APREN JOSEPH ALIAS CURRENT KUNJUKUNJU & ORS. versus THE STATE OF KERELA
Supreme Court of India | Decided 1 September 1972 | [1973] 2 S.C.R. 16 | 1972 INSC 204
Key facts
- Decided
- 1 September 1972
- Bench
- J.M. SHELAT*, I.D. DUA*, HANS RAJ KHANNA
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 300/1971
- Disposal
- Disposed off
- Citation
- [1973] 2 S.C.R. 16
- Neutral citation
- 1972 INSC 204
Text of the judgment
ie
.
APREN JOSEPH A.LIAS CURRENT KUNJUKUNJU &: ORS.
A
v.
Tim STATB. OF KBRALA
September l, 1972
{J. M. SHELAT, ACTING C.J., I. D. DUA, AND H. R. KHANNA, II.]
InditJn PtN.:l Codt-S. 302 rtad wth S. 148 imd 149-Mwdtr-EI«t
of btlattd F.I.R. wlrtn fatal.
ln Cr. A. No. 263 of 1971 , accused Nos. 6 to 1~ were acquitted by
the trial_ Court but the High Court reversed the order of acquittal and
convicted them under S. 302/149 and 148 of I.P.C. In Cr. A•.No.~ 300
of 1971, accused Nos. 1 to 5 were convicted under S. 302/148 J.P.C. b7.
both the Courts below.
The alleged occurrence gh·ing rise to the prosecution of the appellants
took place on the night be!ween· December 13 and 14 at about 2 a.m. as
a result of political animosity between two groups of peoplo-the Marxists
and the agriculturists called the "Karshak Sangham", in Puthupally village
in Kottayam, Ker6la. 'The eye-witnesses, for fear of retaliation, did not
rep(!rt the crim~·to.the police. Only on the next day, a member of the
1~1 panc~ayat (P.W 2) , lodged :t~e F.I.R. at 8 A.M. at Kottayam East
Pollee Stallon, 9 JCM. away from the place of occurrence.
.B
c
()
Before this Court, tile 'following points were raised on behalf of the
appellants :-(i) that the first information report i! highly belated and
(ii) that the alleged eye-witnesses did not lodge the c:omplaint' becauae
they h;~d in fact not w:tnessed the oc;curre'lce, and the accused have been
falsely implicated. Partly allowing the app~al,
HELD : ('i) The Fir: t Information Report relating to the commissior.t
elf an offence is not a condition precedent to the setting in motion of II'
~rim!nal
investigation. [23 C]
R. V. Khwaja, I.L.R. [1945] Lah. I, re'ferred to.
Nor does the statute provide· that such informatiOn r.:port can ooJy
be made by 2.'1 eye-w:tness. F.I.R. is not even considered a substantive
piece of evidence. It can only be used to corroborate or c:ootradict tbe
informants' evidence in court. But this information ·when recorded
is the basis of the case set up by the informant. It is very useful it
F
recorded before there is time and opportunity to embeUisb, or before the
informants' memory fades.
Undue or unreasonable .delay lodging the F.I.R., therefore, give. rise
to suspicion which put the Court on guard to look for the possible motive
and the explanation for the delay and consider its effect on the trustworthj..
ness of the prosecution ve~ion. No duration of time in the abstract can
be fixed a< reasonably for giving information of a crime to the police, the
question of reasonable time being a matter foe determ·i natioa by the court
. in each case. [23 E)
(ii) In the pre~Cnt case, the eye-witnesses were tiraid to go to cbt
police station during night time and their evidence could Dot be shabcl
in cros~amination. Keeping 'i n view the local tense atmosphere aod
the effect of the ghastly murder on the eye-witnesses, their strong· di!inclication to go and lodge the repott ·during the night after the alltged
.,
'I
H
• ·• · ·· . APREN JOSEPH l'. KERAL.\ ·
.A
B
c
D
17
o~c_urrcnce, which seems ~uitc nOJ·m;~l, cannot by itself arouse any sus-
piCIOn about the prosecution case. Further, the prosecution version -as
a whole, has al!>o been :1ccepted by both the Courts below for rea~ons
which cannot be said to he uns<.HtnJ or implausible. Therefore, the:
Jclay in m:~king the F.l.R. hao; rt..~~o:1ahly been expl:1inecl by the prosecvtion wit nesscs.
(iii) Tt is not &·putcd and inth:eu r-Oth the Courts below have found
that on December 12, 1970, there was full moon, aod as such, there was
moon-light at the time · of the occurrence. The ne:lrest street light wa•
ahout 130 ft. away t-ow-:~ rds the \'.C';t and th:: n-:ar~st electric post on
the eastern side was ;:.bou t 90 ft. tm ay from the place of occurrence.
The light of the lorry, which was :.1< the pbc.:, :!:; o hcli)cJ -.yc witnes~cs
to clearly !.C.:: who the assailants were. Th.:: C"licurrc:-ot c ~ :lc!c! :; )n of the
tl'lo Courts below leaves no doubt that the witnesses prc-;r.nt r.• the place
of occurrence were in a p0sition to ch::ar!y t;cc a'"~d identify the acc\L<;eJ
pcnons "ho \\"ere not strangers to them. Th.:rdon::. conviction of accus-:<.1 No;. I to 5 under S. 30:! 1. P.C. anJ S. 14S i~ uphclJ as also the
•.cntcncc under S. 148 I.P.C. Accused No. 6 h~s also h:en rightly founJ
guilty and his sentence is ulso confirmt!J.
(iv) As regards ac'q1~.::J No'i. 7 to 10. they llid not form an unlawful assembly with the common ohjcct l,f 1-.illing the d..:ccascd. Thcrdorc,
they arc acquitted.
Khanna 1. !Jiuentins:) He~J ( iJ From the c\:u.::nc-: on record it
wus Jifficul! to subscribe to -the view th~~ the \\ itnc;;o;cs refrained from
reporting the muller to the pulicc ~oon aft'!r the occurrence because of fear.
The witn.:":·"> h;.J not got nto th:: lorry while the acc\Jscd were on foot.
It would nut have t:1kcn the lorry more than t5 or :o m inutes to rc:-tcb
the police ~t;:.t"on. Further, it cannot he said that the witnesses were not
conscious cf t!l.: necessity of informing th~ pollee about the occurrc1cc.
(ii) E\"Cn if the witnesses wcr~ afr:J.id h) go to the police station . in
the ni~ht, they t~ould h·Jvc gonl.l to thc station in the morning because
they did not remain confined in thdr homcc;; hut were mavin~ nbout and
go to difTu~·ot places on the ftlllowing morning, there is no !atisfactory
explanation as to why they diJ not ~o to the police station anJ make a
report. Their f;Jilurc to report to the police the follo\-\-ing day, creates
<.-on~iJ.:r;~bJc doubts ubout the veracity of their evidence.
Tlwli!. Kali v. St<ll<' t~/ Tamil Nadu, Cr. A. 165/71 decided on Fcbni- .
ary :!5, 1972. rl'fcrrcJ to.
. (iii) Further, the pro>ccution evidence is of a partis:m character.
(iv) Thl.' cir~1unhlaflCC\ of tho.: ca~c tend hl ~how that the dccea~cd
1':." l..ilkd ;,r a Iilli! hour durin!! the nig.ht Pl'hl~n O.:cembcr 13 :1nd 14,
I 'J70 y, h.:n he wa' coming twm a place \\here h..: haJ taken toddy. The
f:u;t th:tt no rcpo1 t 11 ·'' ltlJ~cJ with the polic.: llurin~; the night and no
IHlC '>'cr.t
the 1illa~~: or r;1twd •• hu~ anJ cry kmls to show that no on.:
t•'
\I:J' pr.:>~n t
alnng \1 ith tho.' J.:c.:<ht..'<l >II th;ll tim!!. Therefore, it i~ Ol1t
po"'hlo.: r·.> ,tl'>l;1in th.: Cllllvktit1:l of the r..ccu.;.:u appellants on the e\'iu~·~~~·\! :1ddt•c,•d in th,; ~;;,:.
CIU\f!S.\L AI'I'FLLAlF JlllUSDICTIO~: Crimin:.tl ,\ppe:lls 't\'~h.
~OfJ ~tnJ 263 of 1971 .
II
Ai'r~:tl-.; from the jud~m.:nt and on.l.:r JatcJ Augu-.t ~-+. t lJ71
1'f th.: !:..:r;1L Ili~2h Court in Criminal 1\tmcals Nos. ! 6h ltl
::nJ R. T. "\'~'. 15 of 1971 an•.l Cr. A r-.:ll. 25 !0 1 71.
! 6S
[1973) 2 s.c.a.
18
A. S. R. Chari, N. Sudhakaran and P. Kesava Pillai, for the
appellants. (in both the appeals).
V. A. Seivid Muhmud and M. R. Krishna Pillai, for the res~
pondenr (in Cr. A. No. 263/71).
V. A. S('iyid Mulmuui and A. G. Pudissery, for respondent (in
Cr. A No. 300/71).
The Judgment of Shelat, Acting C.J. and Dua, J. was delivered
by Dua, J. Kb.uma. J. delivered a dissenting opinion.
DuA, J.-The.~~ are two appeals (Crl. A.-no. 263 of 1971 and
Crl. A. no. 300 of 1971) against a common judgment of the
Kerala High Court disposin~ of four appeals (3 separate appeals
'by accused nos. 1 :o 5 ctmvicted by the Additional Sessions Judge,
Kottayam and one appeal by the State against the acquittal of
accused nos. 6 w I 0) affirming the conviction and sentence of
accused nos;, 1 to ~ and reversing lhc order of acquittal of accused
nos. 6 to 10, convicting them under ss. 302/149, I.P.C. as also
under s. 148, I.P.C. Accuscct nos. 1 to 5 have been sentenced
to death by both the trial court and the High Court under s. 302.
I.P.C. and to rigorous imprisonment for one year under s. 148.
t.P.C. whereas accused nos. 6 to 10 have been sentenced to imprisonment for life by the High Court under s. 302/149~ I.P.C.
and to rigo!"ous imprisonment for one year under ·s. 148, I.P.C.
All the ten accused persons have appealed to this Court and they
arc:
A
1S
c
D
E.
I. Apren Joseph alias Current Kunjukunju,
2. Kochukunju Vasu alias Thankappan,
3. Velu Damodaran,
4. Kt:savan Kumaran alias Kochu,
5. 'Cherian Mathew aUas Scaria.
6. Mundan Poulose alias Baby.
7. Yohannan Pothan alias Kochu.
f
8. Gangadiuiran Bhaskaran.
9. Kutty Chellappan alias Jruttu.
10. Kunchan ~ukumaran.
G
This is also the order in which these ten persons appeared as
accused in the trial.
Criminal Appeal No. 263 of 1971 has been presented to this
Court under s. 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appeal Jurisdiction) Act, no. 28 of 1970 by accused nos.
6 to 10 whose acquittal by the trial court was reversed by the
H
. APREN JOSEPH v, KERALA (Dua, J.)
19
High Comt on appeal by the State Criminal Appeal No. 300 of
1971 under Art. 136 of the Constitution has been presented by
accused nos. 1 to 5.
B
c
0
£
The alleged occurrence giving rise to the prosecution of the
appellants took place at abPut 1 O'clock on the night between
December 13 and 14, 1970 at a place on Manarkad-Tenganal
road on the southern side of Kalappurakat dispensary of Baby in
Puthupal!y village in Kottayam. The occurrence is stated to be
tbc result of political animosity between the members of the
~larxht party and the members of an organisation of agriculturists
called "Karshak Sangham" at Puthupally ef which the deceased
Kuru\i1!a was the Vice-President.
On the evening of December 13, there was a meeting of the
K:w.haka Sangham near the Puthupally junction and it was over
~~t about 10-30 p.m.
After attending the. meeting (Pappu)
Joseph (P.W. 1) and Joseph Cheriaa (P.W. 4) along with one
Baby started for going home. Kuruvilla who met them at the
Puthupully junction requested them to accompany him to the
house of Yesu Kathanar (Christian priest) (P.W. 5) which was
on the western side of Puthupally junclion. They readily agreed
with the result they all went together to the house of the priest
along the Manarkad-Thcnganat road. That road runs east to
west. While Puthupally junction is on the eastern side Eramallur
junction is on the western side of this road. In order to reach
the house of the priest one has. to go through Eramallur junction.
After KuruvilJa had a talk with P.W. 5 and when they were .
returning through the same route, at the place of occurrence
which is about 7 furlongs <lway from the house of P.W. 5 they
met Mathayikutty (Mathayi) (P.W. 3) driving a lorry and coming
from the opposite direction. On seeing them P.W. 3 stopped his
lorry. One Achankunju was also in the lorry with P.W. 3. After
~topping the lorry P.W. 3 told these four persons ~hat accu»N
no. 2 and others were coming that way armed with deadly
weapons.
W, 3 accordingly asked these lour persons not to
proceed towards Puthupally junction. at thl! same time offering to
take them in his lorry. Dy the time this conversation was over
the accused had alreaJy reached the seen~ of occurrence. As soon
4lS they arrived there accused no. 1 Apren Joseph struck a blow
with his chopper on Kuruvilla's hi!au. Kuruvilla tried to ward it
off with his right hand but WJS not successful. Accused nos. 2
and 3 (Kochukunju Vasu and Velu Damodaran) who had choppers in their hands also gave blows with their respective weapons
on the back of Kuruvilla's head. This was followed by the fin.t
accused giving two more blows at Kuruvilla's right shoulder. TI1~
fourth accused Kesavan Kumaran stabbed Kuruvilla on his back
with Mallapuram knife. The fifth accused Cheri:m Mathew alsQ
r.
G
Jl
·;..;·
..
k
~
~-·
'.
\
'·r
f
..-
'~ .
~
~.
1
i
j-.
20
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973)2 S.C.R.
struck Kuruvilla thrice with an iron rod on his chest, Kuruvilla
fell down and died after sometime. P.Ws 1 and 4 and Baby
managed to. get into the lorry when Kuruvilla was ~ing beaten
though while doing so they implored the accused persons not to
kill Kuruvilla. However, P.W. 3 with the three men who got
into the lorry at the place of occurrence (P.Ws I and 4 and Baby)
and Achankunju who was already in the lorry drove away towards
the west. The sixth accused Mundan .Poulose hit him with a
wooden spear. As the lorry started moving, the accused pelted
stones at it. After dropping Achankunju at Eramaloor junction
Mathayi (P.W. 3) took P.Ws 1 and 4 and Baby Jto the house ·of
P.W. 5 and dropped them there. Thereafter P.W. 3 went to his
own house. On account of fear he, however, did not go back
towards his home by the same road but took a different route.
Early on the morning of December 14, 1.970 Markose_~anL
(P.W. 2) who is a member of the local Panchaya1 came ·to know
of Kuruvilla's dea.th. He went to the scene of the occurrence and
saw the dead body of the deceased. After getting whatever .information he could gather there he went to Kottayam East police
station, 9 k.m. away, and lodged the first information report. (Ex.
P-1) at about 8 a.m. According to this -report Markose Mani
,came to know of Kuruvilla's death at about 5 O'clock early in
the morning of December J 4, 1970. Having gone to the spot he
saw the dead body of the deceased. He noticed that the 1ittle
linger of the right hand of the deceased had been cut off and the
ring finger was hanging due to a cut. There were also cut in·
juries on the back of the head of the deceased. After stating
what he had seen the informant proceeded to state :
" ..... There was a meeting and· procession of
farmers at the Puthupally junction yesterday. The meet~
ing was over at 10-30 in the night. Deceased Kunju
Kalappurakkal Baby, Padinjarekoothu Pappa, Inchalk~
kad Kochu and some others had gone from Puthupally
to take back the persons who had come from Eramallur
for the procession. What I came to know is that while
they were returning afte.r getting down the persons who
had tor the procession at Kochalum Moodu somE l:x>dy
killed him by inflicting cut injudes· at about 2 O'clock
in the night at the place where the dead body lay. It
is heard that Acbankala Vaslu, Valia Veettil Pothan.
·current Kunju Kunju, Carpenter Damodaran, Inchakad
Bhaskaran and some others b~longing to the Marxist
party who are opponents .of the faqners had followed
. the persons who had gone to Eramallur after the meetat Puthupally held on yesterday and while Kunju etc.,
A
B
c
D
I
E
F
G
H ·
APREN JOSEPH v. KERALA (Dua, J.)
:n
t
A
8
c
0
E
F
G
.. H
were returning from Kochalummoodu. Somebody
among them killed Kunju by inflicting cut injuries at
that place by attacking him. The dead body of Kunju
is lying there. I am the member of the IV Ward in
Puthupally Panchayat. I have come over here to report
the matter. The place of occurrence is 9 k.m. away
towards south-east from here ... , .•,
The Additional Sessions Judge trying the case found accused
nos. 1 to 5 guiHy of an offence under s. 302, I.P.C. and sentenced
them to death. They were also found guilty of an offence under
s. 148, I.P.C. and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for one
year each. Accu!,ed nos. 6 to 10 were, however, acquitted of
all the charges, reliance for the order of acquittal having been
placed on a decision of this Court in Ma.mlti etc. v. State of Uttar
Ptadesh ( L).
The convicted persons and the State, both appealed to the
High Court of Kerala. The High Court, in a fairly exhaustive
judgment, affirmed the convictions and sentences of accused nos.
1 to 5 and dismissed their appeals. The reference in regard to
their death sentence was accepted. The State appeal against the
acquittal of accused nos. 6 to 10 was allowed and their acquittal
set aside. They were sentenced to imprisonment for life under
s. 302/149, I.P.C. and to rigorous imprisonment for one year
under s. 148. I.P.C. The sixth accused was also sentenced to
rigorous imprisonment for one year under s. 324, I.P.C. for eaus~
ing injury (an incised wound) with a wooden spear to Joseph
Cherian (P.W. 4).
Before us it was strongly t:rged by Shri Chari on behalf of
the appellants that -lhG first information report was lodged afteJ:
a very long delay any this in the drcumstnnces of the case is
fatal to the prosecution. The submission most seriously pressed.
and this appears to us to be the basic subcrnission which is sought
to be supported by reference to other faotors. is that- no one had
actually witness~d the occurrence and that the v.·hole of the prosecution story has been fabricated with the object of falsely im·
plicating all the accused persons, who are enemies of the· prosecution witnesses. The story invented by the prosecution, it was
argued, is the work of a highly imaginative and fertile brain. The
first jnfonnation report, contended Shri Chari in his usual forceful manner, was lodged after a long delay because a plausible
story had to be built up .involving the accused so as to fit in with
the murder of the deceased at the place where his dead body was
found. and this, emphasised the counsel. was the real cause for
II) [l%4j 8 S.C.R. n~.
22
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
not l?dgin_g the report immediately after the alleged occurrence.
The mterval between 'the alleged occurrence and the time when
the prosecution story was unfolded to the police was, according
to the submission, uti1ised in inventing the story to be placed
before the police.
Now if this argument is accepted then obviously the prosecution story has to be rejected and all the appellants acquitted. We
have, therefore, to seriously examine the challen~e to the proiecution story on the basis of the argument that the first information report is highly belated and that the alleged eye witnesses did
not lodge it because they had in fact nCl't witnessed the occurrence.
A
D
It may be pointed out that the factum of the unnatural death c
of the deceased by violence at the place where his dead body was
found is not disputed; nor has the time of his death been controverted. The sole argument vehemently pressed upon .us is, that
no one saw the deceased b~ing murdered and the accused ha Je
been falsely implicated, on account of enmity, by the prosecution
witnesses who have deposed to an imaginary story concocted by
<them. There is of course no dispute that there was considerable D
ill-will between the workers of the Marxist party in the local
Puthupalli area and the members "of the Krishak Sangham.
fndeed, even according to the accused, there had been a quarrel
between these two groups about 20 days prior to the occurrence
in dispU'te. Some of the accused persons were involved :in other
criminal cases as well. But enmity as is well-known is a double· E
.edged weapon. Whereas the accused may rely on it in support
of their plea of false implication, the prosecution on the 'other
har.d may legitimately argue that this provided the necessary
motive for ~the offence. It is that none of the persons who claim
to have been with the deceased since ·about 10-30 p.m. right
up to the time of occurrence informed the police or made any F
attempt to do so : nor did K. Achan Kunju who was sitting in
the lorry next to Mathayi (P.W. 3). Mathayi, however, does state
in his evidence that he made an attempt to contact the police on
telephone but the telephone line being out of order he did not succeed. This, he did, from the house of Attupurathu Punnachan
where he stopped for this purpose on his way back home from G
the house of Achan (P.W. 5). The contention forcefully pressed
before us is that P.W. 3 who was driving the lorry could have
driven straight to the police station and lodged the necessary infonnation. Indeed, the submission proceeds like this. After
having left the scene of the alleged murder P.W. 3 and his companions in tlte lorry could and .should have gone straight to the
police station to lodge the first infonnation report. In any event H
P.W. 3, who, on his own showing, tried to contact the police on
telephone but failed to do so as the telephone line was out of
APREN JOSEPH v. KERALA (Dua, /.)
\
order, could and s!lould, after this unsuccessful attempt, ·have
proceeded in his lorry to the police station to make the report.
This should have been considered to be more hnportant than going to his home. The fact that none of these persons considered
it important enough or even pmper to go and lodge the first information report shows that no one witnessed the murder and
the whole story deposed by the prosecution witnesses in court is
a concoction which is the outcome of the fertile brain of P.Ws. l.
3,. 4 and 5 aod does not represent the truth.
B
c
D
,
E
F
Now first information report is a report relating to the colUluission of an offence given to the police and recorded by it under
s.154, Cr. P.C. As observed by the Privy Council in /1.£. v.
Khwaja(') the receipt und recording of information feport by
the police is not a condition precedent to the setting in motion of
a criminal investigation. Nor does the statute provide that such
irformation report can only be made by an eye witness. First
information report under s. 154 is not even considered a substantive piece of evidence. It can only be used to corroborate or
contradict the informant's evidence in court. But this information
when ·recorded is the basis of the case set up by the informant.
It is very useful. if recorded before there is time and opportunity
to embellish or before the informant's memory fades. Undue
or unreasonable delay in lodging the F .l.R., therefore, inevitably
gives rise to suspicion which puts the court on guard to look
for the possible motive and the explanation for the delay and
consider its effect on the trustworthiness or otherwise of the
prosecution version. In our opinion, no duration of time in the
abstract can be fixed as reasonably for giving information of a
crime to the police, the question of reasonable time being n
matter for detennination by the court in each case. Mere delay
in lodging the first infonnation report with the police is. therefore, not necessarily, as a matter of law, fatal to the prosecu~
tion. The effect of delay in doing so in the light of the plausibility of the explanation forthcoming for such delay accordingly
must fall for consideration· on all the facts and circumstances of
a given case.
G
).,
f-1
In the case in hand the eye witnesses who had seen . the
occurrence were afraid of going to the police station during
night time. The evidence to this effect seems to us to be trustworthy and has not at all been shaken in cross-examination.
The submission that no reasonable human being in those circumstances could or should have felt frightened and, therefore,
the ground of fear is a mere excuse is unacceptable. Indeed,
there is hardly any effective cross·e)(amination on the· point
0) T.t.R. 1945 L:lh, I.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R.
eliciting any illuminating information indicative of suspicion A
with respect to their reluctance to go, during the night or early
in the morning, to the police station for making the report. The
effect on their mind of having witnesses such a gruesome murder
at the hands of a group of persons armed with lethal weapons
and extremely inimical to the eye witnesses, cannot be measured
by any general yard-stick. It necessarily depends on the mental B
make up of each individual person. Some may feel so frightened
that they would rue their decision which took them to the place
of occurrence and would tak-e a long time to be their normal
self, whereas some others would not mind informing the police
if they can conveniently do so without going out of their way:
still others may be highly public-spirited and may, therefore. c
feel so strongly that they would in their enthusiasm go all out.
as though inspired by missionary seal, to contact the police and
infonn them about the crime. · It is difficult as also inadvisable
to lay down any uniform general rule in this respect. As each
case has to be considered on its ~wn facts and circumstances let
us see how the courts berow -.have dealt with this question. The D
trial court repelled the defence contention in these words :
"It has been pointed out on behalf of the defence
that none of the persons who were along with the
deceased informed the police. P.W. · 3 swears that he
made an attempt to contact the police over phone.
But because of some line disorder he could not infonn
the police. P.W. 2 is the Panchayat Member of
Ward no. 4 of Puthupally Panchayat. He got information in the early hours of morning and went to the
Thereplace of occurrence <}nd sav..· the deceased.
after he proceeded to the police st<2tion and gave Ex.
P 1 statement, The fact that none of the persons who
was present at the time of occurrence did not infom1
the police is not sufficient to warrant a conclusion that
the alleged eye witnesses were not present there."
1n the High Court also this criticism "Was repeated but met with
no better fate. This is what Narayana Pillai J., said in this
connection :
"
One has· to visualise the situation in
which P .Ws. 1 and 4 and Baby were at the time.
There were many active members and sympathisers
of the Marxist Party at Puthupally. That party had
strong foothold there. The 1Oth accused was the
Secretary of that party there. The formation of tbe
Karshaka Sangham which was opposed to the Marxist
Party was not to the liking of members of the Marxist
F
G
H
AI'RE:'-i JOSEPH \', KERALA
(Dua, J.)
Party. Ten to tw~nty Jays before the occurrence there
was a quarrel between members of the Marxist Party
and the Karshaka Sanghams at Eramalloor about the
putting up of bunds on paddy fiields. There was also
a quarrel between Kuruvilla and members of the Marxist Party about agricultural labour at one Puthukari
B
field which belongs to several persons. The whole
atmosphere must have been surcharged with tear after
the meeting of the Karshaka Sangham on the 13th
evening was over. There was no residential house
anywhere near the scene. The road there was desolate. There was, therefore. nothing unusual if P.Ws. L
3 and 4 and Baby left the place at the time of the
c
occurrence for safety instead of remaining there to
render assistance to Kuruvilla. Although P.W. 3 had
before the occurrence offered to take P.Ws. 1 and 4
and Baby in his lorry, ·after the occurrence he thought
that to take them in his lorry was risky and tllat was
why at the Eramalloor junction he asked them to get
D
out of the lorry. P.W.s l and 4 and Baby were in a
room in the house of P.W. 5 for the rest of the night.
At 7.15 a.m. P.W. 1 went out of that house."
Moidu J ., in a separate concurring note dealt with this mattelmorc specifically and observed ;
E
''The only circumstance pointed out during the
argument of the learned counsel was that these witnesses could not have seen the occurrence and that if
they had seen thi!y would have reported the incident
to the police without delay. The evidence was clear
to show that these witnesses \vould not have dared to
get
out of the place \Vhcre they stayed in the night after
F
the gruesome murder was committed. Neither P.W. 1
nor P.W. 4 was prepared to get out of the house of
P.W. 5 at midnight. P.W. 3 had to go to his house
hv a different route and though he made an attempt to
inform the police he did not succeed. On the next
day P.W. 3 had to go to Erumeli with the lorry and
G
he returned home only by about 5.30 p.m. Within a
short time thereafter he was questioned by the police."
From this it is obvious that keeping in view the local tense atmosphere and the effect of this ghastly murder on the eye witnesses their strong disinclination to go and lodge the report
du~ing the night after the alleged occurre~c~, which seems quit~
H
naturaL cannot by itself arouse any susptcton . about t~e. prosecution ·case. The bad condition of the road, not penmtttng the
lorry to go faster than six or ten miles per hour. ac; stated by
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 S.C.R.
P.W. 3, may also have consciously or unconsciously detened
them, to some extent, from risking a visit to the police station
during the night. In this connection it would not be unimporJ.ant to bear in mind that P.W. 3 did not possess a driving licence
and he would naturally have hesitated in driving the lorry to
the police station. The concurrent conclusions of the two courts
below on this point deserve serious consideration and cannot
be Jigh~ly brushed aside. But that apart, it would also need a
highly creative and fertile brain to cook up an imaginary story
embodying in it, the peculiar .features of the prosecution case .
.and that also within a short span of time, after learning of the
murder on the morning of December 14, 1970 and before making the statement to th~ police at noon the same day as deposed
by P.Ws. 1 and 14. In fact P.W. 2, a member of Panchayat.
who is no partisan and whose statement is corroborated by
P.W. 14 had, already informed the police (per Ex. P-1) much
earlier at about 9 a.m. about what he had seen at the place of
oOccurrence and what he had heard involving five accused
persons: This adds to the vu~nerabi1ity of the defence version.
Features which seem peculiar for their insertion in an imaginary
story which could hardly be circulated so early as to reach
P.W. 2 to enable him to go tothe spot and then to go to lodge
·the F.I.R. at 9 a.m. arc (i) bringing on the scene (a) a lorry
driven by its owner (P.W. 3) who does not belong to Karshak
Sangham and who nonnally does not drive that lorry and does
not even possess a driving licence but has employed a wholelime driver for the said lorry; (b) th~ other eye witnesses along
with the companion of P.W. 3, Kadiyathuruthil Achan Kunju
who has not appeared as a witness, (ii) to make P.W. 3 drive
1he eye witnesses to the house of Achan for dropping them there~
after having dropped Kadiayathuruthil Achan Kunju on the
road, and finally (iii) on his way back home to make P.W. 3
attempt unsuccessfully to contact the police on telephone from
the house of Attupura$u Punnachan. What is more intriguing
'is that as many as ten accused persons should have been in·
volved but only five assigned overt acts in th~ murder and one
only an injury with a wooden spear to P.W. 4, the rest (including accused no 10, the Secretary of the Marxist Party) beh1g
only involved as members of the unlawful assembly. In the
absence of a plausible and rational explanation as to whv only
accused nos. 1 to 5 should have been selected bv the author of
1hi~ concocted imaginary version for the direct and active role
·in the murder, this feature also tends to dhcount the credibility
of the defence version. Now, assuming sucli' a fictional stOJ)'
t~ have been. invented i~ retrospect, for this is the only a1tematrve to the WJtnesses bavmg actualJy seen the commission of the
murder. one has to ponder to find a rational and plausible ans-
B
c
D
E
r;.
H
Al'REN JOSEPH v. KERALA
A
B
c
f)
.,.
E
F
G
(Dua, J.)
27
wer to several puzzling ~estions. To begin with it is not understood where was the necessity of introducing P.W. 3 insteact of
his driver. And then what was the reason for bringing Kadiyathuruthil Achan Kunju in the picture when he was not to
appear as a witness. lt is also not easy to understand, on the
evidence and in the peculiar circumstances of this case, as to
how the prosecution witnesc;es deposing about the occurrence,
other than P.W. 3, managed to get together for consultation.
after learning of the murder and incn how. where and when.
did they contact P.W. 3 with the object of prevailing upon him
to take up the important role in this drama and subscribe to
this imaginary story. P.W. 3 was cros<>-examincd at great length
but his credibility was not at all shaken. He said in a forthright manner that he had reached his house on the fateful night
at about 2 a.m. and on the following morning at about 6 or
7 ·O'clock he went to Erumalloor from where he returned -at
5.30 p.m. and it was then that he learnt about Kunju's death.
He had. however, narrated the incident to his wife and brother
!>n reaching his house at 2 a.m. His statement was recorded by
the police at about 7 p.m. on his return from Eramalloor. His
testimony apoears to be straightforward and imoressive, and it
has been believed by the courts below. No convincing argument has been advanced for differing with their view. In a
concocted story P .W. 3 could not reasonably have been assigned
a role of such vital imPOrtance. Indeed, his presence seems to
be a strong factor which renders the defence theory incredible
and establishes the truth of the prosecution version. But apart
fn>m the inherent weakness of the theory of the story having
been concocted to fa1se1y imolicate the accused persons, the
prosecution version as a whole has also been accented bV both
the trial court and the Hh:!h Court for reasons which cannot be
said to be unsound or imolau<;ible. In fact, there appears 10
be a ring of intrinsic truth in this version.
The trial court believed the version given by P.W. 4 as also
the tesHmonv of P. Ws. 1. 3 and 5. P.W. 5 was not an eve
witness to the occurrence but he fully corroborated that the
deceased and P.Ws.l, 4 and Babv had gone to him bv 11.30 p.m.
and later at 1.30 a.m. The three persons, other than the dece~s
~d. returned to him and informed him of the occurrence. The
trial court felt that P.W. 5 had no reason to falsely swear against
the accused. The sto•.., given bv P.Ws 1. 3 and 4 was consirlered
bv the trial court to b.! sonc:;~ tcnt and reliable. The High Court
in an exhaustive judgment after di~cu~sing the criticism levelled
a)!ainst the orosecution version observed :
"We have carefully gone through the cnti:-~ evidence of all the witnesses. On all material matters the
28
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R.
evidence of P.Ws 1, 3 and 4 is clear, consistent and
convincing. All the facts spoken to by them strike as
nothing but truth. Tht(y are quite natural witnesses.
There is absolutely nothing in their evidence to disbelieve them. They corroborate each other. Their
evidence i-; abo corroborated by the circumstances
brought out in the case. The trial Judge believed them
and we cordider rightly. It is proved beyond reasonable doubt that it was in the manner spoken to by
P.Ws 1, 3 and 4 that the occurrence took place.''
We have not been persuaded to hold that these concurrent
cooclusions of the two courts arc in any wa)• tainted by an infirmity justi~ying interference by us in the present appeal so far as
accused nos. 1 to 5 are concerned whose appeal has been prosented under Art. 136 of the Constitution. Even otheiWise the
conclusions arc unexceptionable on the material to which our
attention is drawn and we unhesitatingly agree with them. It is
not disputed and indeed both the courts below have found that
on December 12, J970, there was full moon and as such there
was moonlight at the time of the occurrence. The nearest street
light is also stated to be about 130 ft. towards the west and the
nearest electric post on the eastern side was about 90 ft. away
from the place of occurrence. The light of the lorry also helped
the eye witnesses to clearly sec who the assailants were. The
concurrent. conclusion of the two courts below leaves no doubt
that the witnesses present at the place of the occurrence were in
a position to clearly see and identify the accused persons who
were not strangers to them.
The lriere fact that the eye witnesses did not gather up
enough courage to go to the police station to lodge the first information report or to go to the place of the occurrence during the
night or early in the following morning to give some aid to the
deceased, who undoubtedly was no blood-relation of any one of
the witnesses, does not show that they had not witnessed the
occurrence and the whole story is imaginary and made up only
for falsely implicating the accused due to enmity. P.W. 3 having
decided to go home with the lorry. the other witnesses quite
naturally did not dare to move about during the nigh't. The conviction of accused Nos. 1 to 5 under s. 302 I.P.C. and s. 148 is
upheld as also the sentence under s. 148 I.P.C.
In so far as accused no. 6 is concerned the High Court has
believed the testimony of P.W. 4 which is corroborated by the
medical evidence. We see no reason to differ with the conclusion of the High Court. He must, therefore, be held to have
been nghtly found guilty of inflicting injury with the wooden
B
c
D
E
G
H
APREN JOSEPH v. KEllALA
A
.B
D
E
F
G
H
.,1.
(Dua, J.)
29
spear on P.W. 4. The sentence imposed on him is also not
open to any objection. This injury was apparently not inflicted
pursuant to the common object to kill the deceased but only when
provoked by P.W.4.
This t<tkes us to the case of accused nos. 7 to 10 who have
been convicted by the High Court of an offence uneler s. 148,
I.P.C. It IS true that these accused persons were accompanying
the others but no overt act has been imputed to them. The
entire occurrence seems to have taken place within a short span
of time and it is difficult to hold that they formed an unlawful
assembl} with the common object of killing the deceased. No
doubt, in their case this Court has to go into the entire evidence
because their appeal had been presented under Act No. 2S of
1970. The evidence does not seem to show that they were aware
of the common object of accused nos. 1 to 5 to kill the deceased.
They must, therefore, be acquitted of the charge under ss. 308/
149. Evidence is also wanting on the record to show that these
accused persons were parties to any common object or committing
any unlawful act which accused nos. 1 to 5 had in view. We
have, therefore, no hesitation in acquitting them of the charge
under s. l 48, l.P.C. as well. On the same reasoning accused
no. 6 is also acquitted of charges under ss. 302/149 and s. l4R .
. Indian Penal Code.
We should like to point out that in this case the learned counsel for the appellants was penuittcd to refer to any evidence he
considered proper for considering the credibility of the witnesses
with regard to the whole of the prosecution story because with
respect to accused nos. 6 to 10 the appeal was not before us
under Art. 133 of the Constitution but under s. 2(a) of the
Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
Act, 28 of 1970. It was, therefore, only proper that the evidence
be appraised by this Court with respect to all the accused persons, in order to avoid conflict in the conclusions in this respect.
Coming to the question of sentence imposed on accused nos.
to 5, after the amendment of s. 367(5), Cr.P.C. in 1955 it is
a matter of judicial discretion for the court to decide on a consideration of all the relevant circumstances of th~ case, which of
the two pem1issible sentences under s. 302, I.P.C. should be
imposed. It is no longer necessary to give reasons for the lessrr
penalty. The detennination of sentence in a given case depenas
on a variety oi considerations, the more important being, the
nature of the crime, the manner of its commission, the motive
which· impelled it and the character and antecedents of the
accused. So far <ts the accused before us 'lfe concerned it
30
•.t
SUPREtfE COURT REPORTS
(1973] 2 S.C.R,
appears that in their excessive .zeal f<;>r their p~rty they felt undulv
provoked by the success of the meetmg orga ntsed by the Karshak.
San&ham and being m~sguided by . politic.al intolerance and cult
of VIOlence they committed the offences m question soon after
the said meeting. We, therefore, feel that the interest of justice
would be fully served in this case if we substitute the sentence
of impri~onmcnt for· me for the sentence ·of deatlt. We, how- n
ever, must not be understood to lay down any general rule with
regard to sentence applicable to all cases of political murders.
Murder inspired by dilfcrences of politicnl opinions ·as idcoloaics.
it may be pointed out, is wholly inconsistent with our svste~ of
government \'!here the Con~titLttion has guaranteed frceJom of
thought and expression to all citizens and patties. so lono- as thcv
act within the Constitution and the law. We have red~tced th~ · C
sentence of death to tbut of li[c impri<;onmcnt OH accused nos. 1
to 5 in thi-; case because of the peculiur circumstances already
mentioned. The sentence under s. 148 I.P.C. woultl be concerned with the sentence under s. 302 l.P.C.
_ The appeals arc accordingly di,poscd of as
JUdgment.
,
stated
in
thi..;
KHANNA, J. Ten accused Apren Jo:-.cph (36), Kochukunju
Vasu (32), Vclu Th:modaran (32). Kcs;mtn Kumaran (24),
Chcrian Mathew (34), Mudan Poulose (30), Yohanna Pothen
(45), Gangadharan Bhaskaran (24). Kutty Chcllappan (42} and
Kunchan Sukumaran ( 40) were tried in the court of learned Additional Sessions Judge Kottayam for offences under section 302,
section 302 read with section 149, ~ecti0 n 324 read with section
149, 148 and I 43 Indian Penal Cod<! in connection with the
murder of Kuruvilla alias Kunju (50) and for causing hurt to
PW 4 Joseph Chcrian (31 ) . 1l1c trial court convicted accused
I to 5 for offences under section 148 and 302 Indian Penal Code
and sentenced them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period
of one year on the former coul!t and to death on the latter count.
Accused 6 to J 0 were acquitted. On appeal and reference, the
Kcrala High C.ourt confirmed the conviction und sentence of
accused 1 to 5. The High Court further or1 St:~tc appeal con. victed accused 6 to 10 undt:r section 148 ami section 302 read
with section 149 Indian Penal Code <IIH.l sentenced them to LUtdcr·
go rigorous imprisomnent for a period u( one year on the fo~er
count and imprisonment for life on the Iutter count. The srxth
accused was <Jiso convicted under section 324 Indian Penal Code
and was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period
of one year. The sentences awarded to each of nccuscu 6 to 10
were ordered to ruo concurrently. Accused 6 to 10 have filed
criminal appeal No. 263 of 1971 under Act No. ~ of . 1970
D
F
G
tl
APRBN JOSEPH v • .KJiRALA (Khanna, J.)
3lt
I
while accused 1 to 5 have filed criminal appeal No. 300 of 1971
by special leave. This judgment would dispose of both the
appeals.
B
c
I ·.~
The ten accused belong to the Communist Party (Marxist)
Accused No. 10 was the Secretary of that party in the area.
Kunju deceased was the Vice President of an organization of
agriculturists called 'Karsh aka Sangham' at Puthuppally. Yesu
Kathanar ( PW 5), who· is a priest, \Vas the President of the
Karshaka Sangham in the adjoining viJJagc Eramallo0r. Therl'
was some dispute between Kunju dccea~ and the accused relating to a ridge and regarding work in the paddy fields. Aboul
20 days before the occttrrencc, there was u quarrel bctWC''"n per-·
sons belonging to Karshnka Sanghum aml those belonging to the
Marxist puny.
Accordiocg to the prosecution case, tber.c was u m~~:.ting ~f the
Kursbaka Sangham on the evening of .l}cccmber 13, 1910 at
Puthuppnlly junction. Earlier on that day the organiY:ers of the
meeting also arranged a procession. The meeting ·w,ls O\·er at
about 10 or 10.30 p.m. Pappu (PW 1), who wa~ pre&:nt in
the meeting, then wanted to go to his house along with one
Achankunju and Kalappurakkal Baby. Kunju deceased then
cal1ed Pappu and his companions and r~uested them to accompany him to the house of Yesu Kathanar (PW 5). Pappu and
his
two companions agreed and accompanied by them, Kunju
E
deceased went to the house of Yesu Kathanar. They arrived al
that house at about 11.30 p.m. Kunju had some talk with Yesu
and thereafter Kunju and his three companions left the house of
Y esu at 12 mid-night. It was a moonlit night. There was also
light from the electric poles. When Kunju and his three companions were going on the road in front of a dispensary, they saw
F the lights of a lorry cOming from the eastern side. Kunju got
on one side of the road, w!dle his three companions got on the·
other side of the road. The lorry was driven by Mathayi (PW 3).
who then told Kunju and his companions that Vasu, · accused
No. 2, and the other accused were coming that way am1ed with
weapons and that Kunju n.nd others should not go in that direcG
tion but should get into the lorry. Immediately thereafter
accused No. 1 arrived there and aimed a blow with a chopper at
Kunju. Kunju warded off the blow with his right hand. The
other accused also in the meanwhile anived there. Accused 2
and 3 then gave blows on the back of the head of Kunju with
choppers. Accused No. 1 inflicted two injuries on the right
shoulder
of Kunju. Accused 4 then stabbed Kunju deceased in
H
his back with a Malapuram knife. At the same time, accused
5 gave three blows with an irou rod in the chest of the deceased.
Kunju deceased fel1 down on receipt of these injuries. The com-
.32
SUPREME COURT REPORTS .
[~973] 2 S.C.R •
.Panions of Kunju then got into the back of the lorry and shouted
.to the accused not to kill Kunju. Accused No. 6, who had a
·wooden spear, then gave a blow with it on the right hand of
Achan-Kunju. The lorry then started. While the lorrv was
moving away, some stones were thrown on the · lorry by the
accused. The lorry thereafter stopped at Eramalloor second
junction where Ach?n-Kunju ~ot down from the lorry. ·· · Mathayi
;.~sked. Pappu and h1s companiOns a(<;o to get down
from the
lorry, but they declined to do so and told Mathayi to drop th~m
.at the house of Yesu P\Y. Tim.e then was past! O'clock. Pappu.
Baby and Joseph Chenan got down ncar Ycsu's house and told
Ycsu PW that accused Nos. 1, 2, J 0 and. others had killed Kunju.
Pappu, Baby and Joseph thereafter slept at the house of Ycsu. c
·Oa the [ollov.ing morning they left th~ house of Ycsu.
Th.:: cnsc of the prosecution further is that on the mom:.1g
.of December l 4, 1970 Markose ( P\V 2), whose house is situated
near Putbupally ·market, · was told about the present occurrence
.by his children. Markose is a member of the Panchayat. After
taking coffee Markose went ut 6.30 a.m. to the spot where the D
de:td body of Kunju was lying. Marlose thereafter went to the
Kottayam police station at a distance of 9 kilometres froin the
place of occurrence and lodged there .r.::port Ex. Pl at 8. a.m.
According to that report, Kunju dccea~cd haJ been kilkJ by
body at 2 a.m. Markose adtkd thut he ha<..l heard that accused
Nos. 1, 2, 3, 7 and 8 had followed the persons who hao gone to f.
Er:tnwlloor after the meeting at Puthuppally. Somebody amongst
them was stated to have killed Kunju.
·
Circle Inspector John (PW 15) then went to the spot of
-occurrence and arrived there ;~t 11 a.m. The Inspector" found
the dcail body lying thcr.: anJ prepared the inquc~t report. The
dead body was thereafter !>COt to tile mortuury where post mor- f
tem examination was p.:rformed by Dr. George Paul ( PW 7) at
3.30 n.m. on that Jay. Joseph Chcrian also earlier 011 th;1t day
"Ot himself examined from Dr. N:~ir (PW 6) at 19 u.m. ·The
doctor found an incised wound 1" :<!"Y. J" on the poste_rior aspect
·of right· forearm or Joseph. . Thc.rc was also Jn :~bra~IOn 01\ the
lip and a contu~ion on the nght stele of the fuce of Joseph P.W. G
Accused 7, 8 and I 0 were <lffC\t.:d on Dccen!bcr 18. 1970.
AccuS<:d I to 6 surn:nucred in the ,.,1urt of magts!rate l 11l Dcct>m·
her 21, 1970, while accu~ed '1'-io. 9 \Urr<:nJ.:rcd in tlwt court lltl
Dcl.'clllher 23, 1970. No ~ l':tp~1n alkg~.:d tn haw h~.:en liS~~ by
the :t~o:<.:U'>cJ co\dd he r~l'<WCr.:d hy the police.
/\t the trial the pro,.:cu:ion c>.amincd P:1ppu (P\V 1),' }I
.\ LftiJ J\ i ( P\V ) ) ;IIH1 J O'-I!flh ( P\V .f) liS eye. \1 itlleS~C\ l 1f' the
o::curr~qt·e an:J th•:y •.uppmt.:J the prno,cc.uttun C.1~~- Adiill1
j.: 11 nil.l :tr.d lbh~· ·~cr.: :·in:n u;, by the Public P n ,,.:<.:utor.
APREN JOSEPH v. KBRALA (Khamuz,. /.)
A
7he plea of all the accused in the course of their statements
under section 342 Code of Criminal Procedure was denial simpliciter. According to them, they had been falsely involved in
this case because they belonged to the Communist Party (Marxist). No evidence was produced in defence.
B
Learned Additional Sessions Judge held that accused 1 to 5
had formed an unlawful as<;embly after arming themselves with
deadly weapons with the common object of committing murder
of Kunju deceased. It 'Yas further held that those five accused
had caused injuries to Kunju deceased with their respective weapons. They were accordingly convicted under section 148 and
302 Indian Penal Code. Accused 6 to· 10 were acquitted as, in
the Qpinion of the learned judge, they were not shown to be
members of an unlawful assembly. As regards injury on the
person of Joseph (PW 4), the trial judge observed that it could
not be said that the above injury was inflicted by accused No. 6
as alleged by the prosecution.
On appeal the High Court agreed with the conclusion of the
trial court so far as the guilt of the accused 1 to 5 was concerned. As regards accused 6 to 10, it was observed that it was not
nece~sary to show that they had committed some illegal overt
act or had been guilty of some illegal omission. In the opinion
of the High Court, the circumstances of the case showed that all
the r~ccused were members of an unlawful assembly and that the
common object of that assembly was to do away with Kunju
deceased, who had earlier on that day organized the meeting. In
the result, accused 6 to 10 were also convicted as mentioned
earlier.
c
D
1 .
E
F
t
G
J-
33
H
It cannot be disputed that Kunju deceased died as a result of
the various injuries which were inflicted upon him. According
to Dr. George Paul, who pedormed post mortem examination on
the body of the deceased, there were 21 injuries on t1~ oody of
the deceased, out of which 7 were incised wounds, one was a
stab ,\·ound and two were cut wou'nds. Besides that, there were
four contused abrasions and 7 abrasions. The stab wound was
on the 1eft side of the back of the chest. while the cut wounds
were on the little finger of the right hand. One of the incised
wounds was on the back of the right hand, while another incised
wound was on the left hand. The stomach contained 280 mls of
greyish white fluid with a smell similar to that of toddv. The
following incised wounds were sufficient. in the opinion: of the
doctor. to cause death in the ordinary course of nature :
" ( i ) Incised wound 14.5 em long. 1 em a aping
obliquely placed on the right side of the back cl the
heae, the lower and inner end being on the midline at
4-U48Sup.C.l. /73
34
SUP.RBMB COUilT ABPOI.TS
[1973) 2 S.C.R.
tbe level of the top of the ears. The wound had clear
cut margins and the ends were sharp. The underlying
skull bone was cut through for 12 em and fissured frac·
ttlfeS were found running outwards for 2 and 5 emrespectively from the upper and middle portions of the
outer edge of the cut on the skull. The coverings of
the brain were torn and the brain contused under the
fractures.
A
8~
(2) Incised wound 13.5 em long 1.5 em gaptn~
hoci~<mtally placed at the back of the head at level of
the lower end of injury No. ( 1) right end being at a
higher level and both ends being 7.5 em behind the
ears. Wound had clean cut margins and ends were.
~harp and the lower edge showed shelving. The under·
Jying skull was cut through for 10.5 em and the left
occipital bene of the brain showed a cut 2 em deep.
c
( 3) Incised wound 5 x 1.5 em bone deep obliquely
placed at the back of the head 2 em below injury No.
(2). Margins were clearly cut and the upper edge
shown shelving.
( 4) Incised wound 7. 5 em long 1. 5 em gaping
vertically placed on the back of the right shoulder, the
upper end being at the level of the top of the shouldec
with clean cut margins and sharp ends, the underlyin~
spine of the shoulder blade was cut through exposin~
the shoulder joint cavity.
(5) Incised wound 10.5 em x 3 em muscle deep
vertically placed on the right side of the back and top
of the shouluer, 8 em inner to injury No. ( 4). The
wound had clean cut margins the upper end was sharp
~nd ]ower end showed tailing for 2.5 em."
According to the prosecution case, the injuries found on the
body of Kunju deceased were caused by accused 1 to 5. In
support of its case, the prosecution has examined Pappu (PW 1),
Mathayi (PW 3) and Joseph (PW 4) as eye witnesses of the
occurrence. The above mentioned three witnesses, as stated
earlier, supported the prosecution case and their evidence w<~s
accepted by the trial court and the High Court_
Mr. Chari on behalf of the appellants hac; assailed th~ ocular
evidence adduced by the prosecution and has contended that it
soffers from serious infirn1itics. As against that, Dr. Mahmood
on behalf of the State has canvassed for the correctness of the
view taken by the High Court.
D
E
F
G
H
•
I
APREN JOSEPH V. KERALA
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Khanna, J.)
35
This Court normally does not interfere with the appraisement
of evidence of the trial court and the High Court, but that fact
would not prevent this Court from interfering if it is found on
scrutiny of the evidence that it suffers from glaring infirmities.
As many as five persons have been sentenced to death in this case
and five others have been sentenced to undergo imprisonment for
life. It is essential, in my opinion, that the evidence should be
clear and cogent, so as to bring the charge home to the accused
beyond all reasonable doubt.
According to the prosecution case, Pappu (PW 1) and
Joseph (PW 4) were going with Kunju deceased from the house
of Yesu PW at about 1 a.m. when Kunju was attacked by the
party of the accused. Mathayi (PW 3) claims to have witnessed
the occurrence because, according to him, he arrived at the spot
shortly before the occurrence in his lorry after paying a visit to
a contractor. It is also in the evidence of the three witnesses
that soon after the accused had caused injuries to Kunju and the
latter had fallen down, Pappu and Mathayi PWs along with Baby.
who too was with them, got into Mathayi's lorry which was then
driven away by Mathayi. The conduct of these witnesses if
they had, in fact, witnessed the occurrence after that was most
unnatural for none of them made any serious attempt to infonn
the police about the occurrence. It is in the evidence of the
above mentioned witnesses that at first Achan-Kunju was droppe<l
from the lorry at the next junction at a distance of about one
furlong from the scene of occurrence. Thereafter the lorry wa<;
taken by Mathayi at the request of Pappu and others to the house
of Yesu PW and Pappu PW, Joseph PW and Baby were dropped
there in front of that house. Mathayi thereafter took the lorry
to his own house. Pappu, Joseph and Baby after infonning
Yesu about the occurrence are stated to have slept at Yesu's
house, while Mathayi remained at his own house. There is no
cogent explanation as to why the above mentioned witnesses ditt
not go at that time in the lorry to the police station and lodge a
report about the occurrence. If, in fact, a murderous assault
had been made on Kunju decea~ed in their presence, this would
have been the n01mal reaction of the eye witnesses. No attempt
was made in the judgment of Narayana Pillai J., who wrote the
main judgment of the High Court, to find any explanation for the
above conduct of the eye witnesses. Moidu J., who added ~
small note, mentioned that the above was indeed the principal
contention which had been advanced on behalf of the accused.
In the opinion of the learned Judge, the witnesses could not have
dared to go out of the place where they were staying for the night
after the gruesome murder. T find it difficult to subscribe to the
view that the witnes~es refrained from reporting the matter to the
police <:Oon after the occurrence because of fear. The witnesses
36
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
A
had got into the lorry, while the accused were on foot. The police
station was at a distance of only nine kilometres from the place
of occurrence. It would not have taken the lorry more than 15
or 20 minutes to reach the police station. There could be no
apprehension in the minds of the witnesses that they would be
overtaken and assaulted by the accused because the accused were
on foot while the witnesses had the advantage of being in a lorry.
it also cannot be said that the witnesses were not conscious
of the necessity of informing the police about the occurrence.
According to Mathayi (PW 3 t he went to the house of one
Attupnrathu Punnachan before going to his house and tried to
send tP.lephonic intimation to the police. The witness added
that he could not contact the police because the telephone line
was out of order.
Another unnatural feature of the conduct of Pappu, Mathayi
and Joseph PWs is that they made no attempt to see as to what
was the condition of Kunju deceased after the assault and whether the deceased needed some aiel. The witnesses were apparently not aware at the time they left the scene of occurrence that
Kunju had died because according to their evidence they shouted
at that time to the accused not to kill Kunju. Had Kunju died
in
the
presence
of the witnesses. there would have
been no occasion fur the witnesses to shout to the
accused at the time they le7t not to kill the deceased.
J~deed, according to Mathayi (PW 3). he came to know of
the death of Kunjn only on the following day at 5.30
p.m. It may also be observed in this context that the evidence
of Dr. Paul, who perfow.ed post mortem examination on the body
of the deceased, shows that the deceased might have survived for
some time after the assault. It also cannot be said that the witnesses did not.go out_of fear after the occurre:nce to the place
where the deceased was lying because in the nonnal course of
events the assailants do not remain at the spot of occurrence after
the assault.
Even if it may be assumed that Pappu. Mathayi and Joseph
PWs were ~fraid to go to the police stntion in the darkness of the
night, there appears to be no justification or cogent reason for
their not reporting the matter to the police early on the following
morning. It is in evidence that on the following morning the
witnesses did not remain confined to their houses but were movin!!
~bout. According to Pappu (PW 1), he went to Puthupaltv fn
a bus on the foJlowing morning and p:lsSed through the spot
where the dead body of Kunju was lying. The witness did not
step down from the bus despite the fact that h·~ saw the dead body
lying there. Mathayi (PW 3) admits that he went on the
R
c
D
E
F
G
H
AJI.EN JOSEPH v. KBRALA
•
0
f
G
H
(Khanna, J.)
37
following morning at 6 a.m. to Erum.eli and returned from that
place at S.30 p.m. Joseph PW s1ates that he went to Va.kathanam
Hospital by bus at 7.15 a.m. on the .following morning. If the
three eye witnesses could move about and go to different places
on the following morning, there is no satisfactory explanation as
to why they did not go to the police station and make a report
about tlle occurrence if; in fact, Kunju deceased had been subjected to a murderous assault in their presence. The failure of
Pappu, Mathayi and Joseph PWs to report the matter to the
police creates considerable doubt about the veracity of the. evidence of these witnesses that they had seen the accused causing
.injuries to the deceased. This Court in the case of Thulia Kali
v. State·of Tamil Nadu (Criminal Appeal No. 165 of 1971 decided on· February 25, 1972) stressed the importance of making
prompt report to the police regarding the commission of cognizuble offence. It was observed :
"First information repot1 in a criminal case is an
extremely vital and valuable piece of evidence for the
purpose of corroborating the oral evidence adduced at
the. trial. The importance of the above report can
hardly be overestimated from the standpoint of the
accused. The object of insisting upon prompt lodging
of the report to the police in respect of commission of
an offence is to obtain early information regarding the
circumstances in which the crime was committed, the
names of the actual culprits and the part played by them
as well as the names of eye witnesses present at the
scene of occurrence. Delay in lodging the first information report quite often results in embellishment
which is a creature of afterthought. On account of
delay, the report not only gets bereft of the advantage
of spontaneity, danger creeps in o~ the introduction of
coloured version, exaggerated acwunt or concocted
story as a result of deliberation and consultation. It is,
.therefore, essential that the delay in lodging of the first
infonnation report should be satisfactorily explained."
Apart from the above ~nfinnity in the evidence of three eye
witnesses, I find that the prosecution evidence is of a partisan
character and not such on which implicit reliance ern be placed.
Pappu (PW 1) admits th<lt there was a criminal case between his
cou ~in and the fifth accused five or six months before the present occurrence. Pappu was asked whether he was a member
of the Karshaka Sangham. He denied this fact though he
admitted that he had paid money rto Kunju for tht- meeting of
Karshaka Sangham which had been earlier he]d on th~ day of
occurrence. The evidence of Joseph PW, however, shows thnt
38
•
SUPREME COURT RBPOR1'S
[1973] 2 s.c.R.
Pappu is a member of Karshaka Sangham. JOseph PW admits
that there were two ca_ses against him for good conduct. Joseph
. and two others were also sentenced to pay fine in connection with
an assault on a tapper. There was also some property dispute
in which Joseph and Kunju were arraigned as accused but they
were acquitted. Joseph is a member of Karshaka Sangham and
was earlier also cited as a witness in a case against the accused.
B
The prosecution has tried to see~ corroboration. of the evi~
dence of eye witnesses from the testimony of Yesu ( PW 5), who
has deposed that on the nigh~ of occurrence at first Kunju, deceased came to l.is house _accompanied by Pappu, Joseph and
Baby, and that subsequently Pappu, Joseph and Baby came to c
the house and informed him of the occurrence. Yesu, as al~
ready stated earlier, is the President of Karshaka Sangham in
Eramalloor. It is admitted by Yesu that he was accused in a case
concerning the church. He was also accused in another criminal
case. One other case had been filed against him. Shortly before
his evidence in court he wac; accused in a case filed in the court
of District Magistrate. Y esu was also a prosecution witness in D
a case in the Court of Sub-Divisional Magistrate Kottayam in
which certain remarks were made against Yesu. Yesu thereafter filed a petition in the High Court for expunging those remarks. Yesu was asked whether a finding had been given in a
civil case that he .had forged a document. Y esu adnutted that
there had been such a case, but according to him, it related to
the correction of a document It further in the evidence of Yesu
that the police had sent up for trial Yesu's son and four others
for causing injuries to accused No. 10. In view of the above, I
find it difficult to place much reliance u_pon his testimony.
Reference has also been made by Dr. Mahmood to the· fact
that an incised wound was found on the person of Joseph PW by
Dr. Nair when he examined Joseph on the morning of December
14, 1970. It is urged that the aforesaid injury was caused to
Joseph by accused No. 6 with a wooden spear. The presence of
the said injury, according to the learned counsel, lends assurance
to the testimony of Joseph that he was present at the scene of
occurrence. In this respect I find that according to Dr. Paul, G
who is Assistant Professor of Forensic Medicine in Medical College, Trivendrum, the incised wound could not be caused with a
wooden spear and t~at such a spear would cause only a lacerated injury. Dr. Paul's testimony thus creates some doubt regarding the reliability of the prosecution evidence that Joseph had
received injury with a wooden spear at the hand of accused No.6.
In any case the aforesaid injury could have been caused in a H
variety of circumstances and would not necessarily show that
Joseph was present at the scene of occurrence.
'·-
·\
APREN JOSEPH V. KERALA (Khanna, J.)
A
B
c
39
The circumstances of the case tend to show that Kunju de~
ceased was killed at a late hour during the night between December 13 and December 14, 1970 when he was coming from a place
where he had taken toddy. The fact that no report was lodged
with the police during the night and no one went to the village
abadi and raised hue and cry tends to show that no one was present along with the deceased at that time. His dead body, it
seems, wa! discovered in the morning and thereafter a report was
lodged by Markose who admittedly was not a witness of the
occurrence. Markose in the report mentioned the names Of only
accused l, 2, 3, 7 and 8 and, according to him, he had heard
that someone out of them had killed Kunju deceased. 1n my
opinion, it is not possible to sustain the conviction of the aecusedappellants on the evidence adduced in the case.
.I, therefore,_ accept the appeal, set aside the convietioa and
acquit the accused .
. f
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org