D. N. CHANCHALA versus STATE OF MYSORE AND ORS. ETC.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 3 May 1971 | [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 608 | 1971 INSC 138
Key facts
- Decided
- 3 May 1971
- Bench
- J.M. SHELAT*, VISHISHTHA BHARGAVA*, I.D. DUA
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 618/1970
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 608
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 138
Text of the judgment
608
A
D. N. CHANCHALA
v.
STATE OF MYSORE AND ORS. ETC.
(with co1U1ected petitions)
B
May 3, 1971
[J. M. SHELAT, I. D. DUA AND V. BHARGAVA, JJ.]
c
D
E
F
G
H
Mysore Medical Colleges (Selection fbr Admission) Rules 1970- -Scope
of Government's rule making power-Rules in University Acts laying down
qualifications for admission do not deprive Government of power to rt·
gulate admission to i'ts own medical colleges affiliated to the UniversitiesUniversity-wise distribution of seats under r. 9(1) not violative of .A.rt. 14
of Constitution-Setting apart of certain number of seats under r. 4 and reservation of seats under r. 5 whether excessive-Whether violative of Art.
15(4) of Constitution-Requirement of 10 years residence in state under r.
3-Jntermittent residence does not satisfy rule-Classification of children
of political sufferers under r. 4(h) whether a reasonable classification1·erm 'political sufferer' whether. vague.
Constitution of India 1950-Rule 9(1) of Mysore Medical Colleges
(Selection for Admission) Rules 1970 whether violates Art. 14-Rules 4 tind
5 whether make excessive reservation-Whether Violative of Art. 15(4)Rule 4(h) making reservation in favour of children of 'political suf}ereri
whether discriminatory.
The Government of Mysore State conducts four medical colleges tv.•o
of which are affiliated to the Universities of Mysore and Bangalore, the
other two being affiliated to Karnatak University. C passed her pro-university course examination from Bangalore University with 67 % marks in
optional subjects, namely Physics, Chemistry and Biology. She then passed
the B.Sc. Part I examination of Karnatak University, Under the Ordinances of the Karnatak University, she was entitled to be admitted to the
M.B.B.S. course of Karnatak University. However the Selection Committee
formed under the Mysore Medical Colleges (Selection for Admission) Rules
1970 did not select her for admission to that course because of Rule 9 of
the said Rules under which preference for admission to a medical college
run by a University was given to students who had passed the P.U.C.
Examination of the same University and only 20% of the seats were avail·
able to those passing the P.U.C. Examination of other Universities. C
filed a writ petition under Art. 32 of the Constitution on the following
contentions: (1) that once the petitioner was eligible for admission to a
medical college affiliated to the Karnatak University according to the Ordinances of that University, the State Government could not make rules, the
effect of which was to deprive her of admission; (2) that the university-wise
distribution of seats provided under r. 9(1) was discriminatory and being
without any rational basis violated Art. 14 of the Constitution; (3) that
the reservation of seats under rr. 4 & 5 for the various categories of per·
sons set out therein was far more excessive than permitted by the decisions
of this Court and was in violation of Art. 15(4).
V passed her P.U.C. examination from a government college affiliated
to Venkateshwar University in Andbra Pradesh with Physics, Chemistry
and Biology as her optional subjects, securing in those subjects 150 out of
200 marks i.e. 75')(,. On July 1970 she made an application for selection
D. N. CHANOHALA v. MYSORE (She/at J.)
609
to a seat in in any one of the medical colleges affiliated to Karnatak UniA
versity. The Selection Committee did not include her in the list o~ selected candidates arid the reason given was that she was not a resident of the
State of Mysore for not less than 10 years at any time prior to the date of
the application for a seat as required by r. 3 of the Mysore Medical Colleges (Selection for Admission) Rules 1970. In this connection the petitioner filed a certificate from the Tahsildar, Bellary that she had resided
in the State of Mysore for a period of 10 years before her applicatiod. 1 B
It was further stated on her behalf that though she had left the State of
Mysore on the transfer of her father to Andhra Pradesh before she was
ten years old, she had continued to come and reside at her family house
in the State of Mysore during her vacations.
•
J. challenged the validity of r. 4(h) of the aforesaid Rules on the
ground that the reservation for children of 'political sufferers' made therein
was not valid under the constitution.
c
Held: (i) So long as the rules for selection applicable to the medical
colleges run by Government do not suffer from any constitutional or legal
infirmity, they cannot be challenged as the Government can regulate admission to its own institutions. The objection that it cannot by such rules,
provide for requirements over and above those laid down by the univer·
sities for eligibility, cannot be sustained. [617D·E]
(ii) Since the universities are set up for satisfying the educational needs
of different areas where they are set up and medical colleges are establish·
ed in those areas, it can safely be presumed that they also were so set up
to satisfy the needs for medical training of those attached to those universj ..
ties. There is nothing undesirable in ensuring as has been done under r. 9
(I) that those attached to such universities have their ambitions to have
training in specialised subjects like medicine satisfied through colle11es attached to their own universities. Such a basis for selection bas not the
disadvantage of districtwise or unitwise selection as any student from
any part of the state can pass the qualifying examination in any of the
three universities irrespective of his place of birth or residence. Further
the rules confer a discretion on the selection committee to admit outsiders
upto 20o/o of the total available seats in any one of these colleges i.e. those
who have passed the equivalent examination held by any other university
not only in the state but also elsewhere in India. It was therefore impossible to say that the basis of selection adopted in those rules would defeat
the object of the rules as was said in Rajendran's case. [619E·620C]
The rules lay down a valid classification. Candidates passing through
the qualifying examination held by a university form a class by themselves
as distinguished from those passing through such examination from the
other two universities. Such a classification has a reasonable nexus with
the object of the rules, namely, to cater to the needs of candidates who
would naturally look to their own university to advance their training in
technical studies, such as medical studies. The rules therefore cannot
justly be attached on the ground of hostile discrimination or as being other.
wise in breach of Art. 14. [620G-621A]
(iii) Setting apart' ~O seats ~der r. 4 is ~ot a r~:vation but laying
down sources for selection necess1ated by cer.ta1n ovcrrldmg considerations
such as obligations towards those who serve the interest of the country';
security, certain reciprocal obligations and the like. The reservation under
r. S though apparently appearing on the high side, not having been shown
as unreasonably excessive the contention in regard to it must fail. [622BJ
39-1 S.C. India/71
D
E
F
G
H
~.10
StJPRBMB COURT llEPOllTS
(1971] SUPP. S.C.Jl,
(iv) The residence contemplated by r. 3 must prima facie have an el•·
ment of continuity or regularity in residence and would not mean an
intermittent stay such as during the vacations. It would thus appear that
B
V did not, withstanding the certificate of residence issued by the Tehsildar,
comply with the requirement of 10 years residence under r. 3. However
the percentage of 7'5 % marks claimed by the petitioner was only in respect
of optional subjects. Her aggregate marks were only' 65 % as compared
to 65 ·6% obtained by the student last selected and on the basis of this
percentage her application was rightly rejected. It was therefore not neces·
sary to go into the facts relating to the petitioner's residence in Mysore
State or the validity of r. 3. [624B·F, G:·Hl
(v) Per Shela! & Bhargava, JJ. (Dua 1. dissenting)
The definition of 'political sufferer' in r. 4(h) is in clear and unambi·
guous language, besides containing sufficient details so as to distinctively
identify the persons who would fall within it. The person must have suf·
fered incarceration, whether as imprisonment or detention, for a period
of at least six months or been awarded capital punishment, or must have
died while actually in detention or undergoing imprisonment, or killed or
incapacitated permanently by firing or lathi charge by the police or by
D
the military, or must have lost employment, property, or means of livelihood. These should have been the consequences of his having participated in the national movement for the emancipation of India. There Was
thus no ambiguity in the definition of politi.·al sufferer which would result
in discrimination in administering the rule. [626F·H]
It is not unreasonable to extend the principle on which Art. 15 (4)
is based to the children of political sufferers who in consequence of their
participation in the emancipation struggle became unsettled in life, in some
cases economically ruined, and were therefore not in a position to make
E
F
G
available to their children that class of education which would place them
in fair competition with the children of those who did not suffer from thnt
disadvantage. If that be so, it must follow that the definition of 'political
sufferer' not only makes the children of such sufferers distinauishablo from
the rest but such classification has a reasonable nexus with the object of
the rules which can be nothing else than a fair and just distribution of seats.
[629G·630C]
Per Dua, 1. The object of selection for admission to the medical col·
leges, considered in the light of the directive principles of State policy
contained in our Constitution appears to be to select the best material
from amongst the candidates in order not only to provide them with ade.
quate means of livelihood, but also to provide the much needed medical
aid to the pleop!e and to improve public health generally. It cannot be con·
fidently said that there is a reasonable nexus between the differentia on
which the children of political sufferers are classified as a distinct group
and tho object of admission to the Medical Colleges. In view however of
the admitted fact that the marks obtained by J were lower than the marks
secured by the last candidate admitted from the category of the children
of political sufferers, the petitioner was not entitled to claim admission,
even if the children of political sufferers were not given any priority. On
this ground alone the petition of J deserved to be dismissed. Accordingly
it was unnecessary to go into the question of the invalidity of r. 4(h) in
H
this case. [632F·HJ
In view of the above findings the writ petitions must be dismissed.
Rajendran v. Madras, [1968] 2 S.C.R. 786, Periakaruppan v. Tamil
Nadu, W.P. 285 and 314 of 1970, decided on Sept. 23, 1970 and Balaj/ v.
Mysore, [1963] Supp. 1 S.C.R. 439, distinltlished.
D. N. CHANCHALA •• 'MYSOl\ll (Shelat,J.)
Andhra Pradesh v. Lavu Narendranath, C.As. 2161-A and 2161B of
1970, decided on Feb. II, 1971 and Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India, [1970)
1 $.C.R. 413, applied.
Surendrakumar v. State, A.I.R. 1969 Raj. 182, Umesh Chandra v. V.
N. Singh, [1967) 1.LR. 46 Pal 616, Kerala v. Jacob, A.l.R. 1964 Ker. 316,
Ramchandra v. State, Al.R. 1961 M.P. 247, Subhashini v. State, A.I.R.
1966 Mys. 40 and Anil Kumar v. Mysore, (1969) 17 L.R. (Mysore) 110, refer-
~~
611
A
B
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Writ Petitions Nos. 618 to 622 of
1970.
Petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution of India for the
enforcement of fundamental rights.
Lakshmlnarasu, Vineet Kumar and Bindra Thakur, for the
petitioners (in W. P. Nos. 618 and 620 to 622 of 1970).
S. K. Venkataranga, Shyamala Pappu, Vineet Kumar and
Bindra Thakur, for the petitioner (in W. P. No. 619 of 1970).
Niren De, Attorney-General, R. C. Mahindra and S. P. Nayar,
for respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (in W. P. Nos. 618 and 620 to 622
of 1970).
C
D
Sunder Swami, Advocate-General, Mysore and S. P. Nayar
for respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (in W. P. No. 619 of 1970).
R. B. Datar, for intervener (in W. P. No. 621 of 1970).
The Judgment of J. M. SHELAT and v. BHARGAVA, JJ. was
delivered by SHELAT, J. I. D. DUA, J. gave a partly dissenting Opinion.
Shelat, J'.-These five petitions have been filed by candidates
who failed to be selected for admission in Government Medical
colleges in the State of Mysore and challenge the validity of the
Selection Rules framed by the Government. Since they raise
common questions, it is expedient to deal with them together and
dispose them of by a common judgment. Writ petition No. 619
of 1970, we were told by counsel, is the most comprehensive of
them all and therefore we shall deal with 1t first and as typical
of the rest. As the rest of the petitions raise the same questions,
it is not necessary to deal with each of them separately. Writ
petitions Nos. 621 and 622, however, raise certain additional
questions which will be dealt with to that extent separately.
E
F
G
Writ Petition Ne. 619 of 1970
The petitioner in. thiB Writ Petition passed the Secondary
School Leaving exruninati9n in March 1968 obtaining first class
marks. In March 1969, she passed the Pre-University Course
'·
H
612
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPRl!ME COURT REPORTS.
(1971 SUPP. s.c.R.
Exami~tion _held by ~he Bangalore U~versity s~curing 67 %
marks m optional sub1ects, namely, Physics, CheIDistry and Biology, and 71 % marks in the aggregate. Her father having retired
at Dharwar, she prosecuted her further studies for B.Sc. Part I
examinailion in the Karnatak Science College, Dharwar, a college
afliliated to the Karnatak University. She passed the B.Sc. Part I
examination held by that University securing once again :i first
class.
Under Ordinance 144(c) of the Karnatak University, a student having passed the B.Sc. Part I examination with Physics,
Chemistry and Biology as his optional subjects would be a eligible for admission to a medical course provided he has obtained
the minimum marks prescribed for admission to that course from
time to time. The petitioner having obtained first class marks
in the B.Sc. Part I examination was, therefore, eligible for admission to the medical course in the medical colleges affiliated to that
University.
There are three universities in Mysore State, namely, Karnatak, Mysore and Bangalore universities. All the three universities hold pre-university course examination, the passing of which
makes a student eligible for admission to courses leading to university degrees. But, whereas the Karnatak Oniversity requires
the passing of B.Sc. Part I examination leading to M.B.B.S. as
the minimum qualification for being eligible for medical course,
the other two universities require the passing of what is c.illed
the Pre-Professional examination, which is equivalent to B.Sc.
Part I leading to M.B.B.S. degree of the Karnatak University.
The State of Mysore conduots four medical colleges ; the
Government Medical College at Mysore, which is affiliated to the
Mysore University, the Government Medical College at Ilangalore,
which is afliliated to the Bangalore University, and the Karnatak
Medical College at Hubli and the Government Medical College
at Bellary, whkh are afliliated to the Karnatak University. All
the four medical colleges together have 765 seats in the aggregate.
Besides these four institutions, there are also private managed
medical colleges at Manipal, Davangere, Belgaum and Gulbarga
with 120 seats in each of them, admission upto 10% therein being
under the control of the Government.
The State Government has framed rules. called the Mysore
Medical Colleges (Selection for AJmissionJ Rules, 1970 regulating admission to Government medical colleges and for a certain
number of seats specified therein in each of the said private medical colleges. Under these rules, the selection for admission to
the Government medical colleges as also for the seats under the
control of the Government iin other colleges is entrusted to a
selection committee constituted by the Government.
D. N. CHANCHALA v. MYSORE (She/at, J.)
613
In- accordance with the said ruloo, the petitioner applied to
the selection committee for admission to any one of the medical
colleges affiliated to the Karnatak University. She was, however,
not selected.· For appreciating the reasons why the committee
could not select her, one has first to examine the said rules framed
by the Government.
A
These rules are annexure '3' to the writ petition. Under
r. 1(2), these rules are to apply for selection for admission to the
Pre-Professional/B.Sc. Part I Course leading to M.B.B.S. in the
said Government medical colleges and to 59 seats in the aggregate in the four private medical colleges mentioned therein. The
expression "the Pre-Professional/B.Sc. Part 1 Course leading to
M.B.B.S." has been used in sub-r. (2) of r. 1 to mean Pre-Professional course in Bangalore and Mysore universities, and B.Sc.
Part I course leading to M.B.B.S. in the Karnatak University.
The scheme under the rules Is that on passing the Pre-University
Course examination a pupil becomes eligible to apply for admission to the Pre-Professional Course in Bangalore and Mysore
universities and to the B.Sc. Part I Course leading to M:B.B.S. in
the Karnatak University, the common qualification for eligibility
to both the said courses in the three universities being the passing
of the P.U.C. examination. Rule 2 prescribes the qualification
for eligibility. Under this rule the candidate must. have passed
the P.U.C. examination or the XI standard of the Higher Secondary Schools examination of any university established by law
in India or of any institution recognized by the State Government,
or an equivalent examination with (i) Physics, Chemisl!y and
Biology, or (ii) Chemistry, Botany and Zoology as optional subjects, or, as provided by cl. (b), who is a graduate of any univer-·
sity with (i) Physics, Chemistry and Biology, or (ii) Chemistry,
Botany and Zoology as optional subjects. Such a candidate must
have obtained specified percentage of marks and must be within
the age limit prescribed by the three universities. Under rule 2,
therefore, there are two categories of candidates who only are
eligible for selection; (I) those who have passed the P.U.C. exam;nation or an equivalent examination, and (2) those who are
graduates, having graduated with the optional subjects specified
therein. The petitioner, not being a graduate, fell under the first
category of candidates eligible for selection.
B
Rule 2(2) provides that out of the available number of seats,
after deducting the number of seats set apan under r. 4, 80% of
the seats shall be open for those who have passed the P.U.C. examination and 20% for those who are graduates. Rule 4·sets apart
in all 60 seats for different categories of persons, namely, students
from Union territories and States where .there are no medical
colleges, students from relatively less developed Commonwealth
countries, cultural scholars and students under T.C.S. of the
c
D
E
F
G
H
814
B
D
G
•
SUPREMI COVRT REPORTS
(1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
Colombo Plan and spec\aJ Commonwea11A Assistance Plan, students from Nepal, repatriates from Burma, Ceylon, Mozambiquo
cbildcen of Defence Personnel and Ex-Defence Personnel, 1;tu:
?ents w~o have ~as.sed L.AM.S. and. L.U.M.S., lady students takmg family planmng programme, children of political sufferers.
and lastly. students from Goa. Rule 5 provides that out of the
number of ~ts available for allotment, after deducting the number of seats set apart under r. 4, 15 % shall be reserved for persons
belonging to the Scheduled Castes, 3 % shall be reserved for persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes and 30 % shall be reserved
for persons belonging to socially and educationally backward
classes. Rule 7(1) provides for the constitution of the Selection
Committee, and a. (2) thereof entrusts oo the Commiittee the duty
to select candidates possessing the requisite qualification for admission to the said Pre-Professional I B.Sc. Part I Course leading
to M.B.B.S. Rules 9 deals with distribution of seats among the
several colleges. a. (!) thereof provides .that seats in the general
pool shall be distributed university-wise, that is, seats in colleges
alliliated to the Karnatak University shall be allotted to" persons
passing from colleges alliliated to that university. and seats in
colleges alliliated to Bangalore and Mysore Universities shall respectively be allotted to persons passmg from colleges alliliated
to each such university, provided that not more than 20% of the
seats in the colleges alliliated to any university may, in the discretion of the Selection Committee, be allotted to students passing
from colleges alliliated to any Other university in the State or elsewhere in India. The rest of the rules do not affect the petitioner's
case, and therefore, need not be cited.
Brietly, the effect of these rules is that the qualification for
selection to the Pre-Professional Course, as it is known in Mysore
and Bangalore universities, or B.Sc. Part I Course leading to
M.B.B.S. in the Karnatak University, is that the candidate has
either passed the P.U.C. examination, or is a graduate having had
the aforesaid optional subjects. The selection is to be made by
the seleotion committA:e under r. 7(2) for admission to the Pre.
Professional I B.Sc. Part I leading to M.B.B.S. A student getting
admission to tlie aforesaid course has thus to pass the Pre-Professional examination held by the Mysore and Bangalore uni¥ersities,
or B.Sc. Part I leading to M.B.B.S. examination held by the Karnatak University. It is only after passing this examinarkm that
a candidate can prosecute .the regular M.B.B.S. course. . The
common qualification for being selected for the Pro-Professional
or B.Sc. Part I leading to M.B.B.S. degree being the pasaing of
die P.U.C. munina11on or ct l!eing a: gradulto, pallllin& of B.SC.
:f'att I examination by a mden• is ilrelBYaDt. • the mmb coan..,
ed for scleclioD ~ dlclBc oblained bf biin cidm" in P..lJ.C. aam.
1'111tion or Ill& D.S.. aaiam.-. JIB aJrWy stated. r. 2~2> . .
o. N. CHANCHALA Y. KYSOllE (She/at, J.)
615
apart upto 20% of the seats for those who are graduates, i.e..
those who have obtained B.Sc. degree. A student passing the ·
P.U.C. examination or an examination equivalent to that examination can branch off either to (I) Pre-Professional /B.Sc. Part I
leading to M.B.B.S .• or (2) B.Sc. degree course. Under the rules
no direct admission to M.B.B.S. course is possible because every
student wishing to take up that course has first to be selected for
B
the Pre-Professional/B.Sc. Part I leading to M.B.B.S. course and
pass the requisite examination in that course.
Though, for the purposes of selection. marks .obtained at the
P.U.C. examination or at the B.Sc. examination only are taken
into account and the passing of the B.Sc. Part I examination is
for that purpose not relevant, there appears to be one advantage
to a candidate who has passed B.Sc. Part I examination with the
prescribed optional subjects held by the Karnatak University.
That advantage. as appearing from the additional affidavit filed
by the petitioner's father and the correspondence between him
and the University authorities, is that such a candidate, if selected,
would be directly admitted to the M.B.B.S. degree course in the
medical colleges alliliated to the Karnatak University. It is not
necessary to say anything about what happens in the other universities since we are for the present not concerned with such
question.
c.
D
a
The second effect of these rules is that if a student has passed
the P.U.C. examination held by a particular university, such a
student is, by virtue of r. 9(1), eligible for admission in the medical college or colleges alliliated to that university. The Selection
Committee, however, has the discretion to allot seats, upto 20%
of the seats in the colleges affiliated to a university, to students
passing from colleges afliliated ~o any other university in the
State or even elsewhere in India.
Consequently, the petitioner having passed her P.U.C. examination from Bangalore University could apply for admission
in a medical college affiliated to that university. If she were to
apply for admisSion in a medical college afliliated to the Karnatak
University she could ooly be selected ti> a seat from among seats
upto the maximum of 20% of seats left in the discretion of the
Selection C.Ollllllltee as provided by r. 9(1). It is true that she
had got 67% "marks iD optiaaal lllhjects in the P.U.C. e.~amina
tion and students with. 1C$Cl' number of marks. but passing from
colleges affiliated w the Karnatak UnWeTsity. got admission. But
that was because silo had passed the P.U.C. =ination held by
the Bangalore University and wanted admission in a medical
E
F
G
H
6J6
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPOR'lll
. [1971) SUPP. s.c.R.
college affiliated to another university, namely, the Karnatak
University.
In view of this consequence, counsel for the petitioner made
three submissions : (!) that once the petitioner was eligible for
admission to a medical college affiliated to the Karnatak University according to the Ordinances of that university, the State Government could not make rules, the effect of which was to deprive
her of admission (2) that the university-wise distribution of seats
provided under r. 9(1) was discriminatory and being without any
rational basis violated Art. 14 of the Constitution; and (3) that
the reservation of seats under rr. 4 and 5 for the various categories of persons set out therein was far more excessive than permitted by the decisions of this Court and was in violation of
Art. 15(4). Consequently, rr. 4 and 5 laying down such reservation should be held invalid.
We propose to deal with these submissions in the order in
which they were placed before us by counsel. As seen earlier,
there are two sets of provisions dealing with the teaching of medical courses. The first consists of Ordinances of the universities,
and the second consists of the rules framed by the Government
for selection of candidates for admission to the Pre-Professional I
B.Sc. Part I leading to M.B.B.S. degree. The Ordinances framed
by the three universities are made under the different U nivers'ities
Acts setting up those universities and under the powers reserved
to them under them. These Ordinances are made for the purposes set out in tb1se Acts and for carrying out those purposes.
One of such purposes would be the maintenance of certain academic standards in the various faculties taught in the college affiliated to the universities. For the purposes of maintaining such
standards the universities lay down certain minimum qualifications for eligibility for entrance in those faculties. These Ordinances and regulations made under the Acts lay down the minimum qualifications required for eligibility and are not to be confused with rules for admission. A candidate may have the minimum qualification so as to make him eligible for entrance in a
particular faculty. That does not mean that his being eligible
necessarily makes him entitled to admission in that faculty, for,
admission can only be commensurate with the number of available seats in such a faculty.
The medical colleges in question are not university colleges
but have been set up and are being maintained by the State Government from out of public funds. Since they are affiliated to
one or the other of the three unlversitie~. the Government cannot
frame rules or act inconsistently with the ordinances or the regulations of the universities laying down standards of eligibility.
It is nobody's case that the Government has made rules which are
D. N. CHANCHALA v. MYSORB (She/at, J.)
in any way Inconsistent with the rules for eligibility laid down in
such ordinances and regulations.
Since the Government has set up these colleges and maintains them, it has prima facie the power to regulate admission
in its own institutions. Counsel for the petitioner pointed out to
us no provision from the University Acts which deprives the Government of the power of making rules for admission in its own
colleges. That being so, it cannot be said that the Government
has no power to regulate admission in its own colleges or that
because a student is eligible for admission under the Vniversity
ordinances, he automatically gets a right to admission which he
can enforce in a court of law.
The rules are limited to admission to the Pre-Professional/
B.Sc. Part I Course leading to M.B.B.S. degree in the Government
medical colleges and in respect of 59 seats in the aggregate In
the medical colleges run by private management. The control for
admission in respect of the 59 seats in the private colleges must
have been acquired by the Government with the consent of or
under some agreement with those colleges by reason of their
getting financial and other aid from the Government. So long as
the rules for selection applicable to the colleges run by the Government do not suffer from any constitutional or legal infirmity,
they cannot be challenged as the Government can regulate admission to its own institutions. The objection that it cannot, by
such rules, 'provide for requirements over and above those laid
down by the universities for eligibility cannot be sustained. (See
A ndhra Pradesh v. Lavu Narendranath (') wherein the earlier
decisions on this subject have been examined and followed.)
The next contention was that r. 9(1), which prescribes university-wise .distribution of seats results in discrimination for it
lays down a classification which Is neither based on any intelligible differentia, nor has a. rational nexus with the object of the
rules. The argument was that although there is one selection
committee for all the Government medical colleges in all the
three universities and for the said 59 seats in private colleges,
students passing from colleges affiliated to a particular university
are first admitted in Government medical colleges afliliated to that
university and only seats upto 20% in each of such medical col1eges can be allotted to outSiders in the iliscretion of the committee.. The result is that a student having higher marks than
the last admitted student is deprived of a seat only for the reason
that he had passed his P.U.C. examination from a college afliliated
to another university. According to counsel, such a classifica·tion has no rational basis and has no reasonable nexus with and
(I} C. As. 2161-A and 2161-B of 1970, dee. on Feb. 11, 1971.
617
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
618
Sl.!1RDIS COVRT REPORTS
(1971] Sl.!1P. S.C.R:.
is in fact inconsistent with the very object of establishment of
Government medical colleges, namely, to train in medicine the.
most meritorio~ aJ!longst the candidates seeking admission.
B
c
D
E
'
G
B
In support of this contention counsel relied on Rajendran v..
Madras (') where rule 8 of the selection rules framed by theMadras Government was struck down on the ground of its being;
violative of Art. 14. Rule 8 provided that the seats available in
the general pool, as also those reserved for the socially and edu·
cationally backward classes would be allotted amongst various
districts on the basis of the ratio of the population of each district to the total population of the State. The contention was
that distribution of seats districtwise would result in denial of
better candidates from being selected and candidates of inferior
' calibre getting selected only because they were born in that district where there were fewer candidates of good calibre. In d~
fence of such a classificaltion, two reasons were urged : (!) that if
districtwise classification was not provided, candidates from Madras city would get a larger number of seats in proportion to the
population of the State, elbowing out candidates from the districts,
and (2) if selection was made districtwise, those selected from a
district were likely to settle down as practitioners in that district,
so that the districts were likely to benefit from their training.
It was conceded that Art. 14 permitted classification. But this
Court rejected the justification for the aforesaid classification
urged by the State on the ground that the first meant that candi·
dates from the districts, admitted to be of inferior calibre than
candidates from Madras city, would stand a better chance of
selection, a result defeating the very object of selection, namdy.
to get the best candidates, and the second on the ground that it
was neither pleaded in the counter-affidavit of the State, nor had
the State placed any facts or figures justifying the plea that stu·
dP.nts selected districtwise would settle down as medical practi·
tioners in the respective districts where they resided. In Periakaruppan v. Tamil Nadu ('), a rule which provided for distribution of seats unitwise and which set up different selection committees for each unit was held to be bad on the ground that it
did not d'iffer much from the districtwise distribution st<uck down
in Rajendran's case ('). Whereas formerly the distribution was
districtwise, the system under attack established six units where
medical colleges were situate, namely, Madras city, Madurai,
Chingleput, Coimbatore, Thanjavur and Tirunelveli. Though in
theory the candidates had the liberty to apply for any 9ne or more
of those units, they were advised to apply to the unit nearest to
their residence and were also informed that even if they were to
(I) [1968] 2 S.C.R. 786.
(2) W. Ps. 2U &: 314 of 1970, dee. om Sept. 23, 1970.
D. N. CHANCJ!ALA v. MYSORE (She/at, J.)
·•
apply to other units, their applications would be forwarded to the
selection committee of that unit which was nearest to their residence. The consequence of the unit system was clearly to con. fine the candidates to the unit nearest to their residence.
It will be easily seen that the. university-wise distribution of
seats in the Government medical colleges has nothing in common
~with the districtwise or unitwise selection struck down in Rajen·
dran's case n and Periakaruppan's case ('). In both the cases
what was mainly objected to was that the selection would have
to be made on the basis either of the place of birth or residence
and the candidate was confined to the medical college at or near·
est to such a place. Such a basis for selection was held to have
no reasonable nexus with the object of the rules, namely, to
select the most meritorious amongst the candidates to have the
advantage of such education. In Periakaruppan's case (') there was
a further infirmity, in that, there were several committees for
selection resulting in varying standards, thus defeating the very
object of screening the candidates with a view to give chance to
t1J,e best of them. Both these decisions are distinguishable as the
basis on which the selection of candidates is sought to be made
under the present rules is quite different in that it is neither dis·
trictwise nor unitwise, but is university-wise. Therefore, the i.nfirmatics found in the selection rules in those two cases and for
which they were struck down cannot be relevant in any scrutiny
of the present rules, much less can they be relied upon for an
attack on them.
The three universities were set up In three different places
presumably for the purpose of catering to the educational and
academic needs of those areas. Obviously one university for the
whole of the State could neither have been adequate nor feaseable to satisfy those needs. Since it would not be possible to
admit all candiQlltes In the medical colleges run by the Government, some basis for screening the· candidates had to be set up.
There can be no manner of doubt, and it is now fairly well settled,
that the Government. as also other private agencies, who found
such centres for medical training, have the right to frame rules
for admission so long as those rules are not Inconsistent with the
university statutes and regulations and do not suffer from lnfirmi·
ties. constitutional or otherwise. Since the universities are set
up for satisfying-the educational needs of different areas where
they are set up and medical colleges are established in those ar~as.
it can safely be presumed that they also were so set up to sa~sfy
the needs for medical training of those attached to those umversities. In our view. th~ is nothing undesirable in ensuring that
those attached to such universities have their ambitions to have
ctJ [196812 s.c.R. 1s6.
(2) W. Ps. 285 & 314of1970, dee. on Sept. 23, 1970.
619
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
620
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] SUPP. S.C.R.
A . training in specialised subjects, like medicine, satisfied through
colleges affiliated to their own universities. Such a basis for
selection has not the disadvantage of districtwise or umtw1se
selection as any student from any part of the state can pass the
qualifying examination in any of the three universities irrespective of the place of his birth or residence. Further, the rules con·
fer a discretion on the selection committee to admit outsiders
B
upto 20 % o.f the total available seats in any one of these colleges,
i.e., those who have passed the equivalent examination held by
any other university not only in the State but also elsewhere in
India. It is, therefore, impossible to say that the basis of selec·
tion adopted in these rules would defeat the object of the rules
as was said in Rajendran's case (') or make possible less meric torious students obtaining aclmission at the cost of the better
candidates. The fact that a candidate having lesser marks might
obtain admission at the cost of another having higher marks
from another university does not necessarily mean that a less
meritorious candidate gets advantage over a more meritorious
one. As is well known, different universities have different stanD
dards in the examinations held by them. A preference to one
attached to one university in its own institutions for post-graduate
or technical training is not uncommon. Rules giving such a pre·
ference are to be found in various universities. Such a system for
that reason alone is not to be condemned as discriminatory, particularly when admission to such a university by passing a qualify·
E ing examination held by it is not precluded by any restrictive qualifications, sucb as birth or residence, or any other similar restric·
tions. In our view, it is not possible to equate the present basis
for selection with these which were held invalid in the aforesaid
two decisions. Further, the Government which bears the finan·
cial burden of running the Government colleges is entitled to lay
down criteria for admission in its own colleges and to decide the
F
sources from which admission would be made, provided of course,
such classification is not arbitrary and has a rational basis and a
reasonable connection with the object of the rules. So long as
there is no discrimination within each of such sources, the vali·
dity of the rul~s laying down such sources cannot be successfully
challenged. (See Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India (')). In our
view, the rules lay down a valid classification. Candidates passG
ing through the qualifying examination held by a university form
a class by themselves as distinguished from those plSsing through
such examination from the other two universities. Such a classi·
fication has a reasonable nexus with the object of the rules,
namely, to cater to the needs of candidates who would naturally
look to their own university to advance their training in technical
H
(I) [1968) 2 S.C.R. 786.
(2) [1970) I S.C.R. 413, at 418,
o. N. CHANCHALA v. MYSORE (She/at, J.)
621
studies, such as medical studies. In our opinion, the rules cannot A
justly be attacked on the ground of hostile discrimination or as
being otherwise in breach of Art. 14.
The last ·cballenge to the vafidity of these rules was based
on the allegation that they lay down excessive reservation for
certain categories of candida·tes. As already stated, under els. (a)
to (i) of r. 4, sixty, out of the present aggregate of 765 seats at the
B
disposal of the Government, are set apan for Uie various categories of persons therein mentioned. As aforesaid, the Government is entitled to lay down sources from which selection for ad·
mission would be made. A provision laying down such sources
is strictly speaking not a reservation. It is not a reservation as
understood by Art. IS against which objection can be taken on c
the ground that It is excessive. The reservation, as contemplated
by Art. IS, is the one which is made under r. S. Under that rule,
15 % reservation is for persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes,
3 % for Scheduled Tribes and 30 % for socially and educationally
backward cl3sses, that is to say, 48 % in all against 690 available
seats after deducting 60 seats set apart under r. 4. But, setting
apart IS seats under r. 4(g) for candidates who take up family D.
planning programme does not constitute a reservation as any one
of the lady candidates can take up that programme. Therefore,
the seats available for distribution would be 720, 48 % of which
are reserved under r. 5. The question is whether such a reservation is unreasonably ellCCSSive.
It was not disputed· that under Art. !S(4) the State was en· E
titled to make special provisions for the advancement of socially
and educationally backward classes. It has to be remembered
that the object of Art. 15(4) is to advance the interests of the
society as a whole by looking after the interests of its weaker sections. But as stated in Balaji v. Mysore ("), while making such
a provision the rights and Interests of the rest of the society are F
not to be absolutely ignored. Consideration for the rest of the
society and those who are its weaker elements have both to be
kept in mind and taking the prevailing circumstances as a whole
have to be adjusted. The impugned provision in Balaji's case (')
made reservation .of 68 % of the seats for the socially and educationally backward classes in medical and engineering colleges.
Such a high percentage was held to amount almost to an exclu· G
sion of the deserving and qualified candidates from other com·
munities, which also was not in the interests of the society as a
whole. The Coun tlicre observed that in adjusting the claim of
both the weaker and the stronger elements the reservation for the
former should ordinarily be Jess than SO%, although no inflexible
percentage could be fixed and the actual reservation must depend · H
upon the relevant prevailing circumstances in each case. In
(I) [1~31 Supp. I s.c.R. 439.
SU
StJPllBllll COUil T llBPOllTS
[1971] stJPP. s.c.a.
Periakaruppan's case (1) 41 % reservation for the Soeially and
cducaponally backward classes was held not to be excessive. No
materials have been placed before us which would show that in
the circumstances prevailing in Mysore State reservation made
under r. 5 is tlllm:isonably excessive. Setting apart 60 seats under
r. 4 is, as already stated, not a reservation but laying down sources
for selection necessitated by certain overriding considerations, such
B
as obligations towards those who serve the interests of the country's security, certain reciprocal obligations and the like. The
reservation under r. 5, though apparently appearing on the high
side, not having been shown as unreasonably excessive, the con·
tention in regard to it must fail.
These were the only three heads under which the validity of
the rules was challenged. For the reasons set out above, none of
them can be upheld. The writ petition, therefore, fails and has
to be rejected.
Writ Petition No. 621 of 1970
The petitiOner here was born on August 2, 1954 at Bellary.
Bellary had become part of the State of Mysore on October l,
1953 in consequence of the reorganization of States. In April
1954, her father, who was till then serving as a Government ser·
vant in the State of Mysore, was transferred to Andhra Pradesh
where he continued to serve until his retirement from service on
June 11, 1970. According to para (2) of the petition, the peti·
tioner was during this period with her father at Cuddappah in
Andhra Pradesh where he was serving. In 1968-69, the peti·
tioner passed her S.S.L.C. examination at Cuddappah obtaining
·first class marks. In 1969-70, she passed her P.U.C. examination
·from a Government college affiliated to Venkateswara University
in Andhra Pradesh with Physics, Chemistry and Biology as her
optional subjects, securing in those subjects 150 out of 200 marks,
i.e., 75%.
On July 22, 1970i she made an application for selection to
a seat in any one of the medical colleges affiliated to the Karnatak
University. An interview card was issued to her which bore No.
K-20, which signified that she was a candidate for selection for
admission in a medical college affiliated to the Karnatak University. On October 6. 1970, the Selection Committee published a
list of selected candidates, but her name was not included in the
said list.
According to the petl"tion, the last student admitted to the
Bellary Medical College in the general pool of seats, (that is
from the balance of seats, after deducting from the total number
of seats seats reserved under rr. 4 and 5) had obtained less marks
in the P.U.C. examination than marks obtained by her, that is,
295 out 450 marks which would be 65.6'){,. The last student ad·
(!) 'W .P.S. 28S & 314of1970, deed. on Sep. 23, 1970.,
D. N. CllANCHALA '· lllY8liR8 (Slielat, J.)
623
milted to the Kamatak Medical College, Hubli had also obtained A
.295 out of 450 marks, i.e. 65.6%. Both these students had passed the P.U.C. examination held by the Karnatak University.
The reason for non-inclusion of the petitioner's name in the
.said llst given by the Selection Committee was that she was not
"a resident in the State of Mysore for not Jess than 10 years at
.any t'ime prior to the date of the application for a seat" as requirB
ed by r. 3 of the said Rules. Rule 3 requires that & be eligible
ior selection, a candidate must be (a) a citizen of India, (b) a per.son domiciled in the State of Mysore, and (c) a resident of the
State for at least 10 years at any time before the date of application. Rule 9(1) provides that seats other than those reserved
under r. 4 shall be distributed university-wise, i.e., seats in colleges
c
.affiliated to the Karnatak University shall be allotted to persons
passing from colleges affiliated to that university, and scats in colleges affiliated to Bangalore and Mysore universities shall respectively be allotted to persons passing from colleges affiliated to
-each such university. That rule, however, has a proviso which
lays down that not more than 20% of the seats in colleges affiliat'Cd to any university may in the discretion of the Selection Com- D
mittee be allotted to students passing from colleges affiliated to
.any other university in the State or elsewhere in India. Thus,
candidates applying for selection fall into two categories: (!)
lhose having passed the P.U.C. examination from colleges affiliated to that univer!lity to which a medical college in which admis'Sion is sought is affiliated, and (2) those having passed the P.U.C.
E
examination or an equivalent examination held b_y other univer·
'Sities in Mysore State or even elsewhere. The petitioner, therefore, belonged to the second category inasmuch as she was a
candidate who had passed her P.U.C. examination not through
a college affiliated to the Karnatak University, but one who had
passed the P.U.C. examination from a university to which none
F
of the medical colleges in Karnatak was affiliated. Therefore, the
proviso to r. 9(1) would be applicable to her and she would be
ellgible for selection only from out of the 20% of the seats at the
most left in the disoretion of the selection committee.
No question relating to r. 9, however, was raised. The case,
Jllaced before us on behalf of the petitioner, was that she was a
G
person who had a domicile in Mysore State and had resided in
the State during the peribd prescribed by r. 3 and was, therefore,
entitled to be considered along with the rest of the candidates.
Even assuming that to be so, the question is whether she satisfied
the conditions of r. 3 as regards residence.
Annexed to her application for selection, dated July 22, 1970, H
was a certificate from the Tehsildar, Bellary, certifying that she
had not only her domici'le in Mysore State but that she had also
TeSided in the State for a period of 10 years prior to the date of
624
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPRllMB COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
her application. In column 13 of the application, where particu·
Jars of institutions where the candidate had studied had to be
given, it was stated that the petitioner had studied in Bellary dur·
ing the years 1959 to 1963, and thereafter, from 1963-64 to 1968·
69 In different institutions in Andhra Pradesh. We will assume,
though her father was in Andhra Pradesh where he served from
1954 to June 1970, that she was kept in her infancy in Bellary,
the total period of her residence would prima facie come to little
less than 9 years, i.e., from August 2, 1954, her dMe of birth, to
1963. Therefore, the certificate obtained from the Tehsildar,
certifying that she had resided in Mysore for 10 years at any time
prior to the date of her application, would appear not to be fact·
ually correct.
This difficulty, however, was sought to be got over by the
affidavit in rejoinder filed by her father in which it was stated
that though the petitioner had beeo studying In Andhca Pradesh
after 1963, she used to come to the family house in Bellary dur·
ing her vacations, and therefore, she must be deemed to have
resided all throughout at Bellary. Such an explanation, however,
suffers from two defects : (1) that sucb a plea was made for the
first time in the affidavit in rejoinder in answer to the counter·
affidavit filed by the respondents, and (2) that reSidence as con·
templated by r. 3 must prima facie have an element of continuity
or regularity in residence and would not mean an intermittent
stay such as during the vacations. It would thus appear that the
petitioner did not, notwlthstand'ing the certificate of residence
issued by the Tehsildar, comp.!y with the requirement of 10 years'
residence under r. 3. However, for the reasons stated hereafter
it is not necessary to go into these questions either as regards the
facts relating to her residence In Bellary or the validity of r. 3
sought to be challenged in this petition.
It is true that the petitioner obtained in the P.U.C. examination held l.>Y Venkateswara University, 150 out of 200 marks in
optional subjects taken by her, but as her application itself shows,
the total number of marks secured by her in that examination were
389 out of 600 marks, i.e., 65 %. Even according to her, the last
student who secured selection for the Bellary Medical College had
secured 295 out of 450 marks, ~.e., 65.6%. The same percentage
of marks was also secured by the last student admitted to the
Karnatak Medical College, Hubli, both these students having
passed the P.U.C. exami~tion held by the Karnatak Universit}'..
Therefore, even irrespective of the fact whether she had qualtlied herself or not under r. 3, she could not have been selected
for either of these two colleges in Karnatak.
The argument that she had been discriminated against in
the sense that though she had secured 75 % marks she was not
D. N. CHANCHALA v. MYSORE (Shelat,J.)
selected and others, with lesser number of marks than those
secured by her were selected for madical colleges affiliated to
the Karnatak University was founded on a wrong premise. For
comparison between herself and the said two candidates she
took her marks in optional subjects only and apparently compared them with the total marks obtained by the said two students
in the whole of the P.U.C. examination. There was thus no
comparison between person equally situated even as regards
the number of marks secured by them. But apart from that,
the result obtained by a student in an examination held by one
university cannot be regarded as comparable with the result
obtained by another candidate in an examination held by another
university. Even assuming that a conscious effort is made to
equalise standards obtaining in different universities, such standards depend on several human factors, methods of teaching and
examining, the syllabus in such uniyersities etc. even though the
subjects taught and examined were to be the same. It is wellsettled that a question of discrimination can only arise in the
case of persons equally situated. That the petitioner and those
whom the Selection Committee selected were equally situated
cannot, from the facts above stated, be assumed. Consequently,
the argument that r. 3. by prescribing tbe 10 years' residence in
Mysore State as a qualification for eligibility, is arbitrary and
discriminatory becomes academic and need not be gone into
in the present writ petition as the petitioner, even without Insisting on that qualification, was not entitled to be selected.
625
A
B
c
D
E
In this view the petition cannot succeeded and has to be dis-
missed.
Writ Petition No. 622 of 1970
The petitioner Is a science graduate having passed her B. Sc.
examination held by the Bangalore University in 1969. In that
examined she secured SOS out of 1000 marks, i. e., S0.5%. On
July 23, 1970, she applied for being admitted to the Pre-Professional Course in Medicine. Her name did not appear in the list
of selected candidates issued by the Selection Committee under
the Rules for Selection of Candidates for Admission, 1970 framed
bv the State Government. Aggrieved by the non-inclusion of her
name. the petitioner filed this writ petition.
Besides raising several displ!tes which are common to other
writ petitions in the present batch, she raised an additional issue.
challenging the validity of r. 4(h) of the said Rules. As already stated, the rule provides for reservation of seats for
different categories of candidates applying for selection and cl.
<h) reserves 4 seats each in the medical colleges at Bangalore,
Mysore and Hubli, and 3 seats in the Medical College at Bellary,
40- I S.C. lndia/71
F
G
H
Ei26
A
SUPRBMB COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
in all 15 seats, for the "Children of Political Sufferers". The
petitioner did not challenge the reservation of seats made in this
rule for other categories of persons, such as children of Defence
Personnel and Ex-Defence Personnel, etc.
The challenge to the validity of cl. (h) was two fold.
It was firstly, said that the expressions "political sufferer" and
"the national movement for the emancipation of India" in
the defin'ition of a "pqlitical sufferer" are so vague ambiguous
that it would be imp0ssible to identify the category of persons for whose benefit cl. (h.) was framed, and consequently, there would be ample room for tliose administering these
to resort to partiality, discrimination and favouritism. The
c rules
second objection was that the category of children of political
· sufferers was merely fanciful, politically oriented and without any
intelligible differentia, and as such the classification had no
reasonable nexus with the object of these rules. A number of
decisions of different High Courts dealing with similar admission
rules were cited for reinforcing the argument against the validity
D
of cl. (h) of r. 4.
B
E
F
G
H
So far as the first part of the argument is concerned, it is
difficult to envisage the danger apprehended by counsel or to see
the kind of vagueness or ambiguity complained of by him. The
rule contains the definition of a "political sufferer" as meaning
a person who "on account of participation in the national movement for the emancipation of India" had suffered imprisonment
or detention for a period of at least six months, or had been
awarded capital punishment, or had died while undergoing
imprisonment or detention or was killed or became permanently
incapaciw•·.d by police or military firing or lathi charge, or lost
his "job, property or other means of livelihood". The definition
is couched in clear and unambiguous language, besides containing
sufficient details, so as, to distinctively identify the persons who
would fall Within it. The person must have suffered incarceration, whether as imprisonment or detention, for a period of at
least six months or been awarded capital punishment, or must
have died while actually in detention or undergoing imprisonment, or killed or incapacitated permanently by firing or lathi
charge by the police or by the military, or must have lost employment, property or other means of livelihood. These should have
been the consequences of his having participated in the national
movement for the emancipation of India. The "national movement"
must obviously mean the late struggle for the freedom of the country from the alien Brit.ish rule. Th~ .am~igui.ty, counsel complained
of, in these words m the defirufion 1s ddlicult to comprehend.
There are ample details in the definition not to leave any scope
for arbitrariness or discrimination in its application to a candidate
o. '.N. CllANCHALA v. MYSORE (She/at, J.)
who claims to be a child of the political sufferer envisaged by
cl. (h) of the rule. We, therefore, turn to the second part of the
argument without detaining ourselves any further on- the grievance
of ambiguity In the definition.
•
The argument is that the category of children ol political
sufferers is arbitrary in the sense that it is entirely politically
oriented, is without any rational differentia and has no nexus with
the object of the rules. In support of the argument against such
a category, the case of Surendrakumar v. State (1) was clted
as an illustration where a similar -category had been struck down.
The State Government there had made reservation of seats which
was incorporated in the prospectus issued by each of the five
medical colleges run by the Government. The reservation was
challenged on the ground of its infringing Art. 14. The reservation was in respect of 5 categories of candidates, namely, (!) for
foreign private students, cultural scholars' and private students of
Indian origin domiciled abroad, (2) students migrating from Burma
(3) candidates from Scheduled Castes and Tribes belonging to
Rajasthan, (4) children of Defence personnel belonging to Rajasthan. and (5) children of political sufferers who are or were bona
fide residents of Rajasthan and who had been to jail in any part
of India. Among other things, the reservation for children of
political sufferers was made the target of the challenge. The
High Court upheld the challenge on the grounds (!) that if the
object was to afford facilities to political sufferers, there was no
reason why the benefit was restricted to the residents of Rajasthan
only, (2) that the expression 'political sufferer' not being a term
of art, opinions might honestly differ as to what sacrifices would
be sufficient to clothe a person with the status of political sufferer, (3) that the independence movement came to an end several
years ago, and therefore, If any facilities were to be afforded to
these who had suffered by their participation in it they could be
given once only, and (4) that there was no justification for such.
a classification as the only valid classification could be for obtai·
ning the best material for medical profession and such a reservation could not achieve but on the contrary defeat that object.
In two other decisions, Umesh Chandra v. V. N. Singh(')
and Kera/a v. Jacob. (') a provision authorising special preference
to the children of the employees of the University who had rendered meritorious service to the University, and a provision for
reservation for children of registered medical practitioners in
modern medicine were struck down, the first on the ground that
it would lead to favouritism and patronage, and the second on
(1) A. I. R. 1969 Raj. 182.
(2) (1967] I. L. R. 46 Put~16.
(3) A. I. R. 1964 Ker. 316.
627
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
628
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
the ground that the classification was not a rational one. Ramchandra v. State (') is yet another case where the High Court.
dealing with rules providing for 3 % of the seats for children of
hon fide political sufferers as defined in M. P. Freedom Fighters
Pension Rules, 1959. observed, though it declined to set them
aside on other grounds, that "the preferential treatment accorded
to them (the children of political sufferers) is based upon irrelevant and wb.olly extraneous considerations because there is no
rational relation between the political suffering of a person and
the education imparted to his descendants In a medical college
with the object of promoting efficiency in the medical profession".
On account of paucity of institutions imparting training in
technical studies and the increasing number of candidates seeking admission therein, there is obviously the need for classification to enable fair and equitable distribution of available seats.
The very decisions relied on by counsel for the petitioner implicitly recognise the need for classification and the power of those
who run such institutions to lay down classification. In Rajendran's case (') this Court impliedly accepted two sources of
recruitment made under the rules there challenged, namely, ())
those competing for seats in the general pool, and (2) those from
the socially and educationally backward classes for whom reservation permitted under Art. 15(4) was made. What was struck
down there was the districtwise distribution based on sheer residence as that would defeat the very object of the rules, namely,
th.e selection of the best and the most meritorious from the two
sources of recruitment. The power to lay down sources from
which selection would be made was expressly conceded to the
Government in Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India, (') this Court
observing in that connection at pp. 418 and 419 of the report that
since it was the Government which bore the financial burden of
running the medical college, it could lay down the criteria for
eligiblity and that from the very nature of things it was not possible to throw the admission open to students from all over the
country. Consequently, the Government could not be denied the
right to decide from what sources admissions would be made.
The Court at the same time emphasised that if the sources were
properly classified, whether on territorial, geographical or other
reasonable basis, the Court would refuse to interfere with the
manner and method of making the classification. The classification
there made were in relation to candidates worn Union territories
other than Delhi, children of Central Government servants posted
in Indian missions abroad, candidates under the Colombo Plan
and other international arrangements. scholars from Jammu &
Kashmir, etc. These classifications were found justifiable on one
(1) A. I. R. 1961 M.P. 247.
(3) [1970] I S.C.R. 413.
(2) [1968] 2 S.C.R. 786.
D. N. CHANCllALA v. MY'SORE (She/at, J.)
ground or the other and as based on intelligible differentia which
distinguished candidates falling within them from the rest. The
Mysore High Court, in Subhashini v. State (1) similarly recognized that there could be valid reservations, apart from those
permissible under Art. 15 (4), .that such reservatiom did not
necessarily infringe the equality protection under Art. 14 and
held that cassification based on a lawful State policy was not
violative of that Article. It upheld on this principle the reservation for children of Defence Personnel, Ex-Defence personnel
as being clearly in national interest.
(See also Anil Kumar v.
629
A
B
Mysore ('):
Once the power to lay down classifications or categories of
persons from whom admission is to be given is granted, the only
question which would remain for consideration would be whether c
such categorisation has an intelligible criteria and whether it has
a reasonable relation with the object for which the Rules for admission are made. Rules for admission are inevitable so long .
as the demand of every candidate seeking admission cannot be
complied with in view of the paucity of institutions imparting
training in such subjects as medicine. The definition of a 'poli· D
tical sufferer' being a detailed one and in certain terms, it would be
easily possible to distinguish children of such political sufferers
from the rest as possessing the criteria laid down by the definition.
The object of the rules for admission can obviously be to secure
a fair and equitable. distribution of seats amongst those seeking
admission and who are eligible under the University Regulations.
E
Such distribution can be on the principle that admission should be
available to the best and the most meritori®s. But an equally
fair and equitable principle would also be that which secures admission in a just proportion to those who are handicapped and
who, but for the preferential treatment given to them, would not
stand a chance against those who are not so handicapped and are,
F
therefore, in a superior position. The principle underlying Art.
15 (4) is that a preferential treatment can validly be given because
the socially and educationally backward classes need it, so that
in course of time they stand in equal position with the more advanced sections of the society. It would not in any way be improper if that principle were also to be applied to those who are
handicapped but do not fall under Art. 15(4). It is on such a
G
principle that reservation for children of Defence personnel and
Ex-Defence personnel appears to have been upheld. The criteria
for such reservation is that those serving in the Defence forces or
those who had so served are and were at a disadvantage in giving
education to their children since they had to live, while discharging their duties, in difficult places where normal facilities availH
(q A. I. R. 1966 Mys. 40.
(2) 1969 17 L. R. (Mysore) 110.
630
A
B
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
able elsewhere are and were not available. In our view it is not
unreasonable to extend that principle to the children of political
sufferers who in consequence of their participation in the eman·
cipation struggle became unsettled in life; in some cases economically ruined, and were therefore, no! in a position to make avail·
able to their children that class of education which would place
them in fair competition with the children of those who did not
suffer'from that disadvantage. If that be so, it must follow that
the definition of 'political sufferer' not only makes the children
of such sufferers distinguishable from the rest but such a classi·
fication has a reasonable nexus with the object of the rules which
can be nothing else than a fair and just distribution of seats. In
our view, neither of the two contentions raised by counsel for the
petitioner can be accepted, with the result that the writ petition
fails and is dismissed.
Writ petitions Nos. 618 and 620 of 1970 raise questions
similar to those dealt with hereinbefore. In accordance with
the reasons hereinbefore given, they fail and are dismissed.
D
The result is that all the five petitions are dismissed. In
the circumstances of the case we make no order as to costs in any
one of them.
E
F
G
H
Dua, J.-I have read the judgment prepared by my learned
brother Shelat, J., and I agree that all the writ petitions should
be dismissed with no order as to costs. I should, however, like,
as at present advised, to refrain from expressing anr considered
opinion on the validity of r. 4(h) of the Mysore Medical Colleges
(Selection for Admission) Rules, 1970. The category of persons
in whose favour seats in the Medical Colleges mentioned in this
sub-rule are reserved are described as "children of political suf·
ferers". The expression "political sufferer" is defined in Expla·
nation (ii) to mean :
"a person who on account of participation in the national movement for the emancipation of India(a) has suffered imprisonment or detention for a
period of not le!ls than six months, the said
period being calculated taking into account the
period of remission, if any, granted for good
conduct and other like reasons, or had been
awarded capital punishment or had died while
undergoing imprisonment or detention : or
(bl was killed or became permanently incapacitated
by police or military firing or latbl charge:
or
D. N. CHANCHAL" v. MYSORE (Dua, J.)
(c) lost his job, property or other means of livelihood."
The petitioner's learned counsed relied on several decisions
in support of his challenge to the validity of this sµb-rule on the
ground that this reservation has no rational nexus with tile object
of selecting the most meritorious or suitable candidates for medi·
cal education so that they may be able both to serve the people
as doctors with the requisite efficiency and to find adequate means
of livelihood -for themselves. According to the petitioner's argument the mere fact that the parents of such candidates had before
I 947, as a result of their participation in national movement for
the emancipation of India from the foreign rule, suffered impri·
sonment, detention, disablement, or loss of property or job, does
not necessarily clothe them with an intel11gible differentia distin·
guishing them as a separate class in 1970 for admission to the
Medical Colleges. It was contended that what may have happen·
ed more than 23 years ago (as no question of the national movement for the emancipation of India could arise after Indian inde·
pendence) is far too remote in point of time for serving as a rational differenfia for sustaining the present classification in favour
of the children of such political sufferers. It was not denied that
the Government could and should extend all help needed to reha·
bilitate such sufferers in order, so far as reasonably possible, to
undo or minimise the effect of, or to compensate them for, their
suffering during the national movement. But that is quite differ·
ent from giving their children preference over other candidates
otherwise equally placed in the matter of admission to Medical
Colleges in 1970, unless there are cogent grounds for holding that
because of their parents' suffering prior to 1947 the children have
been so handicapped as to require a favoured treatment in this
respect. The case of the children of defence personnel, it was
urged, clearly stands on a different footing, as in their case from
the very nature of the duties of the. defence personnel their children
are generally speaking likely to suffer from handicaps justifying
preferential treatment. Minor P. Rajendran v. State of Madras (')
was cited in support of the submission that the fact that classification by itself is reasonable is not enough to support it, unless
there is a nexus between the classification and object to be achiev·
ed and also that the object to be achieved in a case of admission
to the Medical Colleges is to get the best talent for admission to
professional colleges.
631
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
The learned Attorney-General, however, drew our attention
w Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India (') in which after approving
the view taken in Minor P. Rajendrnn's case ('), it was added
that the object of selecting the best possible material can be
(1) [1968]2 S.C.R. 786.
(2) [1970] l S. C. R. 413·
H
632
A
B
c
D
E
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1~7!] SUPP. S.C.R.
achieved by making proper rules for admission. Permissible classification, according to the petitioner's argument, must be founded
on an intelligible differentia distinguishing persons grouped \O·
gether from others left out of the group, and the differentia must
h.ave a rational relation to the object sought to be achieved by
the provision in question. It was emphasized that what has to'
be seen Is the distinguishing feature existing at the time of the
admission and the fact that the parents of the candidates had
suffered by their patriotic activities admittedly more than 23 years
ago does not reasonably lead to an inference that in 1970 also
the children of such political sufferers constituted a class by itself
requiring preference over other candidates seeking admission to
the Medical Colleges.
The learned Attorny-General apart from relying on the
case of Chitra Ghosh (') submitted that the petitioner in Writ PetiNo. 622 of 1970 (R. Jayashree), in which case alone this sub-rule
was challenged, had obtained marks which were lower than the
last candidate admitted from the category of the children of
political sufferers. On this ground it was submitted that, even
assuming r. 4(h) to be invalid, the petitioner could not claim
admission, because l'er marks were admittedly lower than those
of the last candidate admitted from the category of the children
of political sufferers. Those children, even ignoring r. 4(h), had
a preferential right as against the petitioner R. Jayashree. !n
that situation the learned Attorney-General contended the question of the invalidity of r. 4(hJ loses all importance and would
hardly be material.
I must confess that from the very beginning it entertained some
doubt about the validity of r. 4(h), and that doubt has not been
dispelled even after hearing the arguments addressed at the Bar.
The object of selection for admission to the Medical Colleges, considered in the background of the directive principles of State
policy contained in our Constitution, appears to be to select the
best material from amongst the candidates in order not only to
provide them with adequate means of livelihood, but also to
provide the much needed medical aid to the people and to improve public health generally. As already observed, I am not quite
sure if it can be confidently said that there is a reasonable nexus
between the differentia on which the children of political sulferers
are classified as a distinct group and the object of admission to the
Medical Colleges. In view, however, of the admitted fact that
the marks secured by the petitioner R. Jayashree were lower
than the marks secured by the last candidate admitted from the
category of the children of political sufferers, the petitioner was
not entitled to claim admission, even if the children of political
sufferers were not given any priority. On this groond alone the
[1970) I S.C.R. 413,
D. N. CHANCHALA v. MYSORE (Dua, J.)
A
B
633
present Writ Petition (No. 622 of 1970) deserves to be dismissed.
I according consider it unnecessary to go into the question of the
invailidity of r. 4(h) in tllis case. I would thus confine the order
of dismissal of, Writ Petition .No. 622 of 1970 only on this ground
without expressing ,any considered opinion on the question of the
validity of r. 4(h). Except for my reservation on this point, I am
in respectful agreement with all that has been said by my learned
brother Shelat, J.
G.C.
Petition dismissed.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org