NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. LTD. & ORS. versus UN!ON OF INDIA & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 10 November 1972 | [1973] 2 S.C.R. 940 | 1972 INSC 277
Key facts
- Decided
- 10 November 1972
- Bench
- S.M. SIKRI*, A.N. RAY, D.G. PALEKAR, M. HAMEEDULLAH BEG, S.N. DWIVEDI
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 425/1971
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1973] 2 S.C.R. 940
- Neutral citation
- 1972 INSC 277
Text of the judgment
940
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. LTD. & ORS.
v.
UN!ON OF INDIA & ANR.
November IO, 1972 ·
[S. M. S!KRI, C.J., A. N. RAY, D. G. PALEKAR, M. H. BEG AND
S. N. DwIVEDY, JJ.]
B
General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Act 1971 s. l5(a}-'lnsurer' whose business is voluntarily 'lround up or is wound up under order
of Court exemHed from operation of Act-Voh<nt,1/'y winding up of
business 1vhether includes cessatio11 of busines,j-'/I, :urer' and insurance
company, whether distinct-Sections 2(e) and 15(a) of Act whether
violative of Art. 14, Constitution of India.
Tho first petitioner was a public limited company incorporated under
the Indian Companies Act. The second and Jiird petitionei·s were share·
holders and directors of the first petitioner. Up to the end of March, 1971
the petitioner company was registered under the Indian Insurance Act,
1938. The registration authorised it to carry on the busine~ of general
insurance comprising fire ~nd miscellaneous insurance. On September 17,
1970 its Board of Directors resolved that it would cease to underwrite
any insurance business as from the close of business on Septem~r 30,
1970. On that very date it informed the Controller of Insurance of the
resolution and returned its certificate of registration for the year 1970
to the Controller of Insurance. After the close of business on September
30, 1970 it stopped doing any kind o'f general insurance business.. On
October 3. 1970 the Controller of Insurance returned the Registration
C'zrtifi~te to it with the remark that there was no provision in the Insurance Act for return of certificate. The Controller advised it not to
apply for renewal of certificate for the year 1971. On Febuary 2, 1971
the lfoard of Directors of the company passed a resolution cancelling all
policies with effect from March 10/12, 1971 ~ftcr giving due notice to
the policy-holders. Another resolution was passed terminating all re·
insurance treaties, both inward and outward, with effect from December
31. 1971. The company refunded to the policy-holders a sum of Rs. 48.000
on cancellation of their policies. The uncollected refund amount ~me to
Rs. 2013.98, On Febuary 16. 1971 the Controller of Insurance cancelled
the registration of the company .with dfect from April 5, •.971 under
section 3(4) (f) of the Insurance Act. The company reduced its staff.from
the month of September 1970. By the end of Februarv 1971 the total
c
D
E
F
staff cbnsisted of one officer. one clerk, one typist and one peon. ' Tn
respect of some of the policies cancelled cases were pending in court.
The Union of India, the first respondent, appointed a Custodian over
the undertaking of ·the company under s. 4 of the Gcccral Jnsuranc'
(Emergency Provisions) Ordinance I 971 on May 13, 1971. The said
Ordinance was· eventually re-enacted as General Insurance (Emerg'ocy
Provisions) Act. 1971. The Union of India issued also certain directions
on May 13, 1971 to regulaie the management of the undert9king by
the Custodian. The company filed petitions under article 32 of the Con·
situation claiming that the Act of 1971 was not applicable to it because
it was aa insurer whose business was being voluntarily wound
up in
terms of section 15(a) of the Act and therefore it could not be taken
over by the Central Government under s.. 3 of the Act. It was contended
that the words "whose business is being voluntarily wound up" in sec~
tion 15(a) also meant "whose business is being voluntarily brought to
G
H
NEPTuNE ASSURANCE CO,
A
B
c
D
F
G
H
v. UNION
941
a close or final settlement". The company also challenged the constitutionality of part of section 2(e) as also of section 15(a) of the Act,.
under Art. 14 of the Constitution of Inoia.
Held: per majority (Palekar, Beg and Dwivedi, JJ.)
(i) The appellant company could not get the benefit of s. !5(e) ami
was subject to the provisions of s. 3 of the Act which pro;ides for the
take over of insurance companies. [966 HJ
Section 2C of the Insurance Act has limited the denotation of the
\vnrd 'insurer' from the date of the commencemeni: of the Insurance
(Amendment) Act 1950. Section 2C(l) provides that "no person shall,.
atter the commencement of the Insuranee (Amendment) Act 1950 begin,
to carry on any any class of business in India and no insure~ carrying on any
class of insurance business in India shall, after the expiry of one year
from such commencement, continue to carry on any such business unless
he is :1 public company 1ncorporated in or out of India ot a society re·
gistered under ~ny law relating to Co-operative Societies Act, 1972.
In the result at the commencement of the Ordinance and the Act,.
·Insurer' includecl a public company either in<\irporate~. under the Companies Act or under a foreign Company Jaw and a Cooperative Society.
Although according to the proviso to s. 2C( 1) the Central Government may
hv a Gazette notification exempt from the operation of s. 2C(l) any per··
son or insurer for the purpose of carrying on general insurance business
for not more than three years at a time, no such notification was shown to
have been in fact issued. Cooperative Societies are under the various State
laws relating to Cooperative Societies wound up by an order of the Regis·
trar of Cooperative Societies. Therefore the word insurer in s. 15(a) of
the Act includes only two classes of persons : (a) public limited co1npany
incorporated under the Companies Act; (b) a public company incorporated
under a foreign company law. [960 H; 961 BCRF]
The twin expressions "being voluntarily wound up" and "being wound
up by a court" have acquired a crystallised meaning in the Company and.
'Insurer' included a public company either incorporated under the Com·
panies Act and the Insurance Act. In the Companies Act the expression
"voluntary winding up" means a winding up by a special resolution of
the company to that effect. Section 54 of the Insurance Act provides its
011·~ procedure for the winding up of aP. insurance company. According
t_o 1t. an insurance company shall not be wound up voluntarily "except
tor the purpose of effecting a1na1gamation or reconstruction of a company o~. the g'.ound that by reason of· its liability it cannot continue its
husmess . Parliament will be. presumed to know that the expression
··voluntmy windin~ up" and "winding up by the Court" have acquired a·
tcchmcal meanmg m our Company and Issurance jurisprudence [961 H·
962 A·DJ
'
Sections 433(c}, 560, 583(4.) (a) & 584 of the Companies Act and'
sections 2E. 3(5D), 53 of the Insurance Act make a clear distinction
holwecn .the. cessation of business of.a company and its voluntary winding
up or wmdmg up by an order of the court. Parliament will be presumed
!O be aware of the distinctions between the cessation of business by an
rnsurance public company and its voluotary winding up or winding up by
an order of the Court. There is nothing unequivocal in s IS(a) of tr.e·
;\ct to show that P~rliament intend,,d to depart from the t~hnical mea~
[Z~3o~'.~jse cxpresS1ons and to bid good-bye to the aforesaid distinction.
The appellant companv did not claim that it was being wourd up·
under s. 54 or s. ·'\8 of th e I nsurance Act. It could not voluntarily be-
942
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
\vound up otherwise than in accordance with s. 54 of the Jnsurancc Act. Jt
was accordingly difficult to comprehend the argument that the cessation
of business by the appellant company means volunt.iry winding up of
its business. This kind of voluntary \\'inding up of business is unknown
to the Insurance Act. [964 E]
The winding up of a foreign company by an order of the Court in
India really means the wipding up of its business in lndia. The word
'business' is not therefore redundant in s.15 (a). Jf Parliament really
meant that the first limb of s. 15(e) shouJd.aJso apply to as insurer who
is in the process of closing its business ·j1 should have expressed the first
limb in some such manner as any insurer "whose business is being closed''
or "is being wound up''. The constructio'n put for,vard by the appel·
!ant company assigns little significance. to the word "voluntarily" and
makes it n •urplusagc. [965 E·F]
Regina v. Bocml of Trade. i 1965] .I Q.B. 603 !ind Rajah of Vizianav. Of]icltll Receiv"·· Vidanagaram. [1962] Supp. J S.C.R. 344, re·
forrcd to.
·
-~rum
Sections 15(b) and 2(e) of the Act both refer to an insurance company which has ceased to do business for a certain period. Section 15(a)
should be construed· in the setting of~. 15(h) and 2(c)~ So construed,
it is difficult to believe that P-arliamcnt has not used the expression "whose
business is being volu11tarily wound up" in the tcch'lical sense. [966 DJ
One of the professed objects of the Act is "to protect the interest
of the policy-holders pendinµ nationali-;ation of the general insurance
business''. The interpretation !-.Uggestcd by the aP.pellant company \vould
defcur th al object. As5un1ing that ~. 1 S la) h sn'>ccptihle o·f two mcunings-the \\'itlcr and the narrov.cr (tJi.~ technical). the one which fructifies
the sai<l legislative object should be preferred. [966 F-Gl
(ii) The chall~nge to sc.:ti-:>ns 2(e) and 15(a) of the Act based on
Article 14 of the <;onstitution must fail...,f968 E]
When the registr<1tion of <1 con1p-nny has remained wholly cancelled for
six months fron1 the appointed day. the Controller may ;;1pply to the Court
for its winding up under s. 3(5D). As soon as the judicial process is ~ct
in motion. the company com.:s under th~ car.trot of the Court. The
Court's control \\'ill protect those policy holders who have got unsatisfied
On the other hand th: company whose
claims agr:in?-.t the co1nr:1n~
registration has remained '"holly c;;tnccllcd for less than six months can
revive itself. It cannot b.~ ,.·vund up by the Court at the instance of the
Controller. The claim-; of rhe policy-holders agl.linst such a company will
remain unprotected. 'fh1...· tukcovcr of. the undertaking of the, company
under the Act improves, hy rca~on of the Government's management, the
prosp:cts of their cl:iims suti~faction. It is also calculated to protect all
interests by applying after the takeover, if that course is deem.-cd necessary. to revive the business of the company. Section 2(e) is therefore not
Uiscriminatory. For the sr.me reasons s. 15(a) ~Jso is not discriminatory.
f96R B·E)
[As the attnck based on Art. 14 did not succeed. the Court found it
unnecessary rO deal wi.th the respondents' contention based on Art. 31A(b)
(d) of the Constitution.]
Per Sikri C.J. and Ray, J. (dissenting).
On the !-anguagc of section 15 (a) the con1pnny in the present case was
rin insurer -.vhose business \Vas being voluntarily wcund up. Ther.cfore the
Ordinti.ncc a11d the Act did not apply to the petitioner company. [955 G]
A
I!
c
I>
E
F
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. V. UNION
A
B
943
1t is important to notice that the Act uses the word 'insurer' and not
the words 'insurance company'. The Insurance Act has throughout the
Act used the words 'ir.surer' as well as 'insurance company'. The appropriate section in each instance will indicate as to why the Act uses the
word 'insurer' in one section and the words 'insurance company' in the
other. An insurer under the definition of the. Insurance Act is of wider
amplitude than an in~ur~nce company. It is an indiyidual or any unincorporated body of md1v1duals or a body corporate mcorporated und~r
the Jaw of a foreign country. From section 2C of the Insurance Act 1t
follows that an insurer as an individual may be allowed by the Government
to carry on general insurani.:e business undzr the Government exemption.
[948 DE & 949 C]
c
The Legislature knows the distinction between voluntary winding up
of an insurance company or winding up of it by a Court and an insurer
whose business is being voluntarily wound up or is wound up by Court.
Full effect is to be given to the words used in a legislative measure. The
words which arc not found ig the present legislative measure cannot be
substituted by words which are used in other statutes. That would be
defeating the purpose of the Act. The word 'insurer' cannot be read in
place ot msurance company. [952 G-H]
The provisions in the Insurance Act relating to voluntary winding up
D
and partial winding up of insurance companies indicate the
difference
between the concepts of voluntary winding up under the Insurance Act
and the Indian Companies Act and the business of an insurance company
being voluntarily wound up. A voluntary winding up under the Insurance
Act occurs for the purpose of effecting a reconstruction or amalgamation
or on the ground that a company cannot continue its business because it
E
cannot meet its liabilities. None of these contingencies is the same as
voluntarily winding up business. A partial Winding up of an insurance
company is winding up of a particular type of business. That company
does not cease to do business. Nor is the C'Ompany voluntarily wound up
in such a case. [953 D·E]
In :he pre1ent case the company resolved to wind up its business. The
company discontinued to do insurance business. The company canc.elled
all outstanding policies in the month of February, 1971. The company had
not undertaken any new business after 30 September, I970. (953 HJ
F
G
Afte: 30 S~ptember 197~ the company had taken steps to wind up
voluntarily all insurance business. The company informed the Controller
?f its .<lecis.ion to ~top doing insurance business. The company returned
its ~eg1Strat1on certificate. All t~se features lead to the inescapable concluS1on that the business of the msurer was being voluotarily wound up
Therefore the provisions contained in sectio11 15(a) will apply to th~
company whose business is being voluntarily wound up. (954 A·B]
. (ii) In the Ban.k Nationalisation case this Court said that the Court
will n?l, c'O.nc~ntratmg merely upo.n the technical objection of the action,
deny itself 1u11sd1ctton to grant relief to the share holders when the rights
of the shareholders as well as of the company are impaired The loc
standi of the petitioners could not be challenged. [957 C-0) ·
u.r
R. C. Cooper v. Union of India, (1970] 3 S.C.R. 530, referred to.
H
ORIGINAL JuR1SDICTION :
Writ Petition No. 425 of 1971.
P~tition under article 32 of the Constitution of India for the
enforcement of fundamental rights.
944
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
A
B. Divan and 1. N. Shroff, for the petitioners.
V. M. Tarkunde, G. Das and B. D. Sharma, for respondent
No. 1.
·
.
M. C. Setalvad, P. C. Bhartari, J. B. Dadachanji, O. C.
Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for respondent No. 2.
B
The Judgment of D. G. Palekar, M. H. Beg and S. N. Dwivedi,
JJ. was delivered by Dwivedi, J. The dissenting Opinion of S. M.
Sik~i, C. J. and A. N. Ray, J. was given by Ray, J.
RAY, J. This writ petition challenges the application of the
General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Ordinance 1971, the
General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Act 1971 as well as
the General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Amendment Act
1972 to the petitioner company. The petitioners are three in number, viz., the company and two Directors and shareholders.
c
The petitioners asked for a declaration that the order dated 13
May 1971 made in exercise of powers conferred by section 4(1) of
the General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Ordinance 1971
and the directions dated 13 May 1971 given by virtue of powers
conferred by section 4(3) of the General Insurance (Emergency
Provisions) Ordinance 1971 are illegal.
D
The paid up capital of the Neptune Assurance Company referred to as the company is Rs. 10,00,000. The petitioner Jalan is
a Director of the company. He holds 16, 725 ordinary shares of the
face value of Rs. 20 each. The petitioner Goenka is a Director of
the company. He holds 2,000 ordinary shares of the face valu~ of
Rs. 20 each.
E
The company carried on business as general insurers consisting of fire and miscellaneous insurance business. In the month of
September 1970 about 2343 insurance policies of the company F
were in force. On 17 September 1970 the Board of Directors of
the company resolved that the company would cease to underwrite
any insurance business as from the close of business hours on 30
September 1970. On 30 September 1-970 the company wrote to
the Controller of Insurance about the decision of the company to
cease to do business as on the close of business on 30 September c
1970. The company returned its registration certificate for the
current year to the Controller of Insurance. After close of business
on 30 September 1970 the company stopped doing all insurance
business.
On 3 October 1970 the Controller of Insurance returned to the
company its registration certificate. The Controller pointed out H
that there was no provision for return of certificate. The Controller advised the company not to apply for renewal of registration
certificates for the year 1971.
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. v, UNION (Ray, J.)
A
B
945
In the month of October 1970 there was an agreement between the comrany and the New Grert Insuranc.: Company of
India Ltd. referred to as the New Great in respect of an intended
transfer of the entire business of the company to the New Great.
The agreement provided inter alia ihc following features. Before
transfer of the entire general insurance busint".ss by the company
it wiil obtain the consent of the shareholders at the general
meeting far transfer of the general insurance business t'} the New
Great. The company shall prepare a detailed list of all the
claims received from policies issued by the company and which
claims are outstanding and/or pending on 30 September 1970
and give the same to· the New Great with all particulars.
c
On 20 October 1970 notice was given that an extra-ordinary
general meeting of the company would be held on 17 November
1970. The extraordinary general meeting was inter alia to transact
the business of the proposal for transfer of the company's insurance
-business and also of the liabilities in respect of claims relating to
the insurance business to the New Great upon the terms recorded
in the agreement dated 15 October 1970. The second business to
D
be transacted at the said extraordinary general meeting was to
reso:tve that pursuant to section 149 (2A) of the Companies
Act 1956 the company would do business as set out in clause III,
sub-clauses ( 8) and (9) of the Memorandum of Association of the
Company except Banking business. The company thought of investment and finance business. As required by section 173 of the
E Companies Act the company gave an explanato~y statement of the
extraordinary general meeting.
F
G
H
In the month of October 1970 ci:cular letters were issued to
all policy holders about the company ceasing to underwrite new
insurance business with effect from I October 1970. The company
sent to all policy holders letters to express their confirmation of the
arrangement for takiDg over the liabilities by the New Great. On
17 November 1970 there was an extraordinary general meeting
of the company. The resolutions which had been notified were
passed. It may be stated here that about 50 policy holders
demanded cancellation of policies on receipt of circular letters.
About 1,389 policy holders did not send any reply. The company
advised that they would not be completely discharged from their
lia~ilities unless and until all policy holders agreed to transfer
policies to the other insurance company or desired cancellation.
On 2 February 1971 there was a resolution of t·he Board of
Directors of the company cancelling the agreement dated 15
October 1970 entered into with the New Great. There was a
second resolution cancelling al! policies as from 10/12 March
l ~71 after giving due notice to all policy holders. There was a
third resolution to terminate all re-insurance treaties both inward
9 4 fi
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R.
A
and outward from 31 December 1970. Jhe company and the New
Great by mutµal consent cancelled the agreement dated 15 October
1970. In the month of February 197 l the company issued circular
letters to all policy holders effecting cancellation of all policies
under relevant clause in each policy. The company refunded to
policy holders the sum of Rs. 48,000 on cancellation of the
policies. The uncollected refund amounts to Rs. 2013.98.
B
On 16 February l 971 the Controller of Insurance affected
cancellation of the registration of the company with effect from
5 April 1971 under section 3(4)(F) of the Insurance Act, 1938.
On 22 February 1971 the company gave letters to Indian
Guarantee and General Insurance Co. and M/s India Re-Insurance Corporation Ltd. cancelling all re-insurance treaties with
,
effect from 31 December 1970.
c
The company alleged that it ceased to do all new insurance
business from the close of business from 30 September, 1970. The .
company refunded to policy holders premia excepting a small
sum of Rs. 2,000 which was not collected. The company reduced D
its staff from the month of September 1970. By the month of
February 1971 the total staff of the company was reduced to one
officer, one clerk, one typist and one peon drawing total emoluments of Rs. 1854.20 per month as contrasted with salary bill of
Rs. 7179.10 per month prior to the month of September 1970.
On these allegations the company said that its business was being
E:
voluntarily wound up since 30 Septemher 1970.
On 13 May 197 l the General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Ordinance 197 l referred to as the Ordinance was promulgated. On 13 May, 1971 an order under section 4(1) of the Ordinance was made by the Central Government appointing resppndent No. 2 as the custodian of the company. On the same day
directions were given by the Central Government under the
Ordinance in regard to the manugement of the undertaking of the
company.
On 17 June 1971 the General Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Act 1971 referred to as the Act was enacted. The Act
replaced the Ordinance. The Act was retrospectively brought into
force with effect from I '.I May 1971. The Ordinance as well as the
Act contain similar provisions.
The purpose of the aforesaid legislative measures was to provide for the taking over in the public interest of the management
of general insurance business pending nationalisation of such business. By general insurance business is meant under the Act fire.marine or miscellaneous insurance business, whether carried on
singly or in combination with one or more of them, but does not
include capital redemption business and annuity businees. An
G
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. V. UNION (Ray,
B
(:
0
E
J.)
947
insurer under the Act means an insurer as defined in the Insurance
Act 1938 referred to as.the Insurance Act who cafoes on general
insurance business in India, and includes an insurer whose registration under the Insurance Act has not remained wholly carn::elled for a period of six months inunediately before the appointed
day. Undertaking is defined by lhe Act to mean in relation to an
insurer incorporated outside India, the undertaking of that insurer
in India.
Section 3 of the Act statei. that as from the appointed day
which is l 3 May, 1971 the management of the undertakings of all
insurers shall vest in the Central Government. It is further provided that pending the appointment of a custodian the persons in
charge of the management of the undertaking shall be in charge
of the management for and on behalf of the Central Governmenl.
An insurer is forbidden without the previous approval of the
person specified by the Central Government in this behalf to mak~
any payment or grant any loan otherwise than in accordance with
the normal practice observed by him in respect of such matters
immediately before the appointed day. There is similar prohibition
to incur any expenditure from the assets appertaining to the undertaking, to transfer or otherwise dispose of any such assets, to invest
in any manner any moneys for.ming part of such assets, to acquire
any immova\lle property out of any moneys forming part of such
assets to enter into contract of service or agency. Every insurer is
also required to deliver tn the persons specified by the Central
Government various documents, namely, minutes book, current
cheque books, registration books containing particulars relating
to investments, loans, advances, promissory notes and certificates.
Section 4 of the Act is the other important provision. Under
that section the Central Government is empowered to appoint a
custodian for the management of the company. The Central Government is also empowered to issue directions to the custodian as
to his powers and duties in relation to the management of the
company.
c;
The Act provides for payment of compensation. The Act places
a bar against winding up of a company the management of which
is vested in the Central Government. After the appointed day the
Controller of Insurance shall not issue any new certificate of
insurance lo any person.
The crucial provisions are section 15(a) of the Act. It is enany
msurer whose business is being voluntarily wound up or is being
wound 11p by Court.
~cted that nothing contained in this Act shall apply to (a)
II
. ~he petitioners strongly rely on section 15(a) of the Act. The
petitioners allege that the business of the company was being
9-L52 !Sup.Cl/73
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973) 2 s.c.R.
voiuntarily wound up at all material times within the meaning of
the Ordinance and the Act. Therefore the petitioners contend that
the company is not .viihin the mischief of those legislatlve
measures.
The Government contention is that section 15 (a) of the Act
applies only to an insurance company which is being voluntarily
wound up and is being wound up by Court. It is emphasized that
when an insurance company or an insurer ceases to carry on any
particular kind of business it is not being voluntarily wound 'Up.
Voluntary winding up-or winding up by Court is said by the
Government to mean only winding up within the meaning of the
Indian Companies AJ:t and the Insurance Act. The meaning of
the words "an insurer whose business is voluntarily wound up
or is wound up by Court" is, according to the Government, an
insurance company which is bein11: voluntarily wound up or wound
up by CQur~.
At the threshold it is important to notice that the Act u~es the
word 'insur~r· and not the words "insurance company". The Insurance Act has throug~o!Jt the Act used the words "insurer" as well
as "insurance company". The appropriate section in each instance
will indicate as to why the Act uses the word "insurer" in one
section and the words "insurance company" in the other. An insurance company under the Insurance A~t means any insurer being
a company, association or partnership which may be wound up
under the Indian Compenies Act or to which the Indian Partnership Act applies. A partnership to which the Indian Partnership
Act Applies is not a company within the meaning of the Indian
Companies Act. The Insurance Act has yet inclu<led a partnership
within the meaning of an insurance company. An insurer, on the
0ther hand, under section 2 clause (9) of the Insurarice Act means
(a) any individual or un-incorporated body of individuals or body
corporate, incorporated under the law of any country other than
India carrying on business not being a person specified in subclause (c) of clause (9) of section 2, (b) any body corporate incorporated under any law for the time being in force in India and ( c)
any person who in India has a standing contract with underwriters
who are members of the Society of Llyod's whereby such person is
authorised within the terms of such contract to issue protection
notes, cover notes, or other documents granting insurance cover
on behalf of underwriters. Therefore an insurer under the definition of .the Insurance Act is of wider amplitude than an insurance company, it is an individual or any unincorporated body of
individuals or a body corporate incorporated under the Jaw of
a foreign country is an insurer.
Section ZC of the Insurance Act which ~ame into effect in
1950 enacted that after the commencement of the Insurance
(Amendment) Act 1950 which brought that section into existence
A
II
('
I>
F
G
11
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. l', UNION (Ray, /.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
949
no person after the expiry of one year from the commencement of
the Amendment Act s.!!all continue to carry on business unless he
is (a) a public company, or (b) a society registered under the Cooperative Societies Act, or (c) a body corporate incorporated under
the law of any country outside India. Therefore after 1950 :.n
individual will not be allowed to carry on business as an insurer.
There is however a proviso to section 2C of the 1950 Amendment
that .the Central Governn:ient may by notification in the Official
Gazette, exempt from the operation of section 20 any person or
iim;rer for the purpose of carrying on the business of granting
superannuation allowances and annuities as mentioned in section
2 (ii)(c) of the ,6,.ct or for the purpose of carrying on any general
insurance business. It is also provided th.at an insurer carrying on
general insurance business will not be entitled to such notification
being issued having effect for more than three years at any one
time. It, therefore, follows that an insurer as an individual may be
allowed by the Government to carry on general insurance business
under the Government exemption.
The various kinds of insurance business are fire insurance
business, general inslJrance business, life insurance busine~s .
.marine insurance business and miscellaneous insurance business
defined in clauses (6A), (6B), (II) (13A) and (13B) of section
2 of the Insurance Act. General insurance business means fire.
marine or miscellaneous insurance business whether carried O)l
singly or in combination with one or more of them.
'Section 3 of the Insurance Act speaks of registration of the
Se~tion 3 ( 4) of the
persons carrying on insurance business.
Insurance Act speaks of cancellation of the registration of an
insurer. Section 3(5C) of the Insurance Act states that where
the registration is cancelled the Controller may at his discretion
revive the registration. The instances where registration may be
revived are also specified. If the- registratio.i is cancelled on thl'
ground that the insurer is in liquidation the registration cannot bl'
rev!ved. It i~ noticeable. th,at t~e Insurance Act .speaks iif liquidal!on of an msurer. L1qu1dat10n here means wmding up of an
ins?ra~c.e company. Liqu~dation in the first place does nor apply
to md1v~duals or P,artnersh1ps, and secondly liquidation is not thl'
same thmg as ceasmg to carry on business. Under section 3 (50)
wh~re the ~egistration is cancelled the Controller may after the
expiry of stx months from the date on which the cancellation
took effect. aP,ply t? the Court to wind up the insurance companv
unles.s the reg1strat1on has been revived under sub-section (SC). !he Insurance Act in sections 53 to 60 speaks of winding up.
~cl!on 53 states that the Court may order the winding up of an
msurance .company. Section 54 speaks of the voluntary windin~
up of an msurance company. Section 55 deals with valuation ~f
950
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R.
liabilities in the winding up of an insurance company. Section
56 deals with application of sl'rplus assets of life insurance fund
in liquidation of insurance company or insolvency of insurer.
Liquidation is spoken of companies. Insolvency is spoken of
insurers. The distinction between an insurer and an insurance
company is apparent to emphasise the. difference between winding up and insolvency. Section 57 relates to winding up of
secondary companies. That section defines secondary company
to be an insurance company whose insurance business or any
part of the insurance business has been transferred under an
arrangement to a principal company. If the principal company
is wound up by or under the supervision of the Court the Court
shall order the secondary cc;mpany to be wound up in conjunction with the principal company.
Section 58 deals with partial winding up of imurance companies. Partial winding up happens when the affairs of an insurance company in respect of any class of business should be
wound up but any other class of business should continue to be
carried on by the company or transferred to another insurer. A
scheme for partial winding up is to be submitted to Court for
confirmation. A scheme shall provide for allocation and distribution of the assets and liabilities of the company. A scheme is
to contain provisions for altering the memorandum of the company with respect to its objects giving effect to the scheme when
the company carries on another class of business. There may be
winding up of the company when under the scheme it is propo_sed to transfer the business to another insurer. The provision
relating to the valuation of liabilities of insurers in liquidation
and insolvency and to the application of surplus assets of the life
insurance fund in liquidation are to apply to the winding up of
any part of the affairs of the company in case of any partial
winding up. An order of the Court confirming a scheme under
this Section whereby the memorandum is altered as to its objects
shall as respect the alteration have effect as if it were an order
confirmed under section 12 of the Indian Companies Act 1913
and the provisions of sections 15 and 16 of that Act shall apply
accordingly.
Section 59 speaks of return of deposits in the case of winding
up of an insurance company other than in a case to which section
58 applies. Section 60 states that on the winding up of an insurance company, the persons appearing by the books be entitled
to or interested in the policies granted by the company are to be
given notice of policy values. Section 61 states that where an
insurance company is in liquidation the Court may make an
order reducing the amount of the insurance contracts of the
company.
A
B
('
D
F
(;
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. V. UNION (Ray,
A
B
c:
J.)
951
The first noticeable feature is that sections 53, 5:4 and 58 of
the Insurance Act which deal with winding up by Court, volu1.1tary
winding up and partial winding up respectively speak only Qf
insurance company. There are some sections which speak of
insolvency of any other insurer. These sections are 55, 56 and
61 of the Insurance Act which deal respectively with valuation
of liabilities, application of surplus assets of life insurance fund
and powers of the Court to reduce contracts of insurance. In•
solvency of other insurer will refer to Co-9petative Societies,
inc!ividuals and companies which are incorporated outside India.
Under the Insurance Act these are not insurance companies. A
foreign company which is in voluntary liquidation or is being
wound up by Court will be an insurer within the meaning of the
197 l Act and will also be described as an insurer who is insolvent. These sections indicate the distinction between an illsurance company and an insurer.
The second important matter to be noticed in all the sections relating to wi[lding up i~ the Insurance Act is that volunD tary winding up and partial winding up of insurance companies
is not the same as under the Indian Companies Act. A voluntary
winding up under the Insurance Act is impermissible except for
the purpose of effecting an amalgamation or a reconstruction of
the company or on the ground that by reason of its liabilities it
1 cannot continue its business.
The provisions of the Indian Companies Act do not apply to such voluntary'winding up of an inE
surance company. Under the Indian Companies Act 1956 a
company may be voluntarily wound up if the compaQy passes
special resolution that the company be wound up voluntarily.
The special provisions of the Insurance Act regarding voluntary
windin6 up rule out the application of the provisions of the
J
ndial! Companies Act. Amalgamation and Reconstruction
F
under the Indian Companies Act are a different matter. Under
section 394 of the Indian Companies Act a transferer company
on Amalgamation may be dissolved without any winding up.
Again under section 392 of the Indian Companies Act 1956 the
Court at the time of sanctioning a compromise· of an arrangement may make an order winding up the company. It will be
G treated as winding up by Court. These provisions indicate that
voluntary winding up of co!fipanies under the fndian Companies
Act and the voluntary winding up of insurance companies under
the Insurance Act are not the same.
H
Next comes :he partial winding· up of Insurance companies.
Companies Act. A
partial wmdmg up under the Insurance Act is treated as an
alteration of a memorandum of the company. A partial winding
up under the Insurance Act will in relation to that part which is
The~e is .no. such provision in the Indian
952
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R,
wound up attract the provisions of the Insurance Act regarding
valuation of liabilities and application of surplus assets in liquidatioli or insolvency.
The Government relied on sections 53; 54 and 5.8 of the
Insurance Act in supp<>rt of the contention that the winding up
or a voluntary winding up will mean only voluntary winding up
or w~ding ·UP.. of the company and will never mean the voluntary
cesser of doing any kind of insurance business by a company. It
is said that if a business can be said to be voluntarily wound up
without a voluntary winding up of the company the sections will
be robbed .of their full effect. Reliance was also placed by the
Government on section 2D of the Insurance Act which state-;
that ·every insurer shall be subject to all the provisions of the
Act in relation to any class of insurance business so long as his
liabilities in India in respect of business of that class remain unsatisfied or not otherwise provided for. The Government leaned
on this sec.lion to emphasize that if a company ceasing to do any
busin~ss could be said to be one whose business was being voluntarily wound up it could not again be said to be subject to the
provisions of the Act on the ground that the liabilities remain
unsatisfied.
The Insurance Act speaks of winding up of insurance companies. . The legislature has yet in the General Insurnace (Emergency Provisions) Ordinance .I 971 and the General Insurance
(Emergency Provisions) Act 1971 not spoken of an insurance
comp~ny being voluntarily wound up or wound up by Court.
On the contrary, the legislative measures in the present case have
used the words "an insurer" whose business is voluntarily wound
up or is being wound up. by a Court. In this context, it may be
state_d that when the Life Insurance (Emergency Provisions) Act
1956 came into existence both the Life Insurance (Emergency
Provisions) Ordinance 1956 am! its successor the Life Insurance
(Emergency Provisions) Act 1956 used identical words that
"nothing in the Ordinance or in the Act shall apply to any insurer whose business is voluntarily wound up or is wound up
under order of Court". The legislature knows the distinction
between voluntary winding up of an insurance company or winding up of it by a Court and an insurer whose business is, being
voluntarily wound up or is wound up by Court. Full effect is to
be given to the words used in a legislative measure. The words
which are not found in the present legislative measures cannot
be substituted by words which are used in other statutes. That
would be defeating the entire purpose, of the Act. The word
"insurer" cannot be read in place of insurance com9any.
An insurer is not for all purposes the same as an insurance
company. An individual is an insurer. A co-operative society
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO.
ll
c
u
E
F
G
H
v. UNION (Ray, J.)
953
is an insurer. A con}pany incorporated in a foreign country and
carrying on business in India is an insurer. A co-operative
society is not wound up under the Indian Companies Act. A
co-operate society is dissolved under the provisions of the Cooperative Societies Act. The consequence of dissolution of a cooperative society is the winding up of the society by the appointment of a liquidator. A company incorporated in a foreign
country is neither voluntarily wound up nor woun4 up by Court
like other companies under the Indian Companies Act. A foreign
company may under section 584 of the Indian Companies Act
be wound up as an unregistered company. Therefore the words
·'an insurer whose business .is being voluntarily wound up or is
being wound up by a Court" will refer not only to an insurance
company incorporated in India ceasing to do insurance business
but also to individuals or co-operative societies or foreign companies in the same position.
The provisions in the Insurance Act relating to voluntary
winding up and partial winding up of insurance companies indicate the difference between the concepts of voluntary winding up
under the Insurance Act and the Indian Companies Act and the
business of an insurance company being voluntarily wound up.
A voluntary winding up under the Insurance Act occurs for the
purpose of effecting a reconstruction or amalgamation or on the
ground that a company cannot continue its business because it
cannot meet its liabilities. None of these contingencies is the
same as voluntarily winding up business. A partial winding up
of an insurance company. is winding up of a particular type of
business. That company does not cease to do business. Nor is
the company voluntarily wound up in such a case.
The deliberate cb.oice of words in the Ordinance and the Act
of 1971 in the present case indicates that the legislature did not
by the crucial words in section 15 (a) mean voluntary winding
up oJ insurance companies. The legislature meant also insurers
who are not necessarily insurance companies. The concept of
voluntarily winding up business is more akin to individuals or
other persons winding up business than to companies being
voluntarily wound up under the provisions of the Insurance Act.
The voluntary winding up under the Insurance Act is applicable
not only to reconstruction or to amalgamation but to a company
being unable to continue business because of liabilities. The idea
of business being voluntarily wound up is quite a different matter.
In the present case, the company resolved to wind up its
business. The company discontinued to do insurance business.
The company cancelled all outstanding policies in the month of
February, 1971. The company has not undertaken any new busi-
954
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
ness after 30 September 1970. After 30 September 1970 the
company had taken steps to wind up voluntarily all insurance
business. The company informed the Controller of its decision to
stop doing insurance business. The company returned its registration certificate. All these features lead to the inescapable
conclusion that the business of the insurer was being voluntarily
wound up. Therefore, the provisions contained in section 15 (a)
will apply ti) the company whose business is being voluntarily
wound up.
The provisions in section 20 of the Insurance Act show that
an insurer is subject to liabilities under the Act. The company
does. not dispute that proposition. The company has made provisions to meet those liabilities. The company is required under
six:tion 7 of the Insurance Act to keep in deposit with the
Reserve Bank of India sums of money. Under section 9 where
an insurer has ceased to carry on in India all classes of insurance
business and his liabilities in India in respect of all classes of
insurance .business have been satisfied or are otherwise provided
for, the Court may, on the application of the insurer, order the
return to the insurer of the deposit made by him. Section 10
provides that where an insurer carries on business of more than
one of the classes of insurance business he shall keep a separate
account of all receipts and payments. These provisions show
that liabilities under the Act are to be satisfied and provided for
over and above .the deposit under section 7 of the Insurance Act
even. after the business has been voluntarily wound up.
Counsel for the Government relied on the decision of this
Court in The Vanguard Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd ..
Madras v. M/s Fraser and Ross & Anr.(') in order to find out
the meaning of closing of business of any insurer. The company
in that case carried on various kinds of insurance business other
than life insurrtnce business. - The shareholders of the company
passed a resolution by which the business was to be closed. On
the application of the company the Controller cancell~d the certificate· of business. Thereafter complaints are received by the
Government against the company. The Government passed an
order under section 33 of the Insurance Act directing the Controller to investigate the affairs of the company. The company
challenged the legality of the order on the ground that the Government had no jurisdiction to pass an order. The contention of
the company }Vas that section 33 spoke of an order of investigation by the Central Government of the affairs of an insurer who.
as defined in section 2 ( 9), .is one who is actually carrying on the
business of insurance. Section 20 of the Insurance Act was contended to be applicable to cases where an insurer was carrying on
(1l [196013S.C.R.857.
.\
B
[)
G
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE CO. V. UNION (Ray, J.)
A
B
c
955
different classes of business and had closed some of them but
not alt of them.. Section 20 was also said by the company to be
not applicable as the company's liabilities did not remain unsatisfied. This Court held that section 33 of the Insurance Act refers
not only to a person who is carrying on the business of insurance
but also to one who has substantially closed it. Section 20 was
also held to be applicable to cases where an insurer who was
carrying on different classes of business but closed alt of them.
Section 20 was also held to apply to make provision for liabilities· of the· company over and above the deposit. The ·words in
section 33 are that the Central Government may, at any time,
direct the Controller to investigate the affairs of an insurer. The
meaning ascribed to a word in the definition clause was held by
this Court to be not inflexible because there might be sections in
the Act where the meaning might have to be departed from.
This Court in the Vanguard Fire & General Insurance. Co.
Ltd. case (supra) said that the word 'insurer' has been used
in some sections to mean not only a. person carrying on an insuD rance but also one who intends to carry on the business of insurance but has not actually started it and also a person who was
· carrying on. the business of insurance but has ceased to do so.
Section 9 of the Insurance Act which speaks of refund of deposit furnishes an instance of the Act applying the word 'insurer
in relation to one who has ceased to carry on ·business. Section
55 of the Act also speaks of the insolvency of an insurer. An
E
insurer in section 20 of the Act is an insurer who was carrying
on the business of insurance but has closed it. Section 20 was
held to dispel all doubts that the word 'insurer' would not be
referable to one who ceased to carry on any business inasmuch
as all the provisions of the Act applied to an insurer so long as
his liabilities remained unsatisfied or otherwise not provided for.
F Some provisions_of the Insurance Act will apply to insurers who
ceased to carry on business.
It was said on behalf of the Government that if section 15 (a~
applied to the case of an insurer whose business is being volun,
tarily wound up or is being wound up by Court -it might not be
applicable
to the case of an insurance company which was bein~
G
voluntarily wound up under the provisions of the Insurance Ac!:
It i~ for the legislature to legislate as to the dass to which th~
~ct will apply. On the language of section 15(a) the company
m the present case is an insurer whose business is beina0 voluntarily wound uj>. Therefore the Ordinance and the A~t do not
. apply to- the petitioner company.
H
. I~ was also. contended on behalf of the insurance compam·.
that 1~ t~c Ordmance and the Act applied Article 31 A of the
Const1tut1on could not protect the taking over ot the manaee-
.
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
956
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
ment of the company. Under Article 31 A (I ) (b) the taking over
of management of the property for a limited period either in public interest or in order to secµrc the proper management of the
property is protected. It cannot be said in the present case that
•.he management was taken over for a limited period nor was it
said on behalf of the Government that Article 31A(l)(b)
applied.
On behalf of the Government it was said that Article 31 A ( l )
I d) applied because the legislative measures in the present case
modified the rights of the managing agents. It was also said on
behalf of th~ petitioners that Article 14 was offended. In view
of our conclusion that the Ordinan~e and the Act do not apply
to the petitioner company it is not necessary to express any opinion on the two contentions based on those two Articles.
The Government contended that the petitioner company
could not invoke fundamen\al rights. Apart from the company
th~ other petitioners are two shareholC.:er and
Directors.
In
/?. C. Cooper v. Union of illdia(') which is referred to as the
/lank Natio11alisation case the petitioner fulfilled three capacities.
He was a shareholder, a Director ·and a holder of deposit of current account in the Bank. The locus stand! of the petitioner was
d1allenge<l in the Ba11k Natio11alisation case (supra) on the
ground that no fundamental right of the petitioner was directly
impaired by the Ordinance or the Act or any action taken thereunder. The petitioner in that case claimed that rights guaranteed under Articles l 4, I 9 and 31 of the Constitution were impaired. The ruli'ng of this Court in the Bank Nationalisation(')
l':P. c \Vas th is :
''A
111ca~urc cxe~utive
or legislative
111ay
i1npair
the rights of the company alone, and not of its shareholders: it may impair the rights of the shareholders
and not of the company; it may impair the rights of the
shareholders as well as of th~ company. Jurisdiction
of the Court to grant relief cannot be denied. when by
State action the rights of the individual shareholder
are impaired if that action impairs the rights of the
company as well. The test in determining whether the
shareholder's right is impaired is not formal; it is essentially qualitative: if the State action impairs the rights
of the shareholders as well as of the company, the
Court will not. concentrating merely upon that tech·
nical operation of the action. deny itself jurisdiction to
grant relief".
(l) (t970J J s.c.R. SJJ.
I).
E
t
1
l
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co.
A
B
c
I)
I',
UNION
(Dwivedi, J.)
957
It follows tha_t the Court finds out whether the legislative
measure directly touches the company of which the petitioner is
a shareholder. A shareholder is entitled to protection of fundamental rights. That individual right of a sharehold,er is not lost
by reason of the fact that he is a shareholder. The reason why
th~ shareholders' fundamental rights are protected is that when
their fundamental rights as shareholders arc impaired by State
action the Court applies the qualitative test on )he ratio that the
shareholders' rights an: equated to and correspond to the rights
of the company. The shareholde•s own the property through
the company. The shareholders carry on business through the
medium of the company. The shareholders' investment in the
shares is affected by the State action or the legislative measure.
In the Bank Nationalisation case (supra) this Court said
that the Court will not, concentrating merely. upon the technical
objection of the action, deny itself jurisdiction to grant relief to
the shareholders when the rights of shareholders as wen· as of the
company are impaired. The loc11s standi of the petitioners cannot be challenged.
For these reasons, the petitioners succeed._ There will be an
order quashing the orders dated 13 May 1971 being Exhibits
·K' and 'L' to the petition. A· mandamus will also go requiring
the respondents to forbear from acting on and giving effect to
the two orders. Parties will pay and bear their owrt costs.
F
.
G
Dw1vrn1, J .-There are three petitioners in 'this petition under
Article 32 of the Constitution: (I) The Neptune Assura,nce Company Ltd. (2) Sanwar Prashad Jain and (3) Krishna Murari. The
lirst petitioner is a public company incorporated under the Indian
Companies Act. The second and third petitioners are shareholders and Directors of the first petitioner (hereinafter called
the Ncrtunc Assurance). The Union of India, the first respondent. appointed a custodian over the undertakina of the
1\'cptune Assurance under s. 4 of the General "Insurance
( Emer~cncy P~<wisions) OrdiMnce. 1971 on May 13, 1971.
The said Ordmance was eventually re-enacted as General
Insurance (Emergency Provjsions) Act, 1971 (hereinafter called
the Act). The Custodian appointed under the Ordinance is
continuing to manage the undertaking by virtue of s. 4 of the Act.
The Union ~f India also issued certain directions on May 13
19'. l. Those directions regulate the management of the underta],;;~~g of the Neptune Assurance b;r the Custodian. The
H J>~lltmners challenge the validity of the aforesaid ordu and direcfion~. They also question the constitutionality of a part
of s. 2 ( e) an~ s. 15 (a) of ~he. ~ct. They pray for the quashing
nf the aforesaid order and dtrecllon and for a direction to the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973) 2 s.c.R.
A
respondents to hand over charge of. the undertaking of the Neptune
Assurance to the petitioners.
Upto the end of March, 1971, the Neptune Assurance was
registerec;l under the Indian Insurance Act, 1938. The registration
authorise<' it to carry on ·the business of general insurance comprising fire and miscellaneous insurance. On September 17, 1970,
its Roard of Directors resolved that it would cease to underwrite
any insurance business as from the close of business hours on
September 30, 1970. On that very date it informed the Controller of
Insurance of the resolu1ion and returned its certificate of registration for the year 1970 to the Controller o£ Insurance. After
·the dose of business on September 30, 1970, it stopped doing
.any l:ind of general insurance business.
On October 3, 1970, the Controller of Insurance retnrned the
registration certificate to it with the remari.: that there was no
provision in the Insurance Act for return of a certificate. The
Controller advised it not •to apply for renewal of certificate for
the year 1971.
In October 1970 there was an agreement between it and the
.New Great Insurance Company of India Ltd. with respect to transfer of its entire business to the New Great Insurance Company of
fodia Ltd. On October 20, 1970 nmice was given to the share.holders of the Neptune Assurance that an extraordinary general
meeting would be held on November 17, 1970 to consi1er the
proposal of transferring its insurartce business and liabilities to
the New Great Insurance Company of India Ltd. The agenda
.of the meeting included certain other matters for consideration.
It is not necessary to mention them.
On.November 17, 1970, in the extra-ordinary general meeting
·the aforesaid resolution regarding transfer of. business and
liabilities was passed. In the month of October 1970 a letter
was sent to all the policy-holders informing them that the Neptune
Assurance had cea>ed to underwrite new insurance business with
effect from October 1, 1970. It also sought their approval to
transfer of business and liabilities of the Neptune Assurance to
·the New Great Insurance Company of India Ltd.
. About 50 policy-holders demanded cancellation of the policies.
About 1389 policy-holders did not send any reply. n appears
that the Neptune Assurance was advised that it would not be'
completely discharged from its liabilities unles~ and u~til all the
policy-holders had agreed to the transfer of its b~mess and
liabilities to •the New Great Insurance Company of India Ltd. So
·on February 2, 1971, the Board of Director§ of the Neptune
Assurance cancelled the agreement with the New Great Insurance
·Company of India Ltd. The Board of Directors also passed a
ll
c
I)
'£
F
G
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co. v. UNION
A
(Dwivedi, J.)
959
resolution cancelling all policies with effect from March 10/ 12,
1971 after giving due notice to the policy-holders. Another
resolution was passed tem1inating all re-insurance treaties, both
inward and outward, with effect from December 31, 1971.
B
As the agreement was cancelled, it did not have any effect.
In February, 1971 the Neptune Assurance issued circular letters
to all policy-holders cancelling the policies in accordance with
the cancellation clause tn each policy. The Neptune Assurance
refunded to policy-holders a sum of Rs. 48000 on cancellation,
of their policies. The uncollected refund amount comes to
Rs. 2013.98.
c
•
On February 16, 1971, the Controller of Insurance cancelled
the registration of tht: Neptune Assurance with effect from April
5. 1971. He cancelled the registration under s. 3 ( 4) (fl of the
Insurance Act. On February 22. 1971, the Neptune Assurance
sent letters to the Indian Guarantee and General Insurance Company and M/s India Re-Insurance Corporation Ltd. cancelling all
re-insurance treaties with effect from December :u. f-970.
D
The Neptune Assurance reduced its staff 'trom the month of
September 1970. By the end of February 1971 the total staff
consisted of one officer, one clerk, one typist and one peon. The
total emoluments of the staff upto September 1970 were Rs. 7179. l
per month, but after that month they have come down to
Rs.
1154.20 per month.
E
It is not disputed that many claims which 'halilaccrued before
the cancellation of policies are still outstanding against the
Neptune Assurance. Some cases are pending in courts with
respect to some of them.
The first argwnent is that as the Neptune Assurance had ceased
F 1o do general insurance .business several months before the commencement of tl!e Ordinance and the Act, it is out of the purview
of the Act by virtue of s.15 (a) of the Act. It cannot be taken
over by the Central Government under s. 3 of the Act. The rival
contention of the respondents is 1hat it is not covered by the provisions of s.15 (a) and that accordingly it can be taken over by
G the Central Government under s. 3. So the real issue is; what is
the true construction of s. 15(a)? Section 15, in so· far it is
relevant for this case, provides;
H
"Nothing contained in this Act shall apply to(a) any insurer whose business is being voluntarily
wound up or is wound up by a court;
(b) any insurer to whom the Insurance Act does not
apply by reason of the provisions contained in
section 2E thereof : "
960
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973)2 S.C.R.
.
The argument of the Neptune Assurance is that the expression·
"whose business is being voluntarily wound up" in cl. (a) aJso
signifies the voluntary cessation of business by an insurance company. One of the dictionary meanings of the word "wind up" is
'"to bring to a close; to bring an affair to a final settlement" (See
Shorter Oxford Dictionary, 3rd edition). Adopting that n:eaning,
counsel for the Neptune Assurance submits th;it the expressions
"whose 1*!siness is being voluntarily wounlf up" would also mean
"wh&se business is 'being voJun1arily brought to a close or to a
finai settlement".
·
The true meaning oi cl. (a}' of s. 15 is to be determined in the
light of its language, scheme and setting.
Language and setting : The last word in cl. (a) is 'Court'.
This word is not defined jn the Qrdinance and the Act. Bat s.
2(i) oi the Act provides that the words and expressions used in
the Act 'but not defined and defined in the Insurance Act have
the meaning assigned to them in that Act. Section 2 ( 6) of the
Insurance Act defines .the word 'Court' as the principal Civil Court·
,of original jurisdiction in a district, and incluges the High Court
in exercise of its ordinary original civil jurisdiction. The word
'·insurer" in clause (a) of s. 15 ,is defined ins. 2(e) of the Act.
For our present purposes it is sHfficient to say that it means an
insurer as defined in the Insurance Act, who carries on general
insurance business in India. Section 2 ( 9) of the fosurance Act
defines "insurer" as (a) any individual or unincorporated body
of :ndividuals .ai; body corporate incorporated under the law of
ar.y country otner than India, carrying on insurance business in
India, or having his or its principal place of business or domicile
in India or employing a representative or maintaining a place of
business in India with the object of obtaining insurance business;
(b) any body corporate incorporated under any law for the time
being in force in India and carrying on business of insurance.
There is yet another class of insurer, but we are not concerned with
it in this case. The word "lnsuran~e Company" is defined in
s. 2(8) of the Insurance Act as any insurer being a company, or
partnership which may be wound up under the Companies Act,
or to which the Partnership Act applies. Tt is apparent from the
definition of 'insurer' in "the Insurance Act that an insurer may be
an individual, a partnership firm, an association of persons and
a company incorporated in or outside India.
Section 20 of the Insurance Act, however, has limited the
denotation of "insurer" from the date of the commencement of
the Insurance (Amendment) Act, 1950. Section 2c(I) provides
that no person shall, after the commencement of the Insurance
(Amendment) Act, 1950 begin to carry on any class of business
in India and no insurer carrying on any class of insurance busi-
A'
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co.
A
B
c
D
E
v. UNION (Dwivedi, J.)
961
ness in India shall after the expiry of one year from su~h con~
mencement, continue to carry on any &uch \:1Usiness unless h~ 1s
a puouc company incorporated in or out of India or a society
registered under any law relating to Co-operative Societies Act.
19li In the result, at the commencement of the Ordiance and
the Act, ·Insurer· included a public company either incorporated
under the Companies Act or under a foreign company law and
a co-operative society. An individual, a partnership Jinn, and
an unincorporated assodation of persons could not be an insurer
at the time of the commencement of the Ordinance and the Act.
According to .the proviso to s. 2C( I) the Central Government may
by a Gazette notification, exempt from the operation of s. 2C( I)
any person or insurer for the purpose of carrying on genera I
insurance business for not more than three years at any one time.
Counsel for the Neptune Assurance has admitted that the Central
Government has issued no such notification. In any case no
such notification has been shown to us.
Co-operative Societies are excluded from the ambit of 'Insurer·
in s. 15 (a). We have examined the provisions of the Co-operative
Societies Act, 1912, and various State laws relating to cooperative societies. It appears from those laws that a co-operativ
society can neither be voluntarily wound up nor wound up by a
Comt. It is wound up by an order of the Registrar of Co-operative
Societies. It is significant to notice that 1he cessation of busin~''
by a co-operative society is one of the grounds for its being wound
up b.y ~n order of the Registrar. So various State law dealing with
co-operative societies make a dis1inction bet~een the cessation of
business by a co-operative society and its wi!lding up by an order
of the Registrar. When a co-operative society has cessed to do
business, it cannot be said that it is voluntarily wound up.
To sum up, the word 'insurer' in s. 15(a) of the Act inclucks
only two classes of persons : (a) a public company incorporated
under the Compenies Act; and (2) a public company incorporated
under a foreign Company Jaw.
G
The next important word in s. 15(a) is "business". It is not
disputed that it means the entire business ot an insurer.
It will follow from this discussion that cl. (a) s. 15 may
be paraphrased in this manner; "Any public company incorporated
under the Companies Act or under a foreign company law who'c
entire business is being voluntarily wound up by-·a Court."
H
Turning now to the crucial words "being volutarily wound
up'' and "being wound up by a court", it is necessary to observe
.that these twin expressions have acquired a crystallised mcarung
m the Company and Insurance jurisprudence. They have been
962
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R,
used in that sense in the Companies Act and the Insurance Act.
In the Companies Act the expression "voluntary winding up"'
means a winding up by a special ,resolution of a company to that
effect. Similarly, the expression "winding up by the court" means
winding up by an order of the Court in accordance with s. 433
of the Companies Aot. Section 53(i) o.f the Insuranre Act
provides that an insurance company may be wound up in accordance with the Companies Act. Section 53(2) supplements the
grounds for the winding up o,f an insurance company by 1he Court.
~ection · 54 does not apply the provisions o{ the, Companies Act
m rega~d to the voluntary winding up of an insurance company.
It ~rov•des, its own procedure fpr ,clhe .v?lu.nt~cy, winding up of
an lllSurancc company. Accordll)g ,to, it, an msurance company
'hall not be wound up voluntarily "except for the purpose of effect-·
ing amalgamati?n or reconstrucd0n of a company . or. on the
ground that,,:p~ireasQt:i 'Cfjts ·lia~ilil~.~~~'a'!mtit\-i;Qntihu~ ifs busi-
A
8
('
nes~~!;.; ,,;flt~:·~!lJ?J,;i~~.:~~;~:.~i~;;;,'),~'.';:; ;''../1'.'.t,,,' .. ,'., .
· .i\ citfre'n i~~~ulric<i:io~o«i~~ti~w~s~•·iduhir:y,; ·A
Jortiori, Parliament will' be presumed to know fliat the expressions
··voluntary winding up" and "winding up by the Court" have ace
D
a
qui~ technical nieaning'in our Company_. and Insura.ncejurisprudence.' Like the c<>"operative society Jaws, the Companies Act and
lhe Insurance Act also inake a distinction between the cessation
of business by a company and its voluntary winding up or winding
up by an order of the Court. Section 433 ( c) of the Companies
Acl provides that a company miiy be wound up by the Court, if
it "suspends its business for a whole year." Section 560 deals
with the powers of the Registrar to strike a defunct company off
the register. It provides that where the Registrar has reasonable
cause to bi:Iieve that a company "is not carrying on business" .he
shall proceed to strike its name off the register in the manner
provided therein. According to s. 51l3 ( 4 )(a) on a registered
company may be wound up if it "has ceased to car~y on business."
Section 584 provides that where a company which has been incorporated outside India and which has been carrying on business
in India "ceases to carry on business in India", it may be wound
up as an unregistered company.
Section 2E of the Insurance Act provides that, where an insurer as defined in paragraph (i) and (iiJ of sub-~I. (a) of cl. 9
of s. 2 in relation to any class of insurance busipess "has ceased
before the commencement of that Act to enter ipto any new
contracts of that class of business," the lnsuranee Act. shall not
apply to him. According to s. 3(5D) where the registration of ~n
insurance public company stands cancelled for more than six
months from the date of its cancellation, .the Controller of Insurance may apply to the Court for an order to wind it up. The re-
E
F
G
H
'
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co. v. UNION
(Dwivedi, J.)
963
A
gistration may be cancelled inter alia •. on the ground that th~ insurance public company. has ~ot ~pplied for the ren~wal of ~ts registration. When the registration is cancelled, ~e company JS forbidden from entering into any new contracts of msurance. So when
an insurance company has ceased to do the business of ~uran.ce
for more than six months from the date of the cancellation of its
B registration, it may be wound up by an orde~ of the Court .1t the
instance of the Controller. As already menuoned s. 53 ( 1) of
the Insurance Act provides that an insurance public company
may be wountl up in accordance with the Companies Act. We
have already mentioned that s. 433 ( c) of the Companies Act
provides for the winding up of a company when it "suspends its
c business for a whole year." It would follow from the foregoing
provisions that the Insurance Act also makes a distinction b\etw~n
the cessation of insurance business by an insurance public
company and its voluntary winding up or winillng up b(y an order
of the Court. Indeed, the cessation of its busine.ss for a whole year
or the cessation of its business for more tllan six months from
the date of the cancellation of its registration tor not applying for
D
renewal thereof is one of the grounds for its winding up by the
Court. Parliament will be presumed to be aware of the
distinction between the cessation of business by an insurance
public company and its voluntary winding up or winding up by
an order of the Court. There is nothing unequivocal in s. 15 (a)
of the Act to show that Parliament intended to depart from the
E technical meaning ol the "voluntary winding up" and "winding
up by the Court" and to bid a· good-by to the distinction in our
Company and Insurance jurisprudence between mere cessation
of business by a company and its voluntary winding up or winding
up by an order of the Court.
F
G
H
Section 15.(a) consists of two limbs : (a) an insurer "whose
bus!ness !s ~Ing voluntarily wound up"; (2) ~n insurer "whose
business 1s be mg wound up by a Court". The word "wound up"
forms part of both limbs. It is reasonable to assume that it
is u~ed in the same sense in b!>th limbs. It is not and cannot
~e _disputed that \n the second limb it is used in the sense in which
1t 1s understo.od m our Company and Insurance jurisprudence.
!he Companies Act and the Insurance Act provide for the winding ~p of a company by an order of the Court. Neither of them
proy1des for the winding up of anything other than the entire
busin~ss of a company by an order o.f the Court. The specified
cas~ m s. 58 of the l?surance Act of partial winding up of any
particular c1ass of business by preparing scheme for confirmation
by the cou~t :an_not be des7ribed as 'windin!! up by the titdet
of th7. court, ~1thm the meaning of s. 53 .. We \,ave earlier shown
~liat insurer m s; 15(a) means a public company incorporated
m and out of India and none else. Accordingly in the second
IO-L521Sup.CI/73
'
964
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.lt,
limb the expression "whose 1*Jsiaess is being wound up by the
Coun" must be construed to mean the winding up of an
insurance public company by an order ol! the Court. This
should settle the meaninl( of the word "wounc! up" in the first
limb also. The phrase "voluntarily wound up" in the first limb
would mean the voluntary winding up of an insurance public
company in accordance with s. 54. of the Insurance Act.
A company is a creature of statute. Its birth, progress, and
extinction are all controlled by the sta!lute. As the Neptune
Assurance is carrying on the business of General insurance, it
is controlled by the Insurance Act read wi'lh the Companies Act.
Seotion 54 of the Insurance Act provides for the voluntary
winding up of an insurance company. According to it, an
insurance company may be voluntarily wound up only in three
circumstances. Those circumstances are: (I) amalgamation, (2)
reC'.ons'truction of the company; or ( 3) the inability to carry on
business on account of its liabilities. Section 58 (I) oi the
Insurance Act provides for the winding up of only a class of an
il!iurance business of a company in certain circumstances provided
a scheme for that purpose is submitted to and confirmed by the
Coun. The Neptune Assurance has not claimed before us that
it is being wound up uncler s. 54 ors. 58. The Neptune Assurance
could not voluntarily be wound up otherwise. than in accordance
with s. 54. It is accordingly difficU!t to comprehend the argument that the cessation of business by he Neotune Assurance
means voluntary winding up ol. its business. This kind of
voluntary winding up of business is unknown to the Insurance
Act.
It is said that 011r construction makes redundant the word
"business" ins. 15(a). But there is no redundancy. A company
which is being wound up voluntarily or by the coun may, without the least violence to language, be described as a company
whose business is being voluntarily wound up or is being wound
up by the Court. Winding up of a company is, in effect, the
same as the winding up of the entire business of the company.
·Both expressions in substance convey the same sense. Moreover,
the expression "any insurer whose business is being wound up
by the court" is more appropriately applicable 10 the context of
a foreign company whose business in India is being wound up
by the Cou~ under s. 584 of the Companies Act, 1956. The
expression "any insurer who is being wound up by, the court"
wouI~ not ~ appropriate in its application to a foreign company
because the busines.s ol. that company outside India cannot be
wound up by an order of -the Court in India. Its entire business
in India may be wound up. That may be a reason for introducing the word "business" in s. 15(a). Section 481 of the
A
B
c
D
E
F
JI
'r
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co.
A
8
c
D
E
F
G
·'
985
Companies Act, 1956 provides that "when the affairs ot a
company have been completely wound up". the court shall make
an order that the company be dissolved from the date of the
order. Upon that order the company shall stand dissolved. The
phrase "the affairs of a company have been completely wound
up" is significant. It shows that othe expressions "winding up of
a company" and "winding up of the affairs oi: a company" convey
the same sense, for we think that the phrase "1he affairs of a
company" means the business affairs of a company('). In Rajah
of Vizianagaram v. Official Receiver Vizianagaram(') speaking
about the winding up of. a foreign company in India, this Court
said : "It is therefore necessary that if a company carries on business in countries other than the country in which it is incorporated,
the courts of those countries too should be able to conduct winding
up proceedings of its business in their respective countries. Such
winding up of the business . ....... is really an ancillary winding
up of the main company." (emphasis added).
It appears from these observations that the winding up of a
foreign company by an order of the Court in India really means
the winding up of its business in India. Having regard to the
foregoing consideration we are of ·opinion that the word "business'.'
is not redundant ins. 15(a). On the other hand, the charge of
redundancy may really be made against the construction suggested
by the Neptune Assurance. That construction makes the word
"voluntarily" redundant in the first limb. If Parliament had really
intended that the first limb should apply also to an insurer who is
in the process of closing its business, it should have expres.o;ed the
first limb in some such manner as any insurer "whose business is
being closed" or "is being wound up." The construction put forwarded by the Neptune Assurance assigns little significance to the
word "voluntarily" and makes it a surplusage.
Section 15 (b) of othe Act provides that the Act shall not
apply any insurer to whom the Insurance Act does not apply by
reason of s. 2E thereo{. Section 2E of the Insurance Act provides
that it shall not apply to any insurer as defined in" paragraphs ( i)
and (ii) of sub-clause (a) of clause 9 of s. 2 in relation to any
class of insurance business where the insurer has ceased before
the commencement of that Aot to enter into new contracts of
that class of btusiness. Section 29(a) (i) and (ii) of that Act
includes in the definition of 'insurer' a public company incorporated under a foreign Jaw and carrying on business in India or
having its principal place of bu3iness or domicile in India. If such
Regina vs. Board of Trade, [1965] 1 \).11. 60). In this case it was held
that the phrase "the affair of a comp1oy ins. 16 of the English Com~
panies Act connotes its business affairs." Section 1655 corresponds to
s. 237 of the Companies Act, 1956.
(2) [1962] Su;ip. I S.C.R. 344.
(1)
H
v. UNION (Dwivedi, J.)
966
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
a company has ceased before the commencement of the Insurance
Act to enter into any new contracts of insurance business or a
class of insurance business, as the case may be, it shall not
be governed by the provisions of the Insurance Act. According
to s.15 ( b) of the Act such a company shall also not be governed
b\y the Act. Thus s.15 (b) refers to a foreign insurance company which had ceased to do insurance bJUsiness or class of
insurance business in India before the commencement of the
Insurance Act. Section 2 ( e) of the Act excludes from the
. clefinition 'insurer' an insurance public company whose registration
under the Insurance Act has remained wholly cancelled for a
period of six months immediately before May 13, 1971. We
have already discussed that the reghtra\ion of an insurance public
compa:iy may be cancelled by the Controller if the Company
has not applied for the renewal of its registration; One of the
reasons for not so applying may be cessation of business. So
s. 2 ( e) also refers to an insurance public company which has
ceased to do business for a certain period.
Section 15(a) should be construed in the setting of s. 15(b)
and 2 ( e). So construed, it is difficult to believe that Parliament
has not used the. expression "whose business is being voluntarily
wound up" in the technical sense. If Parliament had intended
to exempt from the operation of the Act an insurance public
company which has of its own accord ceased to do business
before the commencement of the Act, it would have inserted
in the Act a clear provision like s. 15 (b) or s. 2 ( e). Now the
deliberate insertion.of s. 15(1J) ands. 2(e) necessarily implies
that Parliament did not intend to exclude an insurance public
company which has merely ceased to do business of its own
accord.
Scheme :-One of the professed objects of the Act is "to
protect the interest of the policy-holders pending nationalisation
of the general insurance ~siness." The interpret<\tion suggested
by the Neptune Assurance would defeat that iegislative object.
Assuming thats. 15(a) is susceptible 9f two meanings-the wider
and the narrower (the technical), the one which fructifies the
said legislative object should be preferred. This preference is
also made persuasive by the nature of the provisions of s. 15 of
the Act. Section 15 carves out an exception to section 3. It
excludes certain insurance public companies and some other
institutions from the operation of the Act.
Ordinarily an
exception is strictly construed. So the technical meaning of the
expression "whose business is being voluntarily wound up". should
he preferable to the wider meaning of that expression.
In the light of the foregoing discussion we are of opinion
that the Neptune Assurance cannot get the benefit of s. 15(a)
A
c
D
E
F
G
,
NEPTUNE ASSURANCE co. v. UNION
A
B
c
D
E
(Dwivedi, J.)
967
and will be subject to the provisions of s.3 of the Act which
provides tor the take-over of the man'!lgement of the insurance
companies.
The next submission of the Neptune Assurance is that a part
of s. 2(e) ands. 15(a) as construed by us run a foul of Art. 14 of
the Constitution. The offending part of s. 2 ( e) according to it is
this : "and includes an insurance cO!Ilpany whose registration
under that Act has ·not remained wholly cancelled for a period of
six. months immediately before the appointed day.'? It is said
that this part of s. 2 ( e) creates two classes of insurance companies.
The first class consists of those insurance companies, whose registration under the Insurance Act has remained wholly cancelled
for a period of six months immediately before the appointed d!iY;
the second class consists of those companies whose registration
under •the Insurance Act has remained wholly cancelled for less
than six months immediately before the appointed day. The Neptune Assurance falls within the second class. It is complained that
the temporal difference as ·to the cancellation of registration
between the two classes is no valid reason for. treating them
diffc:ently. The second class should also have been excluded
from the definition of 'insurer' in s. 2 ( e). The same argument
is reiterated with reference to s.lS(a). It is said that there is no
reason why any insurance company which is closing its business of
its own accord should not be excluded from the purview of the
Act. The respondents, on the other hand, have urged'1Jiat Art. 14
will not help the Neptune Assurance on accom1t of the Act being
protected by Art. 31A(b) and (d) of the Constitution.
It is not and cannot be denied that an insurance com:pany
whose registration under the Insurance Act has remained wholly
cancelled for six months immediately before the appointed day is
F in one very important respect radically unlike the insurance company whose registration under <the Insurance Act has remained
wholly cancelled for less than six months immediately before the
appointed day. An .insurance company whose registration under
the Insurance Act has remained wholly cancelled for more- than
six months from the appointed day has become defunct. It cannot
be revived. It may be wound up by the Court on the application
G of the Controller under s. 3 (SD) of the Insurance Act An
· insurance company whose registration under the Insurance Act
has remained wholly cancelled for less than six months from the
appointed day is in a state of suspended animation. It can revive
itself. The Controller cannot make an application to the Court
for its winding up. The temporal differentia as to the cancellation
u' of registration between the two classes of companies determines
the liability of one of ~hem to be wound up under s." 3 (SD). This
is ~ n;eaningf~l and inte\ligi?le difJ'.erentia. It is not arbitrary,
wh1ms1cal or illusory. The d1fferent1a has got rational relation
968
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
to rme of the objects of the Act. According to the preamble, A
the protection of the interests of the policy holders is an object of ·
the Act. The differentia is calculated to accomplish this legislative
object. Where the registration of a company has remained wholly
cancelled for six months from the appointed day, the Controller
may apply to the Court for its winding up under s. 3(5D). As
soon as· the judicial process is set in motion, the company comes
under the. control of the Court. A liquidator will be appointed
to wind up· its affairs. The Court's control will protect ithose
policy-holders w)lo have got unsatisfied claims against the
company. The liquidator will collect the assets of the company
and pay those claims as far as possible from the realised assets.
The company whose registration has remained wholly cancelled
fot less than six months from the appointed day can revive itself. c
It cannot be wound up by the Court at the instance of the
Control1er. The claims of the policy-holders against such a
company will go unprotected. The company may or may not
pay the claims. It may fritter away its assets. Th.e policy-holders
would be. constrained to resort to litigation against the· company
or realisation of their claims against it. The take-over of the D
undertaking of the company under the Act improves by reason
of Government's management the prospects of their claims satisfaction. It is also calculated to protect all interests by applying
after the take-over, if that courseis deemed necessary, to revive the
business of the company. Section 2(e) is in our view not discriminatory.
E
For the foregoing reasons, section 15 ( o) also is not discrimi:
natory.
As jn our view the attack based on Art. 14 cannot succeed.
it is unnecessary 10 deal with the respondents' contention based
on Art. 31A(b) and (d} of the Constitution.
In the result, we would dismiss the petition with costs.
ORDER
In acqordance with the opinion of the ma_jority, the writ
petition is dismissed with costs.
G.C.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org