BANSILAL KOHISTANI versus RISHI KUMAR KAUSHAL
Supreme Court of India | Decided 23 March 1971 | [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 146 | 1971 INSC 91
Key facts
- Decided
- 23 March 1971
- Bench
- J.M. SHELAT*, C.A. VAIDYIALINGAM
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 204/1970
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1971] SUPP. 1 S.C.R. 146
- Neutral citation
- 1971 INSC 91
Text of the judgment
146
A
BANSILAL KOHISTANI
v.
RISW KUMAR KAUSHAL
B
March 23, 1971
(J. M. SHELAT AND C. A VAIDIALINGAM, JJ.j
Jammu & Kashmir Representation of the People Act, 1951-Cui-res~
pondr to s. 123(4) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951-Corrupt
Practir:t-Statement as to character and conduct of candidate, what consti..
tuteJ-Onw1 to prove that statement is false is on petitioner.
c
D
G
H
Jn the General Election held in 1967 the appellant and the respondent
had filed their nomination papers for election to the Jammu and Kashmir
Legislative Assembly from the Reasi Assembly Constituency. The appellant was declared duly elected. The respondent filed an election petition
cballena;iog the election of the appellant on the ground of corrupt practices
commiucd by the appellant his agents and other persons with hi• consent.
The High Court held the election to be void on the sole ground that the
matters mentioned in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 of the booklet Ex. P.W.
1 /II constituted corrupt practices under s. 132(4) of the Jammu & Kashmir
Represeotalion of the People Act, 1957 corresponding to s. 123(4) of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951. In regard to certain other passages in tho booklet namely paragraphs 7, 8, 10, 18 and 19 of Ex. P. W.
1/JI the High Court held that the allegations therein were not proved to
he false and therefore fell outside the ambit of s. 132(4) of the Jammu &
Kashmir AcL Appeal against the High Court's judgment was filed in this
Court by the appellant. In regard to the allegations in paragraphs 16, 17
and 20 of the offending booklet the appellant urged that the facts mentioned thereia did not relate to the personal character and conduct of the
appellant The respondent sought and obtained leave of tho Court to
question the finding of the High Court in regard to paragraph• 7, 8, 10,
18 and 19 of the booklet.
HELD: (i) In order to constitute corrupt practice under '· 123(4) of
the Indian Act and s. 132(4) of the Jammu & Kashmir Act the false statement should have been in relation to the personal character of the candidate. If a false statement is made with regard to the public or political
character of the candidate, it would not constitute a corrupt practice. even
if it is likely to prejudice the prospects of the candidate's election. Circuta..
tion of false statement about the private or personal character of the
candidate during the period preceding the election is likely to 'Work
against the freedom of election itself, inasmuch as the effect created by
false ~tatement cannot be met by denial in proper time and so the consti·
tuency has to be protected against the circulation of such false ~tate1nent-:;
which are likely to affect the voting of the electors. If a statement of fact
affects the man beneath the politician it touches the private character : if
it afiecM the politician it does not touch his private character. St·rih~
alk>wancc will have to be made in respect of statements made in election
meetings as the atmosphere is usually surcharged by partisan feelings and
emotions. Allegations of depravity or immorality or affecting the 1noral
or n1ental qualities of a person are statements relating to the personal
character or conduct of a person. Attributing acts of violence to a cand;M
d~te- even if such acts are done during his political career, is a statement
re!at!ng to the personal character and conduct. If the conditions of -s.
121.(4) are satisfied it is irrelevant to inquire whether the statetnent has
been n1:ide as a counter blast to another statement issued by the opponent.
BANSI LAL v. RISHI KUMAR (Vatdialingam, J.)
The staiement must be one reasonably calculated to prejudice the prospect•
of the candidate's election. The initial onus establishing the circumstances
mentioned in s. 123(4) is on the election petitioner and when once he discharges that onus, the burden shifts to the candidate making a false statement of fact to show what his belief was. [156G-157D]
147
A
Case-law referred to. ,
(ii) There were no statements of fact in paragraphs I 7 and 20 of lhe
Ex. P. W. I /II in relation to the personal character or conduct of the res-
pondent. There was no allegation in paragraph I 6 that the respondent
"as an associate of drunkards. The averment in the said paragraph that
•ome of the companions of the respondent on whose political support
the respondent relied were found drinking from morning till evening, did not
relate to the personal .character or conduct of the respondent. The allegation in the said paragraph regarding the respondent extricating himself
from a criminal case bad been proved to be true and u 1ucli fell outside
the mischief of s. 132(4) of the Act. It followed that the finding of the
High Court that the statements contained in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20
amounted to corlllpt practice under s. 132(4) of the Act, could not be
austained. [1640-FJ
(iii) It is permissible for a respondent in this Court to support the
judgment of the High Court by attacking the findings recorded against
him. However on an examination of the findings recorded by the High
Court in respect of paragraphs 7, 8, 10, 18 and 19 it could not be held that
the findings therein were erroneous as contended by the respondent. [165A;
171B]
B
c
D
Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dab/U Ajitkumar Fulsinii & Ors. [1965]
I S.C.R. 712 and Shri Thepfulo Nakhro Angami v. Shrimati Raveluei @
Rani M. Shaiza, [1971] 3 S.C.R. 424, referred to.
CIVIL APPELLATE
JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 204 of
E
1970.
Appeal under Section 123 of the J. & K. Representation of
the People Act, 1957 from the judgment and order dated December 15, 1969 of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court in Election
Petition No. 37 of 1967.
F
R. K. Garg, D. P. Singh, A. K. Gupta, R. K. lain, V. I.
Francis and S. P. Singh, for the appellant
Ramnath Bhalgotra, Swaranjit Sodhi and S. S. Khanduja, for
the respondent
G
The Judgment of the Co)lrt was delivered by
Valdialingam, J.-This appeal, under Section 123 of the
Jammu- & Kashmir, Representation of the People Act, 19S7
!hereinafter to be referred as the Act) as amended by Act 11 of
1967, is direeted a~ainst the judgment and order dated December
15, 1967 of the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir in Election
Petition No. 37 of 1967. Section 123 of the Act corresponds
to Section ll 6A of the Representation of the People Act, 195 l.
H
148
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
In the General Election held in 1967, the appellant and the
respondent had duly filed their nominations for election to the
Jammu & Kashmir Legislative Assembly from the Reasi Assembly
Constituency. Scrutiny of the nomination papers was conducted on January 23, 1967 and the polling took place on February
21, 1967. The counting of the ballot papers took place or1
February 27, 1967 and the appellant was declared duly elected by
a majority of 418 votes. The respondent filed an election petition
on April 8, 1967 being No. 37 of 1967 challenging the election
of the appellant on the ground that various corrupt practices, set
out in the. petition, had been committed by the appellant, his
agents and other persons with his consent in the said election. In
.:onsequence the respondent prayed for declaring the election of
the appellant from the said constituency as null and void.
ln paragraph 6 of the election petition, the respondent enumerated the various corrupt practices stated to have been commi.tted during the election, in consequence of which the election
of the respondent was void. It is not necessary for us to set out
the various corrupt practices referred -to in paragraph 6 of the
election petition. The election of the appellant had been declared to be void by the High Court only on the ground that the
matters mentioned in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 of the booklet
Ex. P. W. l/II constitute corrupt practices under Section 132 (4>
of the Act corresponding to Section 123 (4) of the Representation
of the People Act, 1951. We may have to deal with certam
other matters referred to in paragraph 6 of the election petition
in the later part of the judgment, as the learned counsel for the
respondent has tried to support the judgment of the High Court
by attacking the finding recorded against him in respect of some
of those allegations.
Item No. 2 of paragraph 6 refers to the appellant, bis agents,
polling agents and other persons with his consent having published
certain posters and booklets containing statements of facts, which
were false and which they either believed to be false and did not
believe to be true in relation to the personal character and conduct of the respondent. Sub-item (a) of item No. 2 refers to the
publication of a booklet under the caption "open letter from
Debati <Rural) Conference to Mr. Risbi Kumar Kaushal and other
Jan Sangh leaders". This is Ex. P. W. I /II. It was published
by one Lal Singh R. W. 53, an active worker of the Indian National Congress and the agent of the appellant. Lal Singh was lateT
on appointed by the appellant as his polling agent. Ex P. W.
I /II was alleged to contain wrong facts in several paragraph enumerated in the petition.
There were other allegations
of corrupt practices mentioned in paragraph 6 of tbs election
petition.
BANS! LAL'· RISH! KUMAR (Vaidialingam, J.)
The appellant in his written statement pleaded that none of
the allegations that had been made against him by the respondent
in the election petition contained material facts constituting the
alleged corrupt practices. He further pleaded that the respondent
had not mentioned the parties who are aileged to have committed
the corrupt practices nor the dates and places when the corrupt
practices are alleged to have been committed.
Regarding the
various allegations of corrupt practices, the appellant denied that
he had committed any such corrupt practice and that in any
event the allegations do not amount to corrupt practice in law.
With reference to Ex. P. W. I /II, the booklet, the appellant averred that the publication was really a rejoinder issued to a poster
Ex. P. W. l/B issued by the Jan Sangh party, to which the respondent belonged. He further pleaded that P. W. I/II was pub·
lished long before the respondent became a candidate in the election and its object was to educate the voters of the constituency.
With reference to the various paragraphs in Ex. P. W. I /II, relied
on by the election petitioner as constituting corrupt practice, the
appellant pleaded that the matters referred to in the booklet do
not affect the personal character or conduct of the respondent and
that they ·never affected him beneath the politicians. Those
matters contained in Ex. P. W. I /II dealt only with the respondent as a politician and they were only criticism of the respondent
in his public character as a politician and of the political party,
the Jan Sangh, to which he belonged. It was only a criticism of
the Jan Sangh party and its economic and political ideology. He
also controverted the various other allegations made in the election petition.
R. W. 53 Lal Singh has given evidence that he published the
open letter Ex. P. W. I/II as a reply to the poster Ex. P. W. 1/B
issued by the Jan Sangh. He has also stated that the contents
of Ex. P. W. I /II are correct and that the publication was made
in the first week of December, 1966.
149
A
B
c
D
E
F
Issue No. 2 runs as follows :
"Whether the respondent, his election agent and
agents published the booklet "Dehati Conference kee
Taraf se Shri Rishikumar Kaushal "aur deegar Jansanghi
leaderon ke nam Khuli Chitthi" in the name of one Lal
Singh an active worker of the Congress and distributed it
amongst the voters of the Constituency from 1-2-67 to
20-2-1967 and whether the said booklet contained facts in
relation to Rishi Kumar petitioner which were false and
which were either believed to be false or were not believed
to be true?"
G
H
150
A
B
c
E
.,
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
Ex. P. W. 1/11 is a pamphlet. It purports to be from the
Dehati (Rural) Conference to Mr. Rishi Kumar Kaushal and oth«
I an Sangh leaders. Rishi Kumar is the respondent herein and
he was at the material time a sitting member of the Legislative
Assembly. There is a photo of Lal Singh in the said pamphlet.
It calls itself an open letter. It consists of 21 paragraphs and the
relevant paragraphs for the purpose of this appeal are Nos. 16, 17
and 20. There are mistakes in the official English translation of
the pamphlet and there are also mistakes in the translation of th•
said paragraphs by the High Court. Both the learned counsel
have agreed before us that the following translation of the said
three paragraphs is substantially correct.
"Paragraph 16Who raised the question of the village and the town ?
When in the month of September, 1966, two persons of
the rural area Sailanjan-Dhani Ram and Baldev Singh
came to Riasi, and they caught a shop keeper sawing wood
in an unauthorised manner and you with the aid of your
urban colleagues made an attack on them and raised the
question ; that these people from the village come to town
and drink and roam aimlessly like vagabonds etc. and
they were kept in jail for a night. the doctors and the lawyers who were in Reasi were instructed not to take up
their cause and they received no aid. It was the next day
that they were bailed out from jail. No one from Riasi
town came to their rescue. Thereafter they went to the
court of the D.C. Udhampur and there they instituted a
case against 10.11 persons, including you. Then you gave
them some small coins paise and asked for a pardon. But
it has been seen that some of you sathis are found drinking from morning till evening. You rely on their support. Have you ever taken action against them ? Or is
it that we alone from the village are bad characters ? The
urban question has been raised by you and now you are
preaching separation between the urban and the rural
people, and that two foundations are being laid now. Who
has laid these foundations? And who raised the rural
question?"
Paragraph 11.
"It is an incident of four years ago that you had in
this very manner incited our village brethren. On that
account a few Hindus and Muslims of Talwada jointly
seized the cattle and livestock of the peasants living in the
hills, when they were taking them to their home. Their
cattle and livestock were impounded. For this.
BANSI LAL v. RISHI KUMAR (Valdia/ingam, J.)
'
! 51
these peasants filed cases in courts against their own
brethren and a few persons of Talwada were arrested.
The case against them has been going on till recently. But
have you ever rendered any help to them in courts ? They
had to suffer and thus incur expense upto the courts in
Srinagar-but you merely did propaganda about cow
slaughter, you never took into consideration that the peasants invariably carry on the sale and purchase of cattle
and livestock. The livestock keeps moving up and down.
What marks these cattle carried to indicate that they were
on their way to the slaughter house. What work you
have done for the benefit of the village ! Every effort
has been made that in every way the villagers are rendered weak. For this reason alone, you have been knocking at every door and staggering around saying : Vote for
me. Have you the face to ask for votes ? "yeh munh
aur masoor ki dal". Now you secure the votes from your
town. Don't hope for the village. You commit deception and people from the village get a bad name. We
from the village have done everything for you and after
20 years this is the reward you have given us. Now you
reap as you sowed (Jaisa kiya waisa bhogo). Take a
razor and shave the heads of the villagers. Kaushal
Sahib, that is all that is left to be done. Now you consider, who ihould be voted. Strike off the name of 'taklilg'
and insert the name of 'giving'.
Paragraph 20.
"Now we have set up the Dehati Conference orr November 20, 1966. Now you do what you plcaso. Now
no villager will come to you for being hurt, nor lihall anyone else.
Now you fix an iron curtain outside your
town, so that nobody casts eyes on your golden city and
you enjoy the wealth robbed from the poor."
The High Court with reference to paragraphs 16, 17 and 20
of the pamphlet Ex. P. W. I/II held that the allegations contained therein constitute statements of fact in relation to the personal conduct and character of the respondent. With reference to
paragraph 16, the High Court held that the respondent is shown
to have apologised after paying some money and that he extricated himself from a criminal case and that the respondent is
shown to bo an associate of drunkards on whose support he
comes and that these statements of fact were false and have not
been proved by the appellant to have been made in a bona-{iJe
manner. Again with reference to paragraph 17, the Higb Court
is of the view that the respondent is charged with negligence and
is stated to be responsible for the misfortune of certain arrested
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
152
A
B
c
D
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] WPP. s.c.R.
persons. In particular the High Court has held that in this ;:iaragraph "the petitioner is shown to have preached cow-slaughter
(which is indeed henious from Hindu point of view)." The High
Court has further held that there are also allegations that the respondent has committed acts of fraud. These averments have
been held by the High Court to be wrong and false statement>
of facts and not proved to be correct and such a type of propaganda has materially affected the prospects of the respondent's
election as they touched his personal conduct.
With reference to the averrnents in paragraph 20 of the Ex.
P. W. 11 II, the High Court is of the view that there is an allegation that the respondent has looted the property of the poor and
that he is further charged with appropriating the looted property.
Such an allegation, which is false, relates to the personal character
of the respondent. The High Court winds up its discussion on
paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 of Ex. P. W. l /II as follows:
"The above referred to allegations made in paras J6,
17 and 20 are in my opinion statements of fact which are
in relation to the personal character and conduct of the
petitioner. He is described as one who apologised for
extricating himself from a criminal case by paying money
to the other side. He is shown to be an associate of
drunkards on whose support he counts and in whose company he moves. He is also shown to be a preacher of
cow-slaughter (a malafide statement which is likely to
rouse the wrath of Hindu Janta against him and to malign
him). He is said to be begging for votes from door to
door (on humiliating terms). He is said to have committed acts of fraud and in the end what is worst is that he is
asked to appropriate the looted property of the poor. Tr.e
statements of facts have been made in the booklet Ex.
P. W. I /II with the clear intention of maligning and defaming the petitioner and degrading him in the eyes of the
voters. These statements are false and have not been proved to be correct. These statements of fact have been made
by an active worker of the Congress who was not only a
worker in election of the respondent but also his polling
agent. It is true that the booklet was published before
the notificatio!I calling upon the candidates to file nomination papers in the Constituency was made. May be also
that the booklet was published only in reply to the poster
Ex. P. W. l /b entitled 'Dihati Bhai Hoshiar Bash' issued
by Jan Swgh as is argued. But it was issued on the eve
of the election and in this there is a clear mention of election propaganda."
(
BANS! LAL v. RISH! KUMAR (Vaidia/ingam, J.)
Finally the High Court held that the allegations referred to
in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 of the booklet Ex. P. W. I /II are
statements of fact, which are false and have been made in relation
to the personal character and conduct of the petitioner and therefore fall within the ambit of s. 132(4) of the Act. The High
.Cou:·t further finds that there is overwhelming evidence on re,cord to show that the said booklet was distributed and circulated
.by the author of the booklet R. W. 53 and other workers of the
Congres; party including the election agent of the appellant and
the appellant himself amongst the people in different villages of
:the Constituency during the election and also just before the poll.
All other allegations of corrupt practice made in the election
petition were either held to be true or not proved. But on the
basis of the finding on paragraphs 16, 17 and 18 of Ex. P. W. Ii II,
the High Court held the appellant guilty of corrupt practice and
as such set aside his election after declaring it void.
Mr. R. K. Garg, learned counsel for the appellant, urged two
contentions : (!) that the statements contained in the above thre~
paragraphs do not relate to the personal conduct or character of
the respondent and, that, on the other hand, they are only by way
of a criticism of the respondent as a politican and the political
activities of the Jan Sangh Party to which he belongs. The High
Court has misinterpreted and misunderstood the various statements made in the above paragraphs when it came to the conclusion that they amount to corrupt practice; (ii) regarding publication and distribution of the pamphlet by the appellant, his agent,
or by any person with his consent. the learned Judge has merely
extracted the evidence on the side of the appellant and the respondent and has entered a finding that there is overwhelming evidence on record to show that Ex. P. W. l /II has been distributed
and circulated in different villages during the election and before
the poll. The learned Judge has not expressed any opinion as
to which evidence he accepts or rejects, and as such the finding
in this regard is grossly vitiated.
Section 132 of the Act corresponding to Section 123 of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951 deals with corrupt 9ractices and sub-section (4) is as follows :
"The publication by a candidate or his agent or by
any other person, of any statement of fact which is false,
and which he either believes to be false, or does not
believe to be true, in relation to the personal character or
conduct of any candidate, or in relation to the candidature, or withdrawal, or retirement from contest, of any
candidate being a statement reasonably calculated to prejudice the prospects of that candidaite's election."
J 53
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
154
A
B
SUPRllME COllRT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
Sub-section (4), quoted above is the same as Section 123 (4)
of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and the contents
of the said sub-section have been laid down in several decisions of
this Court. We will first refer to the broad principles laid down
in those decisions and then advert to the relevant paragraphs of
the booklet Ex. P. W. l /II and will then deal with the contentions of Mr. Bhalgotra, supporting the findings of the High Court
in relation to those paragraphs.
c
In T. K. Gangi Reddy v. M. C. Anjaneya Reddy and other$(')
this Court stated that the words "personal character and conduct" are so clear that they do not require further elucidation or
definition. The character of a person may ordinarily be equated
with his mental or moral nature. Conduct connotes a person's
actions or behaviour". It has been further held that if otherwise
a statement comes under sub-section (4) of Section 123 as corrupt
practice, it will be no answer to plead that the 11tatement was
made as a counter blast to a rival statement of an opponent.
D
In dealing with sub-section (4) of Sectioo 123 in lnder Lal v.
Lal Singh (') this Court observed as follows :
E
F
G
H
"It would be noticed that in prescribing the requirement that the false statement should have relation to the
personal character of the candidate, a distinction is intended to be drawn between the personal character of the
candidate and his public or political character........ Dissemination of false statements about the personal character of the candidate thus constitute a corrupt practice."
In the same decision it has also been pointed out that though it
is clear that the statue wants to make a broad distinction
between public and political character on the one hand and
private character on the other, it is obvious thal a sharp and
clear cut dividing line cannot be drawn to distinguish the 0nc
from the other. But nevertheless tho courts will havo to draw a
working line to distinguish private character from pvblic character.
It has further been pointed out in Ku/tar Si11:lt v. Mukhtiar
Singh (') that the document must be read as a whole and its purport and effect determined in a fair, objective and reasonabi.
manner and that at the election time the atmOiphcro is usually
surcharged with partisan feelings ood emotiollS and liOlllO allowance must be made in that regard.
(I) (1960) 22 E. L. R. 261.
(2) (19621 Suppl. 3 s.c.R. 114.
t3) [1964) 7 S.C.R. 790.
BANSI LAL v. RISHI KUMAR (Vaidia/ingam, J.)
155
Dealing with sub-section (4) of Section 123, in Sheopat Singh
v. Ram Pratap (') this Court observed as follows :
"The sub-section is designed to achieve this dual purpose, namely, freedom of speech and prevention of malicious attack on personal character or conduct etc. of
rivals. The purity of an election is sought to be maintained without affecting the freedom of expression. The
sub-section prohibits any statement of fact in relation to
personal character or conduct of any candidate, which is
not only false but also the candidate making it either believes it to be false or does not believe it to be true. It
implies that a statement of fact relating to the personal
character or conduct etc. of a candidate can be made, if
it is true. Even if it is false, the candidate making it is
protected, unless he makes it believing it to be false or not
believing it to be true, that is to say statements which are
not true made bona fide are also outside the ambit of the
provision. To be within the mischief of sub-section (41
of Section 123 of the Act, such a statement shall satisfy
another test, namely, it shall be a statement reasonably
calculated to prejudice the prospects of the election of the
candidate against whom it is made. The word "calculated" means designed : it denotes more than mere likelihood and imports a design to affect voters. lt connoks
a subjective element through the actual effect of the
statement on the electoral mind reflected in the result
may afford a basis to ascertain whether the said statement was reasonably calculated to achieve that effect.
The emphasis is on the calculated effect, not on the
actual result, though the latter proves the former."
It has been further stated in the said decision :
"The boundary between personal character and conduct and public character and conduct is well drawn,
though, sometimes, it is thin. Sometimes a statement
may appear to touch both the candidate's personal as
well as public character."
B
c
D
I'
G
In Dev Kanta Barooah v. Golok Chandra Baruah and
Jthers (') this Court had to consider whether an allegation call-
ing as "Deshdrohita" a person who was having military contracts
during the 1942 movements was a statement in relation to his
persooal character or conduct. It was held that the said allegation was only a reflection on the political conduct of the person
(I) [1965) I s.c.R. 17S.
(2) [t970J t s.c.c.392.
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
156
A
B
c
[1971] l>UPP. S C.R.
concerned in siding with the British Government rather than joining the Congress, which was carrying on a movement against the
British for achieving independence of the country. In that cuntext it was held that the statement was not In relation to the
personal character or conduct of the party concerned as there is
no imputation of any depravity or immorality".
In Guruj/ Shrihar Baliram Jivatode v. Vitha/rao and others(')
it was held by this Court that the statements which were under
consideration do not make any reflection on the moral or mental
qualities "of the person against whom those statements had been
made." The following observation of Darling J. in Cumberland
(Cockermouth Divisional) (') case has been quoted with approval
in some of the decisions of this Court referred to above :
"What the Act forbids is this. You shall not make
or publish any false statement of fact in relation to th~
personal character or conduct of such candidate ; if you
do, it is an illegal practice. It is not an offence to say
something which may be severe about another person nor
which ma¥ be unjustifiable nor which may be derogatory
unless it amounts to a false statement of fact in relation to
the personal character or conduct of such candidate ; anti
I think the Act says that there is a great distinction to be
drawn between a false statement of fact which affects th~
personal character or conduct of a candidate and a false
statement of fact which deals with the political position or
reputation or action of the candidate. If that "were not
kept in mind, this statute would simply have prohibited
at election times all sorts of criticism which was not
strictly true relating to the political behaviour and
opinions of the candidate. That is why it carefully provides that the false statement, in order to be an illegal
practice, must relate to the personal character and personal conduct."
D
F
Darling J. was dealing with a provision similar to Section l 23
(4).
G
H
From a review of the decisions referred to above, it fo!tows
that in order to constitute corrupt practice under Section 123(4),
the false statement should have been in relation to the personal
character of the candidate. If a false statement is made with
regard to the public or political character of the candidate. it
would not constitute a corrupt practice even if it is likely to prejudice the prospects of that candidate's election. Circulation of
(I) [1969] I S.C.R. 766.
(2) [1901] S, O' M. & H. lSS.
BANS! LAL v. RISH! KUMAR ( Vaitlialingam, J.)
157
false statement about the private or personal character of the candidate during the period preceding the election is likely to work
against the freedom of election itself inasmuch as the effect created by false statement cannot be met by denial in proper time and
so the Constituen;;y has .to be protected against the circulation of
such false statements which are likely to affect the voting ·:if the
elec10rs. If a statement of fact affects the man beneath the politician, it touches the private character; and if it affects the politician it does not touch his private character. Some allowance will
have to be made in respect of statements made in election meetings as the 31tmosphere is usually surcharged by partisan feelings
and emotions. Allegations of depravity or immorality or affecting the moral or mental qualities of a person are statements re!atir,g to the personal character or conduct of a person. Attributing
acts of violence to a candidate even if such acts are done during his
political career, is a statement relating to the personal character
and conduct. If the conditions of Section 123 (4) are satisfied it is
irrelevant to inquire whether the statement has been made as a
counter-blast to another statement issued by the opponent. The
statement must be one reasonably calculated to prejudice the pro;pects of the candidate's election. The initial onus of establishing
the circumstances mentioned in Section 123 (4) is on the election
petitioner and when once he discharges that onus, the burden
shifts to the candidate making a false statement of fact to show
what his belief was.
Bearing in mind the above propositions, we will now proceed
to consider whether the statements in paragraph 16, 17 and 20 in
Ex. P. W. I /II are statements in relation to the personal character
or conduct of the respondent.
In considering this question it is necessary to note that the
respondent was then a sitting member of the Legislative Assembly
and the pamp.lilet itself is addressed not only to the respondent but
also to other Jan Sangh leaders. There is no controversy that the
respondent belonged to Jan Sangh Party.
Before we consider the contents of the said three paragraphs
of Ex. P. W, II II, we can deal with and dispose of the contentions raised on behalf of the appellant that the booklet was issued
as a counter blast to the pamphlet issued by the Jan Sangh Party
Ex. P. W. II B. As stated by this Court in T. K. Gangi Reddy
and others (), case Section 123 (4) defining corrupt practice, is
not conditioned by any proviso to the effect that it would cease
tc be a .corrupt practice if the statement was made to counteract
the rival statement of an opponent. Therefore, it follows that if
the conditions mentioned in sub-section (4) of Section 123 are
held to be satisfied, it is irrelevant to inquire whether the booklet
(1) [1960] 22 E.L.R. 261.
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
168
A
B
c
D
E
SUPREMI! COUllT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.ll.
Ex. P. W. l /11, has been published as a counter-blast to Ex. P. W.
l/B
Now coming to the material portion of the pamphlet itself,
we are of the opinion that the High Court has misunderstood and
misinterpreted the averrnents contained in paragraphs 16, 17 and
20. Before we deal with paragraph 16, we will consider tho nature
of the statements made in paragraphs 17 and 20.
Paragraph 17 in substance refers to seizure of cattle and livestock of the persons when they were being taken to their home.
There is a reference to the cattle being impounded and the persons
filing a case in the court. The charge is that the respondent
never rendered any help to those persons who had been arrested
and tried by the courts. There is a reference .to the respondent
doing propaganda about the COW-tilaughter and his not havin& done
anything for the benefit of the villagers. In spite of not doing
anything to the villagers, the respondent is alleged to bs asking
for votes from the villagers. It is further stated that the people
of the village have been helping the respondent for over 20 years
and the latter had done nothing to help the villagers. This para·
graph. unfortunately, has been understood by the learned Jadge as
containing the statements to the effect:
(a) that the respondent is a preacher of cow-slaughter
and that it is a malafide statement made to rouse the
wrath of Hindu Janta against him and to malign him;
(b) that the respondent is begging for votes from door
to door on humiliating terms;
(c) th.at the respondent has committed acts of fraud.
I'
H
None of the above conclusions drawn by the High Court
from paragraph 17 are supported by the statements contained !heroin. On the other haoo, it is a wholesale attack against the respendetit as a politician for having ignored the requirements of
the village and the villagers but at the same time trying to woo
their votes which he does not deserve. There is no statement to
the effect that the respondent has preached cow-slaughter in which
case it wt11 be a very serious allegation. On the other hand the
statement is that the respondent did propaganda about cow·
slaughter. Nor is there any allegation that he is begging for votes
on hwn!liating terms. Even if such a statement is there, it will
not be a statement in relation to the personal character or con·
duct. On the other hand, every candidate during elections makes
requests for votes and for this purpose he may be visiting the
voters from door to door. To say that a candidate is asking for
votes, has no reference to the personal character or conduct of that
candidate. But the actual statement in paragraph 17 is that he:
BANS! LAL v. RISH! KUMAR (Vaidialingam, J.)
159
is knocking at every door and staggering around saying "vote for A
me". In our opinion, this statement has no relation to the personal character or conduct of the respondent and it only criticises
him for asking for votes from the voters when he has not done
any good to them ; nor is there any statement to the effect that
the respondent has committed acts of fraud. An argument was
made by Mr. Bhalgotra, learned counsel for the respondent that
B
there is an averment that the respondent has committed deception
and the people from the village get bad name. Deception, according to the learned counsel, consists in the respondent having misled the peopfe in believing that the cattle were being taken for
slaughter and when the villagers got into trouble, when they
attempted to prevent the cattle from being so taken, the respondent did not render any help to them. We are not inclined to c
accept this interpretation sought to be placed on these averments
in paragraph 17. The deception that is referred to is attributed
to the people of the town generally and the people from the village suffering on account of that. This only reveals the antago·
uism of the villagers to the town people on the ground that the
latter exploit the village people for their own purpose. There- D
fore. none of the reasons given by the learned Judge for coming
to the conclusion that paragraph 17 contained statements in reiation to the personal character or conduct of the respondent appeal
to us.
Coming to paragraph 20, the learned Judge had taken the
view that there is an allegation that the respondent has been ask- E
ed to appropriate the looted property of the poor. Here again
there is a fallacy underlying the reasoning of the High Court.
Paragraph 20 in substance is only to the effect that there is a wide
disparity between the people in the town and in the villages and
that the former are gaining at the expense of the latter. It is in
this context that it is sarcastically mentioned that the people of F
tile town can put up an iron curtain and enjoy the advantages
gained from the poor. The sentiments underlying paragraph 20
reveal only the grievance of the people in the village that their
claims are being neglected and that the people in the town are having all the. benefits at the expense of the village people. The
words "wealth robbed" have been understood by the learned
judge as the property looted from the poor. There is no warrant G
for such an interpretation. Those expressions have been used
only to bring out very forcibly that the people in the town are having all the benefits at the expense of the people of the villages who
are comparatively stated to be poor.
Therefore, paragraph 20
again, in our opinion, does not contain any statement relating to
the personal character or conduct of the respondent.
H
Taking up paragraph 16, the High Court has held that it contains two statements which relate to the personal character or
160
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.R.
conduct of the respondent, namely, (a) that the respondent apologised for extricating himself from a criminal case by paying money
to the other side, and (b) the respondent is shown to be an associate of drunkards on whose support he counts and in whose company he moves. Broadly, the statements in paragraph 16, relate
to the attack of two persons by the urban people including the
respondent, their arrest and the case instituted by them being
dropped or compromised on the respondent asking for a pardon
by paying some small amount. There is a further statement that
the respondent relies on the support of his companions who are
found drinking from morning till evening and the respondent not
having taken any action against them, cannot blame the villagers
Here again the theme seems to be the same, namely, of the
town ~ople receiving a more favourable treatment than the people
in the villages. There is no such averment as understood by the
High Court that the respondent is an associate of drunkards on
whose support he counts and in whose company he moves. On
the other hand, there is a statement that some of the sathis of the
respondent are found drinking from morning till evening and that
the respondent relies on their"support. This support, referred to,
must relate to the political support that the respondent derives
from such persons. This averrnent will have to be taken along
with the statement contained in the earlier part of Paragraph 16,
that the respondent along with his urban friends after attacking
the two persons mentioned therein has raised the question that the
people from the village come to towir and drink and roam aimlessly like vegabonds. Read in his manner the idea is quite clear,
namely, that the respondent and his other urban friends charge
the vi\lagers of drinking when they come to town and the villagers
in turn charge the respondent that his own companions in the town
are also persons who drink. There is no reference in these allegations to the personal character or conduct of the respondent. But,
on the other hand, it is really a criticism by the village people of
the habits and manners of the people in the town in retaliation to
the allegations made against the village people. Therefore, it
follows that there is no such statement in paragraph 16 to the
effect that the respondent is an associate of drunkards on whose
support he counts and in whose company he moves.
This leads us with the question whether the High Court is
correct in its finding that in paragraph 16, the respondent is described as one who apologised for extricating himself from a criminal case by paying money to the other side. So far as this aspect
is concerned, Mr. Garg, referred us to the evidence to show that
a criminal complaint was actually filed against the respondent and
others and that the matter was compromised on an apology tendered by the respondent. If that is so, tbe counsel urged, the statements contained herein, even assuming that they relate to the
BANS! LAL v. a!SHI ll:UMAll (Yaldlallngam, J.)
personal character of the respondent, are true anll tneretore tlley
do not amount to corm:pt practice under Section 123 (4). On the
other hand, Mr. Bhalgotra, learned counsel for the respondent,
pointed out that the evidence regarding the filing of a complaint
and the respondent having tender~ an apology is unsatisfactory
and. such evidence should. not be M:ted upon. The evidence bearing on this matter may lie referred to. In i;>aragraph 16, the two
persons who are stated to have come to R1asi and assaulted are
Dhani Ram and Baldev Singh. Baldev Singh has given evidence
as R. W. 37. He has deposed that about two years prior to his
giving evidence, he and Dhani Ram had gone to the town of
Riasi and visited 'the.>Shop of Shyam Lal Jargar. When a piece
of timber was sau$bt to be used as fire wood by Shyam Lal, Dhani
Ram tried to setze the piece of timber on the ground that it
belonged to the firm of 1odha Mal and Company, in which he was
employed. On this a hue and cry was raised by the people of
the town which included the respondent. All of them beat the
witness and Dhani Ram. After refering to the fact that their com·
plaint to the police was not taken on file, the witness has stated
that he went with Dhani Ram and Amar Nath R. W. 43 to
Udhampur to file a complaint before the court. He speaks further to the fact of filing of the complaint and that on the next day
a compri:>mise was brought about between the parties. He has
produced Ex. R. W. 37/ I, the complaint, and the vakalat executed by him in favour of Durga Dutt, Valcil, R. W. 18. has been
produced as R. W. 18/2A. R. W. 12, Fateh Singh also refers
to the incident of attack on Baldev Singh R. W. 37 and Dhani
Ram, in which the respondent and certain other town people also
took part. He speaks to having stood as a surety for Balde v
Singh and Dhani Ram for obtaining their release. He refers to
having delivered a Jetter to Durga Dutt, Vakil, at Udhampur and
to Baldev Singh and Dhani Ram coming to Udhampur to file the
complaint. R. W. 18 is a lawyer at Udhampur. He speaks of
Baldev Sill(!h and Dhani Ram having come to him on September
19, 1966 wtth·a letter from M_r. Raghunath Das, Advocate, Riasi.
He has also spoken to Baldev Singh and Dhani Ram giving him
instructions to file the criminal complaint. He has produced the
vakalats Ex. R. W..18/2 and Ex. R. W. 18/2A, executed by
Dl~ani Ram. and Baldev Singh respectively in respect of the criminal complaint. He has referred to the fact that he signed the
complaint petitions and filed them in the Court of the A. D. M.,
Udh~ur <;>n September 20. 1966. '.I'he Magistrate forwarded the
two complamts to the Station House Officer, Riasi, for i,nvestiga·
tion. Hd' has stated the reasons as to why the vakalats were retained by him, l>y saying that when a complaint petition is sent by
the court to the police for inquiry through the complainant himself, the vakala.ts are retained by the lawyer. He has no doubt
admitted that he is the maternal uncle of the appellant.
11- I S. C, India/71
161
A
B
c
D
E.
F
G
ff
162
A
B
c
SUPRl!MB COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.1:
R. W. 43 Amar Nath has spoken to his knowing Baldev Singh
and Dhani Ram and also to the incident which took place in
Riasi and their being beaten by the people including the respon·
dent. He has further referred to R. W. 12 requesting him to
ac~ompany Baldev Singh and Dhani Ram to Udhampur for filing
a criminal complaint and to his having actually accompanied
them. He further deposed to R. W. 18 being engaged as a coun·
sel and to the filing of the complaints by Baldev Singh and Dhani
Ram. In cros!Hlxamination this witness has stated that the res·
pondent got the case compromised and the various accused in the
criminal complaints were told that if any fine was imposed on
them, it will be paid by the respondent and his party, the Jan
Sangh.
R. W. 53 Lal Singh, who is the author of Ex. P. W. l /11, in
which these allegations Jiave been made, has deposed to the effect
that the statements contained therein are all true and correct.
D
E
G
H
Mr. Garg very strenuously pleaded for the acceptance of the
evidence, referred to above, which, according to him, establishes
the truth of the avennents regarding the filing of the criminal
complaints and the proceedings being dropped in view of the compromise entered into between the parties. Mr. Bhalgotra, learned
counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, pointed out that
even if the above evidence is accepted, in toto, that the allegations
that the criminal proceedings were dropped because of the re•-pon·
dent paying money and asking for a pardon will not stand rstab·
lished. The allegation a person paid money to a complainant to
drop the criminal proceedings is a statement relating to the personal character or conduct of that person.
If so, the counsel
urged that the finding of the High Court that the appellant is guilty
of corrupt practice is justified.
We are of the opinion that the evidence referred to above is
acceptable and it substantially proves the truth of the allegations
regarding the incident referred to in paragraph 16 leading to the
filing of the criminal complaints and their not being proceeded
with due to compromise arrived at between the parties. So far as
we could see, the learned Judge has not properly considered the
above evidence when he recorded a finding that the allegation•
regarding the filing of the criminal complaints and the respondent
entering into a compromise arc false and have not been proved
to be correct. The allegations regarding the attack said to have
been made against Baldev Singh end Dhani Ram by some of the
people in Riasi including the respondent, is established by the
evidence of R. Ws. 37, 12, and 43. Their evidence is corroborated
by Ex. P. W. 37 /I, the complaint, stated to have been made before
the A. D. M., Udhampur. The ninth defendant in the said complaint is Rishi Kumar Kaushal, the respondent. The substance
BANSI LAL'· RIS!ll KUMAR CVaidialingam, i.)
of the complaint is that R. W. 37. and Dhani Ram had come to
Riasi on September 14, 1966 where they were given a beating by
the accused, named, in the complaint which included the respon·
dent. It abo refers to the fact that the police did not take the
complaint on the file and that is why it was being presented before
the court. That complaint is dated September 19, 1966. That
the police declined to entertain the original complaint made by
R W. 37 and Dhani Ram is borne out by the evidence of R. Ws. 12
and 43. That R. W. 37 and Dhani Ram went to Uhampur to file
the complaint is also established by the evidence of R. Ws. 12 and
43. In fact R. W. 43 speaks to having accompanied Baldev Singh
and Dhani Ram to Udhampur to contact the lawyer and have the
complaint filed before the court.
Ample corroboration is found for the above evidence in the
testimony of an independent witness R. W. 18.. Durga Dutt R. W.
18 is a practising lawyer at Uhdampur and he has spoken to Baldev Singh and Dhani Ram coming to him on September 19, 1966
with a letter of recommendation from one Raghunath Dass and
he has also produced the said letter as R. W. 18/ 1. He has also
produced the two vakalats executed in his favou~ by Baldev Singh
and Dhani Ram and they have been marked as Ex. R. W. 18 / 2
and Ex. R. W. 18 / 2A. l;Ie has further referred to the filing of
the complaint before the A. D. M. Udhampur and to the court
handing over the complaint with a endorsement to the police at
Riasi to investigate and report. No doubt. this witness has admitted that he is the maternal uncle of the appellant herein, but that
circumstance alone will not warrant the rejection of the evidence
of this witness. Therefore, it is clear that there was an incident as
spoken to by R. VI. 37 in which the respondent also was involved.
and in connection with that incident a complaint was actually
filed before the A. D. M., Udhampur and as we have already said
the respondent was the ninth defendant in the complaint.
R. W. 43 has stated that the respondent Rishi Kumar Kaushal
got the criminal case compromised and that the respondent further represented that if any fine was imposed the same will be paid
by the respondent and his party. This is an answer elicited from
R. W. 43 in cross-examination. This answer clearly establishes
that the criminal complaint evidenced by Ex. R. W. 37/1 did not
proceed further and the matter ended by-the parties entering into a
compromise. No doubt the respondent has gone to the extent of
denying even about the incident of attack spoken to by R. W. 37
and the filing of the complaint. He bas further denied that he
ever entered into any compromise in respect of any criminal complaint.
We are not inclined to accept the evidence of the respondent
on this point in view of the overwhelming oral and documentary
163
A
B
c
D
E
p
G
H
164
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
Sl.JPREME COIJRT REPORTS
[1971] Sl.JPP. s.c.R.
evidence, which conclusively establishes the events leading up to
the filing of the complaint Ex. R. W. 37 / l and to the proceedings
No doubt R. W. 3 7,
being dropped because of a compromise.
who was one of the complainants does not speak to any apology
being given by the respondent, but we have already pointed out
that R. W. 43 has clearly stated that the criminal case was compromised. In view of all these circumstances the inference is irre·
sistable that the criminal case must have come to a close because
of a compromise arrived at by the parties and probbly due to 5ome
sort of apology given by the respondent. But even if it is held
that there is no evidence that the respondent actually tendered any
apology. nevertheless, as the other allegations are held to 11ave
been substantially true, any reference to respondent asking for a
pardon in paragraph 1. must only be considered to be a highly
exaggerated version given by the author of the booklet. But on
that ground it cannot be held that the allegations regarding the
filing of the criminal complaint are not true. Therefore. the view
of the High Court that the statement in paragraph 16 that the respondent apologised and extricated himself from criminal case by
paying money. is false, cannot be accepted, as we are of the opinion, that the said allegation has been proved to be correct. To
conclude there are no statements of fact in paragraphs 17 and 20
of Ex. R. W. l / 11 in relation to the personal character or conduct
of the respondent. There is no allegation in paragraph 16 that.
the respondent is an associate of drunkards. The averment in the
said paragraph that some of the companions of the respondent on
whose political support the respondent relies are found drinking
from morning till evening, does not relate to the personal character
or conduct of the respondent. The allegation in the said paragraph
regarding the respondent extricating himself from a criminal c~se
filed by Baldev Singh and Dhani Ram has been proved to be true
and as such falls outside Section 132(4) of the Act. Therefore, it
follows that the finding of the High Court that the statements contained in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 amount to corrupt practke
under Section 132(4) of the Act, cannot be sustained.
On the above conclusion arrived at by us it becomes unnecessary to consider the second contention of Mr. Garg th~t the High
Court's finding regarding the publication and distribution of the
booklet Ex. P. W. II II. is erroneous and is not based upon the
evidence in the case.
Mr. Bhalgotra, learned counsel for the respondent however,
has attempted to support the judgment of the High Court by attacking the findings recorded against his client in respect of paragraphs
7, 8, 10, 18 and 19 in Ex. P. W. I !II. He has not attacked the
findings recorded by the learned Judge on other allegations of cor·
rupt practi,e maJc oy tiie respontie1h in hi.< ekc<ion i;etilion. In
Ramanbhai Ashabhai Patel v. Dabhi Ajitkumar Fulsinji and
BANSI LAL •• IUSHI KUMAR. (Vaidiali11gam, J.)
others (') it has been held by this Court that on a consideration
of justice, this Court should pennit the respondent to support the
judgment in his favour even upon the grounds which were negatived in that judgment. The same view has been reiterated
recently by this Court in Shri Thepfulo Nakhro Angami v. Shrimati Raveluei alias Rani M. Shaiza ('). Though the above decisions were given under the Representation of the People Act, 1951,
Mr. Grag, learned counsel for the appellant, accepted the position
that the same principles are applicable to the present appeal which
has been filed under the Act. We have permitted the respondent to
support the judgment in his favour by establishing, if he can, that
the findings recorded by the High Court against him with regard
to paragraphs 7, 8, IO, 18 and 19, are erroneous.
165
A
B
c
There is a slight mistake in the official translation of those
paragraphs and the learned counsel for both the parties agreed that
the following .tran~lation may be adopted. The said paragraphs
are as follows :
"Paragraph 7 :
In the last 20 years whichever Government was formed one after the other and "whenever their Ministers and
Government Officers visited Reasi, you threw stones at
them and made personal attack on them. Instead of welcoming the guests, alongwith city folks and other strayed
Jansanghie.s insulted them.
Did Jan Sangh give you
such instructions as to assault with the help of Riasis Jan
Sanghi Goondas the Minister and other Government officers when they visit Reasi. Is this called democracy?"
D
"Paragraph 8.
Whenever you started any agitation against the Government, you put forward the misguided groups of the village folks and such of the urban people who were with
you, all themselves went underground. Thus the poor villagers faced lathi charge, tear gas and even bullets. Who
did this deception and who got it done?"
'
G
"Paragraph 10.
In the past when famine conditions arose due to
shortage of wheat, you instead of rendering help got
wheat supply stopped to village people through a dty
Panchayat and rotten atta (wheat powder) which was full
of worms, distributed in villages, which our children and
(1) [196S] I s.c.R. 712.
(2) [1971] 3 S.C.R.424.
H
166
A
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971) SUPP. S.C.ll.'
women and elders people had to eat. Were the villagers
not human beings?"
"Paragraph 18.
B
c
D
E
ll
G
H
Which of the Ministers or Government Officers have
you allowed to go out of the Reasi City without being
stoned in the last twenty years. Often the villagers had
probiems to be resolved but you did not let them be solved. Did you alone have the right to think of good a.nd
evil and thus safe the roots of the villages and, bring bad
name to the village people."
"Paragraph 19.
Last year when Khan Saheb had come to Reasi to
resolve the difficulties of uprooted persons, some of the
uprooted villagers were suddenly instigated and some Jan
Sanghi Goondas made an attack on him. At whose instance all this happened. The villages were already ruined, you again made them your target by giving them
wrong advice and you started leading them all. Demands
were to be put up to the Hon'ble Minister but you did
the reverse. We were again the victims. Think for you_rself. Who is responsible for downfall of the uprooted
ones ? Who has taught the people not to Jet officials go
back alive from Reasi and to throw stone at them.
Where did you get all this power? There are many other
areas, cities which are thickly populated but there human
beings are treated like humans."
The High Court considered paragraphs 7, 18 and 19 together
and has held that the evidence establishes that the respondent
was responsible for organising demonstrations and instigating
assaults on ministers apd other Government Officers. In this
view the High Court held that the statements contained in the
said paragraphs do not come under Section 132 (4) of the Act
as those statements were not false. Dealing with paragraphs 8 and
10 the High Court has held that the allegations made therein do
not relate to the personal character and conduct of the respondent and therefore, is outside Section 132 (4) of the Act. It has
further held that in any event the respondent has not satisfactorily
discharged the burden of proving the falsity of those allegatiom.
It is in consequence of these findings that the High Court held the
Section 132 (4) of the Act does not apply to the allegations made
in these paragraphs.
Mr. Bhalgotra, learned counsel for the respondent, very
strenuously attacked the finding recorded by the High Court on
this aspect. We will first take up paragraph 10. It has to be
BANS! LAL v. RISH! KUMA~ (Vaidialingam, J.)
brone in mind that the respondent was a sitting member of the
Legislative Assembly.
The allegation in paragraph 10 is that
when there was a shortage of wheat, the respondent was responsible for stopping the supply of wheat to village people and in
turn got rotten wheat powder distributed to the villagers, which
had to be consumed by the people of the village. The insinu&·
tion is that the village people have not been properly treated by
the respm1dent when he was representing their Constituency in
the Assembly. As we have already pointed out from the decisions dte:i earlier that the public and political character of a candidate are open to the public view and public criticism and
even if any false statements are made about the political or public
conduct or character, the elector would be able to judge the allegation on merit and may not be misled by any false allegation
in that behalf. Even if a false statement is made in regard to
the public or political character of a candidate, it would not constitute a corrupt practice even if it is likely to prejudice the prospects of that candidate's election. In our opinion, the statements
contained in paragraph 10, quoted above, has no reference to the
personal character or conduct of the respondent. Mr. Bhalgotra
has, no doubt, drawn our attention to the evidence of R. Ws. 5,
6. 12 and 28 to establish that no rotten atta was supplied to the
villagers and that the respondent in any event was not responsible
for the same. On the other hand, according to the counsel, the
evidence shows that far from being responsible for the supply of
rotten atta to the villagers, whenever any complaints were received, the respondent did his best to help the villagers. We do not
think itnecessary to go into this evidence because of the view that
we take that the statement in paragraph 10 has no relation to the
personal character or conduct of the respondent. On the other
band, they are statements relating to the respondent as a politician
and even if those statements are false, they will not come under
Section 132 (4) of the Act.
Coming to .paragraph 8, it deals with the role played by the ·respondent and his urban associate in agitations against the government. Here again the implication is that the urban people inc!uding the respondent start agitation against the government and
always put the villagers in the forefront. The villagers had to
bear the brunt of any action that was taken by the government
to put down the agitation and in that connection it is stated that
the villagers had to face lathi charge, tear gas and even bullets.
Mr. Bhalgotra, urged that the allegations contained in this
paragraph really relate to the personal character or conduct of
the respondent The learned counsel pointed out that the insinuation in this that the villagers were fired upon by the authorities
is absolutely mischievious and false. In this connection, the
167
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
168
B
c
D
E
p
G
H
SUPllBMI! COUIT lllll'ORTS
[1971] SUPP. s.c.11.
learned counsel drew our attention to the evidence of R. Ws. 22
and :i3 to the ehect that there has been no firing in Reasi. He
also referred us to the evidence of respondent as P. W. 41 that
there was no firing in Reasi. In our opinion the statements contained in paragraph 8 have no relation to the personal character
or conduct of the respondent. On the otherhand the whole tenor
of the allegation made therein is to the effect that in all agitations
against the government, villagers are made to suffer and urban
people like the respondent conveniently keep themselves in the
background. The reference to the villagers having to face lathicharge and tear-gas and even bullets is only to emphasise the
bardship that the villagers have to suffer in carrying out the agitations against the government and specially when the urban people
like the respondent let them down by making themselves scarce.
The attack is against the urban people as a whole and it has noth·
ing to do with the respondent's personal character or conduct.
Hence we are of the opinion that the statements contained in
paragraph 8 do not attract Section 132 (4) of the Act.
It leaves us for consideration paragraphs 7, 18 and 19. All
these paragraphs will have to be read together. According to
Mr. Bhalgotra, these paragraphs make very serious allegations
that the respondent takes active part in violent activities such as
stone throwing etc. and that the appellant has failed to establish
that those allegations are true. In this connection the counsel
relied on the decision of this Court in T. K. Gangi Reddy v.
M. C. Anjaneya Reddy and others(') wherein it has been held that
a statement which attributes acts of violence, for example, instigation of murder, throwing of stones at public meetings etc. even
though such acts are done during his political career is a statement relating to the personal character and conduct of the candidate. On this basis the learned counsel argued that the appellant
while publishing the statements contained in the said paragraphs is
guilty of corrupt practice under Section 132 (4) of the Act. The
averment that respondent was guilty of throwing stones against
the Ministers or government officers, who had come on tour to the
Constituency is certainly a very serious statement in relation to
the personal character or cond,uct of the respondent as it attributes
acts of violence on his part. The High Court has found that these
allegations are true. That finding is now attacked. The Khan
Saheb, referr~ to in paragraph 19, is Mohammad Ayub Khan,
who was then the Minister for Health in the State. He has given
evidence as R. W. 50. According to Mr. Garg, the allegations
in these paragraphs are really directed against the Jan Sangh
party, to which party the respondent belonged to espouse their
attitude towards the Ministers and Government Officers when they
come on tour to the Constituency. The Jan Sangh party instead
(I\ (1960) 22 B.L.R. 261.
BANS! LAL v. RISH! KUMAR ( Vaidialingam, J.)
of being helpful by placing before the authorities the difficulties
experienced by the villagers, created obstrucles in the way of any
redress being granted to the villagers and were also causing annoyance to the said officers. There is nothing personal against the
respondent.
Paragraph 7 charges the respondent of having thrown stones
against the Ministers and Government officers when they visited
Reasi. Again in paragraph 18 the insinuation is that the Ministers and the Government Officers were not allowed to go out of
Reasi without being stoned. Again in paragraph 19 the insinuation is that the respondent along with others instigated the uprooted villagers and Jan Sangh Goondas to attack the Minister
R. W 50 when he visited Reasi to look into the grievances of !he
people. These allegations, in our opinion, are of a very serious
nature and they attribute acts of violence to the respondent. The
question is whether these allegations are true. It must be noted
that in paragraph 18, Mr. Bhalgotra, has drawn our attention to
.the question that is asked : whether the respondent has allowed
within the last 20 ·years any Minister or Government Officer to
JJO out of Reasi without being stoned ? Mr. Bhalgotra referred us
to the evidence of the Tehsildar, R. W. 28 and R. W. 50, the
Minister to the effect that though there was a demonstration when
R. W. 50 visited Reasi, the respondent was not present. Therefore, he urged that the allegation that the respondent threw stones
is false.
We have been taken through the material evidence bearing on
this aspect both by Mr. Garg and Mr. Bhalgotra and we are of
·the opinion that the finding of the High Court that these allegations were not false, is correct.
The main evidence is that of
R. W. 50 Mohammad Ayub Khan, who was Minister of Health.
He has referred to the fact that when he visited Reasi, he attended
.a public meeing held by the the then Chief Minister Bakshi Gulam
Mohammad. At that meeting there was a pelting of stone~ by
some people in order to create confusion and that the people who
pelted stones were people from the Jan Sangh party. He then
referred to the fact that in September, 1965 when he visited Reasi
there was a very violent demonstration against him by the Jan
Sangh party near the Oak Bungalow where he was staying. The
Assistant Commissioner, Mr. Behari Lal Shanna, after the demonstration, complained to the witness that he had been assaulted and
manhandled by the respondent and other Jan Sangh workers;
and that the witness states that he believed that the demonstration
was organised by the respondent as he was leading the crowd. He
has also stated that the demonstration was very violent and fully
of fury. He then refers to his vehicle being stonned on the way
lo Jammu. No doubt he has stated that at that time the respondent was not present but his father and bis election agent Babu
169
A
B
c
D
E
F
G
H
170
A
B
c
D
E
G
B
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] SUP!'. s.c.R.
Lal were present and made violent speeches and in his presenceone of his companions was manhandled.
In cross-examination, no doubt, he has stated that he is not
able to remember whether the incident of pelting stones was reported to the police. R. W. 28, the Tehsildar while stating 1bout
the violent demonstration against the Minister R. W. 50, no doubt,
says that the respondent was not present. R. W. 31. who was
accompanying the Minister's party has referred to the obstruction
caused to the Minister and to the violent demonstration conducted against the Minister in 1965. He clearly refers to the·fact that
the Minister and others were abused and one member·of the Minister's group was manhandled. Amongst the persons who abused
the ministerial party was a. vakil of Reasi belonging to the Jan
Sangh party. The obvious reference is to the respondent:
The respondent as P. W. 41, no doubt, denies that he was
ever•a party to the violent demonstration against the Minister or
any other Government Officer. but he has admitted that he was
a prominent leader of the Praja Parishad party in 1952 and the
said party had launched an agitation against the Governmenc.
During \hat agitation there were incident~ of lathi charges and
firing and some people were killed. He has also admitted that
he was arrested in connection with the agitation.
Great emphasis has been laid by Mr. Bhalgotra, learned
counsel, that as the evidence of R. Ws. 28 and 50 is to !lie effect
that the respondent was not present at the time of the demom:tration, he would not have taken any part in any violent activi.ties as alleged in paragraphs 7, 18 and 19. We are not inclined'
lo accept this contention of the learned counsel. From the evidence the following facts emerge : there was a pelting of stone•·
by the Jan Sangh part¥ in the meeting attended by Mohd. Ayuf>.
Khan R. W .. 50; the respondent was a member of ihe Jan Sangh
party; there was a violent demonstration against R. W. 50 and
though this witness does not speak to the presence of the respondent, it is cleac that the respondent's father and his election agent
were actively participating in the violent demonstration and th"
inference is that the demonstration must have been at the instanceof the respondent. The evidence of R. W. 31, shows that a valal
of Reasi was present when there was a very violent demonstration
against the Minister. The reference to the vakil must be to the
respondent. P. W. 41 himself has admitted that he was arrested
ir: connection with a demonstration against the ruling party in
which several people died due to police firing. All these circumstances, in our opinion, do establish that the respondent must haw·
either instigated or had been a party to the violent demonstration
referred to in paragraphs 7, 18 and 19 and it cannot be said that
BANS! LAL v. RI~HI KLMAR (Vcidic/ingcm,J.)
171
the allegations contained therein are false. It cannot also be stated that in view of these circumstances the appellant either believed those allegations to be false or did not believe them to be true.
Therefore, the High Court was justified in coming to the conclusion that these statements in the said paragraphs do not come
within the purview of sub-section (4) of Section 132 of the Act and
we also agree with the High Court in this respect.
A
It follows that the finding of the High Court that paragraphs
7. 8, 10, 18 and 19 of Ex. P. W. ! /II are outside the ambit of
Section 132 (4) of the Act is correct. As we are accepting the
findings of the High Court in this regard, we consider it unnecessary to deal with the question of publication and circulation of
the booklet Ex. P. W. I/II. We have already held that the statements in paragraphs 16, 17 and 20 do not amount to corrupt practice under Section 132 (4) of the Act. The appeal is consequently
allowed. The decision of the High Court is set aside and the election petition is dismissed with costs throughout.
G.C.
PeJition dismissed.
B
C
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org