D. A, V. COLLEGE ETC. versus STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 5 May 1971 | [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 688 | 1971 INSC 143
Key facts
- Decided
- 5 May 1971
- Bench
- S.M. SIKRI*, G.K. MITTER, K.S. HEGDE, A.N. GROVER, P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- WRIT TO PETITION (CIVIL)... No. 256/1970
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 688
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 143
Text of the judgment
688
A
D. A, V. COLLEGE ETC.
v.
STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS.
B
May 5, 1971.
IS. M. Sncru, C. J., G. K. MITTER, K. s. HEGDE, A. N. GRovuR
AND P. JAGANMOHAN REDDY, JJ.]
Constitution of India, Arts 29(1), 30(1), 19 and 14.-Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969)-Sections 4(2), (3), 5, els. 2(1) (a) 17
and 18 of Statutes-If violative of the constitutional guarantees-Religious
minority, determination-Arya Samajis, if religious minority.
c
D
E
F
G
H
Constitution of India, Art. 32-Questions of legislative comp~tcnce,
agitation of.
The Arya Samaj is a reformist movement, believes in one God and in
the Vedas as the books of true knowledge. It has a distinct organisation
the membership of which is open to all those who subscribe to its aims
and objects. It admits to membership only those Hindus who >ubscribe
to the deca/ogue and its beliefs in the cannons of Vedic interpretation laid
down by its founder, but, all outsiders who are non-Hindus must undergo
a ceremony of purification or Shudhi. Under bye-law 32 of the Constitution of the Arya Somoj the proceedings of all meetings and sub-committees
will have to be written in Arya Bhasha-in Hindi language and Devnagari
character.
The Dayanand Anglo Vedic College Trust, formed to perpetuate the
memory of the founder of the Arya Samaj runs various institutions in the
Country. The petitioners-<:olleges managed and administered by the Trust
and the Managing Society were, before the Punjab Reorganisation Act, affiliated to the Punjab University constitute<) under East Punjab Act 7 of
1947. After the reorganisation of the State of Punjab in 1969, the Punjab
Legislature passed the Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969)
establishing a University. In exercise of the powers conferred by s. 5 the
first respondent specified the districts in the State of Punjab over which
the University was to exercise its power and notified the date on which
the colleges in the areas so specified ceased to be affiliated to the Punjab
University and were to be associated with and admitted to the privileges
of the new university. Sub-section (2) of s. 4 of the Act enacted that the
University "shall make provision for study and research on the life and
teachings of Guru Nanak and their cultu~al and religious impact in the
context of Indian and World Civilisation; and sub.s. (3) enjoined the Uni·
versity "to promote studies to provide for research in Punjabi language
and literature and to undertake measures for the development of Punjabi
language, literature and culture". By cl. 2(1) (a) of the Statutes ill Ch. V,
framed under the Act, the colleges were required to have a regularly constituted governing body consisting of not more than 20 persons approved
by the senate including, among others, two representatives of the University and the principal of the College, ex officio. Under Cl. (I} (3) if these
requirements were not complied with the affi.liation was liable to be withdrawn. By cl. 18 the staff initially appointed were to be approved by the
Vice Chancellor and subsequent changes had to be reported to the University for the Vice-Chancellor's approval. And by cl. 18 non-government
colleges were to comply with the requirements !aid down in the ordinance
governing service and conduct of te11chers.
D. ,\, V. COLLEGE V. PUNJAB
In petitions filed under Art. 32 of the Constitution it was contended
that the main object of the Act was to propagate Sikh religion and to promote Punjabi language in Gurumukhi script and that since the petitioners
-institutions belonged to a minority based on religion and language their
compulsory affiliation violated Arts. 29(1) and 30(1) of the Constitution.
In support of this it was submitted that s. 5(3) of the Act and also els.
2(1)(a), 17 and 18 of the statutes in Ch. V. interfered with the management
of minority institutions and therefore violated the guarantee under Art. 30;
that tho statutory affiliation being compulsory affected the petitioners
freedom of association guaranteed under Art. 19(1) (c); and that ss. 4(:)
and 4(3) contravened Arts. 29(1) & 30(1) and was discriminatory. The
petitioners further contended that in view of s. 72 of the Reorganisation
Act the State Legislature was not competent to enact s. S which eo1powered
the State Government bf notification to compulsorily disaffiliate from the
Punjab University all colleges including the colleges of minorities and affiliate them to the new University. The respondents contended inter alia,
that education being a State subject, the state legislature alone w:i.s competent to legislate in respect of universities and that in any case in a petition
under Art. 32 this Court could not go into the question of legislative competence if the law that was in1pugned did not in any way affect the fundamental rights of the petitioners.
HELD: (1) Whether or not ultimately any fundamental right ;n fact is
threatened or violated so long as a prima facie case of such a threat or
violation is made out a petition under Art. 32 must be entertained. So
long as the petitioner makes out a prima facie case that his fundamental
rights are affected or threatened he cannot be prevented from challenging
that the law complained of, which affects or invades those rights, is invalid
because of \Vant of legislative competence.. But the proposition that once
689
A
B
C
D
the petition is entertained, irrespective of whether it is found ultimately
that the Jaw has infringed the fundamental rights of the petitioners, the
vires of the legislation or the competence of the legislature to enact the
impugned legislation must be gone into and determined, is not valid. If
in fact, the law does not. even on the assumption that it is valid, infringe
any fundamental rights this Court will not decide that question in a pet.i.
tion under Art. 32. The reason is that no petition under Art. 32 will
be entertained if fundamental rights are not affected and if the impugned
Jaw does not affect the fundamental rights it would be contrary to this
principle to determine whether that law in fact has legislative competence
or not. In the present case none of the provisions of the Act offend any
of the fundamental rights of the petitioners. Therefore, it is not necessary to
go into the question of legislative i;ornpetence or to decide upon the validity
of s. 5. [713A-B; 714H]
Moham1nad Yasin v .. The Town Area Committee, Jala/abad ,(: Anr.
[1952] S.C.R. 572, Charanjitlal Chowdhury v. The Union of Indio &: Or»..
[1970] S.C.R. 869, Kyerbari Tea Co. Ltd. &: Anr. v. State of Assam, [1964]
5 S.C.R. 975 and Saghir Ahmad v. State of U.P., [1955] S.C.R. 707, refetred to.
(2) ·A reading of Arts. 29(1) and 30(1) would lead to the conclusion
that a religious or linguistic minority has a right to establish and administe1:
educationar institutions of its choice for effectively conserving its distinctive
language script or culture subject to the regulatory power of ~he State
and cl. (2) of Art. 29. While this is so, these two articles are not interlinked nor does it permit of their being always read together. [695F]
Rev. Father W. ProQst &: Ors. v. State of Bihar &: Ors., [1969] 2 S.C.R.
73, referred to.
44-1 S.C. India/' l
F.
F
G
H
6!JO
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
(3) Religious or linguistic minorities are to be determined only in relation to the particular legislation which is sought to be impugned; if it ii
State Legislature these minorities have to be determined in relation to the
population of the State. A linguistic minority for the purpose of _.\rt
30(1) is one which must at least have a separate spoken language; it is not
necessary that the language should also have distinct script. [697BJ
Re: Kera/a Education Bill, 1957, [1959) S.C.R. 995, referred to.
B
C
(4) (a) The Arya Samaj,' by "rejecting the manifold absurdities found
in Smriti and in tradition and in seeking a basis in the early literature for
a purer and more rational faith" can be considered to be a religious n1inority, at any rate, as part of the Hindu religious minority in the State of
Punjab. [7000)
(b) The Arya Samajis have a distinct script of their own, namelJ
Devnagri. [701B]
(5} The Arya Samajis are entitled to invoke the right guaranteed bJ
Art 29(1), because, they are a section of citizens having a distinct script;
they are entitled to invoke Art. 30(1), because they are a religious minority.
[701BJ
D
[In view of the holding that Arya Samajis are a religious minority the
Court did not find it necessary to consider whether they are a linguistic
minority or whether they are a religious denomination.] [698G)
(6) Clauses 2(1) (a) and 17 of Ch."V of the Statutes interfere with the
right of the religious minority to adminlster their educational institutions.
These provisions cannot be made as conditions of affiliation non compli·
ance with which would involve disaffiliation; consequently, they have to be
struck down as offending Art. 30(1). [709B]
Kera/a Education Bill, 1957, (1959] S.C.R. 995, and Rev. Sidhaibhai
Sabhm v. State of Bombay, [1963] 3 S.C.R. 837 referred to.
.,
G
H
Rev. Father W. Proost v. State of Blhar, [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73, held inapplicable.
Clause 18 does not suffer from the same vice as cl. 17, because, that
provision empowers the University to make ordinances prescribing regula ..
tions governing the conditions of service and conduct of teachers and these
are enacted in the larger interest of the institution to ensure their efficiency
and excellence. While the power to make ordinances in respect of the
matters referred to is unexceptional the ntaure of the infringement of tho
right, if any, under Art. 30(1) will depend on the actual purpose and import of the ordinance \vhen made, and the manner in which it is likely
to affect the administration of the educational institution. [709C]
(7) Assuming that the Punjab Legislature has the competence to enact
the Act, sub-ss. (2) and (3) of s. 4 do not offend, by themselves, any of the
rights under Arts. 29(1) & 30(1). [702A)
(a) Sub-section (2) merely indicates that the University can institute
courses of study or provide research facilities for any student of the Uni..
versity whether be belongs to the majority or the minority community
to engage himself in such study or research; but, this study and research
on the life and teachings of Guru Nanak must be a study in relation to
their culture and religious impact in tho context of Indian and World cMlizations. To provide for academic study of life and teachina or tho
D. A. y. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB
philosophy or culture of any great saint of lndia in relation to or the impact on the Indian and World civilizations cannot be considered as making
provision for religious instructions. [703G]
(b) While the State or the University has every right to provide for
,the education of the majority in the regional medium, it is subject to the
restrictions contained in Arts. 25 to 30. Neither the University nor the
State can provide for imparting education in a medium of instruction in a
language and script which stifles the language and script of any section
of the citizens. But sub-s. (3) does not lend itself to the interpretation
that the medium of instruction of all affiliated colleges has to be_ Punjabi.
The provision is for the promotion of Punjabi language, literature and culture. Therefore, sub-section (3) does not transgress the guarantee under
Art. 29(1). [704A·D]
(c) The facts of the case do not attract Art. 14. The State of Punjab
is created as a unilingual state with Punjabi as its language and if provision
js made for study of punjabi language that does not furnish a ground
for discrimination nor can the provisiob for the study of the life and teaching of Guru Nanak afford any cause for complaint, since; in neither case
there is any compulsion on any person to undertake such studies; nor is
.any of the communities prohibited from pursuing studies in respect of
either Hindi or the life and teachings of any Hindu saint. [704F]
(8) The notificatioo under s. 5(3) compulsorily affiliating the colleges
to the University does not contravene the right of freedom of Association
guaranteed under Art. 19(1) (c). Section 5 does not interfere ·.vith the
D.A.V. College Trust and Management Society by any attempt to form an
Association with the University. [706B]
All India Bank Employees Association v. National Industrial Tribunal,
[1962] 2 S.C.R. 269 and Raghubar Dayal Jai Prakash, v. Union of India,
{1963] 2 S.C.R. 547, referred to.
691
A
B
G
D
E
Smt. Damayanti Narang v. Union of India, W.P. No. 91 of 1964,
<lated 23·2-1971, distinguished.
OiuoINAL JURISDICTION :
Writ Petitions Nos. 256 to 268 and
271 of 1970.
F
Petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India for the
~nforcement of fundamental rights.
A. K. Sen, B. Datta, S. Swarup, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C.
Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for the petitioner (in W. P. No. 256
·Of 1970).
.
G
Frank Anthony, B. Datta, S. Swarup, J. B. Dadachanji, O. C.
Mathur and Ravinder Narain, for the petitioner in (W. P. No. 257
-Of 1970).
B. Datta, S. Swarup, J. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur and
Ravinder Narain. for petitioners (in W. P. Nos. 258 to 265, 267
;and 268 of 1970).
H
692
A
SUPREME COURT RBPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
Naunit Lal, B. Datta, J. R. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur and
Ravinder Narain, for the petitioners (in W. P. Nos. 266 and 271
of 1970).
M. C. Chagla, R. N. Sachthey and Harbans Singh, for respondent No. I (in W. P. No. 256 of 1970).
B
c
H. L. Sibbal, Advocate-General, Punjab, R. N. Sachthey and Harbans Singh, for respondent No. 1 (in W. P. No. 257
of 1970).
R. N. Sachthey and Harbans Singh, respondent No. I (in W. P.
No. 258 to 268 and 271 of 1970).
M. C. Setalvad, Hardev Singh and Hira Lal Kapur, for respondent No. 2 (in W. P. No. 256 of 1970).
Hardev Singh and Hiralal Kapur, for respondent No. 2 (iu
W. P. Nos. 257 to 268 and 271 of 1970).
D
M. N. Goswami and S. N. Mukherjee, for respondent No. 3
(iu W. P. No. 256 of 1970).
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
E
F
G
H
P. Jaganmoban Reddy, J.-These are fourteen Writ Petitions
by various Colleges managed and administered by Dayanand Anglo
Vedic College (D. A. V. College) Trust and the Managing Society.
against the Respondents challenging the Constitutional validity of
certain provisiqns of Guru Nanak University, Amritsar, Act 21 of
1969 (hereinafter called the 'University' or the 'Act', as the context
may permit) and in particular Sections 4, 4(2), 4(3) and 5 of the
Act as being violative of Articles 14, 19 (!) (c) and (f), 26, 29 ([)
and 30(1) of the Constitution of India. There was also a prayer
for quashing the Notification No. 2201-4-RDI-7017147 dated 16th
March 1970 issued under sub-section (!) of Section 5. by the first
Respondent, the State of Punjab as being illegal, unconstitutional
and void. As all these petitions raised a common question as to
the validity of the provisions of the Act the Notification issued by
the Government pursuant to that Act and certain provisions of
the statutes made thereunder it would be sufficient if facts in Writ
Petition No. 256 are set out.
The Managing Committee of the D. A. V. College is composed of 24 members and manages a score of other D. A. V. Institutions established in the Country. The D. A. V. College Trust
and the Managing Society was formed to perpetuate the memory
of Swami Dayanand Saraswati who was the founder of an organisation known as Arya Samaj, which organisation it is claimed
has a fixed religious programme and its constitution is designed
D. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
693
to perpetuate the religious teaching and philosophy of its founder.
The Arya Samaj it is stated has its own philosophy conception of
God worship, religious tenets, rituals, social work, educational
work etc., as would appear from the Constitution of the Arya
Samaj. It is therefore claimed that it being a religious sect and
denomination, is a minority within the meaning of Article 30(1)
of the Constitution. These Schools and Colleges were established
'on the lines teachings and principles of Arya Samaj' in which
'the imparting of the vedic culture and religious instructions and
worship based on the concept of Vedas, was and has its essential
ingredient'.
A
The Institutions which have filed the Writ Petitions were
before the Punjab Reorganisation Act (hereinafter called the 'Reorganisation Act') affiliated to the Punjab University constituted under
the East Punjab Act 7 of 1947 (hereinafter called the 'Punjab Unieroity' or the 'Punjab University Act' as the context admits). Before
the partition of India some of these Institutions were affiliated to
the Punjab University, Lahore. After the partition 0th.er Universities were set up in Punjab State like the Punjabi University, the
Kurukshetra University, the Agricultural University etc., each of
which ltad its own territorial jurisdiction.
c
There being a strong movement in the State of Punjab by the
Sikhs to have a State of their own and others who did not want
it, the Government of India being faced with this problem ultimately decided to reorganise the State of Punjab on linguistic basis.
A Boundry Commission was appointed under the Chairmanship of
Shah, J., as he then was, and on the basis of that report Parliament
ultimately passed the Reorganisation Act by and under which the
State of Punjab and the State of Haryana were formed and certain
other territories were added to Himachal Pradesh. Chandigarh,
the erstwhile Capital was to be a Union territory and was to serve
as Capital of both these States. A provision was made in this
Act for the continuance of certain Corporations and Institutions
which had served the needs of the people of both areas to continue
as heretofore subject to the special provisions enacted in the Act.
Three of such institutions were the Punjab University, the Punjab
Agricultural University and the Board constituted under the provisions of Part III of Sikh Gurdwaras Act 1925. The continuance
of the aforementioned two Universities was dealt along with other
statutory Corporations under the general provisions contained in
Section 72 of the Reorganisation Act. As already pointed out at
the time of the reorganisation of the State other Universities other
than the University of Punjab were in existence namely the Punjabi
University in Punjab, and Kurukshetra University in Haryana.
After the reorganisation the various Colleges which were in the
B
D
E
F
G
H
694
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19711 SUPP. ~.C.lt.
State of Punjab other than those over which the Punjabi University had jurisdiction were continued to be affiliated to the Punjab
University. While this was the position till 1969 the Punjab Legislature in order to mark the 500th Birth anniversary of Shri Guru
Nanak Devji established a University to perpetuate his name. The
Act received the assent of the Governor on 28th November 1969.
On the 16th March 1970 the first Respondent in exercise of the
powers conferred on it by sub-section (!) of Section 5 of the Act
specified the Districts of Amritsar, Gurdaspur, Julhmdur and
Kapurthala in the State of Punjab as the area in which the University shall exercise its power and perform its duties. It further
notified on 16th March 1970 in exercise of the powers under subsection (3) of Section 5, 30th June 1970 as the date for the purpose
of the said sub-section in respect of the educational institutions
situated within the limits of the aforesaid area, which meant that
as and from that date the Colleges in the areas specified above
which were affiliated to the Punjab University ceased to be affiliated to that University and were deemed to be associated with and
admitted to the privileges of the University.
D
E
F
G
H
The contentions urged before us are that the main purpose and
object of the University as constituted by the University Act is to
propagate Sikh religion and promote Punjabi language in Gurmukhi script, that since the Petitioners institutions belong to a minority based on religion and language in that they being adherents
of Arya Samaj Sect and denomination their compulsory affiliation
to the University violates Article 29(1) and 30(1) of the Constitution of India. In support of this main contention it is submitted
that Section 5(3) of the Act and also clauses 2(1) (a), 17 and 18
of the statutes in Chapter V which inter-alia interfere with the
management of the minority institutions are ultra-vires being violative of the guarantee under Article 30(1). It is also contended
that the minority educational institutions have the freedom !o
choose to which University they will be affiliated and that the legislature cannot compel affiliation to any particular University. In
any case in view of Section 72 of the Reorganisation Act it is
the Central Government which must determine whether Colleges
affiliated to the Punjab University can be disaffiliated before any
Notification under the Act can be issued specifying the areas in
which educational institutions are to be affiliated and admitted to
the privileges of the University as from the date notified. On this
view it is submitted that the notification of the 16th March '70 is
bad and must be struck down. It is also submitted that this statutory affiliation being compulsory affects the Petitioners right of Association guaranteed under Art. 19(1) (c) and that Article 14 is
contravened because Section 4(2) and 4(3) discriminate against the
Hindus, for while providing for the study of the teachings of Guru
D. A. v. COLLEGB v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
Nanak and the encouragement of the Punjabi language no provision is made for the study of the religion or teachings of the
Hindus or of their language-the Hindi.
Now the question is, have the Petitioners been established and
administered by a religious or linguistic minority, having a distinct
script or culture of its own within the meaning of Articles 29(1)
and 30(1) of the Constitution and do the provisions of the Act or
any statute or ordinance or Notification made thereunder offend
any of the rights guaranteed to them. This in turn leads to an
enquiry whether the Arya Samaj Sect is a religious or linguistic
minority. Article 29(1) and 30(1) are as follows : 290)-Any Section of the citizens residing in the
territory of India or any part thereof having a distinct
language, script or culture of its own shall have the right
to conserve the same.
30(1)-All minorities, whether based on religion or
language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.
lt will be observed that Article 29(1) is wider than Article 30(1),
in that, while any Section of the citizens including the minorities,
can invoke the rights guaranteed under Article 29(1), the rights
guaranteed under Article 30(1) are only available to the minorities
based on religion or language. It is not necessary for Article 30
(I) that the minority should be both a religious minority as well as
a linguistic minority. It is sufficient if it is one or the other or
both. A reading of these two Articles together would lead us to
conclude that a religious or linguistic minority has a right to estal:r
lish and administer educational institutions of its choice for effectively conserving its distinctive language, script or culture, which
right however is subject to the regulatory power of the State for
maintaining and facilitating the excellence of its standards. This
right is further subject to clause (2) of Article 29 which provides
that no citizen shall be denied admission into any educational institution which is maintained by the State or receives aid out of State
funds, on grounds only of religion, race, caste, fanguage or any
of them. While this is so these two articles are not inter-linked
nor does it permit of their being alW!lys read together.
In Rev. Father W. Proost & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors. (')
where while conceding that the Jesuits of Ranchi who were a religious minority established the petitioner Institution the St. Xaviers
College which was admitting students of other communities also,
the Attorney General had contended that as the protection to
(I)
[1969) 2 S. C.R. 7J.
695
A
B
c
D
E
G
H
696
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
ff
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971) SlPP. S.C.R.
minorities in Article 29(1) is only a right to conserve a di;tinct
language, script or culture of its own the College did not qualify
for the protection of Article 30(1) because (i) it was not founded
to conserve them, and (ii) it was open to all sections of people.
An attempt was made to read into the protection granted by Article
30(1) a corollary taken from Article 29(1). While conceding that
the Jesuit community is a minority community based on religion
and therefore it has a right to establish and administer educational
institutions of its choice, it was contended that as the protection
to minorities in Article 29(1) is only a right to conserve the distinct
language, script or culture of its own, the College does not qualify
for the protection of Article 30(1) because it is not founded to
conserve them. Hidayatullah, C. J ., rejected the interpretation
sought to be placed on Article 29(1) and 30(1) as if they have to
be read together. At page 80 he said :
"In our opinion, the width of Article 30(1) cannot be
cut down by introducing in it considerations on whiclt
Art. 29(1) is based. The latter article is a general protection which is given to minorities to conserve their language, script or culture. The former is a special right to
minorities to establish educational institutions of their
choice. This choice is not limited to institution, seekin~
to conserve language, script or culture and the choice i~
not taken away if the minority community having established< an educational institution of its choice also aJmi~
members of other communities. That is a circumstance
irrelevant for the application of Article 30(1) since no such
limitation is expressed and none can be implied. The two
articles create two separate rights, although it is possible
that they may meet in a given case."
The next question is what constitutes a rel'igious or linguistic minority and how is it to be determined ? It was submitted
that in Re. Kera/a Education Bill 1957 (') this Court dJd not in
fact lay down any test for ascertaining what is meant by minority
community or how it is to be ascertained because in that case it
had assumed that question (2) itself proceeded on the footing that
there were minorities in Kerala who are entitled to the rights conferred under Article 30(1). ·No doubt to some extent this is true.
Das, C. J., had observed at page 1050 that "strictly speaking for
answering question (2) we need not enquire as to what a minority
community means or how is it to be ascertained". Nonetheless
earlier he did consider these matters (vide pages 1047-1050) and
laid down the principles which govern it, including an examination of the figures relating to the total population of the Kerala
(1) [1959) S. c. R. 995.
I
o. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
State and the population of the minorities, the Christians, the
Muslim and the Anglo Indians.
Though there was a faint attempt to canvas the position that
religious or linguistic minorities should be minorities in relation to
the entire population of the country, in our view they are to be
determined only in relation to the particular legislation which is
sought to be impugned, namely that if it is the State legislature these
minorities have to be determined in relation to the population of
the State. On this aspect Das, C. J., in Kera/a Education Bill
case speaking for the majority thought that there was a fallacy in
the suggestion that a minority or Section envisaged Article 30(1)
and Article 29(1) could mean only such persons as constitute
numerically, minority in the particular region where the educational institution was situated or resided under local authority. He
however, thought, it was not necessary to express a final opinion
as to whether education being the snbject matter of item 11 of the
State list, subject only to the provisions of entry 62, 63, 64 and
66 of List I and entry 25 of List III, the existence of a minority
community should in all circumstances and for purposes of all
laws of that State be determined on the basis of the population of
the whole State or whether it should be determined on the said
basis only when the validity of a law extending to the whole State
is in question or whether it should be determined on the basis of
a population of a locality when the law under that Act applie•
only to that locality, because in that case the Bill before the Court
extended to the whole of the State of Kerala and consequently
the minority must be determined by reference to the entire population of that State.
It is undisputed, and it was also conceded by the State of
Punjab, that the Hindus of Punjab are a religious minority in the
State though they may not be so in relation to the entire country.
The claim of Arya Samaj to be a linguistic minority was however
contested. A linguistic minority for the purpose of Article 30(1)
is one which must at least have a separate spoken language. It
is not necessary that that language should also have a distinct script
for those who speak it to be a linguistic minority. There are in
this country some languages which have no script of their own,
but nonetheless those sections of the people who speak that language will be a linguistic minority entitled to the protection of
Article 30(1).
The Punjab Boundry Commission Report under the Chairmanship of Shah, J. as he then was dealt not only with the several
scripts in use but also the language of the dominant sections residing in Punjab. Earlier the States Reorganisation Report also went
into the question ani:I noted the controversies between Akali Dal
~ponsoring Punjabi with Gurmukhi script and Hindus who while
6~7
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
698
A
B
c
D
E
F
SUPREME COURT RBPOPTS
at home they speak Punjabi asserted that in their religious ceremonies and festivals, in their Schools and Colleges they use Hindi.
In any case they never accepted Gurmukhi script. At page 143
it was observed "The problem of language in the Punjab is therefore primarily one of scripts ; and in this battle of scripts ; sentiment is arrayed against sentiment". This matter was dealt with.
in somewhat great detail in Shah's report at page 2 and 3 :
"History of the language controversy in the Punjab
is over fifty years old. In the Punjab of pre-British days,
the Court language was Persian, and Punjabi was almost
invariably written in the Persian script. Under the British
rule, Urdu was the language of the Courts and of district
administratioa in addition to English. During the last decades of the 19th Century two important social reform
movements gained strong foothold in the Punjab. The
Arya Samaj movement took hold among the urban Hindu
population and use of Hindi in the Devnagri script was
propagated. After Swami Dayanand, founder of the Arya
Samaj movement, published his 'Satyarath Prakash' in the
eyes of a sectioa of the Hindus the Hindi language and the
Devnagri script acquired religious, significance. During the same period, the cause of Punjabi was espoused by
the Chief Khalsa Dewan. They published a large number of books and pamphlets dealing with the lives of
Gurus and diverse facets of the Sikh religion. These books
were written in Punjabi and in Gurmukhi script which
had been given its present form by the second Guru of the
Sikhs, and in which the holy Granth is written. The language issue in course of time got linked up with the politics of the province. Demands for giving better status
in the administrative scheme to Punjabi in Gurmukhi
script and Hindi in Devnagri script gained strength, and
the Government of the day agreed to accede to those
demands and recognised the status of both Pl\njabi and
Hindi in the educational curricula".
G
In our view it is unnecessary to consider whether Arya Samajis are
a linguistic minority, because if they can be considered to be a
religious minority they will be entitled to invoke the protection
under Article 30(1).
ff
For the purposes of Article 29(1) even though it may not
be necessary to enquire whether all the Hindus of Punjab as also
the Arya Samajis speak Hindi as a spoken language, nonetheless
there can be no doubt that the script of the Arya Samajis is distinct
from that of the Sikhs who form the majority. It is claimed that
while the Sikhs have Gurmukhi as their script the Arya Samajis
have their own script which is the Devnagri script. Their claim
o. A. v. COLLEoE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
to be a religious minority with distinct script of their own seems
to us to be justified as would appear from the following :
The Arya Samaj is a reformist movement. believes in one God
and in the Vedas as the books of true knowledge. It holds that
it is the duty of every Arya Samaj to read the Vedas and have
them read, to teach or preach them to others. It has a distinct
organisation, the members!iip of which is open to all those who
subscribe to its aims and objects.. The Arya Samajis worship
before the vedic fire and it begins with the burning of incence (the
homa 'sacrifice') accompanied by the· chanting of the Vedic verses.
Encyclopaedia Britannica-(Vol.
about Arya Samaj at page 558 :
II-1968) has this to say
"Arya Samaj, a vigorously reforming Sect of modern
Hinduism, founded in 1875 by Swami Dayanand Saraswati (1824-83) at Bombay....... The Vedas as interpreted
by the method laid down by Dayanand may be said to be
the theology of the Arya Samaj and are held to contain
all truth and all knowledge. including the basis for
modern science. The Arya Samaj is completely opposed to
idolatry, is sternly monothistic and denies the efficacy of
priestly intervention. Its organization and services are
strongly reminiscant of Protestantism...... The Arya Samaj
opposes the caste system based upon birth, as un-vedic and
insists that caste should reflect merit......... The Arya
Samaj has sought to revitalize Hindu life and to instill
self-confidence and national pride among Hindus. It has
established a network of excellent Schools and Colleges,
including the Dayanand Anglo-Vedi~ College in Lahore,
which teach rigorously in the Vedas and in modern
sciences ............... "
699
A
B
c
D
E
F
To show the affinity between Arya Samaj and protestantism a
comparison is made in the Encyclopaedia of Religion and
Ethics between Dayanand Saraswati and Martin Luther.
In Volume 2 at page 58-59, it is said :
"As Luther the German monk was a child of the European Renaissance, so Dayanand the Gujrati monk was a
child of the Indian Renaissance. Luther attacked indulgences, while Dayanand attacked idolatry. Luther appealed from the Roman church and the authority of tradition
to the scriptures of the Old and New Testaments. Swami
Dayanand appealed from the Brahmanical Church and
the authority of Smrti to the earliest and most sacred of
Indian Scriptures. The watchword of Luther was 'Back
to the Bible'; the watchword of Dayanan1l was 'back to
G
R
700
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
the Vedas' ................ but be it noted to the Vedas as
interpreted, not by the traditional scholarship of Indian
orthodoxy or by the critical scholarship of the West, but
by the scholarship of the Arya Samaj alone ............ The
scripture basis of the Arya Samaj then, while formally the
Vedas, is in reality a certain interpretation of the Vedas,
which is not recognized as legitimate by a single Sanskrit
scholar, either Indian or European, outside of the Arya
Samaj".
Shri :vlotilal Setalvad learned advocate for the respondents contends that there is nothing to indicate that the Arya
Samajis should be Hindus. This argument however overlooks the
basic tenets of the Sect in that it admits to membership only those
Hindus who subscribe to the decalogue and its beliefs in the cannons of vedic interpretation laid down by Swami Dayanand hut
all outsiders who are non-Hindus such as Muslim and Christians
must undergo a ceremony of purification or Shudhi.
D
The passages read above show beyond doubt that the Arya
Samaj by "rejecting the manifold absurdities found in Smrti and
in tradition and in seeking a basis in the early literature for a
purer and more rational faith" can be considered to be a religious
minority, at any rate as part of the Hindu religious minority in
the State of Punjab.
E
It was also sought to be contended by the petitioners advocate that they are a religious denomination for the purposes of
protection under Article 26 (a). It is true that Mukherjea, J., as
he then was in, The Commissioner of Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras v. Sri Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar of Shirur
Mutt (') after referring to the Oxford Dictionary for the meaning of religious denomination as "a collection of individuals classed together under the same name : - a religious sect or body
having a common faith and organisation and designated by a distinctive name" held that different sects or sub-castes can certainly
be called a religious denomination as it is designated by a distinctive name-has a common faith and common spiritual organization. This may be so but in the view we have taken that the
Arya Samaj is a religious minority, we find it unnecessary to determine whether it is also a religious denomination, as it does not
arise for consideration under Article 30 (]).
F
G
H
Now coming to the question whether the Arya Samajis have
a distinct script of their own bye-law 32 of their Constitution shows
that the proceedings of all meetings and sub-committees will have
(1) [1954] S. C.R. IOOS.
o. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
to ile written in Arya Bhasha- in Hindi languages and Devnagri
All Aryas and Arya Sabhasads should know Arya
Bhasha, Hindi or Sanskrit. The belief is that the name of the
script Devnagri is derived from Deva and therefore has divine
origin. From what has been stated it is clear that the Arya
Samajis have a distinct script of their own, namely Devnagri.
They are therefore entitled to invoke ..he right guaranteed under.
Article 29 (!) because they are a section of citizens having a
distinct script and under Article 30 (!) because of their being a
religious minority.
701
A
cha~acter.
It is now to be ascertained whether any of the. provisions of
the Act, statutes or Ordinances offend t11e guaranteed rights of the
petitioners. The petitioners contend that sub-sections (2) and (3.l
of Section 4 directly infringe the fundamental rights guaranteed
under Article 29 (!) and 30 (!) of the Constitution. Under these
provisions the Arya Samaj through its educational institutions have
the right to conserve its script, culture and its language.
Sub-section (2) of the Act, it is submitted enacts a provision
for making it imperative to study and conduct research on the life
and teachings of Guru Nanak and their cultural and religious im·
pact on Indian and World civilizations while sub-section (3) contemplates the adopting of measures for the study of Punjabi language literature and culture which provisions according to the
petitioners directly aim at strangulating the growth of Hindi while
encouraging the growth of Punjabi. Their apprehension is that
Punjabi with Gurmukhi script will be made the sole medium of
instruction in the University and that all Colleges affiliated to this
University may be forced to impart education through that
medium.
The State of Punjab in its counter denied that the provisions
of sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 4 seek to strangulate the
development and growth of Hindi language. It is stated that there
is nothing in these provisions which offends the religious susceptibilities of the Petitioners nor cam the provision for the promotion
of and research in Punjabi language, literature and culture in the
State of Punjab, which has as its declared policy the adoption of
Punjabi as the sole language of the Punjabi speaking area, be
construed as offending the rights of the minorities.
The second Respondent the University traversed the Petitioners all,gations on grounds similar to those taken by the State of
Punjab except that it was further stated that Respondent 3 the
University of Punjab has also set up a Guru Nanak Chair and that
the Punjab Government has offered to set up Guru Nanak Chairs
in the Universities of Calcutta, Dharwar, Madras, Kurnshetra,
Bombay as also in the Khalsa College. Amritsar.
B
c
D
E
y
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
702
A
n
(197!] SUPP. s.c.R.
Assuming for the moment that the Punjab Legislature had the
competence to enact the Act, about which considerable argument
was addressed before us particularly in respect of the ~cope and
ambit of Section 72 of the Reorganisation Act-sub-section (2) and
(3) of Section 4 do not in our view offend by themselves any of
the rights of the petitioners either under Art. 29 (!) or Art. 30
(]) of the Constitution. Sub-section '2' & (3) of Section 4 are
as follows :
Section 4.-The University shall exercise the following powers
and perform the following duties:
(!)
(2) To make provision for study and research on the
life and teachings of Guru Nanak and their cultural and
religious impact in the context of Indian and World civilizations;
D
(3) To promote studies to provide for research in
Punjabi language and literature and .to undertake measures for the development of Punjabi language, literature
and culture.
It will be seen from the language of sub-section (2) that nowhere is
there a mandate for compelling Colleges affiliated to it either to
study the religious teachings of Guru Nanak or to adopt in any
way the culture of the Sikhs.
F
G
H
Guru Nanak is the founder of the Sikh religion. His teachings were inspired by a need to synthesis the essentials of the
Hindu and Mohamadan faith which were always irreconcilable, by
preaching that in no essentials of faith did they differ. His was
intensly a montheistic philosophy of the unit of God largely
directed against idolatory hypocracy distinction of castes, creeds
and the pretentions of priest craft. He was an inspired soul from
his very childhood, travelled widely and his pilgrimages extended
to Mecca and Madina. If the University makes provision for an
academic study and research of the life and teachings of any saint
it cannot on any reasonable view be considered to require Colleges
llffiliated to the University to compulsorily study his life and teachings or to do research in them. The impugned provision would
merely indicate that the Unviersity can institute courses of study or
provide research facilities for any student of the University whether
he belongs to the majority or the minority community to engage
himself in such study or research but be it remembered that this
study and research on the life and teachings of the Guru Nanak
must be a study in relation to their cUlture and religious impact
o. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
703
in the contact of Indian and world civilizations wb.icb is mostly an
academic and philosophical study.
-;,.,
A
It is however contended that as the Guru Nanak University is
wholly maintained out of the State funds the provision under 4(21
offends Article 28(1) which is not saved by clause 2 thereof. The
petitioners pointed out that Section 23(1) of the Act enjoins on
Il
the State Government to provide from time to time 'such amounts
by way of grants for meeting the capital, recurring or other expenditure of the University as it may deem fit' and at any rate require
it to provide a minimum annual grant of Rs. 50 lakhs to the University for meeting its recurring expenditure provided that if during
any financial year the entire amount of the aforesaid grant is not
c
utilized for meeting the recurring expenditµre the unutilized balance
may with the previons consent of the State Government be utilised
for meeting capital expenditure of the University. Neither the
State Government nor the University in their counter denied this
allegation and even in the counter filed during the course of the
hearing by the State of Punjab nothing was stated to controvert
the assertion that the University is who!Jy maintained out of State
D
funds. During the course of the arguments however learned Advo<:ate appearing on behalf of the State a11d the University suggested
that this was not so because the University gets income from affiliation fees and examination fees as such it cannot be· said that the
University is wholly maintained out of State funds. We can only
say that this was not a serious attempt to deny the averment. The
E
income from affiliation fees and the examination fees as the term
'fee' itself indicates is something that is charged for rendering the
service in respect of those two items which is a sort of quid-prq>
quq and could hardly be sait1 to be an income for-the purposes of
running the University.
-
Even so the Petitioners have still to make out that Section 4(2)
implies that religious instruction - will be given. We think that
such a contention is too remote and divorced from the object of
the provision. Religious instruction is that which is imparted for
inculcating the tenets, the rituals, the observances, ceremonies and
modes of worship of a particular Sect or denomination. To provide for academic study of life and teaching or the philosophy and
culture of any great saint of India in relation to or the impact on
the Indian and world civilizations cannot be considered as making
provision for religious instructions.
Sub-Section (3) of Section 4 also does not in our view transgress the guarantee under Article 29(1). Whether one may like
it or not, linguistic States in this country have come to stay. The
purpose and object of these linguistic states is to provide with
F
G
H
704
SUPREME COUllT REPORTS
(1971] SUPP. S.C.R.
greater facility the development of the people of that area educationally, socially and culturally, in the language of that region but
while the State or the University has every right to provide for
the education of the majority in the regional medium, it is subject
to the restrictions contained in Article 25 to 30. Neither the University nor the State can provide for imparting education in a
medium
of instruction in a language and script which stifles the
B
language and script of any Section of the citizens. Such a course
will trespass on the rights of those Sections of the citizens whict
have a distinct language or script and which they have a right to
conserve through educational institutions of their own. In our
view Section 4(3) does not lend itself to the interpretation that the
medium of instruction of all affiliated Colleges has to be Punjabi.
c The provision, as we construe it, is for the promotion of Punjabi
studies and research in and the development of the Punjabi language, literature and culture which is far from saying that the University can under that provision compel the affiliated Colleges particularly those of the minority to give instruction in the Punjabi
language or in any way impede the right to conserve their language
script and culture.
D
It is again contended that while provision is made in Sections 4(2) and 4(3! for the study and research of the life and teachings of Guru Nanak and for the study of Punjabi language, script
and literature no similar provision is made for the study, of religious Heads of Hindus or for the study of Hindi and Devnagri script
though Hindus form a substantial portion of the population of the
E
State. These provisions therefore are discriminatory and violative
This argument in our view
of Article 14 of the Constitution.
is devoid of merit. The State of Punjab is created as a unilingual
State with Punjabi as its language and if provision is made for
study of Punjabi language that does not furnish a ground for discrimination
nor can the provision for study of the life and teachings
F
of Guru Nanak afford any cause for complaint as in neither case
as we have noticed, is there any compulsion on any person to undertake such studies nor is any of the communities prohibited from
persuing studies in respect of either Hindi or of the life and teachings of any Hindu saint. The facts of the case in our view do not
attract Article 14.
G
It is contended tbat the compulsory affiliation of the Petitioners
to the University affects their fundamental right of freedom of Association as guaranteed under Article 19(1) (e), therefore the notification under Section 5(3) affiliating them to the University is bad.
It is also urged that since the words "associated with and admitted
to any privileges" or used in Section 5 of the Act, it would mean
H
that Petitioners are compulsorily formed into an Association with
the University. This contention however is countered by the Respondents who point out that tbe freedom of Association under
A
I
D. A. v. COLL~GE v. PUNIAB (Jog1111 mohan Reddy, J.)
Article 19(1) (c) implies Association between citizens while in the
case of the Petitioners what is sought to be affected is an affiliation
with the University which is a corporate body.
The right to form an association implies that several indivi·
duals get together and form voluntarily an association with a com·
mon aim legitimate purpose and having a community of interests.
It was sought to be suggested thaf the compulsory affiliation with
the University affects the aims and objects of the Association, as
such its freedom is infringed. There is in our view a fallacy in
this argument which on earlier occasions had also been repelled.
In the All India Bank Employees Association v. National Industrial Tribunal & Ors. ('), it was observed that the right guaranteed
under Article 19(1) (c) does not carry with-it a concomitant right
that the Associations shall achieve their object such that any interference in such achievement by any law would be unconstitutional
unless it could be justified under Art. 19(4) as being in the interests
of public order or morality. The right under Article 19(1) (c)
extends inter a/ia to the formation of an Association or Union.
In Raghubar Dayal Joi Prakash v. Union of India & Ors. (')
it was held that if the statute imposes conditions subject to which
alone recognition could be accorded or continued, '_'it, is a little
difficult to sec how the freedom to form the Asso.~ri is effected unless, of course, that freedom implies or involves a gmiranteed
right to recognition also which it did not".
A reference has been made to a recent case of Smt. Damayanti Narang v. Union of India & Ors. ('), that a compulsory
affiliation by statute would interfere with the right of Association.
This argument in our .view is untenable because in that case Parlia·
ment passed a law under entry 63 of List II of Schedule VII to the
Constitution under which a Hindi Sammelan was to be constituted
which was to consist of the first members of the Hindi Sammelan
registered under the Societies Registration Act and all persons who
become members thereof in accordance with the rules in that
behalf. This statutory Sammelan was constituted as a body corporate .the first members of Vl'.hich were to consist of persons who
nn':'ed1ately before the appomted day were life members of the
Society had been President's of the Society or were awarded the
Manf-1.a Prasad ~aritoshik by the Society. There were also other
provmons ~y which the Hindi Sammelan Society, its constitution
as well as its propercy was affected. In those circumstances it
705
A
B
c
D
E.
F
G
H
(I) [1962] 2 S.C.R. 269.
(2) [1963] 2 s.c.R.547.
(3) Writ Petition No'. 91of1964, decided on 23·2·71.
45-1 S. C. Jndia/71
706
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
was held that the Act in so far as it interferes with the composition of the Society in constituting the Sammelan violated the rights
of the original members of the Society to form an Association
guaranteed under Art. 19(1) (c). No such thing was intended or
effected by Section 5 of the Act. At any rate the D. A. V. College
Trust and Management Society is not being interfered with, .by any
attempt to form an Association with the University. We can see
no infringement of Article 19(1) (c).
The next ground of attack is in respect of the statutes made
in exercise of the powers conferred under sub-section (!) of Section 19 of the University Act which according to the petitioners
interferes with_ the management of their institutions as such violates
Article 30(1) of the Constitution. The relevant impugned statutes
are contained in Chapter V relating to admission to Colleges.
These are 2(1) (a) 17, and 18 read with clause 1(2) and (3) whict
are as f9llows : 1(1)
I (2) Colleges shall be of two types namely University
Colleges and affiliated Colleges.
I (3) The educational institutions and Colleges situated in the Districts of Amritsar, Jullundur, Gurdaspur and
Kapurthalla are deemed to be associated with and admitted to the privileges of the Univerity with effect from 30th
day of June 1970. These institutions shall observe the
conditions for admission to the privileges of the University
failing which the rights conferred may be withdrawn.
2(1)(a) A College applying for admission to the privileges of the University shall send a letter of application
to the Registrar and shall satisfy the Senate : (a) that the College shall have a regularly constituted governing body consisting of not more than 20
persons approved by the Senate and including, among
others, 2 representatives of the University and the
Principal of the College Ex-officio.
Provided that the said condition shall not apply in
the case of Colleges maintained by Government which
shall however have an advisory Committee consisting of
among others the principal of the College (Ex-officio) and
two representatives of the University.
H
17. The staff initially appointed shall be approved
by the Vice Chancellor. All subsequent changes shall be
reported to the University for Vice Chancellor's approval.
D. A. v. COLLl!GB •• PUNIAll (Jagan mohaa Reddy, J.)
In the case of training institutions the teacher, pupil ratio
shall not be less than I: 12.
Non-Government Colleges
shall comply with the requirements laid down in the ordinance governing service and conduct of teachers in nonGoverment Colleges as may be framed by the University.
18. Non-Government Colleges shall comply with the
requirements laid down in the ordinances governing service and conduct of teachers in non-Ooverment Colleges
as may be framed by the University.
It is contended that these provisions interfere with the Peti·
tioners in the management of their institutions, in that the Colleges are required to constitute a regular governing body for each
of them, of not more than 20 persons to be approved by the University Senate. Of these, two representatives of the University and
the Principal of the College are to be ex-officio members. Accord·
ing to the Petitioners the Managing Committee of their institution
is composed of 24 members under the D. A. V. College Trust and
Management Society registered under the Societies Registration
Act (Act 21 ·of 1960). It will be observed that under clause 1(3)
if the petitioners do not comply with the requirements under 1(a)
their affiliation is liable to be withdrawn. Similarly it is stated
that clause 17 also interferes with the petitioners right to administer their College as the appointment of all the staff has to be
approved by the Vice-Chancellor and that subsequent changes will
also have to be reported to the University for Vice Chancellor's
approval. We have already held that the Petitioners institutions
are established by a religious minority and therefore under Article
30 this minority has the right to administer their educational institutions according to their choice.
Clauses 20) (a) and 17 of
Chapter V in our view certainly interferes with that right.
In the case of Kera/a Education BIJI () dealing with Article
30(1) this Court observed at page 1053 :
"The key to the understanding of the true meaning
and implication of the Article under consideration are the
words "of their own choice". It is said that the dominant word is "choice" and the content of that Article is
as wide as the choice of the particular minority community may make it. The ambit of the rights conferred
by Article 30(1) has therefore to be determined on a consideration of the matter from the points of view of the educational institutions themselves".
While so stating it was nonetheless observed :
"that the constitutional right to administer an educational institution of their choice does not necessarily
(I) [1959) S.C.R. 995.
707
.l
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
70~
4
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
militate against the claim of the State to insist that in order
to grant aid the State may prescribe reasonable regulations
to ensure the excellence of the institution to be aided".
Similarly in Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai & Ors. v. State of
Bombay & Anr. (')it was held that :
B
c
D
"Unlike Article 19 the fundamental freedom under
clause (!) of Article 30 is absolute in terms ; it is not
made subject to any reasonable restrictions of the nature
the fundamental freedoms enunciated in Article 19 may
be subjected to. All minorities, linguistic or religious
have by Article 30 (I) an absolute right to establish and
administer educational institutions of their choice ; and
any law or executive direction which seeks to infringe the
substance of that right under Article 30(1) would to that
extent be void. This, however, is not to say that it is not
open to the State to impose regulations upon the exercise
of this right......... Regulation made in the true interests
of efficiency of instruction. discipline, health, sanitation,
morality, public order and the like may undoubtedly be
imposed. Such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of the right which is guaranteed ; they secure the
proper functioning of the institution, in matters educational".
E
F
G
H
We. have already seen that in Rev. Father W. Proost & Ors.
v. the State of Blhar & Ors. (~. the provisions of Section 48(A)
which required to selection of the teachers of all affiliated
Colleges including the Colleges established by the minorities, to be
made by the University Service Commission, was held to interfere
with the rights of the petitioners m that case. In that case, while
the petition was pending in the Court, Section 48(B) was added to
the Bihar State University Act whereby notwithstanding the provisions of Section 48(AI exemption was given to the minority institutions to make appointments with the approval of the Commission
and the Syndicate, the petitioners claimed exemption under Section 48(B) and submitted that as an affiliated College established by
a minority based on religion or language they are exempted from
Section 48(A) and that if this petition was accepted they will
withdraw the petition which had become superfiuous. Even this
prayer was not acceded to by the State and consequently it was
held that they were entitled to the exemption claimed. This
decision is not therefore an authority for the proposition that even
the requirement that the staff of a minority educational institution
(IJ
[1963] 3 S.C.R. 837.
(2) [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73
D. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
709
be appointed, dismissed or removed only with the approval of the
University or the State does not infringe the right to administer
the institution guaranteed under Article 30(1).
In our view there is l)O possible justification for the provisions
contained in clauses 2(1) (a) and 17 of Chapter V of the statutes
which decidely interfere with the rights of management of the
Petitioners Colleges. These provisions cannot therefore be made
as conditions of affiliation, the non-compliance of which would
involve dis-affiliation and consequently they will have to be struck
down as offending' Article 30(1).
Clause 18 however in our view does not suffer from the same
vice as Clause 17 because that provision in so far as it is applicable
to the minority institutions empowers the University to prescribe by
regulations governing the service and conduct of teachers which is
enacted in the larger interests of the Institutions to ensure their
efficiency and excellence. It may for instance issue an ordinance
in respect of age of superannuation or prescribe minimum qualifications for teachers to be employed by such Institutions either genorally or in particular subjects. Uniformity in the conditions of
service and conduct of teachers in all non-Government Colleges
would make for harmony and avoid frustration. Of course while
the power to make ordinances in respect of the matters referred
to is unexceptional the nature of the infringement of the right, if
any, under Article 30(1) will depend on the actual purpose and
import of the ordinance when made and the manner in which it
is likely to affect the administration of the educational institution,
about which it is not possible now to predicate.
There is then the larger question which has been urged at some
length namely that having regard to Section 72 of the Reorganisation Act the Sfate legislature is not competent to enact Section S
of the Act which empowers th~ State Government by Notification
to compulsorily disaffiliate from the Punjab University all Colleges
including the Colleges of the minorities situated in the areas which
are now in Punjab and affiliate them to the University. Section
72 of the Reorganisation Act and Section S of the Act are as
foDows :
B
c
D
E
G
Section 72(1).-Save as otherwise expressly provided
by· the foregoing provisions of this part, where any body
corporate constituted under a Central Act, State Act or
Provincial Act for the existing State of Punjab or any
part thereof serves the needs of the successor States or
has, by virtue of the provisions of Part II, become an interState body corporate, then the body corporate shall, on
and from the appointed day, continue to function and operate in those areas in respect of which it was functioning
B
710
SUPREME COUltT ltEPOltTS
A
and operating immediately before that day, subject to such
directions as may from time to time be issued by the
Central Government until other provision is made by law
in respect of the said body corporate.
(2) Any direction issued by the Central Government
under sub-section (!) in respect of any such body corporate may include a direction that any law by which the
said body corporate is governed shall, in its application
to that body corporate, have effect, subject to such exceptions and modifications as may be specified in the direction.
B
(3) For the removal of doubt it is hereby declared that
the provisions of this Section shall apply also to the Punjab University constituted under the Punjab University
Act, 1947, the Punjab Agricultural University constituted
under the Punjab Agricultural University Act, 1961 and
the lloard constituted under the provisions of Part Ill of
the Sikh Gurdwaras Act, 1925.
c
D
(4). For the purpose of giving effect to the provisions of this section in so far as it relates to the Punjab
University and the Punjab Agricultural University referred to in sub-section (3) the successor State shall make
such grants as the Central Government may, from time
to time, by order, determine. ·
E
Section 5(1).-The State Government may, by Notification q19eify the limits of the area in which the University shall exercise its powers and perform its duties.
~
F
G
H
[1971] SUPP. s.c.ll.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law for the time being in force, no educational institution beyond the limits of the area specified under subsection (!) shall be associated with or admit!~ to any
privileges of the University.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law for the time being in force, any educational institution situated within the limits of the area specified under
suJ>.section (!) shall, with effect from such date as may
be notified in this behalf by the State Government be
deemed to be associated with and admitted to the privileges of the University and shall cease to be associated
in any way with, or be admitted to any privileges of the
Punjab University; and different dates may be appointed for different institutions.
The provisions of sub-sections (!) and (2) of Section 72 of the
Reorganisation Act are similar to those contained in Section I 09
D. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (Jagan mohan Reddy, J.)
of the States Reorganisation Act 1956 except that for removal of
doubts sub-section (3) has specified the institutions named therein
as being governed by sub-sections (1) and (2). Sub-section (4) is
consequential on the two Universities being made subject to the
said provisions by requiring the successor State to make such
grants to them as the Central Government may from time to time
by order determine.
The State Government had by Notification of the 16th March
under sub-section (I) of Section 5 Of the Act specified the districts
as the areas in which the Universities shall exercise its powers and
perform its duties and under sub-section (3) of the said Section,
it further notified 30th June 1970 as the date from which the educational institutions situated within the limits of the areas so specified in the notification shall be deemed to be associated with and
admitted to the privileges of the Universities.
The contention of the Petitioners is that since under Section
72 of the Reorganisation Act it is the Central Government which
is vested with the power to issue directions in respect of the Punjab
University or the Punjab Agricultural University and/ or to amend
and alter the provisions of the Punjab University Act or the
Punjab Agricultural University Act, the State Legislature is not
competent to legislate in respect of the said University or Universities. without the necessary directions of the Central Government.
This is sought to be justified on the ground (a) that in respect of
the Punjabi University the extension of jurisdiction of the University by a notification under the relevant provisions of the Punjabi
University Act issued by the State Government, the Central Government had issued a direction disaffiliating the Colleges situated
in those areas which were affiliated to the Punjab University, (b)
that as the Reorganisation of the State of Punjab itself involved
various matters upon which the successor States may not be agreed
Parliament by law had in exercise of the power vested in it, enacted provisions empowering the Central Government to give directions in the interests of both the States, which directions had the
affect of making a change in the then existing law governing the
Corporate bodies till such time as both the States agreed. Though
it is submitted that this power is transitory nonetheless it is -~ffective
till such time as the Central Government in agreement with the
States concerned permits them to legislate in respect of the body
corporate by giving necessary directions in that behalf.
On the other hand it is contended by the Respondents interalia (!) that under item 11 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to
the Constitution education being a State subject the State Legislature alone and not Parliament, is competent to legislate in respect
of Universities, support being gathered for this submission from
711
A\
B
c
D
E
G
H
712
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COUl\T REPORTS
(1971] SUPP. S.C.R.
the provisions of Sections 88 and 89 of the Reorganisation Act
under which the law in force immediately before the appointed day
could be otherwise provided for, or altered, repealed or amended
only "by a competent legislature" which in the context is that
legislature which is competent to legislate under any of the entries
in List I, II or under the concurrent List III of the Seventh Schedule; (2) that the law referred to in sub-section (I) of Section 72
of the States Reorganisation Act which could take away the power
of the Central Government to give directions from time to time as
may be necessary in respect of the 'functioning and operating' of
corporations including those in respect of the two Universities
referred to in sub-section (3) is the State law, as it could not have
been the intention of Parliament to deprive the States of their
legislative powers by means of a Jaw made under Article 4 to give
effect to the Reorganisation of the States by having recourse to
the power to make supplemental, incidental and consequential provisions ; (3) that Parliament itself understood that it has no power
to legislate in respect of one of the two Universities namely the
Punjab Agricultural University when it enacted the Haryana and
Punjab Agricultural University Act 16 of 1970, pursuant to the
resolution of the legislature of the State of Punjab and Haryana
under clause ()) of Article 252 of the Constitution in which it was
categorically stated, as is apparent from the resolution of the legislature of Haryana produced before us, that as legislation had to
be undertaken under entries I I and 32 of list II in the Seventh
Schedule and as "Parliament bas no power to make a law for the
State except as provided under Article 249 and 250 thereof" it
"shall by Jaw make provision for the dissolution of the aforesaid
Punjab Agricultural University .... for setting up a separate Agricultural University............ for vesting the rights and liabilities
of the University so dissolved in the University to be so set up
and for all matters connected therewith or incidental thereto", and
(4) that in any case in a petition under Article 32 this Court cannot go into the question of legislative competence if the law that
is impugned does not in any way affect the fundamental rights of
the petitioners.
We have already found that none of the provisions of the Act
offend any fundamental rights of the Petitioners. But it is contended on behalf of the Petitioners that in a petition under Article
32 once it ill alleged and a prima facie case is made out that the
fundamental rights of a citizen are threatened or violated this
Court is not only bound to entertain it for determining to what
extent the allegation is valid but is also bound to go into the
question, if raised, that the law under which it is alleged that his
fundamental right is infringed is invalid on the ground of want of
legislative competence. There are two facets to this submission.
D. A. v. COLLl!GB v. PIJNJAB (Jagan mo/tan Reddy, J.)
Firstly whether ultimately any fundamental right in fact is threatened or violated, so long as a prima facie case of such a threat or
'violation is made out a petition under Article 32 must be entertained. Secondly once it is entertained irrespective of whether it is
found ultimately that in fact no fundamental rights of the petition·
ers are invaded the vires of the legislation or the competence of the
legislature to enact the impugned legislation must be gone into and
determined. While the first proposition is valid, the second js
not.
Shri Tarkunde the learned Advocate for the Respondents in
Writ Petitions Nos. 353 and 354 of 1970 which were heard imme.diately after these petitions has raised a contention similar to that
raised in the second submission in support of which he referred to
the case of Mohammad Yasin v. The Town Area Committee,
Jalalabad & Anr.. ('). We do not think that this decision supports
his contention because in that case it was held that in the absence
of any valid law authorising the Town Committee to levy any
fees otherwise than for the use of any immovable property vested
in or entrusted to the Management of the Town Committee such
illegal imposition must undoubtedly operate as an illegal restraint
.and must infringe the unfettered right of the wholesale dealer to
carry on his occupation, trade or business which is guaranteed to
him by Article 19(1) (g) of the Constitution. In that case the levy
on the petitioner as a wholesale dealer was held to be obviously
ultra vires the powers of the Committee and therefore the bye-law
under which such a fee was levied could not be said to constitute a
valid law which alone may under Article 19(6) of the Constitution
impose a restriction on the right conferred by Article 19(1) (g). It
is, therefore, clear that as long as the petitioner makes out a prima
jacie case that his fundamental rights are affected or threatened he
cannot be prevented from challenging that the law complained of
which affects or invades these rights is invalid because of want of
legislative competence. In Chiranjilal Chowdhuri v. The Union
of India & Ors. ('), Mukherjea, J., as he then was gave expression
to a similar view as to the maintainability of a petition under
Article 32. At page 899 he said :
"To make out a case under this Article, it is incumbent upon the petitioner to establish not merely that the
law complained of is beyond the competence of the particular legislature as not being covered by any ofthe items
:in the legislative lists, but that it affects or invades his
fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution, of
which he could seek enforcement by an appropriate writ or
orderfl.
(I) l19S2] S.C.R. 572.
(2) [19SO] S.C.R.,869.
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
714
A
B
SUPREME COURT &BPORTI>
[1971] SUPP.s.c.&.
It is apparent therefore that the validity or the invalidity of
the impugned Jaw, on the ground of legislative competence should
purport to infringe the fundamental rights of the petitioner as a
necessary condition of its being adjudicated. But if in fact the
law does not, even on the assumption that it is valid, infringe any
fundamental rights, this Court will not decide that question in a
petition under Article 32. The reason for it is obvious, namely
that no petition under Article 32 will be entertained if fundamental rights are not affected and if the impugned Jaw does not affect
the fundamental rights it would be contrary to this principle to
determine whether that law in fact has legislative competence or
not
c
D
E
Gajendragadkar J., as he then was in Khyarbari Tea Co. Ltd.,
& Anr. v. State of Assam ('), while dealing with a challenge to
the validity of Section 24 of the Assam Taxation on Goods Act
1961 said at page 1009 :
"There may be some force in this contention, but we
do not see how the petitioners can be permitted to challenge the validity of Section 24 when it is not alleged by
them that any action is proposed to be taken against them
under the said Section. In dealing with the petition
under Article 32 this Court would naturally confine the
petitioners to the provisions of the impugned Act by which
their fundamental rights are either affected or threatened.
That is why we are not satisfied that it is necessary to
decide the question about the validity of Section 24 in the
present proceedings".
In Saghir Ahmad v. State of U. P. (~ it was held that when
the enactment on the face of it is found to violate the fundamenF
tal rights guaranteed under Article 19(1) (g) of the Constitution it
must be held to be invalid unless those who support the legislation
' can bring it within the purview of the exception laid down in
clause 6 of the Article but if the Respondents did not place any
materials before the Court to establish that the legislation comes
within the permissible limits of clause 6, it is surely not for the
Appellants to prove negatively that the legislation was not reasonG
able and was not conducive to tho welfare of the community.
There are other such instances where this Court has drawn an
initial presumption of constitutionality when a statute was impugned as being unconstitutional.
H
This being the legal position in our view when once an impunged Jaw does not affect the fundamental rights of the petitioners
(I} (1964] S S.C.R. 97S.
(2) ll9SS] s.c.R. 707 & 726.
D. A. v. COLLEGE v. PUNJAB (,lagan mohan Reddy,J.)
as in this case we have founded it to be so, it is not necessary to
go into the question of legislative competence or to decide on the
validity of Section 5.
We have therefore no hesitation in holding that the notifica·
tion under which the Colleges have been affiliated to the Universi·
ties is legally valid and from the date specified therein Petitioners
Colleges cease to be affiliated to the Punjab University. In the
result these petitions are allowed to the extent that clause 2(1) (a)
and Clause 17 of Chapter V of the statutes are struck down as
affecting the fundamental rights of the petitioners, but in the cir·
cumstances without costs.
K.B.N.
Petitions partly allowed.
715
A
B
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org