THE PANIPAT CO-OPERATIVE SUGAR MILLS versus THE UNION OF INDIA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 6 November 1972 | [1973] 2 S.C.R. 860 | 1972 INSC 272
Key facts
- Decided
- 6 November 1972
- Bench
- J.M. SHELAT*, A.N. GROVER, KUTTYIL KURIEN MATHEW, A.K. MUKHERJEA, Y.V. CHANDRACHUD
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1357/1972
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1973] 2 S.C.R. 860
- Neutral citation
- 1972 INSC 272
Text of the judgment
860
THE PANIPAT CO-OPERATIVE SUGAR MILLS
A
v.
THE UNION OF INDIA
November 6, 1972
[J.M. SHELAT, A. N. GROVER, K. K. MATHEW, A. K.
MUKHERJEA AND Y. V. CHANDRACHUD, JJ.]
B
Essential Commodities Act (10 of 1955); s.3 (3C)cls. (a) to (d)-Scope of.
From 1958 and even earlier,. ex-factory prices of sugar were worked
out or. the basis of cost-schedules prepared by expert bodies appointed
for !hot purpose. The prices in the cost schedules were prepared in
respect of the entire production of sugar and not in relation only to that
part of it which was required to be sold to government (referred to as
c
levy sugar), although, partial control in one form or another was in vogue.
Such cost-schedules were prepared on the basis of average duration and
recovery i the minimum price of cane, the
average
cost
of
production
in the various zones. taxes and a fair return on the capital ,emplOyed in
the industry. In 1967, the Central Government was confronted with the
two problems : (a) the deterioration in the sugar indu•try, and (b) the
conflicting interests of the manufactureri the consumer and the
cane
grower. Accordingly Government announced its policy of partial cootrol
under which 60% of the output of sugar would be acquired and the
balance of 40%would be left for free sale. To implement this policy
sub-s.3 (3C) was enacted in the Essential Commodities Act. 1955. Under
the sub-section there must be an order under s. 3(2) (f) whereby a
producer is required to sell sugar to the Gov-ernment. There shall then
be paid to the producer an amount there or, that is, for such stock of
sugar as is required 1'~ be sold; and such amount shall be calculated with
refrence to such price of sugar as the Central Government may, by order
determine, having regard to the four factors set out in els. (a), (b), (c)
and (d) of s. 3(3C). Clause (a) provides for the minimum price, if
a:iv, fixed for sugar cane by the Central Government.under s.. 3; Cl. (b)
refers to the manufacturing cost of sugar, Cl. (c) to the duty or tax, i'f
any or payable thereon: and Cl. (d)
to the securing of a
capital
employed
in
the
business
reasonable return on the
of manufacturing sugar. The words 'notwithstanding anything contained
in sub-s.(3) suggests that the nmount payable to the person required to
sell the stock of sugar would be with refe:ence t'O the price fixed under
sub-s (3C). (865 E: 868 F-H; 870 D-G; 874B]
In pursuance of the power reserved to it under s.3(2).(f) and s.3(3C)
the Central Government required sugar factories, including the appellantccmpanies to sell to it 60% of their production during 1970-71 at prices
fixed by it under the Sugar (Price Determination) Order, 1971. The
prices \\'ere fixed on the principles laid down by the Tariff Commission
and othc: expert bodies. The appellants filed writ petitions in the High
Court for quashing the Order and for refixation of the ex-factory pric,e
for 1970-71 in respect of the sugar required to be sold to the Government
under s.3(2) (f). The High Court dismissed the writ petitions. In
appeal to this Court it w<is contended by the appellants that sub-section
(3C), and its cl. (d) must be construed to be de•lin~ with levy sugar
only, that a reasonable return under cl. (d) should be assured unitwise,
and that the profit on the free sale of sugar should not be taken into
D
E
F
G
H
PANJPAT SUGAR MILLS V. UNION
A
861
account in considering whether a reasonable return has been allowed on
the capital employed.
Dismissing the appeal,
B
c
...
.
D
E
F
G
H
HELD : On the constru~tion of sub-s. (3C) and on the evidence produced there is no case for quashing the Sugar (Price Determination) .
Order, nor, for refixation of the price fixed by the Goy.ernment under the
suh·section. [881 DJ
(a I The sub-section pr""' ides two things, (l) the determination by the
Government of a fair price during the process of which regard shall be
hJ.d to the fOur matters set out therein, and (2) payment to the manufactur.:r. part of \\hose stock is levied, an 'amount therefor', calculated
\\:ith f'.!f~rcnce to 'such .price· as the Cen,tral Governntent may determine.
The words ·amount therefor' mean the amount to be paid to the manufacturer in respect of such quantity of stock as is required lo be sold
under an order made with referenco to sub-s. (2)(f). That amou~t is
th~rcforc referable to the stock of sugar specified in such order. that is
to say. the le\ y sugar. The \\'Ord~ ·such price of sugar' relate to the
price "hich the Central guvernment has to determine having re[!9rd to
els. (al, (b), (c) and (d). Though the payment would of course be
for the stock required to be sold to Government, there is nothing in sub-s.
( 3C) to suggest that the price to be determined is to be with respect
to that part of the stock of a particular manufacturer \\'hich is required
to he sold to the Gowrnment. [871 A-E]
(b) A fair price for sugar had to be such trtat would harmonise and
satisfv at least to a reasonable extent all the conflicting interests. It could
not n1ean the actu;.1l cost and return of every individual unit because. (i)
it would be impracticable and (ii) because it would he rewarding the
inefficient and the uneconomic. The basis of a fair price would be cost
scheJules v,:orked out \Vith respect to a reasonable. efficient and economic
r·opresentative cross-section of the industry. A claim that such a. price
had to be determined unitwbe and a reasonable return is to be ensured
to e"ch unit or tlrat such a price with such a return should only be· in
respect of that part of its stock required to be sold under sub-s. 3(2) (f)
would be inconsistent with the concept of partial control, the background
in which it was evolved, and the objects which it attempted to secure. Su·:h
•a policy meant determination of a fair price on the basis of which a producer would be paid for part of stock required to be sold to Government.
The fair price would have to be determined having regard to the four
factors set out in the sub·section. Though factors (a) and (cl would
be static. ractor (b) would largely depend on variables. such as duration
and recovery. the prices of fuel. labour etc. differing from zone to zone
or even \l.'ithin the same zone, necessitating the averaging and costing of
a representative cross-section of units. Therefore. fair price could only
mean securing a reasonable req.1fn to the industry as a whole and not
to each unit. or in respect of only the stock required to be sold compulsorily to the Governme.'ll. [873 H; 874 G·H; 875 A·F]
(c) This does not however mean that Government can fix anv arbitrary price, or on extraneous considerations. or a price which does n9t
secure a reasonable return on the capital employed in the industry. Such
a fixation would evoke a chalknge, both on the grounds of its being inconsist~nt with the guidelines built in· the sub-section and its being: ·in
contravention of Arts. 19(1 )(f) and (g) and 31 of the Constitution.
[875 F·H]
'862
(1973) 2 s.c.11..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
A
[On the materials placed before it the Court found that the price fixed
with respect to the appellants ensured a reasonable return on the C"apital
employed and that there was no necessity for its refixatioo.]
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION :
to J 359 of 1972.
Civil Appeals Nos. 1357
Appeals by certificate from the judgment and order dated
January 10, 1972 of Delhi High Court at New Delhi in Civil
Writ Petition~ Nos. 405, 381 and 486 of 1971.
H. L. Sibal and Bishamber Lal, for the appellants
the appeals).
L. N. Sinha, Solicitor-General of India,
S. 1'. Nayar· for the respondent.
(in
all
G. L. Sanghi
and
B
C
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
SHELAT, J. These thre.: appeals, by certificate, arise out of
three writ petitions filed in he High Court of Delhi for quashing
the Sugar (Price Det·~nnination) Order, 1971 made under s.
3(3C) of the fasential Commodities Act, 10 of 1955, and for a
direction requiring the Central Government to rcfix the ex-factory
price for 1970-71 in respect of sugar required to be sold to Gov·ernrnent under s. 3(2) (f) of the Act. The High Court dismis9~d
the writ peti.tions and hence these appeals.
The appellants are three public limited companies having factories in Haryana State where they carry on the business of manufacturing and selling sugar, an essential commodity within the
meaning of tlv~ Act. The Act empowers the Central Government to control the production and distribution inter a/ia of sugar
with the object of maintaining its supply and its equitable distribntion.
Under ~cc. 3, the Central Government has been authorised to
require a manufacturer of sugar to sell to it or to a State Government or any other authorised person either the whole of his stock
or part of it at a fair price fixed by it. In pur.suance of power
reserved to it under s. 3(2) (f) ands. 3(3C), the Ccntrnl Government required the s4gar factories, including the app~llant
companies 10 sell to it 60% of their production during the year
1970-71 at prices fixed by it, the price fixed for the factories in
Haryana zone under the impugned order being Rs. 124.63 per
D
't
E
F
G
auin~.,!.
The principal questions arise in these appeals : (I) what is
the trne interpretation of s. 3(3C), and (2) whether the price of
Rs. 124.63 was in accordance with the provisicns of s. 3(3C)?
Before we proceed to consider these questions it would. we
think, be better to set out briefly the history of control over sugar
H
PANIPAT SUGAR Mil.LS
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
v. UNION (Shelat, ].)
863
production and its distribution and the method followed in the
fixation by Government of the fair, or what has for brevity's sake
·
been named, the levy price of sugar.
The concept oi statutory control over sugarcane is as old
as 1934 when the Central Sugar Cane Act, 1934 was enacted.
Under that Act and orders passed thereunder Government used
to fix the minimum price for cane. Since 1950 and later on
under the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1955, such minimum
price for cane nsed to be fixed having regard to (a) the cost of
production of cane, (b) the return to the itrowers from alternative
crops, and ( c) fair price o~ sugar to the consumer.
So far as supar is concerned, statutory control over it was first
imposed in 1942 under the Sugar and Sugar Products Control
Order, 1942. The Sugar Controller thereun<l~r regulated production, distribution and prices of sugar. From May 1, 1942,
no sugar factory was permitted to effect sales except to authorised
persons. This position continued until December 8, 1947 when
sugar was decontrolled. In 1949, statutory control was once
more imirised under which ex-factory price of Rs. 76.35 per
quintal for D-24 grade was fixed, as during that year sugar production declined. There was also a substantial diversion of cane
to gur and khandsari industry. Contrnl over sugar was relaxed
in 1950 in that production- over 90% of the total production of
each fact-o;-y was allowed free sale. This policy was subsequently
modified and 953 of the average production of each factory during the two preceding years was fixed as basic quota and half of
the production in excess of that quota was allowed free sale, while
the oth~r half together with the basic quota was reserved for sale
at controlled prices. Since conditions appeared to improve, control was taken off in 1952-1953, except that a small pqrtion of
production was reserved for sale at controlled prices. · But as
prices spiralled, Government in April 1954 requisitioned 25%
of the stock for distribution on a tender basis. During 1954-55
to 1956-57 no controlled prices were fixed. By 1.958 the prices
began to soar and the Government once more decided to impose
control.
During 1958 Government requested the Tariff Commission to
examine the cost structure of sugar and fair price which should be
paid to the sugar industry. Such an exercise was not new, for,
as early as 1947, and in 1951 and 1955 these questions had been
gone through, in 1947 by one Dr. Srivastava, and in later years
by expert committees appointed by Government. These committees worked ont cost schedules and fair price to ~ paid to the
industry but on an All-India basis. 'These cost-schedules were
not fair as they did not take into account disparities existing from
864
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
region to region in the matter of price of cane,
recovery and duration of the crushing season.
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
percentage ·of
The Tariff Commission in 1959 did away with the all-India
cost-schedule and instead constructed four zonal cost schedules
having regard to their respective duration and recovery percentage on. which a fair price could be fixed. Government then
requisitioned the stock of sugar and distributed sugar at fixed
prices. In September 1961, the Government removed control
as the situation had improved. But the next two years witnessed
a substantial fall in production and rise in prices. Government
then passed the Sugar (Control) Order, 1963 under which it
fixed ex-factory prices for different regions and regulated distribution according to quotas fixed for each State. Government in
the meantime h:id worked out cost-schedules for as many as 22
zones, according to which, it fixed ex-factory prices ranging from
Rs. 116 to Rs. 125 per quintal.
. Qn August 3. 1964, Government appointed the Sugar Enquiry
Commission. The Commission in its Report deprecated the
Government's practice of incro~asing the number of zones to 20
and more and recommended only five zones. The Commission
worked out the cost-schedules for these five zones on the basis of
duration and recovery percentage in each of the zones and on the
basis of minimum cane price, cess or tax, commission of co-operative societies, transport charges, driage and other expense', packing, grade differential and selling expenses. Tlie Commission
r~commended that while working out the ex-factory prices fo1
each year on the basis of these cost-schedules Government should
make adjustments whenever any escalation took place in cost elements such .as wages, taxes, packing charges. etc. On the question of return, the Commission observed as follows :
"The Tariff Commission, in its last inquiry (1958)
recomemnded a return at 12 per cent on capital employed. Jn doing so, it took into consideration factors
such as the dependence of the industry on an agricultural raw material. the supply of which is affected by
several jrnponderables, e.g., weather and pests and
diseases. A number of factories located in f.1,:~1.irable
regions have made ample profits. In fact, the SJnole
factories earned as much as 15.69 per cent in 196364-Sizeable expansions in capacity have taken place.
The Commission is satisfied that the rate of return of 12
per cent is not unreasonable and should encourage expansion of the industry. .The Commission is aware that
the rate of return indicated will not be realised by each
individual unit in each zone. Majority of·the units in
a zone, however, should be able to earn this return it
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS V. UNION
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(She/at, J.)
865
they maintain a reasonable degree of efficiency. The
method adopted and followed by the Commission in
assessing the working capital is th~ same as was adopted by the Tariff Commission in its 1959 Inquiry."
There were two criteria for fixation of ex-factory prices; ( 1)
estimated cost of production detem1ined according to the costschedulcs prepared by the Tariff Commission in 1959 and adjusted from time to time to provide for increa&~ in any of the elements
of costs, and (2) average of prices at which sugar was sold in an
area during two to three months immediately before April l,
i963. From 1964-.65 to 1966-67 Government fixed ex-factory
prices on the basis of the cost-schedules work>~ out by the Sugar
Enquiry Commission. But the year 1966-67 turned out to be the
worst year in the decade owing to draught. Production of cane
fell by 22% and that of sugar by 403 as compared to 1965-66.
It was kit that the outlook for 1967-68 would be gloomier still as
a further fall in the area under cane plantation would be by
about 11 %.
'
To avoid such a prospect some steps had to be taken providing
incentives for maximising sugar production and increasing the
compctitiveness of sugar factories. vis-a-vis gur and khandsari
factories in se£uring cane by offering prices h;igher than the floor
prices. Accordingly, Government announced in August 1967
its policy of partial control under which 603 of the output of
sugar would be acquired and the balance of 40% would be left
for free sale. To implement this policy, Government secured the
passage of sub-s. 3C in s. 3 of the Act 1hrough Parliament. Having
done that. it fixed the ex-factory prices on Dectmber 8, 1967
which as finalised in May 1968 vari·~d from Rs. 145 'to Rs. 169.50
per Quintal. These were fixed on the principles laid down by the
Tariff Commission and the Sugar Enquiry Commission earlier.
l'iz., on the basis of (a)· floor price of cane fixed by Government.
(b) cess or tax payable thereon, ( c) the manufacturing cost,
and ( d) a reasonable· return on capital employed.
Since the cost-schedules worked out by the Sugar Enquiry
Commiss,ion had by now become obsolete, Government in 1968
reQuest>~ the Tariff Commission to construct fresh cost schedules.
The Commission selected 68 out of 200 working units in the
industry for a. detailed cost study. For the rest, it sent out elaborate cost forms for submitting the requisite data pertaining to
1966-67. For Haryana. out of the three units, one was selected
for the detailed cost study.
The Commission first worked out actual cost of production
state-wise, by taking into accoum a number of units in each
Stare, their installed average crushing capacity, the cane actually
crushed per day, and the average yield of sugar. In this way the
866
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
ex-faC'lory cost per quintal of sugar came to Rs. 104.43, This
figure took into account the actual price paid for cane, which was
often higher than the minimum price fixed by Government,
harvesting charges where incurred, transport, cess/ purchase tax,
and factory conversion charges which included salaries/wage>.
power, fuel, stores, repairs, maintenance, packing and other overheads. These average costs represented the average cos(s of
sugar covering all grades. tlut the factories in different States
had different durations depending on the availability of sugar
cane in adequate supplies and different recoveries of sugar differing from factory to factory. A direct coinparisoil. of actual costs
between factories or States would, therefore, have· led to unrealistic results. These differing factors had, therefore, to be reduced
to a common measure. For these purposes the Commission took
into account five years average recovery and duration of a region
as !he base.
Having regard 10 the wide disparity in duration and recovery
of sugar, the costs were initially reduced to a standard duration
of 120 days (of 22 hours each) with a uniform recovery of I 0
per cent so as to have a comparison of costs as between units in
a zone. Also the differential relating to different grades of
sugar produced by the units was adjusted and. a common schedule
for D-29 grade was evolved. On this basis the conversion charges
for each State were w"rked out. These did not includel
transport charges on cane, selling expenses and returr.. On such
calculation, the conversion charges for Haryana, including
depreciation, at the rate permissible under the Income Tax Act
came to Rs. ! 9.58 as against the All-Ir.dia weighted average of
Rs. 25.20 per quintal. For salaries/wages, the recommendations
of the Central Wage Board for Sugar Industry fonned the base.
For stores and repairs the cost and variations therein from Stare
to State were based on the index of wholesale figures published by
the 'Economic Adviser to the Ministry of Industrial Development
and Company Affairs. For future an incidence of increase of
3% per annum was taken into account, i.e., for the years 196869 to 1970-71. The minimum bonus at the statutorily payable
and managerial expenses were included in the costs of conversion;
so also the transport charges from the factories to railway stations
and the loading and unloading charges. For this. the base was
the actual charges in 1966-67 which came to 15 paise per
quintal for most of the States. For rehabilitation, the Commission suggested Rs. 2 per quintal.
Owing to the wide ranging differences in the capital costs of
various units as also differences from State to State. the Commission did not think it realistic to recommend return worked
out according to the conventional method. A calculation of
A
B
c
E
E
G
H
PANIPAT SUGAll MILLS V. UNION
A
B
c
()
(She/at, !.)
867
return of a unifonn percentage on the basis of such widely varying capital costs from unit to unit and State to· State would tend
to vary the portion of the return margin substantially and confer
an unwarranted benefit on the low cost units. At the s;une time,
a reasonable return was indispensable if expansion was to be
encouraged and fresh capital investment in the industry attracted,
which according to the Reserve Bank's industry-wise study,
showed the lowest profit percentage in sugar industry of all other
industries. The Commission, therefore, suggi:sted. a uniform
amount per quintal as a margin to be added to the other costs in
arriving at the fair price of sugar. The Commission for the
reasons aforesaid was of the view that an amount of Rs. l 0.50
would be a fair return which would be equivalent to 12.53 on
the zonal averages of capital employed. According to Appendix
37 to the report, the average return at 12.5% on capital
employed on the units in Haryana worked out at Rs. 10.40 per
quintal to be added to the fair price worked 0ut for that region.
By adopting the standardised figure of Rs. 10.50 per quintal
the range of variations from region to region was expected to
be narrowed down from Rs. 11.88 in the case of South Bihar
to Rs. 16.94 in die case of Orissa, Kerala, Assam and West
Bengal.
It is quite clear that what the Commission did was to con-
E · struct cost schedules and fair price of the entire production and
F
G
H
not merely of the levy sugar. The return and rehabilitation also
-.wre worked out on the basis of the capital employed in the
entire production and not the capital employed for the production
of levy sugar. Thus, in Table 9.6 at page 80 of i'ts report, the
Commission included Rs. 12.50 (being return and rehabilitation)
in the ex-works price of sugar. There is nothing in that tab!.,
which would suggest that it was confined to levy sugar. Indeed
Ch. 9 in which this table appears is headed "Cost Structure and
Price Fixation'', that is the ex-works price. In calculating the
ex-factory price. the Commission took the minimum price of
cane fixed by Goverrunent ·and not the actual price paid by the
manufacturer as was also done by the Commission in 1959 and
by the Sugar Enquiry Commission in 1955. On this basis the
ex:fact<n1'. price for Haryana worked out to Rs. 128.69 per
qumtal (1.e., cost of cane Rs. 89.73, conversion charges
Rs. 26.46, i:eturn and rehabilitation Rs. 12.50) for· the year
1966-67 on the basis of the average of the past five years' duration
and recovery. The cost of cane would of course depend on the
minimum price fixed for each year by Government. The figure
of Rs. 69.73 was the minimum price fixed for 1966-67. It
also did not indlude the co-operative society's commission, if
any, the purchase tax or cess and the margin for cane driage.
4-L521Sup.Cl/73
868
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[J 973] 2 S.C.R.
A
These were ·~xpected to be worked out by the authority fixing
the fair price for each zone for a particular Y.ear.
The cost schedule for conversion in the light o[ duration and
recovery for each zone was made up of expenses classified as
constants, variables, semi-variables and fixed expenses. For
Haryana, it worked out to Rs. 26.46 per quintal on the basis of
avera,!l,e dur~tion of 125 days (of 22 hours) and 8.70 recovery.
The cost schedule made up of the aforesaid expenses did not include (i) price of cane, (ii) commission to cooperative society,
if any, (iii) purchase tax or cess and (iv) driage of cane, as these
would be taken into account while fixing the minimum cane price.
The constants comprise packing and grade differentials which
would be static. The variables comprise seasonal expenses. i.e ..
other than those incurred nonnally when crushing does not take
pl~.ce, i;uch as. wages of seasonal recruits excluding allowances for
retainers, relevant parts of stores, repairs, transport on cane, shift
depreciation, overheads and credit for recoveries. Semi-variables
would comprise power and fuel and retainer allowances which
won1d vary with duration and recovery. Fixed charges . would
be expenses other than those covered by the three aforesaid expenses and which are of a fixed nature irresp·~ctive of duration and
recovery.
The sum total of these classified expenses would make up the
conversion costs. To these and the minimum price of cane
would be .added Rs. 2 for rehabilitation and Rs. 10.50 as return on
capital employed and excise duty. The Government did not
accept the recommendation as to rehabilitation and defe1Ted its
decision thereon for reasons stated in its resolution dated February
20, 1970, by which it accepted the other recommendations as also
the cost-schedules worked out by the Conmtission, the number of
zones, return of a fixed sum of"Rs. 10.50, etc.
The history of control over sugar set out above shows that
right from 1958 and even earlier, ex-factory prices of sugar were
worked out on the basis of cost-schedules prepared by expert
bodies appointed for that purpose, that such prices and costschedules were prepared in respect of the entire production and
not in relation only to that part of it which was required to be
sold to G:overnment, although partial con'trol in one form or the
other was in vogue for some periods before 1967, that such costschedu1es were prepared on the basisjof average duration and
recovery, the minimum price of cane; the averaged co~,t of production i11 the various zones, taxes, and lastly. a rnturn on the
capital employed, which as· stated above was fixed at the static
figure of Rs. 10.50 per quintal, that being the amount considered
a fair return on capital employed in tho~ industry. Both the Central Government and Parliament were aware of the methods
B
c
D
I
E
F
G
II
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS
v. UNION (Shelat, l.)
869
A
fol10wed by these expert bodies in framing cost-schedules on-the
basis of which ex-factory prices were fixed, the problems which
the Government was faced with in securing adequate supply of
sugar and its equitable distribution at reasonable price to remedy
which sub-s. 3C was enacted. It is in the light of this background that the provisions of that sub-section can be properly
understood.
B
The Act, as its long title suggests, was enacted to provide for
the control of production, supply and distribution of, and trade
and commerce in, certain commodities, sugar being one of such
commodities. Sec. 3 empowers the Central Gov~rnmcut, if it is
of opinion that it is necessary or expedient to do so for maintaining or increasing supplies of any essential commodity or for
securing their equitable distribution and availability at fair prices,
to provide by an order for regulating or prohibiting production,
supply and distribution thereof. Under its sub-section ( 2) cl.
(f), such an order may require any person holding in stock any
essential commodity to sell the whole or a specified part of it to
the Central or a State Government or an authorised person and in
such circumstances as may be specified therein. Sub-s. 3 requires
that where any person sells any essential commodity in compliance
with an order made under sub-s. 2 cl. (f), there shall be paid to
him the price the]1:for (a) where the price can, consistently with
the controlled price, if any, fixed under this section, be agreed
upon, the a,greed price; (b) where no such agreement can be
reached, the price calculated with reference to the controlled price,
if any, or ( c) where neither cl. (a), nor cl. (b) applies, the price
calculated at the market pric.e prevailing in the locality at .the date
of sale. Payment at market price would have to be made ooder
this sub-sectiQn only when there is no agreed or controlled price.
Sub-secs. 3A and 3B then make provisions with reeard to sale of
foodstuffs and foodgrains. Under sub-sec. 3A, the Central
Government' js empowered, if it is of opinion that it is necessary
so to do for controllin.g the rise i!l prices or preventing the hoarding of any foodstuff in any locality, to direct by a notification that
not_withstanding anything contained in sub-sec. ( 3), the price at
which the foodstuff shall be sold in the localtiy in compliance with
an order made under sub-sec. 2(f) shall be regulated in accordence with the provisions of this sub-section. Where after the
issue of a notification under this sub-section, any person sells
foodstuff of the kind and in the locality specified the~in, in compliance with an order made with reference to sub-sec. 2 cl. (f),
there shal.l be pai.d to the ~eller as the price therefor, (a) the
ag;eed pnce consis.tently With the controlled price, if any; (b) the
pnce calculated with reference to the controlled price, if any,
where no such agreement can be reached, or ( c) where neither
cl. (a), nor cl. (b) applies, the price calculated with reference to
c
E
F
G
H
870
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973) 2 S.C;R.
the average market rate as provided therein. Under sub-sec. 3B,
where a person is required to sell any foodgrains, edible oilseeds
or edi~le oils to the Central or a State Goverlllllent, or to a person
a.uthonsed in that behalf, and no notification in respect of such
foodgrains; oilseeds or oils bas been issued under sub-sec. 3A or
is_ in force, there shall be paid as the price for such foodgrains,.
oilseeds or oils, (i) the contro!led price, if any, or (ii) where no
such price is iPced the j)rice prevailing or_ likely to prevail during
the post-harvest penod m the area to which the order applies.
B-:>th under sub-sec. 3A and 3B, the question of market price can
only arise where there is no controlled or fixed price or price
agreed consi;r~ntly with the controiled price, if any. Each of
these .mb-secfrms makes a separate provision for tlie price at
which 1he commodities therein dealt with is to be paid.
Sub-sec. 3C, with which we are presently concerned, was _inserted in sec. 3 by sec. 3 of Act 36 of 1967. 1:he si:b-secuon
lays down two conditions which must exiJt O.:fore 11 applies. The
first is thllt there must be an order made with reference •to subsec. 2 cl. (f), and the second is that there is no notification .under
siab-sec. 3A or if any such notification has b.een issued it is no
longer in force owing to efflux of time. Next, the words "notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section" suggest that the
amount payable to the person required to sell his stock of ;;ugar
would be with reference to the price fixed under the sub-section
and not the ai:rced price or the market price in the absence of any
controlled price under sub-sec. 3A. The sub-section then lays
down two things; firstly, that where a producer i& P~quired by an
order with reference to sub-sec. Z(f:• to sell any kind of sugar,
there shall be paid to that producer an amount therefor, that is for
such stock of sugar as is required to be sold, and secondly, that
such amount shall be calculated with reference to such price of
sugar as the Central Governnfcnt may, by order, cktermine; having regard to th·~ four factors set out in els. (a), (b), (c) and (d).
Unlike the preceding three sub-sections under which the amount
payable is either the agreed price, or the controlled price, or
where neither of .these prices is applicable at the market or average market price, the amount in respect of sugar ruquired to be
sold is to be calculated at the price detem1ined by the Central
Government. The last words of the sub-section empower the
Central Government to determine price either from time to time
or for different areas, which means that it may determine zonal or
regional prices, or for different factories, i.e., unit-wise, or for
different kinds of grades of sugar.
The two concepts, viz., the amount payable to the producer
and the price to be determined by Government are distinct and
much of the confusion in interpreting the sub-section would be
A
ll
c
D
E
F
G
H
PANJPAT SUGAR MILLS' v. UNION
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(She/at, J.)
871
dispelled if they were seen distinctly. The words "amount therefor" mean the amount to be paid to the manufacturer in respect
of such quantity of his stock as is required to be sold under an
order made with reference to sub-sec. 2(f). That amount is,
therefore, referable to the stock of sugar specified in such order,
that is to say, the levy sugar. The words "such price of sugar'',
relate to the price which the Central Government has to determine having regard to els. (a), (b), (c) and (d). The price to
be so determined is not relatable or confined to the stock required
to be sold, for the words are "such price of sugar" and not "the
price for such sugar". This construction is fortified by the penultimate part of the sub-section which authorises the Central Government to determine zonal or unit-wise prices or prices for different kinds of sugar. The price to be detern1ined by the Central
Government is to be tlie rate at which the amount payable to the
producer of such of his stock as is required to be ~old is to be calculated. There is thus a clear distinction between the amount
payable to the producer whose stock is either wholiy or in part
required to be sold under an order made under sub·sec. 2 ( f), and
the price of sugar to be dett;rmined by the Government having
regard to the minimum price of cane fixed by it, the manufacturing cost of sugar, tlie duty and tax paid or payable thereon and
securing a reasonabile return on the capital employed in the business of manufacturing sugar.
In order to appreciate the meaning of els. (a), (b), (c) and
( d), it must be remembeP.!d that ever since control ('Ill sugar was
imposed Government had set up expert committees to work out
cost-sch~ules and fair prices. Starting in the beginning with an
All-India cost-schedule worked out on the basis of the total production of sugar, the factories were later groupd together into
rones or regions and different cost-schedules for different zones or
regions were constructed on the basis of which fair prices were
worked out at which sugar was distributed and sold. The Tariff
Colll!1lission in 1958 and the Sugar Enquiry Commission in 1965
had worked out the zonal cost-schedules on the basfa of averaged
recovery and duration, the minimum and not the actual price of
cane, the averaged coriversion costs and recommended a reasonable return on the capital employed by the industry in the business of manufacturing sugar. This experience was before the
legislature at the time when sub-sec. 3C was inserted in the Act.
The legislature therefore incorporated the same formula in the
new sub-section as the basis for working out the price. The purItOSe behind enacting the new sub-section was three-fold. to pro\ide an incentive to increase production of sugar, encourage expansion of the industry, to devise a means by which the cane producer could get a share in the profits of the industry through prices
872
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
A
for his cane hi,gher than the minimum price fixed and secure to
the consumer distribu'tion of at-least a reasonabb quantity of sugar
at a fair price. Whether these objectivr-s have, throilgh the working of the new sub-section, been realised or not is a different
matter. But there can be no doub't that these were Lhe objectives
for which the sub-section was passed. The i1w~nt\ve to secure
increased prpduction and expansion of the industry was to leave
a certain portion of the stock free for sale in the open market, the
assumption iie.i.ng that the industry would get a bet<er price in
such market than the price det·~rmined under the formula incorporated in sub-section 3C.
II
The fair price, therefore, has to be determined on the mini- c
mum price of cane fixed by Government, the manufacturing cost
on the basis of zonal cost-schedules, the tax or duty applica!:ile in
the zones and must be so structured as to leave in the ultimate
result to the industry a reasonable return on the .;;;pita! employed
by it in the business of manufacturing sugar. It is dear from the
reports of the Tariff Commission that a reasonabie return recomD
mended by that body at a fixed amount of Rs. 10.50 per quintal
which work•w out in 1966-67 at 12.5 % per annum was not in
respect of levy sugar only but on the whole, so that even if such
a return was not obtainable on l~vy sugar but ·w·a; obtainable on
the whole, it would meet the requirement of cl. (d). In this
conclusion we derive a two-fold support, firstly, from the language
used in cl. ( d) itself, viz., a reasonable return on the capital E
employed in the business of manufacturing su,;.ir, which must
mean the business as a whole and not the business of manufacturing levy sugar only, and secondly, from the fact of the Commission having all along used the same phraseology while recommending Rs. 10.50 p~r quintal as an addition by way of a reasonable
return on the capital employed in the industry. The cost-sche- F
dules prepared by these bodies were for determining a fair price
in relation to the entire sugar produced by the industry and the
return which should be granted to it on tl!e capital employed in
the industry and not with respect to· that stock only required to
be sold under sub-sec. 2(f). This is clear from ihe heading of
Ch. 9 of the '.fariff Commission's report, 1969, "Cost Structure G
and Price Fixation".
Counsel for the appellants and for the several interven.~rs,
however, contended (1) that since sub-sec. 3C was enacted after
the policy of partial control leaving a part of the stock for free
market was decided upon, the sub-section must b~ held to deal
with levy sugar only, and (2) that the languag~ o1 the sub-section
as also of its els. (a), (b) and (c) shows that it dealt with and
was concerned with levy sugar only and that therefore cl. ( d)
H
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS
v. UNION (She/at, I.)
must also be construed to be dealing with levy sugar. It was
urged that besides 1he necessity ?f giving t~ ,cl. . (d) the SaJ11;e
meaning as one would have to give to els. (a J, \ b) and ( c). 1f
cl. (d) were to be construed to mean return on the whole of the
capital employed, there would ensue a contrad1ctL•ry and even an
anomalous result. For purposes of cl. ( ~.), one would have to
take
the floor price of cane fi.-;ed by q<>vemment, ~ut for cl. ( d),
II
the actual price of cane paid by a umt would have to be taken
into account for purposes of arriving at a figure which would
leave a reasonable return to the producer, part of \1hose stock
is required to be sold. Counsel also urged that if cl. (d) wore
construed to mean reasonable retiirn on the production of the
entire stock and not levy sugar only, it would mean negativing the
c entire scheme of partial control which wa.\ intended to leave a
rea.,onable return on that part of the stock which was required
thereu~r to· be sold irrespective lof the rocurn obtained by sale
of the rest of his stock in a free market. Therefore, it would be
contrary to that concept if the profits made iu respect of free
sugar were to be taken into account as a cushion if the fair price
()
fixed for levy sugar was not equivalent to the actual cost of production and were to result in a return les~ than the reasonable
return on that part of the stock, or ev-en a deficit. Such a construction would, they argued, permit the Government to fix a price
which would not ieave such a return on the ;;round that sale of
free sugar would bring in sufficient surplus to mal..e up the deficit,
E
if any, on the levy sugar. Counsel further urgctl that such a
construction would also defeat the very object •.1f partial control,
in that, if a reasonable return was not assured tJ th·: manufacturer,
ile was hardly likely to buy cane at a price h:gner than the minimum fixed by Government. a purpose for wi1ich the partial control policy was evolved. To bring in the return on free sugar for
F purposes _of. deciding whether a return guaranteed under cl. ( d)
was obtamable or not from the price fixed hy Government would
also re ushering a factor wholly extraneous to the sub-section.
It would not be, therefore, right to brin.~ into consideration free
sugar which is not the subject-matter of sub-sec. 3C.
G
fl
To accept these contentions would in our view mean disregarding .(1) the language of the sub-section, and (2) the entire background in which it was enacted and the mischief it was
intended to rcn1edy. As explained earlier, the sub-section provides two things: (a) the deternlination bv Government of a
fair price during the process of which regard shall be had to the
.four matters set out therein, and (o) payment to the manufacturer part of whose stock is levied, an amount "therefor" calculated with reference to "such price" as the Central Government
may determine. Though the payment would of course be for
874
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973) 2 ~.C.R.
A
the stock required to be sold to Government, there is nothing in
the sub-section to suggest that the price to be determined is to be
with respect of that part of the stock of a particular manufacturer
which is required to be sold to Government.
In deciding upon the policy of partial control and in having
it incorporated in sul>-sec. 3, the Central Government was controntod with two main probllems (a) deterioration in the sugar · 8
industry. and ( b) the conflicting interests of the manufacturer,
the consumer and the cane grower. The report of the Sugar
Enquify Commission 1965 and that of the Tariff Commission of
1969 highlighted the difficulties that plagued the industry and the
necessity of harmonising the triple conllioting interests. The cane
acreage was dwindling, as the incentives for that plantation were c
not as attractive as those for cereals and other agricultural products. Part of that production was diverted towards production
of gur and khandsari, leaving no scope for greater production of
sugar, the necessity for which was being accentuated as the consumers' demand was rapidly increasing. The floor price of cane
fixed by Government was intended to protect the farmer from
D
exploitation, but that was found not to be an incentive enough to
induce him to increase his acreage. A device had to be found
under which a price higher than the minimum could be paid by
the manufacturer of sugar. The consumer, on the other hand,
had also to be protected against the spiralling of sugar price !llld
his needs, growing as they were, had to satisfied at some reasonable E
price. Both these and a larger production of sugar would not
be possible unless there was a reasonable return which would ensure expansion, which again would not be possible unless new
machinery for such expansion was brought in and factories, particularly in U.P. and Bihar, were modernised and renovated. A
fair price for sugar, therefore, had to be such as would harmoniie
F
and satisfy at least to· a reasonable extent these conflicting interests.
The concept of fair price was not unknown, for, it had been
worked upon from as early a time as 1937. That concept did not
by any account mean the actual cost of production of every individual manufacturer. It had to be arrived at by the process of
costing of a representative cross-section of manufacturing units.
G
The history of the industry shows that such a process was
being practised through various formulas, in the beginning by
working out an All-India cost-schedule, and when that was found
to be unrealistic by working out zonal cost-schedules beginning
with four and by 1969 with 15 such zonal cost-schedules. A fair
price would not thus mean the actual cost and return of every
individual unit, firstly, because it would be impracticable, and
secondly, because it would be rewarding the inefficient and the
uneconomic. An extreme example of such a unit is to be found
in the compilation prepared by Dr. Singhvi where the duration of
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS v. UNION
A
(She/at, J.)
87 5
season of that unit was only seven days, and therefore, its cost
came to over Rs. 600 per quintal. If such a product were left to
the mercy of a total free market and the impact of free competitiveness in it, such a unit would hardly survive. The object of the
policy of partial control cannot, therefore, mean to reward such
units.
B
The basis of a fair price would have to be· built on a reasonably efficient and economic representative cross-section on whoie
workings cost-schedules ·would have been worked out and the
price to be determined by Government under sub-sec. 3C would
have to be built. A claim that such a prii;:e has to be determined
and a reasonable return has to be ensured to each uuit
c unit-wise
or that such a price with such a return would be iii respect of that
part of its stock required to be sold under sub-sec. 2(f) would
appear to be inconsistent with the concept of partial control, the
background in which it was evolved and the objects which it
attempted to secure. Such a policy meant determination of a fair
price on the basis of which a producer would be paid for part of
his stock required to be sold to Government. Such a price would
have to be determined having regard to the four factors set out
in the sub-section. Though factors (a) and (c) would be static,
factor ( b) would largely depend on variables, such as duration
and recovery, the prices of fuel, labour etc. differing from zone to
zone and sometimes within the zone, necessitating averaging and
costing by selecting a representative cross-section of units for that
E
purpose and arriving at a cost-schedule which would do justice to
the weak and the strong alike. If this be the true meaning of cl:C'b), it must mean securing a reasonable return to the industry and
not 'to each unit, irrespective of whether it is economic or reasonably efficient or not, or only in respect of its stock required to be
cc;mpulsorily
sold to Government. A unit-wise fixation of price
F
as suggested by counsel, and payment on the basis of a price so
worked out would mean perpetuating inefficiency and mismanagement, and depriving the partial control policy of the incentives for
economy and efficiency inherent in it. We are, therefore satisfied
both on the language of the sub-section, the background'in which
it
was e~acted a!1d the mischief the legislature sought to remedy
G
through its workmg that the true construction is that a fair price
has !O be determined in respect of the entire produce, ensuring to
the. mdustry a reasona~le return on the capital employed in the
busmess of manufactunng sugar. But this does not mean that
Government can fix any arbitrary price, or a price fixed on extraneous considerations or such that it does not secure a reasonable
return on the capital employed in the industry. Such a fixation
H would at once evoke a challenge; both on the ground of its being
in~onsistent with the guidelines built iu the sub-section and its
being in contravention of Arts. 19(1)(f) and (g), and 31.
.
876
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973) 2 S.C.R.
The constitutionality of the sub-section not being under challer.ge in these appeals, the only question left for consideration is
whether the price fixed under the impugned order, i.e., Rs. 124.63,
is in consonance with s. 3 ( 3C)?
The ex-works price worked out in the Tariff Commission Report, 1969 for Haryana zone for thP. next three years, i.e., 1969-70
to 1971-72, based on the average recovery and average duration
of the past five years (1963-64 to 1967-~8), i.e., 8.70% and 125
days, was Rs. 128.69 per quintal. That figure was made up of
the following :
1. Wages and salaries Rs. 11. 70: (2) stores, fuel and
power Rs. 8 .49: ( 3) repairs and maintenance
Rs. 2.63: (4) packing charges Rs. 2.57: (5)
overheads Rs. 0. 75: ( 6) cane centre and cane
development Rs. 1.36: (7) depreciation (Income
Tax Act rates) Rs. 3.60: ( 8) transport of cane
Rs. 1.53: (9) less-credits Rs. 0.75: (10) grade
differential Rs. 1.07: ( 11 ) return and rehabilitation Rs. 12.50: (12) selling expenses Rs. 0.15:
(13) bonus Rs. 0.60-Total conversion charges
Rs.'38.96: (14) cane and related costs !ls. 89.73:
05) ex-works price Rs. 128.69.
T!1c figure of Rs. 89. 73 arrived at on the basis of driage being
Rs. 9.86 and average recovery of 8.70% was worked out as
follows :
( I ) Minimum price of cane fixed by Government
Rs. 7.37: (2) Co-operative society's cO!lllilission
Rs. 0.13 and ( 3) Cess/purchase tax Rs. 0.24,
Total Rs. 7.74=Rs. 89.73 per quintal sugar,
( vide Table 9.6 and Appendices 35 and 36 at
pages 89 and 212-214; Repof't 1969).
The ex-works price of Rs. 128.69 included Rs. 2 per quintal for
rehabilitation. That amount was not included by Government
when it fixed the price of Rs. 124.63 on January 8, 1971 as the
Government; while accepting the cost-schedules and other recommendations of the Tariff Commission, had deferred its decision
on rehabilitation pending consultation with the concerned interests.
( Vide Government Resolution, Ministry of Food and Agriculture,
dated February 20, 1970). Deducting Rs. 2 from the ex-works
prict worked out by the Commission, the Commission's ex-works
price would be Rs. 126.69 on the basis of 8.70% and 125 days
as average recovery and duration.
It would appear that barring_ the statement in the impugned
order that Government had fixed the price at Rs. 124.63, the
Government had not disclosed even in its return how it had worked out that price. At the instance of the appellants, the· High
A
8
c
0
E
F
G
H
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS l'. UNION
(She/at, !.)
817
A
Court. therefore, by its order dated September 14, 1971 called
upon the Government to show the basis on whi~~ it had fix~ the
price. The Government thereupon filed an add1t10nal affidavit of
the Deputy Secretary to the Ministry of Agriculture dated Septemher 14, 1971 according to which on the available data ~fore lt
th·: price would come to Rs. 126.93. This figure took note of
B tb~ 1ncr~:ise in the purchase tax by Haryana Government from
2.:1 \o 50 paise per quintal of cane. That was how the Government mentioned Rs. 8.003 us the price of cane per quintal instead
of R.~. 7.37 which was the floor price fixed by Government for
the ye~r. Government also added Re. 1.05 being the estimated
impact of increase in wages recommended by the Second Central
c Wage Board, the added depreciation allowed through changes
in the Income Tax Act and increased cost in packing materials,
tile total of all the three having been worked out at Rs. 2.81 per
•1uintal of sugar. According to this affidavit, when Government
was considering the fixation of price for 1970-71, it had before it
the actuals as to recovery and duration for 1969-70 as also the
estimates supplied by the factories for 1970-71. From these, the
ll
Government came to tho conclusion that there would not be any
material difference in recovery and duration between the two year,;
and that was why it decided to continue the ex-factory price for
1969-70 for the year 1970-71 also. The incidence of purchase
tax for 1970-71 was placed at Rs. 2.06, higher than during the
preceding year, because for 1969-70 it was from April 1, 1969,
E while in 1970-71 it was for the whole year. The estimates for
recovery and duration for 1970-71 were on the actual recovery
and duration for the preceding year which came to 8.76% and 187
days, as against the estimates given for that year by the factories,
viz., 9.04% and 157 days. These were accepted for 1970-71 as
the only actuals available to the Government on January 8, 197 !
were
in respect of the month of November 1970, which obviously
F
were too meagre for acceptance for the whole year.
An~exures II and III to this affidavit show that as against the
!cry pnce of Rs. 124.63 fixed by Government, fr~e sugar was sold
G
H
durmg 1969-70 at prices ranging from Rs. 126.21 to Rs. 138.01,
exclusive of excise duty, and from October 1970 to May 25, 1971
when sugar was totally decontrolled at rates ranging from Rs.
'.32.30 to Rs. 151.38. It is undisputed that d;uing the period of
six weeks when the stay order granted by the High Court operated
the appellants sold sugar at about Rs. 150.
. These figures were not accepted by the appellants for according to then:i, they S?ld free sugar during January 197 i to 'May 24,
1.971 at pnces rangmg from Rs. 135.19 to Rs. 160.47, the average
1.1te bemg Rs. 139.70 less Rs. 1.07 differential-Rs 138 63 As
ai-amst the levy price worked out by Government at. Rs. i16.93·.
878
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R.
A
the appellants' case was that on the actuals worked out for the
year 1970-71, the price would be Rs. 129.42, thus causing lo
them a loss of Rs. 5.20 per quintal on levy sugar. The difference
between the price calculated by the appellants and that calculated
by the Government (Rs. 126.93) arises because of certain disparities in their respective figures, as also the percentage in recovery 3:11.d duration. !o the fii:ore <Jf Rs. 129.42, the appellant~
ad_d additional cost of mterest, mcrease in freightage by road and
rail during the year, deterioration in quality, thus bringing the
cost to Rs. 138.93. The loss on this calculation, according to
them, would come to Rs. 3 lacs and odd on levy sugar which
totalled 65,741 quintals.
·
On Government's calculutions based on the returns filed by
the appellants, the Haryana factories realised Rs. 126.50 per r;uintal on levy sugar taking into account the different grades produced
, by them and Rs. 139. 70 per quintal on free sugar upto May 25,
1971 when sugar was decontrolled. If levy sugar alone were to
be taken into consideration, the Joan per quintal of ;evy sugar
would be the difference between Rs. 124.63 and Rs. 129.42, i.e.,
Rs. 6.20, and nearly double if the additional costs claimed by the
appellant6 were to be admissible, which would raise their cost of
production to Rs. 133.98. This calculation is of course on the
b11Sis that the return of Rs. 10.50 per quintal was altogether met,
in the sense that it was not expected to absorb items such i.11 interest and the profits on free sugar were not to be taken into consideration for ascertaining whether a reasonable return on the
capital employed was actually obtained or not by the industry.
The High Court, no doubt, did not hold the price of Rs. 124.63
as realistic and in view of the changes which had taken place during
the year added in all Rs. 3.22, that is, Rs. 1.16 increase in wages,
Rs. 56 additional depreciation and Rs. 1.20 as additional packing
charges, totalling Rs. 2.92 and presumably Rs. 0.30 for increase
in purchase tax. Adding Rs. 3.28 to the Government price, the
High Court worked out the fair price at Rs. 127 .85 instead of
Rs. 124.63. We need not examine the correctness or otherwise
of this addition as the Solicitor General told us that he did not
challenge the correctness of this addition. Ori the basis of Rs.
127.85 being the correct price, the appellants would lose Rs. 3.22
per quintal on levy sugar, if the price realised on levy sugar alone
were to be taken into consideration. The Solicitor General also
conceded that purchase tax on cane in Haryana was increased
during the year 1970-71 from 24 paise to 50 paise per quintal
with effect from April 1, 1970 and that increase according to
para 11 of the return, dated May 1971 was not taken into account
as the Government was of the opinion that the price of 1969-70,
which was adopted for 1970-71, contained sufficient cushion to
II
c
D
E
}
G
H
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS V. UNION
A
(She/at, /.)
879
absorb the impact of this increase. This opinion was based on
the fact that the working results for the year 1969-70 turned out
to be actually very much better than estimated.
8
c
D
E
F
G
H
Counsel for the appellants, however, expressed his dissatisfaction with the increase by the High Court of Rs. 3 .22 only on the
ground that the High Court did not take cognizance of trute
items, viz., increase in purchase tax, increase in the rate of interest
and increase in road and rail freightage. As already stated, the
increase so in purchase tax appears to be included in Rs. 3.22,
granted by the High Court for otherwise the three increases stated
in the judgment, viz., increase in wages, increase in depreciation
and increase in packing charges, would make the total of Rs. 2.22
onJy.
The largest addition in the price claimed by the appellants
was Rs. 2.29 per quintal by way of additional interest. The basis
for the claim was that owing to the. production of sugar in 196970 being the all time highest, there were larger stocks lying unreleased with the factories both in the case of levy as well as free
sugar, with the result that the factories had to bear additional interest on the working capital involved in such unreleased stocks.
The usual period of six months for the release of stock on the basis
of which the return on capital at the static figure of Rs. I 0.50
a quintal had actually become unrealistic. The result, therefore,
was that the factories could not expect to get the said return on
the capital employed.
Since the question was an important one we called upon the
Government to disclose the correspondence, if any, which it had
in this connection with the Tariff Commission. Thereupon the
Government produced the relevant correspondence. It appears
from that correspondence that on March 26, 1970 the Indian
Sugar Mills Association had made a representation for addition in
the ~et~rn of Rs. 10.50 on the ground that the 1969-70 year's
producl!on had come to 42 lac tonnes, an all time record and in
a~dition thereto t~ere _was already at hand a large stock lying undisposed of ~esultmg m the component of working capital being
very IT!u~h higher than that calculated by· the Tariff Commission
wh1!e t.xmg Rs. 10.~0 as the return. On June 5, 1970; the Government referred this representation to the Commission. ljy its
letter.dated July 29, 1970, the Commission recommended that the
quest10n ?f accumulation of stocks as represented by the associa~1011_ reqm~ed sympathetic consideration and suggested ail in¢'tease
m lieu of interest at 9% on the additional working capital represented by the accumulated stock.
. . I? considering this claim however two facts need t~ be borne
m mind. The production in 1970-71 was not as h_igh as that in
880
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
1969-70 and in fact .had considerably declined. So far as the
Ha: yana factories were concern\:(!, :none of them had purchased
cane at a price higher than the minimum fixed by Government,
although the assumption behind the policy of partial control leaving
40% of the stock for free market and the unconventional method
of granting a fixed return of Rs. 10.50 was that these two factors
would enable the manufacturer to pay a higher cane price. The B
figures supplied to us by Government called out from the returns
filed by the factories would also suggest that the claim for Rs. 2.29
per quintal was not warranted. The total production by the
Haryana factories during 1970-71 was of the tune of 82,756
tonnes. Despatches upto May 24, 1971, wheri sugar ~1as decontrolled, of free sugar were 7,065 tonnes at Rs. 139.70 per c
quintal. Despatches of levy sugar, upto the date of the interim
order of stay dated April 8, 1971 were 2,380 tonnes and from
April 8, 1971 to May 24, 1971, 4,194 tonnes at Rs. 158.02 per
quintal. The balance of stock lying with the factories as on June
1, 1971 was 6911. 7 tonnes. Despatches during the decontrol
period, i.e., from June 1, 1971 to December 31, 1971were63,023 D
tonnes at the rate of Rs. 151.39 per quintal, leaving a balance
in hand of 6094 tonnes. It may be mentioned that on June 30.
1972 the stock lying on hand came to 427 tonnes only. Since
this was the position, the claim for additional interest at Rs. 2.29
per quintal does not appear to be sustainable, nor also the claim
for deterioration of stock owing to the stock lying stored up beyond
the normal period, the loss by way of deterioration during such E
period being the normal incidence of the trade which the manufacturer must anticipate.
Regarding the claim of 63 paise owing to increase in freightage
(i.e., of 54 paise by road and 9 paise by rail), the Tariff Commission refused to concede that claim. Even before us there' are
no adequate materials to come to any precise conclusion as to the
extra burden which the appellants had actually to bear, though
increase in freightage during the year is admitted.
F
Have the Haryana factories then not received in fact during
1970-71 the reasonable return as envisaged by sub-s. 3C?
The actual figures of the year for duration and recovery were
not in dispute. They were 162 days and 8.69% respectively. On
that basis, the cost, according to the cost-schedule worked out for
Haryana by the Commission, would come to Rs. 126.61, including
Rs. 10.50. To that amount may be added the following, even
assuming that they are all allowable : ( 1) increase in wages.
Rs. 1.05, (2) increase in depreciation, 56 paise, (3) deterioration
in quality, 19 paise, ( 4) insurance and godo~ costs, 7 yaise, ( ~ l
increase in cost of consumable stores, 19 paise, ( 6) mcrease m
G
H
PANIPAT SUGAR MILLS
A
B
c
D
E
v. UNION (She/at, J.)
881
cost of gunny bags, Re. 1.20, ( 7) increase in freightage by road
and rail, 63 paise, ( 8) interest on longer· storage, Rs. 2.84 a.'ld
(9) selling expooses, 45 paise (tatal Rs. 7.18=Rs. 133.79).
But for the reasons given above, items 3, 7 and 8 (total Rs. 3.66)
must go and therefore the figure would come to Rs. 130.13. As
against this, the realisations for levy_ and free sugar upto the date
of decontrol, i.e., May 24, 1971 were as follows : 63,741 quinta!s
at the average rate of Rs. 124.63 and 70,650 quintals at the
average rate of Rs. 136.49. The average price thus realised comes
to Rs. 130.77. There is no doubt that if the sales after May 24,
1971 which were all in free market were to be taken into account,
the average realised would come to much more than Rs. 130.77.
There is, therefore, no doubt that taking the picture as a whole the
Haryana factories got in any event a reasonable return on the
capital employed.
On the construction of sub-section 3C adopted by us and such
of the materials produced before us, we are of the opinion that no
case for quashing the impugned order has been made out, nor has
the price fixed by Government been shown to be inconsistent whh
the sub-section.
·
In the result the appeals fail and are dismissed. In view of
the somewhat complicated questions as to _the meaning and interpretation of sec. 3 ( 3C) of the Act, we direct that the parties will
bear their own costs althroughoµt. Liberty to the parties to file
applications for directions in respect of the Bank Guarantees furnished by them in pursuance of stay orders passed by this Court.
V.P.S.
Appeals dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org