HIMACHAL PRADESH ADMINISTRATION versus SHRI OM PRAKASH
Supreme Court of India | Decided 7 December 1971 | [1972] 2 S.C.R. 765 | 1971 INSC 340
Key facts
- Decided
- 7 December 1971
- Bench
- P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY*, D.G. PALEKAR
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 67/1969
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1972] 2 S.C.R. 765
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 340
Text of the judgment
765
I
A
HIMACHAL PRADESH ADMINISTRATION
v.
B
SURI OM PRAKASH
December 7, 1971
[P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY AND D. G. PALEKA!l, JJ.]
Constitution of India, 1950, Art. 136-Criminal appeal against acquittal-Scope of interference by Supreme Court.
Criminal trial-Circumstantial evidence-Approach by Court.
Evidence &ct (! of 1872), s. 21-Weight of evidence re : recoveryPanch witnesses-If should b~ different for each recovery.
c
D
Criminal Procedure Code (Act 5 of 1898). s. 510-Admissibillty and
weight of reporl of finger print expert.
The accused was charged with murder by stabbing, ll;nd tha ev!den~e
against him was circumstantial. It consisted of : (a) evidence of 1ll-w1ll
against the deceased furnishing a motive (b) evidence that he was last
seen in the company of the deceased, ( c) evidence furnished by finger
prints, that he was present in the room of the deceased at or about t~e
time of the murder, ( d) evidence that he was subsequently found '!'
possession of articles which had incriminating blood strains. and (e) evidence that he had hidden a dagger with bloodstains thereon, and certain
other articles, which were discovered on information furnished by him.
The trial court convicted him but the High Court set aside the conviction on the ground that the \\ritnesses \vere not independent or impartial.
E
Allowin~ the appeal to this Court,
HELD : (I) In an appeal against acquittal by special leave under
Art. !36, this Court has pawer to interfere with the findings of fact, no
distinction being made between iudgments of acquittal and conviction
though in tho> case of acquittals, it will not ordinarily interfere with the
appreciation of evidence or findings .of fact unless ~he High Court actec1
perverselv or otherwise improperly, [772 B-D]
Slate of Madras v. Vaidyanatha Iyer, [1958] S.C.R. 580. 587. referred
F
to.
G
(2) In the case of circumstantial evidence if the links in the chain are
complete leading to the undoubted conclusion that the accused alone could
have committed the offence then it can be accepted. In aopreciating suc1'
evidence the prime duty of a court is to •msure that the evidence is legally
admissible, that the witnesses are credible and that they have no interest
or motive in implicating the accused. Since it js difficult to expect a scientific or mathematical exactitude while dealing \vith such evidence corrobora~
tion is sou~ht w)lerever possible. If there is any reasonable doubt the
accused is gi~-en the benefit of such doubt The doubt should be reasonable and not a remote po~ibilitv in favour of the accused. "That is, the
greatest possible care should be taken by the court in convicting an
accuse<!. who is presumed to be innooent till the contrary is clearh·
established, and the burden of so establishing is always on the p'rosecution.
[772 C-E, G; 773 E-H; 774 C]
•,
H
( 3) (a) Whi.le considering the evidence relating to thi~ recovery under
s. 27 of. the .Evidence Act the court will have to exercise that caution and
care which 1s nece~sarv to lend assurance that the information furnished
by the accused leadmg to the discovery of a fact is credible. [776 DJ
766
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1972] 2 S.C.R.
In the. pr~sent case, the various panchnamas of seizure prepared by
the Investi&atin& Officer could not be assailed on the &round that the witnesses who witnes•ed the recoveries were connected with the deceaseil or
with his business, and that therefore, they were not independent or impartial witnesses. [775 H; 776 G]
(b) The evidence relating to recoveries is not similar to that contemplated under s. 103, Cr. P.C. It cannot be laid down as a matter of Jaw
or practice that where recoveries had to be effected from different places
on the information furnished bv an accused different sets of persons should
be called to witness them. [777 B-C]
A
,B.
On the contrary, in the present case, the witnesses who worked with
the deceased were pro,..r persons to witness the recoveries as thev could
identify the things which were missing. [777 C-D]
( 4) The report of the Director of the Finger Print Bureau regardine
the finger prints can be used as evidence under s. 510 Cr. P.C., without
examining the 11erson making the report, because identification of finger
prints has developed into an exact science. As long as the report shows
that the opinion was based on relevant observations that opinion can be
accepted. [783 A-El
In the present case, .the report set out many points of similarity between the finger prints found in the room of the deceased and those of the
accused. [783 HJ
c
D
( 5) The information given by the accused that he purchased a dagger
from one of the prosecution witnesses followed his leading the police to
that witness and pointing him out is inadmissible under s. 27 of the Evidence Act. The concealment of a fact which is not known to the police is
what is discovered by the information given by an accused and lends
assurance that the information was true. What make·s the informtaion
leading to the discowry of a witness admissible is the discovery from
him of the thing sold to him or hidden or kept with him which the police
did not know u_ntil information was furnished by the accused. But a
\\'itness cannot be said to have been discovered if nothing was found with
or recovered frol)l. him, as a consequence of the information furnished by
the acc'use<l. [778 F; 779 H; 780 A-C]
Emperor v. Ramanuya Ayyangar, A.I.R. 1935
ruled.
Mad.
528.
over-
Pulukuri Kotayya & Ors. v. King Emperor, 14 I.A. 65, Ramkrishan
Mithap/al Sharma v. State of Bombay, [1955] 1 S.C.R. 9(13, Sukhan v.
Crown, I. L. R. X Lah. 283. Public Prosecutor v. India China Llngiah &
Ors., A.l.R. 1954 Mad. 435 and Re : Vellingiri, A.l.R. 1950 Macl.
613. referred to.
E
F
G
(6) But that the accused had taken some of the prosecution witnesses
to the witness from whom he bought the dagger and pointed him out.
would be admissible under s. 8 of the Evidence Act as conduct of the
accused. [780 C-D]
(7) Even after excluding some recoveries on the ground that the evidence regarding them was not satisfactory. the evidence against the accused
consisted of eyidence of motive. recovery of a button in the room of the
deceased which matched with the button on the cutf of the coat recovered
from the accused. the finger prints in the room, recoverv of a blood
stained coat and other articles of clress, a blanket. and the dagger. and the
H
I
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 767
A
B
luct thaL the accu;ed and deceased were last se<•n toget_her. The evidence
is cogent and conclusive and should not have been re1ected by the High
Co·.irt. i78l C-E; 7Bfi C-D]
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.
67 of 1969.
Appeal b!Y special leave from the judgment and order dated
August 12, 1969 of the Delhi High Court in Criminal Appeal
No. 68 of 1967 and Murder Reference No. 1 of 1967.
H. R. Khanna and R. N. Sachthey, for the appellant.
Har Pershad aud O. N. Mohindroo, for the respondent.
c
D
E
F
G
H
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
P. Ja~anmoban Reddy, J. This Appeal is by Special leave
against the Judgment of the Himachal Bench of the High Court
of Delhi acquitting the accused who had been sentenced to death
for an offence of murder under Section 302 of the Indian Penal
Code. The accused Respondent was a Manager at the Kotkhai
Brunch of the Himachal Pradesh State Cooperative Bank of which
. Sunder Lal Chaturvedi the deceased was the General Manager. It
appears that during the period the accused was working in that
Bank there was a fire in the Kotkhai Branch in which the recordSof the Bank were burnt and a sum of Rs. 10,000/,~ was found
missing. The deceased had suspended the accused from the service
and subsequently he was dismissed. In or about 1964, the deceased retired from the Bank and in 1965 started a Private Limited
Company under the name of Himprasth Financiers with the ~cad
Office at N agina Singh Building which was situated 1n the Mall at
Simla of which he was the Managing Director. He used to also
!iv~ in the same building in one of the rooms of the office and have
his meals in the Mansarovar Hotel. The other Directors of this·
Company were Gurucharan Singh, Puran Chand Sood and Kailash
Devi wife of I. C. Gupta, P.W. 2. who was at one time also Ma·nager
in the Himachal PrQdesh State Cooperative Bank. After the accused was dismissed from ,the Bank he had applied to the deceased
for a job and was appointed as an Accountant in the Finance Company but later when his request for increase in his pay was not
sanctioned, he sent in his resignation by a letter dated 31-12-66
Exh. P. 8 and it was accepted on 3-1-67 by a resolution of the
Board of Directors Exh. P. 43. On the night of 30th January
1967 the deceased had his dinner at the Hotel and when he came
out after taking his food it was alleged that he was met by the
accused. This was witnessed by Romesh Chand P.W. 7 the
Proprietor of the Hot.el who saw them both going towards the Mall.
Thereafter at the betel shop which is near Nagina Singh Building.
Lal Chand P.W. 9 who was purchasing cigarettes at that shop saw
them together and going towards the Nagina Singh Building. It
768
SUPREME OOU'llT REPORTS
[1972] 2 S.C.R.
was the last time he was seen alive. On the 31st January '67 at
.about 9.30 a.m. I. C. Gupta P.W. 2, came to visit the deceased and
found that the main door was bolted from inside. He then peeped
through Ille glass of the window panes through the adjoining room
· .and saw that the deceased was lying in a pool of blood. He imme~iately telephoned to the Police. In response to this call the Station House Officer of the Saddar Police Station, Inder Raj Malik,
P. W. 28 came to the building, broke open the room through the
kitchen door and saw that the back door of the bath room was
open. At that time there were present P.W. 2. Amar Chand P.W.
8, Baldev Krishan P.W.. 13 and others. The deceased had on
him four incised wounds one on the neck and 3 on the hands.
<On ii:ispecti?n of the room he found on the nearby table a key Ex.
4 stamed with blood and under the table there was a biscuit colour
Coat button Ex. I. Inside the shelf of an Almirah there was a
water flask which appeared ~ have on its neck 3 finger impressions. On the glass pane of the door leading to the kitchen were
:also found two finger marks. The curtain near the kitchen door
showed that someone had wiped his blood stained hands on it.
The key and the button wer~ seized and a panchnama was made.
There were also· founc;I tlwo bunch.es of the keys underneath the
pillow of the deceased. Des Raj, P. W. 6, the Police Photographer
took photographs not o.nly of the various objects in the room but
also of the· finger marks on the flask and the window panes after
the same were dusted with some grey powder. Thereafter the
Investioating Officer P.W. 28 requested P.W. 2, P.y./. 8 and P.W.
13 to :scertain if any of the things belonging to the deceased were
missing. These three persons informed him after inspection that
two loan registers, one general ledger, one cash book and vouch~rs
from April' -,66 to December '66 were missim!. They further mformed him that one blanket of the deceased, one tea-poy cover
and one canvas bag was missing. A'n inquest on the dead body
was held and the blood found was also seized. Thereafter P.W.
28 went to Mansarover Hotel and recorded the statement of P.W.
7. On 1-2-67 at about 11.30 a.m. P.W. 28 accompanied by the
Assistant Sub-Inspector and Constables met P.W. 2, P.W. 8 and
boarded the jeep of P.W. 2 driven by Roshan Lal and went towards
the house of Om Prakash. On the way PW. 2 saw Kala Ram,
l'.W. 5, who was waiting for a bus and asked him to get into the
jeep. Thereafter they went to the house of the accused situated
at Anandale and there P.W. 28 went inside the house and saw
the accused in one of-his rooms and brought him outside. After
interrogating him he arrested him and pursuant to a statement
made by him seized from him on~ sweater, one coat, one blanket
which was hidden inside the nivar of his cot lying inside his room.
The sweater and the coat were sta~d by the accused to be his.
The accused also gave them the pair of boots and socks which Ile
·was wearing and informed them that he had concealed one blood
A
B
c
E
F
G
H
,
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 769'
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
stvined dagger under a stone slab below the Maidan of Burnt
Market and over the bakeries which was by the side of a pipe
and offered to have it recovered. He further stated that he had
kept the five registers in a canvas bag which be had hidden below
a stone at Krishna Nagar on the bank of Ganda Nala and that he
had thrown 8 or 9 bundles of the vouchers tied in a tea-poy cloth
and his blood stained pants in the Ganda Nala and would get them
recovered. The Investigating Officer reduced the statements to
writing in the presence of the Panchas and took· their signatures.
This Panchnama is Ex. P. 6. The coat and sweater and the blanket
inside the nivar of his cot were handed over by the accused to the
police. These were found to contain blood and were seized through
a Panclmama. The accused then took them to the market and on
the way were met by Bhag Singh P.W. 12 and in the presence of
all these persons he removed a piece of stone which was near a
pipe and brought out a blood stained dagger from under it and
gave it to P.W. 28. He then took them to the Tekri of one Ganga
Singh P.W. 11, in the Lower Bazar who sells daggers and there
P.W. 28 recorded his statement that on the day of the incident
the accused had purchased the dagger recovered from under the
stone which was identified by P.W. 11, as the one sold to him.
On the next day namely 2-2-07 P.W. 28, got a plan of the rooms
and the office where the deceased was working and living prepared
and from there accompanied by P.W. 2, P.W. 13 went to Krishna
Nagar taking with them on the way Manohar Lal P.W. 14, from
Krishna Nagar to Ganda Nala which was flowing in the khud.
From near there the accused pointed out a stone slab fre>m where
a canvas bag which contained five registers said to be missing from
the residence of the deceased were recovered and then the accused
went into the Ganda Nala brought out a tea-poy cloth which contained vouchers and also recovered ablood stained pant which was
lying under the water. The button and the coat were sent to the
forensic laboratory at Chandigarh for examination. The llash and
the glass panes were sent to the Finger Print Examiner at Phillor
and the button to the Forensic Laboratory which gave a report that
it was similar to the button on the coat from which it was missing.
The Chelllical Examiner and Serologist found hunian blood on
the key, ihe dager, blanket, coat, sweafur and pant, the shoes
.and socks. The blood grouping could only be found on the pajama
and shirt of the deceased which is of 'O' group while no blood
grouping was possible in respect of the other articles referred to.
Vide Ex. P. 60 and Ex. P. 48. The finger print expert found on
the flask and the glass pane reported as per Ex. P. 59 that they
are~~ s~ne ~s those o~ the ~ccused and ~v~more than 12 points
of s1m11anty 1.e. malchmg ndge charactenst1c details.
The High Court grquped the circumstances relied against the
accused under 4 broad heads namely :
770
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972 J 2 S.C. R.
(i) that there was a motive for committing the murder;
(ii) that the deceased Chaturvedi was seen last in the Company
of the accused;
(iii) that in pursuance of the statement said to have been made
by the accused as per Ex. P. 6 a recovery of blood stained sweater.
coat, blanl..1:t. shoes and socks and blood stained dagger were made
as per Ex. P. 6/A on 1-2-67 (the date given in t~e Judgment as
2-2-67 is not correct), and that on 2-2-67 five regi>ters contamed
in a bag and 12 bundles of vouchers were recovered; and
(iv) that the finger marks of the accused were found on the
flask as well as on the glass panes at the place where the murder
took Rlace.
A
B
c
If the circumstantial evidence as relied upon by the prosecution
is credible and acceptable the offence with which the accused is
charged can be held to be estabiished beyond reasonable doubt.
The High Court however did not accept these circumstances as
having been established by any independeu~ and reliable evidence. D
In so far as motive suggested by the prosecution is concerned it
was of the view that while no doubt the accused was suspended
by an orc.kr of the deceased on 21-6-63 that suspension must have
been as a consequence of the ·action taken by the autl:J.orities of the
Bank with the approval of the Board of Directors and this does not
indicate that he ~ould have any grievance ·against him; that the
accused had no grievance against the deceased is also shown by E
the fact that the deceased had given him employment in the Finance
Company. The second circumstance against the accused, that he
was last seen in the Company of the deceased on 30-1-67 at 9.30
p.m. was also held not to incriminate him for the reason that even
if Lal Chand P.W. 9's statement was true, it only goes to show
that the accused was seen .going with the deceased towards the F
Nagina Singh Building but that does not mean that they had gone
into that Building together, but on the other hand there was a possibility of the accused taking leave of the deceased and going away
to his house without entering into. the Nagina Singh Building. With
respect to the third circumstance relating to the seizure and recovery of articles and their admissibility under Sec. 27 of the
Evidence Act, it was observed that the evidence adduced by the G
prosecution for establishing these circumstances reveals a number
of irregularities ood is suspicious firstly because the prosecuting
officer took with him all the witnesses who were neither independent
nor impartial and even the witness P. W. 5 Kala Ram cannot be
considered to be independent or impartial as he was not a stranger
but was known to the Enquiry Officer. A reading of Kala Ram's H
evidence gives tl!e impression that he is a person willing to be an
agent 0f the police. It also appeared to the High Court that the
..
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy. /.) 7 7 I
A
action of P. W. 28 in bringing the accused out of the room when
he and the other witnesses went to his house gives rise to the suspicion that it might have been done deliberately to clear the way for
planting the articles in the cot which was in the room and fourthly
the statement Ex. 6 said to have been made by the accused amounted to a confession by the accused and if as the enquiry officer P.W.
B 28 claimed that the statement was voluntary instead of recording
it himself he could have produced the accused before a Magistrate
for recording the same. In view of this the Higi} Co\lrt wa~ not
satisfied that the statements were freely and voluntarily made by
the accused and accordingly neither the portions of those statements which related to the discovery of incriminating facts nor the
c admissibility under Sec. 27 of these Memos Ex. P6 & P. 6A and
P. 7 which were signed by P.W. 2, P.W. 5, P.W. 8 and P.W. 28
both on 1-2-67 as well as on 2-2-67 could be relied upon. Even
the handing over of the shoes and socks it was observed cannot be
treated as having been discovered because the accused was wearing
them at the time when he handed them over to the police, and
also that it was difficult to believe ~hat the accused will have the
D coaf, sweater and blanket which are said to have blood stains on
them recovered because he could have discarded them in the same
way as he is said to have done with his pants. Moreover the coat
and the sweater were not shown to belong to the accused by independent and reliable evidence. For these reasons the alleged discoveries or the recoveries of the coat, the sweater, the blanket,
E shoes and socks were rejected. Even with respect to the disco;cry
of the dagger the High Court thought that Amar Chand P.W. 8
was not an independent witness, that Bhag Singh P.W. 12 who was
just a worker at the bakery claimed to be present casually did not
inspire confidence, nor in the absence of independent witnesses
who could have been easily procured could the other evidence be
relied
upon. The identification of the dagger by Ganga Singh P.W.
F
11 before the Magistrate was also not accepted because there was
nothing to show that the dagger was the one which was purchased
by the accused nor is it possible ~ distinguish the dagger in question from the other 3 daggers with which it was mixed up. Similarly the evidence relating to the recovery of the account books
and vouchers was disbelieved. The thumb impressions on the flask
G and the glass panes was rejected on the ground that no particulars
were set out by the Director of the Finger Prints Bureau except
the stereotyped statement that there was a similarity of more than
12 points. On this aspect the High Court observed as follows :
H
"If the accused also had handled the flask, as suggested by the prosecution, his finger impressions also would
be on the flask, and there would be quite a good number
of finger impressions on the flask. But curiously only
three finger impressions, and that too of the accused, are
772
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 2 s.c.R.
A
said to be present on the flask. This in our opinion, is a
very suspicious feature. Further, the existence of the
finger-marks is said to have been noticed even at the
earliest stage of the inquest, and that too not by any
expert but by the Investigating Officer, J.C. Gupta, Amar
Chand and Baldev Krishan, as though they anticipated
the pn;sence of the finger-marks. There .is thus no clear
B
proof that the finger-marks alleged to have bleen found on
the 1!ask and the glass pane were those of the accused,
and we hold accordingly".
in possession of articles which bear incriminating blood stains and
Court has undoubted power to interfere with the findings of fact,
no distinction being made between judgmepcs of acquittal and con- c
viction, though in the case of acquittals it will not ordinarily interfere with the appreciation of evidence or op findings of fact unless
the High Court "acts perversely or otherwise improperly" (see
State of. Madras v. Vaidyanatha Iyer)('). The case against the
accused as already stated depends entirely on circumstantial evidence the credibility of which is very much in issue. It is well
established that circumstantial evidence consists in various links in D
a chain, which if conplete, leads to the undoubted conclusion that
the accused and accused ~lone could have committed the offence
with which he is charged. It is said that this evidence is much more
dependable than direct evidence provided that no link in the chain
is missing. While it is possible that each of these links may not
by itself incriminate the accused or be conclusive against him the E
linking of all of them may forge the chain in arriving at that conclusion.
The evidence that accused had ill will against the deceased
furnishing a motive, that he was last seen in the company of the
deceased, that he was present in the room of the deceased at or
about the time he was murdered, that he was subsequently found F
in possession of articles which bear incriminating b'.ood stains and
that he had hidden the dagger with blood stains thereon and certain other articles which were discovered on the information furnished by him, all cl which if believed leads to the conclusion that
he was the murderer. In appreciating the evidence against the accused the prime duty of a court is firstly to ensure that the evidence G
is legally admissible, that the witnesses who speak to it are credible
and have no interest in implicating him or have ulterior motive.
At the very outset an attempt was made on behalf of the defence to suggest that it was P. W. 2 who was the murderer and not
the accused. This suggestion was made to him in the committal
court as also in Sessions Court but it was denied. It was submitted H
that P.W. 2 had a motive to do away with the deceased because he
(l)
[1958] S.C.R. 580. 587.
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 773
A
B
c
D
E
G
H
•
wanted to appropriate to himself the mone.y and property ?f the
deceased. To this end he was cross-exammed with the ob1ect oi.
establishing that he and th!) deceased had purchased jointly a land
near Chhail and that the deceased was in possession of large sums
of money and that P.W. 2 used to receive all the amounts from the
loans adva,nced by the Finance Company and to avoid any liability
for these amounts the murder was committed with the object of
taking away the accounts and destroyjng the evidence relating thereto. It was further suggested that ~cause of this motive he and
P.W. 8 who admitted that he considered P.W. 2 as his superior and
P.W. 13 Bhag Singh who is the brother-inclaw of P.W. 2 being
the wife's brother, were interested in shifting the offence to the
a1<eused by taking a prominent part during the investigation and
became the main witnesses for proving the several incriminating
circumstances against him.
While it is not the function of. this Court to determine who
other than the person who has been charged with ·the murder hail
committed it, the line which the defence adopted was to establish
tljat the witnesses referred to above had 3;ll interest in implicating
the accused or at any rate to create uncertainty and doubt sufficient to give the benefit to the accused. It is not beyond ·the
\;:en of experienced able and astute. ]awyers to raise doubts .. and
unce;:ainties in respect of the prosecution evidence either during
trial by cross-examination or b!Y the marshalling of that evidenrie
in the manner in which the emphasis is placed thereon. But
what has to be borne in mind is that the penumbra of uncertainty
in. the evidence before a Court is generally due to the nature and
quality of that evidence. It may be the witnesses are lying or
where they are honest and truthful, they are not certain. It is
J)l.1;1r~fore, difficult to expect a scientific or mathematical exactitude· while dealing with such evidence or arriving at a true con"
clµsion; Beca~s~ of these diffic11lties corroboration is sought
-~~rever possible and the maxim that the accused should be
g.i.ve,n the bei_iefit_ of ·doubt becomes pivotal in the prosecution of
offe.nd~rs which 1~ other words tne<1ns that the prosecution must
p,rov". its case aga~nst. an. accu_sed beyond reasonable doubt by. a
s\ifficiency of credible evidence. The benefit of doubt to which
th,e. ~ccused is entitled is reasonable doubt-the doubt which
rational think~ng men will reasonably, honestly and c.onst:ien~
llo\!Sly entertam and not ·the doubt of a timid mind which fights
slJ)'-though u_nwittingly it may be-'-0~ is afraid of the logica·J
.c.onsequences; 1f that benefit was not given, Or as one gre'at
J11dge said it is "not the «:foubt of a vacillating mind that ha~ not
the, ll!C(fal courage to dee1de but shelters itself in a vain and idle
scept1C1sm". It does not mean that the evidence must hie so
strong as to exclude even a remote possibility that the ac;cused
could not have committed the offence. If that were so the law
2-L736 SuPCl/72
774
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972) 2 S.C.R.
would fail to protect society as in no case can such a possibility
be excluded. It will give room for fanciful conjectures or untenable doubts and will result in deflecting the course of justice
if ;not thwarting it altogether. It is for this reason the phrase
has been criticised. Lord Goddard C.J. in Rex v. Kritz('), said
that when in explaining to the juries what the prosecution has to
establish "a Judge begins to use the words "reasonable doubt"
and to try to explain what is a reasonable doubt and what is not,
he is much more likely to confuse the jury than if he tells them
in plain language "It is the duty of the prosecution to satisfy you
of the prisoner's guilt"". What in effect this approach amounts
to is that the greatest possible care should be taken 1zy the Court
in convicting an accused who is presumed to be innocent till the
cbntrary is clearly established which burden is always in the
accusatory system, on the prosecution. The mere fact that there
is only a remote possibility in favour of the accused is itself sufficient to establish the case beyond reasonable doubt. This then
is the approach.
The High Court thought there was force in the suggestion of
the learned Advocate for the accused that P.W. 2 had a clear
motive to take away the registers and vouchers of the Company
to make such use of them as would suit him and also to murder
tbe deceased. On the contrary the evidence of P.W. 2 shows
that he was a friend of the deceased. He had been a Manager
in the Himachal Pradesh State Cooperative Bank when the deceased wa~ the General Manager. There is nothing to show that
during that period the deceased and he were on inimical tetms
·Or there was any disagreement between them of such a nature as
would imply that he bore ill will towards the deceased. On the
other hand both of them had jointly purchased a land, and when
the deceased started the Himprasth Finance Company P.W. 2's
wife was made a Director in that Company because P.W. 2 being an employee in a State Cooperative Bank could not take
direct interest therein. At the time of the incident it appears
that P.W. 2 was Jiving in Simla and according to him he had
regard for the deceased ·and as he was his General Manager he
used to go to him almost daily in the morning and in the evening. He further says he must have visited him hundred times
inside the house, and on the evening of the 30th January, '67.
the deceased and he went for an evening stroll as usual and at
9.30 p.m. that day he left him near the Nagina Singh Building.
after which the deceased went away to take his food towards the
Lower Bazar side and he went away to his house. P.W. 2 knew
of the financial position of the deceased which was according to
the loan ledger entries of the Himprasth Finance Company
(1)
[1950] 1 K.B. 82 ·7" 90
A
ll
c
D
E
F
G
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy,!.) 775
A
B
c
D
E
,
H
Rs. 1157.71 np. as on 31-12-66, that there was a credit amount
of Rs. 14,000 as on 29-11-66 which was not withdrawn till then;
that certain amounts were also borrowed for the marriage of his
daughter from Rawal Chand of Sanjouli whom he knew well and
that from the accounts it appeared that there was only Rs. 6.10
np. as cash in hand of the Company which may be in the hands
of P.W. 13. He further states that he used to be present in every
meeting of the Himprasth Financiers and he used to write the
Minutes Book. There is no suggestion that these Account Books
were manipulated or that the entries therein were not made contemporaneously wit!J. the transactions which they evidenced.
There is therefore no justification for holding that either P.W. 2,
or P.W. 8 or P.W. 13 notwithstanding their close connectio.n
with the deceased and the Himprasth Finance Company were
inimically disposed towards the deceased or towards the accused.
No adverse inference can be drawn as contended by the learned
Advocate for the accused, against P.W. 2 that the circumstanil's
point out to him as being concerned with the murder or against
the other two witnesses that they were supporting P. W. 2 with
the object oi' .!xculpatlng him from any charge that may be
levelled against him. The suggestion that P.W. 2 wanted to
appropriate the property of the deceased or do away with the
cash from the loans which were being paid to him directly had
no rationale to support it, because firstly the deceased had one
married daughter and another unmarried, and secondly that he
had nephews who in the absence of the daughters would have
inherited his property. A suspicion wa, 3ought to be aroused
because P. W. 2 did not send for the daughters ~ut sent for the
nephews which was with the object of dividing the properties of
the deceased in league with them. P.W. 2 said that he did not
know the address of the daughters of deceased and therefore he
sent for the nephews, as such no sinister motive can be attributed
to him. P.W. 28 the lilvestigating Officer had known that P.W.
2, P.W. 8 and P.W. 13 were the· only persons closely connecied
with the office and residence of the. deceased and therefore when
he found some finger prints on the flask and the window panes,
he out oi' abundant caution took their finger prints also on that
very day long before the accused was suspected as being involved
in the murder. It was only after the Investigating Officer examined P.W. 7 the Proprietor of Mansarover Hotel at about 8.30
p.m. on the day the murder was discovered. that he came to
know that the accused had met the deceased outside the Hotel
after he had taken his meals that night. The various Panchnamas
of seizures that the Investigating Officer prepared in the ·presence
of P.W. 2, P.W. 8 and P.W. 13 cannot be assailed merely on the
ground that they were connected with the deceased or with
Himprasth Finance Company. The fact that a key and a button
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972} 2 S.C.R.
was recovered or that the flask or the win\!ow panes had finger A
prints were found in the room where the deceased was murdered
are unassilable nor has any doubt b~en raised to discredit these
recoveries. All that is said by the learned Advocate is that P.W.
28 being an experienced Investigator had created evidence and
the Account Books, vouchers, tea-poy cloth, a canvas bag,
blanket of the deceased were shown as missing in order to pla,nt B
thein subsequently on the accused. But at t@ time when these
seizures were made the part played by the accused if any was
not known, and if at all P.W. 2, P.W. 8 aind P.W. 13 who were
witness to the panchnama had not been cleared from suspicion.
We are not unaware that Sectio,n 27 of the Evidence Act which
makes the information given by the accused while in custody c
leading to the discovery of a fact and the fact admissible, is liable
to be abused and for _that reason great caution. has to be exercised ill resisting any attempt to circumvent, by manipulation or
ingenuity of the Investigating Officer, the protection afforded by
Sec. 25 and Sec. 26 of the Evidence Act. While considering the
evidence relating to the recovery we shal! h,ive to exercise that D
caution and care which is necessary to lend assurance that the
infoniiation furnished and the fact discovered is credible.
As already stated, on 1st Fel:lruary 1967 the coat, sweater,
shoes. and socks of the accused and a blanket of the deceased
were recovered in the presence of P.W. 2, P.W. 5, P.W. 8 and
P .. 28. After this they proceeded to the place indicated by the
accused and recovered the blood stained dagger from under a
stone, which was witnessed by them. P.W. 2 did not accompany
the .party as according to him he had to go to make arrangements
for the funeral of the deceased. On the way to the place from
where the dagger was to be recovered the party met qne Bhag
Si.ugh P.W. 12 who also accompanied them to the place of re- F
covery and in the presence of Roshan Lal (who was not examined) Amar Chand, P.W. 8, Bhag Singh, P.W. 12, and P.W. 28.
the dagger was recovered and a Memo Ex. P. 28 was prepared
aind attested by the aforesaid witnesses. The High Court rejected
the evidence of these recoveries under Ex. P. 6/A and P. 28
because P.W. 2, P.W. 8, P.W. 13 and Roshan .Lal the driver of G
P.W. 2, were all connected with the deceased and are not therefore independent or impartial witirtesses. It thought that the
Investigating. Officer should have called independent imd impartial witnesses preferably, and if possible, from the locality, as it
could not b~ said that they were not available or if available
would not be willing to be witnesses and that in any case calling H
of the same persons to witness several searches or recoveries, is
objectionable, and would render the search or the recovery
d®btful and suspect, if not invalid.
w.
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 777
Further having held this it nonetheless said that there was no
injunction agai!IISt the same set of witnesses being present at the
successive enquiries if nothing could be urged againsf them. In
our view the evidence relating to recoveries is not similar to that
contemplated under Sec. 103 of the Criminal Procedure Code
where searches are required to be made in the presence of two
B or more inhabitants of the locality in which the place to be
searched is situate. In an investigation under Sec. 157 the recoveries could be proved even by the solitary evid~ce of the
Investigating Officer if his evidence could otherwise be believed.
We cannot as a matter -0f Jaw or practice lay down that wh~re
recoveries have to be effected from different places on the inf<li'·
mation furnished by the accused differe,nt sets of persons should
c be called in to witness them. In this case P.W. 2 and P.W. 8
who worked with the deceased were the proper persons ·to \vitness the recoveries as they could identify som~ of the things that
were missing and also they could both speak to the Wormation
and the recovery made in consequence thereo.f as a continuous
process. At any rate P.W. 2 who is alleged to be the most
D interested was not present at the time of the recovery of the
dagger.
P.W. S's evideince was not considered to ~ independent because the High Court thought that he was known to P. W. 28
from before. This by itself in our view will not justify the rejection of his evidence. That apart there is nothing in his
E evidence to show that P.W. 28 knew him before he came to
Simla while he was Jiving iin Kaithal. The witness stated that
the S.H.0. was never posted at Kaithal but knew the Daroga
(SHO) from 2/3 months before that date. He had not met
P.W. 28 before he arrived at Simla. It was suggested to him
that Daroga had come ang sat in his shop at the Mandi but that
F was denied. He however stated that the Daro ga used to ask his
'ha! cha!' sometime and used to wish him and that was all. Witness also denied having seen P.W. 2 and P.W. 8 before that day
and came to know their names only when he went to Anandale.
The brothers of P.W. 5 were at Kaithal doing business but here
again there was nothing to connect the brothers with P.W. 28
G and though P.W. 28 admits that his own brothers Roshan Lal
and Malik Harbans Lal reside in Kaitha! and one of them has
some lands there, he was not on good terms with them and
denies that they h_ad any connection with P.W. 5. From this
evidence it is clear that apart from the fact that P. W. 2 8 had
known P.W. 5 after he had come to Simla which is not unusual for
a Police Officer, there is nothing to indicated that P.W. 5 could be
H su'bservient to P.W. 28. It is not unknown that in some insfances
where persons are made to witness Panchnamas they have resiled
from them whi,Je giving evidence in Court, probably either dne to
778
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972) 2 S.C.R.
the pressure exerted by the police at that time oI they have been
won over by the defence. Nothing of that nature is apparent in
this case and the comment of the High Court that a reading of
the e\idence of P.W. 5 gives the impression that he is a person
willing to be pliable agent of the police and cannot be regarde?
as an independent or impartial witness has in our view no justification.
It is said that P.W. 12 Bhag Singh was just a worker at the
bakery and while he pretends to be present there casually at the
spot .from where the dagger was taken out, the Investigating
Officer said he had summoned him on the suggestion of the flead
Constable; as such his evidence does i!lot inspire confidence. -We
do not think that this is a sufficient reason for discarding the
evidence of P.W. 5 because when P.W. 28 says he summoned
Bhag Singh through the constable it does not negative the statement of Bhag Singh that he was casually present and could have
been called by him through the Head ConstaWe. In our view
there is no reason to hold that the evidence of these persons
P.W. 2, .P.W. 5, P.W. 8 and P.W. 12 can be said to suffer from
any infirmity or that they had not witnessed the information
given by the accused as per Exhibits P. 6, P. 6/ A or P. 28 or
the recoveries made by him as a consequence of that information.
B
c
D
E
Thereafter on the information furnished by the accused that
he had purchased the weapon from Ganga Singh P.W. 11 and
that he would take them to him, they went to the thari of P.W. 11
where the accused pointed him out to them. It is contended
that the information given by the accused that he purchased the
dagger from P .W. 11 followed by his leading the police to his
thari and pointing him out is· inadmissible under Sec. 27 of the
Evidence Act. In our view there is force in this contention. A
fact discovered within the meaning of Sec. 27 must refer to a
material fact to which the information directly relates. In order
to render the information admissible the fact discovered must be
relevant and must have been such that it constitutes the information through which the discovery was made. Whar is the fact
discovered in this case? Not the dagger but the dagger hid under
the stone which is not known to the police. (See Pu/ukuri
Kotayya & Ors. v. King-Emperor)('). But thereafter can it
be said that the information furnished by the accused that he
purchased the dagger from P. W. 11 Jed to a fact discovered when
the accused took the police to the thari of P.W. 11 and pointed
him out ? A single Bench of the Madras High Court in Pub/fc
(!) · 74 India Appeals p. 65.
p
G
H
HIMACHAL PRADESH Y, OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy,/.) 779
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
Prosec11wr v. India China Lingiah & Ors.('), and in re Vellingiri('), seems to have taken the view tilat the information by an
accused leading to the disc011ery of a witness to whom he had
given stolen articles is a discovery of a fact within the meaning
of Sec. 27. In Emperor v. Ramanuja Ayyangar(3), a Full Bench
of three Judges by a majority held that the statement of the
accused "I purchased the mattress from this shop and it was this
woman (another .witness) that carried the mattress" as proved
by the witness who visited him with the police was admissible
because the word 'fact' is not restricted to something which can
be. exhibited as a material object. This judgment was before
Pulukuri Kotayya's case(') when as far as the Presidency of Madras was concerned the law laid down by the Full Bench of that
Coµrt, in Re Athappa Goundan(") prevailed. It held that where the
accused's statement connects the fact discovered with the offence
and makes it relevant, even though the statement amounts to a
confession of the offence, it must be admitted because it is that
that has led directly to the discovery. This view was over-ruled
by the Privy Council in Pulukuri Kotayya's case(') and this Court
had approved the Privy Co11ncil case in Ramkishan Mithanlal
Sharma v. The State of Bombay(').
In the Full Bench judgment of seven Judges in Sukhan v.
The Crown ( 7 ), which was approved by the Privy Council in
Pulukuri Kotayya's case('), Shadi Lal, C.J., as he then was speaking for the majority pointed out that the expression 'fact' as defined
by Sec. 3 of the Evidence Act includes not only the physical fact
which can be perceived by the senses but also the psychological
fact or mental condition of which any person is conscious and
that it is in the former sense that the word used by the Legislature
refers to a material and not to a mental fact. It is clear ·therefore that what should be discovered is the material fact and the
information that is admissible is that which has caused that dis•
covery so as to connect the information and the fact with each
other as the 'cause and effect'. That information which does not
distinctly connect with the fact discovered or that portion of the
information which merely explains the material thing discovered
is not admissible under Sec. 27 and cannot be proved. As explained by this Court as well as by the Privy Council. normally
Sec. 27 is brought into operation where a person in police custody
produces from some place of concealment some object said to be
connected with the crime of which the informant is the accused.
The concealment of the fact which is not known to the police is
what is discovered by the information and lends assurance that
··---
(1) AIR 1954 Mad. 333.
(3)AIR 1935 Mad. 528.
($) !LR 1937 Mad 695.
(7) ILR Vol. X Lahore 283.
(2) AIR 1950 Mad 613.
(4) 74 l. A. 64.
(6) [1955] (1) SCR 903.
780
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 2 s.c.R
the information was true. No witness with whom some material
fact, such as the weapon of murder, stolen property or other in~
~riminating article is not hidden sold or kept and which is uri~own to the Police can be said to be discovered as a consequence
.d *he information furnished by the accused. These examples
llo\Vever are only by way of illustration and are not exhaustive.
·What makes the information leading to the discovery of the Wit~S admissible .is Uie discovery from him of the thing sold to him
91' hidden or kept with him whicli the police did not know until
¢1'\e information was furnished to them by the accused. A wit~- cannot be said to be discovered if nothing is to be found
9J ;l'ecovered .from him as a consequence of the information fur.nislled by the accused and the information which disclosed the
~de.11tity 'of the witness will not be admissible. But even apart
from the admissibility of the inlorination under Sec. 27, the
e.vidence of the Investigating Officer and the panchas that the
.accused had taken them to 'P.W. 11 and pointed him out arid as
,<:Qttoborated by P. W. 11 himself would be admissible under Sec.
~ of the Evidence Act as conduct of the accused.
We then come to the recovC,ry 1ln the second February of
Pant, the Account Books and the vouchers. These however, cannot in our view be relied upon because P.W. 28 had infonnition
relating to them which had been furnished by the accused more
than 24 hours before ancl the description given by him was such
that they coujd have been discovered. At any rate the long
delay does. not lend assurance to the discovery. It appears from
41\e. application made 011 the 2nd February to the Magistrate that
•tlle accused was arrested on 1-2-67 and at his instance and from
:h~.possession one sweater. one coat and one blanket· blood '>lain.~. have been recovere4 and in addition one blood stained warm
~nt, one duster, one bag containing 5 registers are still t@ be
~vered on the· .pointing out of the accused but the remand of
·•tl!O .accused is due to expire at I p.m. and accordingly it was
,~ted that a further remand for 7 days be given and. the ac~used made over to the police and orders be passed. Th~ acC:llied is alleged to have given the information that he had hid
intro under the stone slab near Krishna Nagar Ganda Nala which
11¢ had thrown away in the sewage and which he said will point
out and get them recovered. The recovery itself is under Ex.
·P. 7, to which P.W. 2, P.W. 13 and Manohar Lal P.W. 14 who
wag picked up on the 'ras.ta' when he was summoned by the constables are witn_esses. According to P.W. 14 the Thanedar
was going ahead and went down to the Nala, when the constable
summoned. him and lie went there. He further says that the
Thane<lar sent a constable .down. The accused had a talk with
IDhanedar. The constable took out from below a stone slab fi'i'e
registers in a bag, the accused was standing on a stone. At tbis
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
HIMACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 781
n
c
E
p
G
stage the prosecutor sought permission to cross-examine the wiilless and it was given. In the cross-examination he denied having signed the Memo at the spot and said that he had signed it
fi.t the Thana. He also said it was incorrect to suggest that the
Memo was read over to him and he signed it. Whether the articles recovered were planted at the place from where they were
alleged to be recovered or not as suggested by the learned Advocate for the accused, the evidence referred to certainly goes
against the prosecution version that the Account Books, vouchers
<irid the pant were recovered at the instance of the accused. The
police appears to have known the place from Where these articles
were alleged to have been recovered and therefore it cannot be
said that they were discovered as a consequence of the information furnished by the accused.
After excluding the recoveries made under Ex. 7 namely the
Account Books etc. the evidence against .the accused which remains to be considered is, the motive, the recovery of the button,
the finger prints on the flask and the window panes, blood stained coat, sweater, shoes and 'socks alleged to be of the accused,
blanket, the dagger and the deceased b~ing last seen alive in his
Company. As we have already noticed the High Court had rejected the evidence of motive but in our view it failed to coe.sider
one aspect which is important namely that the accused wanted
lb be re-employed with the Himprasth Finance Company and
though the other Directors were willing the deceased was not. It
is true that the initial illWill which he may have had against the
deceased when he suspended l)im in 1964 may have been forgotten because the deceased subsequently extended his sympathy
and employed him in his Finance Company. The accused was
not satisfied with the conditions of his service and wanted an
ircrease in the pay which the Company was not prepared t(l give
causing him to resign. This itself may have given him cause to
nurse a grievance against the deceased because he was the person
who was incharge of the affairs of that Company in which he had
1
a dominant voice but
when he wanted. to be reappointed the
deceased definitely put his foot down and refused to entertain
him which would certainly create illwill in him against the deceased. It is likely that a person may oblige another on various
occasions bnt if he does not continue to do so or positive]y obsti']lcts or is against his being given any benefit even on one such
occasion it may give rise to a sense of grievance against him.
The springs of human action and conduct are unfathomable
because what motivates them is difficult to postulate. At -any
rate where personal interest is involved, it is too mucli to expect
ol>je"c!Mty in a person's relationship with others who are unobli~
glng o.- considered to be hostile to him. There are manylwith
78i
SUPREME COURT REPOR'fS
[1972] 2 s.c.a.
greater cause who may not venture to do away with those that
give occasion for it but experience has shown that even with
les~r motive persons have committed more dastardly crimes;
that 'is why in view of these imponderables, motive by itself is
not sufficient to detem1ine culpability. It has to be judged with
positive evidence relating to incriminating facts and circumstances proved in a case against an accused.
It is contended strenuousfy that there is no evidence to establ.iSh that the accused was with the deceased at the time when he
w11-s µmrdered. This contention seems to have found favour with
the High Court which has held that though the deceased was
last Sc:Qtl alive in the Company of the accused it is not sufficient
to indicate that he had gone with the deceased into the Nagina
Singh Building and was with him at the time when the murder
was committed. The evidence of P. W. 7 is positive that he had
seen the accused in the company of the deceased after the deceased bad his meals at about 9.30 or so. This witness was lhe first
to giive information to P.W. 28 which was at about 8.30 p.m. on
31st January. The High Court does not disbelieve this evidence.
In so far as P.W. 9 is concerned it is said that he is a mere casual
or chance witness. Even if the reasons given by the High Court
for disbelieving his evidence is accepted it cannot negative the
fact of the ·accused being seen in the company of the deceased
at about 9.30 or 9.45 p.m. on 30th January when he was the
last one to have seen him alive. That the accused was in the room
with the deceased is established by the fact that his finger prints
were on the flask and the window panes and that a coat button
of his was found in the room. It was however contended on be·
half ,of the accused that these finger prints were not blood stained
nor do they indicate that the .accused was present at the time·
when the offence was committed because the evidence shows
that he was seeking to get reemployment and the possibility of
his· having visited the deceased earlier in the day or a few days
before the offence when the finger prints could have been found
on the flask and the window panes cannot be ruled out. Secondly it was urged that the report of the finger print expert as the High
Court has held does not furnish the reasons for the opinion that
they belonged to the accused. On the first of these co~tentions
it mav be observed that there is no evidence that he had been
to
the deceased earlier that day or had seen him befor~ that
day as would probabalise these finger prints being still present
on the 31st January. The evidence merely points out to the
fact .that the accused was seeking reemployment in the Company
and the deceased was unwilling to give him employment. It is a
long viay from this circumstance to infer that he had been in the
r-0001 earlier. The second contention is in our view equally. llll·1enable. The report regarding the Finger Print is that of ttte
8
c
D
E
G
see
H
HWACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 783
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
II
Director of the Finger Print Bureau which under Seo. 510 Criminal Procedure Code can be used as evidence in any enquiry or
trial without examining the· person who gave the report just in
the same way as the report of the Chemical Examiners or of the
Chief Inspector of Explosives is evidence. Under sub. sec. (2),
hdwever the Court m_ay, ifit thinks fit, and shall, on the application cf the prosecution or the accused, summon and examine
any such person as to the subject matter of his report. The additien of the report of the Director of Finger Prints Bureau and of
the Chief Inspector of Explosives in Sec. 510 was made by Sec.
99 of Act 26 of 1955 and unless the Court or the Public Prosecuto1 or the accused require the summoning and examining of
any person as to the subject matter of his report that report· can
be acted upon. It is however submitted that while the report.
may be admissible the opinion will have to be justified. Neither
tlw decision of a Single Judge oi Andhra Pradesh High Court in
re. Godarerthy Bheslzyakaracharvulu(i'), nor that of the Madras
High Court case in re. Marudai, support this contention. The
reascn why the reports of the Director of the Finger Print Bureau.
is treated as evidence ·without examining the persons giving the
report is that the comparison and identification of Finger Prints
has now developed into a science and the results derived therefrom have reached a stage of exactitude. As long as the report
shows that the opinion was based on observations which lead to
a conclusion that opinion can be accepted, but should there be
any doubt it can always be decided by the calling of the person
making the report; when once the report is proved; neither .the
pro~ccution nor the accused nor yet the Court thought it necessary
to require the person making the report to be examined. In this
case, however, the pb9tograp_hs of the finger prints were taken
on the very day when the flask and the glass pane were seized.
After these material objects were sent to the Finger Print Bureau
they were again photographed and compared with the finger prints
taken of P.W. 2, P.W. !3 and P.W. 8 and the accused·. In so far
as the Finger Prints of the accused are concerned though somewhat smudged they were said to be readably clear and in each of
the finger impressions found on the flask and the window pane
there were more than 12 points of similarity i.e. matching ridge
characteristic details in their identical sequence. without any
d~cordances in their comparable portion and the corresponding
ponion of the left thumb impression, middle finger impression.
left inclex finger, right middle finger of Om Prakash the accused.
It wJs also stated that so many points of similarity cannot ~
found to occur in the impressions of different thumbs and fingers
and they are therefore of one and the same person. In respect
(l)
AIR 1%0 A.P. 164.
(2)
AIR 1960 Madras 370.
784
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 2 S.C.R.
of a thumb impression compared with the right thumb impressil}n
of Om Prakash the expert had found not less than 1O points of
similarity and even with respect to this his opinion was that so
many points of similarity cannot be found to occur in the impressions of different thumbs and fingers and are therefore identic
cal or are of one and the same person. There appears to be no
difficulty in coming to the conclusion from the report that the
points of similarity are those which can be accepted as a positive
finding. The absence of these Finger Prints being blood stained
is not indicative of the accused not being th'ere before the niurder.
We have it in evidence that the curtain near the door showed
that blood stained hanCls were wiped thereon. That apart the
button which was recovered gives a direct clue to the presei1ce
of the accused at the time when the offence was committed. It
is seen from Ex. P. 61 A that the upper button of the 3 small
bnttons on the cuff of the coat recovered from the accused was
missing and the button recovered from the room where the dece:ised was· murdered matches the button and supplies the missing one. The report of the Forensic expert is that on a compari·son of that button with the button of the accused's coat e>fablishes that it is the similar one. For this reason the accused
bad denied that the coat and the sweater belonged to him and the
fearned Advocate on his behalf has urged in support of that plea
that these were not recovered from the accused and the recovery
memos were all fake and were written subsequently. Accused
fo the statement under Sec. 342 in answer to question 19, that
he had signed the recoyery Memos dealing with the sweater, coat
and blanket said that it was incorrect. He further said that he was
made to sign three blank papers in the Thana and that he was
filing a copy of the application in this connection made by him
while he was in the judicial lock up. Again in answer to question 35 whether he has anything else to say he stated categorically
that on the 1st February '07 he was take11 to the Thana at. 5 p.m.,
on the 2nd Febmary he was produced before the Court from
~here a remand was taken and that on 7-2-67 the S.H.0. obtained his signatures on three blank papers in respect of which
he had sent -an application after he was taken to the judicial
lock up. This statement goes counter to the facts stated in th.e
application of remand made to the Magistrate on 2-2-67 which
was earlier edracted. A perusal of that remand application
wo.uld show that these recoveries had already been made on the
1st and so there could be no question of his signatures beirig
iaken on the blank papers on the 7th for purposes of cooking
up the recovery Memos which according to the accnsed were ··not
recovered on the 1st. The coat. and the sweater were recMeretl
from his room while the shoes and socks from his person as be
was wearing them. There can be no doubt of the ownership
being that of the accused.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
ij!MACHAL PRADESH v. OM PRAKASH (Jag'a11moha11 Reddy,/.)
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
785'
Then there is the recovery of !lie blood stained knife with
tespect to whi.ch similar contentions were raised. Where a per·
snn who is not a hardened criminal is burdened with the guilt
of• a gruesome crime, is confronted with a tell tale finding tho
pO!:sibility of his making a clean breast of what is weighing hea·
ViJy on him cannot be ruled out. It is difficult to generalise
as to what a man may or may rtot do after committing a ghastly
murder nor ·can there be an infallible test to detennine the course
oi. human reaction, conduct or behaviour in a given situation
wfilch might manifest itself irt various. ways. In this case when
the accused was confronted with 'the button of his coat he gavo
infonnation leading to the incriminating discoveries.
Whether the knife could have been properly identified by
P.W. 11 in the identification held before the Magistrate there
can be little doubt, if we believe his evidence, the accused had
purchased a knife that day, which is similar irt nature to the one
lie was selling. There is no reason why P.W. 11 should not be
belie\'ed on this aspect. . He says that it was purchased b~ the!
accused at the noon time on the day when Mahatma Gandhi had
dieJ on the 30th for Re. 1I· and that the police had brought the
accused to his shop on the 3rd day after the dagger was pur·
chased. He further says that the accused used to go to him pre·
viously for the mending of his knife and scissors though the wit~
ness admits that he had not purchased any dagger from him pre·
viously. In cross-examination he admitted frankly that he was
having his thari without permission of the municipality and that
he was challaned and fined almost every month though from the
last 8 months the police have not challaned but the Municipal
Committee have challaned him. He also admitted that once
about 23/24 years ago he was convicted in a theft case and was
senteµced to rigorous imprisonment and his hisfory sheet was
closed 21 or 22 years ago. At the- time of giving evidence he ~
about 35 years and even making an approximation of the age
he must have been 13 or 14 years when the offence for which he
was convicted was committed .. n1is adniis.sion seemed to have
weighed with the High Court that his antecedents were such as
to justify their not relying upon his evidence. They also found
it difficult to believe that when hfl had not put any special mark
on the dagger he could identify it from amongst three similar
ones. In this connection it may be remembered that P.W. 11
was making the knives which he was selling and it is not unknown
that persons who make knives or other implements can recognise
them with some amount of certainty even though special identi·
fication marks may not be present. Be that as it may, even If
the identification is discarded there is nothing .19 doubt his st,ij•
ment that he knew the aecused before the 30tf'i January 1!lll1
786
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(l 972] 2 S.C.R.
A
and that about noon on that day he had purchased a dagger fcoo1
him. It is not unreasonable to infer that the dagger which he
purchased is the dagger which was recovered on the informati<Jn
furnished by the accused himself on the second day after his purchase and that dagger contained human blood. One other important circumstance against the accused is the blanket that was
found in his house which had human blood stains thereon. The
murder of the deceased was in January in the coldest month.s in
Simla and the possibility of the accused having taken a blanket
to c9vt>r himself also fits in with the other evidence adduced by
the prosecution.
There is in our view no justification for the High Court in
jettisoning this cogent evidence of a conclusive nature on mere
conjectures and on the omnibus ground that the witnesses were
not independent or impartial which as we have show:n is without
justification. In our view the evidence in this case is sufficient
to justify the conviction of the accused for an offence of murder.
We accordingly set aside the judgment ol acquittal of the High
Court, convict the accused under Sec. 302 and sentence him to
life imprisonment,
V.P.S.
Appeal allowed.
B
c
D
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org