MANAGEMENT OF THE KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS LTD. versus INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL, A.P. & ANR.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 26 August 1971 | [1972] 1 S.C.R. 428 | 1971 INSC 219
Key facts
- Decided
- 26 August 1971
- Bench
- G.K. MITTER*, C.A. VAIDYIALINGAM, P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1602/1966
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1972] 1 S.C.R. 428
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 219
Text of the judgment
428
MANAGEMENT OF THE KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS A.
LTD.
v.
INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL, A.P. & ANR.
August 26, 1971
B
[G. K. MITTER, C. A. VAIDIALINGAM AND P. )AGANMOHAN
REDDY, JJ.]
"-,
Industrial D'ispute-Recommendations of Central Wage Board for
sugar whether vitiated by fact tha1 it had 'fixed uniform wages region ~i$e
without further classification within each regidn-Tribunal's jurisdictio" to
go into question of financial cupacity of cq"tnpqny to implenient recommendations of Wage Board--Con1pany whether .. had financial capacity,
c
·The Kirlampudi Sugar Mills Ltd. was started in !951 as a small unit
and later was increased to a ]arger c!rush(ng capacity of 1000 tons. BY
1963" the factory got into financial embarTassment. In the middle of that
year the present managemen:t took over the factory~ on the specific assur..
ance of the Government that t~ey would provide for 3nd give all facilities to enable them to run the factory. After the management was taken
over there were disputes between the management and workers with the D
result that they referred various matters for adjudication incWding the
claim for implementation of the recon1mendations of the Central \Vage
Board for sugar. The disputed items related to categorisation of workers
their fitments, fixation of work load, the demand. for increase of Rs. 10
to be given to every v.·orke·r over the basic wage implementation of weightage, dearness allowance. the demand for giving grades and for giving retrospective effect etc. On issue No. IA the Tribunal held that categorisa- E
tion of workers and their fitments and work load should ~ in accordance
with the recommendations of the Wage Board; it deciC.ed in favpur of the
management in respect of certain categories of workers but in respect of
some others it gave relief to the workers. The Tribunal furiher heltl in
respect of is~ue 2 and 5 before it that the financial capacity of the Appellant was not such as to justify an increase of Rs. IO to,all the workers over
the basic wag.e and dearness allowance or the payment ~f Rs. 5 to workmen for implementation of the weightage recommended by ~e Wage Board. F
Appeal No. 1602 of ,.! \166 was filed in this Court by special leave bv the
management 3.gainst tlle Award of the T~ibunal in respect of issue !A in so
far as it went against them. Appeal No. 1603 of 1966 was filed by the
workers against the Tribunal's decision 9n issues 2 and 5 and that part of
issue tA which went against them. The questions ttiat fell for consi~era
tion were : (i) whether the recommendations of th€ Wage Board were
vitiated by the fact that they had fixed the wages uniformly region-wise
without further classification·within each region: (ii) If they were valid, G
whether the Tribunal could go into the auestiofl of the financial capacity
of the company to implement them; (iii) whether the company had the
·
financial capacity to implement the recon1mendations.
HELD : The Wage Board following the principles' laid down by this
Court has considered the capacity of the industry region-wise and has also
fixed wages different from region to region having regard to the difference
in the capacity of the Industry region-wise. Further it' has given good
reason for not furnishing: a criteria for further classification of the industry
within the region. In these circumstances prescribing the same wage ,for
all units of industry in the sam.e region was justified ·and the fact that the
-- - - -
H
.,
KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND, TRIB.
429
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
industry in the region had not been dlvicled into classes could not vitiate
the recommendation of the Wage Board, [441 F-G]
Workmen of Sltri Bajrang Jute Mills Ltd, V. Employers of Sh1·i Bajrang
.lute Mills Lid., [1969] 2 S.C.R. 593, explained and distinguished.
B
·C
Express Newspaper (P) Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors., [1959] S.C.R.
12 and French Motor Car Co. Ltd. v. Workmen, [1963] Supp. 2 S.C.R. 16,
referred to
However, notwithstanding the fact that a fair wage has been fixed by
the Board which would be applicable to all the units in the region for
which wage has been fixed, it may be open to any particular unit to plead
that in fact its financial position is not such that it can bear the burden of
implementing the recon1mendations. ~he justification of the plea of want
of financial capacity will depend upon the evidence of its financial position
over a period of years, to show that it cannot bear the burden or that it is
only a temporary or fortuitous situation \\t'ith every po:.sibility of financial
improvement in the immediate future [442 E; 443 CJ
Ahmedabad Mill Owners' Association. etc. v. Textile Labour
tion, 1.1966] I S.C.R. 382, relied on.
D
E
F
As...ocia-
The Appellant's balance sheets for the years 1960 to 1970 for a period
of JO years showed that except for the year ending 30-6-69 the compan)
was not in a position to declare any dividends. Though the factory
appeared to ha\·e been expanded after 1964 to 300 tons capacity it did not
show uniform net profits; on the other hand losses continued. The profits
that it made in any year seemed to be consumed by losses of the orevjous
years. Various factors contributed to financial unsteadiness. [448 G-Hl
This being the position the Tribunal wi:' justified in holding that the
Appellant did not have the financial capacity to bear the. hurde.n of payment of Rs. 10 increase and Rs. 5 as V.'eightage in accordance with the recommendations of the Wage Board. On this .conclusion and also on an
examination of the relevant material it was evident that the con1pany was
not in a financial position to nleet the burden of iinplernenting the recommendations of the Wage Board. Despite this the company had in1plcmented the a\l,'ar<l in respect of a large number of workers both as to categorisation and fitmcnt except in regard to four categories. 'fhe clain1 of the Respondent workmen for categorisation and fitment in accordance with the
Award in regard to these could not. in the circunl';tanccs. be accepted.
[448 H-4i9 Gl
CAVIL
APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeals Nos. 1602
and 1603 of 1966.
'G
Appeals by special leave from the Award dated November 19.
1965 of the Industrial Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad in
l.D. No. 23 of 1965.
K. Srinivasamurthy, Naunit Lal and Swaranjit Sodhi for the
appellant (in C.A. No. 1602 of 1966) and 'the respondent in C.A.
No. 1603 of 1966).
H
M. K. Ramamurthi and Vineet Kumar, for respondent No. 2
(In C.A. No. 1602 of 1966) and the appellant (in C.A. No. 1603 ·
o.f 1966).
·
9-L1340Sup.Cl/71
430
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] I S.C.K
A
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
P. Jagamnohan Reddy, J. These are two appeals by Special
Leave. Civil Appeal No. 1602 of 1966 is by the Management
against the Award passed by the Industrial Tribunal on a reference made by the Government for categorisation of workers,.
their fitments, fixation of work load, the demand for incp~ase B
of Rs. 10/- to be given to every worker over the basic wage, implementation of weightage, dearness allowance, the demand for
giving grades and for giving re'trosp.ective effect etc. Civil Appeal
No. I603 of 1966 by the Workmen is against the same Award for
disallowing the increase of Rs. 10/- and the weightage of Rs. 51and also against ithe fitment of certain categories of workers. The
Tribunal held that the financial capacity of the Appellant was not C
such as to justify an increase of Rs. l 01- ito all the workers over
the basic wage and dearness allowance. On ithe same grounds
it also disallowed the payment of Rs. 51- to workmen for implementation of the weightage p~commended by the Wage Board for
Sugar Industry. These were the subjeot matter of issue 2 and 5
of the reforence made to the Tribunal. So far as issue IA is con- D 1
cerned, it held that categorisation of workers and their fitments
and work load should be in accordance with the recommendations of the Wage Board for Sugar and even as to these it decided
in favour of the management in respect of certain categories of
workers but in respect of some others, it gave relief to the
workers. The employers appealed against that part of issue IA E
which was decided against 1th.em, while the Workmen's Appeal is
against the finding of issues 2, 5 and part of IA which was against
them. We will first take up the appeal of the Management.
It appears that the Kirlampudi Sugar factory was started in
I95I as a small unit and later was increased to a larger crushing
capacity of 1,000 tons which according to the Tariff Commission F
would not be considered economically profitable, though according to the Sugar Wage Board H would be. By 1963 the factory
got into financial embarrassment as it had to pay heavy debts to
the Government on account of Sugar cess, cane prio~ payable
to the growers and Income-tax. These demands it is alleged
practically brought 1the factory to a stop, when in the middle of G
1963 the present management took over the factory on the specific assurance from the Government that they will provide for
and give all facilities to enable them ito run the factory. After
the inana.rement was taken over there were disputes between the
Management and workers with the result that they referred
various ma'tters for adjudication including the claim for imple- H
mcntation of the wage Board's recommendation which was alleged
to have been implemented by the former management as early as
1961-62. It was the case of the workers that that implementa•
KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS v. IND. TRIB.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
431
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
tion was not satisfactory and it was their demand that the sugar
wage board's recommendations should be implemented. The
management raised a specific objection before the Industrial
Tribunal that the reference relates to a wholesale promotion of
workers from one grade to the other under the guiw of frtment
under the Wage Board's recommendations which is illegal and
without jurisdiction; and in any case the question of promotion,
categorisation and fitment is a managerial function in which !he
Tribunal cannot interfere unless it can be es1ablis!r.,d that the
management acted mala fide or it resorted to unfair practices. It
was further pleaded that the factory had not the financial capacity to implement the demand. One of the grievance of the
Appellant was that though the Tribunal found that it had not
the financial capacity to meet the additional burden of the
demands made by the workm~n rt granted large scale promotions
which it had no jurisdiction to grant. Despite this the inanagement states •that it had implemented the Award in most of the
cases and challenged it in respect of some only.
It may be mentioned that the Central Wage Board for S~ar
was appointed in terms of paragraph 25 of Chapter XXVII of
the Second Five Year Plan. This Wage Board for Sugar Industry divided India into 4 regions and each region included every
State containing even a single unit unlike that adopted by the
Tariff Commission which in its Report on the cost structure left
out some of the States from the 4 divisions. It then considered'
the wage structure, categorisation etc. for each of the snid
regions, in relation to a fair cross-S".ction of the Industry in each
of the regions. In comparison with this method, the Jute Wage
Board had taken India as a whole and fixed a uniform rate for
the Jute industry. The first contention which has been urged is
that the recommendations of the Wage Board were not binding
in view of the fact that it was not a statutory board but was only
a recommendatory one and 1ho~ Tribunal could not implement
them as a whole because it had recommended that fitments and
categorisation should be affected by recourse to Tripartite machinery. The case of Workmen of Shri Bajrang Jute Mills Ltd., v.
Employees of Shri Bajrang Jute Mills Ltd. (1), is cited as an
authority for the proposition that as the procedure prescribed
therein was not valid, the r1:9ommendations of the Wage Board
were declarec! to be invalid and inapplicable to the Jute Industry.
The learned Advocate on behalf of the Respondents raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of this contention as
thi< issue had neither been referred to the Tribunal, nor has it
been urged before it nor had a ground been taken in the Special
Leave Pe.titian. He seeks to distinguish the case of the Bajrang
(I} [1969] 2 S.C.R. 593.
432
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] l S.C.R
Mills, as in that case there was a specific issue while there is n9ne
in this case. In answer it is pointed out that the contention raised
Qn behalf of the Respondents is implicit in issue 1 (a) which is
<is follows :
1 (a) "Whether the demand for categorisation of
workers and their fitment and work load should be in
accvrdance with the recommendations of the Wage
Board for Sugar industry is justified".
The Appellant had in its sta!tement before the Tribunal in para
9 categorically challenged the recommendations of the Wage
Board in these words : "It may be noticed even though the
Wage Board recommendations are not binding, in spite of huge
losses the management went out of the way and implemented
the same". In the Special Leave Petition also in paragraph 2
ilie Appellant had challenged the jurisdiction of the Tribunal "to
go into the question of the capacrty to pay of an individual unit
in respect of one of the recommendations of the Wage Board
for Sugar industry when such recommendations had been made
for-the industry as a whole and agreed ·to by the Management
itsel".
It is •therefore contended that if the financial capacity is taken
into account for placing fitments on the basis of Bajrang Jup~
Mills, no other question arises. In the Bajrang Milis case(1) it
was held that fixation of fair wage depends on the financial capacity but once when the Tribunal had held that the Appdlant did
not have the financial capacity the categorisation and fitments
directed by H in its Award are invalid. The Tiibunal is concerned
with the implem~ntation of the Wage Board recommendation
forgetting that it cannot do so when the implementation of those
recommendations relating to categorisation and fitment cannot
be effected without recourse to the Tripartite machinery. It is
also contended 1hat categorisation and fitment is a managerial
fonction and requires technical knowledge of the various duties
antl functions which each of the category of workmen haw to
discharge.
The following contentions have been urged,
J:'.ll11Cly :
(I) The Wage Boartl recommendations having regard to
tl1e •:asc cf Bajrang Jute Mills are invalid and cannot be enforcect. inasmuch as it has fixed a uniform wage for •the .entir~
region without further dividing the industry in the region i:no
classe' of units according to their capacity namely region-cuminciustry for fixation of th·~ wage structure for 1hose classes of
units. At any rate since what is prescribed in the r.~port is
only r•cc01rnnendatory, unless there is a capacity to pay, no on~
cJn claim iis implementa1ion as of right.
-IT)ff9~iJJ 2Tc.1t 593.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
'
'
KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
433
(Jaganmohan Reddy, !.)
( 2) The Appellant has not the financial capacity to implement the Award which has been held by the Tribunal to be a
fact. On this score itself it cannot implement the Award.
( 3) Jn para 263 of the Wage Board recommendation of
J 960 that when th<~re is a difference between management and
. labour reoarding frtment the Tripartite machinery should be
B
brou£ht i~to existence. The Tribunal was wrong in thinking
that the Wage Board was giving an example of border-lines cases
where there may be a difference of opinion and it is only in those
cases that the Tripartite machinery in the case of fitment is to be
resorted to.
Fitment is a managerial function and unless the Tribunal
c finds( 4)
that the Act of •the manag.~ment is ma/a fide or it has resortco to unfair practices it is not justified in interfering with the fitments effected by the management.
( 5) In any case in respe~t of certain specific fitments the
Tribunal was in error and acted without evidence.
Before dealing with these contentions it is necessary to conD
sider the preliminary objection rais-~d on behalf of the Respondents that before the Tribunal the Appellant did not object to
the implementation of the Wage Board on the ground that its recommendations were not industry-cum-region wise or that it had
not divided the industry into various classes and fixed a wage
for
those classes in that region, and in any case no such issue
E
was referrecJ to the Tribunal unlike in th·~ Bajrang Jute Mills
case('). In that case what was referred to the Tribunal was
whether the demand of the workmen in Shree Bajrang Mills Ltd.,
for implementation of the recommendations of the Central Wage
Board for Jute Industry is justified, and if so, to what extent. In
this case issue IA did not specifically raise an objection to the
F implementation of the Sugar Wage Board's recommendations
in general terms but issues 1, 2, 4, 5 & 6 did raise the question
whether 1the Board was justified in its recommendations regarding categorisation of workers, fitment, increase of Rs. IOI- ro
every worker over the basic wage, dearness allowance, the minimum wage, the demand for fixation of work-load and the demand
G for implementation of weightage. Apart from this a question
seems to have been raised that the Tribunal could not implement
the Wage Board recommendations because it had envisaged the
implementation of the categorisation etc. through the Tripartite
machinery, as such as Tribunal had no jurisdiction to implement
it. It would appear from ithe Award that the learned Advocate
H for the Appellant had challenged the jurisdiction of the Tribunal
to fix the workload or undertake the fitments in view of the recommendations in paragraph 263 of the Wage Board's report
A
tn (10691 2 s.c.R. 593.
434
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972J 1 s.c.R.
that fi'tments have to be effected by the Tripartite machinery to
be appointed by the Government. Even in the startement of claim
filed on behalf of the management it was said that though the
Wage Board's reco=endations are not binding in spite of the
huge losses the management went out of the way and implemented the same. The fact that rt was said that the Wage Board
recommendations are not binding is pressed into service to support the contentions that the validity of the reco=endations of
the Wage Board was challenged. While we are inclined to ,gree
with the submission of the learned Advocrute for the RespoJJd.ents
that nowhere except in the statement of the case before this Court
has a specific plea that the reco=endations of 1the Wage Board
not being in accordance with the well accepted principles laid
down by this Court in the several cases to which reference has
been made cannot be implemented and on that account · the
Tribunal has no jurisdiction to implement those recommendations
it may nonetheless be pointed ou1 that issue IA and other i$sues
in terms challenge the implementation of the reco=endations.
Even if we permit the learned Advocate for the Appellant-and
we think there is justification for it-to challenge the Wage
Board's reco=endations generally, for reasons which we will
presently give, those reco=endations do not suffer from any
vice but on the other hand the Board has fixed a fair wage for
the industry in accordance wi1h the principles laid down by this
Court.
Since a good deal of argument is based on the reco=endations of the Wage Board it may be profitable to examine generally the factors which were taken into consideration in fix.ing
the wage structure for the industry. The Wage Board as has
already been noticed adopted the method employed by the Tariff
Commission by dividing the country into four zones or regions
but unlike it included every State in each region which had even
one unit. It further took these regions which were considered
for fixation of price structure of sugar also for wage structure
in this industry. In adopting this course the Wage Board took
into consideration the seasonal nature and the duration, the
-sucrose content of sugar cane and its yield which varies from
rel(ion to region. It was noticed that the duration of seasons
vary somewhat widely from area to area depending on the availability of cane and the year to year varirution. As a consequence
-of some of the factories in the South owninl? their own sugar-cane
farms while this is not so in the North, the Southern factories do
not suffer from the handicap of Northern factories which have ro
-get sugar cane from nearby growers depending on the conditions
of the crop in the vicinity which is not destroyed by pest or is
unsuitable for anv o•her reason. for otherwi~e to ~ the sugar-cane from growers from Jong distance would involve transport
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
RIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
A
B
c
D
E
F
<G
H
435
(laganmohan Reddy, l.)
costs. This disadvantage the Southern factories do not have.
The quality of cane as detennined by the sucrose content varies
from area to area depending on climatic conditions, in:ig,ation
facilities and cane development aotivities. Factories in Maharashtra and to some extent those in the North enjoy these adventages. Their recovery percentage is higher than in the North.
Thus the average percentage of recovery of sugar in Maharash!tra
was noted to be the highest as against ,those in U.P. and Bihar
and also as compared with the All India average. The variation
in the yield of cane per acre was also taken into consideration;
for instance in Bombay it is much higher 1than in the North. The
Board indicated the main factors responsible for vai,ation in
the yield of sugar cane in different regions due to : ( 1) Improved
variety of cane; (2) irrigation facilities; (3) ecological faotors;
and ( 4) improved methods of cultivation. The difference in the
case of yield in 1the various areas has been one of the factors
which the Board said had persuaded it to divide 1he country into
four regions.
Though the industry is rural based, it was stated the price of
essential commodities in townships where sugar factories are
located, did not vary appreciably from the urban areas. In spite
of the urban amenities not being available in these factory areas,
the Board noted that while the impact of the wages it worked
out, on the economy of the coun1try has been taken into account,
it was not proper ro take agricultural wages as the prevailing
rate of wages for comparison. Further it appeared to the Board
that the Sugar industry was a highly regulated industry where
the minimum cane price is fixed by the State and higher price
depending upon the quality of the cane is to be paid according
to the price linking formula laid down by the State and that even
the ex-factory price for the finished product is fixed by the State
in the North and some other St~tes haw fixed prices at least for
one of its by-products and molasses. The price 'fixation in the
North it is observed has its effect on the price of sugar in the
South where normally sugar cannot be sold for a price higher
than fixed in ithe North plus the freight.
The Board also set out the procedure followed by it in ascertaining the financial capacity and profitability of the industry
region-wise by calling for the balance-sheets of all the factories
for a period .of 10 years and undertook detailed studies for 8
years beginning from 1951 which corresponds to the beginning
of the First Five· Year Plan. However, out of the balance-sheets
of 118 Companies, balance-sheets for 8 years were available in
respect of 87, 8 Companies supplied balance-sheets for 7 out
of 8 years and among the rest balance-sheets were available for
cne or more years. The Board thought 1that this data is fairly
43;
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] l s.c.R.
A
well, if not absolutely, comparable from year to year. Where a
Company owned two or more factories in the same State or
region it was decided to consider only the combined balancesheets for the number of factories covered, because spli~ting the
combined balance-sheets over the number of factories did not
serve the end in view. However, where a Company had under
its management two or more factories in different States but in 8 ·
the same region, it was decided to exclude it from State-wise study
and include it in the regional total. It also took into consideration some of the Companies which along with the sugar manufacture carried other manufacturing activities. Then it also applied
the dividend tests, examined the main profitable ratio, considered
the total dividend as coverage by paid up capital, compared c
gross profits and tatal capital employed and profits and profitability in relation to per day crushing capacity from 1955-58. A
region-wise analysis of financial data was made and the same was
also distributed in different rang~s of daily crushing capacity. In so
far as South region is concerned in which the Appellant's unit is
located it was observed that "the factories seem to have been D
more or Jess evenly distributed among all the regions". Analysis
of financial data region-wise was also made according to differenit crushing capacity ranges for each of the years 1955 to 1958
under differ.ent heads namely, gross profits, sales, total capital
employed, profits after tax, ordinary dividend, ordinary paid up
capital total dividends, total paid up capital, profits before tax, E
taxation provision, retained profits and net worth.
After taking into consideration the several factors in detail
the conclusions of the Tribunal are summed up as unde~ :
(a) "the profit margin whether on sal'-!s or on total
capital employed, or on the net worth does not appear
to bear any set relationship increase or decreas.e consistently-with the size of the Company. The trends
are mixed and irregular. This observation is equally
app!ica ble 'to other ratios and also to the allocation of
profits. It do~s not seem possible from these studies
to loc~te any optimum size of the factory in respect
of any region. The reason probably is that profits
depend not only on the size of the faotory but on
various other factors e.g. efficiency of management,
condition of machinery, availabili1y of raw materials
and efficiency of workers;
(b) However, considering the overall position it is.
evident that with no outside compeititor in the field,
with a consuming public increasing and with national
income which is rising, the industry has a good future.
F
H
KIRLAMPUDl SUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
43 7.
(laganmohan Reddy, I.)
'Jn spite of high taxation, high GoverD:men.t in_iposts. oy
way of cess rise in price of raw matenal nse m freight
charges and in some regi.:ms higher labour char!?ies
owing to recel,lt revision of wag.~s the deman~ ~or white
sugar has been increasing and most of the ex1stmg sugar·
mills have been fairing well. Many of ·them have expanded their• capacity and new units are fast coming
into operation. Progress of the industry has been
rapid._ .. bi:rt the increase in taxes .has hit 1he retained
earnings particularly in the case of North and Central
region "comp.'!_nies.
( c). Taken "region-wise, the financial position of
Maharashtra is the best. It has natural ,advantages.
The yield of cane per acre is higher. 'Its quality is
be~ter. A large number of' the factories have tho~ir own
farms. The cooperatjve have also assured ~upply-t5f
cane. The cane growers are the share-holders. Then
comes the South region. North. region occupies the
third position and Central region •the last. In cess
Pun.iab, West Bengal,, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan,
Madras and Kerala enjoy some advantage with no or
lower rates per maund of cane. . . . :i;t J:!lay be adde<l
here that recovery in some 9f these States is lower than
the average of the country'.
It would appear therefofo that the Board took into con<ideration the special features of the sugar iµdustry and all the relevant
factors wi'lh-gl'eat care and perspicuity and fixed a fair wage for
the industry in each of the regions. What is was called on to
assess is the ,fair wage which as it may be noticed according to
the Report of the fair wag>~ Commil'tee was that which while
determining the capacity of an industry to pay, it considered it
to be wrong to take the capa~ity of a particular unit or the capacity of all indu~tries in the counlry, into account. The relative
criterion should be the .capacity of a par"ticular industry in a
specified region and as .far as possible same wages should be prescribed for .all units in tha·t region. It will obviously not be possible for the wage fixation Board to measure the capacity of e,ach
of the units of an industry ·in a region, as such the only practical
method is to take into consideration a fair cross section of that
industry. This is what in fact the Board has C!on·~- The minimum wage that has ·to'be paid. is as interpreted by this Court in
Express Newspapers (Pvt.) Ltd. v. (he Union of lndir. & Ors.(1)
different from the' subsistence wag_e "which has got to be paid
to the workers irresoective of the capacity of 'the industry 10 pay
while the minimum wage is something more than the bare mini( () [19,59) 5.C.R.
(~.
438
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 s.c.R.
A
mum or subsistence wage. It further obset'\"'.d "The minimum
wage thus contemplated postulates the capacity of the industry to
pay and no fixation of wages which ignores this essential factor of
the capacity of the industry to pay could ever be supported". In
that case the Court also observed at page 90 : "that the capacity
of an industi:y to pay should be gauged on an industry-cum-region
basis after taking a fair cross section of that industry. In a given B
case it may be even permissible to divide the industry irito appropriate classes and then deal with the capacity of the industry to pay
class-wise". The classification into classes, it will be seen is not
an obligatory one but is required only in cases where otherwise a
fair wage cannot be determined. Any injunction that the industry
in a region should in all cases be divided inio classes in derermin- C
ing a fair wage for that industry would on the other hand likely to
introduce greater disparity.
A reference has been made to the case of French Motor Car
Co. Ltd. v. Workmen(1) for the proposition 1that large units
ought not be compared with small units even where the Board D
is considering the wage structure on industry-cum-region basis.
No doubt in that case the Tribunal had gone in'to the history of
the wage revision in 1he undertaking and having regard to. a Jar)',':'
increase in •the cost of living found that a case for further revision
was made out notwithstanding the fact that wage scales were the
highest in the industry. In Appeal this Court held that it was
settled law that in fixation of wage scales, dearmss allowance and E
similar conditions of servic an industrial Court has to proceed on
indusiry-cum-region basis and compare similar concerns in the
region which would be those in the same line of business as the
concern in dispute. But such comparison must not be between a
small struggling concern and a large flourishing one.
F
These cases were considered in Workmen v. Bairang Jute
Mills( 2 ) to which one of us was a party (Vaidialingam, J.). That
care was considering the Report of the Jute Wage Board which
in making recommendations for 'the industry adop1ed a different approach. The Wage Board took the whole of India
as one unit while in fact almost all the Jute Mills were situated
in West Bengal and a few in Bihar and still fewer in Andhra
Pradesh. What the Wage Board did was to compare 20 Mills
from West Bengal and 9 mills from the rest of India as representing a fair cross section of the industry. The Respondenis haw
a fairly small unit in Andhra Pradesh which was considered as
a comparable unit with two larger mills in the State and with
some of the prosperous Mills in Wes'! Bengal. The management of the Mill refused to accede to the d~mand of the workman
(I) [1963) Supp. 2 S.C.R. !«.
(7) [1%9) 2 S.C.R. 593.
G
H
K!RLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
439
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
to pay the wages in accordance with the recommendations of
the Wage Board, fixing uniform wage scale for the industry on
the plea th~t the Mill had no financial capacity to bear the burden
of the wage scale. On the disput•e being referred to the T1ibunal
it upheld the claim of the management. This Court in Appeal
sustained the Award of the Tribunal thwt the payment of the
B workmen for implementation of the recommendation of the Wage
Board is not justified. In this connection at page 609-610 it was
observed by reference to the manner in which ithe Wage Board
had laid down uniform scales for the entire industry irrespective
of where its several units were situate and of the different conditions prevailing in various areas, that it would have been better
if it had "considered the units in each area separately and determined the wage-scalr..s for each such area by taldng from that
area a representative cross-section of ~he industry where possible
or where that was not possible by taking comparable units from
other industries within that area, thus following the principle of
industry-cum-region". It was fu~ther observed :
D
"It is true that in doing so uniformity of wage scales
for the entire industry would not have been attained.
But in a vast country like ours, where conditions differ
o~ten radically from region to region and even the
index of living differs within a fairly wide range, such a
target cannot always be just or equitable. If the wagescales
had been determined by the Board in the manE
. ner aforesaid, even though the Board is not a statutory
body and consequently i1ts decision are of a recommendatory character, it would be possible for industrial
tribunals to give due weight to its recommendations as
such recommendations would have been in conformity
with the principle of industry-cum-region, a principle
F
binding on the 'tribunals. It would be diftlcult in that
· event for any unit in the industry in that region to propound a grievance that its capacity to pay was not
taken into account as the scales so framed would have
·been determined after taking into consideration scales
prevailing in comparable units, whether in that indusG
try or other indus tries in that region depending on
whether in a particular area the accent was on the industry part or the region part of the principle of industry-cum-region".
The leai:ned Adv?cate for the Appellant lay~ stress upon thel
observahon contamed at page 607 where while dealing with the
H Express Newspapers case, this Couvt had observed :
A
1
". . . . the requirement of considering the capacity
of each individual unit to pay may not beco~e neces-
440
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] l S.C.R.
sary if the industry is divided into different classes.
Even if the industry is divided into different classes it
will still be necessary to consider the capacity of the
respective classes to bear the burden imposed on them.
For this purpose a cross-section of these respective
classes may have to be taken for careful consideration
for decid~ng what burden th·~ class considered as a
whole can bear".
A
B
These observations must be read in the light of wha!t was earlier
stated namely "as the Wage Board was fixing a fair wage for the
entire jute industry it may not have been strictly necessary to
consider the financial capadty of each individual unit". There
is nothing in the Bajrang Jute Mills case(1) which makes it obliga- C
tory on a Wage Board to divide the industry into regions as well
as classes or to examine the financial capacity of every unit in
that industry in ilie region, irrespective of the conditions prevailing in th·~ different regions of that industry. As long as all relevant factors appertaining to that industry, industry-wise and
region-wise have been considered and the capacity of a fair cross D
section of that industry to pay in tha1 region has been ascertained,
the recommendations of the Wage Board cannot be held to be
invalid. It is not in every case that a division into classes in the
same region, on a unrt-wise capacity should be made before recommendations of the Wage structure, dearness allowance or
other conditions of service in that industry could be held ito be E
fair and within the financial capacity of the industry in that
region. The criteria on which the recommendations of the Jute
Wage Board were held not to be in accordano~ with the principle
laid down by this Court in Bajrang Mills case do not form the
basis of the recommendations of the Sugar Wage Board. The
Sugar Wage Board not only divided the industry into regions as
already pointed out bu1 on the other hand found that there was F
no great disparity in the region nor did the size of the unit make
any difference. It standardised the wage structure, it adopt·~d a
standardisation of nomenclature by taking note of the various
nomenclatures used in the industry and defined the qualification
for each of the caotegories. The pre-dominant conditions for
wage structure which weighed with the Board were that firs11y G
in view of the great unemployment nothing should be done to
reduce the existing employment but on the other hand efforts
should be made to increase it. Secondly the need for increase
in production was paramount and any action likely to reduce it
should be studeously avoided as far as possible. Thirdly the
capital should not be idle for if a wag-~ structure is evolved H
which leads to the closure of any unit or units, a number of
persons will be thrown out of employment, production will be
(l) [1969j2s.C.R. 593.
'
KIRLAMPUD! SUGAR MILLS v. IND. TRIB.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
441
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
reduced and capital invested in them will become idle. Keeping
these considerations in view the Board d~termined the wage
structure which it recognised may be lower than norms laid down
by the Fifteenth Labour Conference but the fact that there is a
tremendous rush for employment in factories is proof that the
wages recommended by it are higher than the rates fixed under
the minimum Wa,ges Act in industries to which that Act applies
or those prevailing in the open market. It also took irnto consideration the economic units in the regions which as accepted
by it is a unit having a crushing capacity of atleast 800 to 1000
tons 1thought it has noted that the majority of sugar factories
have a crushing capacity hig!J.~r than this and several of those
having uneconomic size have already applied for expansion.
According to the Board there were only 38 factories which were
below 800 tons crushing capacity but a good many of them were
making profits. However, there are some which are running at
loss and for them •the Board recommended that some consideration should b~ given to adjust themselves which should be the
same as these given to n.~w factories. This is what the Board
stated in Chapter XIII at page 111 :
"The conclusion is that except some cases other
units below 800 tons are making profits. Tho~ examination is set out in the Annexure to this Chapter. The
Board is of the view that relax~tion in wa,ges is not ithe
real remedy for those un-economic units. They will
have to fall in line with .the sche1m of wages recommended by the Board. The r.~al remedy for them is to
expand themselves into economic units".
It would •therefore appear tha<t the Wage Board following the
principles laid down by this Court has considered the capacity
of the industry region-wise and has also fixed wages different
from region to region having regard to th·~ difference in the
capacity of the industry region-wise. Further it has given good
reason for no't furnishing a criteria for further classification of
the industry within the region. In these circumstances pr.~scrib
ing the same wage for all units of industry in the same region is
in our view jus•tified and the fact that the industry in the region
has not been divided into classes cannot vitiate the rcconunendations of the Wage Board.
It is contended on behalf of 'the Appellant that while this is
so and the wage fixed is a fair wage for the industry in that region
and cannot be challenged nonethdess the Tribunal is nC't precluded
from considering a plea by any particular unit that ih fact its
financial position is such that it cannot bear •the burde11 of implementing the recom1w~ndations of the Wage Board. The .
learn~d Advocate for the Respondents however, counters this on
442
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
A
the ground that once a wage has been fixed by the Board as a
fair wage on industry-cum-region basis, whether those r'ecom·
mendations are !ltatutory or otherwise, no plea by any individual
unit that it has not the capacity to implement the recommendations, can be entertained. He asks whether an Industrial Tribunal to which a dispute regarding the fixation of wage is referred
fixes a wage structure, is it open to any particular unit to say B
that it is unable to pay ? If this is not so, on the same parity of
reasoning it is coRtended 1that no unit in a region can be permitted to plead that it bas not the financial capacity to implement
the Wage Board's recommendations. It appears to us 1that if in
law it, is open to the unit to plead financial inability to implement the recommendations of the Wage Board the hypothesis on c
which ithe question has been posed will not be relevant because
in such a contingency as is envisaged there would be a specific
issue and a _determination of the wage structure by the Tribunal
will be on the evidence produced before it according to the financial capacity of the unit. Once this is finally determined, the
unit cannot continue to assert that it has no financial capacity to D
implement the Award.
In our view there is warrant for the submission of the learned
Advocate for the Appellant that notwithstanding the fact that a fair
wage has been fixed by the Board which would be applicable to
all the unrts in the region for which wage has been fixed, it may
be open to any particular unit to plead that in fact its financial &
position is not such that it can bear the burden of implementing
the recommendations. In Ahmedabad Mill Owners' Association etc. v. The Textile Labour Association(1), the observations of this Court at page 421 lend support to our conclusions.
Gajendragadkar J, delivering the Judgment of this Court observed
F.
at page 421 :
''The other aspect of the matter which cannot be
ignored is tha1t if a fair wage structure is constructed
by .industrial adjudication, and in course of time ' expenence shows that the employer cannot bear the burden ?f such wage structure, industrial adjudication can,
and m a proper case should, revise the wage structure,
though such revision may result in the reduction of
the wages paid to the employees. It is true that normally, once a wage structure is fixed, employees are
reluctant to face a reduction in the conknt .of their
w~ge packet. but like all major problems associated
with industrial adjudication, the decision of this problem must also be based on the major_ consideration that
.
(I) [1966] I S.C.R. 392
.
H
..
'
K!RLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND; TRIB;.
443
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
the conflicting chims of labour and canital must be
hannonised on a reasonable basis; and so, if appears
that the employer cannot really bear the burden of the .
increasing wage bill, industrial adjudication, on .
principle, cannot refus-~ to examine the employer's
case and should not hesitate to give him relief, if il
is satisfied that if such relief is not given the employer
may have to close down his business. It is unlikely
that such situwtion would frequently arise but, on ·
principle, if such situations arise; a claim by the employer for the reduction of the wage structure cannot
be rejected summarily".
A
B
c
Of course the justification of the plllll of want of financial.
capacity will depend upon the evidence of its financial position.
over a period of years, to show that it cannot bear the burden or
that it is only a temporary or fortutous situation with every possibility of financial improvement in the immediate future.
l t is accordingly contended that an examination of the finanD cial position would show that 1the Appellant is not in a position
to implement the recommendations and that even the Tribunal
had recognised this position when it refused to implement an increase of Rs. 101- to all the workers over 1the basic wage and
dearness allowance, and Rs. 51- as weightage to certain · categories of workers. It would appear from the statement of the
E Company as evidenced by Ex. M. 51 that it had secured and unsecured debts for each of the four years as follows :
Debts
secured
F
1960·61
1961-62
1962-63
1963-64
Debts
unsecured
Rs.
73,59,344
67,78,270
32,31,438
32,99,599
Rs.
8, 13,263
2,64.982
28.06,000
18,71,522
207,68,651
57,55,767
The details of debts would show that they are far in exooss of
the paid up share capital and even taking the profit and dewlopment rebate reserves and other reserves· into account the financial
position of the Company is certainly bad. A reference has also
been made to the notices issued by 1he Revenue Divisional Officer, Ex. M. 53 for showing that on 30th December 1962, a sum
of Rs. 15,91,777.11 ps. was due towards Sugar cane cess for
H 1958-62 and a sum of Rs. 11.66, 718.37 ps. towards cane price
in accordance with the details given thereunder. Subsequently it
would appear from Ex. M. 53/1 that notices under Sec. 53 of
G
444
SUPREME COURT ItEPORTS
(1972] 1 S.C.ll.
A
!lhe Revenue Recovery Act were also issued by the Revenue Divi-
sional Officer, Kakinada for the recovery of these amounts. There
were also other notices and a press note published in the Indian
Express showing that the Government was going to auction the
Sugar Mills for recovering its dues. The Minister concerned is
repoited •to have said that its Department was taking action to
B
collect its dues as arrears of land revenue.
It is on the other hand contended that the Appellant's unit is
. an economic unit and has been expanded into a 1000 ton unit in
1956 and there is nothing to show thereafter what its financial
position was. In any case the profit and loss figures for the four
years starting with 1960 would indicate that there was loss only C
in one year whereas in all the oth·~r three years there was profit
and from 'this we are asked to conclude that the Appellant company was in a sound financial position. No doubt any unusual
profits or losses in any year due to advantageous circumstances
should not be allowed to cloud the decision one way or the other.
In Ahmedabad Mill Owners Association case it was 0boerved at
page 420-421 as follows :
D
"It is a long-range plan; and so, in dealing with
this problem, 1the financial position of th·~ employer must
be carefully examined. What has been the progress of
the industry in question; what are the prospects of the
industry in future; has the industry !J.o.en making profits;
and if yes, what is the extent of profits; what is the
nature of demand which the industry expec•ts to secure;
what would be •the extent of the burden and its gradual
increase which the employ.~r may have to face ? These
and similar other considerations have 'to be carefully
weighed before a proper wage structure can be reasonably constructed by industrial adjudication, vide Express Newspap~rs (Private) Ltd., and A1101her v.
Union of India & Others. Unusual prolit made by the
industry for a single year as a result of adventitious circumstances, or unusual loss incurred by it for similar
reasons, should not be allowed to play a major role in
the calculations which indus•trial adjudic~tion would
make in regard to the construction of a wage structure.
A broad and owrall view of 'the financial -position of
the employer must be taken into account and attempt
should alwavs be made to reconcile the natural and just
claims of the employees for a fair and higher wage
with the capacity of the emnloyer 'to pay it; and in
determining such capacity. allowwice must be nw.de
for a legitimate desire of the employer to mak·~ a
reasonable profit".
F
E
G
H
KIRLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND, TRIB.
A
B
,C
D
E
F
G
H
445
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
Bearing these observations in mind, it is necessary to determine
wh~t the position of the Appellant is ? The conclusion of the
Tribunal in respect of the claim for increase of Rs. 10/- is that
having regard to the balance-sheets "the profits made in the 4
years are about Rs. 4 lakhs and the Joss sustained in 1962-63 is
of Rs. 16 lakhs and after wiping it off to some extent by sale of
debentures it is about Rs. 9 lakhs. This will show that the financial position of the concern is not satisfactory". After noting
that except for 'this one year the concern has al ways been making
profits, it went on to observe : "StiJI, to judge the financial position of a concern, it is always relevant to see what are its reserves. It appears from the balance-sheet that the reserves have
never risen beyond Rs. 8 lakhs or so. In the circumstances, it,
appears to me that it will be difficult to hold that the financial
position of 'the Company is sound. I, therefore, agree with
learned Advocate that it has not the financial capacity to imple-,
ment this increase of Rs. 101- over and above 'the fitment in the
grade recommended by the Board. I hold accordingly". The
comment of 'the learned Advocate for the Respondent is that
these losses did not preclude the managem~nt from accepting the
recommendations of the Wage Board and willingly agreeing to _its
implementation. In a letter dated the I 8'th December '61 to
the President of the Workers Union, the Management stated that
as p~r their talks on 10th December '61, it accepts the implementation of the Wage Board recommendations and will pay
from December '61 onwards salary as per fitments made by it.
Final figures and fitments will be made after the Government
Tripartite Committee comes and discusses with it and the Union
and arrives at a decision. It also promised to pay the difference
in the wage as per wages paid till the month of November 1961
and the Wage Board fitments as made by them wiJI be paid to
the workers before 'the end of March 1962. Again in the agree-'
ment between the Management and the employees under sec.
18 (1) of the Industrial Disputes Act dated 19-9-63 it was specifically stated that "the question of fitments will be taken up as
per the Sugar Board's recommendations in the month of January 1964 and finalise before the end of the 1963-64". Even at
that stage it was never the case of •the Management that the Wage
Board's recommendations could not be implemented. Even the
new management in its letter of September 5, 1964 addressed to
the Union (Ex. W. 36) stated :
"With a view to arrive at an amicable settlement
with regard to fitments a discussion had taken place
between the members of the TripartFte Committee constituted by the Commissioner of Labour and it was agreed
during the discussions among other matters, that :
10-Ll340 Sup. CI/71
-
446
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
( 1) Wherever there is a standard nomenclature
in 1the Wage Board Report corresponding to the previous designation held by an individual before November 1960, he will be given that designation provid•w
the duties and responsibilities of the individual are
similar to the duties assigned by the Wage Board.
A
B
( 2) In other cases, where no standard nomenclature can be applied to the existing cadre, tho~ cadre will
he fixed with reference to duties and responsibilities
and the time scale of pay attached to the cadre in factory before November 1960''.
From the several exhibits it would apP'~ar •that both old and
the new management were anxious to implement the Wage
Board's recommendation but according to the fitments made by
it. But the employees as represented by the Workers Union were
not prepared to accept those fitments and wanted fitments in a
higher cadre and other advantages according to their reading of
the Wage Board's recommendations which the management felt,
it is not able to accommodate not only hxause those recommendations did not justify it but on the ground of financial incapacity.
No doubt it is for the management to show what its financial
position is and how it is going to place undue or impossible burden upon it to implement the recommendations. That burden
it seeks to discharge by production of the balance-sheets which
have nO't been challenired and the contents of which are, therefore deemed to have been accepted. We find from the balancesheet and the Directors Report for the period ending 30-6-60
that a sum of Rs. 6,15,2541- had to be written off against the
old losses leaving a balance of Rs. 40,7741- in the profit and
loss account. The Directors thought that the Company's financial position has now been stabilised and all the old losses have
been wiped off but that hope was only short lived as the subs~
queot balance-sheets for the period ending 30th June '61 would
show. According to the report for 1961 though there was a net
profit of Rs. 1,08,0051- which together with the carry forward
profit of the previous year of Rs. 40,7741- amounted to
Rs. 1,48,7791- and after making provision for reserve for dev-:ilopment rebate of Rs. 38,7881- a balance of Rs. 1,09,9911- was
carried forward 'to next year's account. For that year no dividends were declared and the Managing Agents also waiv'~ their
remuneration. For the year ending 30th June 1962, the position is more or less the same-the net profit for the year amounted
to Rs. 30,616/- which toirether with the nrofits of the previous
year of Rs. 1,09,9911- amounted to Rs. 1,40,6071-. This
c
D
E
F
G
H
K!RLAMPUDI SUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
A
B
c
I)
E
F
!l
447
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
amount was again recommended by the Directors to be carried
forward for the next year. No dividend was declared and the
Managing Agents also waived their remuneration. In 1963 the
position had become critical the Joss incurred was Rs. 16,12,196
which wiped out the previous r.ar's profits. There was no question of declaration of any dividends but Managing Agent's remuneration of Rs. 30,000/" (minimum) was drawn. These
Joss.es would have the effect of eating into the capital of the Com·
pany, unless it could borrow and tide over them. In the year
ending 30th June '64 a Joss of Rs. 6,61,3861- was carried forward to next year. It may be noted that in that y.~ar in June
1964 the Government of India had approved the change in the
Constitution of rthe Managing Agency of the Company and it is
stated that because of th.e efforts of the new Management wh"
borrowed large sums on their personal security for putting th"
Appellant in be'tter shape, large sums were in fact advanced to
the Appellant.
As could be seen from the statement M. 51 that for the years
1960-61, 1961-62, 1962-63 and 1963-64 the secured and unsecured debts were approximately Rs. 81 lakhs, Rs. 70 !akhs,
Rs. 61 Jakhs and Rs. 51 lakhs respectively. It is stated that the
losses were coming down and therefore the financial position is
getting better but in our view this by itself does not mean that
ithe Company is in a sound financial position. What was hap·
pening evid•wtly is as suggested by the learned Advocate for the
Appellant that the Sugar stocks pledged were being sold and
therefore the debts were getting less. It is no doubt itrue that
attachment orders which were made in 1962 must have been
paid off and the attachment wi•thdrawn. That again is not an
indication of the soundness of its financial position because there
is evidence to show that the new management had to secure a
large loan of aboU't Rs. 30 lakhs on its personal security to pay
these demands and that is why Rs. 16 lakhs loss is paid off and
hence in the year 1962-63 the unsecured debt is shown as Rs. 28
lakhs. The Tribunal was therefore justified in coming to the
conclusion that the Company was not in a sound financial position •to implement 1the recommendations of th·~ Wage Board to
increase Rs. I 01- on the basic wage and the dearness allowance
or Rs. 51- as weightage. Apart from these losses the general
reserves are very negligible. Each year about Rs. 3,0001- is
being provided for. In all Rs. 8 lakhs res·~rves were accumulated
from its inception which is not very encouraging.
While •this is so having regard to i'ts working we had called for
the balance-sheets subsequent to 1964-65 to assess the financial
prospects of the Appellant during this period. These reveal the
following position :
448
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1972] 1 S.C.R.
The balance-sheet for the year ending 30-6-65 showed a
profit of Rs. 12,72,1261- before depreciation. After deducting
Rs. 5,25,5451- towards depreciation and Rs. 1,16,1381- as
reserve towards development rebate iqid after adjusting the loss
brought forward from last year, a loss of Rs. 30,943/ - was
carried forward to the next year.
A
B
The balance-sheet for the year ending 30-6-66 showed a vrofit of Rs. 3,23,7891-. After setting apart depreciation a sum of
Rs. 2,27,9421- was the loss carried forward and in 'the balancesheet for the period ending 30-6-67 there was shown a loss of
Rs. 5,10,7711- and after providing for depreciation there was a
10ss of Rs. 9,90,5261 -. It may also be noticed that in the year
of account the Company had to provide a sum of Rs. 2,16,353/towards additional cane price payable ~o the cane growers for
the seasons 1958-59 and 1959-60. After allowing for this there
was a total loss of Rs. 14,23,505/- which was carried forward
•to the next year. In the balance-sheet for the year ending
30-6-68 there was a gross profit of Rs. 13,22,932/ - and after
providing for depreciation and adjustment of loss brought forward there was a balance of loss of Rs. 5,93,620/- carried forward •to the next year. The year ending 30-6-69 was one year
in which dividend of 7.153 was paid on the St% income-tax
Free Cumulative Preference shares. The profits for the year
after adjusting all the losses and providing for depreciation, payment of bonus to staff and taxation it showed a balance of
Rs .. 2,27 ,430/- out of which dividend was declared as aforesaid.
For the year ending June '70 there was again a loss of
Rs. 5,96,913/- after providing for depreciation. The Directors
explained this loss due mainly to high rates of interest charges,
provision for depreciation and the passing on of the entire
realisable profit on 1968-69 season production for the benefit of
the cane growers in that year.
The balance-sheets for the years 1960 to 1970-for a period
. of 10 years show that except for the year ending 30-6-69 the
Company was not in a position •to declare any dividends.
Though the factory appears to have beeri expanded after 1964
to 1300 tons capacity it did not show uniform net profits; on the
other hand losses continued. The profits :that it made in any
year seem to be consumed by losses of the previous years. In
some years the yield of cane seem to be slightly over 103 the
average being a little over 9% which no doubt is encouraging
but in spite of it there are various factors which seem to contribute to its financial unsteadiness.
This being the position we think that the Tribunal was
justified in holding thM the Ap~llllt did not have die financial
c
D
E
F
G
H
KIRLAMPUDHiUGAR MILLS V. IND. TRIB.
449
(Jaganmohan Reddy, J.)
A
capacity to bear the b11rden of payment of Rs. 10/- increase
and Rs. 51. as weightage in accordance with the recommenda·
tions of the Sugar Wage Board. On this conclusion and also
on an examination of fue relevant mat>~rial it is evident that the
Company is not in a financial position to meet the burden of
implementing the recommendations of the Wage Board. The
B
claim of the Respondent for categoriswtion and fitment in
accordance therewi1h cannot in the circurnstancr.,s be accepted.
The Appeal of the Respondents which challenges the Award of
the Tribunal rejecting their claim, for an increase of Rs. 10/ •
and a weightage of Rs. 51. and for the caitegorisation and fit·
ments in respect of the heirarchy of supervising category namely
c Assistant Cane Organisers, Liaison Field Supervisors and Field
Supervisors as also in respect of Head Panman, and Panman
Incharge of shift, Panman, Asstt. Panman, Bench Chemists and
Cane analysists and Canteen Supervisor are all dependent upon
the financial capacity of the Respondent Company to implement
the Wage Board's recommendations which we have held iot has
not. As stated earlier the Company which is the Appellant in
D
Civil Appeal No. 1602 of 1966 has already implemented the
Award of the Tribunal in respect of a large number of workers
both as to categoriswtion and fitmen1. It is in respect of fitment
of only four categories that it has not implemented, namely
Welders, Turbine Engine Drivers, Switch Board Attendants and
Boiler Mason's that the Appellant has objected to the Award on
E
the ground that the Tribunal has acted without evidence and in ·
some cases contrary to the recommendations.
The learned
Advocate for the Respondents felt that he could not really
challenge the contention in respect of the Switch Board Attendants and Turbine Engine Driver, as it would appear that the
Tribunal has acted withourt any evidence. Why we have referred
F
to these specific cases objected to by the Company in their Appeal
is to indicate that, notwithstanding the finding that the Wage
Board's recommendations in the circumstances, cannot be im·
plemented, the Company has given effect to the Tribunals Award.
which will remain in force till a revision takes place.
In the
view we have taken the Appeal of the Appellant is allowed subject to the above directions and tha1 of the Respondents dismissed. We make no order as to costs.
G.C.
Appeal No. 1602 of 1966 allowed;
Appeal No. 1603 of 1966 dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org