
related to promotions which were to be made on merit-cum-seniority
'basis. The State, relating Muslims a8 a backward clasa gave them a
reservatio,n of 50% in the matter of promotion of teachers to the post
of headmasters. This Court in Triloki Nath v. State of Jam1nu &:
Kashmir, [1967] 2 S.C.R. 265 and Makhan/al Woza & Ors. v. State
of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors,, [1971] 3 S.v.R, 832 held that the
promotions of muslims to the posts of headmasters or· teachers·in-charge
were made on the basis of a communal policy and against the aforesaid
1956 Rules, After the decision in Mak/Jan/al Maza's. case the State by
an order dated 23·2-1971 reverted all those teachers who had officiated
as headmasters or had been designated as teachers-in-charge. A Departme:ntal Promotion Committee was appointed in accordance with the
rules and the Committee was directed to interview the candidates. The
interviews were held ~rom March to July 1971. The selections were to
be made in accordance with the Jammu & Kashmir Civil Services
(Clossification Central and Appeals) Rules 1969 which had replaced
the old rules of 1956. Meanwhile In accordance with the recommendations of the Backward Cldsses Committee the State Governme'llt had
also issued on April 18, 1970 the Jammu & Kashmir Scheduled Castes
& Backward Cfasses (Reservation Rules) 1970. Later, on August 8.•
1970, a further order was passed known as Jarnmu & Kashmir Scheduled
Castes & Backward Classes (Reservation of appointment by Promotion)
Rules 1970.
The present petitioners were adversely affected by the
selections made by the aforesaid Departmntal Promotion' O>mmittee
In 1971. l:n their petitions under Art. 32 of the Constitution the ques·
lions that fell ful- consideration were : (i) whether the selections made
c
E
F
G
after interviews were improper and ·illegal and should be set aside;
(ii) whether the Rules of reservation of posts in favour of backward
classes are in violation of Art, 16 of the Constitution and should be
set asic1t:.
HELD : (i) Undoubtedly wht!ll> appointments to higher posts are
·-made it may be perfectly legitimate to test the candidates at a properly
•conducted interview. But interview cannot be made the aole test lll
H
237
J, P, PAll!MOO V, J, & K. STATE
A
cases of this kind. The efficiency of a teacher and hi~ qu~catio~
to be appointed as Headmaster depend on several cons1derations. HIS
character, his teachi:ng experience, ability
popularity with, the
B
to
manage
his
students and the high proportion of
class,
his
successful
students be is able to produce are all matters which must be necessarily
taken into consideration before a selection is made. For this any
Committee which desires to mnke a seLection after interview should
insist that the character roll and the service record of the teacher should
be befdre it. In the present case however the Comm:ittee did ~t have
before it either the character rolls or service records of the teachers
nor any confidential reports about them.
They had to go merely by
the result of the interview. The Committee was wrong in undertaking
to make the selections on the basis of mere interviews. [246 D]
c
Further, the expert adviser had advised 50% as the cutting
but the Committee adopted 30% as the cutting
score.· The
score)>
expert
found that there were ma:ay candidates who could not score even 30%
D
marks and so the Committee decided that even candidates who got
only 20% marks from the expert may be considered. In this way
those who got more than 30% marks from the Committee and more
than 20% marks from the expert were declared eligible for selection.
This was indeed a travesty of selection. A selection made on such a
poor basis cannot be called a selection at all. (248 H]
For the reasons given 'above the whole process of selection
must
be held to be Mong ali:d unsatisfactory.
(ii) 'Art. 15(4) speaks about "socially and educationally backward
classes citizens" while Art. 16(4) speak only of "any backward classes
of citizens".
E
However it is now settled that the expression "backward
class of citizens" i;n Art. 16(4) m011ns the same thing as the expression
"any socially and educationally backward class of citizens" in Art. 15(4).
It is social and educational backwardness of a class which is material
for the purposes of both Articles 15(4) and 16(4). [249 G]
Mere pov~rty cannot be the test of backwardness because in this
country except for a small percentage of the population the people are
F
ge;nerally poor-some being more poor, others less poor. In the rural
areas some sectors of the population are advancing socially and educa~
tiona1ly while other sectors are e.pathetic. These sectors require to be
goaded into the social stream by positive efforts by the
State. That
accounts.for the raison d'etre of the principle explai:oi.!d in Balc.ji's case
which pointed out that backward classes for whose improvement specifil
provision was contemplated by Art. 15(4) must be comparable to Sche·
G
duled Castes and Scheduled Tribes who are standing examples of
backwardness socially and educationally. If those examples are steadily
kept before the mind the difficulty in determinin2 which other classes
should be ranked as backward classes will be considerably lased (252 DJ
Jn identifying ba>kward classes one has to guard
oneself
against
including therein sections which are sociaUy and educatio.nally advanced
because the whole object of reservation would otherwise
[253 D]
H
be frustrated.
M. R. Balaji and Ors. v. State of Mysore, [1963] Supp. 1 S.C.R.
439. State of Andhra Pradesh v. P. Sagar, [1968] 3 S.C.R. 595 and
R. Chitralekha & Anr. v. Smte of Mysore.
[1%4] 6 S.C.R. 368
referred to.
238
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 S.C.R.
(iii) The Jammu & Kashmir Scheduled Castes and Backward
Classes (Reservation Rules) 1970 were defective ood incapable of being
given effect to for the follow~g reasons :
(a) Several of the occupations mentioned as traditional in Rule 4
Chapter I cannot be regarded as traditional. An agricultural labourer
is just a labourer whose services are utilised wherever unskilled labour
is required. His occupation cannot be identified as a traditional occupatiom. Similarly it is difficult to say that the occupations mentioned
A
B
in items (5), (7), (11), (20), (21), (23), (29), (48), (51),
(53), (58) and (62) of Rule 4 are traditional. These occupation do
not require special skills developed by tradition and can be resorted to
by any body with the requisite resources.
(b) Priestly classes listed at Serial Nos. 34 and 56 though following
a traditional profession can hardly be regarded as socially and
educa-
tionally backward.
(c) The definition of 'traditional occupation' in rule 2(j) is open
to serious objection. Under it if a person wants the special advantage
as a member of the backward class it is enough for him to show that
bis grand father was following a traditional occupation. His father
may not be following the traditional occupation at all. If the father
of the person who claims special treatment uinder Articles 15 (4) ood
16( 4) has given up his low income occupation and become a trader
c
D
or Government Servant it will be wrong to give the persons the special
benefit merely on the ground that his grandfather was
following
a
certaiin traditional occupation.
(d) It was not known on what basis the Government in Rule 5
had included cast.es mentioned at serial Nos. 20 to 23 as socially and
educationally backward.
E
( e) The designation of cultivators of la."'1 as backward on the
basis of the sire of the holding, as bad been dooe in Chapter III of
the Rules must be held to be erroneou_s. The error in such a case lies
in placing economic considera~ion alone above considetations wb.'ich
go to show whether a particular class is socially
and
educationally
backward,
(f) The same error is repeated in Chapter IV wherein the dependent
.of a peinsioner is supposed to belong to the backward class if such
F
pensioner has retired from certain Government posts m~tioned in
Appendix I and if the maximum of the scale of pay of these wsts did
not exceed Rs. 100/. p.m. In days when sources of employment were
few many people though socially advanced might have accepted low
paid jobs.
(g) Although the resideu>ts of certain areas specified in Chapter V
and VI of the Rules are rightly da.ignated as backwa;rd, Rules 10
Gnd. 11 have been ~ framed that the advantage. is likely to be misused
· by unporters. Outsiders who, in the course of their trade or business
happened to live in these areas for 10 years out of the pa.st 20 years
would be able to claim the benefit. This loophole must be plugged
and till that is done, tbe production of a certificate from tbe Tehsildar
as fo the backwardness of any person will be of little avail.
Ln view of the abGve findings the selections made by the
mental Promotion Committee must be set aside. [260 CJ
Depart-
G
H
J. "· PAR!MOO v. J. & K. STATE
A
(Palekar, J.)
239
[Since it would take time to revise the rules and to make new
selections the Court gave directions to be followed by the State
authorities].
_
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Writ Petitions Nos. 175, 359 and
360 of 1971.
B
Petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution of India for the
enforcement of fundamental rights.
A. K. Sen, Naunit Lal and I. N. Shroff, for the Petitioners (in
all the petitions)
c
S. V. Gupte, 0. C. Mathur, P. C. Bhartari and Bhuvanesh
Kumari, for respondents Nos. 1 and 2 (in W. P. Nos. 175 and
359)
0. C. Mathur, P. C. Bhartari and Bhuvanesh Kumari for respondents Nos. 1 & 2 (in W.P. No. 360).
D
M. C. Chagla and S. N. Prasad, for respondents Nos.
8-10, 14, 16, 17, 19, 20-24, 31-34 (in W.P. No. 175)
3-5,
·
E. C. Agarwala, for respondents No 6, 27 (in W.P. No. 175)
Jagmohan Khanna, for respondents No. 30 (in W.P. No. 175)
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
E
P ALEKAR, J. These three petitions under Article 32 are a
sequel to the action taken by the State of J ammu & Kashmir in
pursuance of the order passed by this Court in Makhanlal Waza &
Ors. v. State of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors. on February 23, 1971.
In order to understand the background of these cases it would be
sufficient to state here in bare outline the facts which are given in
greater detail in the aliove case reported in [1971](3) S.C.R. 832.
F
Owing to historical reasons there was a large proportion of
Kashmiri Pandits in the serviCes of the State, especially, in the
teaching line, although that community is hardly 2 % of the totlll
population of the State.
In cours' of time other communities
who were in a majority in the State agitated for a larger share in
the services, with the result that prior to 1954 recruitment was
made to the services in proportion to the population of the major
communities in the State.
G
;
H
In 1954 Part III of the Indian Constitution with some modi5cations was made applicable to the State. In spite of it representation in the services followed the communal pattern. On 14th
June 1956 the State promulgated the Jammu & Kashmir Civil
Services (Classification Control & Appeals) Rules, 1956. Rule
19 provided that reservation was permitted to be made in favour
240
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 S,C.R.
of any backward class which, in the opinion of the Government,
was not adequately represented in the service. Rule 25 ( 2)
related to promotions. It provided that promotions to a service
or class or to a selection category or grade in such service or class
shall be made on grounds of merit aQ.d ability and ~hall be subject
to the passing of any tests that Government may prescribe in this
behalf, seniority being considered only where the merit and ability
are approximately equal. In other words, promotions were to be
made by selection on merit-cum-seniority basis. Notwithstanding
the rules, the State followed the communal pattern of appointments and promotions, reserving 50% of the posts for Muslims,
40% mainly to the Hindu of Jammu and the remaining 10% for
Sikhs, Kashmiri Pandits and other minority communitie3. This c
led to an agitation, especially, by the teachers in the Secondary .
High Schools of the State who comprised a large proportion of
Kashmiri Pandits. They found that in spite of their seniority in
the. service as teachers, promotions to the post of Head Masters
and Tehsil Education Officers which are gazetted posts in the
service, were being made· on communal basis and not in accord- 0
ance with the law.
In December 1965 Triloki Nath Tikoo and Shambu Nath
filed Writ Petition No. 107 of 1965 in this Court alleging·that promotions to the posts of Head Masters had been made in contravention of Article 16 of the Constitution. The State admitted that
50% of the posts were filled by the Muslim of the State and
40% principally by the Hindus of Jammu. It was. however.
claimed that this reservation was made on the ground that the
Muslims of the State and Hindus of J ammu province constituted
backward classes referred to in Rule 19 and such reservation was
justified under clause ( 4) of Article 16. The Court found that
there was no sufficient material before it to decide if the claim
made on behalf of the State was justified and so by an order dated
December 15, 1966 direct~d the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir
to gather the necessary material and to report on it. · The decision
is reported as Triloki Nath v. State of lammu & Kashmir.(')
E
p
After the material. was collected the case again came before
this Court for consideration and this Court held (See : Triloki Nath G
v. State of J&K.}( 2 ) that on the material before it it was clear
that there was no reservation as penhitted by Article 16(4) but
that the posts had been distributed on the basis of community or
place of residence. The promotions were accordingly held to be
invalid .. The order affected 81 teachers who had bCen promoted
con~acy to the provisions. of Article 16 (l ) and ( 4) . Their pt!>- H
motions were declared void. The Court observed "this will not, .
(I) f1951] .2 S.C.R. 26S.
(2) [1969] !S.C.R.103
J, P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Palekar, J.)
241
however, prevent the State from devising a scheme, consistent with
the constitutional guarantees, for reservation of appointments,
posts or promotions in favour of any backward class of citizens
which in the opinion of the State is not adequately represented in
the services under the State." This order was passed by the Court
on April 23, 1968.
In view of the order. the above mentioned 81 teachers had to
revert. Along with them some others who had been promoted in
the meantime had also to revert. All of them were, however,
designated as teachers-in-charge because actually they held the
charge of the schools. There is a difference between the parties
before us as to whether there was any actual reversion. It is
alleged on behalf o' th~ petitioners that teachers-in-charge were,
for all purposes, includi'.1g pay, Head Masters while, on the other
hand, it is stated for the State that they were entitled 0nly to the
grade pay as teachers and not as Head Masters. In any case
there seems to have been an anomalous situation which gave rise
to the second Writ Petition by the teachers. That is Writ Petition
108/1969 filed by Makhanlal Waza and 10 Others v. State of
Jammu and Kashmir already referred to. To this petition a large
number of so called teachers-in-charge were made parties. Actually there were about 249 teachers who wern made respondents.
This Court found that al! the promotions of the respondents in that
case were made not purely on m.erit as requiroo by rule 25 referred to above but had been made on account of the communal
policy which had been declared invalid by this Court in Triloki
Nath Tikko's case. The Court further observed "in the absence
of any rule lawfully promulgated for employment of backward
cla~scs, promotions could be made only in accordance with rule
25 and there can be no manner of doubt that there was absolutelv
no compliance with the provisions of that rule. Promotions thus
made of all the respondent teachers were illegal and unconstitutional being violative of Article 16 of the Constitution. They
have, therefore, to be set aside. All the promotions made to the
higher posts or the higher grade pursuant to the communal policy
would have to be revised and reconsidered and appropriate orders
must be passed by respondents 1 and 2 with regard to them as
also the petitioners in accordance with the law". This order was
passed on February 23, 1971.
In view of the above decision the State had to take steps for
making proper selections on the basis of merit to the gazetted
posts of Head Masters and Tehsil Education Officer, from the
eligible teachers. As a preliminarv to the same the State reverted
by an order dated 23-2-1971 all those teacher.s who had officiated
as Head Masters or had been designated as teacher;··in-charne.
All of them were asked to hand over' charge to the second teacher
17-l~l!SupCT/73
24 2
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
in the school. Nearly 1,100 teachers were found eligible for promotion and all of them, including those who were officiating Head
Masters, were required to appear for an interview. A Departmental Promotion Committee was appointed in acc0rdance with
the rules and the Committee was directed to interview the candidates. These interviews were held from March to July, 1971.
A
8
But before the interviews were over the first of the Writ Petitions before us namely Writ Petition 175/71 was filed by 7 Kashmiri Pandit teachers who had been affected by the order reverting
them on 23-3-1971. They were senior teachers who were officiatiiig as Head Masters being appointed between 1960 and 1964 and
had not been directly affected by the two Writ Petitions already
referred to. They alleged that while they were promi"tlY reverted
respondents ·3 to 34 who were all junior to petitioner No. 1 and
also to some of the other Petitioners had not been so reverted nor
were they asked to appear for the interview. Therefore, they
claimed, the petitioners should be either restored to their former
posts or the respondents should be reverted like them in which
case alone, all of them could be regarded as having been equally
treated. They justified their refusal to appear for the interview
on the ground that respondents had been exempted from the interview and continued in their former posts.
Writ Petitions 359 and 360/1971 were filed after the interviews were over and selections made by the Committee. The
petitioners in Writ Petition No. 359 /71 are 37 in number and all
of them belong to the Jammu region. Respondents 3 to 295 are
some of the teachers selected for appointment to the higher posts
by promotion. The grievance of the petitioners was that although
they were seniors and had officiated as Head Masters for a number
of years they had been deliberately dropped to make room for the
respondents who were very much junior to them. They alleged
that the selection by interview was a farce, the device being
adopted to manipulate the selections in such a way that the old
communal proportion was maintained. They further alleged that
a large number of posts was claimed to have been reserved tmder
the Rules for backward classes, but the whole exercise was merely
to secure about 90% of the posts to Muslims. ln other words,
the complaint of the petitioners was that the alleged selection after
interview was not a genuine selection but a fraud. Similar allegations were made iri the other petition, namely, Writ Petition 360/
71. This was filed by 13 Kashmiri Pandit teachers in a representative capacity on behalf of 400 other Kashmiri Pandits who had.
boycotted the interviews on the ground that the interviews were
bound to be a fraud. The respondents 3 to 3 25 are the teachers
who had been selected at the interview.
c
D
E
F
G
H
J. P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE
A
(Palekar, !.)
243
It must be stated here that in 1967 the Government of Jammu
& Kashmir had appointed the J ammu & Kashmir Commission of
Enquiry under the Chairmanship of Dr. P. B. Gajendragadkar.
Its report was submitted in November, 1968 and one of the recommendations of the Commission was to appoint a high-powered
Committee to draw up a list of backward classes in the State of
B Jammu & Kashmir. Accordingly, the Backward Classes Committee was appointed under the Chairmanship of Shri J. N. Wazir,
Retired Chief Justice of J ammu & Kashmir High Court, on
February 3, 1969. This Committee made its report in November.
1969 recommending several classes of citizens who deserved to
be described as socially and educationally backward. Acting
substantially on the recommendations of the Committee the State
Government issued on April 18, 1970 the Jammu & Kashmir
Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Reservatioa Rules),
1970. These rules purported to make provision for reservations
of appointments and posts in favour of certain classes of permanent
resident of the State who were backward and not adequately
represented in such services and posts. Later on August 8, 1970
D
a further order was passed by the State known as Jammu & Kash·
mir Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes (Reservation of
appointment by Promotion) Rules. 1970. By these rules the
principles laid down for appointments under the earlier rules were
made applicable mutatis mutandis to promotions also. The net
result of the recommendations of the Committee as accepted by
E the State was to make reservations in appointments and promotions to the extent of 8 % of the posts for Scheduled Castes and
42 % in favour of the Backward classes.
Since the above interviews had taken place after the application of the above named Reservation Rules, the Departmental
Promotion Committee took these rules into consideration in
making the selections.
It is one of the complaints of the petitioners that though the
Committee had professed to follow the principles laid down by
this Court in several decisions, it had failed to determine the backward classes in accordance with the decisions of this Court. On
the other hand, great anxiety was shown, according to the petitioners, to rope in as many persons from the majority communities
as possible so that in the selections made thereafter a disproportionate share in the appointments and promotions would go to the
majority communities in Kashmir and Jammu.
...
H
In their affidavit in reply to the petitions the State denied all
the allegations made by the petitioners.
The principal points which were involved in these two petitions
are ( 1 ) whether the selections made after interviews are improper
244
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
und illegal and should be set aside, (ii) whether the Rules of
reservation of posts in favour of backward classes are in violation
of Article 16 and should be set aside.
Before dealing with these points, we shall dispose of the
limited controversy involved in Writ Petition No. 175/71 although
the conclusion on the above two points may indirectly affect the
parties in the Writ Petition. The latter is filed by 7 Kashmiri
Pandit teachers. They were all officiating Head Masters when
they were reverted in 1971. Their grouse is that respondents 3
to 34 were junior to them when they were inthe teachers' grade
from which the promotions were made to the Head Masters' grade,
and, if the principle of equality applied, they should have been
also reverted along with the petitioners and required to appe&r at
the interview along with the petitioners. On account of this unequal treatment, it is alleged, the petitioners had refused to appear
for the interview. It cannot be disputed that petitioner No. 1 was
the senior-most in the grade of teachers from which the promotion
is m!Jde to the post of the Head Master or Tehsil Education Officer. The other petitioners also are seniors to some of the respondents. But what happened is that owing to the communal distribution of seats the respondents 3 to 34 were all appointed as
Head Masters in and before 1958. The petitioners had to wait
their tum in the 10% seats earmarked for Kashmiri Pandits and
others and, therefore, although they were senioi:s in the grade of
teachers, their chance of appointment as Head Masters came much
later. Petitioner No. 1 was appointed as an officiating Head
Master in 1960. Petitioners 2 and 3 in 1962 and petitionern 4 to
7 in 1964. Thev all officiated as Head Masters till 1971 when
they were reverted. In the case of respondents 3 to 34 not only
were they promoted prior to 1958 but, except for respondents 26,
27 and 30, they had all been confirmed in the Head Masters'
posts before 1961. Some of the respondents were further promoted as Principals and District Education Officer• which was a
grade higher than that of Head Masters. Somehow it· appears
respondents 26, 27 and 30, though holding such higher grade
posts, had notbeen confirmed as Head Masters and they too were
reverted as soon as this petition was filed. It is not necessary for
us to investigate into the question why these 3 respondents had
not been confirmed dlthough some other respondents who were
junior to them had been confirmed as Head Masters. It might
be simply an administrative omission or something also. But one
thing is clear. All these respondents 3 to 34 had been appointed
as Head Masters much before the petitioners and ;nost of them
were also confirmed in the posts. There may be sonie substance
in the petitioners' contention that the earlier appointment of these
respondents, being based on the communal principle, was not a
A
B
c
E
F
G
H
J, P. PAIUMOO v. ;J, & K. STATE (Palekar, I.)
B
c
245
valid appointment and, therefore, their confinnation may not affect
the question. On the other hand, it is to be noted that the respondents seem not to have figured in Triloki Nath Tikoo's case
(W.P. 107/1965) filed in 1965. It would not, !herefore, be proper to interfere with their appointments now, especially, as in the
meantime they have been promoted to posts which are higher
than of Head Masters. Indeed if any one of the respondents was
a respondent in Writ Petition 107/1965 (Triloki Nath Tikoo's
case) or in Writ Petition l 08/ 1969 (Makhanlal's case) in which
his appointment as He<1_d Master had been set aside as invalid, his
case will have to be treated like that of any other offi,ciating Head
Master who had been reverted in 1971. Otherwise we do not
think that it would be right to interfere, at the instance of the petitioners, with these respondents whose appointments as Head
Masters had been made in or before 1958.
We shall now tum to the two points referred to above arising
out of Writ Petitions No. 359/71 and 360/71. The first point
D involves the question whether the selection by interviews held by
the Departmental Promotion Committee between Mar. 15, 1971
and July 18, 1971 for the purposes of making promotions to the
posts of Head Masters and Tehsil Education Officials was a valid
and proper· exercise. The Department found more than 1100
teachers qualified for promotion and they were all called for
interviews. The selection was to be made in accordance with the
E Jammu & Kashmir Civil Services (Classification Control and
Appeals)° Rules, 1969 which, it appears, had replaced the old
rules of 1956. It appears to us that, there is no distinction between the two rules because even as under the 1956 rules the posts
of Head Masters had to be filled on the merit-cum-seniority basis,
under the 1969 rules also selections had to be made on that basis
r only. From the beginning, it appears, some of the senior teachers, mostly coming from the Kashmiri Pandit class, did not
have any faith in this system of selection and actually more than
400 of them boycotted the interview. Several allegations have
been made that even before and during the period when the interviews were going on many in high authority were giving assuG rances to some of the reverted teachers that whatever happens
those who had been reverted would get their posts back if only
they appeared fo• interviews. We are not concerned with these
allegations. It was also alleged that the selections were stagemanaged with a view to maintain the old proportion of communal representation. It was pointed out that when previously the
appointments were made on the communal basis, 178 posts had
H gone to Muslims and 134 to Jammu Hindus. Now after selection, 177 posts go to Muslims and 134 to Hindus. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that it could not have been
246
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
a mere coincidence that the same number of Muslims and Hindus
could have been selected in any properly conducted system of
selection. It is contended on behalf of the State that if only
the Kashmiri Pandit teachers had taken part in the interview, it
was very likely that the results might have been somewhat
different. There is some substance in that contention also and,
therefore, we shall not go merely by the coincidence that the same
number of Muslims and Jamvi Hindus had been selected.
A
B
There are, however, two important considerations which
show that the selections by interview were thoroughly unsatis·
factory. The candidates for selection included a large number
of senior teachers many of whom liad officiated as Head Masters c
over long periods. They were asked to appear before a Com-··
mittee consisting of 4 officials. One was a Member of the Public
Service Commission, the second was the Secretarv of the Education Department, the third was the nominee of the Chief Secretary and the fourth member was the Director of Education. The
Committee was also assisted by an Educational expert from out- D
side the State and this body was expected to make the selection
after interviewing the candidates. Undoubtedly when appointments to higher posts are made it may be perfectly legitimate to
test the candidates at a properly conducted interview. But it
appears to us that the interview cannot be made the sole test in
cases of this kind. The efficiency of a teacher and his qualifications to be appointed as Head Master depend upon several con- E
siderations. His character, his teaching experience, ability to
manage his class, his popularity with the students and the high
percentage of successful students he is able to produce ·are all
matters which must be necessarily taken into consideration before
a selection is made. For this any Committee which desires to
make a selection after interview should insist that the character F
roll and the service record of the teachers should be before it.
At the time of these interviews, however, the Committee did not
have before it either the character rolls or service records of the
teachers nor any confidential ·reports about <hem. They had to
go merely by the result of the interview. In his affidavit the
Educational Secretary has admitted that such confidential records G
were not made available to the Committee and the reason given
was as follows ·
"Necessary service records in respect of confidential
rolls or character rolls of all the eligible candidates for
the last few years were not available. Moreover the
number of candidates was very large."
H
It is rather extraordinary that such a statement should be made
by a high official of the Government. It is difficult to conceive
;J,
P. PARIMOO v. ;J, "' K. STATE
(Palekar, I.)
247
A
that confidential reports were not available. The statement does
not make it clear whether all the confidential reports were not
available or only a few of them or for what years. The statement. is so vague that it is difficult to accept it. Whenever
appointments to gazetted posts are made and have to be approved
by the Public Service Commission, confidential reports must be
B forwarded to the Commission, for otherwise it is difficult to see
how the Public Serviee Commission can approve the appointments. It may happen that in a few cases the confidential records
may be lost or missing. But to deprive the Committee of the
benefit of these reports on the ground that such reports of all the
eligible candidates for the last few years were not available would
c be ridiculous. The very fact that some other reason was necessary to be given, namely, that the number of candidates was very
large goes to show that the first reason given by the official was
considered by him as not altogether sati~factory. All the available reports ought to have been produced before the Committee
and if any was lost or not available it was the duty of the DepartD ment to ca!l for confidential reports afresh from authorities who
had opportunities to observe the character and work of the
teachers concerned. All the schools are Government schools and
they must have been inspected from time to time by the Educa·
tion Officers or Inspectors. Their reports could have been called
to aid the Committee in its deliberations. We consider that the
Committee
was wrong in undertaking to make the selection on
E
the basis of mere interviews.
F
G
H
It would appear from the affidavit filed on 6ehalf of the State
that out of the total of 50 marks to be given to the candidate,
20 marks were allotted for general knowledge, 20 marks for
aptitude and 10 marks for personality. An assessment of the
merit of a teacher was to be made in a short half hour or even
less. The petitioners have criticised the system of interviews in
these words :
"Personality connotes traits in one's character and
not merely physical appearance or muscular strength.
Their ability to control the students and administer the
work of a school could not possibly be tested by a
viva voce test. For this purpose the service r~cord
and personal files of the candidates were the be~t criteria for assessing the suitability and merit. Unfortunately for reasons best known to them the authorities
never placed the service record and personal files before
the Departmental Promotion Committee members. The
rich experience gained through his cat"'.er in the service, teaching and administrative quality. discipline,
punctuality, regularity, popularity ability to carry on
248
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
with staff, qualities to tone up the schools to create
healthy tradition and create interest among the students
in extra curricular activities which were the most relevant aspects and would have been known to the members of the interviewing committee from the service
and personal records of the candidates."
There is considerable force in the above criticism.
A
8
The second consideration is th.e wholly inept way of making
selections. Selection means that the man selected for promotion
must be of merit. Where promotion is by seniority, merit takes
the second place but when it is a selection, merit takes the first
place and it is implicit in such selection that the man must not c
be just average. When responsible posts are filled by selection,
cases are known where selections are not made because candi"
dates of the required merit were not available. It is, therefore,
customary for a Committee making the selection to fix a standard
below which they should not go. In fact it appears from the
affidavit filed by one of tl)e Educational ~erts who assisted the D
Committee that he had iuggested "that an optimum cutting score
for selection should be at least 50% ." In other words, his advice
was that those candidates who got more than 50% marks alone
should be considered. The affidavit is of Dr. N. K. Dutt, Reader
in Education, Central Institute of Education, Delhi who was the
very first expert who sat with the Committee at the time of the
selection. Dr. Dutt says that his suggestion for optimum cuting E
score of not less than 50% had been favourably received by the
Departmental Promotion Committee. He further says that every
member of the Committee and the advisor were each required to
make his own assessment and give the marks out of the maximum
50 marks fixed for a candidate. In a counter affidavit filed on
behalf of the State by the Education Secretary the statements F
made by Dr. Dutt in his affidavit, though referred to, are not
·controverted. But the actual marking results show .an entirely
different story. The four members of the Committee made their
independent assessment and an average was taken representing
the marks received by a candidate, According to the affidavit
filed on behalf of the State instead of following the suggestion of G
the expert, the Committee fixed 30% instead of 50% as the
optimum cutting score. 30% is generally considered to be less
than just pass marks, being less than one third of the maximum,
and it would be absured to make selections with such a cutting
score. The expert adviser had advised 50% as the cutting score
but the Committee adopted 30% as the cutting score. The export H
advisor had advised 50% as the cutting score but the
Committee
adopted 30% as the cutting score.
The
expert found that there were many candidates who could not
J, P. PARIMOO v. J, "' K. STATE
.A
B
·C
E
F
G
(Palekar, 1.)
249
score even 30% marks and so the Committee decided that even
candidates who got only 20% marks from the expert may be
considered. In this way those who got more than 30% marks
from the Committee and more than 20% marks from the expert
were declared eligible for selection. This is indeed a travesty
of selection. The Secretary has clearly stated in his affidavit that
in fixing the qualifying minimum percentage to determine the
suitability of the candidate, the candidate need have obtained
30% marks and above from the Committee and 20% and above
from the expert. We consider that a selection made on such a
poor basis cannot be called a real selection at all. For the reasons _given above therefore we think that the whole process of
selection is wrong and unsatisfactory and must be set aside.
We have now to tum to the second point involved in the case
namely, reservations in favour of backward classes. We are not
concerned in this case with reservations made in favour of the
Scheduled castes. According to the reservation rules already
referred to, 8% of the posts are reserved for Scheduled Caste
candidates and 42% in favour of backward classei. According
to the figures given by the State, 163 candidates were selected
against unreserved vacancies and 136 candidates were selected
against reserved vacancies in favour of backward classes. This,
however, did not mean that a backward class candidate could not
be selected to the unreserved vacancies on merit. A backward
class candidates can come under the rules in the unreserved
vacancies also solely on merit. We are not concerned here whether such a rule is proper when a large percentage of 42 % is
reserved for the backward classes. We are, however, concerned
with the fundamental question as to whether the Rules by which
backward classes are determined for the purpose of Articles 15
( 4) and 16 ( 4) of the Constitution are violative of those Articles.
Article 15 ( 4) speaks about "socially and educationally backward classes of citizens" while Article 16(4) speaks only of "any
backward class of citizens." However, it is now settled that the
expression "backward class of citizens" in Article 16 ( 4) means
the same thing as the expression "any socially and educationally
backward class of citizens" in Article 15 ( 4). In order to qualify
for being called a 'backward class citizen' he must be a member
of a socially and educationally backward class. It is social and
educational backwardness of. a class which is material for the
purposes of both Article 15 ( 4) and 16 ( 4).
Many State Governments had found it difficult to determine
which class of citizens can be properly regarded as socially and
educationally backward. Several cases have come to this Court
and the decision of this Court in M. R. Balaji and others v. State
250
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
of Mysore(') is generally regarded as the locus classicus on the
subject. Several other decisions have been rendered thereafter
and the passage in a judgment delivered by Shah, J- (as he then
was) in State of Andhra Pradesh & Anr. v. P. Sagar( 2 ) summarises the general principles at page 600. It is as follows :
"In the context in which it occurs the expression
"class" means a homogeneous section of the people
grouped together because of certain likenesses or common traits and· who are identifiable by some co=on
attributes such as status, rank, occupation, residence
in a locality, race, religion and the like. In determining whether a particular section forms a class, caste
cannot be excluded altogether. But in the determination of a class a test solely based upon the case or
community cannot also be accepted. By cl. ( 1), Art.
15 prohibits the State from discriminating against any
citizen on ground~ only of religion, race, caste, sex,
place of birth or any of them. By cl. (3) of Art. 15
the State is, notwithstanding the provision contained
in cl. ( 1), permitted to make special provision for
women and children. By cl. ( 4) a special provision
for the advancement of any socially and educationally
backward classes of citizens or for the Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes is outside the purview of
clause ( 1). But cl.. ( 4) is an exception to cl. (1).
Being an exception, it cannot be extended so as in effect
to destroy the guarantee of cl. ( 1). 'fl!e Parliament
has by enacting cl. ( 4) attempted to balance as against
the right of equality of citizens the special necessities of the weaker sections of the people by allowing a provision to be made for their advancement. In order that
effect may be -given to cl. ( 4), it must appear that the
benefidaries of the· Special provision are classes which
are backward socially and educationally and they are
other than the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes,
and that the provision made is for their advancement.
Reservation may be adopted to advance. the interests
of weaker sections of society, but in dging so, care
must be taken to see thaf deserving and qualified candidates are not excluded from admission to higher educational institutions. The. criterion for determining the
. backwardness must not be based solely on religion,
race, caste, sex, or place of birth, and the backwardness being social and educational must be similar to
the backwardness from the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes suffer. These. an; the principles
(1) [1963] Suppl. 1 S.C.R. 439.
(2) [1968] 3 S.C.R. 595.
A
,.. ..
c
j
(
D
E
F
~
~;
'-'
G
f·
H
J. P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE (Palekar, !.)
A
25t
which have been enunciated in the decision of this
coun in M. R. ffalaji's case-(1963) Suppl. 1 S.C.R.
439 and R. Chitralekh and Another v. State of Mysore
and others (1964) S.C.R. 368."
It is not merely the 'educational backwardness or the social
backwardness
which makes a class c( citizens backward; the class
B
identified as a' class as above must be both educationally and socially backward. In India social and educational backwardness is
further associated with economic backwardness and it is observed
in Balaji's ca5e referred to above that backwardness, socially and
educationally, is ultimately and primarily due to poverty.· But if
poverty is the exclusive test, a very large proportion of the populac tion
in India would have to be regarded as socially and educationally backward, and if reservations are made only on the ground
. of economic considerations, an untenable situation. may arise because even in sectors which are recognised as socially and educationally advanced there are large pockets of poverty. In this country
except for a small percentage of the population the people are
D generally poor-some being more poor, others less poor. Therefore, when a social investigator tries to identify socially and educationally backward classes, he may do it with confidence that they
are bound to be poor. His chief concern is, therefore, to determine
whether the class or group is socially and educationally backward.
Though the two words 'socially' and 'educationally' are used
E cumulatively for the purpose of describing the backward class, one
may find, that if a class as a whole is educationally advanced, it is
genera!ly also socially advanced because of the reformative effect
of education on that class. The words "advanced" and "backward''
are only relative terms-there being several layers or strata of
classes, hovering between "advanced" and "backward", and the
F difficult task is which class can be recognised out of these several
layers as being socially and educationaily backward.
In the report submitted by the Backward Classes Committee
to the ~ate of Jammu & Kashmir it is stated that agriculture is the·
G
H
main stay of the State's economy. 90% of the population depends
for its living on land. See : Chapter IV para- 38 of the Report.
Therefore, the problem of social backwardness in the State, as elsewhere, is the problem of rural India. Nevertheless so much has
been accomplished during the past 25 years for the amelioration of
the conditions of the rural oor.ulation that rural India of a past
generation has no relevance today. Facilities for education which
were practic~lly non-existent a generation ago are now available at
the villagers door-step. In a fonner age it was only the fortunate
few 'Yho .got. thi;ough Secondarv education because of paucity of
teachin~ mshtutions. but now the rural areas are studed with
Secondary schools at comparatively easy distances. Except in
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
252
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
wholly inacceable areas, ev<n colleges are established not far from
the rural population. There is hence a growing sector in the village
population which firmly believes in education as an instrument of
social advancement and more and more of them are receiving
education in these institutions. As a matter of fact, the concept of
education as a cardinal element in social equipment has so much
permeated these sectors that it is almost the measure of social
advance they have made recently. However, side by side with
these sectors there are still some sectors of the population which
show extreme apathy towards education due to age-old customs
and habits of living, fostered by poverty, ignorance, superstition
and prolonged social suppression. The interests of these sectors
must very naturally be the prime concern of the State. Indeed all
sectors in the rural areas deserve encouragement but whereas the
former by their enthusiasm for education can get on without special
treatment, the latter require to be goaded into the social stream by
positive efforts by the State. That accounts for the raison d'etre of
the principle explained in Balaji's case which pointed out that
, backward classes fo~ whose improvement special provision was
contemplated by Article 15 ( 4) must be comparable 'to Scheduled
castes and Scheduled tribes who are standing examples of backwardness socially and educationally. If those examples are steadily
kept before the mind the difficulty in determining which other
classes should be ranked as backward classes will be considerably
eased.
The failure to grasp this fundamental requirement has distortecNnvestigations of those who plumped for special reservations for
communities which comprised both _advanced and backward groups.
In R. Chitralekh & Anr. v. State of Mysore & Ors.(') Subba Rao,
J (as he then was), speaking for the majority, discarded caste as
the dominant criterion in the following words ~t page 388 :
"It may be that for ascertaining whether a particular citizen or a group of citizens belong to a backward class or not. his or their caste may have some
relevance, but it cannot be either the sole or the dominant criterion for ascertaining the class to which he or
they belong.
This interpretation wi]] carry out the intention of
the Constitution exoressed in the aforesaid Articles. It
helps the really backward classes instead of promoting:
the interests of individuals or grouos who, though they
belong to a particular caste a- majority whereof is socially and educationallv backward. really belong to a
class which is sociallv and educationallv advanced. To
illustrate_. take a cas-te in a State which is numerically
--~---
Ii) [1964] 6 S.C.R. 368.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
J. P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE
A
B
c
D
E
.rF
I= ._.,,
(Palekar, /;)
25J.
the largest therein. It may· be that though a majority of
the people in that caste are socially and educationally
backward, an.effective.minority may be 'socially and
educationally. far more advanced than. another small
sub-caste the total number of which is far less than the
said minority. If we interpret the expression "classes"
as "castes", the object of the Constitution will be frustrated and the people who do not deserve any adventitious aid may get it to the exclusion of those who really
deserve. This anomaly will not arise if, without equating caste with class, caste is taken as only one of the
considerations to ascertain whether a person belongs to
a backward class or not. On the other hand, if the
entire sub-caste, by and large, is backward, it may be
included in the Scheduled Castes · by following the
appropriate procedure laid down by the Constitution."
In identifying backward classes, therefore, one has to guard
oneself against including therein sections which are socially and
educationally advanced because the whole object of reservation
would otherwise be frustrated. In this connection it must also
be remembered that State resources are not unlimited and, further, the protection given by-special reservation must be ba!iinced
against the constitutional right of every citizen to demand equal .
opportunity. Moreover, where appointments and promotions to
responsible public offices are made, greater circumspection would
be required in making reservations for the benefit of any backward
class because efficiency and public interest must always remain
paramount. It is implicit in the idea of reservation that a less
meritorious person is to be preferred to another who is more meritorious .
The Jammu & Kashmir Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes Reservation Rules, 1970 are comprised 5 parts. Part I contains 6 Chapters and rule 3 says that the permanent residents of
the State. belonging to the categories of persons in these six
Chapters are declared as socially and educationally - backward
classes of citizens. Chapter I enumerates occupations which are
G regarded as traditional occupations and rule 4 says that every
person whose traditional occupation is one of the 62 mentioned_
therein must be regarded as a person belonging to the backward
class. Chapter II mentions 23 social castes, and persons belom;ing to these social castes are regarded as backward. Chaoter Ill
_describes small cultivators as b~kward. Chapter IV groups low
H paid pensioners as backward. Chaoter V puts residents in an
area adjoining the ceasefire line in the backward class. Chapter
VI specifies some areas in the State as "bad pockets~ and every.
person belonging .to that area is to be regarded as belonging to the
254
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 S.C.R.
A
backward class. We are not directly concerned with the other
parts of these rules. Objection is taken by Mr. Sen, on behalf
of the petitioners, to the several types of backward classes designated under the rules and also to the peculiar manner in which the
.definitions have been framed.
Chapter I gives the <;lass designated by traditional occupa- B
tions. In all about 62 occupations have been identified as traditional. They follow closely the classes designated as traditional
occupational classes by the Committee in Chapter XIV of its report. In para 124 the Committee has stated that with a view to
sorting out backward classes from others. the claim of each and
every occupational and industrial category listed in the census c
report of 1961 had been carefully examined and it is obvious that
the list of traditional occupations is made as exhaustive as possible. A class can be identified on the basis of traditional occupation. A traditional occupation means an occupation followed in
a family in which it is handed down by an ancestor to his posterity. If _there is a section of the population following an occupa- D
tion of that description that section can be regarded as a class.
Such occupations are generally occupations in which some special
skills are necessary like those of an artisan or a craftsman. It is
contended by Mr. Sen that though 62 occupations have been
mentioned as traditional occupations a good many of them are
not really traditional occupations and with regard to others there
has been no investigation in depth as to whether they are traditional E
occupations or not. It is also contended by hirn that the definition of 'traditional occupation' given in the rules actually distorts
the whole picture because whether the father of the person claiming reservation follows the traditional occupation or not, he becomes entitled to be considered as of the class if his grand-father
did.
F
There is no doubt that a large number of occupations mentioned in the list is capable of being followed as a traditional
occupation. But some of them, at least, do not deserve to be
called traditional occupations. Take for example an "agricultural
labourer". We have grave doubts if agricultural labour can be
regarded as a traditional occupation. The occupation is seasonal
and, '!IS is well-known, it is the last refuge of the landless unskilled
labourer who has no other source of employment in the rural
~o~unity .. Indeed, if any one deserved special consideration
it is the agricultural labourer, but the objection is to its identification as a traditional occupation. An agricultural labourer is
just a labourer whose services are utilized wherever unskilled
labour is required. In fact he is the source material for hama!s
and the like-occupations which merely require physical strength
G
H
/
/
J, ·p, PARIMOO v. J, & K. STATE
,
A
B
L
-~'
c
l
D
E
(Palekar, /.).
•/
255
and capacity to work. Similarly it would· be difficult to say that
the following occupations are traditional occupations :
(5) Bearer, Boy, waiter.
( 7) Book binders.
Cll) Cook.
(20) Grass seller.
(21) Hawkers, pedlars.
(23) Load carriers.
( 29) Old garment sellers.
( 48) Watch repairers.. c
( 51) Grocers in rural areas ..
( 53) Mille-sellers in rural areas.
(58) Vegetable sellers in rural areas.
( 62) Drivers of Ton gas and other animal driven vehicles.
All these occupations do not require special skills developed by
tradition and can be resorted to by anybody with the requisite
resources. Then agairi at serial nos. 34 and 56 we have a category of priestly classes who, though following a traditional profession can hardly be regarded as socially and educationally backward. We, therefore, thirik that there must be a proper revision
of the traditional occupations to fall properly under rule 4.
But the most serious objection is to the artificial definition
given in rule 2 (j). The "traditional occupation" iri respect of a
person means .the mairi occupation of his living or late grand_father and does not include casual occupation. This would mean
F that if a person wants the special advantage as a member of the
backward· class it is enough for him to show that his grandfather
was following a traditional occupation. His ·father may not be
following the traditional occupation at all. He might have given
it up to follow some other occupation or trade. It is not enough,
it is contended, that a traditional occupation was followed by the
G grandfather but that the occupation should have descended to
his son also so that at date when the grandson is asking for the
-benefit of reservation the traditional occupation must be still in
the family and continues to. be the living of the family. There is
great force iri this contention. If the father of the_person who
claims special treatment under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) has
given up his low income occupation and. become a trader or a
H
Government servant it will be wrong to give the person the spe·
cial benefit merely on the ground that his grandfather was following a certain traditional occupation. It was against such misuse .
256
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
that the ·committee had issued a warning in para
report. It observed.
129 of its
"While making the foregoing provisions, every possible care
should be taken by the State to ensure that the benefit of such provisions is availed of only by those who are bonafide members of
the classes declared backward and notby imposters." As already
stated it is quite open to the State to declare that persons belonging to low income families following a traditional occupation
should be regarded as persons belonging to a backward class if,
on the whole, that class is socially. and educationally backward.
But it is equally essential that at the time when a person belonging to that class claims the special treatment his family must be
still following the traditional occupation. Since the rule does not
completely ensure this it is likely to be abused and the real person
for whose benefit the rule is made will not get the benefit. The
rules, therefore, pertaining to traditional occupations must be
suitably revised.
A
B
c
Chapter II deals with some 23 low social castes.. The Committee in Chapter XIII had identified the first 19 out of them and D
stated that these castes are considered inferior in society -as the
service which they render carry a stigma in it. They suffer from
social disabilities and both educationally and economically they
are .extremely backward. The last four castes in rule 5 have not
been mentioned in Chanter XIII of the report. It is not also
known on what basis they have been included as socially and E
educationally backward. There may be good reasons for the
State Government to do so. but we have no material before us. ·
As at present addressed. therefore. we are not prepared to proceed on the basis that serial nos. 20 to 23 are backward classes.
Chanter III identifies cultivators of land with small holdings
F
as a backward class. The limits of his holding differ according to
the type of land cultivated and the region in which such land is .
situated. The cultivator may be an owner or a tenant. He may
even be a non-cultivator provided he whol'y depends on land for
. his livelihood. The cultivator is designated as a class on the basis ·
of. the recommendations made bv the Committee in Chapter XII
of its report. The reasons given by the Committee go to show G
that the overriding consideration was economic. A class, as
already observed, must be a homogeneous social section· of the
peoole with common traits and identifiable by · som~ common
attributes.· All that can be said.about the cultivators is that they
are ·persons who cultivate land or live on land, and the simple
accident that thev hold land below a· certain ceiling is sunnosed H
to make them a class. In such a case the relevance of social and
educational backwardness takes a subordinate· place. · · Jn soine
areas as in Kashmir valley the ceiling for a cultivator is 10 Kanals
J. P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE
(Palekar, J.)
257
of irri2ated land. If a cultivator holds 10 Kanals of land or less
he is to be regarded as backward i.e. to §_ay socially and educationaliy backward. But if his own brother living in the same
village owns half a Kanai more than the ceiling he is not to be
considered backward. This completely distorts the picture. It
will be very difficult to say that if a person owns just 10 Kanals
B of land he should be considered socially and educationally backward while his brother owning half a Kanai more should not be
so considered. The error in such a case lies in placing economic
consideration above considerations which go to show whether a
particular class is socially and educationally backward. The same
error is repeated in Chapter· IV wherein the dependant of a pen·
<: sioner is suppooed to belong to the b_ackward class if such pensioner had retired from certain Govt. posts mentioned in Appendix
I and if the maximum of the scale of pay of these posts did not
exceed Rs. 100 p.m. They also included defence service pensioners of the ranks of sepoy, Naik Havaldars etc. :rhis again is
based upon the recommendation of the Committee which in
Chapter II of the report says "Among others, representatives of
D pensioners also called on the Committee. and explained the difficulties faced by them because of being in receipt of a meagre income in ihe shape of pensionary emoluments. The memorialists
contended that they cannot keep pace with the ever-rising price
index as rates of pension have remained static and have not been
enhanced as is being done from time to time in the case of GovernE
ment servants in regular service. It was further argued that they
could ill afford to spare any part of their meagre earnings for the
education of their children." The Committee felt that these
pensioners deserve on there grounds to be shown consideration as
backward classes because most of them held class IV or similar
posts. Ex-servicemen who fall in this class are about 90,000
F- and civil posts pensioners are about 15,000. It is diffic.ult to say
that those pensioners are a class in the sense that they are a homogeneous group. They are an amorphous section of Government
servants who by the accident of receiving Rs. 100/- or less as pay
at the time of retirement or being ex-servicemen of certain grades
are pushed into an artifically created body. It may be that they
belong to class IV or similar grade service of the State. But that
G is not the test of their social and educational backwardness. In
days when sources of employment were few, manv people though
socially advanced might have accepted low paid jobs. Some of
them may have failed to make the educational grade and were
hence forced by necessity to accept such low paid jobs. Some
others might have pre-maturely .retired from posts carrying the
ff scale referred to above. The accident, therefore, that they belong
to a section of Government servants of certain category is no test
of their social backwardness. The test breaks down if the position of a brother of such a pensioner is considered. If the brother,
A
. 18-631Sup.CJ/73 .
258
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
also a Government servant, has the misfortune o[ retiring when
holding a po>t the maximum of which was Rs. 105 he was liable
to be regarded as not socially and educationally backward when,
in all conscience, so far as the two brothers are concernecJ they
remain on the same social level. Another brother who is privately employed and retires from service without any pensionary
benefits would not be entitled to be classed as backwatd under
the test. These anomalies arise because of the artificial nature of
the group created by the Committee. If all the brothers are
socially and educationally backward, you will be differentiating
between them by calling !;()me more backward and others less
backward, a thing not permitted by Balaji's case. There is, therefore, substance in the contention of Mr. Sen that the Committee
has created these two artificial groups of "cultivators" and "pensioners" for the purpose of affording certain benefits under the
Comtitution instead of identifying socially and educatiol)a lly
backward classes.
Chapter V & VI of the Rules identify residents of certain
areas as backward. In Chapter V the residents of certain villages
mentioned in Appendix II are considered as backward, these
villages being within five miles of the ceasefire line. In Chapter
VI some areas in the State are regarded as "bad pockets" and all
the residents of those areas are stated to be backward. These
two Chapters incorporate the recommendations made by the
Committee in Chapter X and IX respectively of the report.
Chapter IX relates to ''bad pockets''. 10 such bad pockets have
been identified by the Committee and cover 696 villages in certain
Districts and Tehsils far away in the interior. The population of
thes,: Jrc:ts according to 1961 census was about three lakh<. The
Co1nsJ:inee reports as follov.·s :
"There are, for instance well known rather notorious backward areas which have to be treated differently
from the rest of the State. There are others which bi.
cause of difficult terrain, inaccessibility and absence of
vehicular communications still retain their primitive
character. There are still some others which suffer from
deficient production on account of soil being rocky and
sandy and irrigation facilities being scanty and inadequate. Besides these, there are areas where due to nonavailability of electric power, industrial development
even on the scale of cottage industry has yet to come
into existence. There are certain areas which combine
all or some of these characteristics."
Ten such pockets were then examined in detail and the Committee
came to the conclusion that owing to lack of communication, \naccessibility, lack of material resources and the like the re-
!l
c
E
F
G
H
J. P. PARIMOO v. J. & K. STATE (Palekar, /.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
259
sidents of these areas are living in almost primitive conditio11~
and they are all socially and educationally backward. The civilzing influence of modern life is yet to reach them. These areas
are carefully mapped. They are situated in the recesses of inaccessible mountains which have primarily led to the residents
therein being almost in a primitive state. The population is about
8% of the total population of Jammu & Kashmir and, in our
opinion, there is no serious difficulty in regarding the residents of
these areas as being backward. Simiiar considerations apply to
areas adjoining the ceasefire line. They comprise about 179
villages with a population of about a lakh. The difficulties of
their situation near the ceasefire line for the last 25 ·years seem to
have contributed to this area being cut off from the main stream
of life. The Committee noticed that the difficulties inherent in
tl:e living conditions in these areas had inevitably lead the inhabitants of these areas living in economic and educational backward•nes~. There are restrictions on their free movement and they
have to remain indoors after sun set. The male members cannot
leave their villages in search of livelihood elsewhere for fear of
their wives and children being left behind unprotected. The land
is unproductive, no investments could be made in the land because of the nearness of the ceasefire line. Raids accompanied
by cattle lifting and damage to property are not uncommon. Loss
of life also takes place occasiona]]y. The inhabitants find it equally
difficult to pursue their traditional arts and crafts. The effect of
all these contributory factors have kept these areas, in so far as
social and educational progress is concerned, verv much behind
the rest of the State. We thus find that soecial reasons have been
given by the Committee why it considered these areas socially and
educationally backward and since the classification is not made
merely on the ground of place of birth, we do not think that there
is any serious objection to regard the residents of the bad pockets
and the ceasefire areas as socially and educationally backward.
But Rules JO and 12 have been so framed that the advanta2e is
likely to be misused by imposters. A person wanting the advanta!!e of reservation would be regarded as belonging to these areas
if.liis father is or has been resident of the area for a period of not
11!9!1 than JO years in a period of 20 year< preceding the year in
which the certificate of backwardness is obtained. The rules do
nOj; insist that either the father or the son should be a resident of
the area when the advantage is claimed. Nor does it require that
the son should have his earlier education in these areas to ensure
that he and his father are permanent residents of that area. Anv
tradl!r or Government servant from outside who is ?e&iding for
about 10 years in these areas within 20 vears of the date when
the ~vantal!e i< claimed would, be entitled to be regarded as belonl!Ulg to the backward class. In order that the benefit may f1;0
to the: residents of these areas, Government ought to frame rales
I
260
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 3 s.c.R.
with adequate safeguards that only genuine residents will get the
advantage of wecial reservation and not outsiders. As the rules
. stand, outsiders who, in the course of their trade or busines5
happened to live in these areas for l 0 years out o( past 20 years
would be able to claim the benefit; This loophole must be plugged
and tlll that 1s done, the production of a certificate from the
Tehsildar as to the backwardness of any person would be of
little value.
We have shown above the defects in the rules which purport
to identify certain residents of the State as backward. Till the
defects are cured, the rules are not capable of being given effect
to.
In view of the above findings the selections made by the
Departmental Promotion Committee have to be set aside.
A
g
c
It is very unfortunate that this controversy is going on from
1965. The net result of it has been to deprive schools of theirHead Masters. There can be no doubt also that on account of
various changes effected during the past years, considerable dam- ))
age must have been done to overall discipline in the schools. The
rules of 1969 provide for promotions to the posts of Head Masters
and Tehsil Education Officers by selection. Therefore, it is essential that these selections must be made on a proper basis. That
will take some time. In the meantime the schools must have a
proper administrative set up and we, therefore, propose an interim E
arrangement. Since the. selections made on the basis of the present backward class reservations rules are illegal and it would
take sometime before those rules are properly revised the State
may consider the suggsetion whether all the posts which are now
vacant may not be filled by selections under the rules of 1969
and appropriate reservations in favour of bacl..-ward classes be
made for future vacancies as the.y occur after the backward class F
reservation rules are properly revised. Accordingly, the following
directions are given as ~ result of our findings in the three
petitions :
( 1) All those Head Masters and Tehsil Education Officers
who have been confinned as such or promoted to yet G
higher ·posts with effect from the date prior to the
filing of the Writ Petition No. 107/1965 (Tri/okl
Nath Tikoo's case) will not be affected by the orders
passed in these cases;
(2) The cases of all other teachers including those who
were officiating as Head Masters and Tehsil E<luca- H
tion Officers and are eligible for promotion shall be ·
reviewed in a proper selection made in accordance
with the 1969 rules. Interviews shall not be the
J. I'. PAlUMOO v. J, & K; STATE (Palekar, J.)
A
B
c
D
E
261
only test. T)l.e character rolls and the confidential
records shall be taken into due consideration. If in
any case the same are not available, a report or reports should be obtained from authorities who had
opportunity to observe th~ teachers' performance and
character.
(3) Pending selection as per (2) above, the following in·
tcrim arrangement for filling the vacant posts of Head
Masters and Tehsil Education Officers is directed :
(a) Those Head Masters and Tehsil Education Olli·
cers who were officiating as such since prior 'to
the filing of Writ Petition No. 107/65 (Triloki
Nath Tikoo's case) and whose appointments had
not been set aside as invalid in that Writ Petition or Writ Petition No. 108/69 (Makhanlal's
case) will be restored to the position they held
before the filing of Writ Petition No. 107/65;
(b) The remaining vacant posts of He11d Mum
and Tehsil Education Officers will be filled by
those selected in 1971 interviews, provided that
each one of those selected had obtained at least
503 ~arks from the Departmental Promo~on
Committee and 50% marks from the Expert.
As between them, seniority will be respected.
( c) U in spite of following (b) above, all the vacancies are not filled the remaining vacancies shall
be filled by teachers in order of their senioritr.
The petitioners in the three petitions shall get their costs from
respondent no. 1 (i.e. State) in one set of hearing fees.
F
G.C.
Petitions allowed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org