UNION OF INDIA & ANR. versus OGALE GLASS WORKS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 1 September 1971 | [1972] 1 S.C.R. 525 | 1971 INSC 229
Key facts
- Decided
- 1 September 1971
- Bench
- G.K. MITTER*, C.A. VAIDYIALINGAM, P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2591/1966
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1972] 1 S.C.R. 525
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 229
Text of the judgment
525
A
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
v.
B
OGA,LE GLASS WORKS
September 1, 1971
[G. K. MITTER, C. A. VAIDIALINGAM AND P. JAGANMOHAN
REDDY, JJ.]
Employees' Provident Fund Act, 1952-Scope of s. t9A of the
A ct-Whether decision under s. 19A of the Act by the Central Governn1e111 is final in the facts and circurnsu1nces of the case.
c
D
The respondent c·ompany was manJJfactu'ring various articles ip.ch~ding
Lc1ntern and Safety Stoves etc. Jn N9vember I 952, _Employees ~rov1~ent
Fund Act, \Vas passed -and 'the conipany was making regular contnhu,tion;~ to the Provident Fund for all employees.
After sometime another establishment which was carrying on si1nilar
business filed a writ petition in Bombay High Court contesting the claim
of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner. that the Act applied to
all sections of the glass works. The Bombay High Court held that the
Act and the scheme applied only to such sections of tJie company as we~e
covered by Sch. I of the Act and not to all sections. Against this dec_:sion. an appeal was preferred before this Court and the Court reversed'thc decision of the High Court and held that the Act and the scheme
applied to nil employees working under the said glass works.
Regio'nai Provide~t f"und Com1nissioner, Bombay v. Shree Krishn(f.
Metal Manufact~ring Co., Bliandra, [1962] Supp. 3 S.C.R. 815.
E
F
G
The respondent, altfiougb was making contributions in respect of all its
employees, discontinued to do so after the decision of the High Court
in the above matte'r, except for those empJoy~es who were working#in the
Lantern and Stove Sections. Thereafter, the employees raised a dispute,
and the dispute was referred to the Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra and
the Industrial Tribunal gave its award against the management but
eJ1<empted the respondent company from contributing for certain years.
After the decision of this Court in Shree Krishna Metar Co.'s case, the
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, called upon the respondent to
make contributions but the respondent pleaded that there has been already
a decision by the Centra~ Government under s. 19A of the Act holding
that the Act and the scheme applied only to the Lantern and. Stove Sec'
tions and therefore the respondent asked for refund of the contributions
made for employees of other sections and maintained that the Department
was not entitled to., call upon the company to m·ake contributioqs for the
years in question. The Department threatened to take cOei'CiVe stePs ·and
in consequence, respondent filed a wiit petition in the Nagpur Bench of
the Bombay High Court, challenging the demand tnade by the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner ancl sought relief.
The High ·court held that in view·of the Central Governmen~ decision
~nder s. !9~ .of the Act, tl;le appellants have n<>-r~ght to reopen. t~e ques-
non. of habtlt!y of .the respondent. On appeal. the folk>wing qtieslions
arose for ~onstderation : (t) Whether there has been a decision· ol the
Central Government under s. 19A of the Act. (ii) the effect of the
·Awa':"- P:"sed by the .Industrial !dbunal exempting the company, from
contQbutmg for-certau.i years; (m) whether the company is liable .to pay
the .administrative..charges for t:tie exempted periods. Allowing th.e appeal,.
l S-1340 Sup. Cl/71
. .
H
,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
HELD : ( 1) From the evidence it is clear that there has been no·
final decision by the Central Government under s. !9A of the Act. It
was only a Lmited decision not to apply the Act and the scheme in view
of the 1udgment of the Bombay High Court and till the final decision of
the .appeal by this Court. After the matter is finally disposed of by this
Court, the appellants arc perfectly justified in demanding contributions
for all employees from the respondent in terms of the demand notice.
,f545 EJ
( 2) Although the Award passed by the Industrial Tribunal exempted
A
B
the manag.!ment from contribut:ng for a certain number of years, it is
not relevant for the purpose of applying the Act an,d the scheme. Moreover, the appellants were not parties to the award. Since the Act and
the schome applies to all sections of the respondent, the respondent is
liable to make contributions at the rate specified in the Act.
The rate
'Pecified by the Industrial Tribunal is not in accordanc::c with the Act.
Therefore, the award of the Industrial Tribunal lloes not stand in the
way of the appellant's demand for the period in question. [545 G-546 CJ
c
( 3) Once the employer is held liable for payment of its share of
Provident Fund contribution for the period in question, it will also be
Jiable to pay the administrative charges. [546 HJ
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2591 of
1966.
D
Appeal from the judgment aill.d order dated September 17, 1965
oJ' the Bombay High Court in Special Civil Application No. 380
of 1964.
R. H. Dhebar, Ram Panjwani, S. P. Nayar and P. R. Ram
Asish, for the appellants.
·
E
.v. M. Tarkunde and K. R. Chaudhuri, for the respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Vaidialingam, J. This appeal, on certificate, by the
Union of India and the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner.
Maharashtra State, is directed against the judgment and order
dated September 17, 1965 of the Bombay High Court allowing
Special Civil Application No. 380 of 1964 filed by the respondent
·company under Art. 226 of the Constitution and quashing the
notice of demand dated May 22, 1963 issued by the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner.
The circumstances under which the writ petition was filed by
the respondent may be stated : The respondent a limited company
having its Head Office at Ogalawadi in Satara District was manufacturing at the relevant time Glassware, Stoves, Lanterns and
Enamel wares. It had several sections in its factory, namely, (I)
Glass Manufacturing Section, (2) Lantern and Safety Stoves
Section, ( 3) Enamel Section, ( 4) General Section and ( 5) Canteen Section. In or about 1946 the Company had introduced a
Provident Fund Scheme for its workers under which it paid 12
pies in a rupee as the employer's contribution towards the said
F
G
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS
A
B
c
•
.
D
E
F
G
H
(Vaidia/ingam. !.) 527
fund. IA 1951 the Provident Fund Scheme was amended and
the Company agreed to make contributions to the fund only if it
made profits.
On November I, 1952, The Employees' Provident Fund Act,
1952, Act No. XIX of 1952 (hereinafter to be referred to as the
Act), came into force and it made applicable to certain scheduled
industries. There is no controversy. that the Act was made applicable to the respondent on October 6, 1952 and the Company had
been paying its contribution to the Employees Provident Fund
from November I, 1952. For the purpose of the Fund, a scheme
had been framed under the Act. According to the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner. the Act and the Scheme framed
thereunder applied to the entire body of employees working under
the respondent. Though the Company then raised objections on
the ground that only the employees in the Lantern and Stoves
Section were covered by the Scheme and that it was bound to make
contributions only in respect of those employees, nevertheless, the
Company continued to make its share of contribution to the Provideht Fund even in respect of other employees working in other
sections .
In the mean while, another establishment in the area, the Nagpur Glass Works, which was carrying on a business similar to that
of the respondent company filed a writ petition before the Nagpur
Bench of the Bombay High Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution, being Miscellaneous Petition No. 122 of 1956 contesting the
claim of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner that the Act
applied to all sections of the Glass Works. In the said writ petition the contention was that the Act and the Scheme will apply
only· to the Lantern and Stove Section. Though this claim was
contested by the Department, a Division Bench of the Bombay
High Court, by its decision dated March 7, 1957 reported in The
Nagpur Glass Works Ltd., v. Regional Provident Fund Commission#r(1) upheld the contentions of the Nagpur Glass Works that
the Act and the Scheme applied only to such sections or departments of the Company as were covered by Schedule I. The respondent before us continued to make its contribution in respect
of all the employees. There was some correspondence between
the Company and the Department, to which we will refer later.
The Department had challenged the decision of the Bombay High
Court before this Court. The decision of the Borribay High Court
was reversed by this Court on March 14, 1962 in the decision
reported in The Regional Proilident Fund Commissioner, Bombay
v. Shree Krishna Metal Manufacturing Co., Bhandara(2). This
Court after refering to the relevant provisions of the Act including
s. 2A which had been introduced by an amendment in 1960 held
that the Act applied to composite factories and that the Glass
-(I)-I.-l.-R.-[1958)
-.-Born. 444.
(2) [1962] Supp. 3 S. C. R. 815,
528
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
tl972] 1 S~C.R.
Works therein was commercially engaged in a Scheduled industry
among others and hence the Act was applicable to it. On this
basis. this Court held that all the employees. working under the
said Glass Works were covered by the Act and the Scheme.
To resume the· narrative, after the decision of the Bombay
High Court, the respondent began to discontinue making contributions in respect of the employees, other than those working in
tl1e Lantern and Stoves Section. '.fhe employees raised a dispute
regard;ng tl:e discontinuance of the Provident Fund Scheme and
in con,equence the, State Government referred the dispute to the
Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra, being Reference No. I.D. 29
o:• 191\0. The Industrial Tribunal, by its award dated June 24,
1 960. after considering the financial position of the Company,
held that for the years, 1951, 1957, 1958' and 1959, the Company
should make contributions to the Provident fund at the rate of S!
pe.r cent of the basic wages to the workers uncovered by the
Scheme under the Act and that the Company need not make any
contributions for the years 1950 and 1952 to 1956, as during
those years they have suffered loses. It ga.ve a further direction
that from March I, 1960 the Company is to make contribution at
6t p~r cent of the wages and Dearness Allowance. The Referenc~ also related to the claim for Dearness Allowance and the
Tribunal had adjudicated on that aspect also.
A
B
c
D
After the decision of this Court, referred to above, rendered
on March 14, 1962, the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner,
by his letter dated March 2Z, 19.63 called upon the respondent
to make its share of the Proviaent Fund contributions at the
statutory rate for the period November 1, 19.52 to December 31,
1960 together with administrative charges for the said period.
The Company made representations protesting against the demand F
made by the Regional. Provident Fund Commissioner. In parti:
cular. they pleaded th~t there has been already a decision by the
Central Government under s. 19A of the Act holding that the
Act and the Scheme apply only to the Lantern and Stoves Section
and on the basis of that decision the contributions made by them,
under protest, with regard to the employees working in the other
sections had been refunded and therefore the department was not G
entitled to call upon the Company to make contributions for the
years in question. They further contested the claim of the department on the ground that the· question regardlhg the liability of the
Company to make contributions to the provident fund was the
subject of adjudication under the Awa.rd of the Industrial Tribunal
dated June 24. 1960 and this Award precluded the department H
from claiming contributions for the identical period. The Company raised a further objection that even on the basis of the decision of this Court, the Act does not apply to its other sections.
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS
A
B
(Vaidia/ingam, J.) 529
These objections raised by the Company were negatived by
the department which threatened to take coercive steps to coiled
the contributions if the demand, under the order dated May 22,
1963 was not complied with. The respondent, in consequence
filed the writ petition in the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High
Court challenging the demand made by the Regional Prmident
Fund Commissioner by his order dated May 22, 1963 and sought
relief for restraining the officers concerned from enforcing the
demand and for quashing the said order.
The appellant contested 1he writ petition on various grounds.
but it is only necessary to note that their main plea was that there
been no decision of the Central Government under s. l 9A of
c has
the Act to the effect that the Act and the Scheme apply only to the
Lantern and Stove Section of the respondent. On the other hand,
their plea was that the Act and the Scheme had been made applicable to the entire establishment of the r2spondent comprising ail
its sections and covering the entire body of workmen employed in
the said establishment. The respondent has been making contriI)
butions as per the scheme framed under the Act. But in view of the
decision of the Bombay High Court, which they had to respect and
obey, they had provisionally decided that the contributions will b~
collected from the respondent only in respect of those sections,
which have been held by the High Court to be governed by the Act.
This decision was a purely provisional and tentative one pending
E the adjudication by this Court regarding the correctness of the
decision of the Bombay High Court, which was being challenged
by the appellants. It was in view of the Bombay High Court's
judgment that the amounts by way of contributions collected
from the respondent in respect of the workmen who were held not
to be goverened by the Act, were either refunded or adjusted
towards his future contributions in respect of those workmen to
F whom the Act applied. In this connection the appellants relied
on the correspondence that passed between them and the respondent as well as the correspondence that the appellant had with the
employees' Union. But after the decision of this Court holding
that the Act applies even to a composite establishment, the appellants necessarily had to take up the matter from the stage a1 which
G it was left because of the Bombay High Court's decision and in
consequence made demands on the respondent to comply with the
provisions of the Act and the Scheme. The appellants forth.er
pleaded that the award of the Industrial Tribunal had no relevancy in considering the statutory liability of the respondent under
the Act. Further, it was pointed out by them that the principles
H o~ which the adju.dication was given were not at all in conformity
with the Act. Fmally, th~. appellants pleaded that they, having
a duty to enforce the prov1S1ons of the Act, which was a benevo,
lent measure in the interest of the worlqnen, issued the demand
530
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1972J l S.C.R.
dated May 22, 1963 which is in conformity with the decision of
this Court.
A
The High Court, by its judgment and order under appeal, has
held that the letter dated August 19, 1959 sent by the Central
Provident Fund Commissioner, New Delhi, to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner read with the letter dated September 21,
B
1959 sent by the latter to the respondent clearly shows that there
has been a decision under s. l 9A of the Act that only the Lantern
;md Stoves as well as Enamel Sections of the respondent Company
would be covered by the provisions of the Act and that the order
of the Central Government having become final, the appellants
have no right to have the question of liability of the respondent in
respect of the other sections reopened. In this view, the High C
Court did not consider it necessary to go into the question whether
the decision of the Central Government as contained in the two
letters referred to above, was inconsistent with the provisions of
the Act, nor did it think it necessary to consider the effect of the
award in I.D. No. 29 of 1960. The High Court rejected the
claim of the appellants that the decision not to enforce the Act in D
respect of the other sections was only a tentative one pending
adjudication by this Court regarding the correctness of the Bombay High Court's judgment. Though it was contended by the
respondent that even on the basis of the decision of this Court,
the Act and tlie Scheme will not apply to all sections of its establishment, the High Court rejected that contention on the ground
that the manufacture of glass wares, the enamel wares and the E
lantern and stoves was the industrial activity of the respondent and
that to such a case the decision of this Court will apply and that
the respondent Company -will be governed by the provisions of
the Act and the Scheme. Ultimately, the High Court quashed
the demand made under the order dated May 22, 1963 and gave
directions to the appellants not to enforce the said demand.
F
On behalf of the appellants Mr. R. H. Dhebar, learned counsel, very strenuously urged that the High 9ourt has committed a
very serious error in construing the letters dated August 19, 1959
and September 21, 1959 as indicating that there has been a decision by the Central Government under s. 19A, accepting the
contentions of the res1_JOndent. The counsel pointed out that the G
entire correspondence clearly shows that in view of the decision
of the Bombay High Court, the respondent's Claim for adjustment
of the amount paid by them was provisionally accepted pending
the appellants' appeal in this Court challenging the decision of the
Bombay High Court. The counsel further urged that the award
o[ the Industrial Tribunal has no relevancy or bearing in con- H
sidering the statutory liability of the respondent under the Act. ·
The appellants were not parties to the award and they have gol a
statutory duty to enforce the provisions of the Act in the interest
uNION OF INDIA V. OGALE GLASS WORKS
A
(Vaidialingam. J.) 531
of the employees. On facts, the counsel urged, there can be no
controversy regarding the application of the Act to all the activities of the respondent. Therefore, he pointd out that the demand
made by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner on May 22,
1963 was justified and the demand in any event are for the peri~
not covered by the industrial adjudication.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
Mr. V. M. Tarkunde, learned counsel for the respondent, has
supported the judgment of the High Court in full as also the reasons given by the High Court for holding that there has been a
decision by the Central Government under s. 19A. In this connection he referred to certain passages contained in the communications that passed between the appellants and the respondent. The
counsel further urged that when the Central Government took a
decision under s. 19A, as is evidenced by the letter: dated August
19, 1959 ·and September 21, 1959, that decision was not in any
manner inconsistent with the provisions of the Act. The said
decision by the Central Government was not a provisional one to
abide the adjudication by this Court regarding the Bombay High
Court's judgment. On the other hand, the said decision was a
totallyfodependent one taken under s. 19A by the Central Government in respect of the respondent's establishment in view of the
contentions raised by it before the appropriate authorities. The
counsel further urged that the liability of the respondent for the
period now covered by the demand dated May 22, 1963 was the
subject of adjudication by the Industrial Tribunal on a dispute
raised by the employees. The award has considered all aspects
and has exempted tb,e respondent from making any contribution
for certain years. That decision is binding on the workmen and
the award is still in force. The claim made by the appellants is
really an attempt made by the employees indirectly to circumvent
the decision in I.D. No. 29 of 1960. Finally, the counsel urged
that even on the principles laid down by this Court regarding· the
applicability of the Act, the respondent's objections regarding their
liability in respect of certain sections are valid.
We can straightaway dispose of the last point urged oy Mr.
Tarkunde that the Act does not apply to all sections of the respondent's establishmc:nt. We have already referred to the decision
of_ the High Court r~jecting the contentions of the respondent in
this regard and holdmg that the manufacture of glass material,
enamel and lantern and stoves, was the industrial activity of . the
respan~ent and that the decision of this Court squarely applies
which, m consequence, makes the Act and the Scheme applicable
to all sections of the respondent. That is a decision recorded by
the High Court on facts and we see no error in this conclusion
reached by the High Court.
532
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] l S.C.R.
Mr. Tarkunde, however, contended that this Court in the case
of The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Bombay v. Shree
Krishna Metal Manufacturing Co., Bhandara(1) has held that the
Act and the Scheme apply to all the sections of the glass works on
the basis of s. 2A, which was inserted ill the Act, with effect from
December 31, 1960 by the Employees Provident Fund (Amendment) Act, 1960 (Act 46 of 1960). Section 2A is as follows :
"2A-Establishment to include all departments and
branches:
For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that
where an establishment consists of different departments
or has branches, whether situate in the same place or in
different places, all such departments or branches shall
be treated as parts of the same."
As the said section takes effect only from December 31, 1960,
the counsel argued, that the decision of this Court does not apply
to the respondent for the years in respect of which the demand is
made. We are not inclined to accept this contention of the learned counsel. This Court has elaborately considered the various
provisions of the Act, and having due regard to the activities of
the Company with which they were qealing held that . the Act
applies to a composite factory. No doubt this Court has also
referl'~d to s. 2A, which has been added by the Amendment Act 46
of 1960 only for the purpose of emphasising that the said provision makes it clear that an establishment may ·consist 'Of different
departments or may have different branches, whether situated in
the same place or in different places and yet all such departments
or branches shall be treated as parts of tlie same establishment.
Reference to this Section has been made only for the purpose of
giving an additional reason for negativing the contention that the
establishment under s. 1(3) (a) does not contemplate a composite
factory. Therefore, it follows that the Act and the Scheme fully
apply to a composite establishment like that of the respondent, as
held by this Court, in the decision referred to above.
Two questions now fall, to be considered in this appeal,
namely, (i) whether there has been a decision of the Central
Government under s. 19A of the Act as contended by the respondent, and (ii) the effect of the award in l.T. No. 29 of 1960. In
order to appreciate the contentions of the learned counsel on both
sides, it is necessary to refer to the material provisions of the Act
and also to the correspondence that passed between the appellants
and the respondent.
The Act, as its preamble shows is to provide for the institution
of provident fund for the employees in factories and other establishments. Sub-section 3 of s. I provides for the applicability
(I) [19621 Supp. 3 S.C.R. 815.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
(Vaidialingam, !.) 533
of the Act to the establishments referred to therein. There is no
controversy that the Act has been made applicable. to the respondent Company on October 6, 19S2 and the Company has been
paying its share of contribution to the emJ?loyees provident fund
from November 1, 19S2.
Section 2 defines the various expr§ssi_ons. In particular four
expressions require to be noticed, namely, "contribution" "scheme"
"1fiember' 'and "fund". Under s. 2(c) "contribution" means a
contribution payable in respect of a member under a Scheme.
Under s. 2(1) "Scheme" means a Scheme framed under the Act.
Under s. 2(j) "member" means a member of the fund and under
s. 2(h) "Fund" means the provident fund established under a
Scheme.
We have already pointed out that s. 2A has also been referred
to by this Court in The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner,
Bombay v. Shree Krishna Metal Manufacturing Co., Bhandara(I)
for holding that the Act applies to a composite establishment.
Section 5 deals with the framing of a Scheme by the Central
Government called "Employees Provident Fund Scheme". Under
sub-s. 2 of s. 5, a scheme framed under sub-section (I) can
provide that any of the provisions shall take effect either prospectively or retrospectively from such date as may be specified in this
behalf in the Scheme. Sections 5A to SC deal with the constitution of the Central Board, the State Board and treating the
Board of Trustees a body corporate, Section SD ( i) empowers the
Central Government to appoint a Central Provident Fund Commissioner who is to be the Chief Executive Officer of the Central
Board and to work subject to the general control and superintendence of the Central Board. Sub-section (2) of s. 5D similarly empowers the Central Government to appoint Provident
Fnnd Commissioners, Regional Provident Fund Commissioners
and other officers to assist the Central Provident Fund Commissioner in the discharge of his duties. Section SE provides for the
Central Board, with the prior approval of the Central Government
and a State Board with the prior approval of the State Government to delegate to its Chairman or any of its officers such of its
powers and functions under the Act as are necessary for the efficient administration of the Scheme.
Section 6 deals with the contributions to be paid by the employer to the fund. It is to be at 6!% of the basic wages and
Dearness Allowance and Returning Allowance, if any, for the time
being payable to the employees. It also provides for the emplo'!ees contribution to be equal to 1the contribution payable by the
employer. At this stage ~t may be mentioned . that during the
period for which the demand has been made contribution is to be
(1) [1962] Supp. 3 S.C.R.815.
534
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
fl 972] l S.C.R.
made at 6 l % of the basic wages including Dearness Allowance,
though the expression "Basic Wages" under s. 2B excludes Dearness Allowance. In I.T. No. 29 of 1960 the Tribunal, even for
the years for which the contribution has been directed to be made,
has fixed it only on the basic wages excluding Dearness Allowance.
A
Under s. 7A the officers mentioned therein have been empowered to determine the amount due from any employer under
any provision of the Act or of the Scheme. Section 8 deals with
the manner of recovery of the amount due from the employer.
Section 19 provides fo~ the apropriate government delegating any
power, authority or jurisdiction exercisable by it under the Act or
the Scheme to the appropriate offices mentioned therein.
B
c
Section J 9A, under which, according to the respondent, a
decision has been taken by the Central Government regarding
non-applicability of the Act to some of its sections, disputed by
it, runs as follows :
"l 9A. Power to remove difficulties :
If any difficulty arises in giving effect to the proviD
sions of this Act, and in particular, if any doubt arises
as to:
( i) whether an establishment which is a factory is
engaged in any industry specified in Schedule I;
(ii)· whether any particular establishment is an estaE
blishment falling within the class of establishments to which this Aot applies by virtue of notf..
fication under clause (b) of sub-section 3 of
section 1;
(iii) the number of persons employed in an establishment;
F
(iv) the number of years which have elapsed from the
date on which an establishment has been set up;
or
(v) whether the total quantum of benefits to which
an employee is entitled has been reduced by the
employer,
G
the Central Government may, by order, make such provision or give such direction, not inconsistent with the
provisions of this Act, as appear to it to be necessary or
expedient for the removal of the doubt or difficulty; and.
the order of the Central Government, in such cases;
shall be final."
It may also be stated that according to the respondent a controversy arose whether its establishment is one falling within the
class of establishment to which the Act applies by virtue of noti-
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS (Vaidialingam, /.) 535
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
fication under cl. (b) of sub-section (3) of s. 1 and it is in view
of that controversy that the Central Government took a decision
accepting the respondent's contention. Such a dispute raised by
the respondent squarely comes under cl. (2) of s. 19A, and that
decision has become final. It is not necessary to refer to the
Scheme as there is no dispute that if the Act applies, the Scheme
framed thereunder does not violate any provision of the Act.
From a review of the sections, it will be seen that the Act is.
essentially a measure 'for the welfare of the employees; and if the
Act applies and a Scheme has been framed for an establishment,
the employer is bound to make the contributions as provided for
under s. 6, There is a statutory liability on an employer to pay
the contribution at the rate mentioned in s. 6. Stringent provisions have been made for non compliance with the requirement
of '!he statute and very drastjc powers have been given to the authorities to recover the contribution due from an employer. Though
there i• a hierarchy of officials, nevertheless, it is only the Central
Government that has been given power under s. 19A to ·give a
direction not inconsistent with the provisions of the Act, if any
doubt arises regarding one or other matters referred to in Cls. (i)
to ( v) ; and that power is to be exercised when any difficulty or
doubt arises in giving effect to the provisions of the Act. While
the contention of the respondent is that the letter dated August 19,
1959 read with letter dated September 21, 1959 constitutes a
direction given by the Central Government under s. 19A, according to the appellants no such direction has been given because the
Central Government had no occasion to consider the matters
mentioned under cl. (ii) of s. 19A.
Now the question arises whether there was any occasion for
the Central Government to give a direction under s. 19A in. the
case of the respondent. In order to understand the context in
which the letters dated August 19, 1959 and September 21, 1959
relied on by the respondent came to be written and to understand
their full implication, it is necessary to refer to the correspondence
that passed between the appellants and the respondent, both prior
and subsequenJ to August 19, 19S9. The judgment of th>~ Bombay High Couprt in the Nagpur Glass Works' case( 1 ) was rendered on March 7, 1957. The respondent in its letter dated
December I 0, 1957 addressed to the Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner, Bombay, after refering to the Act having been
m·ade applicable to its es~ablishment, gave a list of its activities, as
well as the number of the employees working in the various sections. The number of employees to whom the Provident Fund ..
Scheme under the Act applied has also been stated. The respondent then refers to a representation made to the Regional Provident Fund, Commissioner stating that the Act applied only to
0) I. L. R. [1958] Born. 444.
536
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[l 9 72] l S.C.R.
some of its sections, but this representation was rejected by the
-officer concerned as early as March 31, 1953. The Company
.then states that the view of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner as expressed in his letter dated March 31, 1953 that the
Act applies to all sections of the establishment is erroneous in view
of the decision of. the Bombay High Court rendered on March 7,
1957 in the case of Nagpur Glass Works('). After refering to
the material part of the judgment of the High Court, the respondent states that in view of the said decision, the Act, which has
.been made applicable to all the employees working under the respondent can be made applicable legally only to those employees
l!ngaged in the manufacture of Hurricane Lanterns and non
pressure stoves. On this basis, the Company further makes a
request to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner to reconsider his previous view expressed in the letter of March 31, 1953
and grant suitable relief to. The Company winds up the letter by
making a request to the Officer that the contributions made by it
all along even in respect of the employees not covered by the Act
as per the Bombay High Court decision, may either be refunded
or adjusted towards future contributions payable by them in respect of employees to whom the Act will apply under the said
decision.
Two circumstances emerge from this letter of the Company :
(i) that from the very beginning 'the Act has been applied to all the
employees of the respondent working in all its sections and that a
representation made by it to revise the Scheme was not accepted
by the Department even as early as March 31, 1953 and the Company has been making provident fund contributions. for all its
·employees; and (ii) the letter dated December 10, 1957 is necessaciated, as expressly mentioned therein because of the judgment
of the Bombay High Court dated March 7, 1957 and it is on the
basis of that judgment that the Department was being asked to
reconsider its previous view regarding the applicability of the Act
to all the employees of the Company. Therefore, even the very
earlier letter written by the Company asking for modification of
the Scheme is really rested on the judgment of the Bombay High
Court. On November 28, 1958 the Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner, Bombay wrote a letter to the Company. In that
letter he referred to the Company's letter of September 1, 1958
where the latter appears to have stated that it "would be justified
in withholding the payment of employer's share till final decision
from Supreme Court is obtained "The officer then refers to the
General Secretary for the employee's Union having met him and
represented that the respondent was recovering the employees share
of provident fund contribution every month. On inquiry, the
officer states, that the said amount is not being remitted or credited
towards the employees· share for the months for which the
(l) I.LR. [1958] Born. 444.
A
'I
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS (Vnidia/ingam, J.) 537
A
amounts have been collected by the respondent. The officer
makes a request to the respondent to remit the amounts collected
by it as early as possible. This letter of the Regional Provident
Fund Commissioner again indicates that the respondent itself has
been taking up the position that it will be justified in not making
contribution to the provident fund till a final decision is given by
B the Supreme Court. That clearly indicates that the Department
had taken up in appeal the judgment of the Bombay High Court
to this Court and the respondent was fully aware of the same.
This letter further shows that it was not as if the employer, the
respondent, was totally denying its liability under all circumstance>.
lt limits it only till a final decision regarding the correctness of
c the Bombay High Court's view is given by this Court.
On December 22, 1958, the respondent again sends a letter to
the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner stating that they have
never disputed their liability to pay the workers and Company\
contriuution so far as the LaQ.tern and Glass Departments were
concerned. However the Company affirms that they are dispuring
D their liability to contribute in respect of the workers in the Glass,
Enamel and. other Departments. The Company gave an account
of the total amount contributed by it from November 1, 1952, the.
date when the Act was made applicable to the Company, till
October 31, 1958. The Company further says:
"We have so far remitted to you Rs. 7,06,914.87 np.
i.e. we.have paid you in excess a sum of Rs. 1,11,940/E
since employees in Glass, Enamel and other Departments are not covered by the Act according to the decision of the High Court and the matter is now under
consideration of the Supreme Court of India."
The Company makes a request to the Officer to adjust, what
F according to them, were excess payments. Tue Company further
states :
"The excess amount of Rs. 1,11,940/ .. after adjusting all dues upto 31-10-58 may be retained with you till
the Supreme Court finally decides tr~ matter."
This letter further emphasises thaf the respondent was raising
G a dispute regarding their non-liability to contribute in respect of
certain sections mainly on the basis of the Bombay High Court
decision. Tuey also specifically referred to the appeal against the
decision of the Bombay High Court pending in this Court. It is
on this basis that the respondent states that the excess amounts
that have been paid by them may be retained till this Court finally
H decides the matter. Therefore, the non-liability pleaded by the
respondent is again based upon the judgment of the Bombay High
Court and the period during which the non-liability is sought to
. be extended is till this Court finally adjudicates upon the matter.
538
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972) l S.C.R.
Then we come to the two crucial letters dated August 19,
1959 and_September 21, 1959. The first is a letter written by the
Central Provident Fund Commissioner, New Delhi to the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner, Bombay. Obviously, after the
judgment of the Bombay High Court, some correspondence seems
to have taken place between the officers concerned and the
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner sought clarification from
the Central Provident Fund Commi~sioner. The Central Provident Fund Commissioner in this letter states :
"We have since been advised by the Government of
India that the "enamel" and "lanterns and stoves" sections of the Ogale Glass Works Ltd., will continue to be
covered under the Employees Provident Fund Act,
1952. The Provident Fund contributions deposited
by the management in respect of the remaining sections
of the factory viz., (i) general, (ii) glass, and (iii)
canteen may be refunded to them."
The second letter dated September 21, 1959 was addressed to
the respondent by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
after getting clarification from the Central Provident Fund Commissioner. fo this letter it is stated that the Act and the Scame
framed thereunder has been made applicable to Enamel and
Latern and Stoves sections of the respondent's factory and that the
amounts deposited by them in respect of the other sections.
namely, (i) general, (ii) glass, and (iii) canteen are to be r~fund
ed. The respondent was desired to submit a list as on August 31.
1959, giving the account numbers and the names of the employees
who will be uncovered by the Act and also put in a claim for the
excess amount paid by it. Prima facie if these two letters of
August 19, 1959 and September 21, 1959 are read each by itself
and in isolation without having any regard to what has passed
between the parties and the Department, both prior and subsequent, the matters mentioned in these two letters may appear to
support the contentions of the respondent that the Central Government has given a direction that the Act and the Scheme will apply
only to the Enamel and Lantern and Stoves Sections of the respondent. That is what is stated in the letter of the Central Provident Fund Commissioner to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner. On the basis of the letter dated August 19, 1959, the
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner also informs the respondent that the Act and the Scheme will apply only to those sections
and the excess contributions will be refunded. The High .Court.
in our opinion, has laid undue emphasis on the use of the expression "We have since been advised by the Government of India"
occuring in the letter of August 19, 1959. According to the High
C,ourt some doubt must have been raised by the'Regional Provident
Fund Commissioner regarding the applicab!_lity of the Act 'to all the
A
'•.
B
c
D
'--·
F
G
H
•
UNION OF INDIA
v. OGALE GLASS WORKS ( Vaidialingam, J.) 5 3 9
A
sections of the establishment of the respondent and these doubts
must in turn have Been referred to by the Central Provident Fund
Commissioner to the Central Government for resolving the doubts.
The Central Qovernment, according to the High Court, can be
moved only under s. 19A of the Act, and it inust have given a
direction, as indicated in the letter of August 19, 1959. ThereB fore, it is the view of the High Court that a final direction has been
given under s. 19A by the competent authority, the Central
Government, regarding non-applicability of the Act and the
Scheme to ( i) general, (ii) glass, and (iii) canteen sections of the
respondent establishment. The advice that is referred to in !he
letter of the August 19, 1959 is really a direction of the Central
The High Court finds further support for this conc Government.
clusion in the letter of September 21, 1959. This letter, according to the High Court, makes the position very clear that the decision of the Central Government regarding the non-applicability of
the Act to !lheAi) general, (ii) glass; and (iii) canteen sections has
been communicated to the respondent and in addition the Department has also undertaken to refund the excess payments made by
D the respondent in respect of the employees working in these three
sections. According to the High Court the contentions of the
respondent in this regard have been accepted by the O~ntral Government and a decision, which has become final, has been given in
favour of the respondent under s. 19A.
E
F
We are not inclined to agree with this reasoning of the learned
Judges of the High Court in the interpretation placed on these
two letters. They have not given due weight to the earlier letters
already referred to by us, where it has been catgorically stated,
even by the respondent, that its claim regarding non-applicability
of the Act in respect of the three sections is exclusively based on
the decision of the Bomliay High Court and it wants the excess
payment made by it to be kept to its credit till the · matter is
finally adjudicated upon by this Court. The Department also in
its replies specifically refers to the matter pending in this Court
in appeal. The High Court has ignored all these factors when it
held that there has been a decision taken under s. 19A by the
Central Government.
G
H
The further view of the High Court is that there is nothing in
the letters of August 19, 1959 and September 21, 1959 that the
decision of the Central Government was only a tentative or provismnal one, which could be taken up for reconsideration depending
upon the judgment that may be given by this Court. Even here
the view of the High Court is wrong. If the two letters are properly understood in the context of the previous correspon~nce,
the position that there has been no decision by the Central Government under s. 19A and that any order for refund of the excess
..
540
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 s.c.R.
amount that may have been passed was purely provisional or tentative pending the decision by this Court, is made clearer by the
subsequent letters to which we will make a reference immediately.
A
On October 14, 1959 the Central Provident Fund Commissioner addressed a letter to the General Secretary of the Employees' Union that the Central Government has decided, at the
instance of the respondent, that the coverage of (i) general, (ii)
glass, and (iii) canteen sections be discontinued and that the provident fund amounts deposited be refunded. The letter proceeds
to say:
"This decision is due to the judgment of the Bombay
High Court in the cases of Oudh Sugar Mills Ltd., etc.
You will agree that the decision of the Bombay High
Court. had to be given effect to till the appeal preferred
by us in those cases is favourably decided by the
Supreme Court of India. It will take some more time
for getting the Supreme Court's decision and you will
appreciate that it is not in our hands to expedite the
decision.''
c
D
The officer then refers to a suggestion made by the Union for
amending the Act and states that it is not acceptable to the GOvernment of India. Finally, the officer winds up the letter by saying
that nothing can be done till a favourable decision is obtained
from this Court in the appeal filed by the Department against the E
Bombay High Court judgment. · The Union appears to have
been distressed at the decision of the Bombay High Court and
representations appear to have been made to the authorities. The
Union is pacified by the officer that the decision taken regarding
the respondent being a limited one and that such ·a decision was
i:icvitable in view of the Bombay High Court's judgment and that
the position will continue to be the ~ame till the final adjudication F
by this Court in appeal
Therefore, here again it is seen that the Department is putting
in the forefront the Bombay High Court judgment as an obstacle
to enforce the provisions of t!le' Act in respect of all the sections
of the respondent and is waiting the judgment of this Court.
On October 17, 1959, the Union through its Secretary again
addressed a letter to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
regarding the decision of the respondent to discontinue its contribution under the Act in view of the letter of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner dated September 21, 1959.. Tfie
Union takes objections to the Department having taken a decision
like that in favour of the Management when the matter is pending
appeal before this Court. The Union expressed its resentment
that the Department has not waited till the decision was given
G
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS
A
B
c
D
E
F
(Vaidialingam, J.) 541
by this Court. On November 20, 1959 the r~s~ondent ~~ote a
letter to the Regional Provident Fund Comffilssmner givmg a
statement of accounts of the · deposits made by them and
stating the excess amount that is refundable to them being the
contributions made in respect of the employees not covered by
the Act. The respo11dent malres a request for refund of the
amount. On April 20, 1960 the Regional Provident Fund Commisioner informed the respondent about the refund of the amount
of all the employees who are not covered by the Act.
It appears that in view of the fact that the respon~ent stopped
making the contributions in respect of the employees m the ~hree
sections concerned, the Union raised a dispute and the Government accordingly referred the said matter for adjudication to the
Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra. The Tribunal has made - an
award on June 24, 1960 in I.T. No. 29 of 1960, which will be
referred to by us when dealing with the second contention. At
this stage it is enough to note that there was a reference regarding
the provident fund and there was an award on June 24, 1960.
This Court delivered its judgment on March 14, 1962 reversing
the decision of the Bombay High Court. In view of the decision
of this Court, which was favourable to the employees, the Union
on March 28, 1962, addressed a letter to the Central Provident
Fund Commissioner drawing his urgent attention to the decision
of this Court wherein it has been held that the Act applies to all
composite units. The letter then refers to the discontinuance of
contributions by the respondep.t, in view of the letter dated September 21, 1959 of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner.
The Union reiterates that in view of the decision of this Court,
the respondent is liable to pay the provident fund amount accord'
ing to the Act and the Scheme. The officer is requested by the
Union to take the necessary steps to realise the amounts from the
employer, the respondent.
On January 3, 1963 the Central Provident Fund Commissioner addressed a letter to the Secretary, Government of India
Ministry of Labour and Employment. In the said letter th~
G
officer states that the aJ?plicabi~ty of the Act to the respondent
has to be reconsidered m the hght of the decision of this Court
overruling the decision of the Bombay High Court. The officer
proceeds .to s.tate that the respondent who was originally making
the contnbutions stopped domg so after the decision of the
Bombay High Court and the excess payment made between November, 1952 to December, 1960 were adjusted in view of the
H
advice given by the Central Government. The Central Provident
:f'.und Commissioner finally requested the Government to recon. sider the case of the respondent and to direct the same to pay the
16--U 140SupCl.'7l
542
.SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
contributions as per the Act and the Scheme in the light of the
decision' .of this Court from November, 1952 to December, 1960
at the statutory rate.
On January 21, 1963, the Union again wrote a letter to the
central Provident Fund Commissioner. After a reference to· the
various matters regarding the Bombay High Courts' judgment
and the contributions being stopped by the respondent and the
decision of this Court as well as the award of the Industrial
Tribunal in Reference I. T. No. 29 of of 1960, it requested the
officer to collect the provident fund contributions from the respondent from 1952 to 1959 in respect of general, glass and
canteen sections.
On May 22, 1963, the order impugned by the respondent in
its writ petition in the High Court was passed by the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner calling upon the respondent to
pay its share of provident fund contribution at the statutory rates
for the period November I, 1952 to December 31, 1960 together
with the administrative charges for the said period. It is stated
that the demand is made as per the directions issued by the Government of India. The respondent made a representation by its
letter dated May 27, 1963 disputing its liability to pay the· amount
and rt)lied on the award of the Industrial Tribunal in I. T. No. 29
of 1960. The Company also made a request for being furnished
with a copy of the Government's directions. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner sent a reply dated August 31, 1963
declining to furnish a copy of the Government's directions as
they were all contained in the Department's files. It is further stated
that the respondent has to pay the employer's share of provident
fund .contributions at the statutory rates from November I, 1952
to Dec!lmber 31, 1960 in view _of the decision of this Court making the Act and the Scheme applicable to a composite factory and
the officer rejected the plea of the respondent that they are not
liabel to pay the amount.
On October 5, 1963, the respondent sent a further communication to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner. In that
letter after setting out all the previous matters, the Company
took up the stand that there has been a .decision by the Central
Government under s. 19A of the Act and that the said decision
is final and binding on the parties and that it is not open to
the Department to go behind those directions. The Company
refers to the letter written by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner on September 21, 19 59 regarding the decision of the
Central Government about non-applicability of the Act to the
three sections of the respondent. Ultimately, the respondent
disputed its liability to pay the demand made on May 22, 1963
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
UNION OF INDIA v. OGALE GLASS WORKS ( Vaidialingam,
A
J.) 543
and has further stated that if the demand is pursued the respondent will seek relief in a Court of law.
On January 22, 1964 the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner sent a reply stating that the claim made by the respondent
about its non-liability is rejected. The officer in turn called
B upon the respondent to pay its share of the provident fund dues
and administrative charges immediately as demanded by the
letter dated May 22, 1963. On receipt of this communication
the respo,1dent filed the writ petition.
From the letters referred to above, which have passed
between
respondent and the Department as well as the latter
c and the the
Union concerned subsequent to September 21, 1959,
it is clear that the Department has been taking up the position
consistently that the original decision of the Central Government
not to apply the Act and the Scheme to the three sections of the
respondent was a pnrely tentative and provisional one and that
decision was passed because of the decision of the B6mbay
0
High Court Th·~ correspondence referred to above leaves llo
room for doubt that any decision taken by the Central Government-if it can be callec.i a decision-was a purely tentative one
subject to the final adjudication that is to be made by this
Court. Under those circumstances it is idle for the respondent
to contend that when the authorities informed them that the
E Act has been made applicable only to some sections of its
establishment, an irrevocable decision has be.en taken in favour
of the Company. On the other hand, it is very clear from the
stand taken by the officers, as well as the respondent itself, that
it was only a tentative decision taken by the Government by
which it advised the officers not to enforce the Act to the three
F sections of the establishment of the respondent, in view of the
decision of the Bombay High Court. Immediately after the
decision of this Court was given on March 14, 1962, the employees' Union of the respondent promptly on March 28, 1962
moved the officers to apply the provisions of the Act as per
the decision of this Court. It was only at that very late stage
G that the respondent took up the plea that there has been originally a decision by the Central Government under s. 19A of the
Act and that the said decision having become final is binding
on the Company and the Department. From the entire correspondence it is clear that there has been no final decision taken
by the Central Government under s. 19A of the Act regarding
non-applicability of the Act and the Sc!ieme in respect of the
H
three sections of the responde,1t's establishment. At the most,
a decision was taken to suspend the applicability of the Act
during the pendency of the appeal in this Court. Once the
544
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
decision of the Bombay High Court was set aside by this Court,
the Department was within its right in making the demand made
under the letter dated May 22, 1963. Under sub-s. (2) of s. 3
of the Act, we have already pointed out that a scheme framed
under sub-section ( 1) may provide that any of its provisions
shall take effect either prospectively or retrospectively. In fact
there is no question of any claim being made in this case retrospectively. The position is that the amounts that were originally
paid but later on adjusted or refunded in view of the Bombay
High Court's -judgment are being asked to be paid back for the
same period in view of the judgment of this Court. Therefore,
the demand made on May 22, 1963 to pay the amount from
1952 is, in our opinion, justified.
A
B
c
The matter may be considered from another point of view
also. It is the case of the respondent that there has been a direction given by the Central Government under s. 19A by letters
dated August 19, 1959 and September 21, 1959. The matters
referred to in these letters have already been referred to by us. D
The judgment of the Bombay High Court was given on March 7,
1957. If so, after the decision given by the High Court interpreting the _Act in a particular manner, we fail to see how an
occasion will arise for the Central Government giving a direction
under s. 19A on the ground that a difficulty h<I!! arisen in giving
effect to the provisions of the Act and that doubt has arisen
regarding the matters mentioned in els. ( i) to ( v). After a deci- E
sion has been given by a court on a particular aspect relating to
the Act and the Scheme, in our opinioe, there is no question of
any difficulty arising in giving effect to the provisions of the Act
or to any doubt arising in respect of the matters mentioned in
els. (i) to (v). The question whether an establishment, like that
of the respondent relating to the glass works coming under cl. F
(2) of s. 19A was subject of a judicial adjudication and therefore
s. 19A could not have come into play for the Central to give _any
direction. The Central Govrenment and all other authorities
were bound to give effect to the decision of the Bombay High
Court so long as it held the field. Even according to the respondent. as is seen by its letter dated December 10, 1957 addressed G
to the Regional Provident Fund Commisisoner, when the Act and
the Scheme were applied in 1952 to all the employees of the
respondent, the latter raised an objection that the Act and the
Scheme will apply only to employees enga).;'w in the manufacture
of Hurricane Lanterns and non pressure Stoves. The said letter
also refers to the fact that the Regional Provident Fund Commis- H
sioner, Bombay, by his reply dated March 31, 1953 rejected the
said objection and held that the whole of the establishment of the
_ respondent was covered by the Act and the Scheme. There is
UNION OJ. !NlJIA v. OGALL Gi..ASS WORKS
lVaidialillgam. J.) 545
A
no controversy that the respondent has been ever since making
contributions in respect of all the employees and had raised no
dispute at all till after the judgment cf the Bombay High Court.
The proper stage when a doubt might have arisen for the Central
Govermnent to exercise its jurisdiction under s. 19A was when
the respondent raised an objection early in 1953 regarding nonB applicability of the Act to all its employees, and when that
objection was rejected on March 31, 1953. If the matter had
been pursued further and the Central Government moved am.l a
direction was given by th.e Central Government then it could be
said that the Central Government has given a direction undre s.
19A. The position before us is. entirely different. After the
c decision of 1the Bombay High Court there is no warrant for assuming that there was still a difliculty or doubt in respect of which
the Cenu·al Government had to give a direction under s. 19A.
Considering the matter from this aspect also it follows that there
could not have been a direction issued by the Central Government under s. 19A when the letter of August 19, 1959 was sent
D by the Central Provident Fund Conunissioner to the Regional
Provident Fund Comntissioner.
To conclude we are not inclined to agree with the view of the
High Court that there has been decision under s. 19A of the Act
under the letter dated August 19, 1959 read with letter dated
September 21, 1959. There has been, in our opinion, no such
E decision. and as pointed out earlier it was only a limited decision
not to apply the Act and the Scheme in view of the Bombay High
Court's judgment till the disposal of the appeal in this Court.
After the decision of this Court the demand made on the respondent is perfectly justified and the High Court committed an error
in quashing the notice dated May 22, 1963.
F
G
H
The second contention about the non-liability of the respondent based upon t.iie award of the Industrial Tribunal in I. T. No.
29 of 1960 need not detain us very long. It is true that in view of
the decision of the Bombay High Court the employees' Union
moved the State Government to refer the dispute regarding the
providen't fund. The award dated June 24, 1960 has given as
mentioned certain directions in this regard. The Company has
been absolved from making any provident fund contributions
during certain years on the ground that it has suffered Joss. The
award is not based upon circumstancJ;:s which are relevant for
the purpose of applying the Act and the Scheme.
Admittedly the appellants were not parties to the award. No
doubt under the Industrial Disputes Act the award will be binding as against the respondent and its workmen. But the appellants are seeking in 1hese proceedings to enforce the statutory
546
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
duty cast upon them to collect the contributions due from the
respondent which again is a statutory liability under the Act an.d
the Scheme. The object of the appellants m en forcmg the Act Is
only to discharge the statutori)' duty enjoined on them for the
benefit of the employees concerned. In view of the decision of
this Court, it is clear that the Act and the Scheme apply to all
the sections of the respondent, and if so it follows that the P~spon
dent is liable to make contributions and that at the rate specified
in the Act. Even the rate given by the Industrial Tribunai for the
limited perjod is not in accordance with the Act. We have
already pointed out that the High Court has not expressed any
opinion on the effect of the award. But according to us, the
award in I. T. No. 29 of 1960 does not stand in the way of the
appellants' demand for the period mentioned in the letter dated
May 22, 1953 regarding the provident fund and the administra-ive charges.
From the discussion contained above, it is also clear that
even if a decision has been taken by the Centra~ Government, it
is not inconsistent with the provisions of the Act. On the other
hand, as pointed out by us, that decision was only in accordance
with the decision of the Bombay High Court subject to iii being
revised, if the appeal succeeded in this Court. The Department
having succeeded in the appeal in this Court, it is clear that the
demand made by the Department is justified.
We, however, make it clear that in realising the amounts on
the basis of the demand dated May 22, I 963 the appellants will
give due credit for any amounts that may have been contributed
by the employer as its share of the provident fund under the
award in LT. No. 29 of 1960 for the periods in question. If no
contribution has been made for those periods, it is open to the
Department to realise the dues of the employer as per the provisions of the Act. If, however. the amounts have been contributed on!y at a k"er rate. the appellants can realise only the
balance, If any, due under the Act and the Scheme.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
A subsidiary contention was raised by Mr. Tarkunde that in
;my event_ the deinand .for payment of administrative charges for
the penoll referred to m the letter of May 22, 1963 is not
warranted. We are not inclined to accept this :;ontention of the
learned counsel. When once the employer is held liable for
l.'ayment. of it.s share of provident fund contribution for the periods
111 qu~stron. It follows that it will also be liable to p:iy lhc
adnumstrahve charges.
H
UNION OF INDIA
v. OGALE GLASS WORKS (Vaidialin1?am, J.) 547
A
In the result, the judgment and order of the High Court dated
September 17, 1965 are set aside and the writ petition filed by
the respor.dent will stand dismissed. The dppeal is allowed and
the appellants will be entitled to their costs in this appeal.
B
S.C.
Appeal allowed.
Petition dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org